The Failed Grand Strategy in the Middle East
The Failed Grand Strategy in the Middle East
ByWALTER RUSSELL MEAD, The Wall Street Journal, August 24, 2013
An opponent of Egypt's President Morsi holds up a picture of Barack Obama and the American flag during a rally outside the presidential palace in Cairo on July 7.
In the beginning, the Hebrew Bible tells us, the universe was all "tohu wabohu," chaos and tumult. This month the Middle East seems to be reverting to that primeval state: Iraq continues to unravel, the Syrian War grinds on with violence spreading to Lebanon and allegations of chemical attacks this week, and Egypt stands on the brink of civil war with the generals crushing the Muslim Brotherhood and street mobs torching churches. Turkey's prime minister, once widely hailed as President Obama's best friend in the region, blames Egypt's violence on the Jews; pretty much everyone else blames it on the U.S.
The Obama administration had a grand strategy in the Middle East. It was well intentioned, carefully crafted and consistently pursued.
The plan was simple but elegant: The U.S. would work with moderate Islamist groups like Turkey's AK Party and Egypt's Muslim Brotherhood to make the Middle East more democratic. This would kill three birds with one stone. First, by aligning itself with these parties, the Obama administration would narrow the gap between the 'moderate middle' of the Muslim world and the U.S. Second, by showing Muslims that peaceful, moderate parties could achieve beneficial results, it would isolate the terrorists and radicals, further marginalizing them in the Islamic world. Finally, these groups with American support could bring democracy to more Middle Eastern countries, leading to improved economic and social conditions, gradually eradicating the ills and grievances that drove some people to fanatical and terroristic groups.
Unfortunately, [the plan] failed. ......
With the advantages of hindsight, it appears that the White House made five big miscalculations about the Middle East. It misread the political maturity and capability of the Islamist groups it supported; it misread the political situation in Egypt; it misread the impact of its strategy on relations with America's two most important regional allies (Israel and Saudi Arabia); it failed to grasp the new dynamics of terrorist movements in the region; and it underestimated the costs of inaction in Syria.
Click this link to read the whole article:
http://online.wsj.com/article/SB10001424127887324619504579028923699568400.html?mod=djemWMPAsia_h
Tags
Who is online
87 visitors

How to lose friends and underwhelm people.
And what if the US policy was of the 'Divide and Conquer' variety? Seems to be working, since, they are at odds with their own leaders and people.
Buzz-- you beat me to it!
I was going to seed this article a few days ago but didn't get around to it.
However, being the non-conformist type that I am, I did something rather strange-- I actually read the entire article! And I was pleasantly surprised-- it turned out to be one of the best analyses of U.S. strategy in the area that I've read in a long time. If anyone want to know what's really been going on (beyond the usual superficial sound-bites (from both sides of the aisle)-- I highly recommend reading it.
While its considered very fashionable in some circles to blame all the problems in the Middle East on the U.S. (or on " da Jooos "-- take yer pick)-- the fact is that the Arabs are quite capable of doing these sorts of things all by themselves! And-- its been going on for a really long time.
And all that would take is a few small arms shipments, encouragement and the right spark of motivation, like an Arab spring or peaceful demonstrations for the shooting to begin. The US has been playing behind the scenes shenanigans all over the world for years. Helping the mujahedin against the Russians in Afghanistan is just one example. Ollie North helped the Contras against their government.
From the time I joined Newsvine - about 5 years ago, you were my mentor, Krishna. That's why.
'Divide and Conquer' - It has been working very well here in the U.S. too.
This is a well crafted opinion article. But even on the first read, I saw some glaring inconsistencies and jumps in faith and logic. However, first and foremost, this is an opinion piece and as such, does not require proof or evidence, which none is presented in the article.
Secondly, unlike the authors at The American Thinker (an oxymoron if there ever was one) Walter Russell Mead, the author of this article, is well educated in his field of study but falls victim to the same twists of conservative logic that is the downfall of many other educated conservatives.
The article, for example, is a narrative as he is writing to an already convinced audience as opposed to constructing a persuasive or argumentative essay to convince those who may disagree with his points.
Take this phrase Mead writes;
The plan was simple but elegant: The U.S. would work with moderate Islamist groups like Turkey 's AK Party and Egypt 's Muslim Brotherhood to make the Middle East more democratic.
The National Review Online (NRO) has this to say about it;
Anyone notice one of thekey problematic words? Itsmoderate especially when connected with Islamists. (One of the others is democratic especially when democracy leads straight to the Muslim Brotherhood.)There is nothing moderate about the Muslim Brotherhood - ...
If you dont agree that there are moderate Islamist's along the lines that Mead defines them, the rest of what he writes makes no sense and gets deeper into points that require proof or clarification, none which he provides.