Egypt's Christians under attack
Category: News & Politics
Via: the-irascible-harry-krishner • 13 years ago • 40 comments The ancient indigenous Coptic communities here that predate Islam by centuries say they now see a new wave of violence against them
An Egyptian man walks in front of a pharmacy marked with anti-Coptic and anti-coup graffiti in Assiut, Upper Egypt.(Photo: Manu Brabo, AP)
"I'm very afraid, and I'm afraid for my daughter," said Mona Roshdy, 55, as she left the church with her family.
She had reason to be. On Wednesday, as the police in Cairo assaulted two protest camps of the Muslim Brotherhood's, Morsi supporters directed their anger at Christians.
Churches, houses, monasteries, orphanages, schools and businesses belonging to Copts were attacked in nine provinces "causing panic, losses and destruction for no reason and no crimes they committed except being Christians," the Maspero Youth Union, a Coptic activist group, said Thursday.
Christians make up about 8 million of Egypt's population of 80 million and have been victims of Muslim attacks for years. Some Christians were worried when Islamists took over Egypt's government in 2012 and relieved when the military ousted them from power last month.
Tags
Who is online
107 visitors

Lambs to the slaughter.
I ask myself what I can do for my Christian brothers and sisters in Egypt. Pray? Well yeah. Be as vocal as possible about the atrocities being commited against Christian in Egypt? Well, of course. How about political activism? Perhaps. I fear that none of these things will make a difference. The world seems to have decided that the existential threat faced by all non-muslims is either too scary to confront, to expensive, too likely to cause a catostrophic economic collapse brought on by instability in the oil market, global war,and so on.
Pay attention Coptic Christians, the solidarity you have with muslims is not enough either as they themselves are unwilling to do what must be done to clear allah's name of all the blood spilled in his name. The only solution to wiping out islamic extremismis a blatant refusal to put up with their shit. If muslims were in true solodarity with Christians to stop the violence being spread in the name of allah, and perpetrated against non-muslims and muslims alike, is for muslims to take up their cross. Muslims must be willing to sacrifice everything to rid themselves of this cancer that is eating away at them and the rest of the world. They must lay down their ideology, their tradition and whatever else it takes, to either completely and irrevocably disown and battlethe violence done in their names, or quite being muslims. I sincerely doubt it will happen.
There is no doubt in my mind though what this will eventually come down to. We are going to have to descimate islamism, or it will destroy everyone it can possibly reach.
I agree-- the prognosis doesn't look too good.
The only solution that will work is if Muslims themselves take the initiative-- if they themselves actually lead the fight against the extremist crazies (and the extremists are a minrity-- but they have the majority terrified. Well-- perhaps the process is actually starting in a few places...like Egypt!)
If they themselves (the Moderate Muslims) start the process, they will be joined by freedom-loving people everywhere (regardless of race, religion, or ethnicity).
I gotta wonder if this is what the people of the region were saying about Christianity during the Crusades?
Reasonably Related;
Coptic churches burn amid violence in Egypt - Violence in Egypt has taken a dark turn for sectarianism as more than 45 churches and Coptic institutions were torched or stormed across the country.
Obama's legacy.
I think you would do better to look back further into history AP for root cause. Say about the last 1,000 years.
What kept these waring fractions apart was the brutal, but needful dictatorship of Hosni Mubarak, whom Obama was instrumental at overthrowing. The same can be said for Iraq, under Saddam Hussein for which Obama's comrade, George W. Bush, was responsible for overthrowing.
In both cases, both men have blood on their hands.
AP..... I'm really getting worried about you. You are starting to sound like Rush Limbaugh.
I never figured you to be one to ignore historical points of order. A couple of very simple questions, do the people of a country deserve the right to choose their political leaders, and is dissent a human right or not?
The difference being of course that Christianity like many other religions has matured past the point of needing to deliver violence in the name of their God. And the fact that muslim nations now have nuclear weapons.
You and John have become living anachronisms. How sad
History has shown that when governments, however dictatorial they are, fall apart, anarchy ensues. The Shia, Shiite and Sunni have a blood feud that goes back centuries and the only thing keeping them apart have been dictatorial governmentsNOT democracies.
#1 Democracy is NOT a panacea, especially the Bush/Obama Democracy which is heavily infected with banking and corporate interests.
#2 A Dictatorship is NOT an evil thing except when it is in league with the banking, corporate or economic interests.
