Understanding Egypt's Future
In order to understand where Egypt is going, it's imperative to know where it's been. Their history will answer to much of our uncertainty, and also explain the seemingly unnecessary violence. I am suggesting that the crackdown against the Muslim Brotherhood (MB) is necessary, in the eyes of the Egyptian military and liberally biased civilian population.
In 1952, Egypt became a military dictatorship. Since then, the country has been led by former army generals, with the backing of the army. As far as dictatorships go, it was not a very closed society. There was freedom of movement and some Western commerce. Being a poor country, they relied upon foreign aid and tourism for most of their revenue, with most of the aid going towards military hardware. They have not been directly involved in war since 1973, when they fought Israel in the Yom Kippur war. After this war, they shiftedfrom ahostile policywith Israel to one of peace, vianegotiations. At the same time,President Sadatloosened restrictions on the Muslim Brotherhood, which allowed themto publish a "newspaper". Although this was the limit of his "loosening", Sadat himself ordered interruption of TV programming 5 times daily for the Islamic call to prayer. Sales of alcoholic beverages was also banned in non-tourist areas.
With the advent of the Mubarak "administration", there was a great push for economic reform, giving the country a little more of a Western flavor. In the area of government, however, reform did not come. A parliamentary system was put in place, but opposition in the new parliament amounted to less than 10%.
Here's where the rubber hits the road. The economic gains dwarfed the government reform, causing a decrease in Mubarak's influence. When the global economy turned down in 2008, the slide away from autocratic rule steepened. The outlawedMB was always a very organized grassroots movement, and gained influence as an opponent of the ruling military government. The new liberal movements were just as popular, but far less organized than the MB, which was formed in Egypt more than 80 years earlier.
And the payoff:
In response to the groundswell of support for democratic elections, the MB candidate (Morsi) was elected. Why did this dream turn to a nightmare in less than one year? There are many reasons, but all you need to know are two.
1)After his election, Morsi attempted to nullify the power of the courts, making him the sole purveyor of law. Democratic? No.
2)He promised a fully inclusive government, but selected MB officials to occupy every key government position. Democratic? No.
The people lived in a military autocracy for more than 60 years, but it was not a closed society. They understood, and still understand what a democratic government means. They also understand the danger of the MB. Combine all the events of the last 3 years, and you have a population that would rather go back to military rule than Islamist rule.
The people have actually spoken, and the authorities listened to them. When the noise dies down, there will probably be another attempt at parliamentary rule. Do not be surprised if the MB is not included, and probably outlawed. The MB showed their true colors, and those colors do not include a move to true democracy.

Egypt may eventually be the only true beneficiary of the so-called Arab Spring. It is the pre-existing free flow of information to and from the outside world which gives them this advantage. They took immediate note of the fact that they went from the frying pan to the fire with the MB gaining power. They knew they had the frying pan at their disposal still, and opted for that. Now they have to trust that the military will orchestrate the next foray into democracy. If it turns out that there will be no such move, they will be no worse off than they were before Mubarak fell from power.
They have seen what hell looks like, and do not want any part of it.
well, whats great about the ME future is the rodeo clown has another cracker jack secretary of state!
"with all due respect, at this point, what difference does it make"
Not soon. Not the way they want it.
Any kind of change in that country has to be done in a gradual manner.
Take Turkey for example. Turkey was a democracy, controlled by the military. Not a dictatorship, like Egypt, but the strong hand of the military kept stability in the country. Erdogan did what Morsi wanted to do. Erdogan, however, had a 5 year plan. He gradually wrested power from the military and installed Islamist rule that will probably endure. Morsi jumped the gun, trying to turn the tables in less than 12 months. Had he used Erdogan's playbook, he'd probably have succeeded, only a few years from now.
Egypt is officially "once bitten". They have a chance to be the next pre-Erdogan Turkey. That would be far better than the Morsi Administration, and still better than Mubarak's rule.
Mubarak had to go, but did not go on Egypt's terms. He went on the West's push, led by Obama. That was a misguided move that is costing Egypt hundreds of lives.
Sometimes you have to let nature take it's course, especially when it's really none of your business.
Quoth whom...?
A very good analysis. I happen to know Egyptians who feel that they were sold a fake bill of goods with Morsi. They wanted a true democracy. I don't know if that will happen now, since the military is in control and the counter movement is to devoted to going back to a theocracy.
Egypt is split politically along urban vs rural lines just like the US . The difference is that populations are nearly equal in Egypt . To me this spells a lot more violence in the future .
populations are nearly equal in Egypt
I wonder how that compares to the landscape in Turkey.
Any ideas?
Madam Secretary
The military has been in control for the last 60 years. There is no change there. What has changed is the view that democracy can work in Egypt, if non-democratic influences can be held in check. That was successful in Turkey for nearly 100 years. What we need to know is exactly how powerful the counter movement is, and, can the military hold them back?
Hhhmmmmm,
Yeah, misguided moves seem to have proliferated in the region...
between syria and egypt, obamas arab spring may just cost more Christian lives than caesar's policies did
I don't know but that is a very interesting question ...
Since the 1990's the birth rate in the more modern, Euro-leaning western provinces has declined to about 1.5 which is far below the 2.1 needed to sustain the population. The birth rate in the eastern rural provinces is nearly double. The demographics favor the conservative and traditional sectors of the population. This somewhat explains the shift in Turkey away from secularism to a more Islamist political bent. It does not bode well for Turkey's future.
