╌>

Those Who Ducked My First Set of Questions -- Here's Another You'll Likely Evade

  

Category:  News & Politics

Via:  a-macarthur  •  13 years ago  •  113 comments

Those Who Ducked My First Set of Questions -- Here's Another You'll Likely Evade

Zimmerman Juror Looks to Cash in With Book Deal

Martin Literary Management announced this morning that it has signed the so-far anonymous Zimmerman juror and her husband, a lawyer , in pursuit of a book deal. No word yet on the cable-TV movie. Literary agent Sharlene Martin explained her aspirations: My hope is that people will read Juror B37s book, written with her attorney husband, and understand the commitment it takes to serve and be sequestered on a jury in a highly publicized murder trial and how important, despite ones personal viewpoints, it is to follow the letter of the law.

http://www.businessweek.com/articles/2013-07-15/george-zimmerman-juror-looks-to-cash-in-with-book-deal

"HER HUSBAND, A LAWYER?"

REALLY?

1. IS SHE A RESIDENT OF SANFORD?

2. DID SHE OR HER HUSBAND KNOW/HAVE PRIOR SOCIAL, PROFESSIONAL OR OTHER CONNECTIONS TO EITHER OF ZIMMERMAN'S DEFENSE ATTORNEYS PRIOR TO JURY SELECTION?

3. IF SO, HOW'D SHE WIND UP AS A JUROR?

I'm just asking about this, especially on behalf of all you JUSTICE LOVERS out there. If there's a verifiable "yes" to questions 1 & 2, then we're all entitled to the answer to question 3 (unless the word "mistrial" has caused you to perspire).

Inquiring minds want to know. I'll be sharing any/all related information I deem reliable.

And please, no O.J. Simpson references or pissin' contests tallying up the number of black-on-black crimes, black-on-white-crimes, or, if you can't help yourself (as long as you count LYNCHINGS and the number of African slaves that died in service to Massa) white-on-black-crimes.


Tags

jrDiscussion - desc
[]
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   seeder  A. Macarthur    13 years ago

Earlier today, a number of justice-loving, fact-demanding bull dogs-for-fairness-and-full-disclosure, ducked a few questions I had (and still have).

So, I figured WTF, and came up with a few more questions for the Queepy-ass Quackers to duck.

I am proud to be the pain-in-the-ass I am.

Just answer the f'n questions (which I don't think anyone here can do at this time) or, admit they are, if nothing else, f'n intriguing!

 
 
 
CM
Freshman Silent
link   CM    13 years ago

Juror B37 (bookie dealer) was on the news tonight, she said it was important to explain what went on in the jury room and why they came up with that not guilty verdict...they cried, boohoohoo, they wanted to give Zimmerman guilty of something but it was just not possible..If these Jurors were sequestered, when did her husband and juror # B37 sign their book deal? think maybe before she went on that jury duty she sealed the deal?? maybe she already knew how she would be voting...

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   seeder  A. Macarthur    13 years ago

when did her husband and juror # B37 sign their book deal?

Oh my another question.

Won't it be interesting to find out ('course the publisher might be tempted to "modify" the time frame should it be compromising).

 
 
 
CM
Freshman Silent
link   CM    13 years ago

That's the $million question Mike, guess her husband signed that deal while she was serving or something of the sort..

 
 
 
Kavika
Professor Expert
link   Kavika     13 years ago

Something really stinks here Mac.

I've been called to jury duty in both California and Nevada. Each time that I've been selected for the jury, the attorney's ask you a series of question. EACH and EVERY time they ask if you have any connection to law enforcement. Husband etc etc. They ask if you are an attorney, related to an attorney, work with attorney's, etc etc. Each time I answered in the affirmative, since I had appeared a number of times as an ''Expert Witness'' and have been certified as an expert in my field more than 20 times. Each time that I answered the question, I was excused from the jury pool.

She and her husband signed the deal!!!! How long has this been in the planning? Before the trial started? When was it signed?

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   seeder  A. Macarthur    13 years ago

Don't despair, you may still have the shiniest hat.

Jurors are interviewed and smart ones can say things they know will not adversely prejudice either the prosecution or the defense they can appear both neutral and objective. If one side or the other is in on it, the prospective juror must only fool the one that's not.

We don't now know the juror's name it's true, but we already know that her husband's a lawyer and there's a book deal -- and even if that's a bullshit diversion, someone will get to the name and way beyond that. Book signings in the offing, tv/radio interviews?

It's only a matter of time my friend -- your hat status appears, at least for the moment, to light up the night.

 
 
 
CM
Freshman Silent
link   CM    13 years ago

I have been relieved from service by telling the judge and attorneys while been interviewed that I hated guns, even if the person charged didn't fire the gun as long as they had a gun I think they should go to prison, I told them only law enforcement should have the right to carry a gun...dismissed!!!!

 
 
 
CM
Freshman Silent
link   CM    13 years ago

Its not fair, I am laughing too hard..LMAO!!!!

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   seeder  A. Macarthur    13 years ago

Mike, your kids are adorable! Thanks for sharing.

Didn't I see you on Saturday Night Live years ago?

Funny, you don't look like you're from Meepzor in your other photos.

 
 
 
CM
Freshman Silent
link   CM    13 years ago

Mike I luv ya also, I live in NY, we are not a State of gun carrying people, Now, some people should not have a gun, I had one when I lived in Texas but I do not like them...so...yea i vote and serve on a Jury, what's the fascination with blowing up things??

That has to be the most radicalstatement I've everheard in my entire life

If you lived in NY maybe you would change that statement, look, I feel safe wherever I go, I just do not see the necessity, now, If there were dangerous animals, snakes, bears etc. then I could see it and do not laugh at the things you do not understand, just learn about the differences.. my suggestion..

 
 
 
CM
Freshman Silent
link   CM    13 years ago

I do understand Mike, if I lived in Georgia as you do, I am sure I would have to carry a weapon out of necessity and the culture of the people of that State but here in NY it is not necessary, we have a subway system that carries 5million people back and forth every day with very little incidents or none at all, that does not include the bus systems and other modes of transportation, when I lived in Texas it was sometimes scary to travel on the freeways because someone may decide to shoot you, so, I am saying, it is pretty much safe to live here, I must give credit to Guilliani for cleaning up the city and breaking the backs of the "Mafioso crime families."

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   seeder  A. Macarthur    13 years ago

I don't appreciate being mocked and or misrepresented.

Feel free to debate, refute, debunk with factual counter-points, but once you mock me and try to ridicule, you've admitted you're not able to gain the high ground in a serious discussion.

If in fact THE JUROR HAS CHANGED HER MIND AND WILL NOT BE WRITING A BOOK, that implies that I'm not alone in questioning a trial and a law and the would-be profiteering from a tragedy. Doubtless we'll learn more about the juror's original plan and, her reason for dropping it.

