╌>

The Israeli-Arab conflict --- The indisputable F'n truth - at last!!!!!!!

  

Category:  News & Politics

Via:  artiea  •  13 years ago  •  20 comments

The Israeli-Arab conflict  ---  The indisputable  F'n truth - at last!!!!!!!

http://elderofziyon.blogspot.com/2013/05/must-read-israeli-peacenik-meets.html

MUST READ: An Israeli peacenik meets the reality of Palestinian Arab intransigence

Lital Shemesh is a young, liberal Israeli journalist, considered a rising star in the Israeli media who openly expresses her political aspirations.
She wrote a must-read article from Walla , translated by Baruch Gordon on his blog:
Peace? From the Palestinian Standpoint, There is a Past, No Future
The Israeli side, which included representatives from right and left, tried to understand the Palestinians vision of the end of the strife Lets talk business. The Israelis delved to understand how we can end the age-old, painful conflict. What red lines are they willing to be flexible on? What resolution will satisfy their aspirations? Where do they envision the future borders of the Palestinian State which they so crave?

We were shocked to discover that not a single one of them spoke of a Palestinian State, or to be more precise, of a two-state solution.

They spoke of one state their state. They spoke of ruling Jaffa, Tel Aviv, Akko, Haifa, and the pain of the Nakba [lit. the tragedy the establishment of the State of Israel]. There was no future for them. Only the past. There is no legitimacy for Jews to live next
to us this was their main message.
First, let them pay for what they perpetrated.

In the course of a dialogue which escalated to shouts,
the Palestinians asked us not to refer to suicide bombers as terrorists because they dont consider them so
. So how do you call someone who dons a vest and blows himself up in a Tel Aviv shopping mall with the stated purpose of killing innocent civilians, I asked one of the participants.
I arrived at the seminar with high hopes, and I return home with difficult feelings and despair. Something about the narrative of the two sides is different from the core. How can we return to the negotiating table when the Israeli side speaks of two states and the Palestinian side speaks of liberating Palestine from the Jordan River to the Mediterranean Sea? How can peace ever take root in a platform which grants legitimacy to terrorism?

Tags

jrDiscussion - desc
[]
 
aRTieA
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  aRTieA    13 years ago

By Palestine, you mean greater Israel. The Arabs you are referring to. for the most part, originally immigrated from surrounding Arab countries looking for work as the Jews turned the desert into arable land.

Then came the Palestinian Mandate an the British, who slowly took away land from the Jews as mandated in the Belfour declaration.

Its a farce - Arafat was born in Eqypt. Jordan is for the Arabs residing in greater Israel.

The Arabs never wanted or will never agree to a Jewish state even if it consisted a single square inch. I defy anyone to prove me wrong.

 
 
 
Shub Orinuj
Freshman Silent
link   Shub Orinuj    13 years ago

Opinion of aPalestiniannewswoman doesn't mean the same as the governments.

What do the banks want? Warcontinuous

What does Israel and America want? Who knows?

What does Palestinian's want? Apparently a state

Choices now are war, two state, one state, Jews move out, or (fill in blank)

 
 
 
Krishna
Professor Guide
link   Krishna    13 years ago

Jews have come to view this land as theirs when it was taken by force and given to them, as some sort of foolish payment for the German pogrom.

Nope. Not so. You are poorly uniformed.

The original "British Mandate of Palestine", was supposed to be given back to the Jews. However,, the Brits reneged-- and gave over 60% to the Arabs to form a new country. (Originally called "The Hashemite Kingdon of Transjordan"-- as it was ruled by h\Hashea [and not the so-called "Palestinians"], and it was the 0artm east of the Jordan River (hence "trans".

The smaller remaining part was supposed to be divided-- to form a Jewish state and a Palestinian state (in 1948). But the Arabs wanted it all...

When these two countries were supposed to bcome independent, 5 Arab states invaded-- in an attempt to annihilte the Jews. But they failed.

