╌>

Iraq War ?

  

Category:  News & Politics

Via:  petey-coober  •  13 years ago  •  69 comments

Iraq War ?

Why was it that we got involved in Iraq ? Oh right ...

Watch the embedded video at the page bottom on this CNN article for the obvious answer .

Falling oil prices could spark global turmoil
http://money.cnn.com/2013/07/18/news/economy/opec-oil/index.html?source=yahoo_hosted


Tags

jrDiscussion - desc
[]
 
JoAnne Odel
Freshman Silent
link   JoAnne Odel    13 years ago

did barry draw a new red line, or is it a perriwinkle scribble this time?

 
 
 
Petey Coober
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Petey Coober    13 years ago

I haven't a clue who perriwinkle is let alone why they would be scribbling ...

 
 
 
JoAnne Odel
Freshman Silent
link   JoAnne Odel    13 years ago

perhaps it could just be a "so called" war.

 
 
 
Petey Coober
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Petey Coober    13 years ago

If I'm not mistaken you are anticipating this is a new Iraq war . But it is merely the one the G W Bush got us in so many years back . And in spite of the many liberal protests that it was a futility it is actually starting to pay off ... in oil . Please watch the short video in the linked article for elaboration .

BTW , you'd look good in one of those white hardhats especially if ...

 
 
 
Larry Hampton
Professor Quiet
link   Larry Hampton    13 years ago

This is an issue, sooner or late, as is.

The Shaikhs have seen this coming as well; the Caliphate is their great last hope. Renewable resources will scathe them beyond belief as they don't really have a whole helluva lot else to sell besides oil. They are making a desperate and dangerous attempt to settle themselves as THE world power while oil is still the life-blood of the global economy.

 
 
 
brightstarone
Freshman Silent
link   brightstarone    13 years ago

Why was it that we got involved in Iraq ?

Good question.

Hmm.... let's see; why did we get involved in Iraq?

Did Iraq attack the United States ..... No.

Did Iraq invade the United States ..... No.

Was there an imminent threat to America from Iraq ..... No.

Was Iraq involved in 9/11 ..... No.

Did we sacrifice American lives, Treasure and Iraqi civilians for Corporate oil profiteering ..... BINGO!!!

 
 
 
Petey Coober
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Petey Coober    13 years ago

Did Iraq attack the United States ..... No.

But they did attack Kuwait . Have you forgotten already ? Also S. Hussein launched missile attacks on Israel in an attempt to destabilize the entire middle east . The US was forced to step in to prevent an Israeli retaliation ... but I guess that small fact has eluded you . Oh , let's not forget that Hussein also tried to assassinate a US president . A minor inconvenience ...

Corporate oil is the oil our entire transportation system runs on . What kind of SUV do you drive ?

 
 
 
Petey Coober
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Petey Coober    13 years ago

Oil may become far less important in the future . It can't come soon enough for me ...

 
 
 
Krishna
Professor Guide
link   Krishna    13 years ago

Did Iraq attack the United States ..... No.

True.

Iraq did not attack the United States (well, except for an attempt to assassi ate the president). However, Saddam did start two major wars. In the second one he started, Iraq attacked and invaded a soverign country (Kuwait) in an attempt to annex it!

Remember-- we were involved in two wars vs Iraq (both under a different President named Bush):

1. The first one was started by Iraq by their invasion of Kuwait. There was a coalition of many countries fighting Saddam (as I remember, the largest contngents of troops were from the U.S., Egypt, Saudi Arabia, France, Britain) .Unlike the current civil wars today in Egypt, Syria, Iraq, etc-- this one was not a religious war (Sunni v Shia), nor was it a religious war between secularists and Islamists. Rather, it was a war to stop the invasion of a soverign country by Iraq. (And then Pres. Bush Sr.. deliberately made a decision not to topple Saddam). Most of the world was against Saddam's invasion of Iraq-- particularly nearby Arab states who feared Saddam (now they fear Iran-- a plus for the U.S. economy Smile.gif ).

2. Unlike the first war with Iraq, the second one was indeed started by the U.S . The "coalition" was much smaller (and many allies joined because of political pressure from the U.S.). France refused to join for several reasons. The cause? Both Democrats in niitially said it was about Saddam's alleged possession of WMDs (true in the past but no longer true at the time the war started) and because of his horrendous violation of Iraqi's human rights (true-- mass torture, executions, "rape rooms", etc). Later many Democrats changed their position and said it was really "all about oil" (IMO this is true).

But they did attack Kuwait . Have you forgotten already ? Also S. Hussein launched missile attacks on Israel in an attempt to destabilize the entire middle east .

Yes-- the cause of the first war with Iraq was their invasion of Kuwait in an attempt to conquer and annex it! Saddam did launch Scud attacks on Saudi Arabia (mainly because they were a major participant in the coalition against him and were close by) and a few on Israel (not so much to destabilize the region as much as out of his pure hatred. In addition, by attacking the "evil Jews" he was hoping to get support from Muslim countries worldwide) At the time Israel was not known to be a participant in either war. They wanted to, but the U.S. pressured them to stay out.

The US was forced to step in to prevent an Israeli retaliation ... but I guess that small fact has eluded you . Oh , let's not forget that Hussein also tried to assassinate a US president . A minor inconvenience ...

In the first war the U.S. stepped in because of Iraq's invasion of Kuwait. And (IMO) in the second the U.S. stepped in (well, actually the US started it) because of..oil.

Corporate oil is the oil our entire transportation system runs on . What kind of SUV do you drive ?

For years the Arab world had most of then world "by the balls" because of dependency on oil. Recent initiatives to implement alternative energy supplies have either failed, or been to expensive to implement on a wide scale.

However, that is beginning to change-- mainly due to developments in technology. (Within a few years the U.S. will probably have "energy independence"-- and the situation is also improving in other countries due to newer technologies). The Arabs are not too happy about this, of course 15.gif .

 
 
 
Petey Coober
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Petey Coober    13 years ago

Thanks for the elaboration . I've learned from it ...

 
 
 
Krishna
Professor Guide
link   Krishna    13 years ago

Thanks for the elaboration . I've learned from it ...

You're welcome Smile.gif

I may be a bit off on some of the fine points, but I'm pretty sure most of what I said , while controversial, is also factual. ( I omitted some minor details about what happened to and by the Israelis, and also, separately the Palestinians).

And, of course, many people today are unaware of the fact that initially most of the Dems were just as hawkish as the Republicans, as just as "certain" that Saddam still had WMDs (Previously he did have poison gas, and in fact used it on both his own people as well as civilians in a neighbouring country). He was also begininn the process of developing nukes-- but the Israelis (like illegal immigrants, they are allwas willing to "do the job that no ne else is willing to do") took care of that! Grin.gif (Just like what they later did to the Syrian nuclear program...Grin.gif Grin.gif and might in the future do to Iran Grin.gif Grin.gif Grin.gif )

 
 
 
Steve Ott
Professor Silent
link   Steve Ott    13 years ago

I think perriwinkle is bullwinkle's niece.

 
 
 
Steve Ott
Professor Silent
link   Steve Ott    13 years ago

Falling oil prices could spark global turmoil

I suppose it is easier to handle regional turmoil than global. If it got too bad for the Saudis, couldn't we just send them some of our money to pay their people?

 
 
 
Petey Coober
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Petey Coober    13 years ago

I think the Saudis are already well supplied with petro$$ . In fact they have been forced to order 10's of billions of US armaments just to try to balance things out . Or was it 100's of B$

 
 
 
Steve Ott
Professor Silent
link   Steve Ott    13 years ago

It isn't real money till it has a T in it. Well, another good idea down the ole missile tube.

 
 
 
Petey Coober
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Petey Coober    13 years ago

Some ultrarichie was quoted as saying "A billion $$ just doesn't go as far as it used to" .

 
 
 
Neetu2
Freshman Silent
link   Neetu2    13 years ago

What's the point of asking that question now, Petey? Oh yeah, now we have another problem!

 
 
 
Petey Coober
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Petey Coober    13 years ago

Of the 2 problems this one is not such a big deal . How many years have we lived with the ranting that "Iraq was the biggest mistake we ever made ." blah blah blah ? Based on this latest info , it had a value to the global economy which is only coming to fruition now .

 
 
 
Krishna
Professor Guide
link   Krishna    13 years ago

In fact they have been forced to order 10's of billions of US armaments just to try to balance things out .

`Yes. But another reason they are buying all those armaments (and btw, much of the "politically correct" mainstream media tends to ignore this) is that many of the (Sunni) Arab states-- particularly those near (Shiite) Iran, are terrified of the prospects of Iran possibly developing nukes. And, interestingly, most of the armaments they are buyng are defensive in nature-- especially air defenses.

While the politically correct crowd often tends to blame any problems in the area on the U.S. and the Jews "Zionists", the fact is that most of the violence in the area is the result of the Sunni v Shia split (Syria, Iraq especially continue to have more and more Sunnis and Shia killing, maiming and torturing each other). And while in most of the Muslim world the politically correct thing to do is to publically decare hatred of the so-called "Zionists" the Saudiis and the Gulf States know darn well that there's no way Israel will initiate a war with them. But they're not so sure about the crazy Islamist rulers of Iran).

