A Serious Flaw in White Plaintiffs' Account of Gang Rape Could Compromise Investigation
Well of course it could
in the event such a flaw were to arise and it wouldn't necessarily have to be white women it could be Siamese-Twin heterosexual, bi-racial dwarfs the permutations are endless.
And not just in gang rape investigations -- but in virtually any crime scene investigation.
I mean who doesn't get that?
____________________________________________________
Get my drift?
My headline is on topic and perfectly leads into the substance of my article.
But it's misleading in that I intentionally exploited what I know to be certain presuppositions.
We all on board with that?
Tags
Who is online
106 visitors

Stay on topic or I'll call for a moderator or close the article to comments.
AMac, but I don't see anything misleading. "White" is just a detail, an adjective, essentially. I would think discussion is on-topic as long as it has 'anything' to do with the title and proceeding article detail as they both would seem to discuss the same thing = the "flaw" that was involved in a gang-rape investigation. I don't understand why "white" is an issue or that it matters that the mention was made..Is that part of your point?
Egilman... Interesting.
I don't see the problem. Seriously, I think it's because I'm not looking for it. Who does look for it ? Usually someone looking for any way to interpret racism into everything that's said and done. The facts generally speak for themselves. And facts can be swayed, altered and lied...but whatever is heard by the court, we have to accept as fact, I guess. We can't base every situation and event on the Zimmerman case, not that you are, but I'm sure there are going to be those that will be 'looking for it.'
Sure, so could a tainted DNA sample from a rape kit.
Your point?
Nothing happened; I made up a headline to show how misleading headlines can be, especially when they are designed to mislead and incite readers. The "article" below the headline has everything to do with the headline itself and yet there's a credibility issue -- BY MY DESIGN -- IN ORDER TO MAKE A POINT.
The point: If a headline and its corresponding article are somehow misleading and misleading by the design of the author/seeder, it needs to be challenged.
Headlines and their body copy must be ethically tied together lest they be sensationalism, deceptive, dishonest, disingenuous or inciting. My headline and body copy are tied together -- but in a way to set up the reader -- it's an example of "tainted journalism".
Was I talking about you, Badfish?
But since you seem to think this has something to do with you and some topic (possibly related to one of your articles) -- what is the topic?
There is no link; the article is what you see below my headline; it refers to itself, to my intentionally misleading headline. It's an editorial in disguise; the headline suckers its reader by creating an expectation something other than what the headline makes it seem to be. The headline looks like its leading to a news story but it's really circular in that it's about misleading headlines themselves.
My point, which you missed, is that my headline, while consistent with its attendant article, was designed to mislead -- to present an example of disingenuously setting up a reader.
It has nothing to do with rape kits or DNA; it has to do with disingenuously editorializing via a headline while pretending to be objective. It's about deceptive "journalism".
That's my point.
The only possible way you could know that is to be able to READ MINDS. So long as the poster has a "reasonable" explanation, you have no case. As this is NOT a court of law, the benefit of the doubt goes to the poster.
MY ULTIMATE POINT!
We are losing good members, ironically or, predictably, the way Newsvine lost members, namely
An incendiary article is posted, often with a mean-spirited underbelly -- not a problem in-and-of-itself, but -- when the authors of many of these articles are either challenged as to content -- rebutted -- they often go into personal attacks or call for a moderator.
THEY MAKE THINGS REAL FUCKING UNPLEASANT -- AND REASONABLE PEOPLE DON'T GRAVITATE TO OR REMAIN LONG IN UNPLEASANT PLACES!
If one cannot defend an article with facts and counter points to rebuttals, by launching personal attacks and insults, to use a metaphor "you crap where you eat."
Want to kill NT?
The method has just been detailed.
Using the press or social, or any media to perpetuate demagoguery is unethical. When an author/seeder doesn't understand and respect that, individuals and groups of individuals suffer the slings and arrows.
My topic is "the illustration of a headline that intentionally deceives its readers" and the problems it can create.
I've explained it more than once.
And accusing you of being off-topic is part of the illustration; you have every right to bitch that I accused you of being off-topic because I was copping out -- evading your (fair) question.
By those who might proceed in the same manner as the poster perhaps, nevertheless, if the poster is unwilling to state succinctly his topic, he can not with valid reason, accuse anyone of being "off-topic."
Does that mean that reading the headline and article itself might still require some explanation?
You have made my point very well.
Thank you Ms. Pax -- couldn't have done it without you.
Ever been to a library -- read a book -- listen to a lecture -- consulted with a physician?
