╌>

John Kerry reveals Arab countries have offered to PAY America to carry out full-scale invasion of Syria

  

Category:  News & Politics

Via:  rescue  •  13 years ago  •  155 comments

John Kerry reveals Arab countries have offered to PAY America to carry out full-scale invasion of Syria

Secretary of State John Kerry said during a hearing Wednesday in the House of Representatives that counties in the Arab world have offered to foot the entire bill for a U.S. military mission that destroys the Bashar al-Assad regime in Syria.

'With respect to Arab countries offering to bear costs and to assist, the answer is profoundly yes,' Kerry said. 'They have. That offer is on the table.'

5985_discussions.jpg

Florida Republican Rep. Ileana Ros-Lehtinen had asked Kerry to comment on the expenses related to carrying out attacks on Syria if Congress were to authorize them.

Following through on a use-of-force resolution, she said, 'could potentially cost ... billions.'

But Kerry said other nations that see Assad as a destabilizing force in the region have proposed to cover the costs.


Tags

jrDiscussion - desc
[]
 
Mark in Wyoming
Professor Silent
link   Mark in Wyoming     13 years ago

So they offered to PAY Us? they think of us as nothing more than paid mercinairies? , here is what I have to say to those camel riding , falafel eating dirt bags , GO FUCK YOURSELF Hassan . fight your own friggen war for your own beliefs . translation , stand up and grow your own pair numb nuts.

 
 
 
Dowser
Sophomore Silent
link   Dowser    13 years ago

If it is something we want to do anyway, and it involves no troops on the ground, then why not let them help defray the costs of a few conventional missile strikes?

Or am I missing something here?

 
 
 
Kavika
Professor Expert
link   Kavika     13 years ago

I think that you are Dowser. They don't have the guts to fight their own battles, so they think that they can use us as paid mercenaries, to fight to save their ass.

There will be blow back if we strike and Americans will be killed. That, they made a promise on already. So, what is an American life worth to these chicken shit asshatz. $10,000, $25,000, $100,000. Maybe they'll offer to cover the cost of the funeral.

Dowser, IMO we have no business in Syria. It's a civil war. We do not belong in the middle of a civil war. I'm all for doing what we can for the children, supplies, food, medicine, but to fightthese chicken shit cowardsbattles for them, NO WAY.

 
 
 
Mark in Wyoming
Professor Silent
link   Mark in Wyoming     13 years ago

dowser , no arguments there , if they want to pay for it , let them , but first lets find out if the population of this country will pay with the blood needed to support such an action.

john , I don't think there is any question about other countries desiring action , so there is no real "LIE" as you seem to think , when only question is should we the people pay in the price of blood and posterity for our governments actions on something not supported as a whole by the people that would be involved. john your entitled to your opinion just as I am mine , that and a buck fidty a piece , will get us both a cup of coffee at the quick mart. remember a leader is one that people choose to follow , there are those that choose not to follow certain leaders because they feel they have no leadership qualities , or for whatever reasons they hold not to follow them .

so just as you call bullshite on others , I call bullshite on you complaining about the lack of fidelity to the current admin , they are not worthy imho and that's all that is , my opinion. have a nice day( translation: go fuck yourself and your dreams of self important rightiousness).

 
 
 
96WS6
Junior Silent
link   96WS6    13 years ago

Darn no link again...Anyhow, I doubt we would see a red cent even it that were true, I heard the Saudis also offered Russia a sweet deal... link provided (hint, hint)

 
 
 
Dowser
Sophomore Silent
link   Dowser    13 years ago

Thanks, Kavika. When you put it that way, I can understand what you mean. Let them put their money on helping the refugees. Smile.gif

 
 
 
Dowser
Sophomore Silent
link   Dowser    13 years ago

Personally, I don't want any of our men or women setting foot on that soil. And I guess flying over it to drop something on it is the same thing...

Thanks for your patience in explaining your viewpoint, both of you! Smile.gif

 
 
 
Mark in Wyoming
Professor Silent
link   Mark in Wyoming     13 years ago

kavi( excuse the abbr please I have been indulging in the adult beverages that kept the irish from ruling the world according to some of course if the stereotype is followed , the native part couldn't handle it anyway , yes im a Heinz 57 mutt a lot of everything , but can think for myself) most appropriate dittos from here.

 
 
 
Kavika
Professor Expert
link   Kavika     13 years ago

Your welcome Dowser. Exactly, let them put their blood money to helping the refugees. Well said my friend.

 
 
 
Kavika
Professor Expert
link   Kavika     13 years ago

Chi-miigwetch (many thanks) Mark. Enjoy the adult beverages.Smile.gif

 
 
 
Mark in Wyoming
Professor Silent
link   Mark in Wyoming     13 years ago

5986_discussions.jpg

here you go John , I for one choose not to follow this nutless wonder,( notice the black sheep is in whiteface , a tribute to his mixed heritage ). from one from Wyoming , where the men are men , the women are as well, and the sheep are always nervous.

 
 
 
Kavika
Professor Expert
link   Kavika     13 years ago

John there are other countries that what a strike. The problem is they don't want to lead the way. Yup, good old moral support from them.

 
 
 
Kavika
Professor Expert
link   Kavika     13 years ago

Here you go 96.

 
 
 
96WS6
Junior Silent
link   96WS6    13 years ago

A very good reason for pause, and to ask why they are so hell bent on getting Assad out, keeping in mind who we know Assad is fighting of course, and given the current state of Libya.

 
 
 
Tsula
Freshman Silent
link   Tsula    13 years ago

Allow me please to slip in here and say that a couple of days ago when Putin was in full voice he made a statement that if we went forward with the attack on Syria he would retaliate with a full attack on Saudi Arabia. I thought that it was strange until I read about his meeting with the Prince where they did not part as bosom buddies. About a half hour after I went back to find it and lo and behold it had been taken down. Things to make a body go HHhhmmmmmmmmmm!

 
 
 
Kavika
Professor Expert
link   Kavika     13 years ago

''Things to make a body to HHhhhhhhhh. Yup, it sure does tsula.

 
 
 
96WS6
Junior Silent
link   96WS6    13 years ago

First time I heard that, searched it and this was all I could find. I have no experience with either source. (credible?)

...

...

