╌>

A Quiz

  

Category:  News & Politics

Via:  a-macarthur  •  13 years ago  •  88 comments

A Quiz
Why is the FBI unable to trace the manufacturer of the gun powder used in the Boston Marathon bombs?

Tags

jrDiscussion - desc
[]
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   seeder  A. Macarthur    13 years ago
Answer tomorrow (unless someone posts it before I do).
 
 
 
Dowser
Sophomore Silent
link   Dowser    13 years ago

Because it doesn't have a unique formula? Smile.gif

 
 
 
Perrie Halpern R.A.
Professor Guide
link   Perrie Halpern R.A.    13 years ago

Because you can make your own gun powder.

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   seeder  A. Macarthur    13 years ago

Because it doesn't have a unique formula?

Incorrect, it does have a unique formula.

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   seeder  A. Macarthur    13 years ago

Because you can make your own gun powder.

You can, but that's not the answer.

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   seeder  A. Macarthur    13 years ago

My guess would be there is nothing left to trace really. When it exploded it disintegrates, and goes up in smoke.

Logical guess, but wrong in this case.

NOTE:

I'm going to sleep and I will check answers in the morning; if no one has the correct response by noon tomorrow, I'll reveal it.

Night.

 
 
 
One Miscreant
Professor Silent
link   One Miscreant    13 years ago

I'll take a wild-assed guess and say it's because the ingredients are organic.

 
 
 
Mark in Wyoming
Professor Silent
link   Mark in Wyoming     13 years ago

because it is against federal law to place tagants( identifying markers for tracing and tracking) into explosives. this cam about as a result of gun control , gun rights advocates wanted this law on the books to prevent the government from knowing whom was reloading their own ammunition,

 
 
 
Larry Hampton
Professor Quiet
link   Larry Hampton    13 years ago

But a crucial piece of evidence called a taggant that could be used to trace the gunpowder used in the bombs to a buyer at a point of sale is not available to investigators.

If you had a good taggant this would be a good thing for this kind of crime. It could help identify the point of manufacturer, and chain of custody, Bob Morhard, an explosives consultant and chief executive officer of Zukovich, Morhard & Wade, LLC., in Pennsylvania, who has traced explosives and detonators in use in the United States and Saudi Arabia, told MSNBC.com. The problem is nobody wants to know what the material is.

Explosives manufacturers are required to place tracing elements known as identification taggants only in plastic explosives but not in gunpowder, thanks to lobbying efforts by the NRA and large gun manufacturing groups.

~LINK~

 
 
 
Mark in Wyoming
Professor Silent
link   Mark in Wyoming     13 years ago

larry i think you and i share this one if Mac picks us ,

 
 
 
Dowser
Sophomore Silent
link   Dowser    13 years ago

Hmmmmmm... I should ask Magnum this. Smile.gif

 
 
 
Dowser
Sophomore Silent
link   Dowser    13 years ago

Wow, all of you! I'm impressed! Smile.gif

 
 
 
TTGA
Professor Silent
link   TTGA    13 years ago

Explosives manufacturers are required to place tracing elements known as identification taggants only in plastic explosives but not in gunpowder

That's because there is no chain of custody for gunpowder. As long as you look 18, you can buy powder without even showing ID. The logistics of putting taggants in each can of powder and keeping the records on where it goes would be a paperwork nightmare (there are millions of cans sold every year and the final sale is made without keeping records). A registry of who buys powder, you say (backdoor ammunition registration)? Fat chance. Can you spell background check? The Senate wouldn't even pass that, what makes you think they would be stupid enough to try something much larger and more intrusive (and more expensive).

 
 
 
Buzz of the Orient
Professor Expert
link   Buzz of the Orient    13 years ago

Maybe it was made in China. After all, that's where gunpowder was invented.

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   seeder  A. Macarthur    13 years ago
We have multiple winners: the NRA in fact lobbied legislators a number of years ago and was successful in blocking a requirement for gun powder manufacturers to "tag" their products so that qualitative analyses could be done even subsequent to explosion.Put editorially, The NRA is the Lobby of Bombmakers!Thanks for participating - we have some smart folks here on NT.By all means continue the discussion.
 
 
 
FLYNAVY1
Professor Quiet
link   FLYNAVY1    13 years ago

Nice Robert...

Attack someone for publishing a supportable statement.... Best think again as to whom is pathetic here.

 
 
 
FLYNAVY1
Professor Quiet
link   FLYNAVY1    13 years ago

The logistics of putting taggants in each can of powder and keeping the records on where it goes would be a paperwork nightmare

With bar codes.... the tracking is simple. Are you telling me we shouldn't even try?

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   seeder  A. Macarthur    13 years ago

And we have some who are pathetic.

Robert, Good one! Self-assessment is a first step to possible rehabilitation.

FYI:

TERRORISM PREVENTION ACT--CONFERENCE REPORT (Senate - April 16, 1996)

[Page: S3365]

The Senate continued with the consideration of the conference report.

Mrs. FEINSTEIN. Mr. President, I thank the distinguished chairman of the Judiciary Committee for his work on this bill and the distinguished ranking member for his work on this bill.

I am particularly disappointed that the House succeeded in gutting the commonsense prohibition on distributing instructions for bomb making for criminal purposes. I will talk about that in a minute. But the good news is that the conference report also restored good provisions to this bill. I am especially gratified that the conference committee restored my amendment which gives the Secretary of Treasury the authority to require taggants for tracing explosives.

The Senator from Delaware, the distinguished ranking member, just explained what taggants are: simple little coded plastic chips that are mixed with batches of commercially available explosives. They allow law enforcement to trace a bomb that has exploded, just like one would trace a car by knowing the license plate number. That is exactly what taggants are.

It was studied 16 years ago. Everybody said go ahead with it. They have been available. And it has now happened.

Incidentally, it took the Unabomber 18 years to, quite possibly, get caught. Three people have been killed, 23 people have been wounded, in bombs that really plagued nine States. This time could have been cut in half, perhaps, if we had tagging of explosives.

Unfortunately, the bill completely exempts black powder from either tagging or study requirements. I must say, how can a bill even refute the ability to study tagging of black powder? The amendment I submitted on taggants essentially provided for its addition, taggants' addition, where explosives would be bought in larger amounts. But, where small amounts of black powder were purchased to use in antique guns and for small arms, the taggant would not be included.

The NRA opposes this. What the National Rifle Association is clearly saying is they do not want any taggants in black powder explosives period, or even a study of it. Can you imagine the power of an organization that is able to successfully say we will not even study the impact of tagging black powder, which is also used as the triggering device on major explosive bombs that are used by terrorists? I have a very hard time with that.

I heard the distinguished chairman of the Judiciary Committee just say the NRA opposed excluding alien terrorists from this country. The NRA opposed excluding alien terrorists from this country--unbelievable. I think I just heard him say the NRA opposed a prohibition on fundraising in this country by terrorist groups.

Let me tell you something, if anybody believes that Hamas is in this country raising money to use it for charitable purposes, I will sell you a bridge tomorrow. I will sell you a bridge tomorrow. That is just unbelievable to me.

Nevertheless, I thank the chairman of the Judiciary Committee for standing Utah tall in the conference committee on the issue of taggants. I would like to thank Senator Biden and Senator Kennedy for their help as well. I think this is a very important step forward and I do not mean to diminish it in any way.

I also must say that I view the habeas corpus reform also as an important step forward. Abuse of the writ of habeas corpus, most egregiously by death row inmates who file petition after petition after petition on groundless charges will come to an end with the passage and the signature of this bill. I believe it is long overdue.

