Unfriggin' believable
"The Indian Citizenship Act of 1924, also known as the Snyder Act, was proposed by Representative Homer P. Snyder (R) of New York and granted full U.S. citizenship to America's indigenous peoples, called "Indians" in this Act. (The Fourteenth Amendment already defined as citizens any person born in the U.S., but only if "subject to the jurisdiction thereof"; this latter clause was thought to exclude certain indigenous peoples.) The act was signed into law by President Calvin Coolidge on June 2, 1924. It was enacted partially in recognition of the thousands of Indians who served in the armed forces in WWI."
The text of the 1924 Indian Citizenship Act (43 U.S. Stats. At Large, Ch. 233, p.253 (1924)) reads as follows:
BE IT ENACTED by the Senate and house of Representatives of the United States of America in Congress assembled, That all non citizen Indians born within the territorial limits of the United States be, and they are hereby, declared to be citizens of the United States: Provided That the granting of such citizenship shall not in any manner impair or otherwise affect the right of any Indian to tribal or other property." Approved, June 2, 1924. June 2, 1924. [H. R. 6355.] [Public, No. 175.] SIXTY-EIGHTH CONGRESS. Sess. I. CHS. 233. 1924. See House Report No. 222, Certificates of Citizenship to Indians, 68th Congress, 1st Session, Feb. 22, 1924. Note: This statute has been codified in the United States Code at Title 8, Sec. 1401(b).
Imagine - having lived on and protectedyour own lands for thousands of years, being finally made a citizen of the peoples who took everything you had????
Tags
Who is online
93 visitors

Although some white citizen groups were supportive of Indian citizenship, Indians themselves were mixed in the debate. Those that supported it considered the Act a way to secure a long-standing political identity. Those that rejected it were worried about tribal sovereignty and citizenship. Many leaders in the Native American community at the time, like Charles Santee, a Santee Sioux, was interested in Native American integration into the larger society, but was adamant about preserving the Native American identity. Many were also reluctant to trust the government that had taken their land and discriminated so violently against them.
One active assimilation proponent of the early 20th century, Dr. Joseph K. Dixon, wrote (referring to soldiers who served in World War I):
Unfriggin' believable
That would be the "might makes right" philosophy of life with an un-healthy dose of arrogance thrown in for good measure.
It's like creating a new countrybased onfreedom and equality under the law; while owning slaves.
I didn't know about the Snyder Act. It may have been necessary at the time to clarify definitions. I could see that.
My Grandfather fought in the Spanish American war. My Father and his 3 brothers all fought in WWI where he was gassed in France which led tohis early death. My 4 brothers and I all fought in WWII with only 3 of us surviving and all wounded.I would say that as Indians, Tsalagi,my family has paid its dues!
Sorry tsula... I don't delineate. Your FAMILY has paid it's dues as citizens of the United States many times over, and paid the dues owed by many others by the same amount. That is quite an honor sir.
There always seems to be the compulsion to explain our history though and my family's in particular! I thank you sir for your kind words!
As usual, John has his blinders on...
While they were the First People to emigrate to the North/South American continents, the concept of owning land was foreign to the Native Americans, to wit:
The Indians had no concept of "private property," as applied to the land. Only among the Delawares was it customary for families, during certain times of the year, to be assigned specific hunting territories. Apparently this was an unusual practice, not found among other Indians. Certainly, the idea of an individual having exclusive use of a particular piece of land was completely strange to Native Americans. -
Native Americans believe they are closely linked with the land and everything that grows on the land or lives on the land. Because of this belief, the idea of "owning" land did not exist among the Native Americans. They lived off the land, but did not consider that they owned it - ...
Any arguments about land ownership today, stems from treaty and other promises made by the American government, which they broke.
Bye-bye John. When you're ready to actually think and DISCUSS this topic - drop on by.
Wow Aeon - please, please, please show me where I even mentioned "Owning" land - my comment was living and protecting - not owning - huge difference.
Also, I want you to show me where you got your anthropological/archaeological "proof" that we "were the First People" to emigrate" - hint - if you're the First here - duh.
