U.S. taps half-billion German phone, internet links in month: report
(Reuters) - The United States taps half a billion phone calls, emails and text messages in Germany in a typical month and has classed its biggest European ally as a target similar to China, according to secret U.S. documents quoted by a German newsmagazine.
The revelations of alleged U.S. surveillance programs based on documents taken by fugitive former National Security Agency contractor Edward Snowden have raised a political furor in the United States and abroad over the balance between privacy rights and national security.
Exposing the latest details in a string of reputed spying programs, Der Spiegel quoted from an internal NSA document which it said its reporters had seen.The document Spiegel cited showed that the United States categorized Germany as a "third-class" partner and that surveillance there was stronger than in any other EU country, similar in extent to China, Iraq or Saudi-Arabia.
- http://www.reuters.com/article/2013/06/30/us-usa-germany-spying-idUSBRE95T04B20130630
This is getting more bizarre and damaging by the moment. Not only is the US spying on it's own citizens but it is doing so with the citizens of our allies.
Tags
Who is online
91 visitors

There are only 81.3 million Germans . What on earth?
What do we want? BEER!
When do we want it? NOW!
Lets work towards a utopia where Hacker-Pschorr beer becomes "The Worlds Drink", and we all live happily ever after.
..and your point is? Did you READ the article? It stated plainly that these were links or connections. People do make multiple phone calls from one phone ya know. If the article is wrong, please, by all means, prove it. The German's own " Der Spiegel " confirms it; NSA Snoops on 500 Million German Data Connections
I don't thing the Germans are taking this as lightly as the Obama fanboys (and girls) are. - NSA spying row deepens as Germany summons US ambassador over Edward...
Stick to the....come to think of it, you never know what a topic is anyways....
Thank you for your useless comments which had absolutely NOTHING to do with the topic other than drone on about personal and rationalized opinions on spying.
As a side note, apparently the ideal of unwarranted, unethical, potentially illegal by European laws and immoral spying wooshes right over your head. In your mind, if it's legal...it's Ok. My country, right or wrong...OK, everyone has the picture.
Knock off with the Tu quoque defense. The topic is NOT talking about what they are doing to the US, the topic is about the US spying on German civilians and the German/EU reaction to it.
Why is the EU fussing about wiretapping from America when they do the same to us? Everyone spies on one another to see what information they can get an advantage on over others. If that don't work trade information about one country for information on another.
it is like sports everyone cheats to get an advantage. Anyone who says they aren't are probably the biggest cheaters in the game. Look at Armstrong for example.
Easily manageable number. Cray can scan in probably 30 minutes or less.
Do you want to try to catch terrorists why. Hell we let the mentally I'll buy guns here in the good old USA. We let fellons buy guns in the good old USA. We let spousal abusers buy guns in the good old USA. We even tell how to build bombs on Facebook. After all people its a free country. Except for Protests, Protest in front of banks, Protests in Parks, Protests on Wall street, Its legal for Cops to break into your house kill you and no charges filed, break into your house and kill your dog. Shoot a man who got upset at Wal-Mart then left police shot him 36 times he was armed with a pen knife.. Its all just normal shit. More guns sold more Ammunition fired and more baught.
Kids killing kids, Kids killing parents, parents killing wife and children, Parents killing neighbors, Cops killing woman at traffic stop she is unarmed. Yep those guns sure are a god sent technology. If we kill each other off the rich 1% still win.
Is this relevant even?
Yep look at Politicians, Look at Police hell look at ther House of representatives they along with Governors want to put womens rights back to what they were in the dark ages and stupid asses still vote for the Republican House members and Republican Governors that are doing it. And we think we live in a civilized country. Stealing is legal if your rich or a politician, killing is legal if your a cop or a self proclaimed security guard. No pay no job just say you are one and fire away. Hold your ground or run after them its all good.
And were worried about wire taps. Well they don't need wires any more. Stealing its what the rich has taught efveryone to do. Ok rant over. Just a little bit upset with us worring about the trivial shit when gun fire is rampant. Live in an upscale neighborhood here neighborw shooting their semiautomatics several days a week.
AP..... In all sincerity, this is the intelligence game that is played by all sides, and it needs to be played that way too. The trouble starts when all sides don't have enough information. When that happens, countries get hurt, and people get hurt.
A very simple example for you would be to analyze the Cuban Missile Crisis. Had the US known of the buildup earlier, it would have been handled strictly at the diplomatic level. Because the Soviets went for the "big surprise" the US was way behind the curve in intelligence, we damned near pushed ourselves into a shooting war.
I'm sorry that this seems to be so shocking to you, but this whole electronic intelligence business (friend and foe alike) has strong roots all the way back into the second world war. When you get down to it, it has actually allowed most people to get on with their lives without interruption.
Nope not even any sort of important. Just like this topic old technology old tatics peoplle saying they cannot handle the volume. They can, they do and they will The government can do it from here do itfrom overseas it cannot be stopped.