 
 
 
Mark in Wyoming
Professor Silent
link   Mark in Wyoming     13 years ago

96 , it would do us well to remember that the US is not the only player ( as a super power) on the world stage , what we should remember is what the cost will be in the end . and that all players will play to their best interests irregardless of the outcome, its human nature.

 
 
 
Tsula
Freshman Silent
link   Tsula    13 years ago

I don't really know but that is in essence the story that I read also. Credible sources? Who can tell these days?

 
 
 
96WS6
Junior Silent
link   96WS6    13 years ago

Your preaching to the choir Mark. I am against a strike and regime change by the US.

 
 
 
Petey Coober
Freshman Silent
link   Petey Coober    13 years ago

That 1st site seems to go in for sensationalist material . For example :
...

Russia Orders Obama: Tell World About Aliens, Or We Will

This has the feel of a supermarket tabloid ...

 
 
 
Tsula
Freshman Silent
link   Tsula    13 years ago

I'll say! Holy Cow now it is alien life?

 
 
 
Petey Coober
Freshman Silent
link   Petey Coober    13 years ago

Good argument Rescue . I didn't know about the size of Assad's chemical stockpile . Unfortunately , I don't think that would jog the US congress to act .

 
 
 
Dowser
Sophomore Silent
link   Dowser    13 years ago

Me?

I wish... I'm punch drunk with exhaustion. Mama has 4 doctor's appointments in 4 work days. Thursday, Friday, Monday, Tuesday, and then I get to go to the doctor on Wednesday. MRI on Monday. Also, pay her bills, shop for her, manage her in-home help, run back to L'ville to tape the half time show for my son's band, take him to Saturday's parade, and go with them to the next competition, THEN run back to Owensboro for round 2. Sometime in there, I have to do laundry, clean at my own house, take the dog to the vet, etc...

I'm absolutely worn out. Smile.gif

 
 
 
Kavika
Professor Expert
link   Kavika     13 years ago

Rescue, ''Many of you people don't look beyond your noses''.

First, may I suggest that you look beyond your nose Rescue. What makes you think that a ''surgical strike'' is going to have any affect. Do you have a crystal ball that say's Assad is going to pick up his marbles and be a good boy. You, nor anyone else has any idea what he will do in retaliation. The premise that this ''surgical strike'' is not going to have a reaction within Syria is at best speculation.

As you stated, Syria has one of the largest stockpiles of WMD in the world. Our own military has stated it would take 75,000 to 100,000 boots on the ground to secure all the WMD's in Syria. So, if Assad decides to fight back after our ''surgical strike'', what do suggest we do?

Why on earth do you bring Indians into this. I don't give a shit what they believe. If they decide to wipe anyone out, it's the whole U.S. no color, religion etc will deter them. You'll be gone as soon as any Indian.

BTW, Mormons have the same belief re Indians. Should I have a ''surgical strike'' on SLC, get them before they get me.

Youranalogy is beyond ridiculous at best.

I'm not willing to sacrifice one American more, to the pit called the m/e.

 
 
 
Kavika
Professor Expert
link   Kavika     13 years ago

Did you choose not to answer my questions Rescue. Libya is no comparison to Syria.

''I used them as an example to bring it close to home for you.'' I don't need you to bring it home for me rescue. A suicidebomber did that years ago.

 
 
 
Kavika
Professor Expert
link   Kavika     13 years ago

The question regarding what are we going to do if he decides to fight back.

How many children will it take? Youmean in addition to the Americankids that have already died or are maimed for life. You mean the Marines kidsin Beirut that died and were maimed on a ''Peace Keeping'' mission. 200 plus dead from a suicide bomber.You know Beirut, that country in the M/E, were we have been fighting off and on for 25 years. Those kids Rescue, the ones that have to take enough drugs to stop a horse to maintain. Those kids, are those the ones your talking about?

Those are the ones that I think of everyday, every single day. 24/7 Rescue.

 
 
 
Kavika
Professor Expert
link   Kavika     13 years ago

He wasn't talking about you Dowser, it was Mark...

 
 
 
Kavika
Professor Expert
link   Kavika     13 years ago

Rescue, my concern is our children. Let the M/E take care of their own. You don't have any idea what I feel in my gut. Let it be.

 
 
 
Dowser
Sophomore Silent
link   Dowser    13 years ago

Sorry! Thanks Kavika-- I'm so stupid these days, I may sound drunk! My days are passing in a whirl of undone things. Smile.gif

 
 
 
Mark in Wyoming
Professor Silent
link   Mark in Wyoming     13 years ago

regular inspector Cleusue aren't you john? all it took was an admission from me and you came to that conclusion, youll make a fine junior G-man someday .... NOT.

 
 
 
Aeonpax
Freshman Silent
link   Aeonpax    13 years ago

Reasonably related; Pentagon Cant Afford Syria Operation; Must Seek Additional Funds - The U.S. military, struggling after defense cuts of tens of billions of dollars, will be unable to pay for attacks on Syria from current operating funds and must seek additional money from Congress, according to congressional aides .

 
 
 
Tsula
Freshman Silent
link   Tsula    13 years ago

We MUST strike.

You do it because we do not have the legal right, under international law, regardless of how we personally feel about the perpetrator's (Assad)actions. This needs to be done ONLY under UN controlled supervision. What gives us (you) the right to be judge, jury, and executioner on an international scale?

 
 
 
Robert in Ohio
Professor Guide
link   Robert in Ohio    13 years ago

A question and a pointcome to mind -

Why don't the Arab nations band together and kick Syria's ass?

If the Arab nations are going to pay for U.S. involvement then there should be no whining form the Pentagon that they need relief from the sequestration cuts because of the Syrian overseas contingency operations.

 
 
 
Aeonpax
Freshman Silent
link   Aeonpax    13 years ago

It would appear that Obama's biggest supporters here are the oil producing totalitarian theocracies whom are misogynistic, anti-gay, anti-christian and anti-democracy dictatorships.

 
 
 
Tsula
Freshman Silent
link   Tsula    13 years ago

From what I read somewhere the Arab League wants to take this guy out but can not bring themselves to fire upon a fellow Muslim!! So they plan on hiring (Mercenaries) us to do their dirty work for them. This is a regional problem, IMO, and we have no dog in this fight. Stand down!

