Obama administration defends phone record collection
Prologue: For those of you too caught up in the mindless myriad of fake Republican scandals and outrages, REAL news has been happening....
(Reuters) - The Obama administration on Thursday acknowledged that it is collecting a massive amount of telephone records from at least one carrier, reopening the debate over privacy even as it defended the practice as necessary to protect Americans against attack.
The admission comes after the Guardian newspaper published a secret court order related to the records of millions of Verizon Communications customers on its website on Wednesday.
A senior administration official did not specifically confirm the report, but noted the published court order pertains only to data such as a telephone number or the length of a call, and not the subscribers' identities or the content of the telephone calls.
The order requires the government to turn over so-called "metadata" such as a list of numbers that called other U.S. or international numbers as well as other transactional information on the time and location of calls.
Such information is "a critical tool in protecting the nation from terrorist threats to the United States," the official said, speaking on the condition of not being named. - http://www.reuters.com/article/2013/06/06/us-usa-wiretaps-verizon-idUSBRE95502920130606
1 - The ONLY reason we know about this is because a UK, yes UK , newspaper, the Guardian , came out with this. It's been going on for at least a month.
2 - Only just now, the US media is beginning to sluggishly get on-board...Collusion anyone? One gigantic FAIL for the US media.
3 - Do you have Verizon? You are fucked.
4 - Once again, Obama has proved himself a liar, and a tool to the corporations.
5 - Both parties are quiet on this...perhaps using this time to concoct more lies and spins about how they need to violate our civil rights in the name of national security.
6 - Civil Rights? I mean those Civil Constitutional Rights we used to have before Obama, the war mongers from both parties and the corporations took over.

1 - Prove it.
2 - Source?
Bullshit. First off, "those in power" is the Obama administration. Then, this was done in secrecy...get it, SECRECY and in collusion with the corporate owned media which never said a peep about it. Aside from you proving this has to do with national security, which you can't, this reeks of wholesale rights abuse.
More Bullshit. Remember when the King of Lies, Obama, promised a transparent administration? Does this look transparent to you? And, NO, another president would not have done the same. Pretty weak John.
Now you're blaming technology? You should have stopped after the first sentence.
On this, Aeon, I am with you 100%. Those who seek governmental tyranny will, of course, defend these actions. Those who wish for freedom, will denounce them.
AP.... not too long ago we were talking about us making it to Singularity. Like it or not this is the direction things will be going. Progress is never free, something must be offered up as payment. It is hard to move forward and stand still at the same time.
Fly:
So, bend your neck and knee for "progress?" Wow, what a way to live, eh? Become slaves for a brand new cell phone?
If that's the way it is, I suspect many would say where folks who believe that can stick it.
Flynavy,
Are you saying that technology caused the violation of constitutional civil rights or, are you saying that the violation of our civil rights using technology, is the direction the US is going in?
...and you call this progress? Not where I come from.
Well wmolaw....
When you find a technical advancement over the last couple of hundred years that didn't cost us something in return, let me know.
Another non scanda? The FBI ordered this done and Verizon had to comply under the law. The law? Remember that Patriot Act? Yup totally legal and cnn said it was not phone calls conversations being monitored, rather the time and length of calls, whatever that means.
After going thru the situation with the Boston Marathon mess, this bothers me none. Notta. I remember when you had a phone in the home, being on a party line and how truckers were able to pick up your conversation and vica versa way bak when. Do we really think our conversations on a phone are private? No more so than what I am writing right now on this here computer.
Don't play semantics with me John. Obama ALLOWED this to happen WITHOUT informing the US public.
If you are also acknowledging that governments abuse our civil rights, you are also saying that Obama, who represents the elected leader of that same government, to allow the abuse to happen.
AP.... All advancements in technology are double edged swords.
Yes... The study of DNA can help us identify and and possibly eliminate the susceptibility to cancers, and it can lead to insurance dropping you because of of what is in your DMA
Yes... you can have antibiotics to help the sick, but you may just create a resistant superbug that will kill millions from the use of antibiotics.
Yes... we can travel to the moon and the other planets to learn all that we can by building rockets. Oh by the way, those rockets can be fitted the thermonuclear weapons that can wipe out all life on this planet.
Yes... you can have digital cell phones to communicate with. Oh by the way we know when, and who you called and for how long.
Again... progress is never free.
Answer me this.... If the FBI can sniff out and prevent a terrorist cell from killing thousands in the NY subway system by access to phone records, should they have access to such records? I don't have an answer to that question myself.