After the dust settled, the Jews were in control of a tiny sliver of the original British Mandate of Palestine. However, the pplan to form an Arab "Palestine" from te other part was thwarted-- as Gaza ended up being illegally occupied by Egypt, and The West Bank ended up being illegally noccupied (and later illegally annexed) by The Hashenite Kingdom of Jordan (since they now controlled land on both sides of the Jordan, the country changed its name to, simply, "Jordan".

And, BTW, this had nothing to do with the Holocaust. The land was originally Jewish, until the Romans kicked most of them out in 72 AD.

So, now the Arabs have 20 + countries-- the jews finally got part of their original country bck-- although its only a tiny sliver of land (the entire country of Israel is only about the size of New Jersey):

arabwld3.gif Note: This is an old map. Israel is actually smaller than that, as they ended the occupation of Gaza and it is now ruled by a terrorist organization).

Oh, and BTW-- of the tiny area that is israel--over 60% is inhospitble desert-- rocks, not sand:

negev_desert.jpg

 
 
 
Krishna
Professor Guide
link   Krishna    13 years ago

What does Palestinian's want? Apparently a state

Actually-- no.

They have had several offers of a state and turned them down -- because they want it all.

They want a judenrein middle-east.

They want not only the West Bank and Gaza-- they also want all of Israel!

 
 
 
Krishna
Professor Guide
link   Krishna    13 years ago

Jews have come to view this land as theirs when it was taken by force and given to them

Oh really?

If, as you falsely allege, the Israelis "took this land by force"-- who do you believe they took it from?

Can you provide a link showing who controlled the land that is now Israel before Israel became independent in 1948? Who controlled the West Bank before Israel? Who controlled Gaza?

(Link please-- from a reliable source--David Duke or some other bigoted hate site is unacceptable).

 
 
 
Larry Hampton
Professor Quiet
link   Larry Hampton    13 years ago

How important, this tiny strip of land. And how important, as a reflection of America's own choices in fighting militant and colonial islam. There comes a point where there is no in-between left; all comes down to a choice to live and be free, or not to.

Though I would wish to believe otherwise, I see no way around a confrontation to decide the issue. It's been obvious for some time now that "palestine" and it's inhabitants are in this land not to form their own homeland, but merely to be used as a tool to keep Israel from having it's own.

 
 
 
Krishna
Professor Guide
link   Krishna    13 years ago

So how could Israelis take land when there weren't any Israelis to take the land?

Think WWII.

WWII? Many of the Israelites were expelled by the Romans in 72 AD-- but others remained behind and lived there to this day. After WWII some of those who had immigrated to Europe returned to their ancient homeland where they found other Jews who had been living there since ancient times. (BTW, those Israelites [Jews] had been there waaaay before Islam was even invented!

There weren't even Israelis until Israel was reestablished.

Nope-- wrong again! Israelis have lived there for centuries. Check out the history (below).

Important: Be sure to note note when Israelis/Israelites first appeared. (Hint: it was l9ong before WWII).

Also note when "Palestine' first appeared):

 
 
 
Buzz of the Orient
Professor Expert
link   Buzz of the Orient    13 years ago

Jerusalem, Capital of Israel: An Islamic Prophecy : Ali Salim, Gatestone Institute , January 29, 2013 Jerusalem is the capital of the Children of Israeland it is forbidden for Musims to demand it. Is it possible that Allah, who in His infinite mercy, calls them the Chosen People, and promises them the Holy Land, also plans to murder them, using the Muslims in Palestine as His intermediary?

 
 
 
aRTieA
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  aRTieA    13 years ago

When you call them Palestinians, you are giving them credibility and indicatingthe effectiveness oftheir campaign of deception.

As a group, theseArabscannot make any decisions - they are the puppets of the Arab League. Abbas cannot do anything without prior Arab League approval.