 
 
 
96WS6
Junior Silent
link   96WS6    13 years ago

Funny that you equate being against arming and aiding terrorists as cheering for the other side.

 
 
 
Mark in Wyoming
Professor Silent
link   Mark in Wyoming     13 years ago

Tsula , it is one of the tenents of islam that muslims shall not kill other muslims , that's a big no=no in their religion , but they get around it by having the different sects and claiming that one is not a true muslim because they don't practice the faith the same way or believe the same things , its so much easier for them to instigate others to do the killing for them , and them keep their hands clean of the affair.

one has to remember that the leaders in these nations stay in power through a religious doctrine they follow dictated by whomever is in the simple majority religious sect of the nation.

 
 
 
96WS6
Junior Silent
link   96WS6    13 years ago

That seems strange....If you are paying someone else to kill Muslims, aren't you in-fact still responsible for killing Muslims? It is OK if you hire non-Muslims to do it? Really?

 
 
 
Tsula
Freshman Silent
link   Tsula    13 years ago

Mark, agreed but simple checking , which is where I qualify, simple, finds that the 3 major sects Sharia, Sunni, and Kurds have been, and are now, killing each other with gay abandon. It seemsthat the only people that they take greater pleasure in killing just happen to be Christians and Jews. They are totally a violent society regardless of how they deny it.

 
 
 
Mark in Wyoming
Professor Silent
link   Mark in Wyoming     13 years ago

yep 96 , its alright to hire a non muslim to do the deed , as long as you don't get the blood on your hands personally, infidels afterall aren't allowed into Islamic heaven anyway, so they have nothing to lose, least that's my understanding of their beliefs , they have to actually have the blood on their hands and do the deed to be judged , now arranging the deed , the blood is not on their hands so to speak . remember also , their religion allows them to lie in order to further their beliefs, taqquea ( sp) is what I think its called.

 
 
 
JoAnne Odel
Freshman Silent
link   JoAnne Odel    13 years ago

kerry should have gone in obamas place to negotiate with putin, as a known communist sypathizer, he surely would be even more effective. this could free obama up to be "more flexible" with all the russian transexuals that seem to run his former soviet policies.

 
 
 
JoAnne Odel
Freshman Silent
link   JoAnne Odel    13 years ago

lol, confusing i know!

cant help w/the red underlines, you may want to ask obama.

 
 
 
Mark in Wyoming
Professor Silent
link   Mark in Wyoming     13 years ago

whatever floats your boat babe, sorry not a supremacist white or otherwise ( read that a liberal progressive, collective socialist) not a member of any tea party group , though I do tend to adhere to the original intent of the Constitution and the powers granted within , I also understand the limitations that document places on the federal entity , which is constantly attempting through circumvention by color of law its constraints. I also do tend to believe even though a person is a citizen that they can also be a domestic enemy of this Constitutional Republic ( not a democracy that some erringly think we have as a form of government ). no need for forts , stockades or bunkers in my mind , as for the rest , I have what I need , and mitigate to the lowest possible amount , by law I have to give to a government and particularly an administration I oppose , which madam , is my right of free choice , you want to pay more , have at it . as for picking a poison, you already picked yours , and there is no way you can make anyone else take it .

 
 
 
Mark in Wyoming
Professor Silent
link   Mark in Wyoming     13 years ago

Im still waiting to see this supposed "proof " that it was assad or the Syrian government that used chemical weapons , lets not forget that saddams chemical stockpile some how "vanished prior to that invasion , popular theories are they were smuggled out to the north by former soviets , or smuggled out if you believe an iraqui AF generals congressional testimony that they were air lifted out of Iraq to Syria to end up in who knows whose hands , so there is a definite posability the rebels aligned with AQ did this themselves to foster animosity against a disliked regime . Like I said a lets see the proof positive , because this transparent admin , isn't really all that transparent , and ill just say as Reagan said , trust( not ) but verify , so lets see the verification of who actually did the deed .

 
 
 
Petey Coober
Freshman Silent
link   Petey Coober    13 years ago

That type of nonsense "thinking" is almost enough to convince me to want to avoid US involvement in Syria .

 
 
 
Mark in Wyoming
Professor Silent
link   Mark in Wyoming     13 years ago

...

for other links than the sun.

 
 
 
Mark in Wyoming
Professor Silent
link   Mark in Wyoming     13 years ago

randy you must be using Hitlers use of zyclon-B as an execution method , if you wish to condemn him you have to condemn California for its past use of the gas chamber as a method of execution , yes saddam used gas against civilians most notably the kurds of the northern provinces , and a group we let downvery badly later on .and against the Iranians during that war , but he wasn't the only one , so did daffy Kaddafi of Libya during his war with chad , and so on down the line till you get to the old world nations that colonized every nook and cranny of the world . and I dare say that there are little brushfire wars in Africa that most likely had chemical weapons used , just not publisized . know how easy it is to make? just mix ammonia , and chlorine beach and take a big whiff in an enclosed space .

 
 
 
Mark in Wyoming
Professor Silent
link   Mark in Wyoming     13 years ago

right Jason , just like saddams scuds were not setting off the chemical detectors at KKMC or in rhihad during the storm nor out of Kuwait city on rte1 northbound...

 
 
 
Mark in Wyoming
Professor Silent
link   Mark in Wyoming     13 years ago

( loud buzzer) wrong randy , many of those smart bombs did indeed need ground personel to "paint " a lazer on target , the AF does have the capability of doing so in flight by the flight crew, but not all services air arms use the same systems , hense the need for FAC's ( forward air controllers) on the ground .

lemme guess your AFSC was MWR?

 
 
 
Mark in Wyoming
Professor Silent
link   Mark in Wyoming     13 years ago

ahh randy a keyboard commando , Mine was the one that kept you safe in that silo or in the CP on base, when something went bump in the night , I was the one that bumped back, or anywhere on base for that matter , I spent enough time around the fugwits in the MEto know Jasons version and description is closer to the reality than yours is.

this isn't a game of thrones , or was it dungeons and dragons in your day? I still say ask for volenteers let those that wish to go those that don't , don't have to , I have a feeling you might want to clean up your old utilities and get ready to go do some fighting for your cause , it sure isn't mine and I wont be supporting it , matter of fact ive already spoken to all 3 of my reps in DC. we shall see how the congressional vote goes, my reps already are aware of the reprecussions here on the home front . where their votes are tallied by their constituants .

