Egypt, and the Devil You Know
As with any major news event in the world today, the military coup in Egypt has confronted us with a crush of information that we must process in order to develop a reasonable perspective. In this article, I am providing you with some practical, factual information that may help you form a more informed opinion on the event.
1)Since Egypt's formation as a republic in 1952, there have been 6 Presidents, aside from a few interim appointments. The first 5 were career military men; they were army generals. The sixth was Mohammed Morsi, a career politician.
2)The Muslim Brotherhood, founded in the 1920s in Egypt, is a social, religious and political movement. Their original and continued goal is to promote the implementation of traditional Islamic law (that's right - shari'a) throughout theArab world. Throughout their history, they have supported destabilizing and violent means of furthering their cause.
3)The Muslim Brotherhood claimed responsibility for the assassination of Anwar Sadat, President of Egypt from 1970 until his murder in 1981. He was targeted because of the peace treaty with Israel that he helped to forge, and signed.
4)Since their peace agreement with Israel in 1979, Egypt has not been involved in any wars, other than its peripheral participation in the Gulf War in 1991. There has been frequent social unrest within the country, as it is a poor country with high unemployment, and many protests from groups demanding greater freedom.
5)Although Egypt has significant oil reserves, it has not developed a great deal of their reserves, and actually produces far less than they did in the 1990s. Their importance in the petroleum industry lies more in the control of the Suez Canal, a major waterway for oil tanker traffic.
So here are your facts. There are more facts out there, but I think you can take these and make heads or tails about what's going on.
Here's what I think:
The pressure of the Arab Spring squeezed Mubarak out of office. The most organized group in Egypt is the Muslim Brotherhood, who succeeded in getting their candidate, Morsi, elected. The military and MB were always at loggerheads, and had no interest in an Islamic government, which Morsi was implementing through his political appointments and attempted takeover of the judiciary.
The military is in favor of a secular government running Egypt. The next election will feature one or more candidates that are favored by the military. My impression is that the MB will be outlawed, and therefore not have a candidate in the next election. The next President of Egypt will be a former general, and probably serve for a decade or more. That's what the people know and are familiar with. The liberal elements of the country will get a number of small concessions, so long it does not affect the military's power base.
But that's just my opinion...
Tags
Who is online
104 visitors

If I had to point to one particular event that gave this move impetus, I'd have to go with Morsi's attempted power grab on the judiciary. Speaking in general terms, his approach to consolidating power was not very nuanced. He immediately filled all key political positions with MB people. This contradicted his pledge for a more representative government. The MB was a very organized group; this move could have been made more gradually. Had he developed a 2 or 3 year plan, he'd have had much greater success in seizing complete control.
Nice history lesson, Jonathan!
Latest events...
People have looted and destroyed the offices of the Muslim Brotherhood and the army has opened fire on supporters ofMorsi with US builtApachehelicopters.
Well, personally I have to agree with his ousting. He made promises that he had no intention of keeping. They were already better off with Mubarak.
Good article . Thanks .
My impression is that the MB will be outlawed, and therefore not have a candidate in the next election.
That would be an interesting development . But it would likely result in a reforming of the MB under another name .The result is that that the latest history will repeat . Egypt does not seem to have a history of the "rule of law" .
The military has been the stabilizing factor in Egypt for decades. Given the alternatives, they look to be the most reasonable show in town. They have a power base, and may be the most moderate bunch to deal with for all involved.
The last three world leaders who stuck with Morsi and the Brotherhood were Obama, Kerry and Ambassador Anne Patterson.
Another symbol of our ME incompetence.
Your opinion exposes the cultural difference between Egypt and authentic democracies. Our Presidents over-promise, over-extend and take action that is often inconsistent with their original statements of policy. But we don't oust the leader when he does this. We don't even censure their moves the overwhelming majority of the time. The good news is that we replace our leaders every 4 or 8 years, rather than put them under house arrest.
Therein lies the rub, Robert.
Morsi was the "Muhammad candidate". By your calculation, he should have been their forever, not 1 year.
Those in power in this particular Muslim country probably don't take the rug out 5 times a day.
Hence, the next sentence in the paragraph.
The next President of Egypt will be a former general, and probably serve for a decade or more.
We agree. The latest history will indeed repeat.
a decade or more.
Given the large showing from Morsi supporters I hope you're right . But I am not as confident as you on the time frame ...
Good Lesson Jonathan.
It is interesting that the Egyptian Military is even wary about allowing mb soldiers into their own ranks. Can you imagine, deliberately filtering the military, for those considered Islamic extremists, in the US?
Shit, maybe Fort Hood coulda been prevented after all!
:~)
I took that number from the previous presidential terms. Nasser and Sadat were about 10 years (Sadat would've lasted longer had he avoided the hail of gunfire) and Mubarak lasted 30(!). So 10 was more or less a baseline.
I always prefer democracy to any other form of government. The upside of a non-democratic society is that they need not be PC when it comes to preserving the status quo. If MB poses a risk to the Egyptian military, there will be at most a minimum of them. Here in the US, citizenship and physical fitness seem to the be the only things you need to gain access to some pretty heavy duty weapons.
Ayaan Hirsi Ali makes a compelling argument that Islam is not compatible with modern Liberal Democracy. Perhaps the US as a Democracy would do well to consider that when hiring soldiers.
