[Rand] Paul wants to lead Supreme Court challenge to fed's tracking of Americans' calls, emails
Sen. Rand Paul said Sunday he wants to mount a Supreme Court challenge to the federal government logging Americans phone calls and Internet activities.
Paul, R-Ky., a leading voice in the Libertarian movement, told Fox News Sunday he wants to get enough signatures to file a class-action lawsuit before the high court and will appeal to younger Americans, who appear to be advancing the cause of less government and civil liberties.
Im going to be asking all the Internet providers and all of the phone companies: Ask your customers to join me in a class-action lawsuit, he said. If we get 10 million Americans saying we dont want our phone records looked at, then maybe someone will wake up and something will change in Washington. - http://www.foxnews.com/politics/2013/06/09/paul-wants-to-lead-supreme-court-challenge-to-fed-tracking-americans-calls/
While I'm not going to vote for him, I like this idea of Rand Paul's and surprisingly, it came from the republican camp.
Judging from the posts here, most people are hopelessly out of touch with the younger generation on this issue. Obama, and the democrats who support him on this invasive and damning spying on civilians, have cut off a lot of younger voters who see both republicans and democrats as; " Party Before Country. "

This is exactly the sort of thing that needs to end up before the Supreme Court if for no other reason than to help catch the US Constitution to the reality of 21st century technology.
A ruling is necessary because right now we have a Hodge-podge of laws and regulations that really don't fit to provide a clear cut interpretation of what can be done related to the NSA metadata. The sooner this can be made to happen, the better. I don't care how the SCOTUS rules, just that it does rule on this issue.
I agree, this should be reviewed by SCOTUS, if for no other reason than as Navy notes, to bring some of these issues into the light of the 21st century.
As to Mr. Paul, I would rather he rally the legislature to address jobs and the economy. Remember those issues?
Rand Paul speaks hyperbole. He has 2016 on his brain. These things were voted on by Congress in order to pass into law and were recently reviewed and re addressed I believe 2 years ago.
So to say they are unaware tells me they dont read the bills they are voting on..... um that might be a problem?
Another thing to watch is Paul, Rubio and Cruz.. They are all in to discredit the other in their hopes for the white house. Paul simply is making sure we hear his name and see his face as much as possible .
I have been hearing that for years, first with his father? Im hearing from my kids and their friends they think he is kind of a fruit loop, but I guess it depends on where one lives possibly? God help us all if you are right! When has freedom and liberty ceased to be cool anyway?
You have no idea. Finally something we agree on.
Rand Paul-who else is standing up saying this needs to be addressed and addressed now? Not many from the Loonie Left as they are just the sheep guided by your shepard.
This is simply the government exceeding the law and now they are caught. How does it go? Easier to beg forgiveness than get permission?
The Right To Privacy is defined as a human right (commonly understood as inalienable fundamental rights to which a person is inherently entitled simply because she or he is a human being) and is recognized by the UNs Universal Declaration of Human Rights. What is US constitutionally covered, is the issue.
As far as being a US constitutional right, (privacy) the document contains no express or enumerated right of privacy. However, Supreme Court decisions over the years have established and concurred that the right to privacy is a basic human right, and as such is protected by virtue of the 9th Amendment.
The right to privacy has come to the public's attention in several controversial Supreme Court rulings over the years, including several dealing with contraception (the Griswold and Eisenstadt cases), interracial marriage (the Loving case), and abortion (Roe v Wade case). In addition, it is said that a right to privacy is inherent in many of the amendments in the Bill of Rights, such as the 3rd, the 4th's search and seizure limits, and the 5th's self-incrimination limit.
Agreed thoughSCOTUS needs to look at the scope of what is and is not covered as a right to privacy.
Rand Paul is a chip off the old block of his dad....both live in their own paleolibertarian world of unreality, so to speak. However, this isn't the issue.
A Good Idea, even if it comes from a nut, is still a good idea. The naysaying anachronistics may say Paul's pursuit is a waste of time and is grandstanding. Perhaps it is, but any activity put forth for the common good in politics, is never a waste of time.
Things like this need to change. There is no privacy in this country any more.
why? obama only expanded bush's program, to make it more intrusive on all Americans. its not like we have any indication that the left may use any of this information to profile certain groups.
actually no, not true. Obama put the factor in place that BEFORE acting on any one person if that person is suspect, that a court had to issue the okay to do it.... Not in place when Bush was president.
And as far as the profiling inuendo? Well, now that some facts are emergin, such as in the IRS case? Looks like it was much ado about a whole lot of nothing.
But stay tuned because by tomorrow there will be another scandal accusation and still nothing will get done for the people. Same shit different day as they say.....
"much ado about a whole lotta nothin"
like asking people what they pray about, what books they have read, what rallies they have attended?
nothin like that?
IDK about specifically Libertarian...more like indies. People who are sick of partisan politics and a two party system.
Obviously we have two different conversations going on here because admittedly I have no clue what you are talking about. Enlighten me?
Yup.
Even filing your Income taxes.
(And if anyone thinks that that doesn't force you to reveal things-- try refusing to give that information to the gov't and see what happens!
)
I wonder if it is? (I'm not a lawyer but...).You might be right.
Which law would it be violating?
Taxes are constitutional, thus information reporting of the same is the same.
I know I'm stating the obvious, however, the case that is considered by the Supreme Court (sc) as you put forth, must be worthy of 4th amendment preservation. Using a weak case will not establish the precedent that is desired for citizen protection. Look for the growing list of cases in this area.