A can of worms has been opened and beneath the worms, who knows what slime will be found and biopsied.

 
 
 
ArkansasHermit
Freshman Silent
link   ArkansasHermit    13 years ago

Juror B37 was also the one who,(during her voir dire), several times described the actions of those who questioned the fact that Zimmerman wasn't even going to have to explain his killing of a child in court as "Riots" instead of the peaceful protest that they actually were.

 
 
 
Len
Freshman Silent
link   Len    13 years ago

The reason women were selected is t6hat the prosecutors considered them more likely to convict Zimmerman than male jurors.

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   seeder  A. Macarthur    13 years ago

Len,

It's not about the gender-verdict-likelihood, it's about how this particular juror was both called and subsequently selected and, the details of the book deal.

 
 
 
sixpick
Professor Quiet
link   sixpick    13 years ago

Well A Mac... Your link isn't working in your article. Do you think they trying to escape a law suit as well. Since ABC and NBC are facing lawsuits for defamation of character.

You know the part where the video of Zimmerman got out of the car at the police station appearing to have no damage to the back of his head, not even the band aid that was put on him. They had to admit they edited the video. Do you think they should suffer consequence for doing so?

And the edited audio leaving out the question from the 911 operator which aired by NBC I believe without the question in it. This is something that has witnesses. Do you think they should suffer consequences for doing so?

And if you could provide a link showing without a shadow of a doubt the juror's husband is a lawyer, that would be nice as well. I haven't researched this very much.

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   seeder  A. Macarthur    13 years ago

Mike,

Yesterday the book deal was real, so your question, in its time frame was invalid. Ultimately and in retrospect, you may be shown to have been dead-on in your skepticism. To my knowledge, the juror has not declared that the original story was bogus, only that she has changed her mind. If she does yell "foul/bogus" then I will gladly give you kudos for your insight provided that claim is truthful.

 
 
 
JoAnne Odel
Freshman Silent
link   JoAnne Odel    13 years ago

want to follow the real money?

check out the sharpton bunch for the next few months. the "reverend" and the rest of the racism peddlers will have carpet bags in hand, and do their very best to profit off fear and hate.

just like they always do.

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   seeder  A. Macarthur    13 years ago

And the edited audio leaving out the question from the 911 operator which aired by NBC I believe without the question in it. This is something that has witnesses. Do you think they should suffer consequences for doing so?

And if you could provide a link showing without a shadow of a doubt the juror's husband is a lawyer, that would be nice as well. I haven't researched this very much.

The link worked when it was posted; you may be quite right presuming that Business Week removed its article for fear of litigation. I'll look for another.

If NBC or Breitbart or any entity intentionally edits a video to exclude relevant information, it needs to be called out and address any/all allegations. You and I agree.

Regarding Zimmerman's injuries -- we still saw the injury photos and there are still questions as to how the injuries were acquired; recall the distance of Martin's body from the concrete sidewalk and the absence of Zimmerman's blood on Martin's hands.

Here's a link that should satisfy your request

George Zimmerman juror nixes plans to write a book


Read more: ...

FOX NEWS!

And here's another -- it may be that an incredulous public (via Twitter) got its point out there; if so, more of the same may ultimately get answers to the questions not answered during the trial -- the truth in other words.

Zimmerman Juror B37's book deal squashed by Twitter's Cocky McSwagsalot Tuesday, July 16, 2013, 10:01 AM Mike Bertha
Read more at ...

It appears I'm not the only gadfly in America. And there will be others and there will be the exposition of truth as a result.

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   seeder  A. Macarthur    13 years ago

When?

Likely sooner than when you're willing to accept anything other than what you choose to believe beyond that

6337_discussions.jpg

 
 
 
Spikegary
Junior Quiet
link   Spikegary    13 years ago

Well, you've gone from "he will be Convicted" to 'the Fix must've been in' in record time.

Do you think book agents and publishers sleep on weekends when there's something this big in the offing? Why do you automatically assume it was done 'before' not 'after'? Have you even the tiniest shred of proof?

When you're wrong, you are wrong, as you were in your predictions. Now, in New York, no one is excused form jury duty sutomatically, including lawyers, doctors, etc. This woman has the bad taste to be married to a lawyer. That should disqualify her? She was sequestered, so what instructions did she get form her husband? Or could she just be an opportunist that was ready for the 'rush' once the jury was dismissed?

The tin foil hat metaphor certainly works in this case.

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   seeder  A. Macarthur    13 years ago

Robert G,

I, being used to an environment populated by articulate professionals, understand why you tend to mock and ridicule that in which your are neither qualified nor intellectually suited to participate, and, those who dwarf you.

Mockery is often the result of a poverty of wit.

Jean de la Bruyre

 
 
 
Spikegary
Junior Quiet
link   Spikegary    13 years ago

IYHO. The prosecutor and the defense both had the opportunity to strike her from the list. And she fooled both of these marvelous legal teams? Please.

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   seeder  A. Macarthur    13 years ago

Thanks for being open minded to that Mac.

Right-is-right, Mike.

I believe that the juror story is only the beginning of a giant can of worms from which they'll crawl and reveal a layer of slimy revelations.

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   seeder  A. Macarthur    13 years ago

You think?

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   seeder  A. Macarthur    13 years ago

More personal stuff Robert G?

Go wash off the vomit

Then return in a clean undershirt and continue to validate that which caused you to spew not only the usual venom, but apparently lunch as well.

Multi-tasker Robert G.

 
 
 
Spikegary
Junior Quiet
link   Spikegary    13 years ago

BTW, there's a whole lot of NY that is not NYC and there are lots of Wild Animals outside of the city. New York is a vast place with mountains, lakes, forests, etc. And yes, there are dangerous things out there and with our government's clumsy way of re-populating certain animal populations, the dangers are increasing.

 
 
 
Spikegary
Junior Quiet
link   Spikegary    13 years ago

Or maybe there is none there, which would puncture a few people's balloon.

 
 
 
Spikegary
Junior Quiet
link   Spikegary    13 years ago

And you didn't get personal with him, A Mac? Stones/glass houses and all.

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   seeder  A. Macarthur    13 years ago

Whether Corey withheld evidence or not, let's STILL COMPARE her sentence with those who walk free while having actually done more harm.

If she i.e. perjured herself, that added to the mix doesn't reasonably add up to 20 years. And I ask again, if Zimmerman stood his ground, how wasn't Corey entitled to "Castle Doctrine"?

Mike, can you post a link to the "withholding evidence" information?

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   seeder  A. Macarthur    13 years ago

I notice you failed to admonish the aggressor.

Consistent and ironic.

Hey, Spikegary, I was merely STANDING MY GROUND against the guy that got out of his vehicle and confronted me.

 
 
 
Spikegary
Junior Quiet
link   Spikegary    13 years ago

You are going toe-to-toe right along with him. Who started it? Who finishes it? Pride. Nothing more. You're supposed to be a moderator on this site. Try acting like it.