For anyone who believes that habeas is not abused, let me just quickly--because it has been thrown out before, and I know others want to speak--speak about the Robert Alton Harris case. It, I think, is a classic case on what happened with Federal habeas corpus, and State habeas corpus.

Mr. Harris was convicted in 1978 for killing two 17-year-old boys in a merciless way, eating their hamburgers, and then going out and robbing a bank.

His conviction became final in October of 1981. Yet, he was able to delay enforcement of the California death penalty capital sentence until April 21, 1992--for 14 years.

Over that time, he filed no fewer than 6 Federal habeas petitions and 10 State petitions. Five execution dates--five execution dates--were set during the pendency of his case. In all, Harris and his attorneys engineered almost 14 years of delay and piecemeal litigation by misuse of habeas corpus, and, I might say, it was 14 years of unresolved grief for the parents of the children.

I think cases like that one point out the need for habeas corpus reform, and, frankly, I want to commend the Judiciary Committee, and in particular the chairman, for seeing that that is included.

Senator Hatch also just mentioned the pathogens incident. In the Judiciary Committee, we had some full hearings, that were rather chilling to many of us, on how easy it is to obtain human pathogens.

I cannot help but note that the Chair is a distinguished physician and surgeon who knows this area well. But what we found out, essentially, is that one person--namely, Larry Wayne Harris--managed to order and to receive samples of bubonic plague through the mail less than a year ago.

Incredibly, although he was caught, he could be charged with only wire and mail fraud, because there were no laws on the books prohibiting the possession of bubonic plague pathogens. In fact, he made up a letterhead and sent it in to a lab, asked to purchase the plague bacteria, and it was sent to him, no questions asked. So this bill clearly takes care of that problem.

It adds that any attempt, threat, or conspiracy to acquire dangerous biological agents for use as a weapon are crimes punishable by fines or imprisonment, up to life imprisonment.

It also asks the Secretary of HHS to establish and maintain a list of biological agents which pose a severe threat to the public safety, and it directs the Secretary to establish enforcement and safety procedures for the transfer of human pathogens.

As a matter of fact, a number of us wrote a letter to the President and urged that emergency action be taken quickly because of the potential ability of people to acquire these bacteria prior to the enactment of this statute.

I want to also express my thanks that fundraising by terrorist organizations will be prohibited in the United States of America. I think it is extraordinarily important that this take place.

I am also very pleased that there is a section, known as 330, of the conference report--which, as a matter of fact, I offered--which prohibits the United States from selling weapons and defense services to countries that the President determines are not fully cooperating with U.S. antiterrorism efforts.

This is a commonsense provision, and I am amazed that there has been nothing in law that meets it. But there certainly is no reason the United States should continue to provide weaponry to any country that refuses to do all it can to combat terrorism.

My big disappointment--and I think because the Presiding Officer is relatively new to this body, he would be interested to know--is that on the Internet today, there is a volume called The Terrorist Handbook. The Terrorist Handbook describes how you can make bombs, whether those bombs are in baby food jars, in electric light bulbs or in telephones. To my knowledge, there is no legal use for a bomb in a baby food jar, for a bomb in a light bulb, or for a bomb in a telephone. You know that once you teach somebody how to do that, their only use of the knowledge is to slaughter and to kill.

So I have a very hard time understanding why simple language, which says if you knowingly publish material with the intent of enabling someone to commit a crime, shall not be permitted.

Let me quote the February 2, 1996, New York Times Metro section. Headline: `3 Boys Used Internet to Plot School Bombing, Police Say.'

Three 13-year-old boys from the Syracuse area have been charged for plotting to set off a home-made bomb in their junior high school after getting plans for the device on the Internet. The boys, all eighth graders at Pine Grove Junior High School in the suburb of Minoa, were arrested Wednesday by the police. `There is no doubt that the boys were serious,' the captain said, adding that they've recently set off a test bomb in a field behind an elementary school and that it started a small fire.

This cartoon is exactly what is happening all across the United States with young people. The cartoon is a youngster, sort of a Dennis-the-Menace type sitting at his computer, wrapping dynamite and attaching a detonation and clock device to it, while his mother is on the telephone saying `History * * * astronomy * * * science * * * Bobby is learning so much on the Internet.'

I have another article. The Los Angeles Times, just this past Saturday, April 13: `Four Teens Admit to Bombs in Mission Viejo School Yard.'

The boys, all 15- and 16-year-olds, told investigators they learned how to build the small high-pressure explosives from friends who got it off the Internet. According to the chief, who is then quoted, `It's something they're getting off the Internet. Any time you mix volatile chemicals and have a little bit of knowledge, you put yourself and others in jeopardy.'

A third article, Orange County Register, `2 Home-Made Bombs Dismantled in Orange' County.

Authorities theorize that teens are learning how to make the 2-liter bottle devices on the Internet.

Ladies and gentlemen, how far do we wish to push the envelope of the first amendment?

Let me tell you what is also in this `Terrorist Handbook.' People say, `Well, we have a first amendment right.' There is a part on breaking into a lab. This `Terrorist Handbook,' which we downloaded yesterday on the Internet, let me quote from it. The first section deals with getting chemicals legally. This section deals with procuring them.

[Page: S3366]

The best place to steal chemicals is a college. Many state schools have all of their chemicals out on the shelves in the labs, and more in their chemical stockrooms. Evening is the best time to enter a lab building, as there are the least number of people in the building and most of the labs will still be unlocked. One simply takes a bookbag, wears a dress shirt and jeans, and tries to resemble a college freshman. If anyone asks what such a person is doing, the thief can simply say he's looking for the polymer chemistry lab or some other chemistry-related department other than the one they are in.

Then it goes on and it tells them how to pick the lock to break into the chem lab. It tells them what kind of chemicals to steal from the chem lab, and then to go out and how to make the bomb--baby food bomb, telephone bomb, light bulb bomb.

We know people are following this. Yet this conference committee deleted--deleted--a simple amendment which said, if you knowingly publish this kind of data with the view that someone will commit a crime, that is illegal--that is illegal. The conference committee voted it down, I would take it, at the behest of the National Rifle Association. Why? I cannot figure out why. I cannot to this day figure out why.

Let me give you one other quote that was on the Internet. It tells you where to go.

Go to the Sports Authority or Hermans sports shop and buy shotgun shells. At the Sports Authority that I go to you can actually buy shotgun shells without a parent or adult. They don't keep it behind the little glass counter or anything like that. It is $2.96 for 25 shells.

Then the computer bulletin board posting provides instructions on how to assemble and detonate the bomb. It concludes with:

If the explosion doesn't get 'em, then the glass will. If the glass doesn't get 'em, then the nails will.

This is what, by rejecting my simple amendment, the conference is saying is permissible on the Internet.

Let me give you one last thing so that it is, hopefully, indelibly etched in everybody's mind what we are doing. Following Oklahoma City, this was on the Internet.

`Are you interested in receiving information detailing the components and materials needed to construct a bomb identical to the one used in Oklahoma?' The information specifically details the construction, deployment, and detonation of high powered explosives. It also includes complete details of the bomb used in Oklahoma City and how it was used and how it could have been better.

How far are we pushing the envelope of the first amendment? What I have tried to show is that not only is this kind of thing with knowledge, with intent, on the Internet, but that youngsters are using it. They have used it within the last 2 weeks in New York, in California, and they have used it to do bodily harm to others.

So this is my big disappointment in this bill, because I believe we have as much to fear from domestic terrorism, as I think the Unabomber has pointed out, as we do from foreign terrorism. It begins right here at home. It begins with a system that lets everybody do anything they want, including telling you how to steal, break in and steal the chemicals, make the bombs, go out and deliver them.