Now, let's discuss the topic.
Thanks.
You're a good man FLYNAVY1.
Let me make this really simple for you and Aeon John - the lands you live on do not give you OWNERSHIP - they give you residency - nothing more. We have never and can never OWN the land - that's something dominant society thinks they can do - own everything within their reach.
Here's a question Chief Seattle asked - that, as usual and unfortunately, dominant society has yet to answer - "How can you buy or sell the sky, the warmth of the land? The idea is strange to us. If we do not own the freshness of the air and the sparkle of the water, how can you buy them? Every part of this earth is sacred to my people. Every shining pine needle, every sandy shore, every mist in the dark woods, every clearing and humming insect is holy in the memory and experience of my people. The sap which courses through the trees carries the memories of the Red Man. How can you sell Mother Earth who has given you life and nourishment for all of your days. How can you sell what you don't own?"
Now - get back on the topic of U. S. Citizenship "given" to the Indians 89 years ago - and why it was given.
Thanks.
Ouch, ouch, ouch - you caught me. Now Mr. Derailer, show me in the article where there is any mention, by me, of "white bashing". OOppppps.
Get back on topic John.
Beautiful! As part of the "citizenship" thingy, my Grandfather took a job as a guard at a Ma prison because he was a crack shot and pretty formidable in person. Suddenly he was fired for no reason. No reason wound up being that Civil Service had just been passed and he, because he was an Indian, was not considered to be a citizen and thus fired.
Darn EI - I thought it was chartreuse 'cause it was less easy to blend
John - I'm attempting to teach a part of history that is not covered in any of the school history books. Why, I don't know. But the terminology of the message is not subject to analysis as I didn't write the original, therefore will not defend the author's words. However, attempting to pick apart a word to derail the subject thatwas not based onthe "word" is not discussion - it is an attempt to change the subject to something you are comfortable with.
You really need to get comfortable with learning history - or anything else you are not familiar with - and quit nit-picking in anattempt to change the topic to something you are comfortable with - both of you.
We are able to go on because of people like you Robert G. And I thank you for that.
''Stop worrying about us and do whatever it is you are doing here....Perfect John, you have no idea of what is obvious to most.
I don't know, who else deserves bashing within the context of this topic and period in history. The Buffalo Soldiers? The victors and perpetrators were/are the dominant culture which is white and European.
I think it is important to expose history to the rabble. Hell, most Americans are sadly bereft of any knowledge of our history other than the "we soar like an Eagle" pablum they got in their history text. If they bothered to read even that. It's not like 19th century history isn't relevant to our current sit rep either. In many ways the Rez in the US is like an ignored Third World country within our border.
These articles are a good thing.
Tex - now you just blew my mind. Not that many people know the link of the Buffalo Soldiers and the Native Americans. Would you feel up to seeding the history and the outcome? Thank you, that is so cool.
EI - there's a whole slew of things that many folks don't understand about the Native philosophy. Example - the richest person is the tribe was usually the person who had to least personal effects (horse, clothing, hides, weapons, food, etc.) because "most" tribal cultures believed, truly, that it is better to give than it is to receive - unlike dominant society. That person would give all they have to others who are in need and, as such, would gain the admiration and protection of the entire tribe.
Can't beat that, eh?
It's a pretty fascinating subject, for certain sure. Not to insult their fierceness and bravery, but I've always felt sort of sad about those guys. Newly freed folks used as an arm of conquest and genocide.
You know, they were involved in the National Park system as rangers in the late 1800's. It may be that they were responsible for the Montana Peak style hat worn by rangers to this day.
If I can find the time I'll post something. Life in the working class is kind of a shyte sammich these days with a copious helping of creamy shyte in every tasty bite. Considering the quest to keep beans and rice on the table and not be living in a refrigerator box down at the China Mart parking lot it may take awhile to get the time for a proper article. We'll see.
best atcha
History is important. It should not be dismissed as white and US bashing. We should examine the bad as well as the good.
