EU Finally Takes a Step Against Islamic Intimidation
EU Challenges the UN and OIC on Press Freedom
by Nathaniel Sugarman American Thinker June 18, 2013
http://www.legal-project.org/4119/eu-challenges-the-un-and-oic-on-press-freedom
The European Parliament (EP) in Strasbourg passed two resolutions Thursday, each detailing a set of recommendations to protect the rights of journalists to speak and print freely. 21
"The EU, as a community of values, should aspire to lead in ensuring the free word, whether blogged or spoken, and information, whether researched or photographed, are protected. Journalists and a free, pluralist media, are essential for democracies and checks on power. Freedom of speech and freedom after speech are at the core of open and free societies," said Marietje Schaake (ALDE, NL), rapporteur for press and media freedom in the world. The EP is the directly elected parliament of the European Union.
The first resolution ( 2011/2081(INI) ), focusing on press freedom, "(r)ecognizes that governments have the primary responsibility for guaranteeing and protecting freedom of the press and media." The resolution also "points out that governments also have the primary responsibility for hampering freedom of the press and media and, in the worst cases, are increasingly resorting to legal pressures in order to restrict that freedom, e.g. through the abuse of anti-terrorism or anti-extremism legislation and laws on national security, treason or subversion." The EP endorses a "balance" between the concerns of national security and press freedom. The resolution goes further to deplore the fact that "journalists are frequently wounded or murdered or are being subjected to serious abuses throughout the world, often with impunity," and stresses the "importance of combating impunity."
The second resolution ( 2013/2082(INI) ), centering on religious freedom, endorses the firm opposition of "any attempt to criminalise freedom of speech in relation to religious issues, such as blasphemy laws." The EP predictably condemns "all forms of violence and discrimination," but goes further to emphasize that "particular attention should be paid to the situation of those who change their religion or belief, as in practice they are subject in a number of countries to social pressure, intimidation or outright violence."
Both moves by the EP stand in contrast to the more restrictive policies endorsed by the United Nations (UN) and the Organization of Islamic Cooperation (OIC). The OIC has endorsed "blasphemy laws" -- the same type of law denounced by the EP in today's resolution. Although now blasphemy laws are often euphemistically referred to as laws protecting the "defamation of religion," the concept remains the same -- laws that punish non-incitement speech about religion. The UN has worked with the OIC to help codify this type of speech restriction as international law.
In recent years a number of religious and nationalistic extremists, seeking to insulate themselves from criticism, have sued journalists who report on their malfeasances for defamation. This tactic is often called " lawfare ." In 2012, with the help of the Legal Project , Hassan Daioleslam defended a defamation lawsuit from plaintiffs Trita Parsi and the National Iranian American Council (NIAC). The plaintiffs were not able to demonstrate defamation, and their case was dismissed on summary judgment. Further, the Court ordered NIAC and Parsi to pay the defense sanctions. Earlier this year the Spanish government charged Imran Firasat with "hate crimes" for a YouTube video he produced called "The Innocent Prophet." Firasat has since been acquitted , but still faces possible deportation to Pakistan. Controversial journalists, bloggers, and other activists who seek to publish non-defamatory expositional material would likely favor the liberal standards of speech endorsed by the EP over the more restrictive policies of the UN and the OIC.
Some have already opined that the European Parliament, although ideologically praiseworthy, lacks the will to implement these resolutions as law, which now only exist as recommendations. Whether or not resolutions 2081 and 2082 are eventually codified in any way, the EP's actions remain significant in the face of UN and OIC pressure to promote a more restrictive international speech code.
Nathaniel Sugarman is a Law Clerk at The Legal Project , an activity of the Middle East Forum . This article was commissioned by The Legal Project .
http://www.legal-project.org/4119/eu-challenges-the-un-and-oic-on-press-freedom
Tags
Who is online
107 visitors

The second resolution ( 2013/2082(INI) ), centering on religious freedom, endorses the firm opposition of "any attempt to criminalise freedom of speech in relation to religious issues, such as blasphemy laws." The EP predictably condemns "all forms of violence and discrimination," but goes further to emphasize that "particular attention should be paid to the situation of those who change their religion or belief, as in practice they are subject in a number of countries to social pressure, intimidation or outright violence."