In Iraq, Libya and Egypt, there were harsh yet stable governments. The people had food, water, shelter and reliable infrastructure like gas, electric and community services. That also fell apart when the US either directly or tacitly, interfered both politically and militarily, in the affairs of those aforementioned countries.
History also shows that the road to hell, is paved with good intentions.
What an odd POV . A dictatorship is more powerful when it is in that league but its motives are identical . To say that the cruder dictatorships are not evil ... ridiculous . Saddam Hussein , for example was as brutal as they come . As far as things falling apart because of US intervention : of course things fell apart . They needed to . There is always destruction before a rebuilding can happen .
Dear Pete,
As usual, you are looking at this from your perspective only. People in the West have been brainwashed to see Democracy as Good and all other forms of government as evil. Life is never that clear cut and too often, the choices available amount to choosing the lesser of two evils.
Marshal Josip Broz Tito was also a dictator...one of the dreaded communists that the latter generations were taught to hate and fear. When he died, Yugoslavia turned into a blood bath between ethnicities that were centuries old, where weeks earlier, they lived together in peace and tranquility....a forced peace no doubt brought about by Tito, but peace nonetheless. In the same vein, so did Hussein and Mubarak.
Obama is sponsoring these waring incursions into other countries at the behest of the bankers and corporations. They have the most to gain by deposing their leaders and they found the perfect tool to do it in Barack Obama.
While yours remain consistent from day-to-day. Why is it John that you insist on attacking the messenger rather than addressing the message?
Fly..... I've had some sympathy for your feeling of cynicism, but maybe you should just reset you calendar to the current date and maybe that will do the job for you.
As Perrie would say AeonPax....... Bingo!
John.... I don't see any discrimination in her comment.
Saddam Hussein may have done a lot of bad things and he deserved to be removed. The only problem with that is he kept Iran and every other country in that region in check. Now they are in freefall. Two warmongers and I am not discriminating. Actually three but we wont mention her.
A. Pax ,
That is a valuable historical lesson about Tito . Thanks . But characterizing US incursions as more "evil" than what went on before Tito took power is unjustified . Change is almost always painful and destructive . Some changes however result in a better result . The advantage of afree market economy under democracy is that it keeps going after the ruler dies or is removed from office . As a result there is no need to repeat the bloodshed that happened previously .
If you are saying that a free market economy is not better then I cannot agree .
Is that what you are saying ?
BTW don't call me Pete . There is already a Pete on the site . I am Petey .
Even when it affects our national interest and the safety of our citizens?
There are some real figures for what is happening in the Muslim-controlled countries, as compared to the reverse in Israel, the "Apartheid" nation.
The Muslim Brotherhood burned 50 churches in 24 hours in Egypt, some of the churches existing since the 4th century. They killed Christians inside churches and when Christians buried their dead, the Muslim Brotherhood exhumed the bodies for intimidation.
All religions suck...Islam more than most.
Who cares?
We don't live in the times of the Crusades.
(Any words of wisdom for us about what the people of the region were saying about the cavemen during the pre-historic era? Interesting, of course-- but not exactly relevant to our lives in 2013...)
True.
And what people often forget-- he started two wars against his neighbours!
According to the teachings of Muhammed,yes.
But-- is that what Jesus taught?
Link?
(That sounds like something you just made up....)
True-- mass torture, his infamous "rape rooms", etc, etc.
In addition, he started 2 horrendous wars...
That is a really big topic . Fortunately I don't know much about it so I will not address it .
What a banal question.
Is the Pope Catholic?
Well I do believe the primary topic at hand would be Egypt's Christians under attack , and you are correct that the subtopic introduced was " God likes slaughter "; or,as you more clearly articulate " How brutal religions are " above.
There is a clear and blatantgeneralization of religions and their adherants, a prejudiced view when discussing belief systems. This biased opinion, in regards to Christians in Egypt (ya know, the topic?), is a much expected response to the topic......"Christians are attacked in Egypt and the reason is religion". Specifically Christianity.
As a Christian I see the the cosmos, and whatever knowledge we can glean from it as important a revelation as Scripture. We attempt to translate that knowledge into something undertandable and have developed all kindsa tool to do so; as a species we have made incredible strides. Natural observation, mathmatics, and technological advancements reveal truth. All truth is God's truth, and the scientific method helps us get to that.
