╌>

The ‘Muslims-Killed-by-the-West’ Lie

  

Category:  News & Politics

Via:  buzz-of-the-orient  •  13 years ago  •  19 comments

The ‘Muslims-Killed-by-the-West’ Lie

The Muslims-Killed-by-the-West Lie

By Dennis Prager for townhall.com, May 29, 2013

6624_discussions.jpg The alleged butcher of the off-duty British soldier, Drummer Lee Rigby, defended his carving up of a living human being by claiming that he was engaging in "an eye for an eye" because the British army is killing Muslims in Afghanistan.

Normally there is no reason to respond to the justifications offered by terrorists and other murderers of the innocent. But in this case it is important to do so because much of the Muslim world resonates to this argument and because much of the world's left offers this argument.

This is true even though a large majority of Muslims do not support terror and even though leftists do not support it. Nevertheless, throughout the Muslim and leftist worlds it is believed -- and our children are taught this at college -- that America, the UK. and other countries are targeted by Muslims because we kill Muslims.

The argument is morally perverse and a lie.

First, the U.K. and others are in Afghanistan in order to defend Muslims. Brits and other Westerners are risking their lives, and dying, in that country on behalf of Muslims.

Here's a question for Muslims and leftists who buy this argument about the West killing Muslims in Afghanistan: Who are we fighting in Afghanistan?

I thought the Brits and Americans were fighting the Taliban, the people who throw acid in Muslim girls' faces for attending school, the people who murder nurses who inoculate Muslim children against disease. Now, if fighting the Taliban is to be equated with fighting Muslims, this is a real contradiction of everything much of the Islamic world and virtually all of the left have been contending for years -- that the Taliban represent a tiny group of extremists in the Muslim world, and that they have so completely perverted Islam that they cannot even be called Muslims.

Well, you can't have it both ways. If killing the Taliban is the same as "killing Muslims," then you can't argue that the Taliban don't represent Islam or Muslims.

So, on the issue of the West fighting in Afghanistan, the Muslims and the left need to make up their minds: Is killing the Taliban a service or a disservice to Muslims? This is the first and last question both groups need to answer. Everything else is commentary.

Click this link to read the rest of this article:

http://townhall.com/columnists/dennisprager/2013/05/29/the-muslimskilledbythewest-lie-n1608158/page/2


Tags

jrDiscussion - desc
[]
 
Arch-Man
Freshman Silent
link   Arch-Man    13 years ago

It's my opinion that the Muslim Clerics are responsible for this violence. They preach hate and death and out of fear try to impose their beliefs on others. God's goal is to redeem his creation not to destroy it. God made the world without our help and he will end without our help.

 
 
 
bluearcher
Freshman Silent
link   bluearcher    13 years ago

All religion is a mental disease and should be treated a such.

Islam is the most odious of all archaic creeds and fairy tales as it specifically insulates itself from logic, reason and rational thought.

Islam is not just a religion, nor is it a cult. In its fullest form, it is a complete, total, 100% system of life. Islam has religious, legal, political, economic, social, and military components. The religious component is a cover for all of the other components.

 
 
 
Arch-Man
Freshman Silent
link   Arch-Man    13 years ago

All religion is a mental disease and should be treated a such.

That's your opinion. You will never get rid of religion it's mans search to understand himself and the world he lives in.

 
 
 
Aeonpax
Freshman Silent
link   Aeonpax    13 years ago

I understand what the author of this piece is trying to say; unfortunately hes saying it so very poorly - Who are we fighting in Afghanistan?

The Taliban is an Islamic fundamentalist political movement in Afghanistan, which adheres to strict Sharia Law. They are recognized as a legitimate governmental body by our own allies: Saudi Arabia and the UAR.

Where the author, Dennis Prager, goes outside of logic and reality is his proposition:

  • Now, if fighting the Taliban is to be equated with fighting Muslims, this is a real contradiction of everything much of the Islamic world and virtually all of the left have been contending for years.

Key word here IF. The author does not establish nor even attempt to establish a real world connection between the Taliban and Islam,. At worst, he assumes there is without proving it or more likely, sets up a hypothetical situation whereby there is a connection, without qualifying it.

The real contradiction here is Dennis Prager. He poses a loaded question which is a question with a false or questionable presupposition, and it is "loaded" with that presumption.IF.

The continued logic is juvenile at best. Who were we fighting during WWII, the Nazis in Germany or the Protestant Christians in Germany, whom were mainly Lutheran?

Who were we fighting during the Civil War; the Northern Christians or the Southern Christians?

Were we fighting the Spanish government during the Spanish-American war, or the Catholic Spanish, which was the predominant religion there?

Yeah the Taliban are Muslims but all Muslims are not Taliban.

 
 
 
bluearcher
Freshman Silent
link   bluearcher    13 years ago

That's your opinion.

Actually, if you read the DSM and understand the definition of delusion you will see that it is actually considered a diagnostic fact. If I were to continually believe, endorse and talk to an "invisible friend" I would be considered delusional and diagnosed as mentally impaired.

The natural state of the disease-free mind operates from logic, reason, rational thought and the integrity of "belief-with-proof".

...it's mans search to understanding himself and the world he lives in.

No. You just described science. Man doesn't understand himself via religious myth, superstition and perpetuation of delusion.

 
 
 
Arch-Man
Freshman Silent
link   Arch-Man    13 years ago

No. You just described science.

