╌>

Beware Persian Leaders with Masks

  

Category:  News & Politics

Via:  buzz-of-the-orient  •  13 years ago  •  10 comments

Beware Persian Leaders with Masks

Beware Persian Leaders with Masks

By Michael J. Totten for World Affairs, September 29, 2013

5802_discussions.jpg

Barack Obama and Iranian President Hassan Rouhani spoke on the phone for a couple of minutes on Friday, and NBC News breathlessly reported that this was the first time leaders from the U.S. and Iran have directly communicated since the 1979 Iranian revolution.

Thats not exactly true. Hassan Rouhani is not Irans leader.

Supreme Guide Ayatollah Ali Khamenei is Iran s leader. He is the head of statethe dictatorand the one who makes all sovereign decisions. And of course Rouhani is loyal and does what hes told. Khamenei and his hand-picked Guardian Council vetted him thoroughly. Otherwise he wouldnt be president.

Iranian expat Sohrab Ahmari summed it up bluntly , and aptly, in The Wall Street Journal after Rouhani won the presidential show election in August . This is what democracy looks like in a theocratic dictatorship. Iran 's presidential campaign season kicked off last month when an unelected body of 12 Islamic jurists disqualified more than 600 candidates. Women were automatically out; so were Iranian Christians, Jews and even Sunni Muslims. The rest, including a former president, were purged for possessing insufficient revolutionary zeal. Eight regime loyalists made it onto the ballots. One emerged victorious on Saturday.

It is still historic than Obama spoke on the phone to a second-tier regime official, but its not like Richard Nixon going to China and meeting with Mao Zedong. Nor is this the beginning of the kind of dtente Ronald Reagan and Mikhail Gorbachev established near the end of the Cold War.

For that, the President of the United States would need to meet with the Supreme Guide of Iran. And the Supreme Guide of Iran would need to be reasonable. He would need to pull the kind of reversal of Iranian policy that Anwar Sadat did in Egypt after the Yom Kippur War. None of those things are happening. I wish they were, but theyre not.

So lets not get carried away.

Click this link to discover the rest of the truth about the smiley Iranian takkiyah:

http://worldaffairsjournal.org/blog/michael-j-totten/beware-persian-leaders-masks


Tags

jrDiscussion - desc
[]
 
Buzz of the Orient
Professor Expert
link   seeder  Buzz of the Orient    13 years ago

The prevailing narrative in the Western media regarding the new president of the Islamic Republic of Iran, Hassan Rouhani, is reminiscent of the optimistic assessment of Ayatollah Khomeini by the Jimmy Carter administration. President Carter's ambassador to the UN, Andrew Young, said that Khomeini will eventually be hailed as a saint; President Carter's ambassador to Iran, William Sullivan, observed that Khomeini was a Gandhi-like figure. Khomeini was seen by the administration at that time as a man of impeccable integrity and honesty. Today, of course, the gravity of this historic mistake and its consequences are self-evident.

HASSAN ROUHANI AND WESTERN SELF-DELUSION
G. William Heiser & Amir Abbas Fakhravar
Real Clear World , Sept. 29, 2013

 
 
 
Buzz of the Orient
Professor Expert
link   seeder  Buzz of the Orient    13 years ago

Netanyahu's visit with Obama will be a waste of time. He will never be able to convince the Muslim-loving Hussein of the danger that is fast approaching.

 
 
 
Petey Coober
Freshman Silent
link   Petey Coober    13 years ago

It looks like everyone is being taken in from the US leadership to the Iranian people ... They voted Rouhani into office but he is mostly just a figurehead .

 
 
 
Kavika
Professor Expert
link   Kavika     13 years ago

Watch out for the man behind the screen.

 
 
 
Buzz of the Orient
Professor Expert
link   seeder  Buzz of the Orient    13 years ago

Surely, Kavika, you're not making a Wizard of Oz reference there, are you?

 
 
 
Cletus Wilbury
Freshman Silent
link   Cletus Wilbury    13 years ago

Well, it is exactly true that Rouhani is an Iranian leader.

This should be interesting to watch.

The Domestic Politics Driving Irans Diplomatic Shift Author: Ray Takeyh , Senior Fellow for Middle Eastern Studies
September 25, 2013
Financial Times

But Mr Rouhani's success abroad does not mitigate his problems at home. Ayatollah Ali Khamenei, the supreme leader who holds the ultimate authority in the Islamic Republic , and his aggrieved Revolutionary Guard are wary of the new president. It is the domestic manoeuvres of these three parties that is likely to define the terms and limits of Mr Rouhani's diplomacy particularly regarding Iran's nuclear programme.

...

It has long been known that the Guard oversees Iran's nuclear infrastructure and has a vested interest in the programme's survival. It was during Mr Rouhani's tenure from 2003 to 2005 as the nuclear negotiator that the programme was suspended, causing much resentment among those scenting the power of atomic weapons. Mr Rouhani's appointment of Ali Shamkhani a longtime guardsman and an advocate of Iran's nuclear surge as head of the Supreme National Security Council must have calmed nerves. The programme remains firmly with the SNSC despite official claims it has been transferred to the foreign ministry. Mr Shamkhani will devise the strategy while Mohammad Javad Zarif, the urbane, thoughtful foreign minister , will present it at any international talks.

...