I believe it is the job of this Congress to try to do something about it. With that in mind, I will support the amendment to recommit this to committee. I realize that that is a useless gesture, but just to make the point.

I will vote for this legislation and I will at the earliest time possible reintroduce my amendment on another bill to take another crack at saying the time has come for the United States of America to say, indeed, everything does not go. There are some restrictions and some things that we are going to do to stop criminality in this country. I thank the Chair and I yield the floor.

[Page: S3367]
 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   seeder  A. Macarthur    13 years ago

Thanks to Mark and Larry; the time stamps show them to have both presented the correct answer 8 hours ago.

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   seeder  A. Macarthur    13 years ago

Thanks. I've thought about it.

Amac. And now you.

Keep digging the hole for yourself, Robert G; no one does a better character assassination on you

Than you.

Of course, in order to do a character assassination, there must be character to assassinate

Fuckin' details.

 
 
 
Michael Barineau
Freshman Silent
link   Michael Barineau    13 years ago

Im all about the NRA personally. I just dont see what the big deal about tagging gun powder would be. I mean had they have instituted that in 96 then the logistical nightmare would have been over before i was out of high school anyway and the process would have been the norm. But whats done is done.

That is something that may have changed the situation and how events panned out, but the overwhelming fact is; these guys were going to do something super cereal to hurt people....regardless of the means.

If you are a Tax payer, then you have helped fund terrorist activities over the last 12 years. So also give yourself a slap on the back. Dont just knock the NRA. :)

 
 
 
luther28
Sophomore Silent
link   luther28    13 years ago

The answer was already in (mine would have been wrong), but I will sayI learned something new and a bit disturbing.

 
 
 
TTGA
Professor Silent
link   TTGA    13 years ago

Are you telling me we shouldn't even try?

No, I'm telling you it's an idea that would accomplish nothing and isn't worth the expense. Another example of law made based on emotion. Laws based on emotion are invariably bad laws, since they're not properly thought out.

 
 
 
luther28
Sophomore Silent
link   luther28    13 years ago

Yup. Much different train of thought than my own. Strange days, that is for sure and certain, I only hope it is not contagious.

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   seeder  A. Macarthur    13 years ago

Now that the police are going about putting bullets into the assholes, you can ask them where they bought their materials. If they survive.

You can ask them what kind of toilet paper they use when you write your fan mail. Maybe it's your brand!

Translation of Robert G's comment.

"I can't stand it when anyone posts information contrary to my desired outcomes/beliefs/opinions etc. regarding any given issue. Whenever I can post no valid rebuttal (which is virtually all the time), I will instead post quips that are intended to insult that individual(s) with whom I disagree."*

___________________________________________________

NOTE: Please see my discussion on why I tend not to delete comments like Robert G's.

Also see the Mayo Clinic list and my explanation as to why I included it.

* When Robert disagrees, it's indication enough that the information he disparages is completely accurate.

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   seeder  A. Macarthur    13 years ago

NRA Opposes Bill to Prevent Suspected Terrorists From Buying Guns

May 4, 2007 - by Donny Shaw

Lat week, I mentioned a bill introduced by Frank Lautenberg (D, NJ) that would close a loophole that currently allows suspected terrorists to legally purchase guns. Today, the AP is reporting that the NRA has officially come out against the bill:

>nra_logo.jpg The National Rifle Association is urging the Bush administration to withdraw its support of a bill that would prohibit suspected terrorists from buying firearms. Backed by the Justice Department, the measure would give the attorney general the discretion to block gun sales, licenses or permits to terror suspects.
>
> In a letter this week to Attorney General Alberto Gonzales, NRA executive director Chris Cox said the bill, offered last week by Sen. Frank Lautenberg, D-N.J., would allow arbitrary denial of Second Amendment rights based on mere suspicions of a terrorist threat.
>
>"As many of our friends in law enforcement have rightly pointed out, the word suspect has no legal meaning, particularly when it comes to denying constitutional liberties," Cox wrote.

It is unlikely that their line of reasoning will work with President Bush. He has done much worse when it comes to denying constitutional liberties to people based on a mere suspicions of a terrorist threat. But, since it is the NRA that is asking, loyalty may weigh out reason and cause him to back away from the bill.

Here is the letter that the NRA sent to Attorney General Gonzales.

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   seeder  A. Macarthur    13 years ago

Oh, I think I can do the idiot math here.

No one doubts that for a second.

Robert G, clearly puzzled asked

Who fucking cares if the FBI can trace the manufacturer of the gun powder used in the Boston Marathon bombs?

Oh, another quiz, Robert G?

My guess would be "the parents of a murdered 8 year old boy and dozens of others plus every sane person in America."

6873_discussions.jpg The parents of this boy

I have several friends who are NRA members -- thankfully, not one of which is the "Heartless Fuck variety who values guns over lives."

 
 
 
Larry Hampton
Professor Quiet
link   Larry Hampton    13 years ago

Gotta give it to Mark as I didn't know until I Googled.

:~)

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   seeder  A. Macarthur    13 years ago

Gotta give it to Mark as I didn't know until I Googled.

Decent of you, Larry, but I think the identical time stamps indicate co-champions.

 
 
 
Mark in Wyoming
Professor Silent
link   Mark in Wyoming     13 years ago

a copule things have come up since i posted last night that ild like to adress and put on the table for some thought . first is the shortest issue and why it was apposed . sen latenburg proposed that SUSPECTED terrorists be refusebuying guns . on the face sounds like a good idea until one delves into it . first of anyone can be suspected of anything , but under our legal system no rights can be removed until one is charged and or convicted . simply being suspected of something is not good enough . how mr latenberg stated he would determine this was to use the lists compiled by the government , those lists that no one can check ( national security reasons)to see if they are even on the lists , and there is no legal recourse that if you are inadvertantly place on these lists to have ones name removed . perfect example is the no- fly list look at how many people have erronously been placed on these so called "lists" it took being a sittin US senator from Mass to have his name taken of the list in one case . so though it sounded like a good idea , it didnt fit with the legal presedent of due process guarenteed by the constituion in this country . so of course many , not just the NRA opposed such ultimately bad legislation.

on to the second of taggants , and this is more of simply my opinion based on my knowledge and i am by far not an expert nor even claim to be the expert or authority .

the taggant issue came about in the mid 90s after the OKC and Atlanta bombings , there had bin other instances leading up to this time frame but as i remember these 2 were the catalysts that brought the issue to a boil.

Currently commerciallymade high explosives are made with taggants as the law allows , but some desired it as someone has posed that ALL explosives should have a taggant . there were as i remember a couple of issues as to why different organizations opposed this and again it wasnt just the NRA that opposed this . Gunpowder has a shelf life as do many things , but it if stored under the porper and optimal conditions can stay usable for many yrs . so a taggant would nessisarily help in an investigation all no taggant could men if it wasimplimented was that someone used pre taggant powder .

