Mr. President -- Try This and Galvanize the American People!
Here's how I'd negotiate with Boehner and the Tea Party.
OBAMA: "Okay boys, here's the offer. I will allow the repeal of "Obamacare" under the following terms:
Upon the ratification of a bill into law, one enabling SINGLE-PAYER-UNIVERSAL-HEALTH-INSURANCE (as per the parameters of Jon Conyers' H.R. 676), and, upon its effective date of implementation, I will sign a bill repealing 'Obamacare'/PPACA."
No more for-profit health insurers No more putting health insurance on employers Much reduced health insurance premiums http://www.govtrack.us/congress/bills/113/hr676/text The Tea Party will call it "Socialism" Americans will call out the Tea Party. That's the f'n' deal -- do it Mr. President!
i dissagree, the left has spent too much capital pretending socialized medicine is not the true goal.
pretty sure hes going with the medical device tax, mathews floated it yesterday
That's the fuckin' deal -- do it Mr. President!
If I wasn't so bad at writing I'd go on the whitehouse website and start a petition. Absent that I will send an email, a fax, a tweet, and 2 pidgeons. I Love This Idea!!!
Send a link to this article!
In other words you have no viable argument against my idea!
The medical device tax?
How about making the corporations that manufacture them PAY CORPORATE TAXES?
Commentary: A look at who's paying no taxes
Another non-subtantive comment.
Universal-Single-Payer -- go to the link and get educated.
Thank you, AE.
A Mac
I think a single payer medical insurance process is ultimately the solution to the nation's health insurance issues, but neither the position the Republicans in the House have taken nor the position you suggest that the President should take can be or will be beneficial to the crisis faced by the nation.
Your fantasy suggests that, when presented with an unsavory option, the president who is supposed to bring opposing factions of the government together for the good of the nation should flippantly respond with an option which he knows is even more unsavory to the opposition and is in fact even less likely to happen than the unsavory option they suggest.
That is not leadership, just as the House actions are not good governance, both are arrogant abdication of the responsibility
Obviously I don't agree; there's nothing flippant about metaphorically "beating someone with his own stick".
My plan offers a "compromise" in the form of a program (Medicare) that is time tested and popular, and less costly to individuals and businesses.
It offers an end to "Obamacare" and shows a willingness to negotiate.
It would put Boehner and the Tea Party into a deeper hole than they've already dug themselves into.
Here's an example of the morons who hate "Obamacare" and have no f'n clue! Tea Party zeal-without-knowledge Obama-haters!
Got the numbers from a non-political source to back that up?
Yes they call it a national debt clock. Let me know when the numbers start to decrease.
Too late for the Republicans to claim that; had they offered a viable health insurance alternative instead of the bullshit they've foisted, then maybe they'd get partial credit -- not now.
BTW, I mailed the article (a slight variation) to the White House, as follows:
Are you implying that the U.S. has never accrued any debt in the past?
A Mac
But the totally unrealistic parts of your "plan"
Since there is no real way or reason to expect either to happen except in a fantasy world
To reiterate what I think of your proposal
Thanks to Michael Ramirez for the graphic
You are uninformed.
Until you read the information at the link you'll continue with seat-of-the-pants comments; the plan, in other words, is Medicare for all.
READ IT!
In general
Fuck Town Hall -- read what I wrote about. I'm advocating an end to Obamacare and replacing it with Single-Payer -- it's what we should have implemented all along.
In this article, knocking Obamacare is pointless -- so learn about Single-Payer and comment how you will on that.
IGNORANCE! Much of which comes from the heavily funded misinformation campaign (Koch Brothers and other "organized wealth" pimps and whores).
What? You mean cut out the corrupt middle-man (the health insurance industry)? Make itso human health is not a free market commodity? Not be at the mercy of those who seek to make the most profit off of human misery while providing as little service as possible? Okay, you talked me into it.
Well paraphrased!
Exactly what I mean.
Mac comes up with a great plan that knocks the socks offeveryone's objections, and you, Chucky, are the only one to stop telling him how it WON'T work and applaud the plan.
I vote to send you and Mac to congress....
No thanks. I got a real job. And my cootie shot isn't up to date. Plus I don't wanna give up my rural hipster lifestyle.
I had my years in politics -- elected to the Philadelphia Democratic City Committee and, as Legislative Representative for the largest AFL-CIO affiliate in Pennsylvania.
But I'd seriously consider accepting the position of Commissioner of the Pennsylvania Fish and Boat Commission or Editor of its official publication.
Damn, Chucky! That's why we can't get good representation. The good ones are too smart to willingly crawl into a cesspool.