Mr Khamenei is likely to offer Mr Rouhani an opportunity to craft a nuclear settlement, but the terms have to be acceptable to the ever suspicious supreme leader and his Revolutionary Guard. Should the president succeed, commerce and contracts will return to Iran, ensuring the survival of the regime. Should he fail, a unified elite will try to persuade the Iranian populace that the cause of their hardship is American truculence. Putting aside the bickering and back-stabbing that has characterised Iran's politics in the past eight years, the Islamic Republic will try to fracture the international consensus on its nuclear programme. Either way, Mr Khamenei wins.

...

By changing the style and tone of its diplomacy in this way, Tehran can offer itself as a stable power and so legitimise its nuclear programme. By condemning the chemical weapons attacks in Syria as opposed to suggesting that the evidence was fabricated by Washington and Jerusalem, and by calling for nuclear transparency as opposed to denouncing the inspectors as spies of a mendacious west, Mr Rouhani can present Iran as a regional stakeholder not just a violent spoiler. Should perceptions of Iran change, then perhaps its nuclear programme can seem less menacing.

...

If that's what Iran is thinking, while it's a welcomed change in rhetoric, it will not be enough to stop the sanctions. Yeah, the Iranian government can blame the failure of the offer* on the U.S. or the west in general. I still think the effort is worthwhile, but UN inspectors will be required before we believe Iran is serious about not working towards nuclear weapon capabilities.

-----------------------------

* (in reality of just a changing rhetoric)

 
 
 
Kavika
Professor Expert
link   Kavika     13 years ago

Me Buzz!!! no way.

 
 
 
Aeonpax
Freshman Silent
link   Aeonpax    13 years ago

I would agree with you, even a change in rhetoric offers a welcome relief to the constant pounding of war drums in regards to a war with Iran. The easing of sanctions against Iran by the US as a good will gesture, may also pave the way for an eventual peace.

 
 
 
Cletus Wilbury
Freshman Silent
link   Cletus Wilbury    13 years ago

For a long as I can remember Republicans and hawks of other stripes have said economic sanctions "don't work".

Why Economic Sanctions Dont Work - 1998

When I was a kid, the boy next door once played a nasty trick on my brother Paul: our neighbor held his cat in his arms, brought it within a few inches of Pauls face, and pulled its tail. The suddenly angry cat bit Pauls face. My brother and I were upset; the cat, we thought, should have bitten the perpetrators face. I think of that incident whenever I hear people call for economic sanctions against a whole country.

...

Although socialism is whats killing poor people in Cuba, for example, Fidel Castro has, for almost forty years, blamed Cubas economic problems on the blockade, his word for the embargo imposed by the U.S. government in the early 1960s. But he can plausibly make this claim because the embargo exists. Likewise, although much of the Iraqis pain is caused by Saddam Husseins diversion of resources to his war machine, the pain caused by economic sanctions is quite real.

...

What do people in embargoed countries do when they find out that foreign governments threaten their survival? They want to do what the cat wouldnt do: bite the hand or face of the perpetrator. In fact, I can think of no case in history where as a result of sanctions imposed by government A on people in country B, country Bs people overthrew their own government. Its the stuff of novels, and not very good novels.

Good points, but I can point to some examples in history where economic sanctions have worked.

Take the embargo against Japan in 1941.

Japan's Decision for War in 1941: Some Enduring Lessons

The Japanese decision to initiate war against the United States in 1941 continues to perplex. Did the Japanese recognize the odds against them? How did they expect to defeat the United States?

Japan's aggression in China, military alliance with Hitler, and proclamation of a "Greater East Asian Co-Prosperity Sphere" that included resource-rich Southeast Asia were major milestones along the road to war, but the proximate cause was Japan's occupation of southern French Indochina in July 1941, which placed Japanese forces in a position to grab Malaya, Singapore, and the Dutch East Indies. Japan's threatened conquest of Southeast Asia, which in turn would threaten Great Britain's ability to resist Nazi aggression in Europe, prompted the administration of Franklin D. Roosevelt to sanction Japan by imposing an embargo on U.S. oil exports upon which the Japanese economy was critically dependent. Yet the embargo, far from deterring further Japanese aggression, prompted a Tokyo decision to invade Southeast Asia. By mid-1941 Japanese leaders believed that war with the United States was inevitable and that it was imperative to seize the Dutch East Indies, which offered a substitute for dependency on American oil.

In hindsight, the embargo worked perfectly. It forced the Japanese government to choose, war or peace.

I will also claim that had the US joined the League of Nations in its oil embargo of Italy in 1936, the Italian military would have been hard pressed in the same way the Japanese were, if not more so.

That theory is heavily debate. Anyone want to argue I'm wrong about the oil embargo against Italy, above? Or just want to read more details on the history?

 
 
 
Cletus Wilbury
Freshman Silent
link   Cletus Wilbury    13 years ago

From that same article:

The Japanese-American road to the Pacific War in 1941 yields several enduring lessons of particular relevance for today's national security decisionmakers:

1. Fear and honor, "rational" or not, can motivate as much as interest.

2. There is no substitute for knowledge of a potential adversary's history and culture.

3. Deterrence lies in the mind of the deterree, not the deterrer.

4. Strategy must always inform and guide operations.

5. Economic sanctioning can be tantamount to an act of war.

6. The presumption of moral or spiritual superiority can fatally discount the consequences of an enemy's material superiority.

7. "Inevitable" war easily becomes a self-fulfilling prophesy.

Those sound like valid lessons, especially #5. I think that demonstrates how economic sanctions can work.

 
 

Who is online



Gazoo


94 visitors