On Labor Day 2013, Welfare Pays More Than Minimum-Wage Work In 35 States
Forbes and the Cato Institute take a look at the benefits of the social safety net and discuss how they can be a disincentive for people to seek employment.
Since 2009, the Fair Labor Standards Act has dictated that the federal minimum wage is $7.25 an hour. Some people think thats too low; others think its too high. But it turns out that, in 35 states, its a better deal not to workand instead, to take advantage of federal welfare programsthan to take a minimum-wage job. Thats the takeaway from a new study published by Michael Tanner and Charles Hughes of the Cato Institute.
The current welfare system provides such a high level of benefits that it acts as a disincentive for work, Tanner and Hughes write in their new paper. Welfare currently pays more than a minimum-wage job in 35 states, even after accounting for the Earned Income Tax Credit, which offers extra subsidies to low-income workers who take work. In 13 states [welfare] pays more than $15 per hour.
The welfare system, at its best, is a system that gives people a way to live when they cant find work for themselves, when theyre down on their luck. At its worst, the welfare system rewards people for not working, and incentivizes people to develop habits that make it harder for them to find work in the future, miring them in permanent poverty.
In Catos new 2013 study, welfare paid more than $10 an hour in 33 states; 17 paid less than $8 an hour. Comparing the two data sets and accounting for inflation, 18 states saw a decline in the total value of welfare benefits; 32 states and the District of Columbia saw increases.
Tanner and Hughes award the national welfare championship to Hawaii, which offers $60,590 in annual welfare benefits, once you account for the fact that welfare benefits are tax-free to the recipient, compared to work-related wages. Thats the equivalent of $29.13 an hour. Rounding out the top five were D.C. ($50,820 per year and $24.43 an hour), Massachusetts ($50,540 and $24.30), Connecticut ($44,370 and $21.33), and New York ($43,700 and $21.01).
States with the lowest welfare benefits were Idaho ($11,150 and $5.36), Mississippi ($11,830 and $5.69), Tennessee ($12.120 and $5.83), Arkansas ($12,230 and $5.88), and Texas ($12,550 and $6.03).
Tanner and Hughes count 126 distinct federal means-tested anti-poverty programs in force today. For the purposes of their study, they looked specifically at:
(1) Temporary Assistance for Needy Families (TANF), the post-1996 cash welfare program; (2) the Supplemental Nutrition Assistance Program (SNAP), formerly known as food stamps; (3) Medicaid;
(4) housing assistance;
(5) utilities assistance;
(6) the Women, Infants, and Children program (WIC), and
(7) the Emergency Food Assistance Program (TEFAP).
Not all of these benefits apply to every welfare beneficiary, and some are time-limited, like TANF. But it remains true that an alarming number of welfare beneficiaries do not have an economic incentive to find entry-level work.
A better way to address this problem would be to treat welfare benefits like taxable income. Even low-income workers with no income tax liability have to pay Social Security and Medicare taxes. But welfare benefits are entirely tax-free.
http://www.forbes.com/sites/theapothecary/2013/09/02/on-labor-day-2013-welfare-pays-more-than-minimum-wage-work-in-35-states/
Tags
Who is online
106 visitors

Anew study from the CATO institute concerning welfare (actually multiple social safety net benefits), the minimum wage and the effect of both on peoples' incentive to find employment.
speaking of the astounding ability of vallery jarrett to control the "news"...not one peep about the steavadors pulling out of the afl/cio because of obamacare.
not a peep.
pretty scary.
JoAnne
Perhaps what you say is true, but it is not relevant to this thread.
Please refrain from your scoop and poop tactics unless the comment is at least tangentially relevant to the article presented.
John
Try to focus on the topic
sorry RIO i should have pointed out that obama care, is welfare.
JoAnne
Actually it is not but thanks for explaining what you were talking about
Seven fifty an hour is not a living wage but if ya'll like paying for workers food stamps and Medicaid you are hitting the nail on the head. Why should stores and businesses pay a living wage and why can't children be part of the work force. After all that has been considered in at least one state. Lets go back to serfdom. There are enough filthy rich people to buy up all the housing and use it as a tool to attract workers like in the days of old in the coal mines and steel mills.
As the owner of I believe it was Nestles said people do not have a right to clean safe drinking water. Corporations have been buying up water/mineral rights for decades.