TTGA pointed out that buying just powder ( smokeless or black ) is a simple process , in most places no permit or id needed over the counter and usually is bought in 1 or 5 pound containers ( serious reloaders either buy multiples of the above in 10 pound containers , me i like the 1 pounders because i only have to expose 1 pound at a time and get to keep the factory seal intact on the rest) now reloaders when the issue was discussed were opposed because of the method of tagging , those small microsized plastic chips those added into the mix , altered the preformance of the powder however so slightly, youll get an altering naturally from batch to batch , but thats to be expected for reloaders , the problem for reloaders themselves was that how much the addition alterd the powder could not be controled because the mix of the chips could not be uniformly distributed even in the one pound can . keep in mind people reload for a variety of reasons , some to save money , some to increase accuracy over that of commercial factory load usually done by competition shooters whose end goal is to have the most accurate and uniform ammunition possable . the taggants affect on burn rate altered all existing tables and data to be unusable because the taggants affect was not uniform when your attempting to create match grade ammo there are certain things that are considered and a consistant burn rate and pressure are one of them . something taggans affected dramatically and there was no way and is no way to effectively compensate for .

when shooting in competitions , a person breaks down the components and well as the actions , attempting to make that so called "perfect" shot , and in order to make that shot everything has to be consistant , everything has to be the same . so competition shooters tweek their guns thats one aspect they can control it does the same thing each and every time , another component broken down is the ammo , from the projectile to the legth of the case ( all sized and trimed to the same dimesions 0 to the same exact powder charge down to the granual to even the type and batch of primer used . onece they find that "perfect recipe" they tend to stick with it for their particular guns , now id everything is good , the gun does the same things over and over again , the ammo is exactly identical from round to round , any aerror or diviation is only in one place and it is there that those that enjoy shooting be it in competition or simply as siomething they enjoy to challenge themselves withis the human factor , which is why they practice the proper basics of shooting , from breathing control and trigger queeze . if they have a flyer on the target and the gun and ammo are all the same , the flyer is caused by something that they did .

IMHO these things played factors in why gunpowders were exempted , and it wasnt just the NRA opposing them , powdermakers , reloaders hunters target shooters all had concerns as how it would affect their individual aspects of how they used these things . i think it was a combination of all the deriding factors associated with doing it that defeated taggants in powder itself especially since and in no particular order , the amount of older powder still out there , the fact that the composition of and ease om making your own would negate the usefulness of it . so why not tag all explosive materials or components? want to have to show iD for buying a bag of charcoal? how about being put on a list because you habitually buy clorine bleach or even just clorine tablets for your pool and ammonia ? I can almost guarentee you , i can walk into a non gun owners house that absolutely contains no gun powder , but just with the contents most people keep under their sinks or in their garages and basements . come up with something that could make what happened in boston pale by comparison. whats the answer ? tag it all? and place all of us on suspect lists ?

sorry for the legth mac , but just some things to think about .

 
 
 
Michael Barineau
Freshman Silent
link   Michael Barineau    13 years ago

Oh Mac, do we need to go down the dead baby road again?

This time Mac, I am certain that the events that led up to this could have been mitigated had there have been more regulations placed on explosive substances. As far as chain of custody and tracking.

As much as it pains me to agree with you. Tongue.gif

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   seeder  A. Macarthur    13 years ago

first of anyone can be suspected of anything , but under our legal system no rights can be removed until one is charged and or convicted . simply being suspected of something is not good enough .

I agree with that, but I'll bet that a significant segment of NRA just loved the Arizona "reasonable suspicion" racial profiling" fiasco of a law. Let's be consistent. And like it or not, since 9-11 we have watch lists that deny a number of rights and privileges in the name of "ounce-of-prevention."

powdermakers , reloaders hunters target shooters all had concerns as how it would affect their individual aspects of how they used these thing.

I can't verify this but I'm looking further.

three NRA board members have financial interests in reloading manufacturers, so their "advocacy" (i.e. making our country vulnerable to terrorist attacks) is motivated not by public interest but personal greed.

RE:

sorry for the legth mac , but just some things to think about

No problem, it promotes dialogue.

 
 
 
Buzz of the Orient
Professor Expert
link   Buzz of the Orient    13 years ago

Let me preface what I have to say by exposing the fact that I know little about guns, never having owned one except the one I made out of two sticks and a couple of nails when I was a little kid. What I really want to know is why the possible use of taggants (sp?) is a concern to anyone who uses black powder for innocent purposes? It seems to me that it can prove innocence just as DNA does, as well as being a factor to prove guilt. Now that I think of it, if use of taggants is outlawed, then why isn't DNA outlawed as well?

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   seeder  A. Macarthur    13 years ago

Oh Mac, do we need to go down the dead baby road again?

Call me "sentimental" -- a "bleeding-heart liberal."

Proud of it too.

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   seeder  A. Macarthur    13 years ago

What I really want to know is why the possible use of taggants (sp?) is a concern to anyone who uses black powder for innocent purposes? It seems to me that it can prove innocence just as DNA does, as well as being a factor to prove guilt. Now that I think of it, if use of taggants is outlawed, then why isn't DNA outlawed as well?

Possibly because and I can't verify this but I'm looking further.

three NRA board members have financial interests in reloading manufacturers, so their "advocacy" (i.e. making our country vulnerable to terrorist attacks) is motivated not by public interest but personal greed.

 
 
 
Mark in Wyoming
Professor Silent
link   Mark in Wyoming     13 years ago

Buzz , maybe my line of thought can answer your question of why it could be a concern. and it could also be a response to charles as well.

black powder is measured by volume we call grains , easg granuale takes up space . in order for that plastic chip to be inserted ( remember there isnt just 1 but many ) they will replace the explosive granuals with nonexplosive granuales . the tables we use to determine the amount of pwder is set to the volume take some of those granuales out and the charge thuse becomes smaller , in some fire arms the powder charge is what also operates the actions , too light a charge the gun fires but wont cycle . the compesation would to be add a tad more powder , but since there is no way to regulate how the taggants are dispersed within the powder itself , the question is how much more to add? too much and you have an over charge which could be a potential danger to bystanders and the shooters . this would be true of all powders be it th black powder associated with antique firearms , or modern guns using smokeless powder , . too add the taggants they require space , with out redesign of the cartridges or powdercharges themselves its now a guess how much is actually powder and how much would actually be non explosive taggants .

Another reason based on this theory maybe use of taggants in gun powder was suspect , imagine a cop having to depend on a commercially made round , but the powder charge is as i said insuficcient to operate his weapon or make it a soldier on the front line . is it then worth the risk or decrease in accuracy or some percieved security and safety?

as for black powder , the recipe is simple been around for thousands of yrs , its not hard to make if you have charcoal , sulfer and potasium nitrate . all can be obtained naturally . sulfer and charcoal are real easy , the potasium nitrate i leach out of chicken shit . and its just as effective as the pyrodex bought commercially , just means i clean the guns a little better after use . think of that some might be shooting chicken shit at ya , whats the world coming too?

 
 
 
Buzz of the Orient
Professor Expert
link   Buzz of the Orient    13 years ago

Thanks for taking the time to provide that explanation, Mark. Not being a chemist or a gun expert I have no idea how much or how little taggants can affect a proper charge, or what proportion is even needed for identification, so unless someone can disprove your theory it appears reasonable.

I must confess I had not read your explanation above before asking my question.

 
 
 
Michael Barineau
Freshman Silent
link   Michael Barineau    13 years ago

Not to mention Coalition Forces in both Iraq and Afghanistan.

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   seeder  A. Macarthur    13 years ago

you have got to be fucking kidding me. so now its the NRA's fault for the bombing. you are amazing dude.

Don't fucking misquote or mischaracterize what I post; it's the NRA that killed the provision in a bill that would have allowed the tagging of gunpowder and made it easier to trace purchases and expedite investigations of things like bombings.

Either work on your reading comprehension or get an interpreter.

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   seeder  A. Macarthur    13 years ago

Yup. Amac and the pictures.

The NRA did it. If emoting reflected brain power we could solve anything.

I could get a Nobel just for saying that I'm sad.