 
 
 
Mark in Wyoming
Professor Silent
link   Mark in Wyoming     13 years ago

who could assad retaliate against? hmmm , lets think... randy are you really that obtuse? lets see targets for retaliation through different cells in countries in favor of the actions would be a good start , im sure there are Syrian loyalists in most of those countries , lets not forget the member states of the arab league that are offering to pay the bill ( snort). now of curse if there is no action im sure the affiliates of the rebels have cells that of course could do the same things in those same countries.

short of a bullet in Assads head nope nothing else would work , and most likely even that would just make things worse. besides , there is something in international law that forbids the targeting of another nations head of state other than by his own people , start doing that and the president might as well put a gun to his own head and every future president that follows. last I knew , presidents were not bulletproof , no matter how good their security was or is .

 
 
 
Mark in Wyoming
Professor Silent
link   Mark in Wyoming     13 years ago

randy and there is still nothing stopping you personally from hopping a plane , going to syria , and joining the rebels to fight the fight your saying others must , but somehow I don't think that's going to happen , you going and standing by what you want others to do and risk.

now I will admit , the gOp support for saddam is a black stain on this nation , but this admin so far is 0 for 2 when it comes to regime change and backing decent replacements , I see they want to go for 0 for 3 now .

the US has been meddling in the ME for the past 60 yrs and usually not for the better and usually under a democrats administration . we can go back to the imposing the Shah back on the throne in the 50s , the assassination of egypts nassar which got us sadat who became a soviet satilite lets not forget Libya , we had a hand in installing kadafi though he went soviet on us , we helped saddam gain power through a coup and the only reason we did that was for the listening posts during the cold wat we lost when we lost Iran during their revolutionas well as backed regimes that basically are contrary to America ideals and democratic methods of equality , seems this country is always going with the lesser of the evils offered , heres an idea , lets stay the fuck out of it , ley their peple fight and decide for themselves their own paths , and we deal with what comes out the other end however we have to .

now here is something said that I believe is true for any nations citizens , no just this ones , and they deserve to do so under their own power without outside help or interference ,forming whatever government suits them.

This country, with its institutions, belongs to the people who inhabit it. Whenever they shall grow weary of the existing Government, they can exercise their constitutional right of amending it or their revolutionary right to dismember or overthrow it..."
-- US President Abraham Lincoln, First Inaugural Address , March 4, 1861

the question now is if left alone , do the sides have the will and fortitude to strive to do as they desire.

 
 
 
Mark in Wyoming
Professor Silent
link   Mark in Wyoming     13 years ago

randy , in order to lose standing or credibility , one must first have that quality , this admin lost all that very early on on the world stage someones alligator mouth overloaded their hummingbird ass me thinks , especially without knowing if he had the countrys support, as for this nations standing , it just might be time to tell the rest of the world , we are no longer their police man , and that they better be willing to start putting their own blood on the line and pay their own way thus raisingits standing . after all we still maintain a chemical as well as biological and nuclear stockpile contrary to international agreements .

and like I said your free to go fight the fights you believe in ,so get booking a flight . just don't expect many to follow you that would be worth a tinkers damn , but I wont hold my breath waiting for you to say your on your way to get dirty . somehow , that just doesn't appear to be your "style ". so go get your own skin in the game .

 
 
 
Mark in Wyoming
Professor Silent
link   Mark in Wyoming     13 years ago

president Romney, if he existed would be just as wrong , and I would still oppose the proposed actions for the same reasons , want to try again numb nuts with another backhanded insult? at least I insult a person to their face , you however ,Comment removed for CoC violationtrue progressive liberal can be ., with insinuation and backhandedness. randy , this discussion is over , oh Comment removed for CoC violation

 
 
 
Mark in Wyoming
Professor Silent
link   Mark in Wyoming     13 years ago

Eg , you might be , but im not ,Comment removed for CoC violation Im not PC .

Mark, never had any problems with ou before, so this must be an off day. It's not being PC, it's not breaking the CoC. Please keep it civil

 
 
 
Mark in Wyoming
Professor Silent
link   Mark in Wyoming     13 years ago

are all muslims bad? nope , though those that claim to be alqueda ( the ones that claimed responsibility for the towers) tend to be bad some of the other named groups are bad as well , maybe that's why we have been hunting them down and killing them for 10 yrs now , so explain the logic to me in , arming , training and supporting the same group or an affiliated group that has sworn loyalty to AQ, in a civil war setting , where the facts of gassing are clouded as to who actually did the gassing? this administration says they belive it was one side , I say show the proof . that wont nessisarily waiver my opposition to action on behalve of the other side made up of those we have been fighting killing and chasing all over the globe . neither side is our ally , one is definitely connected to an enemy of the past 10 yrs , sorry but I will not support action that favors a current enemy over one that we simply don't like .

 
 
 
Mark in Wyoming
Professor Silent
link   Mark in Wyoming     13 years ago

naaaaah , im a gelding

 
 
 
Krishna
Professor Guide
link   Krishna    13 years ago

There will be blow back if we strike and Americans will be killed.

In addition to not having "boots on the ground", if Obama does this the smart way, no Americans (and very, very few Syrians) will be killed.

The smart way would be to really limit the attack-- the goal should not be to seriously weaken Assad's military. In fact, IMO we should do everything we can to aboid weakening Assad's military to any significant degree, and especially avoid killing Syrian-- soldiers as well as civilians!

The situation does not lend itself to the use of drones-- and not manned aircraft of course. The weapon of choice would be cruises missiles-- fired from our destroyers offshore and by submarine.

Why is that significant?

Well, the cruise missiles we would probably use have a range of 1000 nautical miles. Think about what that means in terms of putting American soldiers in harms way...

Dowser, IMO we have no business in Syria. It's a civil war. We do not belong in the middle of a civil war.

That is certainly true in most cases, but whether we get involved or not has much wider implications--- some of them have the potential of greatly harming the U.S.

 
 
 
Krishna
Professor Guide
link   Krishna    13 years ago

Who would have ever thought we would enter the era of the NeoDem Warmongers.

