Hanna's Story......Does Anyone See Anything Wrong With this?
I read this somewhere else. Does something seem a little off to you about this young lady's story? I just have this little nagging doubt in the back of my mind about her story during and after what happened to her mother and brother. I understand that shock may not have set in, but there are just too many little things that don't make sense to me.....
Tags
Who is online
107 visitors

The fact that they were constantly in touch with each other, went on day trips together all the time, were ont he phone with each other the day of the killings.....to me, something feels wrong here. What do you think?
Well, I am not sure why she would be writing letters to her abductor. Seems a bit odd.
This is the first time I have made any comment at all, on any thread, about this matter.
But I have felt that, for her mother and young brother to be brutally tortured and murdered by the man she was forced to spend time with, she seems to be unnaturally accepting and to be adjusting quite fast to everything.
Either a delayed emotional reaction is due to happen or something is "off."
I would have said Stockholm Syndrome, but that requires extended time with him, which she didn't have.
But then again, we don't know what happens behind closed doors.
Still seems off.
See what I mean, Perrie? Things just seem a degree or two off plumb.
Since I saw the stories of her answering questions on a social networkign sight the day or the day after she was freed, pictures of her now, just something that makes me feel like we're not getting the whole story here........and they said the crime scene folks found used condoms. I wonder if they are able to pull DNA from them as they were in the house that burned.....
I did an investigatory term paper on the Elizabeth Smart incident. There many things about the incident that just didn't add up. It took me about 6 months, hundreds of hours and frequent to and from Utah and Salt Lake City. I even had a sponsor which covered $1,000 of expenses (mainly traveling) and still ended up spending money out of my own pocket.
My investigation was inconclusive but I can say with absolute certainty there was a lot that was deliberately covered up by the LDS. All the people I interviewed were uncooperative, but out of fear of the LDS. What little I did learn I could not go public with because if I did, the LDS (to this day) would know where it came from and they are vengeful.
Yes.....There is something "odd" about this girls story, at least I "sense" there is, and I've learned to pay attention to my intuitions.
To quote the late great Louis Armstong;
"If you had to ask the question, you ain't never gonna know the answer."
I can tell you this girl had an unnatural relationship with this man and the death of her brother and mother means nothing to her since she is completely obvious to all of it due to her own involvement in it all. She lacks any feelings of any kind and is living in a dream world and doing just what she expects everyone to believe she should be doing or she is doing one hell of an excellent job of hiding her feelings from public view while being viewed publicly quite often.
There is not just something strange but something really strange and unnatural happening here in my opinion. She will need mental health treatment very shortly. She will not be able to live with it.
This is how rumors get started. While even I suspect something amiss here, without further investigation and proof, this is only hearsay.
Once again, trial by internet and innuendo.
The US has a what seems to be an unending appetite for anything salacious and titillating as far as news is concerned. Those on the internet whom would encompass a a supposedly justice tribunal, would be part of the dregs of society.
It can raise suspicions, but, then again, I'm pretty cynical.
Very true and I'm trying to walk a tightrope on this, I'm not of any opinion, I just have more questions than answers and you're right, it's all conjecture-what any of us think. To me, something feels wrong about what I am hearing.
As I said before, something just seems off-I'm not spending too much time speculating as I don't have access to what LE does and am not in a position to make a judgement of truth-I just feel like there is something wrong with the story we are being given.
O.K., that's plenty of that, please return to discussing the story instead of each other.
Thank You.
Rescue ,
You have nothing to apologize for . Also nothing to be ashamed about . Let it go .
Raven Wing..... you see..... I have this curse. When I suspect something I usually find out it is true. Just can't help it. Have too many success stories to back it up. Could be wrong on this since I don't have 100% success.
Since everything is guesswork, I'll throw something in.
It could be six of one and half a dozen of the other, as my Dad used to say. Perhaps she had an infatuation with the man and a relationship with him and the mother found out the day everything came apart. Perhaps he killed the mother and little brother because they were caught together AND then kidnapped her to come away with him.
That scenario would place her on a very precarious mental and emotional tightrope which would explain the bizarre sides of her seen by the watching public. First intense teenage love, unresolved, turned to hate and anger because of the death of her family, not being able to tell anyone of the guilt she harbors....
just throwing it out there.
I was 12 and really infatuated with a man, twice my age...married too, with two sons and a daughter. Those were dangerous times.
You use your gut to identify the danger, your head to figure a solution.
Yeah, I agree what mother in her right mind would send off a teenage girl with an older man, even and uncle for that matter for an entire week? And the day of the incident there were something like 13 or so text messages and phone calls between the two. Now I hear the family of the uncle jim want a dna to see if he is the father of the two children after a life insurance policy was discovered from the perp on behalf of the two children.
Something is Waaaay off here.
Getting a publisher willing to pay money is always harder to do than getting readers Raven.
In HIS house ? Did she sneak away from cheer camp, meet her mom and brother at his house, torture and murder them, set his house on fire and scoot back to cheer camp ? As weird as this story is she couldn't have pulled that off by herself. It's possible she was involved in setting this up though.
Maybe she was involved in setting it up Pat, or maybe she just tried to save her own life by going along with a situation she stumbled in to. For the most part, we may have questions but must, at least for now, give her the benefit of the doubt.
I'll give her the benefit of the doubt but this case gets stranger everyday.
So they were at his house. I guess it wasn't unusual as he was like an uncle to the family.
This is an interesting part of this story. James Dimaggio's father committed suicide while holding a sixteen year old girl hostage. This happened 18 years ago to the day when James was killed while he was with Hannah.
...
Now that is weird Pat. Doesn't give any real answers but raises some interesting questions.
What do I think?
I think it is too soon to tell. She is incredibly composed. Maybe she is still in "survivor" mode. I'm sure the police are investigating this thoroughly, and I can only try to give the girl the benefit of the doubt. She is still very young, and may not know what an appropriate response would be-- not sure I would, either. I'm sure she is suffering from 'survivor's guilt', not to mention confusion, anger, fear, etc. Or, at least, I would be.
It appears that the close relationship between the two was condoned by the parents, so she may not only be in shock at what happened, but puzzled as to why the rest of us would wonder about the close relationship she had with her kidnapper. I think that time will tell.
My prayers are for that poor girl and her father.
The old female response to these things,it cant happen to me because she must ofdone something wrong ,!m smarter than that so it cant happen to me,thing.
Try seeing what happens in the court.
Well, there you go Fish. if you can't believe a fantasy toy from Parker Brothers, who can you believe?
RW-knock it off, please. Back on topic. Thank you.