I didn't say the NRA did it and I'm tired of the intentional misquotes and mischaracterizations; if you do it again AT ANY TIME I will tell you to leave this (or any other) discussion of mine and stay the fuck away.

Only a heartless self-serving, ass-backwards-priority fuck would mock the posting of a photograph of a child murdered by fanatic lunatics.

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   seeder  A. Macarthur    13 years ago

oh yay pics again.

Tough guys can't deal with pictures of murdered children ironic, sickening.

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   seeder  A. Macarthur    13 years ago

Guess what ass???? with common items around the house you can make a bomb.

Not the point and watch what you call me; do it again and you'll be directed not to comment on any of my discussions.

I'll type slowly; the "tagging" of gunpowder, while it wouldn't be a factor regarding homemade gunpowder, in conjunction with crimes where manufactured gunpowder was used, it could establish a trail to possible suspects.

Gun-worshipers don't appear to give a fuck about human life if deferring to it might mitigate or even minimally affect their 2nd Amendment rights.

so how about you go find another fuck the NRA tree to go climb up, This one isnt going to support your big headed moronic ideas.

The NRA is in the process of fucking itself; there's a limit to what even reasonable and ordinarily indifferent people will tolerate.

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   seeder  A. Macarthur    13 years ago

Jason, they had pics of the suspects two days in. If the bomb remnants contained pictures of these guys buying gun powder in a particular store, they couldn't have been on these two any faster.

Not the point; if the FBI hadn't had pictures which is more typical of crime scenes

Never mind, waste of fucking time.

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   seeder  A. Macarthur    13 years ago

The presenter of this article wants to blame gun owners for what terrorists did.

I'm catching up on comments in this thread; if you misquote or mischaracterize what I state one more time, I will direct you to leave this article and not comment in any future articles. You know exactly what culpability I placed on the NRA regarding the gun powder.

 
 
 
Buzz of the Orient
Professor Expert
link   Buzz of the Orient    13 years ago

That's exactly my opinion too, A.Mac. Just what you didn't say.

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   seeder  A. Macarthur    13 years ago

The tagging of gun powder would only be of use in the investigation of a crime, and wouldn't provide a paper trail back to the purchaser,

But in the absence of, or where there is a limited amount of other evidence, it would provide an option that doesn't currently exist. And in a "round up" of the "usual suspects," matched residue samples could start/continue a "paper trail."

Now for some connect-the-dots.

BOB HOGDON

He's been a tireless defender of the Second Amendment including two terms as a NRA Board Member and NRA Foundation Trustee.
Hogdon Powder Co.!!!!!!!!!!!

POWDER COMPANY!

  • National Reloading Manufacturers Association
  • Treasurer and Board Member Hodgdon Powder Company

Robert Hodgdon (cited earlier) is president of Hodgdon Powder Company and a charter member of the National Reloading Manufacturers Association .
The company makes gun powder. Mr. Hodgdon has in the past maintained that taggants would force an increase in prices that would lead to reduced sales.
Profiteer whores!
I'm continuing to research. Stay tuned.
 
 
 
Buzz of the Orient
Professor Expert
link   Buzz of the Orient    13 years ago

"The company makes gun powder. Mr. Hodgdon has in the past maintained that taggants would force an increase in prices that would lead to reduced sales."

In other words, he was not at all concerned about whether the taggants would affect the accuracy or power of the shot, which is Mark's theory. It all had to do with his personal greed.

 
 
 
Mark in Wyoming
Professor Silent
link   Mark in Wyoming     13 years ago

TTGA , remember the first thing we talked about in PM last night ? i think i had a BINGO , or YATZEE or whatever.

 
 
 
Mark in Wyoming
Professor Silent
link   Mark in Wyoming     13 years ago

SO do i mac i only know because of my involvement with reloading and it was anumber of yrs ago.

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   seeder  A. Macarthur    13 years ago

Robert G,

Leave my article and don't come back to this or any other of mine; what's clear is your fucked up priorities and your willingness to distort facts to rationalize a character-disorder perspective.

I will not delete your comment; I want all reasonable individuals who come to this thread to be reminded of the depraved gun-worshiper myopic mental state.

Any future comments by you on my discussions will be deleted.

 
 
 
Leotie
Freshman Silent
link   Leotie    13 years ago

It DOES have a signature of sorts. I heard this on TV either yesterday or today. It was while they had left the weather portion and then to this. But, yes, it does have a signature of sorts.

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   seeder  A. Macarthur    13 years ago

Two Words to say about that:

BULL SHIT!!!

Virtually every NRA lobbying effort to kill common sense gun safety reforms gives an edge to criminals and has less to do with Second Amendment rights than it does with gun sales.

Those relatively few NRA rank-and-file members who support such lobbying efforts and believe they do so to protect the Second Amendment are consequently a frightening lot

To be that naive and gullible and simultaneously in possession of firearms almost guarantees future catastrophes.

 
 
 
Perrie Halpern R.A.
Professor Guide
link   Perrie Halpern R.A.    13 years ago

Robert, that comment was beyond the pale. Do not return to this article.
Mac, You can't ban Robert from all of your articles.

 
 
 
Mark in Wyoming
Professor Silent
link   Mark in Wyoming     13 years ago

6874_discussions.jpg Well , this didnt take long , Sen Latenberg( D-NJ) has announced 2 proposed amendments to the not quite yet dead S-649( gun violence bill recently shelved) the amendments title is the explosive materials background check act . basically the language used is that persons buying gunpowder would need to submit to the same background check as those purchasing a firearm currently( excuse me but im not making this up and i am trying REALLY hard to stifle myself ).

OK this is the same guy that wrote legislation that wanted to give the AG the arbitrary power to determine if a person suspected of terrorist ties or activities should be put on the prohibitted persons list without a trial charges or conviction( sounds alot like the amendment he got passed about those accused of domestic violence loosing their guns ).

OK i think its time that those with their hands up Sen latenbergs ass , find a new sperm doner to shoot latey his daily dose of nut butter for brains . seems the latest swimmers arent that strongand are affecting th senators actions . and they might want to changethe delivery route . up the nose doesnt seem to be working.

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   seeder  A. Macarthur    13 years ago
Jason,The picture was posted because Robert G asked who would care whether or not the gunpowder in the bombs was tagged. I indicated that the parents of the dead child whose picture I posted, would care.
 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   seeder  A. Macarthur    13 years ago
Let's be clear about something;
 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   seeder  A. Macarthur    13 years ago

Nowhere in my article that I say the NRA was responsible for the marathon bombing; what I did say was the NRA as a lobby is responsible for the inability of government, particularly the FBI to trace the manufacturer of a particular gunpowder in order to expedite an investigation.

But several people in this article, in the true NRA manner of lying about or mischaracterizing a particular issue (such as they did regarding the law that was just struck down, namely that there was a national registry provision in that law, which there was not), at least twice in my article, it was stated or implied that I stated the NRA was responsible for the bombing.

I did not and I resent this tactic of making a false accusation then challenging me on that accusation.

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   seeder  A. Macarthur    13 years ago
Robert G,You're banned from this article.
 
 
 
Mark in Wyoming
Professor Silent
link   Mark in Wyoming     13 years ago

jason , some folks dont understand the concept of adepttation , those bombs didnt need actual gunpowder , the heels could have adapted by using perfectly legal fireworks as their explosive material they could have soaked sawdust i diesal . so far i dont think anyone has came out and said exactly how the bombs were constructed . personally i think using the imagage of these dead kids is more hurtful to their parents , especially without their permission , yeah the intent is to show others that these kids are gone , thats a fact that the parents will deal with ,with pain for the rest of their lives and everytime they are used with or without permission , to me is like stabbing these people in the heart again and again , and for what to further your adgenda ? to shame people to comply with your wishes?

and its not working so your going to continue to inflict pain on these families that have experiened a loss no parent should endure? thats the definition of a Ghoul to me , you say that if we dont do something we are uncaring , your use of the dead , and the pain your inflicting on the parents to me is uncaring .