Well now John, you must remember that no one waits for the facts to start a pointing that finger at that black man in the white house. What exactly did you expect? Common sense? Research before pointing? Now come on! We been around long enuff to know better!
Is that a fifth scandal on the highway to dictatorship?
Many of them, even pseudointellectuals,are right here so no proof is needed.
6th! You forgot the infamous umbrella!
Michelle Bachman made a big deal out of that one, even tho they had video showing someone holding one for her as she came off a flight. Hipocrit..
I think ya all otta grab your signs and hit the steps of the white house for all the world to see! And dont forget the umbrella!
Well now come on EI, we all know he walks on water! sarc/
That was before we had politicized "nonpartisan" government agencies that harassed, punished and held down their "enemies."
You are equating the deliberate violation of our legal constitutional rights to technology and progress, which is a " No Go. "
Wow! You even use the race card against Obama supporters.
What can the rest of the world expect? Jail?
You haven't heard a word I've said have you?
Which came first.... the technology, or the ability to use that technology to obtain information? If you are that worried about collection of information AP, what are you doing on the internet?
Please answer my question I put to you....
If the FBI can sniff out and prevent a terrorist cell from killing thousands in the NY subway system by access to phone records, should they have access to such records? I don't have an answer to that question myself.
LOL, gotta go, you guys try not to give yourself a stroke now! This constant 24 a day anxiety is not good for the body or the mind. ltr
Bush justlyfollowed the Patriot Act. Here it's open-ended.
EI,
1. That does NOT justify anything other than to prove both houses are in collusion not only by agreeing to this but deliberately keeping it from the public.
2. The document that stated it happened was a FISA court document - Which was NOT released to the public and was obtained surreptitiously by the UK Guardian newspaper.
3. No, those in 'power' in this case is the NSA. - Gee, I forgot. The NSA is an independent branch of government that is accountable to no one and take their orders from no one. Thanks for the info.
4. It IS possible that this crosses the line, because it appears to break 'new ground'. - According to YOU it breaks "new ground" but as the word of this spreads, organizations like the ACLU and other civil liberty groups see this as an old fashion, uncomplicated, case involving the violation of the Constitution.
5. Yup, because according to you, Obama knows absolutely every detail that goes on in the government - I daresay you should get glasses, I never said or implied that. Funny though, that as part of what is called "damage control", Obama must now go public and defend the actions of the NSA of which he was absolutely clueless about.
Cool.
Now, this actually does bring up a very valid issue. - Sorry, this is NOT a technology issue as you so fervently want to believe it is. You realize that Google has multiple times, publicly announced they were served legal papers for allowing the government to do isolated searches on individuals...NOT wholesale records of Americans using Verizon.
I'll stick my two cents in, as I do not own a cell phone (yup there are still one or two of us) no one can listen anyway.
You or we as a people have to decide just how much we are willing to give up in order to have some sense of security. In the months that followed 9/11 the general clamor from the public was for our government to keep us safe, at that time many did not care as to how that would be done they just wanted results. Now if safety (in truth, which of us is really ever safe) is the main concern then the cost of that (which will never be 100% anyway) is privacy and to one degree or another personal freedoms. For those of us that acknowledge that we have little to no say over our time and place we may opt to roll the dice and let it fall where it may. Regardless you cannot have both (if either in truth).
But I would say that if you fall on the security and safety side of the fence (which is okay), then do not ask for it, thenquestion the methods in which that security is provided.
After reading about this in the newspaper, obama was visibly outraged. immediatley after having threatened anyone who may be able to provide a link to himself, obama advised his press to announce that he has directed the AG to conduct a full investigation, bringing all parties to justice-especially if they work for fox and are innocent. obama then indicated that going forward, he has instructed his new security secretary to have someone besides herself write daily breifings on the matter (subject to stylistic changes) to which the president promised to personally attend about 60% of the time, depending how close it is to golf, beddie-bye, or any standard awol period.
above for immediate release per valerie jarrett, with instruction any deviation will result in accusations of racism.
Linda,
I do not share your cavalier attitude, misinformed and confused reaction to the infringement of our constitutional rights, by shrugging it off as a non-scandal. Fortunately, there are many, like me, still guard our sacred rights from violations by the federal government and from the indifference you appear to project.
Failed logic Jon. It's called "Post Hoc."
It's my opinion, not a fact...deal with it.
Len,
this is only the first as I see it and I'm not even sure it qualifies as a scandal per se.
