Stephen Hawking accused of hypocrisy over Israel conference boycott
Stephen Hawking accused of hypocrisy over Israel conference boycott
By Harriet Sherwood in Jerusalem - the guardian - 8 May 2013
Scientist's critics say he should stop using Israeli technology in computer equipment that allows him to communicate
Stephen Hawking's decision to boycott an Israeli conference in protest at the state's 46-year occupation of Palestine was derided as hypocritical by some, who pointed out that the celebrated scientist and author uses Israeli technology in the computer equipment that allows him to function.
Hawking, 71, has suffered from motor neurone disease for the past 50 years, and relies on a computer-based system to communicate.
According to Shurat HaDin, an Israel law centre which represents victims of terrorism, the equipment has been provided by the hi-tech firm, Intel, since 1997.
"Hawking's decision to join the boycott of Israel is quite hypocritical for an individual who prides himself on his whole intellectual accomplishment. His whole computer-based communications system runs on a chip designed by Israel's Intel team. I suggest if he truly wants to pull out of Israel he should also pull out his Intel Core i7 from his tablet," said Nitsana Darshan-Leitner of Shurat HaDin.
Intel could not be reached for comment, but their website quotes Justin Rattner, chief technology officer, as saying earlier this year: "We have a long-standing relationship with Professor Hawking." He added: "We are very pleased to continue to work closely with Professor Hawking on improving his personal communication system."
Cambridge University declined to comment on allegations of hypocrisy regarding Hawking's communications system .
Tags
Who is online
89 visitors

I have always said that those who support a boycott against Israel are hypocrites if they use any Israeli products or technology, medical or scientific, and most people do. Intel should hack his computer and disable the equipment that was invented and provided by them in order to shut his hypocritical mouth.
Intel's research and development is carried out in Israel. The computer chip that is inserted in his computer that enables him to communicate was developed in Israel, notwithstanding the fact that the computer itself was assembled in California.
The article made this statement, and I have no reason to disbelieve it:
I appreciate your opinion. You, as well, have voiced opinions about hypocrisy recently. I'm going with the author here.
So no one who uses a product from Israel can criticize Israel?
Hawking took his criticism to the boycott level. I criticize Israel, but look for their products wherever I shop.
He's boycotting. What is that, a part-time vocation?
Why didn't he boycott the $3 million award from Yuri Milner last year? THAT would have been a boycott worth taking note of.
John, that makes no sense. You don't support a boycott of goods from a country, if you are using them yourself.
Intel does business in Israel. They employ many people in Israel. They develop many products in Israel.
If Hawking wants to boycott Israel, he should consider whether or not he should use any product manufactured by any company that employs so many people in the land of the dirty disgusting occupiers of Arab land.
So what is it, John, do you only boycott the items you don't use? And what does that make you?
Spot on.
Who in the Hell, in their right mind would give a horse pa-too-ta what Steven Hawking thinks about Israeli policies or military action that they deem necessary for their country's security.
Hawking is difficult enough to understand when he lectures on "Black Holes", now, he's an expert on foreign policies? Next, he'll tell us there is no God only him.
His opinion is valid on physics not chicken liver. Reel it in Steven.
Stephen Hawking and the Israel Boycott
Sometimes very smart people do very dumb things.
"Dr. Hawking, whose academic research is world-class, must also realize the key to bettering the world lies in fostering communication, not in shutting it down. By turning his back on all of Israel, he's sending a reactionary and hate-filled message at odds with the extensive academic collaboration that's marked his entire career."
Why don't we all chill out on Israel. From the safety of my home in lovely, but, nearly all torn down Mildew, Ohio, where there are no jobs because Johnnie Boehner and his corrupt cronies sent them all overseas to Communist China, the idea of a Palestine state sounds reasonable to me.
But, I am not living in Israel, where mortar reign down on civilians from those seeking a Palestine state.I do not witness the suicide bombers who board a crowded bus and kill men, women and children because the believe that Allah want them to blow themselves up, and kill ever man, woman and child that is not them.
The solution to the Middle East and to the smoldering coming battle in America is simple:
Let us gather up all the true believers, pitching the far out right wing primitive fundamentalist on one hand and the far right extremist Muslims on the other, and, let this RELIGIOUS NUT JOBS KILLEACH OTHER!
Both are more in LOVE with DEATH than LIFE, so, let the pure, devoted instruments of God slaughter each other until they all are with their God.
That's my lesson for today, kids. Remember, stealing money from your parents and sending it to me is CLEANING YOUR MONEY. I will bless it, lauder it and, maybe, maybe, send you some back after I deduct by tithing fee.- Reverend Oral Fleece
What Mark? I saw the Police Tape, but No Mark!
I didn't see any mark, or Marks.I saw Mathew, Luke and Johns, but no Mark. Maybe he was in Israel getting instructions from Hawking.
Wasthe Markshaped like a UFO?Cause, I did see that?Was it a permanent marker, or washable?
As to the point of the discussion: I say, let Israel decide what is in their best interest and tell Hawking that if he is so damn smart, then, why doesn't he just get off his lazy ass and go to the refrigerator himself.
For, Chris sake, Einsteinium Insanity, we were bunk mates at the same asylum.Do I have to do all the damn thinking around here, or, is this place marked up, also.
Inquiring Minds Want To Know!
I agree.
Actually, IMNSHO, this is more or less a "non-story". I don't think that his statement will influence a single person who is currently buying any Israeli product (or products) to stop buying them.
Most (all?) of those who support a boycott of Israeli products also support a boycott of communication and interchanges of ideas between Israeli academics, scientists, etc and their non-Israeli counterparts. Their opposition to dialogue strikes me as hypocritical-- to say the least. (Unless, of course, their goal is not peace, but rather annihilation of the Jewish state).
Aside from the fact that intelligent people often do stupid things-- there's an interesting specific instance of that here-- one I've seen time and time again. And that is that so often, when people who are truly brilliant express opinions outside of their particular area of expertise-- they are often just plain wrong! (This even happens re: non-political issues as well).