 
 
 
brightstarone
Freshman Silent
link   brightstarone    13 years ago

But they did attack Kuwait . Have you forgotten already ?

No I didn't forget that at all, but that war was Herbert Bush's war which is off topic and has nothing to do with the war his son George ~the buffoon~ Bush started which is the topic in discussion.

Looks like you forgot that and got the two mixed up.

The US was forced to step in to prevent an Israeli retaliation ... but I guess that small fact has eluded you . Oh , let's not forget that Hussein also tried to assassinate a US president . A minor inconvenience ...

None of the reasons that you've sighted were given as the excuse by:

George ~the buffoon~ Bush

to invade Iraq and start a war. The reason given by the Buffoon was thattheir were weapons of mass destruction and that we were in imminent danger from mushroom clouds.

Minor facts that you are ignoring because it does not agree with your phony revisionist narrative about why George ~the buffoon~ invaded Iraq.

Corporate oil is the oil our entire transportation system runs on .

Is there a reason why you are statingan obvious fact that is not in dispute and does not stregnthen your argument.

What kind of SUV do you drive ?

I don't drive an "SUV" why do you assume that I drive an "SUV"?

And what does that have to do with the topic in discussion?

 
 
 
Petey Coober
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Petey Coober    13 years ago

Looks like you forgot that and got the two mixed up.

Looks like you don't get that those 2 wars had a dictator in common . Are you always this confused ?

Is there a reason why you are stating an obvious fact that is not in dispute and does not stregnthen your argument.

Did you bother watching the linked video ? Do you not understand that the topic is oil as a positive outcome from that war ? If you are this confused , leave off comments , watch the video & let the topic sink in ... no matter how long it takes.

I don't drive an "SUV" why do you assume that I drive an "SUV"?

And what does that have to do with the topic in discussion?

See above . BTW what kind of gas guzzling beast do you drive ?

 
 
 
Petey Coober
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Petey Coober    13 years ago

Thank you DMT . Precise & to the point .

 
 
 
Petey Coober
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Petey Coober    13 years ago

Most people don't understand the dynamics of this region . Thanks for your insight .

 
 
 
Petey Coober
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Petey Coober    13 years ago

I'll bet you've got some hairy stories to tell ...

 
 
 
brightstarone
Freshman Silent
link   brightstarone    13 years ago

Looks like you don't get that those 2 wars had a dictator in common . Are you always this confused ?

The lead question of your article is: Why was it that we got involved in Iraq ?

The reason given by George~ the buffoon ~Bush for invading Iraq was that there were weapons of mass destruction and we were in imminent danger.

That was a Lie.

Is there a reason why you are stating an obvious fact that is not in dispute and does not stregnthen your argument.

Did you bother watching the linked video ? Do you not understand that the topic is oil as a positive outcome from that war ? If you are this confused , leave off comments , watch the video & let the topic sink in ... no matter how long it takes.

Yeah the video had a lot of speculation about the outcome of the Buffoons Iraq invasion. And about oil prices which go up and down all the time nothing new and each time the talking heads in the media speculate about why and guess about future out comes relating to oil prices that may or may not result.

You asked the question: Why was it that we got involved in Iraq ?

Crystal ball speculations aside, the answer is simple; George Buffoon Bush lied to us about weapons of mass destruction to justify his invasion of Iraq and as a result we spent a staggering amount of money that the buffoon borrowed from China, we spent the lives of thousands of Americans and tens of thousands of innocent Iraqi's.

I don't drive an "SUV" why do you assume that I drive an "SUV"?

And what does that have to do with the topic in discussion?

See above . BTW what kind of gas guzzling beast do you drive ?

No answer just a phony dodge, why am I not surprised.

 
 
 
brightstarone
Freshman Silent
link   brightstarone    13 years ago

George the Buffoon Bush invaded Iraq for two reasons both which he did not say were reasons.

1. to finish what his pussy footed dad didn't, get rid of a mad man and his sons.

2 "OIL".

He lied to the American people so that Dick Cheenee's Oil and Haliburton buddies could cash in at the expense of American and Iraqi lives and a great deal of treasure.

 
 
 
Petey Coober
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Petey Coober    13 years ago

That was a Lie.

So ... your one of these hopelessly naive types who thinks that pols should always tell the truth ?

You asked the question: Why was it that we got involved in Iraq ?

No no no . Not the stated reason , the actual reason . Are you always this naive ?

No answer just a phony dodge, why am I not surprised.

In other words you are 1 of these complete hypocrites who use up lots of petroleum and then whine because of what is required to obtain more of it . Grow the fuck up ...

 
 
 
Petey Coober
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Petey Coober    13 years ago

He lied to the American people

Ooooh . Punish the baaaaad man daddy !

 
 
 
Aeonpax
Freshman Silent
link   Aeonpax    13 years ago

Iraq did not attack or threaten the US, ever. Desert Storm, which was a UN sanctioned war, addressed the Iraqi invasion of Kuwait and had nothing to do with the U.S. albeit the fact that it was affecting oil cartel profits. This small fact has eluded you.

The death of over a hundred thousand innocent Iraqi civilians, not to mention U.S./ally military deaths just because Saddam threatened to assassinate a President, is a monument to US arrogance and utter stupidity.

 
 
 
Aeonpax
Freshman Silent
link   Aeonpax    13 years ago

1 - Saddam had chemical weapons supplied to him by the Reagan administration during the Iran/Iraq war.

2 -Saddam Hussein used chemical weapons against the Kurds in northern Iraq.

3 -There was no evidence that Iraq had or was developing their own WMD's.

4 - "Operation Opera" - Israel bombed a nuclear plant in Iraq, which was bought from France, that was intended for peaceful research.

 
 
 
Aeonpax
Freshman Silent
link   Aeonpax    13 years ago

The immoral Bush/Cheney war in Iraq is directly responsible for the deaths of over a 120,000 innocent men, women and children not to mention the over 4,600 US and Allied military deaths. If one included the injured, the count goes over 400,000.

Your cavalier attitude about this is duly noted. Bush is and forever will go down in history as; A War Criminal.

 
 
 
brightstarone
Freshman Silent
link   brightstarone    13 years ago

That was a Lie.

So ... your one of these hopelessly naive types who thinks that pols should always tell the truth ?

Yeah I'm also one of those people that thinks people should not rape or murder, but they do.

So what am I suppose to do abandon that moral philosophy and accept with out question immoral behaviour because as you have been suggesting their might be a good money making result?

According to what you are suggesting then it is alright to sell addictive drugs to self destructive people or to be a merchant of child pornography because there is money to be made, and so who cares how we get that money or who gets hurt as long as I get mine; the hell with everybody else, who needs moral standards when there is money to be made.

You asked the question: Why was it that we got involved in Iraq ?

No no no . Not the stated reason , the actual reason . Are you always this naive ?

Again you are stating the obvious and making my case for me.I knew before the first bomb dropped and before the first American soldier stepped foot on Iraqi soil and before the first innocent Iraqi civilian was murdered that George~ the buffoon ~ Bush was lying about weapons of mass destruction and that the war was first and formost for the corporate oil giants and the corporate contractors who would greedily make tens of millions of dollars from the deaths of innocent Iraqis and American soldiers.

No answer just a phony dodge, why am I not surprised.

In other words you are 1 of these complete hypocrites who use up lots of petroleum....

That is a weak straw-man argument.The economy that we live under is a petroleum based economy and so anyone living in a petroleum based economy is part of it and a consumer of it; no choice in the matter we were all born into it.

So what does that have to do with me pointing out the truth about George ~the buffoon~ Bush lying the country into an unnessary war of choice in Iraq?

...and then whine because of what is required to obtain more of it .

The murder of innocent people and the miss-use and abuse ofour military and lying to the American people is not a requirment to obtain oil, it is a false argument and a requirment, to make obscean profits with out moral conscience or care.

Grow the fuck up ...

So in your depraved morality, the acceptance with out question of being lied into an unnessasary criminal war; that resulted in the deaths of tens of thousands of innocent people for the staggering profit of a tiny few, is the mark of a "Grown up"

Wellif a politician lie's about having an affair, I expect that and I would not consider that honorable; but if a politician lie's to engineer the deaths of thousands of innocent people for the profit of his corporate cronies then I will consider that Criminal and speak out against it.

So instead of telling me to "grow the fuck up" maybe you should look at your deraved indecent moral philosophy of: "anything goes" as long as you make money it's OK.

And get a fuckin conscience Petey.

 
 
 
Petey Coober
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Petey Coober    13 years ago

Yeah I'm also one of those people that thinks people should not rape or murder, but they do.

So what am I suppose to do abandon that moral philosophy and accept with out question immoral behaviour because as you have been suggesting their might be a good money making result?Yeah I'm also one of those people that thinks people should not rape or murder, but they do.

Wow , now you're equating lying with rape or murder . Where is your head at ?

So what am I suppose to do abandon that moral philosophy and accept with out question immoral behaviour because as you have been suggesting their might be a good money making result?

