Compelling Theory - Trump Is Successful In Campaign because Obama Is Successful In Presidency
I heard an interesting analysis of Donald Trump's popularity the other day. I can't remember which talking head brought it up, so I can't give credit, but I think it is an interesting and probably accurate explanation.
According to this idea, Trump is doing so well in the Republican presidential polls, despite his being a preposterous boor who is literally ignorant about many of the issues facing the nation today, because President Obama has done so well in his presidency despite the GOP taking full control of Congress.
Obama has governed with executive orders, won more than once in critical Supreme Court decisions, seen his stamp of approval on gay marriage fulfilled in a burgeoning national consensus, completed an important nuclear arms deal on the international stage, and has seen his approval ratings rise among the American people, all while he was supposedly buried under a "LAME DUCK" status , and while his opponents have control of both houses of Congress.
This has peed off many a "patriot", right winger , and conservative, especially those who have especially hated Obama throughout his presidency.
Trump comes in and calls Obama names, and calls Clinton names, and calls all the GOP politicians who have allowed Obama to be successful in the late stages of his "lame duck" presidency names. To this seething mindset, Trump's obvious shortcomings, such as no political experience, abominable personality, and cluelessness about both the government and just about any policy issue you could imagine, have no importance.
The only important thing is that he tells everyone that Obama is stupid , and that the world is laughing at us because of Obama, and that the Republicans who tolerate this this state of affairs are stupid and have the world laughing at us.
Donald Trump promises to make all right with the world again.
Added bonus - Trump (still) isn't sure if Obama was born in America.

Donald Trump is a fucking idiot that just loves to hear himself talk.
It disturbs me that anyone takes his <cough> <cough> "campaign" seriously.
To say that he is boorish is an understatement, he never talks about any issues in earnest, his entire campaign is a series of one-liners and pig-headed bloviation, he's rude, crude, and a thoughtless dipshit.
Oh, and his hair is a goddamned joke.
More Americans disapprove of Obamas so called successes than approve. One could just as easily say Trump is doing well because Obama has been such a failure.
All President Obama Job Approval Polling Data
Dean, how do you explain the popularity of a candidate that has no idea about government ,or national or world issues, and whose answer to most questions is " I am very rich" ?
Something has to explain why Trump is leading, AND why his base is composed of a particular type of Republican (one who is very anti-Obama), when it is obvious Trump is totally unqualified to be President of the United States.
you are misunderstanding the sentence.
maybe i should have said "despite the GOP taking full control of Congress"
Asshats like trump are laughed at when the country is optimistic and happy about its condition. His success is tied to obamas failure.
Part of Trumps popularity is that he can fund his own campaign. Part of it is he's not a Washington insider and people want real change not more of the same. Part of it is his fame as a TV star and partly because they see Obama as a failure. I suspect his ratings will fall in the future.
Except that the last year has been widely seen as success for Obama. Won on Obamacare, won on gay marriage (although that was not really his issue), took it to Congress on immigration, economy improving, completed nuclear deal with Iran, etc.
The red meat GOP thought Obama was left for dead after the last midterms. Now, Trump offers the yahoos a chance at the last laugh.
I think the theory in the OP is the likely one.
Also note trump is statistically tied with the democratic frontrunner in Iowa, a blue state where the democratic candidate has been camped out ( when not meeting with lawyers to avoid jail). To imply that his appeal is simply limite to republicans is simply false at this point.
Sure, a Trump presidency would be a disaster for the nation on practically every level. But just think of the comedic gold it would produce. And if we survived 4 years of a Trump administration (a big if, I grant you) think of the amusing stories we could tell. Just call me a glass-half-full kinda guy.
Why hasn't Joe Biden declared a run yet?
Since when did a sitting vice-president not even bother to attempt a run on the heels of a two term president?
Sure, "Dick Cheney", but he was hated like he was the anti-Christ.
Trump makes my head want to explode.
I wish he'd choke to death on his enormous ego.
Well, I did qualify my statement with "if we survived...".
Probably because the last time he tried it in 2008 he fell flat on his face and didn't get very far.
My guess is that Biden is going to wait as long as he can to see if anything comes from the email stuff. If it looks like it will get serious he'll jump in. If it looks like it will blow over, he'll stay out. He still has a few months.
A Donald Trump Presidency is a credible threat to the entire population of the world.
I don't know how anyone can see him as anything other than a freak show, but how in the world can anyone actually think of that buffoon sitting down in the Oval Office and being the leader of the free world without a cringe going down their spine?
It is literally inconceivable to me.
I hear he's going tomake his hair his running mate.
Trump/Trump's Hair 2016!
There are a few people around me who are unfailingly honest and can't lie and you see them for what they are - blemishes and all.
I think this is what is appealing about Trump. I'd say Sanders has this quality too.
Trump's going to fade out though because there's a few blemishes too many for a President. The best analogy I heard so far is Trump is like having as much pancakes and ice cream as you want - delicious for sure, but we realize eventually that's not good for us. The population just hasn't quite gotten there yet but they will.
"unfailingly honest and can't lie and you see them for what they are - blemishes and all.
I think this is what is appealing about Trump."
You're kidding, right?
So ... summarizing what is wrong with Trump [from your POV ] , he has bad hair ? That's the only statement you made that is verifiable .
I hope so...
Only sheep would be misdirected by the gay marriage issue . It is nothing but a red herring to get voters minds off the economy . Say baaah , John !
Compare that to other candidates who give us lipstick on the pig canned responses to everything and don't answer anyone's questions.
I get your point that Trump's answers are highly rationalized - just like the kinds of answers humans in general use. It's still more honest than the crap we get from the mainstream candidates.
I think Trump is out of his mind and I'll never vote for him, but the fact is he is talking to us. That's why he's getting support. Most of the other candidates aren't even taking to us they're just spouting BS.
I don't even think he's getting support based on what his positions are on issues. He's got a populist streak the mainstream GOP hates - especially openly advocating universal health care.
You are a sucker to Trump. No more, no less.
Learn how to read English shit-breath boy ...
That's politics - you're a sucker for Ms Clinton, Rubio, Jeb Bush or whoever else is running for office.
Out of all the people running, I'd say Sanders is the only one that actually gives a damn about what happens and will give it an honest effort if he's elected. All the others including Trump just want a cool job with perks and some power and judge their success by poll numbers - and the corruption we have in government now will go on unabated.