How Do You Defend From This?
This man said he was going to walk down the street and hit the first white man he saw. He managed to punch three of them in the face, and the first one he hit died from the encounter.
What is the defense for this type of attack? How do we even address this type of insanity?
http://www.nbcnewyork.com/news/local/Union-Square-Bias-Attack-White-Person-Punch-Death-222995081.html
Tags
Who is online
117 visitors

There was no warning, Mike. He just walked up to them and hit them. No prelude.
It seems ridiculous that they are still debating this as a hate crime. He only shouted that he "hated white people".
I agree. I hate hate crime. I think it should be outlawed.
It was a hate crime. Who is debating this?
The whole purpose of a surprise attack, is to hit your opponent when he is least expecting it, thereby giving the aggressor the advantage of "surprise". I don't know how I'd defend myself against this. Me, I'd probably be looking up at the sky, or 'window shopping', being fair game for anyone that would hit me.
You can't live your life with your adrenaline pumping, expecting to be thwacked at any moment, ready to be attacked. It's too hard on your body, your heart, etc. Yet, it appears that all of us must somehow do so.
I'd say it was a hate crime. He targeted a specific group of people, and acted out on his fantasy. The people he hit weren't necessarily the individuals he was mad at, just their racial profile. It's not right, no matter who does it.
Glad I live elsewhere. It's a lot more peaceful in spots here at home.
If you rob a bank and you kill someone, that isn't hate. It's just doing business.
If an father who just lost his job and goes home and kills his family, it isn't hate, it's insanity.
When the mob takes out a contract, it's business.
When a guy says that he is going to kill the first white guy he sees, that is a hate crime.
As you know it is impossible to avoid brushing up against someone else where they were. The man was, I believe near 70 years old, had no idea what he was in for.
I still don't believe in hate crime although this definitely qualifies as one. I think hate should be considered but not classified.
We all know it was a hate crime, but I would prefer to rid ourselves of the words "hate crime" and just punish him for taking another person's life with the circumstances to be considered in the punishment.
I really hate it when something like this happens for all of us. It's one step forward and two steps back for our society.
Where is George Zimmerman now that we need him ?!
The hate attacks with no fore-warning [an argument or some kind of verbal fight], but just going up to some random person and assaulting them - wouldn't seem to be possible to defend against; just not enough time. And now the perp has a death on his soul to bear.
Murder is murder, but not all murder comes from hate. When there is a bank robbery, and a cop is shot, there is no hate, but a misguided idea that they will get away.
And not all hate ends in death.
Aswastika on a synagogue's door doesn't kill anyone, but is hate.
Do you think the president will make a speech to explain to us how we must try to understand where this young man was coming from with his rage against the white man, based on the history of the black people in America that he hasn't been able to get past?
Interesting thought, mimi. I can't excuse 'hate' violence of any kind.
I don't think he intended death to be the result, Chloe. By the same token, I don't understand why he decided on attacking someone so much older and less able to defend themselves than someone younger might have been.
The other two men who were attacked had tried to help the elderly gentlemen. The attacker was able to defeat two on one which suggests either a high level of rage or perhaps a drug induced attack.
The entire episode is bizarre and very sad. And it unfortunately reinforces the very thing Obama was trying to suggest was unwarranted in the stereotyping of young black males.... that they are potentially violent and should be avoided if encountered on the streets or in public places.
When these types of incidents are happening, no amount of rationalizing can dismiss thepreconceivednotion that it's best to play it safe and avoid close contact. Not even a presidential speech can smooth away an irrational incident like this, although it has only happened once.
Oh, neither do I. My point was more that of unintended consequences; or in other words, how many times do some take action without thinking about the consequences beyond the momentary effect.
In addition to your article scenario, there are many examples that can happen in our daily lives where people use emotion first, and logic second, and then have hind-sight.
With the wide-spread age range, it pretty much looks like random decision to me - for the victim, it would seem to be 'being in the wrong place at the wrong time.' Very unfortunate.
The entire incident seems off kilter, even the talking about how he hates white people and is going to hit the first one he sees. No would announce something like that to the world at large. Sounds like something you would do if you were drunk in a bar.
Chloe is correct, this is the unintended consequences type of thing, and I'm thinking either alcohol or drug induced.
I would love to see Obama put his foot in his mouth about this but he seems to pick his cases very selectively . His slickness allows him to come out as the "President of all the people" even though he has already stepped out of that role ...
Why does it have to be "slickness"? Wouldn't the word "wisdom" fit as well? He's wise enough to know when to shut up. Unlike many of his cohorts.
Why slickness ? Because the president is expected to be the president of all the people . He is expected to not show favoritism to one ethnicity over others . But Obama seems to be incapable of acting in that role .
Agreed. I've and I'm sure you have seen a lot of bully types in our lives, but we've not seen any unless they were crazy take on someone they knew could whip their ass. This incidence as it happened should eliminate the insanity defense stance in itself.
"I just went crazy, but not crazy enough to hit someone who could whip my ass," said the guy. <sarc>
I shouldn't even joke about this since as I understand the man who is now dead for all practical purposes was a retired train driver or something like that and was taking care of someone, maybe his mother, I don't know for sure.
It is our responsibility to either bring people together not divide them. There hasn't been a lot of that going on lately.
Yes, he promotes racism [not just him]; it's used to intentionally cause division in the populace to play up 'sides' - partisanship... then faux fixes promised to the lower classes to get votes. ...As I like to say, "One thing always leads to another." ..And that's not conspiracy theory -- it's common-sense.
That is true. It's also true that many of us have behavior and feelings that is normally hidden by political correctness, and for some it borders on hatred that can rise to the surface when alcohol and drugs are present.
Otherwise, political correctness is what helps us function as a reasonable society among people we would otherwise not associate with. No amount of legislating or preaching is going to change the mind of people who have ingrained prejudices.