Traditionally, the Republicans are much more eager to jump into wars-- the Democrats, not so much. But something here is very different. I saw some video clips on TV today-- statements of political figures who were anxious to get us involved in Iraq (Rumsfeld, a few others). They showed clips of their very hawkish statements at the time.

And then, recent statements from these same Iraq hawks about Syria. They all said the same thing-- the U.S. should not get involved!

And then, some of those who had strongly opposed the war in Iraq-- President Obama and Kerry, and a few others. Those people who opposed i nvolvement in Iraq were the strongest supporters of military intervention in Syria. And the Neocons who were the biggest war-mongers for Iraq are now some of the biggest opponents of taking action in Syria!

(Golly gee-- I wonder why? 15.gif )

 
 
 
Aeonpax
Freshman Silent
link   Aeonpax    13 years ago

False analogy. Aside from the fact that there is absolutely no proof to substantiate that, it's a Straw Man argument.

 
 
 
Aeonpax
Freshman Silent
link   Aeonpax    13 years ago

The obvious reason that those Democrats whom were against war in Iraq but are now for war in Syria, is because it's their man, Obama, that's doing the war mongering. In their obsequious devotion to party and president, they have discarded principles for political ideology.

When I see an argument degenerate to equating the need to go to war with saving children, I'm look at desperation.

 
 
 
Aeonpax
Freshman Silent
link   Aeonpax    13 years ago

I see it as desperate monkeys throwing any kind of shit they can at the wall, hoping something sticks.

 
 
 
JoAnne Odel
Freshman Silent
link   JoAnne Odel    13 years ago

nothing about "jenjiss" kahn?

 
 
 
Mark in Wyoming
Professor Silent
link   Mark in Wyoming     13 years ago

to which ever moderator took out the purple pen, no not an off day , just a very emotional subject , one that I feel very strongly about when it comes to our service people , based on my own experiences . It of course would have been nice if you identified yourself with the deletions .

rescue and raven , your concern for the children is an honorable one , but please consider that others concerns may be for our own children that are of age to bear the brunt of any proposed actions and would actually have to stand and be those boots on the ground , and to insure that this doesn't happen again , it would take actual boots on the ground to secure those weapons , irregardless of which side used them , for whatever reasons , that is the only way to insure that they are never used , someone has to take them away from those that would use them and in doing so , there will be a fight , there will be casualties because they will not want to give them up willingly, who ever has them.

rescue , Jason and the president get different briefings and for different reasons , and view things differently , the president is given the over all picture more in detail to the situation , but by virtue of his position in the chain of commnd , its difficult to put a human face to it , they are numbers and statistics to those at that level , there are percentages and probabilities taken into consideration when weighing the "butchers bill" of the eventual cost for the eventual outcome.

at jasons end , there is a very human face attatched to that bill , so his briefings to properly train his personel may be restricted to his AO, but has to be detailed enough so that he can prepare them for whatever they may face , the best way I can explain it is the president is concerned with the success of the operation or objective , he has a built in set of casualty figures that are determined acceptable , jasons job is to accomplish the objective , and get as many of the personell under him out alive , the president may mention names ,in speeches , honoring the fallen , but its men like Jason that carry them and their face with them the rest of their lives .

randy , you opposed the intervention in Iraq , I take it because of how this nation was sold into going to war, ie the lies supposedly told or the facts omitted, very understandable , and I remember the cry that we should have gone slower before we committed troops , and found out exactly what was what , yet now to save this nations credibility , you appear to wish to do the same thing you admonished the last admin for doing , and insinuate that a slow approach now is based on who the sitting president is , if this admin doesn't get the congressional vote to use military force , it wont be because people are racist , or because its all bushes fault , its because this time round we took heed to making sure the information we have is correct and true , and not some politicians desire at the behest of the MIC to make tons of cash for someone else at the expense of our troops .

it has also been brought to bear the international community , they talk a good game , but where is their payment for those treaties and obligations that some would hold the US solely responsible for , where is their actual skin in the game , the treasure of their youth of draft and war fighting age ? their boots on the ground?

now a little more personal information , how many here lost a family member on Sept 11 , 2001? this will explain , my abboration to anything AQ , or even remotely affiliated with them , yes we have hunted down and killed most responsible for that horrific day , but anyone , and I mean anyone , that flies their banner , claims alliegence ,or loyalty to them , anyone that aides any of the above in any way shape or formwill forever be my personal sworn enemy and I will do anything and everything within my power to insure that they failand are defeated and perish from the face of this earth.

 
 
 
mypocketsrmt
Freshman Silent
link   mypocketsrmt    13 years ago

We will still be funding as theywill pay uswith money they received from us. That makes sense.

 
 
 
Tsula
Freshman Silent
link   Tsula    13 years ago

Well and truly said, IMHO, of course! Especially this for it is yet another chorus of my long standing hymn: it has also been brought to bear the international community , they talk a good game , but where is their payment for those treaties and obligations that some would hold the US solely responsible for , where is their actual skin in the game , the treasure of their youth of draft and war fighting age ? their boots on the ground?

Unless or until there is evidence that we are getting more than hot air, as we seem to be getting now, there is NO shame in our standing down to preserve our greatest treasure--our young people!!

 
 
 
Tsula
Freshman Silent
link   Tsula    13 years ago

....

 
 
 
Aeonpax
Freshman Silent
link   Aeonpax    13 years ago
  • ..."anyone that aides any of the above in any way shape or form"...

Is Obama Arming Al Qaeda to Topple Assad?

 
 
 
Aeonpax
Freshman Silent
link   Aeonpax    13 years ago

Not you.....these replies don't line up.

 
 
 
Tsula
Freshman Silent
link   Tsula    13 years ago

What you are preaching here in great strident tones is the equivalent of anarchy as even the UN has decided that this would not be legal move and will not sanction it. Just whom do you want to sacrifice for this since the latest estimate right now for securing this material is a minimum of 79,000 men with supporting personnel increasing that number to over 100,000. Where do youpropose thatthese people come from since the world at large is giving this a big yawn. NOBODY is happy with this situation but be reasonable with what you are demanding of your fellow Americans. If the Arab League which has the most to lose, followed by the European union, except France wavering on the side lines, and finally NATO refuses to consider this seriously where would you have the United States fit as ultimately we will suffer the casualties and the body bags for what?