And the Arab league plan continues to put forth the same demand that led Arafat to reject all peace proposals even when the proposed agreement gave the Arabs literally all the land they were demanding.

In the partition plan, Jerusalem was to be an international city allowing all religions to practice peacefully. The Arabs when they occupied Jerusalem denied these rights to Jews.

"The (Muslim) Arabs do not compromise and only understand force" -- this quote is from my primary care physician who is an Egyptian Coptic.

 
 
 
Len
Freshman Silent
link   Len    13 years ago

Flameaway,

You know zilch about history and interpret what you THINK you kinow prejudicially against Israel and America -- typical liberal moral equivalence to put it charitably.

Israelis have become what they lived in camps to demonstrate to the world. No one group has anymore ethical/moral right to any square inch of the 'holy land' than any other. it is quite simply strength that controls it.

And as many have heard might does not make right it engenders entitlement.

Jews have come to view this land as theirs when it was taken by force and given to them, as some sort of foolish payment for the German pogrom. It was supposed to lend security to a beleagured people.And now we watch the victims victimize.

Your third paragraph contradicts your first two which hold that might makes right. As far as who has a right to it, I note that the Jewish Scriptures mention Jerusalem 650 times whereas the MuslimQu'ran mentions it not one single time.

But the Qu'ran also gives the Jews the right to the land; first by God's doing and then by justice:

"Say: 'O God, King of the kingdom, Thou givest the kingdom to whom Thou pleasest, and Thou strippest off the kingdom from whom Thou pleasest; Thou endurest with honour whom Thou pleasest, and Thou bringest low whom Thou pleasest; all the best is in Thy hand. Verily, Thou hast power over all things." (Q!u'ran Sura 3:26)

The Qur'an commands Israel to conquer the Holy Land:

"And [remember] when Moses said to his people: 'O my people, call in remembrance the favour of God unto you, when he produced prophets among you, made you kings, and gave to you what He had not given to any other among the people. O my people, enter the Holy Land which God has assigned unto you, and turn not back ignominiously, for then will ye be overthrown, to your own ruin." (Sura 5:20-21)

It also refers to the reinstatement of the Jews in the Land before the last judgment:

"And thereafter We said to the Children of Israel: 'Dwell securely in the Promised Land.' And when the last warning will come to pass, We will gather you together in a mingled crowd." (Sura 17:104)

It recognizes that Jews will pray towards Jerusalem and Muslims towards Mecca:

"...They would not follow thy direction of prayer, nor art thou to follow their direction of prayer; nor indeed will they follow each other's direction of prayer..." (Sura 2:145)

The purpose of this distinction is to prevent conflict. All qur'anic commentators explain that "thy qibla" is obviously the Kaba of Mecca, while "their qibla" refers to the Temple Area in Jerusalem.

Continued

 
 
 
Len
Freshman Silent
link   Len    13 years ago

Mike I raise your Sharia Law with the Phillipines, Hiroshima, Western pillaging of South America. And a host of other heinous crimes perpetrated by our "Captain America" government. All this in the name of some foolish progress that threatens the environment folks need to live in.

Again, to teach you history, you evidently havfe no clue nwhat led to Hiroshia so you blame the policeman for apprehending the criminal. Let me explain.

In his speech after the bomb was dropped Truman said: The world will note that the first atomic bomb was dropped on Hiroshima, a military base. That was because we wished in this first attack to avoid, insofar as possible, the killing of civilians. But that attack is only a warning of things to come. If Japan does not surrender, bombs will have to be dropped on her war industries and, unfortunately, thousands of civilian lives will be lost. I urge Japanese civilians to leave industrial cities immediately, and save themselves from destruction.

If we knew then what we do now perhaps we would have made a different choice. On the other hand, your concern about dehumanizing Japan is not based on knowledge of what Japan did. Check out the following for a long list of Japanese atrocities in China.