What you do on a philosophical level is your problem . I'm sure you have not suddenly accepted me as your mentor . But since you asked , here's an interesting tidbit for you . Western civilization is based on the ancient Athenian model . Athens became successful at defending herself when she listened to a general lying to them about an external threat . That lie motivated them to build the fleet of ships which saved their city state from invasion .

According to what you are suggesting then it is alright to sell addictive drugs to self destructive people or to be a merchant of child pornography because there is money to be made, and so who cares how we get that money or who gets hurt as long as I get mine; the hell with everybody else, who needs moral standards when there is money to be made.

Where have I said that ? Point it out to me . And stop putting words in my mouth . I have implied that lying is part & parcel of the political process . That's how it is . To expect otherwise is to be naive to a fault .

That is a weak straw-man argument. The economy that we live under is a petroleum based economy and so anyone living in a petroleum based economy is part of it and a consumer of it; no choice in the matter we were all born into it.

Wrong . That was a very weak argument . You have choices . You can choose to consume less petroleum . For example :
...

George ~the buffoon~ Bush lying the country into an unnessary war of choice in Iraq?

Perhaps you are still not groking what this article is about . You call it an unneccessary war but it is starting to yield useful result even as OBAMA's trek into Libya has yielded useful results . Does that make Bams a buffoon too ?

So in your depraved morality

That did it . Get off my article . That is a deeply offensive statement . Just because you are too fucking naive to accept the real world for what it is that is no reason to fling around nasty accusations . Good fucken bye .

 
 
 
Petey Coober
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Petey Coober    13 years ago

albeit the fact that it was affecting oil cartel profits.

More importantly it was affecting the actual flow of oil . Apparently you are another one of these hyper-naive types who live in a vacuum . You use petroleum daily but then bitch about what it takes to obtain it . Stop whining and starting altering your transportation habits :

The death of over a hundred thousand innocent Iraqi civilians, not to mention U.S./ally military deaths just because Saddam threatened to assassinate a President, is a monument to US arrogance and utter stupidity.

Thanks for completely ignoring the subject of this article . Try watching the linked video before you insert your foot in your mouth again . If you can't be bothered to acquaint yourself with the subject matter go away .

 
 
 
Petey Coober
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Petey Coober    13 years ago

The immoral Bush/Cheney war in Iraq is directly responsible for the deaths of over a 120,000 innocent men, women and children

Based on the politics of the middle east equating innocence with the freedom to stay alive is hopelessly naive . How about Obama's little trek into Libya ?
Saying that the war was directly responsible is just wrong . Indirect maybe . Did the US directly attack civilians in Iraq ? Of course not . You are being just plain silly in your overly "pure" motivations . Wake up and smell the gasoline . Oh , and stop using so much of it . If the cops can do it so can you :
...

Your cavalier attitude about this is duly noted. Bush is and forever will go down in history as; A War Criminal.

Your hopelessly naive attitude is noted . Stop being a hypocrite .

 
 
 
Petey Coober
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Petey Coober    13 years ago

Thanks for your confidence DMT . I wish I could live up to it . But maybe I am learning . I didn't realize how entrenched this liberal "morality" thing is . They actually believe that this "morality" trumps physics and economics . I actually wouldn't mind moralizing if they showed some willingness to sacrifice for their beliefs ...
but to dismiss questioning about that as a "phony dodge" is quite an exercise in arrogance from my POV .

 
 
 
Petey Coober
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Petey Coober    13 years ago

I accept that description of overzealous . [Geez , isn't that what some were saying about G Zimmerman !]
In any case I appreciate your attempts at mediating . Also I think I have reached an epiphany of sorts about the liberal mindset . I am def gonna try to use different tactics in the future ... although I'm not sure which ones .

 
 
 
brightstarone
Freshman Silent
link   brightstarone    13 years ago

Yeah I'm also one of those people that thinks people should not rape or murder, but they do.

So what am I suppose to do abandon that moral philosophy and accept with out question immoral behaviour because as you have been suggesting their might be a good money making result?Yeah I'm also one of those people that thinks people should not rape or murder, but they do.

Wow , now you're equating lying with rape or murder .

No.

But it certainly is true that lying can lead to murder and rape as in the case that we are discussing.... you know when the "buffoon" lied us into a war with Iraq.

Where is your head at ?

What do you mean by that?

So what am I suppose to do abandon that moral philosophy and accept with out question immoral behaviour because as you have been suggesting their might be a good money making result?

What you do on a philosophical level is your problem .

It is not a problem, it is my personal view and beliefs.

I'm sure you have not suddenly accepted me as your mentor .

That is a clever deduction Petey.Grin.gif

But since you asked , here's an interesting tidbit for you . Western civilization is based on the ancient Athenian model . Athens became successful at defending herself when she listened to a general lying to them about an external threat . That lie motivated them to build the fleet of ships which saved their city state from invasion .

That is a very impressive history lesson Petey, but it does not justify the "buffoons" lies that got us into an unnecessary war.And itdoes not equate with what happened in ancient Greece, you see in Greece it was an issue of self defense, in the buffoons case it was a deception to gain lots and lots of money for his corporate cronies at the expense of very many American lives and even more innocent Iraqi lives, and the abuse and miss-use of our brave military.

You can see the difference can't you Petey?

According to what you are suggesting then it is alright to sell addictive drugs to self destructive people or to be a merchant of child pornography because there is money to be made, and so who cares how we get that money or who gets hurt as long as I get mine; the hell with everybody else, who needs moral standards when there is money to be made.

Where have I said that ? Point it out to me . And stop putting words in my mouth .

I didn't put words in your mouth Petey it was a metaphor,a smart guy like you should be able to tell the difference.

Are you pretending to be Obtuse.

I have implied that lying is part & parcel of the political process . That's how it is . To expect otherwise is to be naive to a fault .

I never thought of that Petey, thanks for clearing that up.Grin.gif

That is a weak straw-man argument. The economy that we live under is a petroleum based economy and so anyone living in a petroleum based economy is part of it and a consumer of it; no choice in the matter we were all born into it.

Wrong . That was a very weak argument . You have choices . You can choose to consume less petroleum . For example : ...

My point about living in a petroleum economy was a response to your bogus claim that I have no right to complain about citizens being lied into an unnecessary war for oil profits, because I use petroleum.

And your examples of alternatives to oil, make my case; that lying to the people to make war for profit in oil is unnecessary, because there are many other ways to go besides petroleum, as you yourself have acknowledged.

George ~the buffoon~ Bush lying the country into an unnessary war of choice in Iraq?

Perhaps you are still not groking what this article is about .

"groking".... hmm .... is that the same as understanding?

If so, then you are incorrect (yet again - surprise!)

I understand what the article is about, I just don't agree with it and I am pointing out what is wrong with it. And since you are arguing a weak incorrect point then your hasty reply is :

"I don't understand" for some reason that does not convince me.

You call it an unneccessary war but it is starting to yield useful result ....

Yeah ... it was very useful to Buffoon Bush and Dick Cheenee's corporate buddies ( Haliburton, KBR,Big Oil .... etc ) but those are a teeny-tiny bunch of people who profited massively from the buffoons criminal war.

The rest of us who paid for Bush's War are left holding the bag, having to pay the debit to China with Tax payers money, and in addition to that, ongoing expense that ourtax monieswill have tocover, such asthe emotional and physical damage to our brave military women and men who served in that criminal war.

even as OBAMA's trek into Libya has yielded useful results . Does that make Bams a buffoon too ?

I am discussing with you, your article about :

"Why was it that we got involved in Iraq ?"

Your weak argument in favor of the criminal war hasn't made your case and so you are now deflecting with a false equivalency about Libya .

I understand .

So in your depraved morality

That did it . Get off my article . That is a deeply offensive statement .

Yes, the idea that it is a good thing for the leader of a super power like the United States to tell lie's that unleashits mightymilitary machineintoan unnecessary criminalwar for oil profiteering.

A war that involves the deaths of thousands of innocent human-beings including women and children, and the abuse of our fine military and justifying that immorality with the claim that it was useful because lots of money was made and so who cares about the victims of Bush's Lie's.

That is very offensive in my opinion. And that is why I pointed it out in this conversation. I'm sorry if your feelings are hurt but it is futile for you to blame the messenger.

Just because you are too fucking naive to accept the real world for what it is that is no reason to fling around nasty accusations . Good fucken bye .

Remember Petey you set the tone with your potty mouth :

"Grow the fuck up" ... "you are 1 of these complete hypocrites" ... " too fucking nave " ... "Are you always this naive ?" ....

Hmm ... bad words and name calling.

Throwing atantrum, is childish and does nothing toconvince me of your arguments merit.

If you are too sensitive and fragile to withstand a difference of opinion and an honest reply, then don't post to me.68.gif

 
 
 
brightstarone
Freshman Silent
link   brightstarone    13 years ago

I disagree with your characterization of my posts being nasty.68.gif

 
 
 
brightstarone
Freshman Silent
link   brightstarone    13 years ago

Tsk tsk tsk your better than this Petey.

Very emotional isn't he.

