╌>

A short guide to the Middle East

  

Category:  News & Politics

Via:  malamuteman  •  13 years ago  •  14 comments

A short guide to the Middle East

This morning I came across an article in the Financial Times that explains who supports who and who hates who in the Middle East.

The printed version can be found here , although I am not sure you will be able to see it unless you subscribe.

They asked that the story (text) not be copied and pasted so I am respecting that request. However, I thought this story might be conveyed as well or better in a graphical form so I produced the following graphic. I dont completely agree with every relationship as described by the article, but most, and this illustrates what a quagmire it is to get involved Notice this does not even mention the various factions fighting Assad or the Palestinians and Israelis. Still it is quite a tangled mess...

6082_discussions.png


Tags

jrDiscussion - desc
[]
 
Perrie Halpern R.A.
Professor Guide
link   Perrie Halpern R.A.    13 years ago

Really interesting graphic for the events in the ME. I think you are missing how Iran feels about the Muslim Brotherhood.

 
 
 
MalamuteMan
Professor Silent
link   seeder  MalamuteMan    13 years ago

Yeah... I only put in arrows for the stuff that was listed in the FT article... Actually, I did add one, I felt it had to say that General Sisi was against the Muslim Brotherhood... That was just too obvious to be left out. I also thing the USA to Sisi and USA to Muslim Brotherhood links should be more ambivalent. What is the relationship between Iran and the Muslim Brotherhood??? Based on Iran supporting Hamas and Hamas supporting the Muslim Brotherhood, it seems like Iran should also support the Muslim Brotherhood... What do you think???

I think I will try to research this further to see if I can fill in more of the links...

 
 
 
Krishna
Professor Guide
link   Krishna    13 years ago

To simplify things a bit- as with most things in the Arab world, "its all about religion". There are mainly 3 major conflicts going on:

1. An Islamic religious war of Sunni v Shiites. The War in Syria. The war in Iraq. Iran (Shia) vs most of the Arab world (Sunni).

2. An Islamic religious war between extremists v moderates/secular types: Egypt. Turkey's internal dissent, amongst the Syrian opposition its al Qaeda vs the so-called "moderates".

3. An Islamic "Holy War"of Muslims against the kuffar ("non-believers"): Muslims v Jews (Israel), Muslim vs Christians (Egypt); Turkey's illegal apartheid occupation of N Cyprus (again, Muslims v Christians). al Qaeda vs the U.S. (Muslims v Christians & Jews). And just outside the Middle East, Islamic extremists from Chechnya and Dagestan vs Christians (terror attacks in Moscow).

 
 
 
pokermike
Freshman Silent
link   pokermike    13 years ago

You left out the Muslims vs Buddhists in Thailand. It has resulted in around 4,000 deaths since 2004 with no signs of letup. In addition Nigeria's Boko Haram (meaning Western education is sacrilege) is responsible for even more thousands of deaths. They mostly target Christians but are also murdering Muslims who they feel are not pious enough.

 
 
 
One Miscreant
Professor Silent
link   One Miscreant    13 years ago

The Hatfield and McCoy feud is a good example of the dynamic in the middle east too. Going on so long, that the reason it started is mythical.

 
 
 
Krishna
Professor Guide
link   Krishna    13 years ago

You left out the Muslims vs Buddhists in Thailand. It has resulted in around 4,000 deaths since 2004 with no signs of letup. In addition Nigeria's Boko Haram (meaning Western education is sacrilege) is responsible for even more thousands of deaths. They mostly target Christians but are also murdering Muslims who they feel are not pious enough.

And lets forget Muslims terrorists in the Philippines who are murdering Christians. And even in Thailand-- Islamists are murdering non-Muslim Thais. And of course the terror attacks on Hindus in India. Attacks on Christians in Southern Sudan. Subway bombings in London and Moscow, terror attack son trains in Spain., etc. These are not isolated incidents, but rather part of a larger pattern.