Here are the first two:

Nanking, China. Over 200,000 Chinese men used for bayonet practice, machine gunned, or set on fire. Thousands more were murdered. 20,000 women and girls were raped, killed or mutilated. --- New officers [were] indoctrinated to the expectations of war by beheading Chinese captives. The last stage of the training of combat troops was to bayonet a living human and a trial of courage for the officers. Prisoners were blindfolded and tied to poles. Soldiers dashed forward to bayonet their target at the shout of "Charge!"

This is just in Nanking!

By comparison 110,000 Japanese were killed by two bombs, 70,000 at Hiroshima and 40,000 at Nagasaki.

Murder by old-fashioned means is still murder. In all, the Japanese inflicted 10 million civilian casualties on China (See below).

Here is the Death March of US captive soldiers in the Philippines soon after the war began:

After the first day of marching, without food or water, men began to drop out of column. Japanese guards would rush up, shouting commands in Japanese to get back in the group. When that approach failed, shots rang, out killing those who would not or could not rise. Many of those failing to obey the order to march were beheaded by sword wielding-Japanese guards, usually officers and non-coms.

I showed you the above documented evidence that the accusations were not hyperbole. Was it racist of the US to come to China's defense? What civilized people fail to realize is how easily ordinary people can become dehumanized under certain circumstances. The Nazi SS, the Einsatzgruppen who were assigned the task of the Jewish Final Solution by Hitler, were not the ignorant, low-life, uneducated, ex-convicts some would have us believe. They were specially-selected pillars of German society; college professors, doctors, scientists, bankers and musicians. The men who administered the death camps were very familiar with Goethe, Kant, Wagner, Beethoven, Bach, Mach and Heisenberg. After a day of murder they would attend a concert in the evening.

If you want to compare body counts, Germany suffered far worse than Japan. Here is a comparison:

Germany had over 3 million military and almost 4 million civilian casualties vs. Japans 1.7 million and 360,000 respectively. So Germany suffered far more than Japan in both categories. France had as many civilian casualties as Japan.

To put these figures in perspective look at the following civilian tolls:

Soviet Union 7.7 million

Poland 5.3 Million

China !0 million.

Practically all the Chinese casualties were at Japans hands; 10 million vs. 360,000.

What your message lacks is the perspective I brought with the above figures. It is easy to be sympathetic in theory; without knowing the facts. I alluded to these facts when I talked about the four years between Pearl Harbor and the Bomb. Now I have fleshed them out a little more. I dont relish any civilian deaths but the comparisons show that the Japanese suffered a good deal short of what a measure-for-measure quantity would yield.

The Hebrew Talmud says: He who is merciful to the cruel will end up being cruel to the merciful.

Next I call a revered eastern voice, Confucius, who said, If we reward the bad with kindness, with what will we reward the good?

 
 
 
Len
Freshman Silent
link   Len    13 years ago

First of all, you reason like a rusty sieve. The United States is the only super power because we are the meanest, toughest dog in the pack.

I "reason like a rusty sieve"whereas youassert thatyour country does worse things than "200,000 Chinese men used for bayonet practice, machine gunned, or set on fire. Thousands more were murdered. 20,000 women and girls were raped, killed or mutilated. --- New officers [were] indoctrinated to the expectations of war by beheading Chinese captives. The last stage of the training of combat troops was to bayonet a living human and a trial of courage for the officers. Prisoners were blindfolded and tied to poles. Soldiers dashed forward to bayonet their target at the shout of "Charge!""

Where did you "match this trail of tears?"

You are a typical ultra-left liberal who ignores facts andhates the United States and Israel while justifying their enemies. Reasoning with you is like reasoning with a wall.

 
 
 
luther28
Sophomore Silent
link   luther28    13 years ago

If the Sunni, Shia etc. cannot get along together, I do not see any of them taking the Israelis into their happy fold.

Leon Uris's Exodus is must reading to gain some insight into why this will never be. This has been going on for two thousand years in one form or another. Will not be solved in my lifetime, maybe Mike L is correct as barbaric as it may sound.