Though if you think about it his reaction to my pointing out the twisted morality of war for profit, is an indication that he does recognize the depraved nature of that morality and is their-fore offended by being associated with it, which shows some level of compassion and empathy for the victims of war profiteering, and that is a good thing because it shows that he is not a heartless bastard after all.67.gif

 
 
 
Aeonpax
Freshman Silent
link   Aeonpax    13 years ago
  • Based on the politics of the middle east equating innocence with the freedom to stay alive is hopelessly nave

That makes absolutely no sense, which is par for you.

  • How about Obama's little trek into Libya ?

I was against it and have no love for Obama.

  • Saying that the war was directly responsible is just wrong . Indirect maybe . Did the US directly attack civilians in Iraq ?

Dont play word games with me. I did not say the US killed, I said the US (or more to the point Bush/Cheney) is directly responsible for the deaths. Had we not invaded Iraq, those people would still be alive. Get a clue, learn English

  • You are being just plain silly in your overly "pure" motivations .

I guess that would make you just plain ignorant of reality that doesnt fit into your preconceived notions. Since when is being against wars in which innocent humans are being killed, "pure motivations"? You have a strange way defining things.

  • Your hopelessly naive attitude is noted . Stop being a hypocrite.

You are hopelessly if not tragically uninformed.

 
 
 
Petey Coober
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Petey Coober    13 years ago

Well , I read your moralistic screed & I'm amazed . Your obsessive focus on war profits as evil while ignoring the actual results of the war [oil getting to market ] is odd at best .

What have you done in your life to reduce the consumption of petroleum is the one question I have .
Why do I want to know that ? That is the 1 thing an individual can actually do to change [in some small way perhaps] the effects of living within the petroleum economy . If you haven't done anything of that sort then you are still a part of the problem rather than part of the solution . The problem is that our society is addicted to petroleum . The near term solution is to conserve it .

it does not justify the "buffoons" lies that got us into an unnecessary war. And it does not equate with what happened in ancient Greece, you see in Greece it was an issue of self defense, in the buffoons case it was a deception to gain lots and lots of money for his corporate cronies

Apparently you don't comprehend what living in a western country implies . To me the implication is so obvious that I expect that everyone will immediately get what I am saying ... but I do have education of a technical nature in my background so forgive my overly high expectations about the general public .

People's lives DEPEND ON THE FLOW OF PETROLEUM . For you to say that this war was only about war profits [and I'm sure there were war profits] seems obsessive . To me what is most important is not war profits but the fact that people's lives DEPEND ON THE FLOW OF PETROLEUM . To distinguish between ancient Greece as being purely defensive and the west's addiction to oil as not defensive is to lose sight of the facts . I hope that clears up whatever misconceptions you may have had ... although I suspect I have not heard the end of the moral rantings . Forgive me if I don't share your focus on the morality of this conflict but I have those other concerns .

OK , I will own up to starting the worst of the shouting match we had . Perhaps I am overly focused on one aspect of events [in many people's perception ] but that is not going to stop my concerns which IMO trump all the other concerns . I think that pretty much sums up what I have to say but I'd like to add that finding out the hard way about the flow of petroleum dependence is not a lesson you want to receive .

 
 
 
Petey Coober
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Petey Coober    13 years ago

That makes absolutely no sense

Huh ? Are you not even gonna try ? Are you that ignorant of what goes on in the middle east ?

Dont play word games with me. I did not say the US killed, I said the US (or more to the point Bush/Cheney) is directly responsible for the deaths. Had we not invaded Iraq, those people would still be alive. Get a clue, learn English

Yeah , definitely . Why don't you learn what directly means ... Can't be bothered ? Too "moral" for these petty definitions ?

Had we not invaded Iraq, those people would still be alive.

LMAO ! Do you have any idea of how many Arabs kill each other every month over sectarian squabbles ?
Do you know how many S. Hussein had killed ? The middle east has long been a very violent place . What about that don't you understand ...

You are hopelessly if not tragically uninformed.

See the above . Or if you're a really hopeless case see this :

 
 
 
Perrie Halpern R.A.
Professor Guide
link   Perrie Halpern R.A.    13 years ago

Guys this is a warning. This is bordering on the personal. Please calm down. Breath deep. This is a very interesting discussion otherwise. Remember tomorrow is the last day of this grace period before the new enforcement code kicks in. Thank you!Grin.gif

 
 
 
Perrie Halpern R.A.
Professor Guide
link   Perrie Halpern R.A.    13 years ago

They were both getting heated, hence the warning

 
 
 
Petey Coober
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Petey Coober    13 years ago

Was your comment nasty ? Maybe , maybe not . What is far more important is the following :

My point about living in a petroleum economy was a response to your bogus claim that I have no right to complain about citizens being lied into an unnecessary war for oil profits, because I use petroleum.

You keep saying it was a war for oil profits . But you ignore the fact that it was a war to obtain oil . Why is that ?

And your examples of alternatives to oil, make my case; that lying to the people to make war for profit in oil is unnecessary, because there are many other ways to go besides petroleum, as you yourself have acknowledged.

Actually that's not what I said . In this subject I have a fair amount of knowledge . Oil is still necessary in our transportation system and it will be for sometime . The fact that alternatives exist does not mean they will be adopted in large enough amounts to make a dent in the petro economy . But you found it necessary to twist words around while not being willing to even explore said alternatives is quite a hypocritical act . Until you demonstrate such an interest , you really don't have the right to complain about a war for oil . You are just part of the problem .

 
 
 
brightstarone
Freshman Silent
link   brightstarone    13 years ago

Well , I read your moralistic screed & I'm amazed . Your obsessive focus on war profits as evil...

Hmm.... "moralistic screed" ... that's one theory. But I disagree with it. And yes it is "amaaazzzing" that I or anyone else would consider it a bad thing to profit from the death and destruction of other human-beings.

Considering the morality of war and those who profit from war is not necessary right Petey? All of my statements as to the morality of it all is just crazy talk.

Well some people care about how they make their money and some people don't. To each his own they say.

Personally I could not live with myself if I made my money off of the death and pain of people I never even met. I'd rather make money providing a valuable service or selling something useful or needed, but hey ... that's just me with my amaaazzzing obsession with the morality of things, and the evil of war profiteering. I know I must be crazy right Petey?

while ignoring the actual results of the war ...

Yeah the results were that a tiny number of the people made tens of millions of dollars and tens of thousands of innocent people were killed, dismembered, mutilated ... etc,inBush's Iraqi war for profit.

What have you done in your life to reduce the consumption of petroleum is the one question I have .

OK Petey I'll tell ya,

first off despite your blind self-serving assumption; I don't drive a gas guzzling SUV, I drive a 4 cylinder car and so does my wife. I have changed all the bulbs to florescent bulbs in my home, and I am going to change those over time with LED bulbs because they are even more efficient.

When we have to cook or heat food we always use the small toaster or microwave and when I do use my electric range which is very rare I coast cook to save electricity.

We don't use a cloths dryer we hang em out to dry, pain in the ass but it saves a ton of money and energy. When we shop we always do it in town instead of driving 20 or 30 miles out of town, and we only drive out of town or at all when absolutely necessary.

My water heater is always off, about 2 hours before we take showers I turn the heater on. I don't use my central A/C I bought window units for the bed rooms and only use A/C when in the room. Why cool the whole house when there is only 2 of us and we are not in the other rooms.

(down side is you have to look out for mold)

When we can afford itwe will invest in an all electric car forin town driving and use the gas cars for highway driving. And we will invest in solar when the price finally becomes affordable.

In short, despite your assumptions I am aware and engaged with the effort to reduce energy consumption.

Why do I want to know that ? That is the 1 thing an individual can actually do to change [in some small way perhaps] the effects of living within the petroleum economy .

I agree and I can't wait to get an electric vehicle, that will be a great day, my one finger salute to BIG OIL & SUADI ARABIA.

If you haven't done anything of that sort then you are still a part of the problem rather than part of the solution .

Well now you know you are not the only one thinking about it or doing something about it.

The problem is that our society is addicted to petroleum . The near term solution is to conserve it .

I agree completely,see Petey we agree on some things, you gave me hate before when I disagreed; and so now you gotta give me LoveGrin.gif

Apparently you don't comprehend what living in a western country implies .

I don't? ..... do tell.

To me the implication is so obvious that I expect that everyone will immediately get what I am saying ...

Hey Petey, not all of us can be so smart like you.

but I do have education of a technical nature in my background so forgive my overly high expectations about the general public .

No problem Petey, you're forgiven.

People's lives DEPEND ON THE FLOW OF PETROLEUM . For you to say that this war was only about war profits [and I'm sure there were war profits] seems obsessive .

Let me get this straight Petey, if Bush had not lied us into the Iraqi War then the vital flow of oil to the United States would have stopped.

Sorry Petey I don't buy that, it's obvious that it was a war for profit; human lives be dam-ed.

To me what is most important is not war profits but the fact that people's lives DEPEND ON THE FLOW OF PETROLEUM .

Sorry to disturb your theory but there was no danger of an oil stoppage if Bush had not lied us into a war with Iraq. The war was for war profiteering and the weapons of mass destruction was a phony lie to justify the invasion of Iraq.

To distinguish between ancient Greece as being purely defensive and the west's addiction to oil as not defensive is to lose sight of the facts .