I dont care if they were published and available on the internet , i dont CARE about common use agreements and law , what i do care about is the politisizing and the possible use without the permission of the rightful owners of those pictures , the parents . will they care about taggants , thats for them not us to say , i think the questions and what they care about , isnt how their children died , but the question they are most likely struggling with and may never get a suitable answer to is WHY ,yeah the antis will say the why was the availability , the pro guns will say the why is there are bad people out there we really cant do anything about . but the answer they are looking for they have to find and come to grips with for themselves . so let the ghouls continue to abuse the dead , and pretend its because they care , their actions speak otherwise , because if they cared they wouldnt torment the parents in their greatest grief .

thats right , i call ANYONE that prostitutes the pictures of these kids , GHOULS predators of the dead .

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   seeder  A. Macarthur    13 years ago

anyways aside from all this nonesense. I love blame the nra for every thingt hat happens in the world. next time there is a natural disaster you should post more pics of dead kids and blame the NRA.

That hyperbole is part of the problem, Jason; the NRA DOES NOT GET BLAMED FOR "EVERYTHING THAT HAPPENS IN THE WORLD," only that for which it is actually responsible. You have wrongly mischaracterized my position in this thread as have others.

I HAVE NOT BLAMED THE NRA FOR THE MARATHON BOMBINGS! I have blamed the NRA LOBBY (not its rank-and-file members) for killing legislation regarding the tagging of gunpowder and, more recently, killing the reform legislation BY LYING, by falsely stating THAT IT MANDATED A NATIONAL REGISTRY. In fact, that legislation contained language THAT PROHIBITED THE FORMATION OF A NATIONAL REGISTRY AND HAD SANCTIONS AGAINST ANYONE WHO TRIED TO ESTABLISH ONE! Unfortunately, there were those who didn't bother to learn the facts AND WHO NEVER BOTHER, rather they either willingly buy the lies, start them and/or spread them

Somewhere in this thread I posted information about the NRA Board Member who owns a powder manufacturing company and how he helped kill the tagging legislation! That's putting greed ahead of making FBI investigations more potentially efficient.

You are more than welcome to express yourself in my articles; but you are not welcome to post misinformation and falsely attribute it to those with whom you disagree -- that's dishonest.

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   seeder  A. Macarthur    13 years ago

B/C if it was tagged they still wouldn't have been able to make the bomb right??

Jason, that can't be a serious comment. Tagging has nothing to do with "making the bomb." It has to do with, in the absence of conclusive evidence, allowing the FBI, etc. to try and establish perpetrator identity by working back to the purchase and purchaser(s) of materials found in conjunction with a crime.

Did I really have to explain that?

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   seeder  A. Macarthur    13 years ago

Robert G,

You are banned from this thread. I'll be deleting your last comment and any further comments after you've had time to get this notification.

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   seeder  A. Macarthur    13 years ago

then it doesn't rule the individual out.

Where "beyond a reasonable doubt" is the standard for conviction, if motive and opportunity are definitively established, ironically, should a non-tag-matching sample of gunpowder be found in a suspect's residence, vehicle, on his clothing or even under his finger nails, that might even become exculpatory!

On the other hand, if motive and opportunity are established and a gunpowder sample linked to the suspect matches a tagged sample, that might get the prosecution to "beyond a reasonable doubt."

Why any reasonable person would advocate a lesser advantage to law enforcement over a potential for greater advantage, makes little sense unless, the NRA has propagandized effectively, bought legislators, or both!

Ooops! Case closed.

 
 
 
Montego
Freshman Silent
link   Montego    13 years ago

As I understand it, all explosives (to include cartridge powder) commercially manufactured in the United States is required to and does have a 'marker' ingredient added that is unique to each specific 'batch'.

The reason that the FBI was not able to trace the origins of the explosive is because it, perhaps, was not manufactured in the United States.

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   seeder  A. Macarthur    13 years ago
Lobbying for legislation that assists bomb makers in a avoiding being identified, apprehended, tried and convicted is not the same as setting off the bomb itself is it? Lobbying to stop legislation which would restrict the sale and manufacture of 30 round ammunition magazine is not the same as murdering 20 children ... it just helps the murderer to murder them faster and more efficiently.I choose my words carefully, Jason, knowing that even then they will be misconstrued or intentionally misrepresented by some nevertheless; but your question was fair and I trust I have answered it directly.
 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   seeder  A. Macarthur    13 years ago

But from what i understand some morons belive the NRA in some way helped build the bombs, im just trying to explore the imagination of those who believe that way. Oh yes thats right evidance. so they can be tried in our alreday flawed system. they go to jail there will be no justice. kill them that wil bring justice

Anyone who believes that does qualify for moron status; we agree.

As for our judicial system, flawed or not, if we resort to the system of "justice" of our enemies, they will have succeeded in destroying or disrupting ours. I doubt you want that.

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   seeder  A. Macarthur    13 years ago
Jason,I'm saying that regardless of the outcome of any prosecution of any American citizen, if we violate our own Constitution, we are hypocritical and act like the very Barbarians who are our enemies.
 
 
 
Michael Barineau
Freshman Silent
link   Michael Barineau    13 years ago

So..........does this also apply to the 2nd Amendment rights?

 
 
 
Michael Barineau
Freshman Silent
link   Michael Barineau    13 years ago

On a more serious note, did they ever come out and say that gun powder was used to make the explosive device?

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   seeder  A. Macarthur    13 years ago
Michael,I asked you et al first; should all amendments be inviolable?My answer is that since the Constitution is amendable, it is ever subject to change according to the time. I confess my purpose for asking is to determine if those who will not accept any changes to the 2nd Amendment would want an American citizen's 14th Amendment rights to be abrogated for any reason.Your turn.
 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   seeder  A. Macarthur    13 years ago

this whole being the better person stuff is for sissys. and this is why ass clowns keep attacking us.

It's not about being a "better person," it's about respecting our own laws and not being a hypocrite nation.

If we suspend the 14th Amendment rights because they are being afforded to an indicted citizen for the worst type of criminal act, that to show we're not a "sissy" nation -- to show "we're-tough-on-murderers-so-fuck-the-law," then an argument could be made to suspend the 2nd Amendment when the Adam Lanzas come along.

"Hey all you Adam Lanza types out there -- fuck you -- no more right-to-bear-arms you murdering-bastards-in-waiting."

We can't destroy our system of justice to show we're not "sissified." We can be tough and fair simultaneously unlike our enemies.

 
 
 
Michael Barineau
Freshman Silent
link   Michael Barineau    13 years ago

So we should get rid of abortion too?

 
 
 
Michael Barineau
Freshman Silent
link   Michael Barineau    13 years ago

Im pulling your leg on those other two comments. I agree that because of his status he should and will be given the treatment reserved to him. That means going through the legal system and getting off on the charges against him. Which may happen given the way are justice department seems to work these days. I am still curious though if they ever came out with the post blast analysis for those devices, i really want to know what they used.

 
 
 
Mark in Wyoming
Professor Silent
link   Mark in Wyoming     13 years ago

just reported on NBC Nightly news , that the surviving bomber , used legally purchased fireworks that he bought in NH , not gunpowder used for ammunition . hmmmm mebbe they should make china ( where most commercial fireworks are made ) place taggants in it there in China.