Exposure is a good thang. If anything is ever to change one has to examine how it got this way in the first place.
John, believe me, you are not getting insulted - truly. The difficulty folks haveis that you don't discuss the subject matter - you pick a section of the subject and tear apart the wording - every time.
No, we're not overboard pc and over sensitive. Initially, our intent is to give a more in-depth knowledge of history dealing with our peoples. Unfortunately, that history has a habit of making many people feel very, very uncomfortable and they automatically begin to "fight" with us. Instead, they should try to develop an understanding and an interest is what is being displayed.
I'd ask you to do the same. Quit picking something out and going off on a tangent that has nothing to do with the thread/discussion.
Thanks for your feedback - helps me understand better.
What's interesting 'bout that picture Tex is - I work the Cultural resources for the DoD. The Corp of Engineers was getting ready to raze a building in New Orleansand build over it's foundation. What they found was a cemetery of Houma, Coshatta/Choctaw and Seminole from the ol' slave ring under the building they razed. Wow - we had a lot of consultation over that one.
Yeah. Ol Ron Cobb is a masterful cartoonist. Great stuff.
A friend of mine may have found the lost village where, Shyte, I'm having a brain fart, de Soto? died on the Alabama/Mississippi line. The Auburn U Archeology department is researching presently. If they do an official dig it's looking like I will be the archeological illustrator. Sadly, for me, no yankee dollars involved but I'll be able to sit in the sun and draw artifacts. Long as they feed me.
Remember, it wasn't until 1879 in the ''Standing Bear'' trial that Indians were considered ''people'', in the eyes of the government.
Basically, it's what Kavika is about on all participatory journalism sites. Just do a search of his screen name on Newsvine for verification.
Respectfully, his entire existence is centered upon his "race".
I cannot imagine waking up daily and continually focusing upon the past injustices experienced by the Irish. Understandable as a hobby but not as an obsession that encompasses an entire onlinepresence.
Kettle, meet black...(while seeing only red)?
I've always felt sorry and angry and frustrated with their situation. As you said - newly freed, hired (?) to "round up" rabble rousing Indians (see Geronimo/Cochise/Roman Nose/Nanta), catching some, releasing some, killing some - a first class Catch-22 'cause they knew exactly what the Indians were about.
Thanks - that would be awesome.
Further verification that the topic is beyond your limited comprehension.
It's isn't about past societal ills and injustices but focusing one's online existence. (i.e. your perpetual bigotry and prejudices).
Once again, you have (inadvertently)proven my point.
Thanks for the plug bluearcher, but I didn't post this article. If it bothers you so much why do you participate?....Shouldn't you be addressing the author? Oh sorry, you have a problem with just me...Well, to bad, deal with it.
I can't imagine waking up in your skin bluearcher, what a burden that must be...
Tex - the Spanish were instructed to toss his body in the river from a boat so my tribe (Chickasaw) couldn't get at it and do what we think it should have deserved. Damm new warrior who didn't know how to use a bow properly only gave him a gut shot. Yeah, 1541 was a very good year for us. After the de Soto route, none of dominant society came to visit us for 'bout 150 years - yeppers - we shure felt neglected, ya know?
So? It doesn't change the facts @ my statement.
You wear your "race" upon your sleeve promoting sympathy for the plight but ignoring culpability for the multitude of societal ills Native Americans create and experience.
No. You should have a problem with your perpetual perception and promotion of victimization.
Because you are too self absorbed with your own. That's the point. Now do you get it?
I'll repeat it bluearcher...DEAL WITH IT, now do you get the point!!!!!!
BTW, your derailing the article. Isn't that a violation of the CoC?
Very very harsh statement of condemnation: ignoring culpability for the multitude of societal ills Native Americans create and experience. Show me irrefutable proof of this indictment please! Show me exactly where the American Indians (you call us Native Americans but I am an INDIAN, Tsalagi)created societal ills for the rest of the citizens from the confines of our concentration camps built forus by the White Man, including the Irish,and where they still are confined! You are worried about the problems that the Irish had when they flooded this country because of their own self inducedfamine. Compare that to governmentally approved genocide and you come up sadly wanting. Go away, troll!!