Expressing disdain for backing ones position with ACTUAL CORROBORATING INFORMATION, is the refuge of the willingly ignorant.
lol... Probably so.
Well, yes, I understand the main point you are making, and thank you. My point was more relative to BF's article and Mac's faux article here. I only felt racism in these two cases was prevalent 'if' someone wanted to read it into the articles. I really meant my point when I stated 'White' and 'Black' are descriptions and nothing more, part of the who, when, how, of a story. We all know that either race rapes, and we know that a plaintiff can be White or Black; so logically, neither story was 'all about race.' BF's story was about rape, and Mac's story is about a flaw. ...It's only 'racist' in the eye of the reader that chooses to see it that way. ...I don't.
I look for an article premise or point to the report, generally, and the races involved aren't so much for profiling to me, as they are for looking for patterns.
It's the same thing I did with the Zimmerman case. It was never all about race to me; it was about crime prevention. The characters in the story could have been purple and green, and I would have viewed it the same.
I understand propaganda, but that is generally more 'statement of fact' oriented that could be a blatant lie, rather than trying to sensationalize or skew a given perception.
Personally, I don't think racism is something we can 'force' on someone else. In the media, it's in the readers' mind, and in person, it's in the watchers' ego.
Opinions are fine -- stating an opinion as if it's a fact and doing so intentionally is not ok.
Egilman, I love you and respect you and you are a friend; but permit me to disagree with your, uhhh, opinion.
VALID
valid |valid|
adjective
actually supporting the intended point or claim; acceptable as cogent
OPINION: The earth is flat
SECOND OPINION: I don't think the earth is flat but I'm not sure exactly what it is
THIRD OPINION: The earth is an oblate spheroid
Which opinion(s) is VALID
Which opinion, if any, is simultaneously both AN OPINION AND THE TRUTH/A FACT?
While one's opinion may seem valid to its owner, in reality, that phenomenon can be anything from "off base" to psychotic depending on one's ability and willingness to accept VALID CONTRADICTION SUPPORTED BY VALID INFORMATION -- BY FACTS THAT SHOW THE OPINION TO BE OTHER THAN VALID.
Mike,
We often disagree but I like you and respect you.
I see no contradiction in that concept.
For the record, I like Badfish as well.
In fact, I also like hmmmmmmm
Have to get back to you on that one.
Mike,
Everyone who was drawn into my article by its headline (which is the very purpose of a headline after all), was not a "guinea pig," rather the potential victim of a set-up. THAT'S THE WHOLE POINT -- TO ILLUSTRATE THE POTENTIAL HARMS, GREAT AND SMALL, OF MISLEADING PEOPLE THROUGH DECEPTION!
Again, you reacted as any reasonable person might react -- your most recent comment again verifies my point -- yes, I played a mind game! And yes, you were appropriately pissed off -- TO YOUR CREDIT!
We all should express our disdain to being deceived and manipulated by wolves-in-sheeps-clothing particularly when we expect honesty and get fucked over instead!
That's just your
You know!
I wasn't shouting at you, Egilman
I was shouting at those who are willingly blind that because I can't make the text any more luminous.
An OPINION by definition is "a view or judgment formed about something, not necessarily based on fact or knowledge"
Some opinions can't be fairly refuted -- "I think steak is way better than fried chicken," for instance.
A dishonest statement or intentional misrepresentation cannot be justified because "it's my opinion" -- we get a lot of that and it can be insidious; i.e. "You don't know shit."
A nebulous insult is not an opinion, as opposed to, "You seem quite ignorant on the subject of X, Y or Z," or better yet, "On the topic of X, let me correct you etc."
I can take an insult and I can sure as hell top it, with usually a comeback that beats up the insulter with his own stick (metaphorically speaking). But some members are put off by constant insults and, in some cases leave. Bad for NT.
I have no problem with opinions as long as those who state them understand when they are purely or partially that and as long as when someone posts information to show that an opinion is inaccurate, they don't simply reject the information off-handedly and become insulting.
That's why I rant regularly about debating via point-counterpoint exchanges.
OPINION STATED>OPINION REFUTED WITH EXAMPLES AND COUNTER INFORMATION>>EXAMPLE AND COUNTER INFORMATION REBUTTED WITH OTHER COUNTER INFORMATION, etc. .
What I see a lot of is
OPINION STATED>OPINION REFUTED>"Oh yeah, well fuck you, etc. ."
That's what has eroded NV -- I don't want it to erode NT.