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   seeder  A. Macarthur    13 years ago

You're supposed to be a moderator on this site. Try acting like it.

Moderators don't moderate their own articles. Learn the particulars before you choke on your shoe.

But, if ya' wanna' get technical, your client, Robert G. skirts the CoC for a living.

And it seems my "stand your ground defense" flew past you despite its ironic brilliance.

Make your case, Spikegary -- rebut my content on a point counter-point basis if you can; I'll respect that. But stay out of other members' pissin' contests.

Third man in.

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   seeder  A. Macarthur    13 years ago

It's not pride for me. It's pointing out a bigot's view of justice. And pointing out a fool's view of racism.

How could it be pride? That would imply that there was something of which to be proud? Still, I'm encouraged to see you on the verge of self-awareness.

Atta'-guy.

Where you ignore the hundreds of murders in your city, and screech about a killing in Florida, for a year, because a death only counts if it involves a white suspect.

REDUNDANT ROBERT REITERATION

I've responded to that every time you've used it as a dodge for addressing the issue we've been discussing.

Look up my answer(s).

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   seeder  A. Macarthur    13 years ago

Suz,

I am part Bulldog myself, and, for the record, you are one of my all-time favorites on the World Wide Web.

 
 
 
screminmimi
Freshman Silent
link   screminmimi    13 years ago

Your comments to me yesterday left me with a lot to face about my own feelings.

When I was 16 and my sister 15, at the height of the civil rights movement, I drove to a local country store around 8:00 one night to get milk and coffee for my Dad's breakfast... just my sister, me, and Rowdy, our German Shepherd, who was quietly laying down in the back seat of the car.

Eight black teens were lounging all over a vehicle parked in front of the store. It didn't worry us at all; we knew them, went to school with them, had no problems with them. As we stopped the car, their vehicle being on the passenger side, one guy said, "I want me some of that" and started toward Sarah's door. I had left the driver's side and reached the left headlight and froze in my tracks.

Sarah clicked the door handle, drew the knife from her boot and when the guy reached for the door she flung it open and knocked him to the ground just as the others were moving toward us. One was already in front of the car almost in arm's reach of me when I drew my knife.

Sarah stood over the one she knocked down and told him if he moved she would cut him like a can of sourkraut just as I yelled "Rowdy!" and the dog leaped from his sleeping dreams with a roar and hit the window in the back that was slightly down and cracked it. The other guys ran for their vehicle and piled in slamming doors and locking them. The one under Sarah's knife and mine were frozen with shock. We made them back up to the car and get in and leave. (Sarah made her guy crab walk back.)

An experience like that colors your perspective. I was terrified for my sister, furious that classmates accosted us for no reason, and knew that the only thing that saved us was a dog whose breed had a reputation for being used to intimidate black Americans. (We had had German Shepherds all my life.)

Mac, you are trying so hard to have us all look at Treyvon as an individual. And we should; if we could, we might all be able to view this case in the light of the tragic death of a young boy who should not have died as he did.

But the black community won't allow us to see Treyvon as an individual. They have taken him and elevated him as a symbol of black youth nation wide, while at the same time telling us NOT to view him as a symbol of black youth who have made negative headlines and impacts.

If they would shut up and allow us to just look at the case on its merits alone we might be able to get past all the other junk clouding the issues.

For my part, I'm sorry that past experiences have made me someone unfit to contribute objectively to your column. I value your friendship and apologize for the situation. I understand the irony as I am so rabid about prejudice and racism directed at Indians. And I have a half black great grandchild who is very precious to me and.... wait for it... I have many black friends I am close to.

I haven't considered myself a racist but I must now entertain the certain possibility and deal with it. I'm hoping you remain my friend as I work through the quagmire.

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   seeder  A. Macarthur    13 years ago

screminmimi,

I certainly can understand how a direct, personal experience can color (pun intended and not intended) one's opinion in the long and short term. But if you think about it, consider those with negative views towards a particular demographic and ask yourself, "what proportion of those individuals had an experience like mine, and what proportion merely assimilated its negative feelings through repeated stereotyping and propaganda?"

If one never had a direct encounter, positive or negative, with a demagogued population, but nevertheless spews and feels all sorts of profile-type venom towards that population, from whence does it arise?

What did I do in my articles to generate such outpourings? I MERELY ASKED SIGNIFICANT QUESTIONS ABOUT A SITUATION THE LED TO THE DEATH OF A YOUNG MAN; THAT'S IT! I ASKED QUESTIONS AND MADE IT MORE THAN CLEAR AS TO BOTH THEIR YET UNANSWERED STATUS AND MY CURIOSITY AS TO WHY. I ALSO POSITED WHAT I BELIEVE ARE PLAUSIBLE, POSSIBLE ANSWERS TO THE QUESTIONS OR LEFT THEM TO OTHERS TO ANSWER.

How many even tried? And how many came at me, not with simple "yes" or "no" or "I don't know" responses, rather with mockery and hateful, personal attacks?

I hit nerves did I not? And why?

I hit nerves that were wired to some deep-seated ugly, hateful feelings about black people.

Trayvon Martin apparently fit the profile of "nigger-in-a-hoodie-and-like-all-niggers-in-a-hoodie-he's-a-crime-waiting-to-happen-a-welfare-recipient-to-be", those and all the other bigoted-sloppy-brainless-lazy-ass "thoughts" sent out regularly by the purveyors of hate in this country. And one self-appointed WHITE-KNIGHT on a self-proclaimed mission -- "GOD's PLAN" he told Shaun Hannity -- put a bullet in that "nigger-in-a-hoodie-fuckin'-punkin-asshole-who-always-gets-away's heart

And 6 white gals from a town known for its racist issues ruled the WHITE-KNIGHT "not guilty," gave him back is gun and off he goes -- perhaps to further assist God in his grand objective of genocide.

Watch the juror post-trial interview and/or read the transcripts --

First hand information? I have more than most. I've lived in a major American city for 69 years, went to the public schools here (Philly) and taught no fewer than several thousand black boys and girls in some of the baddest neighborhoods imaginable. I broke up fights, took away knives and guns -- BUT I ALSO WATCHED NICE KIDS FROM CARING HOMES LEARN, STRUGGLE TO LEARN, bleed when they fell, cry when they were hurt or sad, win track meets, lose basketball games you know the way human beings do.

I taught in Philly's discipline school (the Daniel Boone School - since converted to apartments) - Light Heavyweight Matt Franklin (later Matthew Saad Muhammad) went to that school. Later in life I represented the man credited with helping establish the group BOYZ II MEN.

In spite of what the haters want us to believe, most black folk are not anything like an "n"-word in a hoodie.

Unlike the haters, I KNOW THE DIFFERENCE FIRST HAND BETWEEN WHAT THEY THINK EXISTS ALMOST WITHOUT EXCEPTION IN THE BLACK COMMUNITY AND WHAT'S REAL.