Now we know why nothing is getting done in the Government....they're too busy paying attention to what the other guys are doing! Which means the other guys aren't getting anything done either-- so, who's running the world ? The Muppets, did they say? Oh wait...maybe it was the Puppets' (masters).
I still see potential for political bribery 'for' info of other governments and political leaders, if that isn't already happening. This might be a very lucrative trade business!
It doesn't take much to entertain you I see. Next time I'll post a picture of a ball of string and you can have yourself a real riot.
Governments spy on governments, that's a given. Governments spying on the citizens of their own country is totalitarian. Governments spying on the citizens of other countries is unheard of.
If you think I'm outraged, you haven't been keeping up with the news: Germans so outraged at U.S. over spying that Merkel will raise the issue directly with Obama
Things have gotten so bad for Obama over this, his mentor has gone public in defending him: George W. Bush Defends PRISM: 'I Put That Program In Place To Protect The Country
In all of history, can you show me examples where a foreign government spied on the citizens of another country?
How is this related to the topic?
Russia was spying on our scientists and academics at every technical institution and university in the United States from the time that Stalin came to power to the present day.
The researchers at the University of Chicago, Berkly, MIT, all have been targeted. Engineers at Westinghouse, Oak Ridge, and other nuclear production sites have been tracked/spied on by operatives/operations run by Russia, North Korea, and Israel. The list is endless AP.
Now it is my turn. Can you show me an example where the enemies of the state were not so much from a single country like militant Islam is today? An enemy that has no government to talk to, no uniformed stand up military to oppose? The intelligence of those that would do our country and others harm is distributed, and it takes a wide net to obtain that intelligence.
FLYNAVY,
Please SHOW me, not tell me. Do you have sources for your allegations? Besides, all those groups you mentioned were employed by or had a contract with, the federal government, which makes them legitimate targets. None the less, I'd like to see your proof.
Let me clearly reiterate, I'm talking ordinary citizens with no ties to the government. Evidence please.
As for your question, that sounds a lot like paranoia. I seem to recall a certain Joe McCarthy going after US citizens because in his paranoid mind; Everyone was a communist just like Obama and his fans think everyone is an Islamist terrorist.
Flame.... I think those are legitimate groups to counter with.
This effort by terrorists against our country and others has evolved into a new/advanced form of gorilla warfare. Important information and intelligence to combat the enemy is down in the data noise "weeds" if you will, where civilians and governments operate and communicate. To give up efforts to glean this intelligence from this source would provide a huge tactical advantage to those that would do us and others harm.
FLYNAVY,
You are passing off one gigantic canard full of mysterious boogeymen involved with the evil Islamist (or Illuminate, communists, right wing conspirators, etc) that is so omnipresent in this society that we must spy on each other. What a crock of shit.
Here is a specific example for you.... Look up Project Ryan run by the Soviets in the 1982-83. They were watching our entire economy, from meat processing facilities, to grocery retailers. They were looking for signs that the Regan administration was moving for a first strike.
None of these groups had alignment with the US Government.
The mysterious boogeymen that you seem to think don't exist took out the world trade center, and more recently killed and wounded a bunch of people in Boston.
I'll say it again AP, there is nothing of such value in my phone calls, or my internet connection that I place it above your life, or the lives of the other 315 million Americans. Your sophomoric rhetoric only belies your lack of understanding of electronic intelligence gathering and analysis, and how it pertains to the real world vs. the one you think you live in.
Speaking of sophomoric, you give ONE example in over 60 years (yeah that's really proof that foreign governments spying on our citizens..in all fairness, I did only ask you for ONE.), you then spew out some conspiratorial paranoid garbage about the dreaded communists spying on everyone here (again, no proof) then you use 9/11 and the incident in Boston to justify the spying on all citizens? Are you losing it?
Well, if my sophomoric (actually sarcastic) rhetoric offends your perspective, so be it. I place my constitutional rights and the rights of all Americans above your delusional paranoia.
Looks like you've lost all sense of objectivity in this matter AP. Feel free then to go wallow with the like of Brietbart, Glenn Beck, and the other political sensationalist. The rest of us that understand ELINT, the evolution of communication technology and the world as it is, will do our best to keep an eye on things.
I'm glad you will be keeping an eye on our constitutional rights for us. I bet you would have saved a lot of lives had you been yelling out the bill of rights in Boston during the marathon.
By the way.... nice job on the posters.
FLYNAVY;
a) Every rational objection Ive had with Barack Obamas spying on civilians Ive backed up with sources and proof. Its called the Objective approach while you, on the other hand, use the Subjective Approach and ne'er the twain shall meet.
b) This must be the new Democratic party approach to disagreements; compare them with right wing losers. Cute, in a childish sort of way.
c) Who is US? Is us you and that mouse you have in your pocket or is it you, John, EI and the rest of the Obama fan club?
d) ELINT Electronic Intelligence system - - Ummm, I read about it and it says NOTHING about spying on US civilians.
e) The flip side to your flippant remark is that PRISM and domestic spying had already secretly been in place for years before the Boston terrorist attack, which did absolutely NOTHING to prevent it. Our less than effective intelligence system even ignored a warning by Russia about it.
