John Wiley & Sons v. SCOTUS, Thanks For the Death of the Publishing Industry
Last month SCOTUS ruled in Kirtsaeng v. John Wiley & Sons, 11-697,onallowing the importation and resale of foreign editions of American works, which are cheaper than domestic editions. John Wiley & Sons will now need restructure like many other publishing houses but that restructurewill come at the cost of many employees. Pink slips are being issued throughout the industry.
This ruling of course will not just affect John Wiley & Sons, which is the oldest publishing house in the US, but all publishers. Between e.books, and this, the publishing business as we know it will die, and with it tens of thousands of jobs. And it's not only the publishing houses that will suffer. Until now, the courts have ruled against such activity as a violation of copyright. This ruling has now opened the gates to a flood of cheap imports and at the same time, since they will be sold in a secondary market, authors wont get royalties. So it will be the death of the author, too.
Authors and publishing houses everywhere are left scratching their heads, as what went into thisdecision.In a dissent for herself and Justices Anthony Kennedy and Antonin Scalia, Justice Ruth Bader Ginsburg said the court was ignoring Congress' aim of protecting "copyright owners against the unauthorized importation of low-priced, foreign-made copies of their copyrighted works."
"The ruling for Kirtsaeng will send a tremor through the publishing industries, harming both U.S. businesses and consumers around the world. Today's decision will create a strong disincentive for publishers to market different versions and sell copies at different prices in different regions. The practical result may very well be that consumers and students abroad will see dramatic price increases or entirely lose their access to valuable U.S. resources created specifically for them," said Keith Kupferschmid, general counsel for the Software & Information Industry Association.
And now the movie, software and the already damaged music industry waits for the fallout.
This ruling is probably one of the most damaging to our copyright laws that has come along since theelectronicage. Since Amazon killed the book store business,all types of publishers, who were struggling to stay afloat, find themselves being strangled by Amazon, who by theirvirtualmonopoly, dictates on how they will do business with all publisher, by forcing buy outs of divisions. This ruling, is the nail in the coffin for the publishing industry.
So what does that mean to you?
It means it will no longer be viable for authors to write.
In a New York Times Op Ed, "The Slow Death of the American Author", written by ScottTurow, President of the Writers Guild, Turow said,
"There are many e-books on which authors and publishers, big and small, earn nothing at all. Numerous pirate sites, supported by advertising or subscription fees, have grown up offshore, offering new and old e-books free.
The pirates would be a limited menace were it not for search engines that point users to these rogue sites with no fear of legal consequence, thanks to a provision inserted into the 1998 copyright laws. A search for Scott Turow free e-books brought up 10 pirate sites out of the first 10 results on Yahoo, 8 of 8 on Bing and 6 of 10 on Google, with paid ads decorating the margins of all three pages."
But here is the crux of the story. Google and other search engines stand to gain from thisdecision:
"Google is also at odds with many writers because in 2004 it partnered with five major libraries to scan and digitize millions of in-copyright books, without permission from authors. The Authors Guild (of which I am president) sued; years later, with a proposed settlement scuttled by the judge, the litigation goes on.
Google says this is a fair use of the works, an exception to copyright, because it shows only snippets of the books in response to each search. Of course, over the course of thousands of searches, Google is using the whole book and selling ads each time, while sharing none of the revenue with the author or publisher."
So there you have it, two monopolies, Amazon and Google were the driving force in thisdecision. Publishers, and writers alike, will shrink in size, while these monsters grow...You might save a dollar or two, but the big winner is are both of these companies. Who will lose? Youultimately. If there is no money in writing, authors will not write. It has never been easy living, but with this decision, it won't be a living at all.
In closing Turow said this,
"Last October, I visited Moscow and met with a group of authors who described the sad fate of writing as a livelihood in Russia. There is only a handful of publishers left, while e-publishing is savaged by instantaneous piracy that goes almost completely unpoliced. As a result, in the country of Tolstoy and Chekhov, few Russians, let alone Westerners, can name a contemporary Russian author whose work regularly affects the national conversation.