 
 
 
Kavika
Professor Expert
link   Kavika     13 years ago

RW, attacking those that disagree with you isn't going to sustain the debate. As for macho balls, perhaps those with macho balls have ''been there, done that''. Actually seen combat, have returned wounded or have lost sons and daughters in our endless wars. Their perspective would be much different.

I say wait, aremissiles going to stop him? That is an assumption that many are making. IMO, a very bad assumption.There are huge downsides to jumping into this mess.

Yes, children are dying, and that is a horrible thing to see. But our children are the ones that will have to do battle. They will die or be WIA,it will affect the rest of their lives, and those around them.

This is not a decision to be made lightly, the consequences could be devastating. More devastating than what we are seeing now.

I remain against involvement at this time. If that makes me less than macho, so be it. I've ''been there, done that'' as have a number of my family. So we have nothing to prove.

 
 
 
Tsula
Freshman Silent
link   Tsula    13 years ago

Thank you Kavika. A voice of reason. Panic feeds upon panic. Been there and have seen that too!

Just want to add that I and my family have also paid our dues for this exclusive club, too! Each generation it seems becomes members thereof, sadly.

 
 
 
Tsula
Freshman Silent
link   Tsula    13 years ago

Well done, son. Sure wish that we could have had some of the close air support back in 43! Semper Fi and Go Army!

 
 
 
Kavika
Professor Expert
link   Kavika     13 years ago

Yes, it is sad Tsula. It's a club that I would rather not belong to, nor my family. But it is what it is. We can only hope that somewhere, our ''leaders'' will learn.

 
 
 
Mark in Wyoming
Professor Silent
link   Mark in Wyoming     13 years ago

AP , I do believe I clarified that even a citizen of this nation could be classified and considered a domestic enemy of the state , now my recognition of the POTUS as my enemy , hold about how much water? right , not much and what I do within the law to show non support , such as mitigate any tax liability as to not fund his plans or objectives of course being legal is entirely up to me , if I decide to fund or spend money with watchdog groups to ring the bell so to speak , that again is up to me , if I donate to other politicians working for his ouster and defeat , that is up to me , and all perfectly legal, there is no law that says one has to be loyal to any elected official once they are seated in office, something many on the other side do not understand nor care for , the man made his own bed , he gets the support he is due for his own choices and actions , he was elected by only 53% of the electorate , that other 47% either choose to disagree with him or choose not to follow him ,.

thesimple definition of a leader is one that others are willing to follow and trust, I am neither willing to follow nor do I trust the man currently in the executive seat of power , and it has nothing to do with his race , his own actions words and choices brought me to my choices , and frankly there is no law that says I have to support the potus in anything , there certainly isn't any law that says I have to respect him , respect is often given as a curtesy , whether one keeps itgains more or looses it totally is entirely dependant on the individuals actions , and I am my own judge using my own criteria on what those standards arefor myself alone .

yes I consider the presidents actions in arming AQ affiliated cells as the acts of a domestic enemy , and I WILL continue , to work for his failure in all he touches , removal and the demise of his type of politician , all within the laws of the land .

 
 
 
Tsula
Freshman Silent
link   Tsula    13 years ago

Nvwadohiyadv Peace is always good. Agreeing to disagree when done as neatly as we have just done shows just that, too! Families always seem to do this with class! Smile.gif

 
 
 
Chucky Stuart
Freshman Silent
link   Chucky Stuart    13 years ago

Secretary of State John Kerry said during a hearing Wednesday in the House of Representatives that counties in the Arab world have offered to foot the entire bill for a U.S. military mission that destroys the Bashar al-Assad regime in Syria.

Great, so now we get to be mercenaries.

 
 
 
Tsula
Freshman Silent
link   Tsula    13 years ago

Points taken and accepted. I did not mean to put words into your mouth and if you take offense then I sincerely apologize for that was not my intent! Friends? Grin.gif

 
 
 
Tsula
Freshman Silent
link   Tsula    13 years ago

Yep The Arab League wants this to be done but they don't want to get their hands dirty or spill fellow Muslim blood so who better to do their dirty work than the Infidels!

 
 
 
Mark in Wyoming
Professor Silent
link   Mark in Wyoming     13 years ago

Jason I was thinking the same thing , but I promised someone I wouldn't engage the antagonists at least that seems to be the prudent course of action, but I would reiterate that even chemical weapons experts have nixed the idea , of targeting the weapons caches and dispersal systems due to the extremely high risk that the resulting destruction would even further dispurse those agent , and of course not knowing the nature of the weapons , they could be blister agents such as mustard gas , choking agents or nerve agents , now imagine a combination of all 3 released as a result of such a proposed strike . the very thing the strike is to stop , actuallyhappens , release uncontrolled over a population. a little looking around shows that periodically, in Europe , they still have deaths caused by 80/90 yr old cw munitions in farm fields . a strike like proposed would make a deliberate use look small.

simply blowing this stuff up will not remove its lethality or toxicity, the approved method is of course incineration , but the types of incendiary weapons we have don't even come close to the temperature needed to make the chemicals inert and ineffective . but im thinking some haven't thought that far ahead .

 
 
 
Tsula
Freshman Silent
link   Tsula    13 years ago

My Dad was gassed in France during WWI and the residual effects on him and his health lasted until his early death so I have some small knowledge of the effects of chemical warfare. I lost a brother from the long term effects of agent orange poured down on him for years is viet Nam. This is no way for people to have to die even by accident which will happen for sure. In the interest of caution I advised standing down and still do.

 
 
 
Mark in Wyoming
Professor Silent
link   Mark in Wyoming     13 years ago

Rescue , I have responded to what randy says he thinks the targets should be , nothing more , and provided that those with expertise , do not think good of targeting such things .

 
 
 
Mark in Wyoming
Professor Silent
link   Mark in Wyoming     13 years ago

I think the G-20 did one better, as my comment on that other seed indicates.

I particularly liked the part unless there is UN backing/autherization , even france wont go in .

 
 
 
Mark in Wyoming
Professor Silent
link   Mark in Wyoming     13 years ago

rescue , these missiles being talked about are loaded with conventional explosives , when they hit their target or are in proximity , that's what they do to destroy the target , they blow up.