This started aover a decade ago the recording of Cell phone calls. At one point in time the location was in Kentucky but was moved. Also another location in Australia which wasreported years ago. Obama didn't start it and nor will he stop it. Any signal radiated Radio waves is monitorable all internet communications are by wire and wirelessradiated and monitored. Wake up and smell the bull shit. I understand Texas politician satated men with Beards are identifiable Muslims she was the President of the Texas republican party. Must be arsnic in the water in Texas as Texans are brain dead. Arizona Politicians and sherrifs must drink the same water.
Actually way longer thanseven yearssite in Kentucky has been closed for that long or longer. Maybe 25 years could be a little more or slightly less. Court approved you could be right.
Why do you think the Public has a right to know everythiing. Like the press telling how information was gathered and is used to fight terrorism. How do you think terrorist are identified? Man the water in this country must have a higher and higher lead content maybe because of all the lead bullets being shot and laying on the ground and in trees and in the ground. Each one leaching a little more lead in ground water rivers ponds and streams. Do you know what lead does to the body see what the half lead fillings in your teeth are doing to your body think the material is called amalgum.If its all made public then it doesn't work does anybody understand. Kind of like telling whichway your military members will attack time direction and mode of transport. This whole topic is lunacy. Idiotic bat shit nuts.
AeonPax
I think if you would familiarize yourself with what the constitution is, what it says and doesnt say, and keep abreast of the many laws that are passed in this country (patriot act)?, you might find that (its all in yer head!), so t speak......
It really does help to be informed, it causes much less anxiety!
EI:
Of course Obama knew. This was the most widely spread shot to date, that we know of. Which is not to say that it hasn't happened before in this admin, or it won't happen again. To assert that this is, somehow, just a little "factoid" of which the president should not know, is, to say the least, disingenuous. After all, Obama is, supposedly, briefed daily.
Just like he didn't know about the IRS targeting, the press targeting, and all the other little "factoids" that are now coming out (no thanks to the American Press, by the way).
As to the technology issue, anyone who wishes to rid this Country of freedom can use any excuse they want. Those who wish to preserve it will create ways to do so, no matter the technology.
The real issue here is that it was comprehensive, and mostly American citizens!
And you're right, hysteria doesn't help, but coordinated action to try to regain those freedoms we have lost, and are losing, would be a good thing.
I find it fascinating that though Obama is doing EXACTLY what he previously criticized Bush for doing (though Bush didn't even come CLOSE to this sort of surveillance), everyone seems willing to give him a pass.
When Bush passed the Patriot Act, many, including myself, were critical of it as it was not solely directed to FOREIGN terrorists. WE are now seeing the result of that.
Ah, yes, the old "it's all about race."
I wonder, will you racist folks ever got off your racist hobby horses?
That is pretty disgusting, isn't it?
To them, it's all about race. The guy commits murder, and it's his detractors who are bad, because they are racist!
And, don't forget, the IRS is now the "new nigger!"
God, what asshats.
Linda's attitude leads to brown shirts, plain and simple.
Yup, it's always about the police power, when you get right down to it. Government has it, corps don't.
SCOPE is different, EI.
What's also amazing is how one person criticizes another for the use of such power, but then when he has the power and uses it, it becomes "a necessary tool!"
Only a "tool" would say such a thing, actually.
Please keep off the slippery slope my friend. At issue is the deliberate and secret violation of our constitutional liberties as privacy is, NOT a person's deliberate approval of communicating on the internet where it is stated in writing by ISP's, etc, that as a Term Of Service, you give up that right to privacy.
Phone calls have been legally classified as a constitutionally protected right of privacy ...don't ya know?
At the risk of sounding sarcastic, I don't suppose you ever heard of the Fourth Amendment to the United States Constitution which guards us from the arbitrary and capricious violation of our rights, just so that the government can go on fishing expeditions without "due process" on each individual case.
It has been said;
He (or She) who sacrifices freedom for security deserves neither.
Well, Fly, flip it around.
Is horrific torture alright if it prevents a terrorist attack?
Is it alright if it prevents the murder of a child?
Of an adult?
A rape?
Just where do you call the end game?
Note also, this was against American citizens, one of them being myself. Is there no longer any difference between an American citizen and a foreigner, as concerns our threat level?
The FBI has, for several years, been trying to FORCE all software makers to include "back doors" into their software so that the FBI or other governmental agencies can easily hack into anyone's computer.
