Tribalism, Post-Tribalism and Counter-Tribalism
Man begins with the tribe. The tribe is his earliest civilization. It is enduring because it is based on blood. The ties of blood may hinder its growth, the accretion of tradition holds it to past wisdom while barring the way to learning new things, but it provides its culture with a physical culture.
The modern world embraced post-tribalism, the transcendence of tribe, to produce more complicated, but also more fragile cultures. And then eventually post-tribalism became counter-tribalism.
Our America is tribal, post-tribal and counter-tribal. It is a strange and unstable mix of all these things.
The post-tribal could be summed up by the melting pot, a modernist idea of a cultural empire, the E pluribus unum of a society in which culture could be entirely detached from tribe, manufactured, replicated and imposed in mechanical fashion. The counter-tribal and the tribal however are best summed up by multiculturalism which combines both selectively.

Yes we are.
I see nothing in the near future to change it either, beyond the unthinkable.
A very interesting concept Larry. Do you think it also might apply to other aspects of Sociology/Anthropology?
Excellent article Larry, and it is the unthinkable.
Which race, specifically, are you referring to?
The Buddhist "race"? The Christian "race"? Or...maybe..the Female "Race"? The Gay "Race"? Perhaps the Heterosexual "Race"?
Bull-Shit.
And your intolerance for honest commentary is noted.
One thing in particular has grabbed my attention as I get older, and is touched on here...
(my bold)
I do have a real concern for conservancy; I believe that we must take better, bolder care of the planet and it's creatures. For so many years this has been a battleground that the Left has mostly joined into; counter-tribalism has pushed an awareness that many themselves do not live up to though. Take for example a wonderful book Last Child in the Woods ...about something that I firmly believe in, called Nature Deficit Disorder.
~WIKI~
There are so many that speak out about how we need to be more careful with our natural resources, both for and against, yet don't have a clue about the realities of what that actually means, in real-world, nitty-gritty pragmatic sorta way. Both those from the Left and Right are guilty of ignoring the facts so they may more forcefully articulate their own agenda. Many who are making terribly crucial decisions about our environment and our role on this planet, are not at all close to the planet. So many righteous sounding pundits espousing their particular take on how we treat the planet, yet who have no more a real working relationship with the natural world, than a mouse does with space travel.
"Tribal" can be many things, depending on how you define it.
Yes it can!
So do you agree or disagree with Mr. Greenfield's analysis of "Tribal", and why so?
It took you this long to notice Larry??
1 - The author, Daniel Greenfield, is a blogger and columnist born in Israel and living in New York City. He is a Shillman Journalism Fellow at the David Horowitz Freedom Center and a contributing editor at Family Security Matters. He posts extensively on Family Security Matters, the Jewish Press, Times of Israel, Act for America and Right Side News.
2 - The author writes an interesting but flawed analogy. For starters, any thing that is quoted by Rush Limbaugh, Glenn Beck, Daniel Pipes , Glenn Reynolds, Lou Dobbs, Dick Morris, Ed Driscoll, Andrew Bostom, etc, is already suspect...but I digress.
3- The author takes liberty with the English language, coining new terms such as "Counter-tribalism" and "post-tribalism." At this point he can assign whatever ideology he wants them to mean. Greenfield syntheses words into what is a very garrulous report. Hardly an academic material and the analogies, forced and contrived.
4 To quote from a comment on that article;
Small wonder the right feeds on this kind of pseudo-intellectual pap.
Is counter-tribalism real? This whole essay seems to revolve around the us vs. themtheme, where the us is anyone who sticks to culturally defined norms and the them being anybody who departs from what our tribal societies would have us do.
At least part of it does. At other parts it seems that the author is just typing to fill up space and use the words tribalism, post-tribalism, counter-tribalism, modernism and post-modernism as many times as possible, while combining them in a seemingly random fashion. Seems like it would take a symbolic logician to determine if there was a point to writing the essay in the first place beyond, Tribal Good Lefties' bad....
I liked the last comment on the article (by someone called DenisO):I'm sure there was a great point in there, somewhere, but I can't remember reading anything more confusing. If you followed it, you're amazing. Wow!
Sorry.
1-Ok; Mr. Greenfield is a conservative, a Jew, and dare I say, a Zionist.
2- The claim of flawed logic could be taken more seriously if based on contextual criticism, rather than a reference to those who quote from it. THAT is flawed logic. I hear Timothy McVeigh was fond of quoting parts of the constitution.