Do you think there is any truth to this John? I know there were other reports similar to this in the past, but I did not save them.
Tickle, you think it's all digital imaging and publishing their paper in the - Bentham Chemical Physics Journal --- is a hoax???
Were the perpetrators of the rape captured and positively identified? Do we know who they are, their names, shoe sizes, race?
Was that information in the seeded article? Is there DNA evidence? What was the jury verdict at the trial?
Did your headline in any way indicate that the article it led to reported on AN OPEN CASE or did your headline imply/state definitively that the perpetrators were X, Y or Z as if the case was solved and closed?
Then clearly state it is an opinion and don't change a headline to make it appear as PROVEN FACT.
That others are of the same opinion does not justify you or anyone else misrepresenting it so as to appear as proven fact.
No, you don't have to go through anything. I only posted the info because John was suggesting disbelief over the use of explosives.
I very much believe their research. I see now that it was the scientist Mr. Legge that I read shortly after 9/11.
I don't know what you are referring to about Wiki. I looked up their publishing company and it said the group has been posting research data since 1992. Looks legit to me. I believe their findings. There are way too many unanswered questions and things that don't make sense.
I believe the televised video footage that I saw that morning on 9/11 of planes hitting the WTC. I was on the freeway, here, at the time, but when I got to my destination, the coverage was on the screen.
So then you are in favor of the MSM distortions ... Not surprising .
He didn't say that, you implied that he feels that way. We talked about your ascribing things to other members before. You can ask how he feels or state that it's HOW YOU THINK HE FEELS, but stop putting words in other members' mouths and then expecting them to defend or deny what they didn't say.
Regardless, changing someone else's writing/headline without noting you're doing so and having it appear as though the author put it with his/her article, is dishonest.
Even though BF changed someone else's headline, what if I changed it back without BF's permission -- you know, to make it honest.
See the problem?
How 'bout that BF -- let me "improve" your headline. OK?
REALITY CHECK:
Several years ago, a corporation pirated one of my photographs from my agent's web site and "improved it" by putting its corporate logo over it after "editing out" the agency logo and using the "improved version" as their very own signature image.
Who the fuck's going to catch that, right?
The legal department of the agency regularly monitors visitors to its web site and the type of activity in which visitors engage. When it's determined that an image has been copied to a "light box," or a "comp image" has been downloaded, or if the image has simply been dragged and dropped to a remote computer or storage device, the law department then checks with the licensing department to see if the image was subsequently leased as per contract.
If not, the legal, etc. department then begins to check websites, publications, etc. of the downloader and if it discovers an unauthorized use, it first checks with the photographer to see if he/she licensed it through some other agent or, as an individual; if not, a cease and desist, etc. letter goes out with a bill -- if that is ignored -- a law suit, etc. is filed.
Had my image been licensed legitimately, the corporation probably would have paid under $200.00.
It wound up paying MUCH, MUCH MORE the settlement being split as per agreement, 50-50 between the agent and myself.
The message; FUCK WITH OTHER PEOPLE'S INTELLECTUAL PROPERTY AT YOUR OWN RISK!
Here's the e-mail I received from my agent
It is not a lie if the title is an improvement . The MSM are fond of creating media circuses . By using the same omissions they employ you are cooperating with their lies .
It's a lie. Misrepresenting what someone wrote in the name of "improvement" is dishonest unless authorized by the originator.
But remember your comment when I change one of your comments in order to "improve it" but not tell anyone that's what happened.
You good with that? Because like BF, I have the power to do that without anyone's permission, and, as long as I have that power, that's all I really need.
The NIST could have been putting pressure on her to 'not' authorize their findings, EI, why they might have decided to publish it anyway; in fact, that makes the most sense. Most employees don't go over their bosses head without darn good reason.
The Federal agency could have intentionally spread negative propaganda to place doubt.
Mr. Legge is in the group you quoted.
I am not a scientist, so I have no reason to 'not' believe their findings, and long ago, I did download their PDF info. What impacts me the most, was that, at the time, there were other engineers and scientists from around the world (Japan, Sweden or Denmark possibly) that concluded similarly to the above statements. I simply find no reason to 'not' believe it.
As I recall, the 9/11 Commission wasn't in full agreement on everything. That was uncomfortable to me.
____
At this point, I'm not sure what we're each disputing other than I believe explosives 'were' used to take down the buildings demolition-style. I think we both believe it was a planned event. Some of the planners were long-time residents here, apparently.