Yes , how about it ... all that is needed is to reform the tax code . Remember who was running on that idea during the pres election ??
The Republican idea of "reforming" the Tax Code is to let Corporate Lobbyists re-write it so that it entirely favors corporations instead of just primarily so.
And
You can copy/paste a thou pages on this topic but it won't change a thing .
We'll never know if Romney would have "done the correct thing" for the US or not . The reason we won't know is because of the extreme vilification of his character during the election .
Romney would have been very capable at effecting tax code reform had he set his mind to do it . Bams has done nothing in that regard . So you can cease your whining about big corps not paying taxes . You voted for him ...twice .
Copy/paste = providing information (which you and others are free to debate); do you have a problem with being specific rather than making empty rhetorical comments like
Give us something of substance!
"Vilification of Romney's" character?
Anyone ask for his fucking birth certificate, lie about death panels, mock his wife for advocating that children exercise and eat health foods?
Shall I go on?
You're the whiner -- the corporate tax evaders are real and it's documented. If you have specifics to the contrary, post them!
Your whining has been perfected over thousands of comments . I can't hold a candle to you on that skill .
There is no disputing that companies avoid taxes [ not evade ] . The difference is tax avoidance is PERFECTLY LEGAL while evasion is illegal . But nice attempt at prevarication . And the reason that avoidance will continue in the future is that Obama has done NOTHING to effect reform of the tax code . Romney might have been able to make the needed changes in the tax code because he is well connected in the business community . Obama's lack of business background makes any such reform from him impossible ...
Get off the personal crap and discuss the content of my article; the only reason I commented on corporate tax loopholes was out of deference to JoAnne who seemed to side with medical device manufacturers.
"Legal" is sometimes an insidious "justification." Millions have been murdered under regimes that "legalized" shit like genocide.
The topic in this thread is a suggested negotiating tactic for the President. Feel free to speak to that.
So ... now your are changing the topic back to the original ? Nah , not buying it . You should have stopped JoAnne but you responded . Now welcome to my "personal crap " . You've earned it .
You're a laugh riot ! In the US we have this system called "the rule of law" . If the laws are unjust then they need to be changed . But you seem to want to merely use the nuclear whining option [Godwin's Law ] .
So ... since you have dedicated yourself to extreme whining instead of action I wish you many more enjoyable years of whining about Big Corporations . Action is not your forte ... Romney 2016 ?!
I had my time in DC as a lobbyist for the company I worked for, to get the Clean Water Bill passed. That's when I learned the most uninformed and ignorant people on the Hill, about any subject concerning this nation whatsoever, are those you elect to represent you.
If you want to influence your representative on an issue, find out his/her aide's name, contact them, invite them to lunch/dinner, lay out your concerns, your facts... they are the most powerful people in DC. Regardless of which committee your representative is assigned to, they know NOTHING about the issue until their aide tells them about it. The committee members responsible for voting on the Clean Water Act had no idea at all how a treatment plant worked or that "clean" water (ground water runoff from rainstorms) was sometimes 50% of what overflowed treatment plants and necessitated municipalities to ask for more federal funds for expansions, rather than mending broken underground sewer pipes or replacing corroded ones.
hows a willingness to negotiate.
I don't think you know what that word means. That would be like the Republicans saying we will accept Obamacare if every single democratic member of Congress and the President immediately resigns. That would demonstrate a willingness to negotiate as well!
This might be the most unserious proposal I've seen to date. Congratulations.
It's a tactic, a ploy, a trap, a setup -- a way to put Boehner between a rock and a hard place -- Did I need to explain that?
It's a poison fucking pill for Republicans! They'd have to say "no" to something many of their own constituents want even if they're too dumb to realize it; look at the Tea Party signs I posted.
The fact that you mock it means you hope to God it doesn't happen.
A Mac
Please sharpen your reading skills by re-reading my earlier comment concerning single payer
You need to debate the point rather than soliciting the sexual favors of the website
You say
But the truth is that offering an opinion contrary to yours on any article is pointless - you do not want to debate you want to pontificate
But hell whatever gets you through the day, I will continue to offer my thoughts and ideas and you can continue to suggest having sex with a website
That was then -- this is now.
Obama's miscalculation regarding uniting Washington was noble, altruistic, idealistic and unfortunately UNREALISTIC. Consequently, trying compromise was both ineffective and ultimately resultant in a "compromise" health insurance law -- the PPACA ("Obamacare").
No public option then for the reason I just cited and of course, no Single-Payer. Now's the time for Obama to acknowledge that trying to compromise with Republicans is not viable and therefore, "it's time to do what's best for most Americans and if the Tea Party doesn't like it -- TOUGH SHIT!