Do black kids murder each other at alarming rates, oh yes they do. Is it tragic and abominable - yes, it is. And do the bigoted frauds who somehow minimize the death of Trayvon Martin because it's just one and not 10,000 -- do they do shit to curb the number of illegal guns used in the preponderance of those thousands of killings?

I know the answer to that question.

Thanks for sharing your story screminmimi; it gives perspective and helps with the understanding of complicated reality.

 
 
 
Petey Coober
Freshman Silent
link   Petey Coober    13 years ago

perhaps to further assist God in his grand objective of genocide.

I'm glad you said perhaps because otherwise one might conclude you are delusional ...

In spite of what the haters want us to believe, most black folk are not anything like an "n"-word in a hoodie.

That's true . So why are you inflaming the situation so as to make it about race in their minds ?You have declared yourself judge & jury towards G. Zimmerman . The real jury declared him not guilty .The real judge released him from custody .

do they do shit to curb the number of illegal guns used in the preponderance of those thousands of killings?

That's one side of this issue which is , as always , the only impassioned side you look at .

 
 
 
One Miscreant
Professor Silent
link   One Miscreant    13 years ago

screminmimi and AMac sometimes we have to read through a lot of bullshit to find the enlighten response. Thanks.

A good friend of mine had lost his wife and we were on the backporch discussing life and how bad it had become. He always had a way of seeing things, even the bad, which forced many to love him. They met in a catholic school in east LA.When she died hundreds of people from that parish made the long trip, to the high desert area where they had moved, for her funeral. My friend looked at me and said, "There is hope for the world, when they drive that far to pay respects to their child's teacher."

About a year later, I attended his funeral, also a large gathering. Not only could I see what he meant, but I could feel it too. Any race issue 'feared the light of day' at that gathering. My friend and his wife would have none of it and neither would the rest of us.

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   seeder  A. Macarthur    13 years ago

OK.

Oh, it's a discussion where people, you know, discuss stuff.

If you really need me to answer your questions it's likely because you can't actually debate point-for-point.

No one needs you to distinguish between "the real jury" and post-trial questions regarding things like one juror's claim that she and the other jurors were confused by the standard complicated by Florida's SYG law.

Scholars, students, law professors and just plain folks will discuss every aspect of this and other landmark trials forevermore. Ever been to a law library?

Rather than criticize me for asking questions, explain why my questions are either factually ill-conceived or, be a help and give me the answers.

And when I place a qualifier in an opinion, you don't need to tell me stuff like I would have looked delusional if I hadn't, because I knew that or I wouldn't have added it.

Don't take oblique shots at me, just discuss the points.

 
 
 
Petey Coober
Freshman Silent
link   Petey Coober    13 years ago

Don't take oblique shots at me, just discuss the points.

OK , the points are that you are intending to inflame a situation . Every "point" you claim to be making by "innocently" asking questions were already asked by the sheriff of Sanford . His decisions about those issues got him fired . Likewise for the prosecutor deciding not to prosecute but he was overruled , not by the normal channels , but by the MSM inspired frenzy of faux racism .

The prosecution did not have a chance in this case because they simply didn't have a case . And so in an effort to appease the rabble whipped up by the MSM they forced it into the court system anyway wasting both tax payer dollars and the court's time . Now that due process has run its course instead of letting it go you continue to attempt to inflame the situation . Mighty brave of you . Do you actually think your mouth is going to protect you if the rabble really get roused up ?

 
 
 
Petey Coober
Freshman Silent
link   Petey Coober    13 years ago

Remember, this is the same prosecution team that got a black women sent up for 20 years for shooting a hole in her ceiling,

There are so many factual errors in that I am not even going to bother . Shrooms ?

Classic Florida justice.

Classic LA justices examples :

Journalist Assaulted By Trayvon Martin Protestors

 
 
 
Petey Coober
Freshman Silent
link   Petey Coober    13 years ago

Tell me if you're having fun at the riots ... uh I mean "demonstrations" .

Journalist Assaulted By Trayvon Martin Protestors

 
 
 
Perrie Halpern R.A.
Professor Guide
link   Perrie Halpern R.A.    13 years ago

OMG, what a waste of GB's. I am not sure if there was any on topic discussion, but a lot of mud throwing. I'm leaving it up as a reminder of what NOT to do.

 
 
 
JbBirder
Freshman Silent
link   JbBirder    13 years ago

I don't get it. Snakes and bears are not as dangerous as people. No way near.

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   seeder  A. Macarthur    13 years ago

Tell me if you're having fun at the riots ... uh I mean "demonstrations" .

Riots are most of the time, unforgivable; but not all demonstrations for peace or justice are "riots" -- and it's disingenuous to characterize them as such if they are not.

What fascinates me are the Tea Party types who feign disdain for so-called "riots" and conveniently factor out, the changes brought about by an act of civil disobedience back in Boston years ago -- there were even killings!

Don't be naive Petey -- demonstrations, riots, wars, beheadings -- all things that have historical meaning and which became courts-of-last-resorts when speaking truth to power wasn't, in-and-of-itself, enough to get 'er done.

 
 
 
Spikegary
Junior Quiet
link   Spikegary    13 years ago

Congratulating your self on what you call 'ironic brilliance'? Someone is full of themselves.

As to skirting the coc, you seem to be doing the same. Much like Democrats and Republicans-different sides of the same coin.

I understand you don't moderate your own articles, but wear a different pair of shoes and pretend it's not your article (if you can stifle your pride ofr a minute or two) and look at it with that set of glasses and see if you still see things the same way.

I have no clients-I'm not a lawyer, nor do I pretend to be one. I look at both your comments-and they look like you are just pissing on each other's leg, for no other reason than to be the alpha dog.

 
 
 
sixpick
Professor Quiet
link   sixpick    13 years ago

Well don't worry, we're going to get him one way or another. I ask though, How many cases can you remember where the accused is found "not guilty" and convicted later? Of course with the entire weight of the Federal Government with special emails accounts to report anything that can be found out in this world about Zimmerman under the Attorney General of Unjustice Eric Holder, (by the way why hasn't this guy been removed?) I'm sure they may find something, anything doesn't matter if it's true or not, just anything to get this guy. During the meantime maybe this would occupy some of your time.

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   seeder  A. Macarthur    13 years ago

How many cases can you remember where the accused is found "not guilty" and convicted later?

It is not unprecedented to have an individual found "not guilty" of a criminal charge, to subsequently be tried for i.e "Wrongful Death" and be found guilty. Probably the O.J. Simpson case is the best known, but it wasn't the only one by far.