Based upon the caps and exclamation points in your response...you're the one not dealing with it so well.
Nice dodge and deflection. When cornered, scream FOUL!
Comment removed for CoC violation
LMAO...No worries, it's just me that drives him up the wall...and that's a good thing as far as I'm concerned.
Google Native American alcoholism rates on and off reservations.
Google domestic abuseamongNative Americans.
Google unemployment rates among Native Americans.
Google high school and college graduation rates among Native Americans.
Actually, I am not....you missed the pointentirely.
Nicely said! Truly, thank you!!I should be so articulate! I have a tendency as shown to simply get pissed off at ignorance and revert to my original savage self!
bluearcher - I KNOW you didn't come to this thread to create havoc. If you did, I think we can get that fixed.
IMHO, if you had, indeed, googled the data/information you list below, you'd be singing an entirely different tune. The information gained from that data "should" give you additional fodder to discuss in favor of this particular thread.
All of these so called arguments you place before the court were created by, and are now supported, and encouraged, by the keepers of the keys to the domestic concentration camps, the White Man. Arguments dismissed, as are you!
No dodge bluearcher, you are derailing the article. The caps and exclamation points were there for you, since you didn't understand it the first time.
Comment removed for context Never fight with idiots, they'll drag you to their level and beat you with experience..
Not even a good try bluearcher.
@flameaway,
What you have just described is the Native American legend of the birth of the Weendigo, the most horrifying creature in Indian lore. It is born of greed and devours everything around until it feeds upon itself, leaving nothing.
That is what is happening to the resources of Earth in the name of progress, spurred by the never ending claws grasping for energy and fuel.
Yes, don't ever forget that the Spanish are white also. But there have been non-whites who have gone on conquering sprees. How about the Khans?
And this has what to do with the article John? Would you like me to link you to the atrocities by the Spanish, and SpanishMissionariesto the SW Indians?
There are times when I get my timelines confused. I blame it on the voices.
John - this is what the article is about - "The Indian Citizenship Act of 1924, also known as the Snyder Act, was proposed by Representative Homer P. Snyder (R) of New York and granted full U.S. citizenship to America's indigenous peoples, called "Indians" in this Act"
If you or any of your like types put one more post on this thread that does not discuss what the article discusses, I will ask the moderators to keep you off of all of my lists.
Clear?
John, I don't know why you believe that the site portray's NA as saintly and extremely noble beings. I have never said in any of my articles.Neither did I say wedidn't have wars among the tribes. It is you thatis interperting that. The one thing that we didn't do is commit genocide.If you like it or not, that is what happened. As for the things that justhappened to our ancestors, that is completly false. I suggest that you undate youself on what has happened, and is still happening to Indians to this day. If you need links or personal experience I'll be happy to help you. Should we start with 1900 and move forward through today?
We are discussing the Americas John, and that is the white man, or the European if you prefer. To try to excuse or avoid that, is simply ignoring the truth. If you would like to hear the truth, and not some B.S. history book you'll see how, to this day they are trying to marginalize us.
You ready for the challenge John? Why don't we start with the ''tribal termination act''...1953 to 1973. You were alive than, were you not?
Didn't realize your reading comprehension level had dropped so low.
Please quit posting.
1stwarrior, Mike the moderator posted on here that if you request it he will delete all off topic comments.
BadFish, I'm trying very hard not to laugh at that...It's not working, LMAO
So, you didn't read Mike's warning, did you? What does any of that have to do with the American Indian Citizenship Act of 1924???? Please - seriously, enlighten me.
If you want to discuss the subject of the thread - I'll be glad to discuss it. So far, nine pages later, you have yet to offer any discussion regarding the American Indian Citizenship Act of 1924.
Please quit posting.
I just saw Wrath of Khan. Does that count?
1 - John summed up my objection, insofar that "your" is a pronoun indicating ownership or possession. "Your own lands" clearly indicates ownership or possession. However, as you stated you meant "residency", that explains it.