 
 
 
pokermike
Freshman Silent
link   pokermike    13 years ago

What it comes down to is Israel exists because of the courage and industriousness of its people who never give it up. And no matter who sits in the White House the American people will always remain a steadfast ally. Support for Israel in the U.S. has always been at or above 50% while support for the Palestinians never rises much above the low 'teens. Rightly so. Has there ever been a group so unworthy of sympathy and support? The Palestinians must be the most stupid people on earth. They have tried for decades through war, intifadas, terrorism, and suicide bombers to eliminate Israel and Israel today is stronger and richer than ever. Their hatred blinds them to the obvious facts. By negotiating in good faith (without their usual ludicrous "pre-conditions") to get the best deal possible and begin to act civilized in a peaceful manner with their neighbor, they might have a chance to build a prosperous future for their children. Until they come around to rational thinking, let them suffer the consequences of their actions. Israel has been quite patient, only punishing them every few years when their outrages become beyond the pale. God help them when Israel's patience finally runs out, because no one else will. Not their Arab "brothers", not the UN, and not the despicable fools like George Galloway and his ilk.

 
 
 
aRTieA
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  aRTieA    13 years ago

Peace will come when the Arabs will love their children more than they hate us.

Statement to the National Press Club in Washington, D. C. in 1957, as quoted in A Land of Our Own: An Oral Autobiography (1973) edited by Marie Syrkin, p. 242

-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

There were no such thing as Palestinians. When was there an independent Palestinian people with a Palestinian state? It was either southern Syria before the First World War, and then it was a Palestine including Jordan. It was not as though there was a Palestinian people in Palestine considering itself as a Palestinian people and we came and threw them out and took their country away from them. They did not exist.

  • As quoted in Sunday Times (15 June 1969), also in The Washington Post (16 June 1969)

----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Nothing has changed in the minds of the Arabs since 1948.

 
 
 
Buzz of the Orient
Professor Expert
link   Buzz of the Orient    13 years ago

I think that if people were truly objective, not infected by propaganda and political correctness, a lot of truths might actually be learned.

 
 
 
aRTieA
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  aRTieA    13 years ago

I think that if people were truly objective, not infected by propaganda and political correctness, a lot of truths might actually be learned.

Buzz - good comment

It didn't take long for people to meander and go off-topic on this seed. So let me restate what I think the issue is...

The Arabs living in what waspreviously called the Palestinian mandate have yet to acceptdividingthe land and recognizing Israel as a Jewish state. And for those of you who don't understand the concept of a Jewish state - please review UN resolution 181 which specially called for the creation of a Jewish state.

 
 
 
aRTieA
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  aRTieA    13 years ago

Comparing apples and oranges will get you nowhere.

Please address the content of the article, if you are capable, without going off-topic.

Your level of misinformation and lack of understanding makes your comment immaterial to the discussion at hand.

1. The US is not (and I repeat not) dependent on Mideast oil. The EU and China are. So now you know why the EU has a total bias.

2. No one was screwed out of their land. Perhaps this is relevant to a discussion on Tibet or the partition of India on a religious basis.

3. The fact is that Israel exists. (make that a big period) Now are you interesting in resolving the issue peacefully or not?

 
 
 
Buzz of the Orient
Professor Expert
link   Buzz of the Orient    13 years ago

I'm confused by your allegory. Just whom does the insect represent?

 
 
 
aRTieA
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  aRTieA    13 years ago

I don't know Art, I'm pretty sure I understand what's going on. I'm not so sure about you, though.

Thank you so much for the insult.

I stand by my statement. Comparing apples and oranges does not present a compelling argument.\

Let's not revisit history - it only results in an endless pissing contest. Let's focus on today's reality. Israel exists and will continue to exist as a Jewish state. How do we go about changing the Arab mindset to accepting the existence of Israel.

 
 

Who is online



93 visitors