 
 
 
JoAnne Odel
Freshman Silent
link   JoAnne Odel    13 years ago

apparently, on peirce morgan 360 recently, the star witness for the prosecution has admitted that zimmerman didnt realize trayvon was only giving him a "woopass". we have been able to also determine she was concerned that zimmerman was possibly going to rape trayvon, and any young male children in trayvon's home.

so baisically, we now know, that according to this star witness, zimmerman should have just accepted he was being beaten up, because martin thought it was likely zimmerman was a homosexual rapist.

now everything makes sense.

 
 
 
Petey Coober
Freshman Silent
link   Petey Coober    13 years ago

Don't be naive Petey

Right back atchya . If due process is no longer accepted then this is no longer a nation of law . It is then just anarchy. But keep on fanning the flames of the stupid rabble .

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   seeder  A. Macarthur    13 years ago

If due process is no longer accepted then this is no longer a nation of law

Ever heard the expression "Bad facts make bad law"?

Laws evolve at times and some are even repealed. You confuse the scholarly analysis and critiquing of trials and legal decisions as expressions of rejection when in fact, they represent the on-going dialogue of civilized societies being diligent and self-aware.

If you follow the juror interviews -- including those just emerging from other Zimmerman jurors, you'll see more-and-more how confusion due to the SYG statute created a verdict problem.

Even the Constitution provides for its own amending -- a manifestation of the Founding Fathers' awareness that as times may change, so may laws to be more suited to their time.

But keep on fanning the flames of the stupid rabble .

The "stupid rabble" is comprised of those who express zeal without knowledge.

 
 
 
Petey Coober
Freshman Silent
link   Petey Coober    13 years ago

The "stupid rabble" is comprised of those who express zeal without knowledge.

Right . For example :

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   seeder  A. Macarthur    13 years ago

You mean you didn't know that "being black is not a crime"?

That you fail to grasp the significance of the sign nor the despair of those who live it, tells me that you are part of the problem.

DO NOT ADDRESS NOR SPECULATE ABOUT ANYTHING OTHER THAN WHAT I WROTE HERE IN RESPONSE TO YOUR LINK.

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   seeder  A. Macarthur    13 years ago

now everything makes sense.

Not everything JoAnne.

 
 
 
Petey Coober
Freshman Silent
link   Petey Coober    13 years ago

You mean you didn't know that "being black is not a crime"?

Sure I did . But based on your ignoring the link I posted I have to assume you are willing to give a pass to blacks rioters just because they are black . That is blatant discrimination and a violation of the rule of law .

DO NOT ADDRESS NOR SPECULATE ABOUT ANYTHING OTHER THAN WHAT I WROTE HERE IN RESPONSE TO YOUR LINK.

Stop telling me what to do . I answered your comment and you refused to even look at my counter evidence .You have lost all credibility on this thread .

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   seeder  A. Macarthur    13 years ago

I am flattered.

Thank you, Suz -- I'm glad you're Bach.

(I sound like Ahhhhnold Schwarzenegger)

 
 
 
Petey Coober
Freshman Silent
link   Petey Coober    13 years ago

You OTOH have something in your brainz . Shrooms perhaps ?

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   seeder  A. Macarthur    13 years ago

I have another question:

IN FLORIDA, WHO DID GOVERNOR SCOTT PLACE IN CHARGE OF REVIEWING THE STAND YOUR GROUND STATUTE AFTER GEORGE ZIMMERMAN SHOT TO DEATH, TRAYVON MARTIN?

Answer that and we'll go to the next round of questions?

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   seeder  A. Macarthur    13 years ago

Chairwoman Lt. Gov. Jennifer Carroll

Well done, Mike in Ga. -- Carroll was placed in charge!

NEXT QUESTION -- WHAT HAPPENED WITH JENNIFER CARROLL AFTER SHE WAS APPOINTED BY GOVERNOR SCOTT?

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   seeder  A. Macarthur    13 years ago

Well done, Mike!

And the outcome of the review

Florida Stand-Your-Ground Task Force: No Law Changes

After all the post-Trayvon sturm und drang over Stand Your Ground laws remember how they were called a license to kill? Florida Governor Rick Scotts 19-member committee tasked with examining the law and making recommendations where necessary decided that the law is basically fine as it stands. miamiherald.com is reporting that, The task force made a handful of recommendations for the Legislature, but began the report by stating that, at its core, the self-defense law is fine as it is. All persons who are conducting themselves in a lawful manner have a fundamental right to stand their ground and defend themselves from attack with proportionate force in every place they have a lawful right to be, the report reads. . . .

Since you cant empanel a group like that an expect them to recommend nothing, they dutifully wrote up a few recommendations to justify their existence.

The groups recommendations included reconsidering the states 10-20-Life law, tightening standards for neighborhood watch groups and commissioning a study to look into issues of racial disparities and unintended consequences of Stand Your Ground.

And, shockingly, the fact that the Governors task force, chaired by Lt. Gov. Jennifer Carroll (above) didnt recommend shredding Floridas Stand Your Ground law didnt make everyone happy.

Its what I expected, said Sen. Chris Smith, D-Fort Lauderdale, told the News Service of Florida. When you put a task force together of people who wrote the bill and full of people who support Stand Your Ground I knew the task force wouldnt come up with anything earth-shattering in their final report.

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   seeder  A. Macarthur    13 years ago

OH -- AND NOW, THE REST OF THE STORY AND IMO, THIS IS JUST THE BEGINNING!

Zimmerman Jurors Slam Book-Deal Juror B37: Her Opinions Were Her Own

George Zimmerman Juror B37 Hates Media, Called Trayvon "Boy of Color"

A mere two days after finding George Zimmerman innocent of the murder of Trayvon Martin, juror B37 in the case has signed on with a prominent Read

Four of the six jurors from the George Zimmerman trial issued a statement Tuesday night, asking for privacy and explaining that the views of Juror B37 were hers alone and not representative of the rest of the jury.

Juror B37 wasted no time after the trial's end, signing with a book agent and appearing on Anderson Cooper's show just two days after helping to acquit Zimmerman. Thankfully, Twitter-generated public backlash to the book news caused Juror B37's book agent to "rescind her offer of representation" hours after the Cooper interview aired. The second half of B37's interview with Cooper aired Tuesday night.

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   seeder  A. Macarthur    13 years ago

Mike,

Consider yourself an inspiration!

 
 
 
Steve Ott
Professor Silent
link   Steve Ott    13 years ago

Jurors are interviewed and smart ones can say things they know will not adversely prejudice either the prosecution or the defense

Gotta laugh here. I've seen it done, by my ex-mother in-law, who's husbands have always been attorneys. She did this simply to prove she could. Jury selection is not always the rigorous ordeal some would believe.

Good questions A Mac.

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   seeder  A. Macarthur    13 years ago

It's my understand that the book deal was on, and she/or the publisher backed out after the outrage about the verdict, and her appearing to try to profit from it.

Agreed. Outrage that began with one individual via social media. I view it as the first particle launched in an inevitable shit storm.