And again the war in Iraq was not about the flow of oil, it was about making money from the misery and death of human-beings. Just like a contract killer, who makes money from killing people. Going to war and killing tens of thousands of innocent people for oil and military contract profits, is similar indepravity of morality.

I hope that clears up whatever misconceptions you may have had ...

You repeated the same depraved philosophy of money and things matter more then human-beings, I already understood your position repeating it was not necessary.

although I suspect I have not heard the end of the moral rantings .

If by that you mean that I will respond and express my disagreement then yes of course, I could never accept your depraved immoral philosophy.

The lack of moral consideration that you are advocating for is the same mind set of a drug dealer or a merchant of child pornography, thepeople who runthose kinds of business's are not concerned with morality or who they are hurting. All they care about is making money that is all.

If people are destroyed by the drugs they sell then so what, and if children are miss-treated and destroyed by being used as sex objects then so what, people that use to sell slaves had the same mindset, they just care about making money to get things and not how they get their monies or who they hurt.

There is no moral compass there, and to me that is morally depraved, you might want to take it personally but it is a statement of fact as I understand it.

lf you are too sensitive and fragile to hear an opinion that questions your lack of moral consideration then don't post your arguments for depraved morality to me because you will never convince me and I will respond with a contrary opinion.

OK , I will own up to starting the worst of the shouting match we had .

That's OK Petey I didn't take it personal, it is just blogging in the Internet after all.

Perhaps I am overly focused on one aspect of events [in many people's perception ] but that is not going to stop my concerns which IMO trump all the other concerns .

Good for you Petey think what ever you like I won't worry about it. But there is one thing that puzzles me and that is "IMO" what the hell does that mean?

I think that pretty much sums up what I have to say but I'd like to add that finding out the hard way about the flow of petroleum dependence is not a lesson you want to receive .

Well Petey, I hope that this never happens to you; but if another country attacked the United States and your house was bombed and you survived but your loved ones did not, then I think you would understand the moral implications of such immoral acts and appreciate that aspect of the equation..

 
 
 
Chucky Stuart
Freshman Silent
link   Chucky Stuart    13 years ago

But they did attack Kuwait

At the start, we had no problem with him invading Kuwait, in fact, we gave our tentative blessing. The problems started when Hussein decided to stay there past the point where we felt comfy. That's when we decided to stand up for democracy.......excuse me, I meant monarchy.

 
 
 
Petey Coober
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Petey Coober    13 years ago

At the start, we had no problem with him invading Kuwait

You're off to a bad start ...

in fact, we gave our tentative blessing

That's your example of a fact ?

That's when we decided to stand up for democracy.......excuse me, I meant monarchy.

You should mean oil . BTW oil is what this article is about . How about watching the linked video and directing your comments based on that ?

 
 
 
Chucky Stuart
Freshman Silent
link   Chucky Stuart    13 years ago

Yes PC, the topic is oil. But you were the one who brought up the fact that Iran invaded Kuwait as if that anything to do with anything. To believe that this invasion had anything to do with what has happened since is erroneous and you know it.

 
 
 
Petey Coober
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Petey Coober    13 years ago

you were the one who brought up the fact that Iran invaded Kuwait as if that anything to do with anything

I expect you mean Iraq invaded Kuwait but then all of these little middle eastern states are soooo confusing .And yes it had to do with OIL from Kuwait . Once again , that is the subject .

To believe that this invasion had anything to do with what has happened since is erroneous and you know it.

You have just violated one of my cardinal rules . Don't tell other people what they know .
And yes that is exactly what I am saying . The 1st Gulf war was about oil . So was the second . The 1st one had a fairly quick effect on restoring the flow of oil . The 2nd one took awhile but to imply that G. Bush had no idea that oil was involved is patently absurd ...

 
 
 
Chucky Stuart
Freshman Silent
link   Chucky Stuart    13 years ago

I expect you mean Iraq invaded Kuwait but then all of these little middle eastern states are soooo confusing .

Okay, I deserve that (GADAMIT). But my point that the invasion of Kuwait had nothing to do with the wars that followed is still valid. I agree that it was all about oil.

 
 
 
brightstarone
Freshman Silent
link   brightstarone    13 years ago

BRO you can disagree with his opinions but to defer to name calling by both of you is uncalled for.

BRO thanks for giving me permission to disagree.

But if you go back and read my response's you will not find me calling him nasty names. I stated my opinion; that advocating for war profiteering is a philosophy that is morally depraved.

That is not the same as calling someone a nasty name.

The only one who called names was Petey and he said a bad word

f*ckin, he is quite the emotional potty mouth when you disagree with him.

 
 
 
brightstarone
Freshman Silent
link   brightstarone    13 years ago

Was your comment nasty ? Maybe , maybe not .

Let me clear that up for you Petey.

No.

My comment was not nasty, and that is very important to note.Grin.gif

What is far more important is the following :

Please do tell Petey, what is more important.

My point about living in a petroleum economy was a response to your bogus claim that I have no right to complain about citizens being lied into an unnecessary war for oil profits, because I use petroleum.

You keep saying it was a war for oil profits .

Yeah because that is what the war was about oil profits.

But you ignore the fact that it was a war to obtain oil . Why is that ?

Splitting hairs are we Petey. (btw-that was the Royal "WE")

So tell me Petey when oil is "obtained" is any profit made?

And if so then might the profits around oil "obtaining" be motive for the behavior and actions around "oil obtaining?" You know actions like lying and creating unnecessary wars for profit?

And your examples of alternatives to oil, make my case; that lying to the people to make war for profit in oil is unnecessary, because there are many other ways to go besides petroleum, as you yourself have acknowledged.

Actually that's not what I said . In this subject I have a fair amount of knowledge .

Yeah I know Petey your very smart.

Oil is still necessary in our transportation system and it will be for sometime .

Of course.

The fact that alternatives exist does not mean they will be adopted in large enough amounts to make a dent in the petro economy .

Never said that Petey, what I was saying was that we can make a reduction in our dependence and eventually reduce it over time to nearly zero after maybe a couple of generations, but we have to start where ever we can.

But you found it necessary to twist words around while not being willing to even explore said alternatives is quite a hypocritical act .

You twist my words around and miss-represent what I meant and then you accuse me of twisting words around and lying about my willingness to "even explore alternatives" what you are doing is obvious and lame.

Until you demonstrate such an interest ,

I've already answered your question about what am I doing to reduce my energy consumption and you completely ignored my response and claimed that I have no interest in that.

Again obvious and lame.

you really don't have the right to complain about a war for oil .

I have every right to complain about war for oil or anything else and I will continue to complain about war for oil profiteering, and your arrogance in thinking that you can dictate to me what my right is to complain about isirrelevant.

You are just part of the problem .

No.

The problem is when we are lied into unnecessary wars for oil and military contractor profits. That is morally depraved.33.gif

 
 
 
Krishna
Professor Guide
link   Krishna    13 years ago

We invaded and occupied Iraq because the neoconservatives were sure that it would inspire an outbreak of western style democracies through the region that we would, in effect, control.

Yup.

The absurd notion that Arab societies, and the predominant values in those cultures, were consistent with democracy was really pushed for for in a big way by George W. Bush (Peace Be Upon Him).

Saddam was a truly barbaric dictator-- I think Bush honestly believed that if he was overthrown there could be true democracy in Iraq. Total nonsense-- as history shows.

Bush also extended this bizarre belief in an even more ludicrous way-- believing that the Palestinian values were not inconsistent with democratic values! 24.gif

Really-- ya can't make this stuff up.

He pushed hard for, and finally got, a Palestinian election! (BTW, it was so closely monitored by International observers that it was a pretty honest election).

And who did the Palestinians choose to lead them? Hamas-- a brutal terrorist group made up of religious extremists! (After they got into power they murdered, imprisoned and inflicted some really gruesome tortured political opponents (mainly Fatah).

And then there's the so-called "Arab-Spring"... Frown.gif Frown.gif Frown.gif

 
 
 
Petey Coober
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Petey Coober    13 years ago

Thanks for your comment J4T .

We invaded

Yes .

and occupied Iraq

Sort of

because the neoconservatives were sure that it would inspire an outbreak of western style democracies through the region

They were sure ? Very doubtful .

western style democracies

In retrospect it does look foolish but that was the hope . However , I should point out that the Kurds were very glad we arrived . And they were also eager to establish a market economy . That's what they did . For proof , just watch the linked video in the article .

It was a twisted form of colonialism. It was meant to be just a first step in an American take over of the entire region.

Geez , at least get your pejorative terms right . No one does colonialism anymore . Now it is called imperialism .
BTW how do you distinguish imperialism from establishing trade relations in a market economy ?

 
 
 
Petey Coober
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Petey Coober    13 years ago

they would be puppet states of ours.

Apparently we are soooo venal that our plan is to take over the world . I didn't know that . Why don't you post a list of countries we have done that with ?

Also how about answering the question at the end of my previous comment .

 
 
 
Krishna
Professor Guide
link   Krishna    13 years ago

western style democracies

Democracy is democracy.

Attempting to portray it as "western style" show that the speaker has an agenda...

(And what, pray tell, is a " Non- western-style democracy"?