Texas removed the saftey inspections on manufacturing companies and a town was blown up. We are producing a coutry made usafe by to little Government. Self regulatingBusiness ignore safety they have insurace and workers are a dime a dozen. Texas is advertising in Missouri for factories to get moved to Texas for the right to work state has dirt cheap labor.Very few regulations and safety regulations are almost non existant.
Corporations pay minimum wages to workers andhandicapped wages way below the minimum wage relying on food stamps and medicaid to pick up the shortage to be able to live a simple existance. Our tax dollars are supporting Corporations directlyand indirectly by also giving huge tax breaks which enabled corporations to pay little or no taxes and still gives tax deferments for companies to move jobs over seas go figure.
r m e r
Thanks for sharing and getting that off your chest
What do you think the minimum wage should be? $10, $12.50, $15, $20 ???????
I wrote an article a while back about minimum wage vs living wage which drew no interest.
You have reiterated some of the problems do you have thoughts on possible solutions
John
No the message of the article is that the total monetary value of social safety net benefits is more than minimum wage in many states.
The implication, since you missed it, is that the minimum wage needs to be raised.
And the need to raise the minimum wage (in my view to around $12.00 and link it to CPI) immediately is a huge deal.
I read a study a while back (it was put together in 2010). At that time, it found that a single person needed to earn around $12/hour (working full time) in order to NEVER need any public assistance. Without that minimum, the single person (living modestly) was not able to save enough for emergencies or retirement. When bad things happened (or they retired) they would need to depend on some type of social assistance to get by.
leonaharware
Thanks for sharing that perspective
I have seen similar reports and commentary and it seems that the costs may have risen a but in the last couple of years
John
You are reading the text but not understand it - the influence and "incentives" (not a great choice of words in my view) are the cause of a developing "welfare class", but if the minimum wage was raised that influence and those incentives would be removed.
If the minimum wage was raised and it was economically more lucrative for people to work than to rely on the social safety net that is exactly what people would do.
Actually it is Robert. If you don't make 400% of the Federal Poverty Level which is approximately $11,700 per individual, you receive a subsidy to offset your premium which is up to 2/3 of the premium depending what percentage your income is of the FPL. Also as much as 50% or more will not pay anything at all. So JoAnne's comment is somewhat relevant to welfare:
It discourages someone from having the incentive to work to make over a certain amount of income in order to receive anywhere from zero to full premiums paid by the government (which of course is comprised of tax paying citizens).
So when she says it is welfare, I say when the tax payers are paying up to 100% of a person's premium for them, it may not be called welfare by name, but it fits the definition. I prefer to call it the "Heroin Syndrome". Once you've tried it, you don't want to stop using it.
As I've posted other times, your article is true, there is a anti incentive to improve oneself under this system. Reminds me of getting a paddling in school for making an "A" on a test and getting an ice cream bar for failing the test.
I give you the example of the girl who was asked why she didn't try to move on up the ladder on her job after 6 years saying, "I can't do that because I would lose my benefits" meaning government benefits.
I posted information a few weeks ago it would take at least $21.00 per hour to make it worthwhile in order to make it more beneficial to get off so-called welfare. If all you had to do was increase the minimum wage to $22.00 per hour and everything else would not be affected in the market, then by all means I'd go for it, but everything is relative.
I believe this info was for a single female with one child.
John, I consider anything the government pays the public from taxes paid by others is a subset of so-called welfare. Right now there are 46.6 million people receiving food stamps. This alone far exceeds your 4% figure. They are receiving food stamps because their income isn't high enough according to the government system to allow them to have enough money to live and eat at the same time.
John
Don't get all intellectual on me now.
No one said that we did - now read the article slowly again and think about it, the point is that if we raise the minimum wage to a more reasonable level that many people working at entry level jobs will no longer be dependent on the social safety net and will be more motivated and able to better their economic lot in the work force.
Ironic that you should speak of someone talking out of their ass.
jwc2blue
Exactly the point
If the minimum wage is raised to a more reasonable level, those folks working hard at entry level jobs will be less or even not dependent on social welfare benefits in order to get by
Who the CATO institute is funded by is less important than what the numbers tell us and the numbers seem to be correct
John, there was no reason to make the comment that Robert was "talking out of his ass". It degrades the discussion. Please try to refrain from it.
John
I actually keep pressing the basic theme and point of the article which is by no means a "non issue".