How do you feel about that? What if the providers have ALREADY done that, and we don't know it?
What happened to the 4th amendment? Do you really care?
And we're worried about protecting the "privacy" rights of mentally ill folks when they go to buy a weapon!
That is fricking hilarious!
Aeon:
So far this admin has argued that they have the absolute right, without a warrant to attach a gps system to your car without your knowledge and to track you where ever you go.
Why is it you are surprised at this?
I noticed that neither one of you answered the simple question that put to you.
wmolaw.... As you have never had the privilege of being interrogated by professionals you will never understand how or believe that physical torture yields less information than other methods do. So no, physical torture is unnecessary.
Now I've answered your question, please answer mine.
Not to mention that just a few months ago, the intelligence agencies, well, they FUCKING LIED!
Nothing to see here, right folks?
EI,
1) I obviously answered John's question to YOUR dissatisfaction. Shit happens.
2) Oh, you mean the "super secret" Federal Intelligence Surveillance Act of which the American public was not aware that a federal judge SECRETLY gave the government approval to go carte blanche sifting through millions of private phone calls, hoping to find something?
You mean that FISA? Naw, never heard of it.
3) You seem to be unaware that when a government does things to hide the truth from the American public, legal or not, then gets caught, that they can fall back on the law as a flimsy defense? Just because they have a right to do it does NOT mean it's the right thing to do.
4) Touche.
5) Again, your opinion. My logic tells me that when an action so big as to spy on the phone calls of millions of Americans is made, the president, in this case, Obama, has to be in on it... either that or he is as clueless and inept as to allow subordinates to run things without his approval. - You can't have it both ways.
6) Technology simply is not involved in this...period, mentioned or not, no matter how much is claimed or otherwise obfuscate or prevaricate this matter.
7) My Google comment is FACT. It's called Transparency, something our government doesn't practice and something Google does voluntarily.
"I have NOT formed an opinion as to whether this 'crosses a line' " - I have and at this point am expecting spins from the government, media, democrats and republicans on this.
Really, RMER? Just lunacy right?
Well then, let's just get rid of the right to privacy, okay with you?
I mean, come on! Worrying about that type of shit is just "bat shit nuts." right?
Yeah, right!
Why do you think the Public has a right to know everythiing.
Who's to decide what "everything is? The Government which lies? The political parties that lie? The corporations that lie? You realize there is a massive creditability issue here. I might be willing to give the government the benefit of of doubt IF it had a history of being upfront with the public, which it has not.
Fortunately, I did not have to depend on misinformed posters on an internet forum to teach me about the Constitution. Thank you for your misapplied concern but it's not needed, wanted nor desired.
At this point, as we say in Wisconsin, "It's a horse a piece."
As if 95% of the folks here have read the Constitution and "kept abreast" of the many laws. Here is what is happening to our rights:
And most just don't care. After all, it only affects bad guys, right?
Clearly they have never heard of Martin Niemller , or they just don't give a shit.
No, not all the way EI, not all the way. Even if that were true, that does not mean we should stand by and not try to resurrect them.
EI if everyone involved in this discussian would take your advice and research FISA a lot of their questions would be answered. Requesting of the documents were likely done by Congress not the President or possibly NSA. I would suspect following the Boston Marathon every bit of communication was examined filtered examined and refiltered. Ei thanks there have been several changes made that I wasn't aware of and even that Wikki write up may not be all inclusive. But if nothing it will Identify George W. and Lindsey Grahm and a ton of other Republicans and yes Democratic members but in much lesser numbers probably due to Bush being president. Thanks I think you must have a cray computer attached to your brain. Good work good explanation on how to find the real answers.
its ok, its being done by obama
GOsearch forFISA and see what has been done with your priivacy. Homeland security to a lesser degree the laws basically already existed. Privacy there really isn't any. I'm afraid to give total privacy which we all really would like to have we give the ability to operate a terrorist cell that same right and protection. Initial Identification is the real issue first contact.
I have read several articles that the SCOPE of this was "unprecedented."
There is no doubt but that FISA courts have been around for some time, hell, the lefties/liberals were SCREAMING about them when Bush was president.
Interestingly, however, they have been very, very silent since Obama is doing the same.
Note also, as pointed out by Aeon, these are private courts, we are not INFORMED of what they have been doing for, well, since they began!
We only discovered this due to informers.
...
Note, Feinstein is completely unreliable.
As I posted in another post, just a couple of months ago, the intelligence agencies testified to CONGRESS that they were NOT collecting information on US Citizens.