2 - Scientifically, the American continents did not spawn any indigenous humans so they any people here had to emigrate (the act of leaving one's country or region with the intent to settle permanently in another) here. However, that word was poorly chosen. I should have said "migrated" here.
3 - The topic; I will admit that the Synder Act shows condescension but in a country of laws (like them or not) such an Act (however late it was) was a necessary hypocrisy.
Excuse me all to hell BUT I addressed two questions brought forth to me by the OP. If I may add, YOUR comment (as well as mine right now) are not on topic either. - Sheesh!
Flame, it's not just this article by 1stwarrior, it's everything posted with hopes of educating nt members regarding Indians that is attacked. Although I'm inclined to let JR babble on, I would rather that he accepted my challenge to discuss a specificgovernment lawthat happened in his life time to Indians. I suppose that I'm dreaming that he would have the courage to do it, but one can always hope.
I rather agree with Flameaway. The more John talks the more it becomes apparent he has no concept at all of the Indian culture or thought process or his spiritual center or connection to the land and Nature.
The answers that you, Gunny, and 1stwarrior, Kavika, and others give are teaching anyone who reads this thread about history and about us as well, regardless of how John tries to derail, because you know what you are talking about and he only thinks he does.
He still hasn't grasped the concept of why we are so indignant over being offered citizenship in a country where our ancestors lived long before the white man ever "discovered" it.
Agreed. Keep talking and allow the comments to continue freely. Somewhere along the lines, we of European decent will learn something by osmosis at the very least.
I had the privilege of growing up in a town that had a large NA population due to having Haskel Indian Junior College as part of its makeup. From grade school through senior high, we had a much larger than average exposure to NA culture, and I know I'm better for the knowledge gained.
Mike is not a moderator. He's not, is he?
Not that I'm against moderation... and staying on topic.
You mean that little Jr. College that grew up into a full fledged college? I've got a number of friends who went there and they say the camaraderie and educational benefits are outstanding.
To me, one of the more interesting aspects of the AICA is that by the time it was passed, there were only 'bout 250K Indians left, according to the census. Of those, approximately 3/4th's of them were already citizens through the Allotment process or Executive Order or through choice.The passage of the Act really didn't benefit any more than 60K Indians, of which 1/2 of them declined the offer. Congress wanted the Indians assimilated in the worst way and they figured that by giving the Indians citizenship, the Indians would automatically "want" to become like dominant society.
Well, this plan didn't have the "A" Team ending, eh?
Yes. That is where I grew up.
It was a Jr. College when I was growing up. I didn't know that it was a full fledged college today. As I said, as a kid growing up, with the likes of Haskel, and the University of Kansas in the same town, the cultural and educational exposure growing up was phenomenal. All with a resident population of about 30K.
Mike is a moderator on News Talkers.
Just shock and awe.
John, you are talking at cross purposes with everyone here because you won't stick to the subject... which is the lack of understanding and insight into the Indian psyche that we would be amazed that the white government would think it could by any stretch of the imagination feel empowered to offer citizenship to a People who have inhabited this land long before Europeans ever arrived.
That is the discussion. That's it. Can you go there are stay?
Aeon - if you had come across like above on your first post, there would have been a lot of angst avoided.
# 3 - Some day, if you're really interested, I can talk with you about the lead-up to that "condescension" starting with the Trilogy Cases handled by Chief Justice Marshall. As a hint, it starts with his term of "wards"/"dependent nations" - talk about a diochotomy.
Obviously, you don't understand thedefinitionof irony.
Nice try.Accuseothers of what you are guilty of. Typically conservative.
Play on, online bigot. Agreed?
Nice try. The caps and exclamation points are reflective of your inability to refute my observations.
Typical position of the losing side. Name-call the victor.
It must be a "good try" since it's a victory.
bluearcher, please take this elsewhere. Your comments have been deleted before for this. Step back, and take a deep breath. Leave the article, or behave in a civil manner. Please consider this to be your warning. MTM
Only a victory in your mind bluearcher.