Thanks for your perspective
Barb-btco
Thanks for sharing your perspective
Do you agree with the premise that if the minimum wage was higher, fewer working Americans would be dependent on social safety net benefits?
A simple yes or no to a simple question
Thanks in advance for your feedback
John
Good point about using the report information to advocate for higher minimum wage
Barb-btco
Appreciate the feedback and perspective
Bar - btco
Look past the source and consider the issue- raising the minimum wage will make fewer working Americans dependent on the social safety net
Sixpick
A tax credit, well you receive a tax credit for the personal exemption and dependent deductions and that certainly is not welfare it is a tax credit just as the assistance for the PPACA is a tax credit
Barb-btco
I get the same feeling about a lot of people quoted and sources of information on the internet and in the media - some of which are sometimes used here on NT.
I tend to try to focus on the issue rather than belaboring a like or dislike for a political source
Thanks again for sharing feedback and perspective
To which Barb said :
So I am asking Barb : Are you opposed to the above concept statement ? If so what is ill conceived about it ?
Interesting info . Thanks . However I would like to point out the date on that NYT story :
It was Jan/2007 ; In other words right before the bubble burst . Sure employers can afford to pay more when business is good . But in 2 years conditions changed radically . In 2009 there was less business [more than likely]and also far more out of work youth [and adults] .
The conditions under which economics predictions are most telling is when the economy is doing poorly . I don't want "fair weather" legislation that turns into a disaster when the economy slumps . In such times businesses WILL lay off workers if they make too much . And if they can't pay a lower wage then they are forced to shutdown . Is that the "benefit" you want to legislate ?
The argument made in RiO's seed is that the taxpayer is supplementing the wages of many minimum wage workers . Do you share that objection ?
I can't argue with that . The issue becomes one of finding the "right" level . And I expect that is a tricky thing to do to find a single number for the entire country . It might even be hard to find a single number for an entire state ...
All of that may be accurate but it completely missed the point I made . I don't expect you have any interest in receiving such info however .
Again you have missed the point . I don't see any value in continuing to talk with someone so bull-doggedly focused that she is unable to even let another argument penetrate her skull ? Do you ?
Wow
A lively exchange on raising the minimum wage - exactly what I was hoping for.
Thanks to all for their input and feedback to me and others so far.
After reading a number of comments directly above this, I have a couple of response points --
Yes, the stock market is doing very well partly because business is improving and partly because companies are retaining cash equity as they delay expansion and hiring until "they" are more sure of what the future holds for them.
A raise of the minimum wage to say $12.50 would have an initial sting at the entry level as some small businesses and franchises attempted to hold the line by trimming hours or workers to offset the raise in wage, but after the increase a general increase in buying by consumers would expand many businesses and require additional headcount in the work force.
A big question that the two sides of this issue are wrestling with is what is a "reasonable / unreasonable" amount to increase the minimum wage.
"Business" is great on Wall Street but that has not been a clean one for one pass through to Main Street where many small businesses, local businesses and regional businesses are still struggling and unemployment is still too high.
It is hypocritical to debase companies to taking advantage of the law - the tax code, as bas as it is the law of the land and it is perfectly reasonable for a business to take advantage of tax deductions and credits to minimize their tax liability. It is nave to think otherwise.
jwc2blue
Again I disagree, citizens are not getting screwed by the fact that companies are complying with the law.
Don't get me wrong - I am for tax code reform. I would advocate that all deductions, credits and subsidies be removed from both the corporate and personal income tax codes and that citizens and companies pay a simple tax rate based on their income.
If he minimum wage needs to be raised, it should be raised but conflating the minimum wage issue and tax code reform is not the answer to either problem.
behold the fruit of decades of democratic legislation.
I'm glad you published this thread Robert . It has helped me put things into perspective . Personally I would rather subsidize the low income workers with taxes than see an irreversible minimum wage put into effect . That would only lead to unneccessary business closings when the economy goes south .
I said no such thing . Don't you know how to read English ? You have already demonstrated a lack of interest in presenting a real argument [many times in many different threads ] .
I have no problem with that . But when you pretend I have not presented an argument you are saying something non-factual . Just because you are incapable of mounting a counter argument does not give you the right to denigrate others . What I am wondering is that just due to stubborness or to an inability to reason . I suspect the latter . Feel free to disprove that at any time by making an actual argument ...