Gee who was it that said that legally purchased fireworks could have been used for the explosive materials? lucky guess i guess.

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   seeder  A. Macarthur    13 years ago
Chemistry and Fireworks

For many people the attraction of chemistry starts with fireworks - bangs, flashes, stars in the night sky, catherine wheels and Roman candles. Even the smell of gunpowder (the main propellant and explosive in fireworks) is evocative of bonfire nights and celebrations. Fireworks (and gunpowder) were probably invented by the Chinese and are still a major feature of Chinese celebrations. Bige events are usually marked by firework displays - who can forget the fireworks in Sydney or Dublin at the start of 2000?

TOC40_1.jpg

 
 
 
Mark in Wyoming
Professor Silent
link   Mark in Wyoming     13 years ago

gunpowder not under the authority or jurisdiction of our laws EI I can see the chinese government telling the US government where to go if taggants were demanded . besides , i REALLY wouldnt want to use what they use in fireworks as a substitute for the powder for my firearms .

 
 
 
Buzz of the Orient
Professor Expert
link   Buzz of the Orient    13 years ago

Why should the chinese care, they do it to US products,

What, exactly, do the Chinese do to US products? Don't many civilized countries require labelling of country of origin.

 
 
 
Krishna
Professor Guide
link   Krishna    13 years ago

Here's why:

It is possible to put a substance called, I believe, a "tagger" or "taggant" in explosives. This enables the police to trace the explosive back to the source. (Its very effective-- in fact I believe that this technique works not only for explosives before they are blown up, but even afterwards!)

If this was present at the crime scene in Boston it would help then investigation quite a lot. However, its not allowed in gunpowder.

Why?

Well, a particular lobbying group has been effective in preventing the use of taggers/taggants.

Now, IMO, the use of this technique would help police immeasurably-- its a really stupid idea not to do it. Golly gee-- I wonder who would be stupid enough to oppose its use? (Other than, of course, A-criminals, B-terrorists, and C-those who sympathize with either or both groups and/or wish to aid them in eluding capture and being brought to justice).

Quiz Q #2_-who could these folks possibly be?

 
 
 
Mark in Wyoming
Professor Silent
link   Mark in Wyoming     13 years ago

EI , given the perpensity of whats already happened with conjecture( it was the TP, it was a jihad , it was ( fill in the blank) speculation , imagine if the taggants traced the explosive to China , then fireworks , yeah im sure some moron would have then been saying there was a Maoist-islamic conspirocy , think things are batshit crazy now with speculation?

krishna , as for your quiz 2 , ild be against it but not for the reasons you list , earlier i detailed the aspect of reloading , and how the taggants couldnt be uniformlydistributed tob able to adiquetly be able to compensate for the taggant , powder ratio , too little powder you get a malfunction too much and you create an over pressure that could be catastrophic in the end results . take into account that the ammunition companies also supply the military , and LEO would be using the same powders , do you think either of those groups would willingly risk having either a misfire , or an explosive bolt situation? and should they be asked to have to put themselves in that position because some think it will aide in investigations somewhere down the line ?

An example i can use for reloading , a 45 acp takes a charge of between 4 and 10 grains of powder dependant on the type of powder and the type of load you desire , lets use 5 as a benchmark , if half of it is taggant that means only 2,5 is powder , well below the charge needed to function the weapon , granted at 5 it would function normally if it was all powder , now lets saywe compensate by adding another 2.5 grains , still below the max of 10 grains but heavier load than desired that would cause undesired resultssuch as shooting differently and changing the point of impact , the problem is as i stated , there is no way to tell from round to round , how much is taggant and how much powder , you might get 1 roung=d thats goes true , the next shoots high , the next drops at yopur feet about 6 ft in front of you . imagine how this would affect training or qualification in the 2 different careeres i mentioned .

it cannot be compensated for safely , and due to the nature it cannot be predicted what the mix ratio would be from round to round , thus creating an unsafe condition .

 
 
 
pat wilson
Professor Quiet
link   pat wilson    13 years ago

This may be a dumb question. Can you trace gunpowder from an exploded device ?

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   seeder  A. Macarthur    13 years ago

If there's any recoverable residue and a taggant has been incorporated in the manufacturing process, the answer is "yes."

BUT, the NRA lobbied in 1996 to keep the use of taggants from gunpowder!

How the NRA Impeded the Boston Bomber Investigation

By David Cay Johnston, The National Memo

20 April 13

rsn-T.jpg he intense hunt for the Boston Marathon bombers illustrates another way that the National Rifle Association helps mass murderers - by delaying how quickly they can be identified.

The inability to quickly track the gunpowders in the Boston bombs is due to government policy designed and promoted by the NRA, which has found a way to transform every massacre associated with weapons into an opportunity for the munitions companies that sustain it to sell more guns, gunpowder and bullets.

The price for such delays was put on terrible display Friday morning when the two brothers, who had been caught on video placing the bombs, killed one police officer, wounded another and carjacked a motorist, creating conditions so unsafe that the 7th largest population center in America spent Friday on lockdown.

But for the NRA-backed policy of not putting identifiers known as taggants in gunpowder, law enforcement could have quickly identified the explosives used to make the bombs, tracking them from manufacture to retail sale. That could well have saved the life of Sean Collier, the 26-year-old MIT police officer who was gunned down Thursday night by the fleeing bomb suspects.

Had the suspects in the Boston bombings killed by slipping poison into bottled water or canned food at a factory, or lacing spinach in a field with a deadly chemical, it would have taken only minutes to a few hours to identify exactly where that food was manufactured and how it moved through the food chain. That would have quickly narrowed the search for suspects.

With many food products you can use a smartphone app to scan the product's barcode and learn where, when and by what company the product was made. Cans and bottles also come with codes printed or stamped on them to help stop foodborne illness by tracking products to their source.

"With almost any food these days you can quickly track it from the source to the store where it was sold," according to Bill Marler, a Seattle litigator who specializes in food safety cases and sponsors the website Food Safety News .

Had the Boston bombers used a plastic explosive, it would have included identifiers that would have allowed a quick trace. Those taggants exist because the NRA does not oppose them.

Why is that? Why this breach in the NRA's Maginot Line of defense against reasonable regulation of guns and ammunition?

The answer appears to lie in who makes plastic explosives like Semtx, which was used to bring down Pan Am Flight 103 over Lockerbie, Scotland, in 1988. The world's main supplier was not a company that finances the NRA, but Libya under Moammar Khadafy.

That this one breach in NRA policy traces directly to the economic interests of the American munitions industry provides powerful evidence of what motivates the NRA - profits.

That the gun makers have managed to turn each massacre into a spike in sales of both expensive rapid-fire weapons and ammunition adds to the evidence that the NRA should be viewed as the mass-murder lobby.

The major source of plastic explosives may also be significant in understanding the NRA's willingness to go along with taggants for plastic explosives, which are much more powerful than gunpowder.

But gunpowder, like guns, are extremely difficult to trace because for more than three decades the NRA has fought to make sure it's difficult to almost impossible to do.

That difficulty results not from the technical issues at hand, though the NRA tries to make people think that's the case by mischaracterizing a 1980 government report.

In the case of guns, the NRA claims anything remotely resembling a gun registry or a national database tracking guns from manufacturer to retail sale would help the government disarm the citizenry. In this the NRA fuels the fantasy that in the event the American government turned on the people, bands of armed patriots could defeat the military with its trained soldiers, aircraft, drones, advanced weaponry and communications.