Perhaps those in eastern o-- Australia? new Zealand? Japan? India?

Or perhaps that would mean the sort of so-called "democracy" such as in those under Saddam, Mubarak, Karzai, Egypt's Muslim Brotherhood, Hamas in Gaza, Syria, Iran, The Sudan, Saudi Arabia...etc..etc? Is that what you would men to be considered non-Western-style "democracies"?

Or perhaps non-western-style-democracies is what they had under Communism-- all those "Peoples-Democratic-Republic-of" type "democracies"?

IF the foolish plan had worked (and there is not a chance in hell that it ever would)

Agreed,

Certainly not in any Arab country....

Bush was totally delusional in that regard.

But I'm not being partisan here, because the fact of the matter is, Obama is equally so:

"And throughout history, Islam has demonstrated through words and deeds the possibilities of religious tolerance and racial equality."
Barack Obama, Cairo, June 4, 2009 .

 
 
 
Krishna
Professor Guide
link   Krishna    13 years ago

I haven't a clue who perriwinkle is

I think its a flower. Sort of blue. Also, I think the word is used to describe that colour--for example a paint of that colour.

Buts not a red line-- if anything it would be a shade of blue.

But why are we wasting time discussing this-- we should be discussing something really important-- a crucial news story that has been all but ignored on NT.

Does anyone have any thoughts on the Trayvon Martin/Jorge Zimmerman kerfuffle (and the ensuing brouhaha)?

HaHA! Grin.gif

 
 
 
Krishna
Professor Guide
link   Krishna    13 years ago

I think perriwinkle is bullwinkle's niece.

Perhaps "Winkle" was Perrie's last name before she got married?

 
 
 
Petey Coober
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Petey Coober    13 years ago

BS1 ,

Sorry I missed your last replies . They were covered over by someone else's replies .

Considering the morality of war and those who profit from war is not necessary right Petey? All of my statements as to the morality of it all is just crazy talk.

I choose to not apply my energies opposing something that is inevitable . Wars about oil are . That has been historically demonstrated ever since WW2 , maybe even earlier .

Yeah the results were that a tiny number of the people made tens of millions of dollars and tens of thousands of innocent people were killed, dismembered, mutilated ... etc, in Bush's Iraqi war for profit.

A little melodramatic ? No , a lot . Again , this was a war to maintain the oil markets and as such was inevitable . You keep looking at profits as the only result & ignore the result for the oil market .BTW , how many deaths would occur if oil flow was interrupted ? That is something you have not factored into your moral calculus .

My water heater is always off, about 2 hours before we take showers I turn the heater on.
....
now you gotta give me Love

Definitely ...
Not only is that action commendable but it is a good idea . I'm glad to hear you're on board with conservation .

Let me get this straight Petey, if Bush had not lied us into the Iraqi War then the vital flow of oil to the United States would have stopped.
Sorry Petey I don't buy that, it's obvious that it was a war for profit; human lives be dam-ed.
....
Sorry to disturb your theory but there was no danger of an oil stoppage if Bush had not lied us into a war with Iraq

You seem to have a very provincial view of markets . Oil is a global market . The US is the only country powerful enough to protect that market . Are you saying that disruptions are unimportant when they affect Europe ?
That does not sound very moral to me . Where is your concern for human life ?

And again the war in Iraq was not about the flow of oil . it was about making money from the misery and death of human-beings.

Doesn't matter how many times you say it . Prove it . In fact prove that it was NOT about the flow of oil since that is the topic of this article .

You repeated the same depraved philosophy of money and things matter more then human-beings

I am going to ignore your attack since it is clear you are operating under a fallacious world view . Those who attempt to deny the laws of physics and economics are _____ [fill in your own pejorative here] .

The lack of moral consideration that you are advocating for is the same mind set of a drug dealer or a merchant of child pornography, the people who run those kinds of business's are not concerned with morality or who they are hurting. All they care about is making money that is all.

Not me . All I care about is the energy markets . Our entire civilization is dependent on energy getting to where it is needed . If it doesn't people die . But I guess your "morality" doesn't cover those . Now who's expressing depravity ...

So tell me Petey when oil is "obtained" is any profit made?

Yup . That is the capitalist way . You can call it immoral or depraved all you want but I think that makes you extremely naive . Profits are what makes our system run . Without them there would be no economy , jobs etc .

I have every right to complain about war for oil .

Sure you do . Tilting against windmills seems to be your forte , Don Q .

One more thing . Forming a democracy seems to inevitably result in conflict and death . That is what was attempted [unsuccessfully ] in Iraq . I think it was an experiment worth trying . It was partially successful .For the details about that see the linked video .

 
 
 
Petey Coober
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Petey Coober    13 years ago

Obviously Imperialism is when we force our ideas and ideals on a different country.

Not obvious and not even correct :

imperialism [im-peer-ee-uh-liz-uhm]
noun
1.
the policy of extending the rule or authority of an empire or nation over foreign countries, or of acquiring and holding colonies and dependencies.
2.
advocacy of imperial or sovereign interests over the interests of the dependent states.

As you can see it has nothing to do with ideas/ideals . It is about rule or authority.

 
 
 
Petey Coober
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Petey Coober    13 years ago

Ideas and ideals are about rule and/or authority, especially if we force them on another nation.

That is impossible . You can take over a country's power structure by military force . But ideas and ideals are products of the mind . Just like I can't force you to change your mind [even if I held a gun to your head ] . All that might happen is you may decide to tell me I'm right . But inside your head you would still hold onto your ideals .

But if you feel the need to believe you're right about this keep on truckin' . Just don't expect me to buy this confused thinking .

 
 
 
brightstarone
Freshman Silent
link   brightstarone    13 years ago

Sorry I missed your last replies . They were covered over by someone else's replies .

That's Ok, sometimes the "reply" function is not present and it is hard to figure out how to respond in order, using another postings "reply" function.

I choose to not apply my energies opposing something that is inevitable . Wars about oil are . That has been historically demonstrated ever since WW2 , maybe even earlier .

It is your prerogative to make what ever choices you like, whether the subjects you are choosing about are " inevitable" or not- inevitable.

But I choose not to buy into the notion that because something might be "inevitable" we might as well not try to improve it and just keep doing the same things.

Consider that for much ofhistory Slavery was an ingrained and inevitable part of human societies. Slavery is an ancient concept that has been around for thousands of years, evenbefore the Roman Empire and after; right up to the present time. In the America of the 1860's, many advocated for the maintenance of Slavery using theargument that it was an inevitable part of civilized society and that great civilizations like the might Roman Empire had it and that it was even in the Bible. And so all of the depravity and in-humanity of the Slave trade was minimized and excused as normal.

But there were many who chose not to passively accept the false argument of inevitability.They were correctly outraged at the moral depravity of en-slaving people for profit and not trying to end the in-defensible trading and selling of human-beings. And they aspired to makesociety better, to strive for that more perfect union.

The result was that as far as I can tell for the first time in history, a country went to war against it self over the question of slavery. And the undeniable result of the American Civil War was that Slavery as an institution of society was ended, and millions were freed.

If everyone at that time had accepted the false argument that it is inevitable and so lets do nothing and keep going as we have been, then we would still have Government sanctioned slavery, instead of Slavery being against the law and contrary to the founding principals of our Constitution.

Yeah the results were that a tiny number of the people made tens of millions of dollars and tens of thousands of innocent people were killed, dismembered, mutilated ... etc, in Bush's Iraqi war for profit.

A little melodramatic ? No , a lot . Again , this was a war to maintain the oil markets and as such was inevitable .

"melodramatic"..... well considering that the Iraqi War involved the inevitable Death,mutilation, anddismemberment of tens of thousands of Human-beings many of them women and children, for the rank reason of profiteering;I guess you can consider the facts of the case "melodramatic" but my acknowledgement and expression of those facts are not "melodramatic" in themselves; it is instead a truthful accounting of the facts.

You keep looking at profits as the only result & ignore the result for the oil market .

Greed for profits are the motivating factor that drove buffoon Bush and Dick Chee- nee to steer us into an unnecessary and criminal war of choice for profit. Greedy Profiteering is the dominant reason that made the war in Iraq happen; not the need to keep oil markets flowing.

If it were reverse and there was no profit from War or Oil then the greed for excessive profit's would not be there to instigate unnecessary wars with thousands of innocents dying and our brave military being abused for the profit of a tiny few who don't care about the country but only care about : I got mine f**k everybody else.

BTW , how many deaths would occur if oil flow was interrupted ? That is something you have not factored into your moral calculus .

Any comments by me or you or anyone else about the potential deaths or non-deaths, from oil flow interruption would be speculative and not factual. But the Deaths from the buffoons Iraqi war of profit for the tiny few is definite and undeniable.

My water heater is always off, about 2 hours before we take showers I turn the heater on. .... now you gotta give me Love

Definitely ... Not only is that action commendable but it is a good idea . I'm glad to hear you're on board with conservation .

Always have been Petey.8.gif

Let me get this straight Petey, if Bush had not lied us into the Iraqi War then the vital flow of oil to the United States would have stopped. Sorry Petey I don't buy that, it's obvious that it was a war for profit; human lives be dam-ed. .... Sorry to disturb your theory but there was no danger of an oil stoppage if Bush had not lied us into a war with Iraq

You seem to have a very provincial view of markets .