Petey
I disagree, at a very minimum the minimum wage should be adjusted for inflation from the 60's level wich would place it near $11.00 per hour
I think $12.50 immediately and then tie it to CPI
JoAnne
Another swoop and poop
The past 4 decades have seen a fairly equal distribution of democratic and republican legislation
Would you are to elaborate?
Barb-btco
I fail to see any relevance
jwc2blue
We are not getting screwed "by the companies" that comply with the tax law.
That is the point
People are quick to blame corporations and companies for taking advantage of what the tax code allows, if you are getting screwed it is by "we the people" who do not insist on tax code reform not by the companies that obey the law.
The companies are paying above the legal minimum wage, if that wage level requires government assistance then the minimum wage level should be raised. Until it is, the companies are doing nothing wrong with the wages they pay or how they pay their taxes.
jwc2blue and Petey
Play nice
Disagree without being disagreeable
jwc2blue
As I have said many, many times if theminimum wage needs to be raised then we should raise it
i would tend to agree with you, but blame the "party of compassion" more in their endeavour to create a permenant lower class, where the lie of fairness reduces self acheivement, and the folly of the nanny state destroys individual responsibility.
JoAnne
What specifically do you base the culpability of the party of compassion - by the way I am n independent and I consider my self compassionate as I consider friends who are both democrats an republicans.
So who exactly are you labeling?
You are long on rhetoric and short on specific
Try again
OvO
If you wish to share your opinion, please feel free to do so as I am sure everyone would be appreciative of the opportunity to learn from a wise owl.
And if you wish to continue with the juvenile drivel, you are welcome to do that as well
All are welcome here
This from Jonathan Walters, aka, Einstein Insanity (or whatever moniker he used last, lol)
leonahrdware
Jonathan and I have discussed those very points many times and he is certainly correct that what we need is the emergence of a new production/manufacturing base in the U.S. creating products for existing and emerging technologies which will fuel the creation of upper middle class jobs with good salaries.
Those jobs will require better educated, more technically savvy workers and will reestablish the American Dream for all citizens.
That being said raising the minimum wage is still a national imperative in my view
Thanks a lot for your perspective and for quoting Jonathan which is always welcome input on my articles
Robert ,
I am not totally against reevaluating the minimum wage level BUT the fact is such legislation is pretty much irreversible . If the federal government can guarantee that the US will NEVER experience deflation again this would not be a problem . But deflation with a high minimum wage is a sure recipe for business closings .
Petey
I said that the minimum wage should be indexed to the CPI which means that once adjusted to catch up with ground lost since the 60's increases would be dictated by the economy not legislation
So , in the event of deflation the wage level would decrease ?
Petey
Likely not but there would be no automatic annual increases either.
Prices and wages seldom are lowered once they are set, they only rise or say the same
That's 2 problems from my POV . Minimum wages don't exist in a vacuum . Therefore when they are raised the employees who make more than minimum are going to want to get raises too . If they don't they will tend to find other workplaces .
The other problem is what happens when an actual deflation occurs ...
In the event of an actual deflation prices do decrease ... The federal government has done everything it can to prevent deflation BUT the market has other ideas . The housing market for example , is badly in need of a "reset" in pricing but things are rigged to prevent that from happening . There are many homeowners suffering now because their asset is unsellable .
Petey
Prices seldom decrease much if at all for most items even in a deflationary period
Wages do not go up and down in a company based on annual profits and they are not likely to go down in your scenario either.
I do not see us agreeing on this issue as I find it irrational to think it is acceptable that the minimum wage adjusted for inflation is so far below where it should be compared to where it was in the 60's.
That other wages will increase if the minimum wage is raised is a welcome side effect of the action and will also help to strengthen the middle class and the economy by infusing more money into the economy from consumers.
Raising wages by government control in that manner is likely to bring about even more offshoring of jobs if possible . However , I am not arguing that the current minimum wage is too high . Frankly I am not sufficiently informed on this topic to make that distinction .
This discussion has given me much food for thought . I am now asking myself questions I have not explored before . There is going to be some homework needed on my part . Thanks for making me think about this .
Petey
The raising of the minimum wage needs to be done as part o a process that includes tax code reform and other changes that make job creation in the U.S. more appealing and profitable to U.S companies than moving jobs off shore
I totally appreciate all of the back and forth. too have learned some things and have some things I want to do a little research on. I have a feeling that this discussion will continue in the future.
Enjoy the rest of the weekend