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   seeder  A. Macarthur    13 years ago

An allegation like that needs to be verified; can you show us a source?

 
 
 
Buzz of the Orient
Professor Expert
link   Buzz of the Orient    13 years ago

In the Province of Ontario, Canada, where I had practised law, a lawyer is barred from serving on a jury, but there is nothing to prevent a lawyer's spouse from serving. The logic of that bar as I understood it, is that the jury is to determine the facts, but because a lawyer has knowledge of the law it is difficult for him/her to ignore it and focus only on the facts. As well, a lawyer is apt to have relationships with officers of the court in a trial, such as the judge, lawyers, prosecutors, even police officers involved with the case, which could be deemed to be prejudicial.

 
 
 
Spikegary
Junior Quiet
link   Spikegary    13 years ago

Currently, in New York, all are called to serve as part of the Jury pool-getting out of this service is much harder than it used to be. It's up to the lawyers in the case and the judge to look at jurors, question them and decide to keep or dismiss them. They usually have an extensive questionaire that is the 'first' item of business when you sign into the Jury Pool Room-where much of the individuals past and current history is recorded.

I agree Buzz, that for the most part, lawyers, judges and cops would be struck off consideration by the lawyers in the case.

 
 
 
Buzz of the Orient
Professor Expert
link   Buzz of the Orient    13 years ago

In Ontario they do not need to be struck off by the lawyers; they are ineligible ab initio.

Persons in the following professions do not qualify to serve as jurors:

  • A legally qualified medical practitioner, coroner or veterinary surgeon who is actively engaged in practice
  • A police officer
  • A firefighter regularly employed by a fire department
  • A superintendent, jailer or keeper of a prison, correctional institution or lockup
  • The warden of a penitentiary
  • A sheriff or a sheriff's officer
  • Armed forces personnel of the regular and special forces and members of the reserve forces on active service
  • A barrister and/or solicitor or a student-at-law
  • An officer of a court of justice
  • A judge or a justice of the peace
  • A member of the Privy Council of Canada, the Executive Council of Ontario, the Senate, the House of Commons or the Assembly
 
 
 
Spikegary
Junior Quiet
link   Spikegary    13 years ago

Seems like a reasonablelist (well, not sure about Veterinarians). Why bother bringing them in just to be dismissed. I think they do it here just to be P.C. and show that 'no one is above serving' even though those folks will be dismissed anyway.

 
 
 
Buzz of the Orient
Professor Expert
link   Buzz of the Orient    13 years ago

It's possible that some of the "Monday Morning Lawyers" on NT are actually lawyers the rest of the week.

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   seeder  A. Macarthur    13 years ago

"There sure a a lot of "Monday Morning Lawyers" on NT about this."

Point being, dennis?

Bad Facts Make Bad LawThe Hawley Decision

By John Tredennick

In law school, we learned the old adage that bad facts often make bad law. What it means is that judges are human. When presented with compelling circumstances, or the fear that a bad guy might get away with something, judges sometimes get creative with the law. In an effort to do justice, they make rules and interpret things in ways that dont always make sense for later cases.

The opposite is also true.

Regardless as to how one feels about the Zimmerman verdict, while the case is closed, issues about the SYG law as it applied to that case, are anything but closed.

IMO, the SYG statute in Florida makes it virtually impossible to reach a verdict of "guilty" in trials like the Zimmerman case. By that I mean, because SYG in effect sanctions killing in many, if not most scenarios, where the last man standing in a shooting is the only remaining eye witness, even if he does not overtly contend that he was "standing his ground," jurors in deliberation cannot avoid factoring it into their verdicts!

Sometimes the law goes on trial; and if you think perhaps "not", consider that the Founding Fathers in writing the Constitution, included a process for amendment -- a recognition that times change and that laws may need to change to reflect the times.

 
 
 
Petey Coober
Freshman Silent
link   Petey Coober    13 years ago

I'm not saying you're wrong A Mac . But as a non-lawyerly type I don't perceive the connection between a law that has not been used in a defense and the jury decision in that trial . I don't even know how to attempt to "disprove" that connection . Can you explain things in layman's terms ?

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   seeder  A. Macarthur    13 years ago

While Zimmerman did not ultimately use the "stand your ground" defense in his case, Sanford police did not arrest him until almost two months after the shooting because of the Florida stand your ground rules that require police to have specific evidence to refute a self defense claim in order to arrest someone claiming self defense.

That provision of the law "does a disservice to Floridians because it's so vague," said Florida Sen. Dwight Bullard, a Democrat, in an interview Sunday with CBS Miami.

The police initially did not have evidence to disprove Zimmerman's self-defense claim, said former Sanford Police Chief Bill Lee, Jr.

It was not until the case drew national attention and a Department of Justice investigation that prosecutors found evidence to charge Zimmerman with second-degree murder. The NAACP Legal Defense Fund is urging Attorney General Eric Holder to undertake a review of the case and encouraging Trayvon Martin's family to pursue civil action against Zimmerman.

Last year, a Florida task force headed by the lieutenant government reviewed the state's "stand your ground" law, but in a final report, the task force only made minor recommendations that required no action from the legislature. No changes were made to the law this year.

"The liberal activists tried to use that tragedy (the shooting death of Trayvon Martin) as an opportunity to take our rights as Americans," said Florida House Speaker Rep. Will Weatherford, a Republican, on the attempts to change the state's stand your ground law. "We stood our ground on Stand Your Ground."

Across the country, at least 22 states have "stand your ground" laws, with varying degrees of requirements for when citizens may use deadly force to protect themselves. Before these new laws were put in place beginning in 2005, people who felt threatened outside their home were required to flee from an attacker before they were allowed to use force to defend themselves.

The new laws make clear, however, that if someone feels threatened either inside or outside their home, they do not have to run away and are legally justified in using force to protect themselves.

"If (my family and I) are walking through the mall and someone attacks us, I should not have to retreat. I should be able to defend myself in any place or forum that I need to," said Florida Rep. Carlos Trujillo, a Republican, on Sunday in an interview with CBS Miami.

Some states just allow people to defend themselves in their homes or businesses, while others extend the law to cars or any place someone "has a right to be." Florida's law falls into this second category. (See chart)

The Zimmerman case drew national attention to the "stand you ground" laws, which were promoted by the National Rifle Association and the American Legislative Exchange Council through model legislation and advocacy.

In a study of "stand your ground" laws commissioned by the National Bureau of Economic Research, researchers found that in states with "stand your ground" laws, the number of homicides had significantly increased from the years before the law was enacted. They found that the provision that allows self-defense "in any place a person has a legal right to be" is the driver of the increase in homicides. The increase in homicides, they argue, negates the claim that these laws reduce crime.