Now unless you can guarantee a high enough temp to make inert the chem weapons , simple explosions wont do whats desired , they may very well have the opposite effect and contaminate an even wider area. thats why the experts on CW are saying NOT to go after the stockpiles , or the dispersal units( they would have the component chemicalsin them)because there is no guarantee that dispersal wont happen . these people aren't playing with windex and hairspray with a bic lighter.

as has been pointed out by others , this is NOT going to be a simple little "surgical" strike , and this is definitely not Assads first rodeo either so the likelihood he just gives in isn't really realistic . unless of course that's the real plan to start another MIC war for profits under the guise of humanitarianism. naw no self respecting human would do that ....

 
 
 
pokermike
Freshman Silent
link   pokermike    13 years ago

Are we the new Hessians - paid mercenaries to intervene in a revolutionary war? Didn't turn out too well for them back then, as I seem to remember.

 
 
 
Mark in Wyoming
Professor Silent
link   Mark in Wyoming     13 years ago

Jason , no worries , just put in your papers , count the short timers calender and let be what will be , you sir have done your due and duty , nothing more is to be expected .honor , pride and integrity , never loose any of them.

 
 
 
Mark in Wyoming
Professor Silent
link   Mark in Wyoming     13 years ago

ravenWing , mighty fine speechifying you jut did , . im not gonna chastise you for your earlier rant towards Jason nor telling him to stick a feather somewhere , I will agree you have the right to speak your mind and will stand by and defentd that right for you to have your opinion and to let it be known ,.

what I would like to point out that you most likely missed , in your pleading and demanding for action on behalf of the Syrian children , is that Jason , is a currently serving active duty marine , one of the very people that , if your wishes are filled will be one of the ones called upon to achieve the objective you desire .

he has at times explained his stance and reasons for not desiring this conflict , as is the manner of some marines , but he has also courteously explained how he gets his information and as the true professional that marines are strive to be extremely competent at what they do .

here is what should be considered , did your lambasting and diatribe against Jason endear him towards your cause ? or could It have possably made it that more difficult to sway those like him in his position ,to your side ?

jasons 10 yrs experience is built on my 10 yrs service and his fathers service , mine on kavika and tsulas all the way back each succeeding generation learns from the last in the military. your insulting backhanded thank you for his service , was noted , right after you flaunted your relatives service laurels , not your service , but theirs , they earned them and the respect that go with them , not you. remember that when among veterans , that have big macho balls because they have actually had to walk the walk and had to put thise balls in harms waythus earning the right to talk the talk , not some IBM selectric II wrangler or Remington typewriter ranger sitting in an air conditioned office with a coffee maker , but those in the field without the creature comforts many here wouldn't know how to survive without .

when I came back fron DS, I was met by 3 uncles , one a Korean vet , one a viet vet , and the last a vet of the carter yrs , all 3 made a pledge to me , and I made one to them , they pledged that they would not let my generations service be forgotten like korea , vilified like Vietnam , nor demeaned as under carter , I pledged to them that I would not stand idilly by and let that happen to any other combat vet that followed me . I now make good on that pledge , if your thanks for service is not heart felt and sincere , then take them back , they are worthless , if you cannot see the experience in such a young person and the responsibility taken on then pay no heed to his information or opinion . but also do not expect him that wears the uniform and most likely will be the last to step on your rights and most likely be the first to defend them to have to endure such fake graditude. its people like you that make me ashamed of how our combat vets get treated , it would be better if you said nothing at all in the way of thanks , you cheapen the sincere ones when you do .

Jason if your willing , I pass the pledge on to you for future keeping for future vets.

 
 
 
Mark in Wyoming
Professor Silent
link   Mark in Wyoming     13 years ago

this seed seems to have the most comments and contentious disagreements about the Syrian issue so far to date , I was reading randys seed about israel backing limited us strikes , and many of the comments pertained to hitting the CWs and stockpiles directly , what I posted there I will post here and it bears to be thought out carefully no matter which side of the discussion your on.

I know I have pointed this out in various threads but it bears repeating for those still considering targeting the CWs directly , currently the US has nothing in its conventional weapons arsenal , that would reach the needed temperatures to make the chemical agents inert and non toxic , so a direct attack targeting those weapons would most likely only result in an uncontrolled release of the very agent wished to be contained resulting in even greater collateral damage casualties .

now here is a very serious question , one that all wishing to target these weapons of mass destruction directly .

are you willing to go nuclear?

because currently those ARE the only weapons this nation possesses that WILL reach the needed temp to incinerate those chemical munitions and take them out of the picture .

you better think about that long and hard.

this isn't isolationist thinking , this is the cold hard fact of it . which is the worst option , a president hoisted by the petard of his words , this country loosing face , or the nuclear obliteration of an area ?

those being your choices , what are YOU willing to do ?

 
 
 
Aeonpax
Freshman Silent
link   Aeonpax    13 years ago
 
 
 
Tsula
Freshman Silent
link   Tsula    13 years ago

What consideration is given here to collateral damages and massive deaths? There will be no threading of the needle here because of the proximity civilian enclaves. Think Hiroshima and Nagasaki here without the radiation. Do we really want to go in this direction simply because the President, our President, drew a red line an refuses to say I made a mistake! Some say that if he does that it will make the US look to be weak. Who cares because many who would have diedbecause of this macho image will in fact be alive.

 
 
 
pokermike
Freshman Silent
link   pokermike    13 years ago

Who cares because many who would have diedbecause of this macho image will in fact be alive.

I don't think his macho image will take too much of a hit:

5987_discussions.jpg

 
 
 
Tsula
Freshman Silent
link   Tsula    13 years ago

With respect, I really don't thing that he is so much interested in a macho image as he is in his legacy as the first Black American president. I personally don't give a crap about either his macho image or his legacy if it means another stupid war where the arms dealers get rich and our kids get dead. Be well.

 
 
 
Mark in Wyoming
Professor Silent
link   Mark in Wyoming     13 years ago

Eg , the problem with all those as you pointed out , being the same as using the nuclear option is the swath of devastation left the one I would be least in favor of would be the f/ae, as you said it to acts as a chemical weapon , so the dispersal of the mixture is dependant on the the factors associated with the air , and if it does ignite , the explosive forces , can literally crush the life out of anyone caught in one , its debatable how they would die , either from the crushing blow from the force of the explosion , or from the rapid loss of breathable air , or the searing heat of ignition. some of the others present their own problems with collateral effects moabs being the most obvious .