I even believe that a group of Arabs were out to dinner when I was about two weeks before the event that I will always wonder if they were passing through on their way to NY (suspicious not just because they were Arab--but they were so rude to those around them - but maybe it was because they didn't speak English. It was the attitude and body language that I am judging, as well as their possible vehicle. Yes, they could have been on vacation, but they didn't seem like it, imo, at least I tend to think there is a 'tourist' attitude, and they didn't have it). I don't have any answers. I just go with what makes sense to me.
Then WT7 ? I had trouble with the short video, but maybe you won't.
I can't remember all of it, EI. Getting a headache.
Exactly ,
The MSM is always careful to kowtow to the black racists by excluding the use of the word black in headlines .
But BF is entitled to not do things that way , especially since his headline accurately reflected the contents of the story .
Of course not . The original headline represented a lie of omission . Repeating it word for word would only be complicit in repeating the original lie , a lie designed to satisfy the black racists ... and those fearful libs who refuse to face up to the ugly reality of life in the US .
Whether that's the case or not -- IT'S THE AUTHOR'S PREROGATIVE AND NOT ANY ONE ELSE'S WITHOUT THE AUTHOR'S PERMISSION!
OH , that explains it ! LMAO ...
Feel free to limit your headlines to word-for-word replications "Einstein" . The rest of us will make adjustments if we think they are needed .
As John Russell pointed out above , these 2 threads have become a mess . The obsessive focus on a minor but informationally accurate change to a headline has been nothing but an attempt to deflect the point of BF's article .
This disingenuous tactic is a 2 edged sword . I suggest that you disgracefully biased libs pull in your horns if you don't want the same thing to happen to your articles .
CHOOSE MY OWN FUCKING TITLES/HEADLINES.
Thas nice ...
Thank God there are people here who do understand that!
I've always admired literate individuals.
No . BF published a news story . It had no copyright restrictions posted with it .
Okay then BF? Coober says I can change your headline.
By the way, it's neither BF's story nor his headline -- it's the headline of the article that he seeded which IN FACT IS THE COPYRIGHT/INTELLECTUAL PROPERTY of the publication that ran it originally.
BF would be violating copyright law were he to claim the copyright as his own or, to in any way indicate that he had any authorized say as to the use of the article by others.
See the term "derivative works," Petey (and everyone else), check it out. One cannot legally take someone else's work and modify it then (mis)represent it as his own --
After 70 years, a copyright becomes public domain -- so BF has 69 years and 364 days and he can do as he likes with the headline, article, photo
News stories by their very nature are NOT proven facts . To ignore that simple reality is nothing more than a distraction . The reality is that a mob of propagandizing libs descended on BF's seed and derailed it . It was a disgraceful immoral performance and it will bring about a war of future retaliatory distractions to lib articles . You have only brought this upon yourselves to the detriment of the site .
I absofreakinlutely cannot believe all of you are still going over this!!
Speaking only for myself, Chloe -- I was in the gifted-slow track all through school.
Just teasing you all...pointing to everyone.
I believe the gifted part!
I had to give my teachers gifts in order to be promoted.
Now you tell me.
I said I was slow.
All too funny!!
Thank you, Egilman. Seriously, i always enjoy reading your comments - always interesting and informative, and delivered without all the attitude.
JFT, I wasn't suggesting ignoring blatant acts. I was just saying that I'm not looking for it. So, if a report that ten black kids raped two white girls, then that doesn't mean that I'm going to assume more rapes occur with that race in that age group - it might - but I'm not going to assume it. I would have to research it. Or any event that harms, if a group of White or Asian or Mexican teens were caught robbing the local store, I'm not going to assume they are the most prevalent thieves in the area.
And-- even worse than television-- the Internet. There are many really nutty crackpot extremist hate sites that push all sorts of bizarre hoaxes-- and there are millions of gullible people who believe them! ("Global Research", Press TV, "RT" (Russia Today), Aryan-Nations, Rense, etc. Even some of the reporting on al-Jazeera...
).
What always amazes me is how many people are gullible enough to believe things-- if they read it on the Internet they think it must be true. (I imagine that many of these hyper-gullible types are the sort of people who also fell for some popular email scams-- like the Nigerian Scam .)
Right on PChltb - I noticed that there is a member on NewsTalkers who actually used Rense as a source. My God!!
You have no proof, which would make that your opinion. Good members is subjective and the rest is pure hyperbolic nonsense.
Now this is interesting. Underneath the superfluous rhetoric is something that distinctively sounds like a personal grudge between you and the OP, which negates and moral high ground you perceive you have on this so-called issue.