You fundamentally misunderstand the poll numbers! It's not so much that Americans don't want "Obamacare" because they don't like Obamacare, IT'S BECAUSE IT DOESN'T GO FAR ENOUGH, "FAR ENOUGH" BEING ALL THE WAY TO SINGLE PAYER!
If Obama were to say, "I should have done this in the first place -- I'm happy that millions will now benefit from the PPACA BUT IT'S TIME TO TAKE IT THE REST OF THE WAY -- TO SINGLE-PAYER UNIVERSAL HEALTH INSURANCE -- STAND WITH ME AMERICA" -- he'll get it!
Robert in Ohio,
On the one hand you acknowledge single payer as the ultimate solution but then you go with the Town Hall attack on Obamacare. That's taking one step forward then taking one backwards to make sure you get a potshot in.
WTF does this mean?
As for
You mean in the way you've done with that comment? My article is clearly and unambiguously stated -- feel free to disagree with its premise -- but let's not try to have it both ways. Single-Payer is an idea pushed hardest by Democrats (Jon Conyers in particular) and one that, even in a watered-down form of a "public option," hasn't found its way into law because of Republicans who pimp for insurance companies; out of one side of your mouth you like the idea but out of the other, you knock those who knock Republicans for standing in the way.
Pick a side on the issue itself.
Again, can you explain this?
now i understand.
If that were the case, the Republicans would go along with it and I think you'd agree they would not, probably in fear, that like the PPACA, once people could access SINGLE-PAYER, they'd clamor to it in throngs, give the insurance companies the finger and say "good riddance you heartless, greedy pricks"!
And Obama would be the hero!
I personally respect someone who can say, "I made a mistake -- I should have done this in the first place but lacked the resolve; I realize now that this is the best situation for the most people -- AND THIS IS WHAT I AM DETERMINED NOW TO DO! I am not concerned with saving face -- I am concerned about doing the right thing and now I will."
Agreed! And going to Single-Payer would say to the ORGANIZED WEALTH ESTABLISHMENT
"You don't own my ass any more -- Americans can have Health Insurance without the bullshit, the unconscionable profiteering, the waste, the cancelled coverage when they most need it, the excessive premiums imposed at your whim no CEO should make $20 million a year, predicated in part on people dying!"
IMO, the Tea Party is the Establishment's Fox (pun intended) in the hen house.
That could be easily fixed pay them decent salaries (based in part on cost-of-living where they practice) instead of fee-for service -- that fixes a number of things.
They're out! Medicare-for-all premiums are paid through taxes and it pays the physicians/hospitals, etc. . And they no longer have the burden of providing benefits for employees so their bottom lines increase.
Health of Americans should not be a commodity!
That would be just fine if, when an uninsured person/family member could literally and figuratively live with a choice to be uninsured -- but, with the exception of i.e, religionists who believe in faith healing, that's not what happens. Such individuals go to emergency rooms and stick those who are voluntarily insured with the costs (on the average, about $1100/year in higher premiums).
It's one thing to make life choices on a voluntary basis but quite another to make others pay for those choices when they turn bad.
Bf asked,
Don't give me the "come on" stuff; it's clear I cited that demographic as an exception.
And this has nothing to do with Single-Payer it's just more fear and hate-mongering!
Every chance you get -- you get around to your racist and xenophobic agenda! It's the usual bullshit from the usual haters!
WTF does this mean?
You need to debate the point rather than soliciting the sexual favors of the website
Well it appears that is what you desire when you say
Fuck Town Hall
My side of the issue is that I think the PPACA is not the solution to the health care problems of the nation but accept it as the law of the land. I also think the shutdown is asinine.
If that is not clear enough for you let me know
As to your intolerance of contrary opinions it goes beyond this article, but I have gotten used to your "my way or the highway attitude (very tea party like) and it bothers me not.
Here is how Republicans say "Fuck you, I've got mine!"
Fox's Varney On Furloughed Federal Employees: "I Want To Punish These People"
Fox Business host Stuart Varney believes that the ongoing government shutdown, while presenting no real threat to the economy, offers an opportunity to "punish" federal workers for "living on our backs."
On the October 2 edition of AM 560's The Big John & Amy Show , co-hosts John Howell and Amy Jacobson interviewed Fox Business' Stuart Varney and asked him about the government shutdown and its effect on workers and the economy. Varney stated, incorrectly, that the shutdown was not having an impact on financial markets or the greater economy before launching into a tirade against federal employees.