The real point being made though , is one has to ask themselves exactly how far are they willing to go. when it comes to CW there will be no second chance , so I don't believe that half measures should even be considered , and if the objective is not to totally irradicate the posability of their use by either side , then there better be a plan b that will work each and every time , no "spanking" strikes , your either all in , or all out and looking for a different path to gain your objective .

 
 
 
Mark in Wyoming
Professor Silent
link   Mark in Wyoming     13 years ago

ok lets talk worst case scenarios here .

worst case for the Syrian people , we strike half heartedly , and it changes nothing , we strike and retaliatory strikes spread the fighting elsewhere increasing the butchers bill.

worst case for the world , their apathy and hypocricy is shown , taking all meaning out of the rule of international law .

now for the US , and this sitting potus, here is where we complicate things for ourselves I will start with the worst case for the Potus ,.

as it stands there is no real international coalition willing to back and commit to the proposed planned strikes at least not the ones that would be needed to ensure the success of the operation, without UN sanction , and it is unlikely the UN will make a decision anytime soon( though they could be the wildcard and surprise everyone ).

the president also faces not only a divided congress , but a divided people on this issue and it even divides the individual parties , so there is going to be a very hard sell before congress comes to a vote . the presidents worst case , is he gets no international backing ,the congress votes no , and he is left to choose to invoke the presidential war powers act and hope he can get it done and finished in a 2 month time period without drawing this nation into an even bigger war, the reason I say 2 months is that's the initial 60 days allowed , it would be highly unlikely that congress would authorize the extended 30 days after being circumvented in such a manner , reason for that is the people against this action that vote for them would raise holy hell come election time if they decide to run again. or the president can simply accept it , and try to find another way to approach the situation.

for the congress , this can go 2 ways they can vote for the proposed limited strikes , and they are ineffective , they can vote for the strikes and it leads down the path of open war with Syria and their allies or they can vote no and things get worse , or vote noand be seen as throwing the POTUS under the bus

about the only good thing for congress voting no , and appearing to throw the POTUS under , is that it would show the international community that this government is not run by the politicians , that they are answerable to the people whom elect them and place them in office , and if the executive makes a mistake even if his intentions are good and right , it is still the people that rule the government here and not the other way around . as far as the divided country, that's why I would expect the vote on action to be very very close , however it goes .

worst case for the people? there are over 300 million people in this country according to the last census , so there are just as many worst case scenarios to be brought up. and each one being equally valid in the minds that hold them.

 
 
 
Tsula
Freshman Silent
link   Tsula    13 years ago

We are going to have to agree to disagree here since no strikes against him will be either efficient or final since he will still control to stockpiles. If you feel that slapping him on the wrist even hard enough to break his arm will stop him then you are not seeing the big picture that you ask me to see. Nothing of value will be accomplished without securing those stockpiles and that will mean boots on the ground. It is inevitable. What I have seen so far would call for a minimum of 79,000 combat personnel along with another 21,000 support. Where the heck do you suppose that we are going to get another 100,000 people to fight this war for the world as they show no inclination to fight this for themselves and it is in truth their fight now ours. Once these poisons have been secured the problem then becomes where and how do we dispose of them and who beside the American taxpayer would be expected to foot the bill once more. What you are saying here does indeed have great merit but unless it is UN sanctioned and worldwide participation in men and materiel is committed then it become another American red herring. I paid my dues 2 generations ago and when we came home then we said never again and while I don't have a grandchild to sacrifice for this adventure many of my old time combat buddies do so I will reiterate--stand down. Be well!

 
 
 
Mark in Wyoming
Professor Silent
link   Mark in Wyoming     13 years ago

lol I remember that quote from the matthew Broderick movie from the 80s from the computer , seems the only way to win is not to play...thermo nuclear war game then it asks if he would like to play a nice game of chess.

 
 
 
sixpick
Professor Quiet
link   sixpick    13 years ago

There's just no damn evidence either way. That's all there is to it. And it is not our responsibility to be Al Queda's Air Force. This whole thing could have been fabricated. Tell me, has anyone seen the UN's assessment? I have seen it. I haven't seen their scientific proof and even if I did when someone votes to let the children die, it's hard to believe this is the reason for this strike. Talk about phoney scandals.

 
 
 
Krishna
Professor Guide
link   Krishna    13 years ago

I guess to you it is all abut politics and not human lives AMERICAN lives....

If we do launch airstrikes-- I wonder if we will have as many combat-related American deaths as we did during the War in Kosovo???

 
 
 
Aeonpax
Freshman Silent
link   Aeonpax    13 years ago

Sixpick,

I would agree with you here, this is a phoney issue. There are so many propaganda releases, half-truths, spins and misconceptions floating around about this "gassing issue" that it has become near impossible to tell facts from fictions and lies from truth.

On top of that (you can tell in this very forum) this issue has reduced itself to acrimonious demagoguery between the informal coalition of extremist pro-war Democrats and Republicans and those who desire peace.

Political ideology has tainted, if not virally infected, any sane and/or productive discussion on this issue.

 
 
 
Aeonpax
Freshman Silent
link   Aeonpax    13 years ago

Good analogy Mike. The problem here is that the educated American (or poster here) need to read through various different sources about the same thing to arrive at some kind of logical consensus and even then, you have to be objective and schooled in critical thinking as nothing anymore is as it seems.

While often misused, the quote "In wartime, truth is so precious that she should always be attended by a bodyguard of lies" can be misleading as what this supposed "truth" is may not be factual.

This is were a well formed conscience, minus all the tainted opinions, has to make the final decision. I start with "Thou shall not kill" as a moral absolute, and work my way down.

 
 
 
Kavika
Professor Expert
link   Kavika     13 years ago

If I remember correctly 18 Americans died. Then there was the place crash that killed 32 American Civilians. Between 479 and 527 civilians were killed byerrant bombs.

No war is withoutdeath Krishna.

BTW, Good morning.

 
 

Who is online






118 visitors