The "Cliff Effect" When Working Americans Have to Turn Down Pay Raises
What's wrong with this picture. You start off working at the bottom and through hard work you get a promotion. It's wonderful until you start to do the math. This is the problem with many blue collar jobs. It's called the "Cliff Effect" It hurts these families and it hurts the US economy.
Visit NBCNews.com for #999;font-weight:normal;height:13px;color:#5799db;" href="http://www.nbcnews.com"> breaking news , #999;font-weight:normal;height:13px;color:#5799db;"> world news , and #999;font-weight:normal;height:13px;color:#5799db;"> news about the economy
Civility required.
Tags
Who is online
93 visitors

More and more folks falling into this predicament. Only one solution I can think of,,,we'll have to start renting our kids out as slave labor rather than putting them into childcare.
I think that raising the income limit of child care would be a big help. These folks want to work and shouldn't be penalized for hard work. By raising the child care limit, not only will they be able to climb economically, but they will also be making more money, which will be taxed. It's a win/win.
Can you clarify bring up the gap. By what means and where? In the case of this fellow, all that was needed was that the child care cut off wasn't so low.
I disagree. If you are barely making ends meet at 30K but you still get you childcare which is worth say 10k a year, then 40 K would be the break even point. Anyone making more than that would be nuts not to take the pay raise. They are working still and will then be paying more into the tax base. It is human nature to try to maximize their income.
Raising the min wage might not cut it for this guy, if the cut off for child care remains the same.
I never knew about this either Barb. That is why I thought it was worth sharing. I'd love to know the stats on this issue.
Well that is definitely one idea, EI. There are many solutions to this issue, but it still needs to be addressed.
Here is one. Tax incentives to businesses who help pay for child care. This would be a win/win/win/ The business gets an incentive, the employee gets the help they need to move up the economic ladder and it lessons the burden on the government.
But of all the entitlements out there, the one that I think that gets abused the least is child care. You either work and have kids or you don't get anything. But I surely don't feel that any working person should be discouraged to do better because they are at that cliff. What incentive is there to do better?
I've seen this at least a hundred times....people refusing raises, people refusing higher paying jobs, because of this "cliff effect" (I never knew it had a name) The cut off of benefits is so sharp and if you ask me, arbitrary, it screws the people whom depend on them.
Rather than this draconian method, I'd just as soon use a system that "weans" people off of public benefits gradually.
Yeah! If we assist deadbeats like this, how the fuck can we subsidize those corporations (and continue to allow them to operate tax free while putting their profits in offshore tax havens)?
It's about priorities people.
I can completely sympathize with your amoral perspective on this...NOT.
Fortunately, in my business, the common welfare is my business. Virtues such as charity, mercy, forbearance, and benevolence, all but forgotten by the greedy and amoral right, are my business. I hope I never degenerate into something like: Them.
You bet!
As per my above suggestion, it's way past time for these juvenile delinquents to get outta da crib, and start earning their keep. America needs industry and we have a burgeoning underdeveloped asset at our fingertips. Put kids to work making thing America needs, like cell phones, and TVs, clothes, furniture...Keep the jobs here at home!
Don't we realize that our children are our future? How can we not, make the most of our progeny?
Not really. Greed is the corporate welfare recipient who sucks the taxpayer dry which makes it difficult for government to help the working poor and lower middle class workers to afford day care so THEY CAN WORK INSTEAD OF COLLECTING WELFARE!
Where's your perspective, man?
Fair enough I'll meet you part way.
The point of moving it, is so that they get to the stage where it you archive equilibrium. The raise no longer harms them and any future increases in pay is cream on the cake, so to speak.
That being said, there is nothing wrong with your method either.
There are many ways to handle this, but the present system is not addressing the problem.
What's wrong with sliding scale benefits?
BF,
I just checked out the average child care fees for CO and it's $100/week per child. So for this guy this would cost him $300/week. Do the math. His child care cost would be over $15k a year. So had he accepted the "raise" he would be in the hole for $9k a year, which hardly seems like an incentive. So his choice was a non choice. There has to be a better way and there are...
EI,
I get what Eiglman means. I person needs to make a working wage by which they can live. It helps the individual, the businesses, and the economy.
Aeon,
That is what EI is suggesting and I do think that it is a good idea.
Well that assumes a lot BF.
Like there are other job opportunities for his skill set Or he can just pick up an move. Do you know what Dad can or can't do? In fact, the only person that should be called a dead beat is someone who doesn't work. As far as I am concerned, he is a guy just trying the best way he knows how. And you should go back and read my previous post to you about the math to this issue.
Polly,
Nothing. It's a good idea.
Gonna argue that. Let's take those numbers again. At $40k a year, with a $4k raise it doesn't pay for this guy to give up his child care since it would cost him about $9k more to send his kids off to child care.
At $55 he hits equilibrium. Anything over $55 is cream and he would be stupid not to take the raises.
Now this day may never come, or his kids will enter school and he won't need full time child care services...
Then he hits equilibrium earlier. Just one kid off to school and his cost go down about $5,000 a year.
But as you suggested, a slope would be preferable or even a tax incentive to the business.
People were dying at the age of 45, with the remnants of an agrarian society still around. There were also 200,000,000 less of us to worry about.
For sure EG!
I would describe myself as an independent moderate... and I would say that statement is true.
That's because you have a heart Suz.
Which means our tax system is screwed up (but I know this to be true, since I am an accountant)
Not to mention the fact that Dan is not only a ready and capable worker, but one also who has chosen to make his work one that constructs hope and enables fellow humans in need. If you ask me, that's just as good as a doctor or lawyer any day...a productive member of society.
The expression of human compassion
is offering something "worthwhile."
I've always known you to be intense and caring.