When asked if federal employees deserved to be recompensed for lost wages during the shutdown, Varney had this to say:
Talking about POS --
Congressman Stutzman: He Has No Idea What the GOP Wants
But he sure as hell won't be dissed!
Read more:
Government shutdown halts search for missing woman inside national park
It's on your heads Mr. Boehner, Mr. Cruz and the Tea Party.
Oh, and
They're HAPPY!
While avoiding taxes and making the corporate buyouts and then breaking up the company and sending jobs overseas and receiving millions of dollars in U.S. tax fund dollarsof tax deferments Romney set the bar for other Corporations to follow. Taking that money and placing it in the Mormon finance system Romney avoided paying any tax at all on these gigantic cashouts using our tax dollars. He could not and would not produce his tax return therefore I believe making him inelgible for holding Public office period. Trying to substantiate the probability of future good deeds of a tea Publicanis a joke worth mentioning. Look at Bain Capitols financial history look at the inside hook into the electronic voting machines Co. owned by Romneys son.These machines were proven corruptable to Congress and could be done from a distance.
The machines are still in use. Just not enough of them apparently to flip enough votes to get his daddy elected.
Do itMr. President. Tell them to take it leave it or start cutting Military defense projects like the Pilot killing fighter. Quit buying outdated C-130's that are bought even after a competitive procurement they competed in did not pick their Co. with their outdated c-130's instead picking a new concept aircraft easily supported into the distant future. Congress the House of Representatives breaks their own rules and procurements after a complete compition threw out the design of the outdated C-130 flown by the USAF who wanted no more C-130's. House Republican members recieve the lions share of the Lobbyist money. I know no one cares about the corruption except the currentAF members and retired military members watching their government buying outdated equipment with outdated technology.
Coming back to the USA many military members find no jobs and have no insurance for their families. The Affordable care act at least gives them a fighting chance and better yet the Single- Payer-Universal-Health-Insurance- Plan H.R. 676 would be much better.
Indeed, dennis, Obama has said he wouldn't negotiate regarding the debt ceiling; but he has said again and again that if Republicans had ideas to improve "Obamacare," he'd be willing to listen (and possibly negotiate).
My idea is not only an improvement to the PPACA/"Obamacare", it's what I believe most Americans want. And my article is just as much a tactic to put Boehner on the spot by both offering to repeal "Obamacare" but to replace it with something better.
I e-mailed this article (minus the "f"-bomb) to the President; I don't expect a response, but, if I receive one, or, miracle-of-miracles he calls in Boehner and goes with my idea -- I'll buy you a beer!
Then I'll send you a gift card and you can buy a bunch of Pepsis!
lculation regarding uniting Washington was noble, altruistic, idealistic and unfortunately
Please tell me you are not naive enough to honestly engage in this sort of hagiography tha tis not worthy of any literate person. It just discredits you when this same guy used the "elections have consequences" line to justify excluding Republicans from negotiations on the stimulus at the onset of his administration.
onsequently, trying compromise was both ineffective and ultimately resultant in a "compromise" health insurance law
This type of blatent rewriting of history would have made a Stalinist text book writer blanch. The PPACA was the single most partisan piece of major social legislation passed since the Civil War. Republicans were not involved in any of the process and it only passed over the wishes of the majority of the population because of legislative kickbacks to get Democrats on board. Remember the Cornhusker kickback? the Louisiana purchase? The idea that these Senators would have supported legislation that was even more radical is so bizarre as to be untethered to reality as we know it.
PPACA BUT IT'S TIME TO TAKE IT THE REST OF THE WAY -- TO SINGLE-PAYER UNIVERSAL HEALTH INSURANCE -- STAND WITH ME AMERICA" -- he'll get it!
This is insane. The idea that the Republican house would somehow vote for this suggests a troubling disconnect from reality. I thought the discussion was supposed to be about ending the shutdown, not engaging in Obama fantasy fan fiction.
Me too; and you have my word regarding the gift card.
Could it be?
I think it possible a pair of articles, one written two days after I posted this, and one, four days after, may have run with my "Single-Payer/Obama strategy" a link to one such article and an excerpt:
...
The debt ceiling turns out to be unexploded ordnance lying around the American form of government. Only custom or moral compunction stops the opposition party from using it to nullify the presidents powers, or, for that matter, the president from using it to nullify Congresss. (Obama could, theoretically, threaten to veto a debt ceiling hike unless Congress attaches it to the creation of single-payer health insurance.) It is a shockingly powerful self-destruct button built into our very system of government, but only useful for the most ideologically hardened or borderline sociopathic. But it turns out to be the perfect tool for the contemporary GOP