Iraqi households almost all had guns, too, but that did not protect them from their country's military or the invading American-led ground forces a decade ago.

Bombs have long been used in America for personal, criminal and political purposes. The frequency of bombings may surprise many people given the intense focus on the Boston bombs.

Roughly 5,000 bombings and attempted bombings are reported in the U.S. each year, according to Bureau of Alcohol, Tobacco and Firearms reports.

The ATF data, like that the FBI gathers, takes a broad measure, counting bombs made from matchsticks as well as dynamite.

The level of reported bombings in 2011 and 2012 was triple the number compared to more than four decades ago, when I wrote a three-part series in the afternoon San Jose News on homemade explosive devices. Back then, as a staff writer for the morning San Jose Mercury, I covered California radicals, left and right, and the cops trying to catch them. I even got one bomb-maker in 1972 to invite me home to see a nonworking bomb model fashioned from advice in a book we both owned, anti-war protester William Powell's The Anarchist Cook Book.

Hobbling law enforcement, and attacking it, has long been an NRA strategy.

After the 1995 Oklahoma City bombing, federal agents had a tough time tracing the fertilizer used to make the bomb that killed 168 people and injured 680 more because the NRA had fought using identifiers for explosives.

As my then-colleague Fox Butterfield reported in The New York Times three weeks after the crime:

Technological advances in the last three decades might have made it harder to build such a bomb and easier to trace its origin, the experts say, but gun enthusiasts and makers of fertilizer and explosives have repeatedly blocked efforts to put the research to use.

"It is just amazing that in this dangerous time, fanatical, boneheaded people are opposed to controls on explosives," said then-Representative Charles E. Schumer, a Democrat from Brooklyn, who introduced bills in 1993 and 1994 that would have forced manufacturers to add an identifying marker to explosives so their users could be tracked.

Mr. Schumer was referring primarily to the National Rifle Association and the explosives industry, which helped defeat the bills, citing among their objections safety hazards and reliability. The use of markers, they said, makes explosives more unstable and, when used in gunpowder, makes the charge less reliable.

Reynold Hoover, a former bomb expert with the Bureau of Alcohol, Tobacco and Firearms, said his agency had money in the budget in the 1970s to develop a tagging or identification agent, known as a taggant. The 3M Corporation devised the technology by the late '70s, said Mr. Hoover, now a consultant in Washington: fluorescent particles that could be detected by ultraviolet light. Manufacturers would use a different taggant in each batch.

Although up to 90 percent of taggants might be destroyed in a detonation, enough would remain to reveal their source.

In 1979, while conducting a $5 million pilot project using taggants in some seven million pounds of explosives, the ATF was able to track down and convict James L. McFillin, who had used an explosive, Tovex 220, to make a bomb that killed one man and injured another in Baltimore.

But shortly afterward, Congress ordered the bureau to stop work on ways to trace explosives. At the time, Representative William J. Hughes, the New Jersey Democrat who headed the House subcommittee on crime, said the National Rifle Association and makers of explosives had pressured Congress to block the program.

The NRA opposed using taggants, saying they would contaminate some explosives used by gun hobbyists, like old-fashioned gunpowder called black powder and the newer smokeless powder. It said people who liked to fire antique rifles or who loaded their own ammunition would have to use less accurate gunpowder.

Let's not forget what Wayne LaPierre, the NRA's CEO, said shortly after that terrorist act in Oklahoma City. LaPierre went on the attack against law enforcement, comparing federal agents to the Nazis and calling them "jack-booted thugs."

Former president George H.W. Bush then resigned from the NRA in protest, but LaPierre kept his job, which speaks volumes.

As for taggants, the "study" the NRA cites to show that good science found taggants would make gunpowder less reliable and would not work was in fact only a review of the literature.

Anyone who actually reads the 1980 report, " Taggants in Explosives ," will find this revealing line by the Office of Technology Assessment: "Due to severe time constraints, OTA did little original research."

Technology has advanced since that report, which is so old that it was prepared on a typewriter.

We can get identifiers put in gunpowders because of technological advances, just as reports get prepared these days on computers. And if "good science" says existing taggants fall short, then Congress can fund research to develop taggants that work without degrading the quality of the explosive charge in bullets.

But as the votes in the Senate killing modest gun regulation and controls on gun trafficking showed this week, what stands firmly in the way of reducing mass murders and bombings is one organization and its backers.

We can change that, once the public understands that the NRA is not so much a defender of Second Amendment rights as a lobby for enabling mass murder.

 
 
 
pat wilson
Professor Quiet
link   pat wilson    13 years ago

Thank you for the thorough explanation.

 
 
 
pat wilson
Professor Quiet
link   pat wilson    13 years ago
 
 
 
One Miscreant
Professor Silent
link   One Miscreant    13 years ago

Had these novice terrorists used match heads, taggants would be a moot point here. There are as many ways to build these devices as there are ways to solve the crimes using them. Wouldn't some real science be the key regardless? Mass spectrometry comes to mind or the clues left in their apartment, a.k.a. pyrotechnics.

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   seeder  A. Macarthur    13 years ago
The taggant is not ONLY about this, or any one particular investigation; it's about affording every possible/potential advantage to law enforcement. Those who lobby to mitigate such advantages do so to the advantage of criminals.
 
 
 
Mark in Wyoming
Professor Silent
link   Mark in Wyoming     13 years ago

mac i would say that that is untrue , at least in my case ,and with what i have pointed out . In my case its more of a safety aspect for those that use it legally, both for those that shoot recreationally , or in self defense , and those that have to depend on firearms as tools of their trade , and like i pointed out there is no real way to control the dispertion of any taggant in gunpowder ( and its mix would affect the performance of said powder in these cases ) that it is a legitimate safety issue for everyone as to how the ammunition made from said powder would work. it is a chance and risk to those it would affect the most that is not worth whatever precieved benefits those less knowledgable would desire .

So Mac not everyone lobbying against it do so to the advantage of criminals , but the safety of those that oppose them and whose very lives may depend on properly functioning material. think about it if your life depended on it . would you rather have a round you know will work? or have to hope and not know if its going to work as expected? I know my choice .

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   seeder  A. Macarthur    13 years ago

Mark,

Somewhere in this thread, I posted information regarding one of the NRA Board Members who influenced the legislation and the exclusion of the requirement of adding taggant. I'll look for the comment and repost it here. Hang on while I find it.

Here it is, Mark.

BOB HOGDON

He's been a tireless defender of the Second Amendment including two terms as a NRA Board Member and NRA Foundation Trustee. Hogdon Powder Co.!!!!!!!!!!!

POWDER COMPANY!

  • National Reloading Manufacturers Association
  • Treasurer and Board Member Hodgdon Powder Company
Robert Hodgdon (cited earlier) is president of Hodgdon Powder Company and a charter member of the National Reloading Manufacturers Association .
The company makes gun powder. Mr. Hodgdon has in the past maintained that taggants would force an increase in prices that would lead to reduced sales.
Profiteer whores!
I'm continuing to research, I believe two other NRA Board Members were involved. Stay tuned.
Mark,
Note the objection nothing to do with reliability, safety, etc. -- only profit. I do not have your expertise do I'll ask, "if your objections to taggants are accurate, why didn't Hodgdon raise them; wouldn't that have been a more palatable reason for exclusion from the legislation?"
 
 
 
Mark in Wyoming
Professor Silent
link   Mark in Wyoming     13 years ago

mac i read it , so no need to repost , thing is though that may have been that individuals motivation , it is not everyone elses .

 
 

Who is online







122 visitors