 
 
 
Petey Coober
Freshman Silent
link   Petey Coober    13 years ago

That's a pretty good explanation . That said , I am not clear on this :

In a study of "stand your ground" laws commissioned by the National Bureau of Economic Research, researchers found that in states with "stand your ground" laws, the number of homicides had significantly increased from the years before the law was enacted.

I would expect that incidents would not be classified as homicides if the SYG defense was being used and was successful .

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   seeder  A. Macarthur    13 years ago

In a study of "stand your ground" laws commissioned by the National Bureau of Economic Research, researchers found that in states with "stand your ground" laws, the number of homicides had significantly increased from the years before the law was enacted.

(Petey commented) I would expect that incidents would not be classified as homicides if the SYG defense was being used and was successful .

I believe that the classification may include all violent deaths not just those that were contested where (i.e.) there were no eyewitnesses other than the "killer" and/or, where SYG may have been cited as a defense but could not hold up because of eyewitness testimony, video recordings (cell phones, etc.).

There is also the possible explanation that the term "homicides" was used as a generic/all inclusive term, one that only considered violent (wrongful, etc.) deaths since the statute went into place.

 
 
 
Petey Coober
Freshman Silent
link   Petey Coober    13 years ago

OK thanks for your perspective .

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   seeder  A. Macarthur    13 years ago

Does anyone know what happened to this article?

I was commenting, refreshed the page and then it was gone.

...

 
 
 
Mark in Wyoming
Professor Silent
link   Mark in Wyoming     13 years ago

Could the author / poster or another adminhave deleted it ?

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   seeder  A. Macarthur    13 years ago

Could the author / poster or another adminhave deleted it ?

I may have been Sixpick's article "Are you going to be part of the problem "

I was in the process of commenting a showdown of sorts with a member refreshed the page and when it came up again, the article was gone.

 
 
 
Mark in Wyoming
Professor Silent
link   Mark in Wyoming     13 years ago

yeah I saw it , read some of it and the responses , didn't really interest me due to the confrontations and back biting going on in it so I didn't really have a comment , nothing I could have said would have really made a difference any way.

if its gone , maybe someone got tired of what I just mentioned. its a possability.

 
 
 
Mark in Wyoming
Professor Silent
link   Mark in Wyoming     13 years ago

usually during a jury selection process , those eliminated are done so because either the prosecution or the defense objects , in this case , what most likely happened was neither objected . though I have a back ground in LE I was selected to be on a jury involving a cop and a citizen. after the trial I asked the judge why I wasn't excluded when a former county sheriff was, he told me even in spite of my background , and because of what I was employed in doing at that time( unrelated to LE) , neither had objected to me being on the jury.

 
 
 
Mark in Wyoming
Professor Silent
link   Mark in Wyoming     13 years ago

randy and has been pointed out in another thread ( and most likely will justexplode some brain cells. Zimmermans team neverinvoked SYG , BUUUT,by its inclusion in the jury instructions by the judge , it could be reasonably believed that its immunity from civil suits also applies to the case as it stands. It can be rightfully argued that SYG was applicable ( because the Judge applied it even without being asked for a hearing) thus granting the immunity section of the statute , cant partially ring or unring a bell once its been rung , just like you cant use only PART of the statute without the whole statute applying, so if its found that the judge unilaterally using it sets precedent that itapplies, seems not only the federal civil rights case which there is absolutely no grounds or proof that meets the standards the feds have to meet for a case against Z ( no a case against Martin , might be another story with the testimony, as ive pointed out elsewhere), but any following civil case under Fla lawis basically shot out of the water if its sucsessfully argued that way. you can thank the judge for that . and the prosecution if need be .

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   seeder  A. Macarthur    13 years ago

Zimmermans team neverinvoked SYG , BUUUT,by its inclusion in the jury instructions by the judge , it could be reasonably believed that its immunity from civil suits also applies to the case as it stands.

I disagree;

Wrongful death is a claim in common law jurisdictions against a person who can be held liable for a death. [ 1 ] The claim is brought in a civil action , usually by close relatives, as enumerated by statute . Under common law , a dead person cannot bring a suit, and this created a loophole in which activities that resulted in a person's injury would result in civil sanction but activities that resulted in a person's death would not.

Consider O.J. Simpson

In 1995, he was acquitted of the 1994 murder of Nicole Brown Simpson and Ronald Goldman after a lengthy and internationally publicized criminal trial, the People v. Simpson . In 1997, a civil court awarded a judgment against Simpson for their wrongful deaths ; to date he has paid little of the $33.5million penalty. [ 2 ]

The standard of proof in the United States is typically preponderance of the evidence as opposed to clear and convincing or beyond a reasonable doubt .

If acquittal of First Degree Murder does not preclude a wrongful death suit, I can't see how SYG, in-and-of-itself could.

 
 
 
Mark in Wyoming
Professor Silent
link   Mark in Wyoming     13 years ago

simple AMac , we are dealing with Fla law not California law (and they different) from one another , part of fla syg statute states that if a defense under SYG is found the that the individual is held harmless / immune from civil torts and claims which an unlawful death suit is a civil tort /suit/ claim . in other words if a SYG finding is made , those surviving of the dead or injured individual cannot sue in civil court under Florida law . that A Mac is how the law is written and how it would be judged, in a florida jurisdiction.

Basically IMHO , it doesn't appear to good for those calling for retribution or vengeance though they call it justice . hopefully I never have to face the justice system progressives dream of , for it would truly be the definition of a Kangaroo court .

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   seeder  A. Macarthur    13 years ago

in other words if a SYG finding is made , those surviving of the dead or injured individual cannot sue in civil court under Florida law . that A Mac is how the law is written and how it would be judged, in a florida jurisdiction.

I stand corrected; I was unaware 776.032 until your comment which caused me to look at the full statute.

I disagree with what you're calling "retribution or vengeance" however; SYG is a bad law and whether or not a wrongful death suit is filed symbolically in order to publicize the existence of 776.032 and further stoke public outrage, or, some other means is employed, I believe SYG will at some point "go on trial."

It would not surprise me if SYG became a metaphorical target pinned on Republicans running for office in red states in 2014.

Either way, thanks for the information

And watch for some attempt to get around 776.032.

 
 
 
Mark in Wyoming
Professor Silent
link   Mark in Wyoming     13 years ago

No worries Amac , its basically the same thing I tried to tell randy from California , and many might have been doing , judging this case , based on the knowledge of their own particular states laws not realizing they all differ. one has to be careful of that when talking about cross jurisdictions . as for SYG going away, IMHO I doubt it will , I feel it is the result of too lax a justice system where the actual perps got too leinient of sentence only to return after wards to repeat . its not a republican thing though some could paint it as such its a basic human right to self defense and not to have to flee from aggression, if we allow that the the criminals wi and take over by brute force and many of these laws passed because the people told their representatives in government how they felt and what they wanted . of course we can agree to disagree if the present situation is vengeance , retribution or justice , we are after all so called , civilized . I really don't see an end run around the section of the SYG you mentioned , since it has been applied even though unasked for , if I were Z's defense team , or on it , that's an angle I would argue , even though it wasn't asked for the judge said it applied , Z had no duty to retreat before he defended himself , so in essence , a judgement had already been rendered even though it hadn't been asked for.