Pointing out once that the inclusion of the word black is problematic (on different levels) and discussin why is one thing but hijacking an entire thread to voice your personal diatribe against a poster and/or to expound your personal PC beliefs is in and of itself, deceptive.
a) AllCaps is cruise control for cool. b) You havent proved a problem exists.
Pardon me for bringing this up but it was John and you that hijacked this thread and reframed it from a tragic incident where two women were raped to a harangue about the inclusion of the word black. The OP has spent his time defending himself but in the minds of the PC self righteous, he has already been convicted.
You are doing a good job of it in this thread.
Krishna, are you saying we can't believe anything coming from those sources, or only occasionally? As you noted not long ago, I was citing from Press TV, and actually I did the day before that, too, re a White House report showing protesters. As long as we are reading the same/similar info from other sources, shouldn't that be an indication that the main premise is correct when it's coming from those sources you cite?
In the future, maybe you won't mind dropping me a message if you think I posted a hoax or false information?
I can't speak for Krishna, but I think he is referring to media that are known to be exceptionally biased. Press TV is an Iranian source and one might think that they could be somewhat prejudiced against the USA, so one takes what they have to say with a grain of salt.
Yes, I would think so too. But then, so can our MSM, depending on the report. For example, the slant on a US MSM about the Russians sending a team here to discuss with Congress had the elements to it that K. is pointing out about those above.
To me, it's not just the source that needs to be considered, but also the Journalist. For example, the NYT has both Right and Left-leaning biased Journalists; I think I've noticed the same with the Washington Post. But...not all sources seem to do that.
My interests with the news are 'generally' less 'reporting' of the events [we can learn those from all of the majors], but more the analysis reports [which will be considered biased because reasoning is being used] that try to give us the 'whys' that the majors don't give us and shouldn't - reporting should be just the what and how of the event.
So, I am aware of the 'slant' being used in the type of report I am generally looking for. Thanks Buzz.
Aeon..... your logic is overwhelming me.
Dang..... I wrote that two pages ago.
Now now now......... Maybe we should take this to the Supreme court. This is referring to Tickle's Red/Blue comment. You know the Supreme Court has a way of redefining things these days instead of interpreting them. Yea......Take it to the United States Supreme Court. They may find Red can be blue. Who knows!
Me?
LOL!
True. They are a delegation of Russian Lawmakers it said.
Who am I to believe, the eyes in my head or the news?
John brought up this topic along with A Mac. I'm sorry that fact does not agree with you....however, you have my sympathies.
EI, Actually I didn't know we did the same thing with domestic issues. Interesting.
I thought ambassadors primarily were used for PR and policy promotion, but I didn't know we sent out a team, such as described by Putin, to other countries with hopes to persuade their decisions.
Well after another fun day at work yesterday, a fun night last night in chat and not having even read the article referenced yet, I am unqualified to make any educated comments about the article, but I can make some educated comments on a few things.
Some of my friends who have not gotten banned from NV are telling me members are leaving there in droves and as I recalled most conservative members who left during the time I was there were banned and were not liberals.
So I can tell you with the influx of new members in the last two months on NT, I think we have inherited some of the liberals and they aren't use to having the nanny site to ban anyone who disagrees with them, so they rightfully feel they must "Fundamentally Transform" this site to be like the site they left because they didn't like it.
You know, kind of like the Muslims who leave the countries they don't like and try to "Fundamentally Transform" the new location they have decided to live to make it more like the location they left.
I can tell you from experience having lived my entire life in NC when the blue started bleeding down here onto the red because the blue didn't like it where they lived before, we became purple and have now have come to look like a "Purple People Eater". And that's not good. Have you ever seen a "Purple People Eater"? Excuse my punctuation. Never sure about that. Any help would be appreciated.
I've noticed lately we are starting to look like a "Pink Pussycat". Now there's nothing worst than a "Pink Pussycat". Have you ever seen one? It's a terrible sight to see up close.
Although you are technically correct about strict copyright interpretation , I very much doubt that CBS would even mention this minor alteration to a headline . Even though they would be within their legal rights to challenge it they won't because it would call attention to their error by omission of the pertinent facts ... in effect hiding the facts from the headline scanning public .
And then I wonder what will happen when the "Purple People Eaters" mix with the "Pink Pussycats." ...Google told me you get something that looks like Miley Cyrus.
If CBS hid a pertinent fact it may have been for a very good reason and nobody has the right to put words in CBS's mouth any more than you have the right to put words in my mouth.