But it also raises the question why do they have the weapons any? Very tricky issue.

 
 
 
Chloe
Freshman Silent
link   Chloe    13 years ago

Hi Mal... hope this finds you well. Haven't seen you around in a very long time..

What a mess!! I knew Hezbollah (sp?) was supported by Iran, but from this report , is appears that Hamas may no longer be ?

That's a very nice graph you drew up for us. Thank you.

 
 
 
Krishna
Professor Guide
link   Krishna    13 years ago

What a mess!! I knew Hezbollah (sp?) was supported by Iran, but from this report , is appears that Hamas may no longer be ?

True.

As I mentioned here in this comment-- there are three types of conflicts throughout the middle East today-- all Islamic religious wars :

1. Sunni v Shiites (ex: Syria)

2. Extremists vs moderates (ex: Egypt)

3. A "Holy War"of Muslims against "non-believers" (ex: Muslim attacks vs. Christians & Jews)

The nature of the relationship between Iran and the terrorist group Hamas has changed!

First it was a case of "conflict #3", above. Iran and Hamas both hate Israel, so Iran supported Hamas.

BUT: As the Sunni vs Shia conflict in Syria heated up (conflict #1, above) & since Iran and Hamas supported opposite sides in Syria-- so there was a major falling out between the two.

 
 
 
TTGA
Professor Silent
link   TTGA    13 years ago

I knew Hezbollah (sp?) was supported by Iran, but from this report, is appears that Hamas may no longer be ?

Perhaps somewhat CL. Remember that any support (financial or military) going from party 1 to party 2 may, in whole or in part, be passed on to party 3; even though there is no record of direct support between parties 1 and 3, and party 1 may not even want party 3 to be supported. In other words, it's pretty jumbled up.

 
 
 
Chloe
Freshman Silent
link   Chloe    13 years ago

Thank you again, Krish. That's a great explanation, one that I have not forgotten, for sure.

The only reason I provided a link for Mal was because I know he likes to read sources rather than personal statements. Smile.gif

 
 
 
Krishna
Professor Guide
link   Krishna    13 years ago

even though there is no record of direct support between parties 1 and 3,

True.

However, in the case of Iranian support for Hamas, both parties were quite open about it.

And their falling out was quite open.

In other words, it's pretty jumbled up.

Again, quite true. Although there may be a natural tendency to want to simplify things, in this situation there so many factors involved, and so many actors involved, it requires a lot of study to understand what's really going on. (I think even the State Dept & Obama initially misunderstood the situation in Egypt-- and for some time).

 
 
 
TTGA
Professor Silent
link   TTGA    13 years ago

Krish, I have my doubts whether even the participants can understand what's going on in that snakepit, far less the US State Department.

 
 
 
Chloe
Freshman Silent
link   Chloe    13 years ago

TTGA,

even though there is no record of direct support between parties 1 and 3,

Additionally, that's what really bothers me about aid packages, generally. I don't see the sense in handing money to a foreign country when we have no idea of how or where it's going to be spent.

Although there may be a natural tendency to want to simplify things, in this situation there so many factors involved, and so many actors involved, it requires a lot of study to understand what's really going on.

I would think so, too. It seems the basis to most of those decisions is about money and control. That article I linked stated it was about Syria, tho, as a basis.

 
 
 
Krishna
Professor Guide
link   Krishna    13 years ago

Krish, I have my doubts whether even the participants can understand what's going on in that snakepit, far less the US State Department.

I'm not a big fan of most gov't depts, but I agree-- the State Dept is one of the worst!

U>SZZz. fireign policy has scewed up so many times.

In Egypt we screwed up twice in a row:

-Initially we supported the widely hated Mubarak. It was only after it started to become obvious that he would be overthrown that we suddenly change course...

-We strongly supported the Muslim Brotherhood, and criticized the army. Most Egyptians support the army and sees it as the only thing that prevents a dictatorship by Islamists.

 
 

Who is online







88 visitors