I believe it starts with the question we all ask ourselves is "why are we here". Plus the fact that I'm a born-again Christian and Buzz is Jewish why would you attack our beliefs? Anyway this is not an article about our faith but about the Muslim world believing that the US and it's allies are fighting against Islam.

 
 
 
Arch-Man
Freshman Silent
link   Arch-Man    13 years ago

Good points but I think it's more groups then just the Taliban. It's radical Islam anywhere for any reason. Which I believe the Muslim Clerics are responsible for, whether they speak for these radical views or fail to speak against it. I feel both are responsible.

 
 
 
Aeonpax
Freshman Silent
link   Aeonpax    13 years ago

I'm considered liberal/progressive and quite frankly, there is just too much anecdotal, circumstantial and provisional evidence that postulates some sort of surreptitious link between the spread of terror and the Islamic faith, that cannot be ignored.

The right keeps pounding away at this without logically outlining it, and the left arrogantly just keeps repeating it's mantra that the religion is not at fault, without looking at all the facts.

All this article does is attempt to establish a childish arguing point as opposed to building up a bona fide case to support their point.

 
 
 
FLYNAVY1
Professor Quiet
link   FLYNAVY1    13 years ago

As I have stated before. There is nobody that is speaking for Islam, thus no one to negotiate with. With so many demands from so many quarters, it is impossible to find a solution. The best solution is to disengage as much as we can/dare, and work from there. Sending money, weapons or our military is just going to piss somebody else off.

I wish somebody would discover an efficient portable energy source so the world could reduce its need for oil. That would help so very much.

 
 
 
Arch-Man
Freshman Silent
link   Arch-Man    13 years ago

Point is people are being killed by this shallow dogma.

 
 
 
Aeonpax
Freshman Silent
link   Aeonpax    13 years ago

Fly,

When we remove the religion factor from this equation, you get a false perspective of the problem. While I am convinced that the US involves itself militarily in events where there is even the slightest hint of oil involved, religion (Islam) just cannot be arbitrarily removed.

I agree though, sending arms only further escalates the problem and it needs to be our country's goal to develop alternative energy sources to completely negate the need for oil in this manner.

 
 
 
Buzz of the Orient
Professor Expert
link   seeder  Buzz of the Orient    13 years ago

Is it HIS determination that the West is killing Muslims around the world? This appears to be the case, and thus , to him, he did kill the soldier as "an eye for an eye". He wasn't "lying".

Nobody said he was lying. The lie is that the West is at fault for all the killing of Muslims.

Since this is a "stupid article" you're entitled to write a stupid comment (politics aside, of course).

 
 
 
Neetu2
Freshman Silent
link   Neetu2    13 years ago

Only the ignorant would believe that argument. It is, indeed, a lie.

 
 
 
Aeonpax
Freshman Silent
link   Aeonpax    13 years ago
  • International political interest require that counties pretend that Islam has nothing to do with Islamic violence

Why???? The Western powers, and especially the corporations, have entered countries with little or only token regard towards the religion of the area.

  • You can't say "Islam sucks" while you want to influence a Muslim country in your favor.

No, but as the US has demonstrated, you can pay or bribe your way into any situation regardless of religious feelings.

  • terrorist movements consist of Muslims who are confused about "true Islam."

With all due respect, I question the veracity of that statement.

******************

It's not just the US leaders whom want to brainwash the public into accepting Islam as a religion of peace, behind it all are the money people, especially the oil interests whom have everything to gain by this.

It has become a matter of PC (Political Correctness) that propels this insane chant in order to placate the Islamic, oil rich states of the Middle East....least I remind you of George W. Bush kissing and holding hands with King Abdullah bin Abdulaziz Al Saud. The House of Saud itself, is an affront to humanity.

 
 
 
Aeonpax
Freshman Silent
link   Aeonpax    13 years ago
  • terrorist movements consist of Muslims who are confused about "true Islam."

All I'm saying is that statement is NOT factual, period. Because "leaders" or other political persons think it is true, does not make it so. IF that statement was rhetorical, then you are right...I didn't get it.

And honestly, I roll my eyes at your obsession/need to get "corporations" into every issue, as if having mentioned that word, nothing else need be said. I hesitate always to question it, because it just opens the door to distraction

In other words, you don't have the facts or information to refute it. I understand. Well, just so ya know...I can back up such statements...anytime, anywhere.

 
 
 
Arch-Man
Freshman Silent
link   Arch-Man    13 years ago

I thought we where in Afghanistan in direct response to 911 and not resources. I also thought that we where killing those that where trying to kill us and our soldiers where killing those that are trying to kill them and to prevent them from completing their mission.

And belief is tied mostly to emotion, not reason.

I don't know; when I look at the world around me and how the human body is made and I look in to the sky at night makes me acknowledge a creator: I think that is reason.Smile.gif

 
 
 
Arch-Man
Freshman Silent
link   Arch-Man    13 years ago

Ok you stated your position clearly and good luck on your quest.

 
 
 
Aeonpax
Freshman Silent
link   Aeonpax    13 years ago

True that....I'll save that argument for another day.

 
 
 
Buzz of the Orient
Professor Expert
link   seeder  Buzz of the Orient    13 years ago

And belief that belief is tied mostly to emotion, not reason could also be pure opinion. Is that an opinion or a belief?

 
 

Who is online








94 visitors