Things aren't always what they seem Petey; as in this instance.

Oil is a global market .

Do tell .... golly gee Petey,... I didn't know that.

The US is the only country powerful enough to protect that market .

Waging unnecessary wars to benefit the Greedy Few is a stupid way to use that power and ultimately counter productive, with the inevitableblow back sure to come when ever power is miss-used.

Are you saying that disruptions are unimportant when they affect Europe ?

No. You're saying that.

That does not sound very moral to me .

Yeah but what does that have to do with what I've said?

Where is your concern for human life ?

Haven't you been reading my responses? I've been expressing my outrage and disgust about the Criminal War for profit that Buffoon Bush and Dick Chee -nee engineered.

And again the war in Iraq was not about the flow of oil . it was about making money from the misery and death of human-beings.

Doesn't matter how many times you say it .

It will still be correct.

Prove it .

Let's see now.... Bush lied, Thousands died, a tiny few made tens of billions of dollars from monies borrowed from China, that the tax payers are now on the hook for.... all facts that prove my argument correct about the moral depravity that results from greed and war profiteering.

In fact prove that it was NOT about the flow of oil since that is the topic of this article .

Greed for profit is what drives the flow of oil, if there is no money in it; then the Oil Corporations wouldn't even exist in the form that they exist in today.

Those are the obvious and elementary facts of the case.

You repeated the same depraved philosophy of money and things matter more then human-beings

I am going to ignore your attack since it is clear you are operating under a fallacious world view .

The philosophy of greed and money at all cost no matter who it hurts is a deprave philosophy drug dealers, and criminals of all kinds use itand corrupt politicians like the Buffoon and his master Dick Chee- nee use it.

And I will continue to point that fact out.

Why you chose to take it personal is your choice, it was never meant that way.

But I will never stop telling the truth just because you chose to be offended. Iffacts offend you then don't post to me because that is what I will continue to do, state the facts as I understand them.

And my understanding is that lying us intoan unnecessary criminal war for profit is :
"morally depraved"

Those who attempt to deny the laws of physics and economics are _____ [fill in your own pejorative here] .

Again what does that have to do with what I've been saying?

Those that attempt to deny the moral considerations of illegal criminal acts by Government and Corporations are wrong headed.

The lack of moral consideration that you are advocating for is the same mind set of a drug dealer or a merchant of child pornography, the people who run those kinds of business's are not concerned with morality or who they are hurting. All they care about is making money that is all.

Not me . All I care about is the energy markets .

The point that I was making was that you don't think it is important to consider the suffering and death of your fellow human-beings because of the mean actions and behavior's of a greedy few who profit from death and suffering as was the case in the buffoons war for profit in Iraq.

Our entire civilization is dependent on energy getting to where it is needed .

That is obvious, we live in a petroleum based economy.

If it doesn't people die .

Killing people who have done us no harm in pre-emptive wars of aggression as happened when Buffoon Bush unleashed the US military on Iraq is a stupid and immoral and ultimately self-defeating way in which to protect the vital flow of oil.

But I guess your "morality" doesn't cover those .

The Buffoons criminal war against the Iraqi people was not necessary to keep people from dying, it has long been established that Iraq posed no immediate pending threat to America when the Buffoon decided to invade and occupy Iraq. But as a result of his depraved miss-use of power we are less safe and more people died then would have been the case otherwise if he had not abused the military in an unnecessary war for profits.

Now who's expressing depravity ...

????

So tell me Petey when oil is "obtained" is any profit made?

Yup . That is the capitalist way .

Exactly and excessive greed for profit is what drove buffoon Bush and his neo-con henchmen to engineer the Iraqi war for profitresulting inthe destruction of tens of thousands of innocent human-beings.

You can call it immoral or depraved all you want but I think that makes you extremely naive .

I call it as I see it; and I see the murder of innocent human-beings, for the profit of a tiny few as morally depraved.

Profits are what makes our system run .

Corruption and excessive greed for profit is what makes disasters like the war in Iraq happen.

Without them there would be no economy , jobs etc .

Excessive greed for profit is what degrades the economy, when wages are stagnant and excessive profiteering puts most of the nations monies in the hands ofthe few well connected super-rich.

I have every right to complain about war for oil .

Sure you do . Tilting against windmills seems to be your forte , Don Q .

Your perceptions are skewed.

One more thing . Forming a democracy seems to inevitably result in conflict and death .

It seems that way doesn't it, but sometimes it might not if people don't blindly accept the inevitability concept,and abandon the worthy effort oftrying to change the way things are done.

That is what was attempted [unsuccessfully ] in Iraq .

Iraq was about making a lot of money for the few at the expense of the many. Dick Chee- nee and his Buffoon Puppet : George Bush , didn't give a crap about Democracy or the Iraqi people or even the American Military for that matter.

I think it was an experiment worth trying . It was partially successful .

The Buffoons Iraqi Warwas not about trying an experiment in nation building, it was about the rank miss-use of our military power for the profiteering war mongers and the Giant Oil Corporations.

 
 
 
Petey Coober
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Petey Coober    13 years ago

Then why are you here ?

 
 
 
Petey Coober
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Petey Coober    13 years ago

And the undeniable result of the American Civil War was that Slavery as an institution of society was ended, and millions were freed.

Although that is true it was not what the civil war was fought over . It was to decide which economic system was to be in power , an agriculturally based one or a manufacturing based one .

then we would still have Government sanctioned slavery, instead of Slavery being against the law and contrary to the founding principals of our Constitution.

I don't know where you got the idea that slavery was unconstitutional . IIRC slaves were counted as some fraction of a freeman in census counts . BTW you seem to be implying that slavery is ended in the world . Its not . Africa still exports slaves , lots of them .

I guess you can consider the facts of the case"melodramatic" but my acknowledgement and expression of those facts are not "melodramatic" in themselves; it is instead a truthful accounting of the facts.

Your accounting lacks proper comparison to the alternative . Leaving S Hussein in power would also have resulted in many deaths . And it would have suppressed the kurds . They are now free to pursue a free market economy .We have some new allies in that region . That is a real + .

Any comments by me or you or anyone else about the potential deaths or non-deaths, from oil flow interruption would be speculative and not factual.

There are historical examples to point to . They are not pretty .

But I will never stop telling the truth

I'm guessing you are fairly young . Only a youngster would say something like that ... especially with such a narrow focus .

Again what does that have to do with what I've been saying?

Seriously ? To me the connection is obvious . If you just get off your soapbox for a minute and take a broader view you might see the connection .

Killing people who have done us no harm in pre-emptive wars of aggression as happened when Buffoon Bush unleashed the US military on Iraq is a stupid and immoral and ultimately self-defeating way in which to protect the vital flow of oil.

Yeah ... welcome to the petroleum economy . That is how the real world works . Guess what . No matter how much ranting about immorality you or your group wail about , obtaining oil will continue and at the cost of human lives if necessary . As I said before history demonstrates what happens when oil is contested . People get killed , period . The fact that you choose to ignore history is not my problem . I suppose you know what Santayana had to say about that . One more thing ... since you are so "moral" why don't you come up with a non-deadly way to protect the flow of oil ...

excessive greed for profit is what drove buffoon Bush and his neo-con henchmen to engineer the Iraqi war for profit resulting in the destruction of tens of thousands of innocent human-beings.
....
The Buffoons Iraqi War was not about trying an experiment in nation building, it was about the rank miss-use of our military power for the profiteering war mongers and the Giant Oil Corporations.

I don't think you have any idea what drove Bush . Do you know what drove his father to start the first gulf war ?
Try learning some history before you spout off again . Remember what Santayana said .

 
 
 
brightstarone
Freshman Silent
link   brightstarone    13 years ago

DMT regarding post:

such hatered towards President Bush my my.

Yeah I don't like sHitler or Stalin or any other war criminal so your point was.....?

FDR and Truman killed more innocent people.

Uh huh.... so what does that have to do with the topic in discussion :

Why was it that we got involved in Iraq ?

Carpet bombing of cities to bring governments down and the use of the Abomb. Against innocent people. Not against the government nor their armies but civilians.

Do you have anymore un-startling information to share, Captain Obvious?

This was not criminal?

I believe it was, what do you think?105.gif

Where is the outrage?

What are you talking about; what is the context of your question?

I see it wasn't during your life time.

You don't know me personally and you only know some of my opinions from what ever postings of mine that you have read. So why do you make ignorant statements about what was or was not inmy life time?

You're making blind assumptions about some one you've never even met.

What's up with that DMT?106.gif

Wars are hell ....

Yeah thanks again Captain Obvious.

.... wars will always be fought...

Maybe they will or maybe they won't time will tell if humanity can evolve beyond its meanbeginnings, so I will not accept your opinion as the finale judgment.

....and many innocent people will die during war.

Captain Obvious strikes again.41.gif

The reasons for war are irrelevent.

That makes no sense what so ever, it doesn't matter why we go to war? You think that is irrelevant? That is a strange nonsense statement.

Btw- Is there a point to your post?