19 They know the truth about God because he has made it obvious to them. 20 For ever since the world was created, people have seen the earth and sky. Through everything God made, they can clearly see his invisible qualitieshis eternal power and divine nature. So they have no excuse for not knowing God.
Romans 1:19-20
You see OvO, I am not your anticipated back-ass-ward Christian (again, another boring yet expected bias); I knew that such adisparaging and generalization of the situation in Egypt would be boiled-down to sometedious and predictable, example of disimulation.
Yes-- it was the topic you were discussing....- a blatantly transparent attempt to post an off-topic remark in order to push your agenda ('how brutal all religions are*)-- but off-topic here.
This is not about "all religions". Nor is it about the situation worldwide . Rather, its specifically about the current situation in Egypt, and and specifically how the Islamists there are attacking churches.
And, importantly-- its not an isolated incident-- its a pattern. The Muslim Brotherhood is revealing their true colours-- they are an Islamist terrorist group. Morsi is pretty sneaky-- he even had some Egyptians fooled for a while, but most of those have started to wake up as to the true nature of the MB. (Fada can tell you a lot more about that if/when she emerges).
And by all means- -if you want to post your own article about "brutal all religions are"-- by all means do so. But that is not the topic here!
I've noticed that Bob Nelson now posts a warning at the beginning of his articles about proper behaviour-- including a warning about trying to change the topic by posting off-topic remarks. An excellent idea.
It should be unnecessary, but I've noticed that in many online discussions, people are so hopped up abut promoting their own political agenda that they will prostelyize about it- - even if its totally off topic. Perhaps I was remiss in not reminding people about this-- I think I will start doing it from now on:
* If you do decide to post an opinion piece about your agenda ('how brutal all religions are*)
If he wants to post an opinion piece about "how brutal all religions are" he will have to explain how the Baha'i faith fits that mold. One needs to be very careful with generalizations.
Sorry Krishna - off topic n'est ce pas? However, a lesson worth learning.
Well, only if one wants to be seen as creditable. People can post all sorts of false b*llshit- (AKA false alegations)- but if they do it a lot, they might well discover that most other users begin doubt the veracity of what they say...
Well, that may not necessarily be considered off topic.
(Actually I personally am not so bothered by "off topic remarks" per se-- sometimes they are valuable contributions. What bothers me is when they are nothing to the conversation, and/or their purpose is merely to derail the conversation in an attempt to change the subject just to push some irrelevant personal political agenda!
)
Egypt: Islamists hit Christian churches
HAMZA HENDAWI Associated Press
CAIRO (AP) -- After torching a Franciscan school, Islamists paraded three nuns on the streets like "prisoners of war" before a Muslim woman offered them refuge. Two other women working at the school were sexually harassed and abused as they fought their way through a mob.
In the four days since security forces cleared two sit-in camps by supporters of Egypt's ousted president, Islamists have attacked dozens of Coptic churches along with homes and businesses owned by the Christian minority. The campaign of intimidation appears to be a warning to Christians outside Cairo to stand down from political activism.
Christians have long suffered from discrimination and violence in Muslim majority Egypt, where they make up 10 percent of the population of 90 million. Attacks increased after the Islamists rose to power in the wake of the 2011 Arab Spring uprising that drove Hosni Mubarak from power, emboldening extremists. But Christians have come further under fire since President Mohammed Morsi was ousted on July 3, sparking a wave of Islamist anger led by Morsi's Muslim Brotherhood.
Nearly 40 churches have been looted and torched, while 23 others have been attacked and heavily damaged since Wednesday, when chaos erupted after Egypt's military-backed interim administration moved in to clear two camps packed with protesters calling for Morsi's reinstatement, killing scores of protesters and sparking deadly clashes nationwide.
More:
Quite true. And its been going on for years...even decades.
Yep, sooner or later, the results will come back to haunt the perpetrators, with interest.
not just in egypt, the systematic elimination of christians from the middle east, and northern africa is so prevelent as to be perceived as having been the goal of this administration.
and the liberals want hillary to implement 8 more years of obama!
Now, I can see why Mr. Morsi would not have been the best idea for Egypt... and now the MB is torturing them for supporting the outing of Morsi. The Coptics would have suffered either way - with him in, or with him out.
I read they've more recently been terrorized since the outing of Mubarak (tho I know it's been going on for years, generally).
The Rise of Islamic Fascism
They already have rid themselves of Jews, now it is Christians