In short, they lied, have been lying.
wmolaw,
I'm not surprised by this. I did not not vote for Obama this election because of his past dismal record on civil rights and liberties; among other things.
John, when the EFF (The Electronic Frontier Foundation) starts to bypass this as a technological issue in favor of a constitutional violation, I'll side with them.
We differ on this...nothing personal.
Here's the problem EI, it's probably Constitutional, but that's NOT the issue. Hell, given SCOTUS over the last fifty years, pretty much EVERYTHING is Constitutional.
What it really is, citizens must make up their minds what kind of Country they want. Do they wish a completely centralized government controlling every aspect of their lives?
Or do they wish for freedom, understanding that freedom is messier, more dangerous?
No....I used the word "upfront" which means "straightforward, in advance". Had the government made it known publicly that because of national security issues, they needed to comb through millions of telephone calls, I might have been acquiescent but they did this secretly with the express intention of hiding it from the public.
Coming from you, I take that as a compliment.
Guess what? I didn't say it wasn't legally done. Jump to conclusions, must we?
The government has been legally obtaining warrants to spy on "individuals" for longer than seven years. What makes this situation unique is it involves MILLIONS of innocent citizens.
Big difference.
It is PAST time to repeal the Patriot Act!
Why is ANYBODY defending this? Quite possibly, this is the BIGGEST most BLATANT attack on the Constitution that has ever existed in the 200+ year history of this country. Why isn't everybody outraged?
Big brother is watching you and you don't Care???????
To the best of my knowledge, there is NOTHING in the Constitution which gives Congress the right to violate the Constitution.
Oh Snap!
Its obviously Bush's fault.
NSA's Verizon records collection: "Calm down," Reid says
If you read (or view the video the link goes to) you'll see/hear Harry Reid, start the Democratic party spin stating it's a program that has been in effect for seven years...."this isn't anything that is brand new."
Does he mean to say that Congress has allowed the government, through the FISA, to troll through MILLIONS of innocent citizens phone calls looking for years looking for god knows what?
Let there be no mistake here, the applications for surveillance orders from the FISA court are nonadversarial, which means the target of the investigation is not represented. In the colloquial, it's called "fishing".
People need to get enraged at this. I can understand individual, legal, court approved surveillance on specific targets but not wholesale trolling through people's private phone calls.
It's also time people realize, as I've been saying for years....there is no difference to the political parties as both signed off on this.
Who represents the privacy interests of ordinary Americans before the secret intelligence court? The answer; No one.
Until someone is irrevocably harmed, WE THE PEOPLE have no standing.
The surveillance is "limited?" It's "supervised"? Limited to WHAT and supervised by WHOM? That's like saying it's OK to rape a woman as long as a man "supervises" it so it doesn't get TOO violent!
Still wrong. Whether or not a Judge signed off on it, or the FISA court signed off on it, I will remind you that many, many, many, many SCOTUS decisions have OVERTURNED the decisions of other judges and courts.
....and you know this how? Are you employed by the government or acting in the capacity of a person who has first hand knowledge of this?
Paranoid? I think not John. It's called "passion". I am passionate about my legal rights and the rights of others...human rights, civil rights, gay rights and women's rights.
All the talk about this spying on the American public being legal, is a joke. Apparently our government and it's partisan party supporters have forgotten something called "civil disobedience" and the fact that this country was founded on that.
Those Tea Party loons aside, England legally taxed the inhabitants of their colonies which they had militarily supported during the infamous "French and Indian" war. A capitalist would see the logic in that. However, the colonists didn't see it that way. Taxation without representation, is tyranny.
In the same vein, the Americans now don't cotton to being spied on without their knowledge by a paternalistic government with a long history of lying and just by claiming it's "legal" (like the Tea and Coercive Acts) isn't going to make this go away.
While it is unfortunate that this incident came out while the far-right wingnuts are mindlessly gorging themselves during their scandal orgy...shit happens.
"Legal" and "Right" are not synonymous words.
We differ here. What you see as "mass hysteria", I see as an awakening by people whom have been lied to and deceived.
EI...At the very least, the enemy will know that this means of intelligence gathering is out there and it will make their methods of communications more difficult. Who knows, we still might catch some of the stupid ones as is
Don't worry, the euphoria will soon wear off. Enjoy it while you can.
lucky for obama, he can still blame bush!
cant wait to hear how "rev" al pronounces national security tonight.