3-A common literary tool, an effective one as well. Assigning ideology is what an essay is for; I wonder sometimes if something described as garrulous and contrived, hasn't really been taken as disagreeable by the reader.
4 There are extreme and even sometimes weird comments made on every forum,,,every single one of them.
The analysis of the article seems to boil-down to a critique instead, of who the writer and audience are. Perhaps you just don't care for conservatives, Jews or Zionists; perhaps it clouds your judgement, making objective criticism impossible on some articles?
Tribalism used in anthropological and ideological discussion may be quite useful in understanding patterns, motivations and consequences. Human behavior in it's history and at it's essence, began with the Tribe,,,some believe it also ends with the Tribe.
But hey, the article is (imho) is meant to be thought through and digested in a deliberate manner. I know that many in our current culture are more used to baby food, but I for one do enjoy a good steak; the extra work is worth it not only for the taste but more especially for the nutritional value.
And Gunny, you make more sense than any of the convoluted mess I have read on this thread.
He usually does Mimi. You don't need many friends as long as the ones you have can be trusted.
@TTGA:
mihunka: Native word meaning "relative by choice."
New terms are coined every day. What matters is how they are defined and are they used consistently within the narrative.
You leave it that? No explanation as to what the flaw is? I thought you were better than that.
I have read this article twice now, and my mind keeps leaping to the same place. What does this really mean in a wider perspective, which to me means, human history. I can see certain times where the authors analysis would hold, but only with a specific time frame and event. Not sure about the context of the whole.
I will have to ponder upon this a bit more before I can make a definitive statement.
Damn Gunny, if Nixon hadn't called a halt to the war I would have been in the Marines. Reading the above, I almost feel like you and I are some kind soul twins.
Some things deserve careful rumination, to be taken apart at the sentence and word level, dissected for meaning and increased comprehension, which I actually started to do, but the article seemed to lose cohesiveness....
I can accept, for arguments sake, the premises that: a) Thebeginningsof civilization reside in the tribe, being one step further up the organizational chart than the family unit; and b) That the tribe at once helps thedevelopmentof traditions and substance of the culture but may also inhibit thedevelopmentin ways which are, for one reason or another, considered to be off limits and, culturally speaking, taboo. But, if you really want to get right down to the meat of the issue, that is what all cultures do. As I see it, the amount that a culture limits itself to examining only certain ideas is directly proportional to it's limitingeffects on the amount that it is possible to be learned. Obviously, if the culture does not look at or discuss some issue, then it cannot learn anything new about that issue, by default. But, if a culture does consider the issue, then it has the chance to learn, for better or worse, about that issue.
To reduce that whole paragraph down to one sentence, we could say that the cultural structure of a tribe provides a physical and mental framework on which to hang the trappings of society, both of which may or may not be limiting on the whole.
This is theauthor'sthesis, which he would supposedly want to reinforce throughout the article. But he doesn't really. He just starts heaping more unfounded assertions on top of the prior unfounded assertions, so we know, presumably, what he thinks makes the world tick, but nowhere does he back up these assertions with anything but more assertions. And, eventually, he gives us a glimpse into his true intention, which is trashing the left (might that be a form of the other that he says the counter-tribals' areobsessedwith? That would seem to me to be ironic) whomever that might happen to be, as no clear distinctions were made todelineatethese terms.
So, it really is food for thought, because you have to seek out and define for yourself just what he is talking about..... Here is my synopsis of his position: Left = bad. Multiculturalism = bad. Anything else that is generated by the left as a topic = bad.
IMO, Mr. Greenfield is just a shill for the right hiding under the guise of an intellectual to spread propaganda. But, hey. To each their own.
Yep. You can't choose your relatives. Some of mine are people I wouldn't have chosen.
With all due respect Larry, youre only spouting rhetoric.
That article is a mess, from analogies, logic and factual inaccuracies. Its the kind of stuff youd hear at a coffee shop where everyone is buzzed by either alcohol and/or potaside from being poorly written.
I can just imagine Data saying this to Geordi;
"Counter-tribalism perverts post-tribalism and yet it is also the natural outcome of post-tribalism. The expansion of boundaries eventually leads to the collapse of boundaries and the search for boundaries. The certainty that we live in a material universe with no need for taboos or higher powers eventually ends in the manufacture of taboos and apocalypses, a new grammar of post-rational superstitions and fears of the self. The destruction of the tribe and its certainties leads to the construction of new tribes based on that mingled sense of superiority and inferiority that characterizes the modern neurotic."
I got a headache just reading that babble.
I mean if you like it, cool, Im just saying its a confusing mishmash of convoluted thoughts.