The UN, under the auspices of the Islamic bloc, succeeded in endorsing so-called "blasphemy laws". Essentially, the UN says it's not OK to speak out against Islam. Christianity, Judaism or any other faith? No problem.
This is unfortunately coming at a time when Europe has welcomed too many immigrants into their countries, and feel as though they are losing a grip on their own leadership. Multiculturalism has backfired, but getting the genie back into the bottle will be a monumental task.
We could could put it into the constitution or something.
Hey, that's a great idea. There should be protection in place for those who express their...
...heeeeeey, wait just a minute now.
Glad to see it happen.. where it will go is unclear. I really wish someone would decide to demolish the UN. What a useless was of money and excellent prime NYC waterfront property.
Media shield law?
What does the term "freedom of the press", as contained in the First Amendment, mean?
For starters, I think this will stop things from getting worse. That said, the status quo is not so hot. People who write articles and draw cartoons still have their lives to fear for. The animals that are going after them are not afraid to die. There's got to be something more forceful to act as a deterrent to the violence. Unfortunately, the only thing these people respect is force. Don't know how that's going to play out, but probably not to anyone's satisfaction.
I think Paris would be a good place for the UN. I think I'd visit. I'll rent a car, an park illegally nearby. Throw my tickets in the garbage when I leave...
Well moving the UN to Paris would only be appropriate.
Considering the US is already i ntimidating journalists, I'm not sure the timing is right for that.
I think the "timing" is always right for respecting the First Amendment. Any new "shield laws" would probably give the government the opportunity to somehow amend the existing amendment. Free speech is in the process of being redefined. A dangerous exercise, if you ask me.
But this all speaks to our domestic free speech woes, which must be addressed. Europe, on the other hand, has a different type of problem. The Islamic world has conquered the UN, and one of their agenda items was to gain influence and power in Europe. The "blasphemy law" was the first shot over the bow in their attempt to control the speech of an entire continent, for the purpose of stifling criticism of Islam. If you can be arrested for making a movie or murdered for drawing cartoons, it's apparent that you've ceded authority to ascary lot of people. Europe's problem is more obvious than ours...
... but no less dangerous.
Oh for sure let's stop paying their bills. The French can. They are so much more enlighten then us, it should be worth it to them, LOL!
Moral relativism doesn't equal more enlightened.
They'd take the UN if they got a promise from the US to pay the bills.
The fact that the UN is over 50% Muslim influence wouldn't seem to help the issue, either; nor that we have a sitting President in our country that holds an important position as Security Council Chairman.
The anti-West record at the UN rose to prominence in the 1970s. The 3rd world countries formed a bloc that could not be outvoted in the General Assembly (remember Zionism=Racism?). The Arab League, consisting of more than 50 countries, wields significant voting strength due to the sway they hold over oil consuming nations. The Security Council has also proven itself to be less than just, with Russia and China often wielding their veto power to keep the despoticChihuahuas nipping at the heels of the developed world.
It's an important realization for the EU. The only question is how much damage they can reverse at this point.
I don't see that any of the mandates that have come out of that org. to 'ever' be in our best interests as a Nation. ..Even International Law. I think our Constitution and due process should always override their's.
Don't despair. As soon as we elect a President that is more comfortable with America LEADING the world, we won't have to worry about things like that.
That thought sort of reminds me of the jokes they make about the Seattle area: When the sun comes out, everyone runs and hides, thinking God is punishing them
, that's what the Nation might do if we ever have a Leader.
Good for them
-- this long overdue!
Yes it is!
The sad part is, we'd probably do it... let's see, what do we need from the French... tires?
You mean get rid of the Islamic Fascist?
Islamic Fascist
Redundant...
That is good news but there is still no recognition of the principle of separation of church and state ?