So, assuming population trends are very similar in Egypt and Turkey, we have 2 potential outcomes for Egypt:
1)The military re-establishes itself as the eminent power, holding down the Islamist elements until they are overrun by a large majority Islamist population, or
2)The military returns the country to parliamentary rule, outlawing the MB, who will eventually overrun the government through sympathetic elected officials.
Differential birth rates may well be a problem in Egypt too . Thanks for the demographic perspective .
I suppose. Keep producing hungry, poor, angry children, until the country collapses from the weight.
Here's their problem. The worm is turning on OPEC. The US is now an net exporter of energy, and we're approaching 10% in vehicles running on something other than gasoline. Their currency of choice is becoming less and less valuable. As they fade into oblivion, these countries will mean less and less to the world, and less and less to us.
Soon, we'll be sending them humanitarian aid instead of weapons.
That is a perfect set of circumstances.
When Ethiopia completes its hydro-electric dam and diverts the Blue Nile from Egypt it may accelerate things somewhat ... OK , a lot .
The Muslim Brotherhood and Morsi never had more than a slim majority in the parliamentary vote.
True. The biggest fallacy of an election in the Arab world is that an election somehow defines the country as a democracy. An election occurs over a single day; the type of government that rules is illustrated during the other 364.
He used power of the presidency to enact the "pro-MB " measures that were so controversial.
They were controversial in the respect that they were anti-democratic moves. Taking power away from a branch of government and bestowing it upon yourself is anti-democratic. When you're mandated to create a cabinet that reflects the elected parliament, but end up only appointing your friends from your own party, that's anti-democratic.
There is no way a faction that large can be kept out of a governing coalition. At least not without further public unrest.
This is truly the sad fact about Egypt. The country could very well be roiled in some level of violence for the next generation, or even longer. The military is not going to allow them to participate in the next government because of their anti-democratic actions. It's hard to blame them, but it underscores the rock/hard place that the country is now situated in.
A) Mostly Episcopalians?
B) Mostly Jeffersonian Liberals?
C) Muslims?
D) Nazis?
Hey, am I allowed to use that word?
John,
This is a very interesting point, that demands more ofa panoramicview of the Arab/Islamic world.
We stand by and watch while the Arab world does things a bit differently than the rest of us. Some of it is unorthodox, some of it frustrating and some of it downright atrocious. But we do not pay lipservice to any of it, because of our alleged need to be tolerant of cultures not our own.
So, here we have a situation where a country is nearly subjugated by the MB within a single year of coming to power in an allegedly democratic governmental process. I think that the MB will be kept out of the process. That's a prediction on my part. I have no inside info, but I think my opinion is reasonably well informed. I base my opinion on the fact that this is an Arab/Islamic country that has very recently experienced a rather adverse situation, which BTW continues. I do not believe that there will be any foreign intervention if the military chooses to exclude the MB. I believe that they will do it by forceful means, which many countries will frown upon, but not take any decisive action. I believe that there will ultimately be greater calm in Egypt, punctuated by military action against a number of MB quarters inside the country, which will be viewed as anti-democratic by the detractors of the military regime, and they will be correct.
I believe Egypt knows that there is no good right now, only a lesser evil, and they are in the process ofworking towards that.
Watch out for the purple text.
hey rodeo clown, quite pandering and approve drilling on fed lands pending, and that _________ pipeline already!!!
I think that the army is going to have to keep control for the time being, but I don't think that precludes the idea of a democracy. The counter movement of sectarians are going to have to take a more active approach before this can happen. Also keeping the Brotherhood at bay. Lots of pieces that have to be in place before this can happen.
I think it all depends on how much of a stronghold the Brotherhood has.
Today's chat with a professor of middle eastern studies :
The reason that the MB does not promote Democracy is found in the first word of their name. Islam is NOT compatible with Liberal democracy, at least not in it's present state, and most assuredly not in the Middle East. The lion and the lamb may lay next to each other in Heaven, but on Earth it will only happen if the lion is beat into complete submission; and not to the will of allah, but to the will of the rest of the peace loving world.
The counter movement of sectarians are going to have to take a more active approach before this can happen.
They were very active during the last campaign. They were not very organized, and lacked the tactical skills to reach the voting population. They need to learn how to campaign on a national level, so that they can get votes from everywhere in the country, not just the liberal enclaves of Cairo.
We are planning on renaming the secret moderator group "Warehouse 13" . The significance of that will be lost on you till you see the use for purple goo on that series .
As the intramural conflict continues, we can see that the both the military and the MB supporters have the same quantity of resolve in their mission to secure a position of authority in the country. What this means is that we are going to be watching this battle for a long time, witnessing significant casualties on both sides. The Arab world is taking sides, emboldening both sides to fight on. My impression is that the army is very well armed, and will quell the MB rebellion in less time than the Syrian conflict (still going). Hopefully, there will be fewer casualties than in Syria.
That's the true conflict in the Middle East. It's the Sunni Saudis vs. the Shi'ite MB.
Among the myriad fallacious statements made in reference to the Middle East, my personal favorite is "If only Israel would make peace with the Palestinians, there would be peace in the Middle East". The fact is that nothing compares in size and scope to the Sunni/Shi'ite divide. Israel has served the Islamic world as a uniting force of hatred so strong that it masks the actual conflict. If, G-d forbid, the Muslims prevailed over the Jewish State, it would unlock the gate to Middle Eastern hell.
Israel is that shiny coin on the ground that distractsthe ADHD Arab world from the ultimate conflict.
Israel stands as the Gate to Vienna. If they and the West are not there, the life-blood of the world (oil) would be in serious peril. Muslims would use this to extort the rest of the globe, as well as each other.