Soooooo, it wasn't hisallegiance that got him bounced?
Wow, that's some meaty content. I watched most of it, but I need to go back.
Nothing like watching a former insider tear the caliphate to shreds...
I very seldom link to long pieces, but it is excellent and brings out a couple of viewpoints I hadn't considered. Politics is a strange thing at times, especially when it deals with islamism; she pulls back the curtain a little.
She doesn't pull back the curtain a little, she pulls it back a lot. She gives the most realistic description of the Muslim mind-fix; i.e. why compromise is not even in their vocabulary. Their religion and their politics are one and the same. They cannot and will not veer from the dictates, which is a reason why you would have to be a dreamer to think a solution to the I/P conflict is possible. I have posted an explanatory interview with her on NT:
It's a lesson for liberals.
Here is another opinion on the incompatibility of Islam and Democracy:
Islamists Are So Over Democracy After the Egyptian Coup
As far as I can see, we are back to square one in Egypt. Not all that unexpected, really.
Muslims have no business in the US Armed Services. Their first and last allegiance will always be to Islam. Yes, Ft. Hood could have been prevented. Hasan communicated over US militarycommunications systems with a top terrorist... one that was being hunted by the US and was eventually killed by a drone, a US citizen killed on foreign soil as a dangerous terrorist.
His communications were recorded and dismissed. Hasan was a screwup who was promoted again and again simply because he was Muslim and his superiors were afraid of repercussions up the line if they did not. In fact, he is still drawing a salary as he sits in military custody for killing 13 US soldiers and making a joke of the US military court process.... because he is Muslim and no one has the balls to move the trial forward.
He will NEVER be executed for his crime. Never.
Muslims have no business being in our military. Their loyalty is to Islam. Egypt will never be satisfied regardless of whom is elected the next president. We promise democracy will solve all problems of inequality and unemployment, that we can turn every country into a prosperous United States just by the democratic process.
We neglect to remind them that it took us over two hundred years and lots of sacrifices and bloodshed to get where we are and we still fight over how to do it. They are suffering from classic post partum depression, common to new mothers. They expected to wake up the morning after the official end of the revolution to find the magical mummies had put everything to rights and they could start their new, shining lives of peace and prosperity RIGHT NOW.
SURPRISE, SURPRISE, SURPRISE, when those who fought for the revolution find that they and their the next few generations will be dead and buried before the results of their revolution will see results.
Americans have worshipped just a little too much at the false god of political correctness. There have been other examples of the result, haven't there? And the TPTB just let the disease grow. It's like flesh-eating disease - it will eventually totally devour everyone (who is not a devout Muslim). The WW Caliphate will eventually be achieved, because nobody but Israel has the guts to fight it.
You do have a point, Buzz. I don't know whether it is a case of worshipping the false god of political correctness or naivete or simply arrogance that has led to imagining we can establish the order of our beliefs elsewhere.
Very interesting, and I hope you are correct about the MB being outlawed. That certainly won't solve all the problems, but would be a good start.
Actually, of the major parties-- there were two.
In the general election, The MB came in first. But the party that got the second highest number of votes was not a secular party that wanted democracy. Rather, it was the Salafis. (This extremist Islamist group actually hates the MB because they consider the MB to be too moderate!).
If you add the votes for these 2 Islamist parties, an overwhelming percentage of Egyptians voted for Islamic parties.
many westerners are under the impression that the huge crowds opposing Morsi were against rule by an Islamist party. But this is not true-- one of the main reason was the economy. Egypt was always poor. But under Morsi the economy got really, really terrible!
(In a post somewhere on NT, Fada mentioned another reason: the MB, while it sometimes acts fairly moderate (to avoid the cut-off of huge amts of U.S. aid)-- has a history of supporting terror, and being affiliated with terror groups. (tere have been terror attacks in Egypt. But ecently terrorists from gaza murdered some Egyptian sodiers which of course pissed offf the Egyptians).
IMo the rejection of Morsi was not a rejection of islamist rule, but rather a specific rejection of Morsi and the MB party.
When we think of a military coup d'etat (which this was, although won't admit-- for good reasons) we usually think of th army seizing control by force, often in Latin America or Africa. Almost all the time, its a move away from democracy.
Ironically, however, in the Arab world (and Turkey) most of the time the military seizing power if better for the people (and, BTW, usually better for the U.S.). As you mentioned, in the Arab world the army is actually usually more moderate than the alternatives!`
These 2 Islamist parties should be encouraged to think of each other as infidels . That usually results in a thinning of the ranks ...
And beyond that-- its also the religion of religious tolerance! Yup. It gotta be true-- even our president said so-- and of course he wouldn't lie, would he?
Ironically, the best ("least worst") form of government for most Arab countries is army rule.
Looks like the backlash over the horrors of MB rule might even get worse than that:
The thick plottens: Egyptian army killed dozens of Hamas fighters in Sinai
If America does anything to help democracy in the area, they should make efforts to organize the non-fanatics in Egypt so that they could with a majority vote create a real, rather than fake, democracy in Egypt. The problem is that the fanatics are organized and the fundamentalist factions vote the same way whereas the others are disorganized and untrained in voting procedure.