Can you explain to me again why you feel the spying of U.S. citizens that are not even remotely connected to terrorist or ideologically subversive organizations, is so vitally important to our nations security? I must have missed that.
f) Thanks.
You and I have been down this road before flame, and we are very much in agreement that we have created our own enemies time and time again.
We also agree that if there wasn't any oil in the Middle East, we would not be there, and the age old fight between Sunny and Shia would just be something that you might hear about in a philosophy course.
For better or worse, we have made our bed, now we get to sleep in it. Unlike others, you will pardon me if I sleep in it with at least one eye open.
I agree with one premise, behind it all are the corporations.
Proof? Evidence? I don't see any. If you you claim what you say is a fact, prove it?
I've seen no evidence, not coming from the Freedom Of Information act, that ever even hinted that the mass spying of US civilians or foreign nationals who were NOT directly associated with any espionage apparati was ever done...and certainly not to the extent the NSA has been doing it to innocent German civilians.
For all you patriots out there that are perfectly content to sit back and let the government rifle through your personal information and private discussions in the name of national security - ask yourself how much is too much to pay for the kind of mechanics and manpower that are required to run such a marginally useful system. While unemployment soars, and infrastructure crumbles, and privatization creeps into the lives of taxpaying citizens to compound our own personal financial debt, our taxes are being funneled into the most bottomless money pit that the human mind can conjure up - and it was all done without your say-so, or even your acknowledgement. Maintaining this nightmare of useless technology will continue to suck the life out of our economy until prosperity becomes a meaningless word.
Just curious Flame, do you believe that Snowden's passport was rejected upon trying to re-enter the US? It was stated that he is accused by the US of being guilty of the Espionage Act.
So the fact that he can't get back in, and that he is charged with a crime would seem to suggest that he needs to seek asylum for exercising his 1st Amendment rights. Where's the diplomacy on Snowden's behalf ?
Additionally, there are some saying Snowden's just putting this on himself, that's he's acting delusional, and doesn't need to be seeking asylum at all. What?
If this had been going on for generations to the degree that it is now, then we never would have had the money to build the national highway system. Now we can't even afford to repair the NHS,instead favoringa bloated defense budgetto cover programs like this.
Hal, If you want to look at it that way, then every birdfarm and submarine the Navy has was a waste of money.
No, somebody built the buildings, Cray made jobs to build the two Titan computers, thus money was put in circulation in our economy. You want the NHS repaired, kill the F-35JSF program and you have all the money you need. That's the kind of waste that needs to go.
What we built was a program that will ensure an enormous budget to staff and maintain in perpetuity, and now that it is common knowledge throughout the world that we are storing unheard of amounts of data, the whole system is that much more meaningless. In addition, we now have the world's largest database amassed for any one of millions of people with the right clearance to exploit for their own personal gain.
Absolute security is a pipe dream, and this system couldn't even stop a couple of rogue Russians from following through on their evil plans - Russians who had already been called out as possible terrorists by their own country.
Submarines could never be called out as a waste of money, as they are one of the principle deterrents to nuclear war. They are physical, stealthy and fiercely defensive. This program is none of that.
I agree, Hal, and that is why I take my larger, more skeptical view that this has little to do with security, but is yet another profit-generating government scheme to which they most likely 'sell' the data, our personal information, to the right bidder, just like the social sites sell us to advertisers---I'm thinking the important people are being targeted moreso than you or I, but it's still the principle of no one should be used in that manner.
Thanks for your thoughts, Flame. I mostly 'picked on' you
because you brought in the word "diplomacy" in with this issue of spying, and while I knew what you meant, I couldn't help but bring up how little of it has been used in Snowden's behalf...the person that has brought all of this to light in a genuine desire of privacy and security for the citizens, as I viewed him.
Personally, I hadn't viewed motives on his part for the 'limelight' (tho, I agree there might be), because he must have known there would be repercussions...and scary ones at that! ...Whistleblowers are often murdered, as it appears.
I just brought up the skeptics suggesting Snowden's delusions of persecution, trying to understand what's delusional about having one's passport revoked. lol
EI & Flame,
Thank you for your explanations, both good and very logical on 'why' he would not want to re-enter, considering he would be arrested.
Too bad he didn't express it that way, too, instead making a misleading comment that his passport was revoked. Now I see why others are suggesting he's being delusional. I can't help but wonder if his seemingly strategic wording is his way of trying to get public sympathy/support, essentially saying, ..I did this for you, so will you help me.. Just speculating.
EI, I didn't know what the conditions of asylum were, and after you presenting them, I can see how he would be violating those terms, if he kept on. (..This would impact Assange, too, in that he suggested he wants to keep on.) Thank you for your comment on that.