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   seeder  A. Macarthur    13 years ago

My point is that just like Monday morning quarterbacks, the Monday morning lawyers whine about what might have happened if this or if that had been the case. In this case it is factual that the justice system ended with a not guilty verdict.

I understood your point when you first made it and gave a specific response -- rather than re-make your point, you could specifically address the particulars in my response.

Much of what you regard as "whining" is not about the verdict, rather about the SYG statutes that make any verdict other than "not guilty" almost impossible.

 
 
 
Mark in Wyoming
Professor Silent
link   Mark in Wyoming     13 years ago

A Mac I have to disagree here that SYG makes any verdict except not guilty impossible , currently there is another case ( in Fla ) that the shooter is claiming SYG , this one will result in a guilty verdict though . the particulars of the case that I have read , an older gentleman and ablack teen got into an argument about the level of music coming from the car the teen was in , one of the people in the car turned the music down a little the shot teen reached over and turned it back up ,the older white guy , claims he saw what appeared to be a shot gun in the car and opened fire, when the cops got there , nothing resembling a weapon let alone a shotgun was found in the car.

in this case , there was no physical contact everything was verbalso there is no "guess work" for a jury to have to winnow through this gentlemans claim of SYG , will be throw out and he will face murder charges because the prerequisites for SYG have not been met because a reasonable person wouldn't have feared an individual sitting in the car simply verbally arguing. this time there will be a conviction and rightly so .as long as the judge and the prosecution don't fuck it up. but hey , this is Fla after all.

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   seeder  A. Macarthur    13 years ago

A Mac I have to disagree here that SYG makes any verdict except not guilty impossible , currently there is another case ( in Fla ) that the shooter is claiming SYG , this one will result in a guilty verdict though . the particulars of the case that I have read , an older gentleman and ablack teen got into an argument about the level of music coming from the car the teen was in

Mark,

That's a different situation; there were eye witnesses start to finish unlike in the Zimmerman case. I think my first comment indicated that, where a the killer is the only eye witness to the killing itself as was Zimmerman, in the absence of video, etc., it's the killer's account that the jurors hear -- his written statements, etc. . By claiming "self-defense," even if the words "stand your ground" never leave his mouth or that of his defense, because of the SYG statue and "no duty to retreat," IT'S THE KILLERS WORDS AGAINST THAT OF THE DEAD MAN'S SILENCE.

The instructions to jurors apprise them of SYG and that's almost a guaranteed "not guilty" if only the killer's information is what is considered when deciding "reasonable doubt."

 
 
 
Mark in Wyoming
Professor Silent
link   Mark in Wyoming     13 years ago

Mea culpa Amac , I didn't see the part about there not being witnesses and only having the accused word or version to go on, even then ( yes the ex wife still calls me the contrary old man), I would have a disagreement because a sucsessful SYG plea and application would have to be supported by the forensic evidence, in other words , the evidencethey find in the lab and at the scenbetter match your story of the events , enough so that if your charged it can cause a reasonable doubt as to guilt or innocence the instructions either way to a jury Amac could almost guarantee a verdict , one way as you say if SYG applies , its innocent , the other that SYG does not apply could just as well be an automatic guilty verdict because the person did NOT retreat when given the opertunity .

Amac we obviously disagree on SYG , or the duty to retreat laws which is what they actually are , I think they are actually good if written properly , applied using common sense , and not abused to the point of being ridiculous and cannot be supported by witness and evidenciary testimony. here is a question , lets take this case , remove the firearm from it , lets say Zimmerman had killed martin using nothing more than his hands with the same outcome , would there be the same outcry over SYG? or would it be viewed differently if a gun wasn't involved?

 
 
 
Buzz of the Orient
Professor Expert
link   Buzz of the Orient    13 years ago

Great cartoon - so relevant it says it all.

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   seeder  A. Macarthur    13 years ago

I think they are actually good if written properly

And therein exists our differences of opinion. IMO, any law that includes a proviso that essentially makes it impervious to an appeal process, in essence has acknowledged its own "stacked deck/rigged game." Let the law be the law and not try to inherently subterfuge the system of justice beyond itself.

remove the firearm from it , lets say Zimmerman had killed martin using nothing more than his hands with the same outcome , would there be the same outcry over SYG? or would it be viewed differently if a gun wasn't involved?

Interesting scenario; in the absence of eyewitnesses, video, etc., YES, for me the problem would still exist re: SYG.

if Zimmerman, etc., had to kill his victim with his bare hands, it would be quite difficult to explain why, if he had to get within arms length of his victim to kill him, why he just could not back away, run away, etc. . BUT, if he could "justify" killing his victim with "I had no duty to retreat because of SYG," that would underscore how SYG ENCOURAGES KILLING, etc., EVEN WHEN KILLING COULD BE AVOIDED!

My two cents.

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   seeder  A. Macarthur    13 years ago

A Mac - The SYG statutes are legal and are subject to the justice system. If the law is altered or changed so be it, until then it is simply a defense to be used when appropriate and in this case it was used.

dennis,

I'm not questioning the "legality" of SYG -- it's the law in Florida and elsewhere; I AM questioning the wisdom and efficacy of such laws.

Because something is law does not in-and-of-itself make it reasonable, good, or, by some other standards, even LEGAL; I'll explain.

Under certain governments, what's legal is also abominable. Laws under Hitler, Mussolini, etc., were THE LAW -- they were "legal." But by any reasonable human standards, they were criminal. I'm not comparing SYG to genocide, what I am comparing are laws that get on "the books," but which have serious flaws and potential for tragedy.

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   seeder  A. Macarthur    13 years ago

Justice, the people and politicians in states who have this law see fit for it to be so. What you call legal murder others calllaw and not murder. There are two sides to issues, not just one.

And yet, you seem stuck on just one yourself.

If you think "LAW" and "JUSTICE" are synonymous, I'll repeat what I wrote earlier because you either did not understand it, or choose not to.

Under certain governments, what's legal is also abominable. Laws under Hitler, Mussolini, etc., were THE LAW -- they were "legal." But by any reasonable human standards, they were criminal. I'm not comparing SYG to genocide, what I am comparing are laws that get on "the books," but which have serious flaws and potential for tragedy.

LAW -- the system of rules that a particular country or community recognizes as regulating the actions of its members and may enforce by the imposition of penalties

JUSTICE -- the quality of being fair and reasonable

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   seeder  A. Macarthur    13 years ago

Fair enough, dennis.

Sometimes the law prevails and sometimes not. When law and justice prevail simultaneously, IMO what we have is "civilization."

 
 

Who is online







101 visitors