No offense but I gotta tell ya, so far I'm not see'in it.

Wars will always be.

Yeah like Isaidtime will tell how humanity evolves,I don't accept your absolute declarations about the future conduct of humanity.

Even Armageddon is gonna be a war.

What ever.

  • Petey Coober regarding your reply:

And the undeniable result of the American Civil War was that Slavery as an institution of society was ended, and millions were freed.

Although that is true it was not what the civil war was fought over . It was to decide which economic system was to be in power , an agriculturally based one or a manufacturing based one .

So you're trying to sell the idea that Slavery was not the pre-eminent reason for the American Civil War, it was over economic systems ...what's the other one .... oh yeah "States Rights" I don't buy that because I know that Slavery was the main engine that drove that war, revisionist history not withstanding.

then we would still have Government sanctioned slavery, instead of Slavery being against the law and contrary to the founding principals of our Constitution.

I don't know where you got the idea that slavery was unconstitutional . IIRC slaves were counted as some fraction of a freeman in census counts .

Oh I see so it was not unconstitutional and that is why it was outlawed because it was Constitutional. Yeah you make a lot of sense Petey.

BTW you seem to be implying that slavery is ended in the world . Its not . Africa still exports slaves , lots of them .

Your perceptions of my seeming implications are incorrect.68.gif

I guess you can consider the facts of the case"melodramatic" but my acknowledgement and expression of those facts are not "melodramatic" in themselves; it is instead a truthful accounting of the facts.

Your accounting lacks proper comparison to the alternative .

Proper to your narrative but not necessarily to the facts.

Leaving S Hussein in power would also have resulted in many deaths .

Yeah Hussein was always having people killed, but I don't believe that he would have killed the tens of thousands that Buffoon Bush's Criminal war killed.

And it would have suppressed the kurds . They are now free to pursue a free market economy .

That is nice but that was not the reason that Buffoon Bush sent the US military to invade Iraq.

We have some new allies in that region . That is a real + .

Besides the Kurds, who are these many allies that you imply we now have?

Any comments by me or you or anyone else about the potential deaths or non-deaths, from oil flow interruption would be speculative and not factual.

There are historical examples to point to . They are not pretty .

I'm sure you can dredge up some historical comparisons that support your argument; if you present it in a way that has a false equivalency, that supports your argument.

But I will never stop telling the truth

I'm guessing you are fairly young .

Yeah you're right your guessing, incorrectly; just as you guessed that I drove around in a big SUV and that I was not pro-active in my conservation habits at home..... maybe you should stop guessing and in that way you would not be so wrong so much of the time.Grin.gif

Only a youngster would say something like that ... especially with such a narrow focus .

Only a foolish person makes absolute conclusions about a stranger, with out anything to go by except to make self-serving conclusions that support a weak incorrect argument.

Again what does that have to do with what I've been saying?

Seriously ? To me the connection is obvious .

I'm sure it is to you Petey. But to me it is sounds like a false equivalency to support a weak argument.

If you just get off your soapbox for a minute and take a broader view you might see the connection .

Oh I see Petey, the reason I disagree with your incorrect point of view is because I'm on a "soap box" .......

No.

The reason I disagree with your incorrect point of view is because it is incorrect and so I disagree. You can understand how that works can't you Petey?

Killing people who have done us no harm in pre-emptive wars of aggression as happened when Buffoon Bush unleashed the US military on Iraq is a stupid and immoral and ultimately self-defeating way in which to protect the vital flow of oil.

Yeah ... welcome to the petroleum economy . That is how the real world works .

Yes and that is exactly what needs to change, using the military in every instance for oil will be self defeating in the end, and it will not benefit anyone in the long run.

Guess what . No matter how much ranting about immorality you or your group wail about ,

What group would that be Petey? I've been expressing my opinions to you on this website, so what is this group?

And to be clear I have been expressing myself, your miss-characterizing it as "wailing" does not make your incorrect argument for depraved immorality correct.

obtaining oil will continue and at the cost of human lives if necessary . As I said before history demonstrates what happens when oil is contested . People get killed , period . The fact that you choose to ignore history is not my problem .

Your problem is that you expect me to accept your philosophy of deprave morality to be the absolute and only way to do things and I don't believe that for a minuet.

I suppose you know what Santayana had to say about that .

I have no idea what that reference means.

One more thing ... since you are so "moral" why don't you come up with a non-deadly way to protect the flow of oil ...

Hey how about trying diplomacy ... you know reaching an accommodation, cutting a deal, taking out and regulating oil speculation ... I'm not even an expert but I know that the imagination and creativity of the human mind can come up with something better then a morally depraved philosophy of blood for oil.

excessive greed for profit is what drove buffoon Bush and his neo-con henchmen to engineer the Iraqi war for profit resulting in the destruction of tens of thousands of innocent human-beings. .... The Buffoons Iraqi War was not about trying an experiment in nation building, it was about the rank miss-use of our military power for the profiteering war mongers and the Giant Oil Corporations.

I don't think you have any idea what drove Bush .

Yeah he lied us into an unnecessary war for profit to benefit his Corporate buddies ... Haliburton - KBR - the Oil Corporations - military contractors...etc

It certainly wasn't because Iraq was an imminent threat to us or because there were weapons of mass destruction.

Do you know what drove his father to start the first gulf war ?

The invasion of Ku-wait.

Try learning some history before you spout off again .

Your speculation about my knowledge of history is irrelevant, you are uncomfortable with my challenge and disagreement with your philosophy of depraved morality for profit, and so you dismiss my points with the self-serving claim that I must not know history.

Yes I know me some historyPeteyand from my understanding and knowledge of history I can easily tell that your advocacy for the philosophy of depraved morality is flawed, incorrect and short sighted.

Remember what Santayana said .

I don't understand the context of that reference.

 
 
 
Petey Coober
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Petey Coober    13 years ago

To present my side of course.

But your "side" is absurd . Anyone with half a brain would immediately see through this :

Obviously Imperialism is when we force our ideas and ideals on a different country

Clearly you are making this up as you go along . Find me one more NTer who agrees with that contorted mess of distorted facts . And when you do lets see them support it in reply . Your fiction won't fly anywhere except in your head .

 
 
 
Petey Coober
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Petey Coober    13 years ago

I know that Slavery was the main engine that drove that war,

Your simplistic view of the world is consistent even though highly incomplete .
If the 2 sides in the civil war were agreed on which system of economics would take precedence the war would NOT have happened irregardless of slavery .

Oh I see so it was not unconstitutional and that is why it was outlawed because it was Constitutional. Yeah you make a lot of sense Petey.

The interpretation of the constitution frequently changes . Are you denying that slavery was a facet of the original constitution ? Your ignorance of history is becoming too obvious .

That is nice but that was not the reason that Buffoon Bush sent the US military to invade Iraq.

You don't know what Bush's motivations were . The fact that you can't identify the motives of a "buffoon" says something unflattering about you .

Besides the Kurds, who are these many allies that you imply we now have?

The kurds are many in number .

I'm sure you can dredge up some historical comparisons that support your argument;

What you have just said is that you have NO interest in reading the other side of this . This is NOT communication . It is just spewing of propaganda again & again & again .

Yeah you're right your guessing, incorrectly

I'm sorry to hear you are not a youngster . Only a foolish adult would take such flights of fancy from the real world .
You live in a capitalist society but reject its main premise . You live in a petroleum economy but consider its functioning to be immoral . Why don't you go somewhere else ? I'm sure you can find a socialist country that will take you in . Doing without oil might be harder but it is not impossible . I think the Palestine territory gets by with very little petroleum products largely because their neighbors are afraid they will use it to construct bombs .
Have fun there . Write me about your experiences .

The reason I disagree with your incorrect point of view is because it is incorrect and so I disagree. You can understand how that works can't you Petey?

I understand that your head is in some cloud that few can see but you . This convo has turned into nothing of value . You spew your idealistic propaganda under the mistaken idea that you have a greater sense of morality than others . You have certainly not converted me , nor will you . Your "morality" is so unrealistic as to be a joke .

Yes and that is exactly what needs to change

Yes it does . But YOU are not going to change it . All you are doing is endlessly bitching about a product you are as addicted to as the rest of us . Cursing at your addiction does not make it go away . Likewise denigrating those of us who realize the system we are in does not help . People will change when they have opportunities to do so . Driving an electric vehicle would . I notice you did not comment on the following article . It presents a real alternative to petroleum .

If you are so opposed to the use of petroleum why don't you comment or maybe even write your own material about the alternatives ? And the ugly answer is because you like to bitch . You enjoy shoving your meaningless morality in others faces . You are not more moral . You are merely more obnoxious .

I have no idea what that reference means.

And you are not going to find out from me . Google it . Lets see you do some work instead of some bitching and taking a holier-than-thou attitude .

I know that the imagination and creativity of the human mind can come up with something better then a morally depraved philosophy of blood for oil.

Thas nice . Why don't you do it ? But don't do it here . I've had enough from you . I'm closing comments . Write your own article . Go bitch to yourself for a while . Oh , that's right .. you don't write articles . You just bitch in other peoples articles . Go away .

Comments closed . I get the last word .

 
 

Who is online


CB


113 visitors