Comment removed due to context stillusing your comment from a prior article, didn't work than, won't work now. If I remember correctly didn't all your comments from that article get deleted?
Time to try something new bluearcher.
Actually, "white" is ALL colors!
Egilman - I'd like to discuss some of your points with you. How 'bout supplying me with some links to your points.
Sorry guys but my 2 yr old grandson can take his finger paint set and mix all the colors together and the end result sure isn't "white" its more of a plum black. true albinism is a genetic defect that all 3 races( yes there are ONLY 3, caucasoid , mongoloid and negroid, anything else is a blend of those 3 ) and is an absence of the pigment that controls the skins coloration what we really are talking about is ethenticity as in ethnic groups , NA is an ethnic group , as for the discussion on the Snyder act well it was along time coming and like it or not , there isn't a square centimeter of this planet that wasn't taken from one ethenticity by another when they got to the area. no side is innocent in this discussion and I say this as a mixed blood of many different nationalities AND ethenticities, and am proud of all of them they all have their good points and bad , what you choose to do is what matters . so sign me as a Heinz 57 American mutt with roots from almost all over the world .
Morning from here Flame.
I agree, and have said it before. This country needs another mountain to climb like we had with the space program in the 1960. Unfortunately I think the math and science skills we had back then were superior to that our kids end up with today.
Bluearcher, I can see no purpose here other than to disturb the discussion. This whole thread was set up by you to be off topic and a boarderline personal attack on Kavika. Next time, all the comments that resemble anything like this will be deleted, even those not made by you, for the sake of the discussion.
Sweet Jesus......
Lighten up.... all of you.
John Russell, regarding comment:
That is certainly true john, violence is a part of human instinct and can be found all over the world in all of the different human families around the world.
But, there is violence and then their is violence.
Violence seems to be more potent and dangerous from the European side of the equation.
By that I mean that while it is certainly true that one can find equal appitites for acts of gross, disqusting violence from all parts of the human family.
It is also true that our European brothers have a particular talent for using their gift of intelligence towards the invention of weapons that kill on a massive scale.
Correct me if I am wrong, but there were no Africans or Chinese or Native Americans participating when the Atomic bomb was being created, I think the white guys were in charge of that one.
Again; correct me if I am wrong, in WW2 the machinery of the industrial revolution was used for the extermination of millions of human-beings on an industrial scale in factories of death, never seen before in history.
And that was thought up and excecuted by the white guys. (the so called Superior Nazi white guys)
The inventions of biological and chemical weapons that kill on anindustrial scale was thought up by the white guys too.
When it comes to violence the white guys seem to prefer using their intelligence in useless ways, by concentrating on figuring out how to kill a lot of people very fast.
And they have shown themselves to be very good at coming up with new ways to do just that.
As I said there is violence and then their is violence.
I was married to a violent man, so violent he tried to kill me more than once. He continued his violence after I filed for divorce. He stalked me, stole from me and worked hard to ruin my reputation. When he wasn't doing this, he was bringing me flowers and asking me to return to the marriage. When I refused his overtures, he whined, "You only remember the bad stuff. There were good times too."
This schizophrenic socialization reminds me of the whites who used similar tactics against the Indians and then offered them flowers in the form of "citizenship." I"m glad this stupidity is being revealed and ridiculed. Our nation needs to stop covering up its horrendous deeds of the past, and whites need to learn what we really inherited from those falsely glamorized figures in the white man's history books.
I see a couple of people here telling the Indians posting here to "just get over it." Same thing I heard, even as he continued his abuse. As long as the abuse is continuing, there is no "just getting over it." As long as the abuse lives in memory, there is no "just getting over it." The abuse and its results become a part of the person who experienced the abuse. They can no more erase it from their Self than they can erase their body or brain.
The people who tell others to "just get over it" are usually the people who are continuing the abuse. They want to be free to continue abusing without having to face the consequences. Well, there are consequences to every deed. If anyone wants better consequences, they need to change their tactics and commit better deeds. Or they need to just go away and stop persecuting those who have already suffered enough.
Mashkawide'e