The Constitutions framers had it right. Soviet-style repression is not necessary to diminish authors output and influence. Just devalue their copyrights."
Tags
Who is online
112 visitors

The publishing houses are starting to feel the same pain as newspapers. Digital copies are the way of the future.
Typical publishing houseroyaltiesfor the author is around 8%-10%
Amazon gives around 70% to the author for a self-published e-book
Who do you think is going to attract the most new authors?
There has been a downward trend in new novels. This is due to the reduceroyaltiespaid out to new and special interest authors.
So I guess the answer is a lot less than before.
It's a nice book andironicallythe first to be printed... but not needed for critical thinking.
EI,
That post was spot on.
Robert, you know that we do the exact same thing with big Pharma, right?
Robert,
What most people don't know is that these books are substandard. Their paper isn't as good and the binding are meant to only last a short period of time, hence the lower price. Wiley makes these books available to developing nations as a way to educate and meet what the market will bare. What they are planning on doing now, is stopping any publishing of books that are in both markets and only print the high quality books here in the US, where students often sell them back to college book stores and are meant to last for a much longer period of time. So really what this little guy did, was screw these developing nations who will now not be able to afford the higher quality books.
And yes, I didlove the 6-3 line ups in this one. It goes to show that the court can still surprise every now and then, thank goodness.
Well, yes and no. On the surface, Yes. But I also showed how it has hurt the Asian market. Also, there are major ramifications for both Amazon and google, who pushed for this decision and they don't look like little guys to me.... Wiley does.
Modern day book burning.
Signed,
Montag ofFahrenheit 451
The old conventions are dying. Traditional means of conveying news, information and entertainment are getting shunted aside for the internet. The laws covering copyrights also need to be updated.
I hate to hear this...
My Uncle Louie was a reader for the Viking Press. I truly appreciate the feel, the smell, the reverence of a hard back book. I have tons of them and will never let them go willingly-- unless they could benefit people that have NO books.
I have over 4,000 books in my library-- from references, fiction, non-fiction, to interesting and unusual finds. Classics, pleasure books, stupendous stories! Most are boxed up, but someday, somehow, I'm going to have enough shelves for them all...
I REALLY hate to hear this!
What will happen to text books? Just curious.
Wiley will be closing operations in the East and ship from Europe and the US. Text books will be the last stand of publishing, but as the technology evolves, and student will be able to mark up on a tablet as they can in a text, who knows?
Robert that is amisrepresentationof the situation. The actual book is inferior. In fact, college book stores are now looking to see where a book is printed. Usually the dead give away is a broken spine.
What Wiley tried to do is offer information to developing nations at a price point that they could afford. For instance my daughters organic chem book cost $400 but inThailandit was sold at a lower price, one that they could afford. But the book will only last through 1 student and my daughters will sell theirs at the end of the semester.
Wheel,
I had the same thought when I wrote my response to Robert. The difference here is that we absorb the whole R&D while other nations get the exact same meds but because they negotiate as a nation, they get them at reduced prices.
Tru dat! And this guy went and ruined it for everyone else who lives in the East and other developing areas.
Quite true! And very troubling.
Aeon,
Copyright is protects ideas andoriginalthought. If there is no way to make a profit from it, then eventually you will drive it underground and make it something for theelitefew. Think back to when only the rich and the church could afford books. That's what will happen.
Dowser,
You and me. There is something about owning a book. Holding it in your hand and turning an actual page. Something to lend a friend. A page to mark up with your own notes and ideas. My daughters own both books and Kindles. They feel that there is a specialness about books. Material that they want to keep forever, they buy a book for.
My beaten up copy of 'Catcher in the Rye" brings back such memories for me. I doubt it would on a kindle.
Its very distressing to hear this. I enjoy nothing better than sitting back and pulling a book out of my library, (not as big as Dowsers) and re-reading it. Old, read many times but still a joy to go through once again. I still have my childhoodcopy of Jack London's ''Call of the Wild, White Fang and the Sea Witch''..I can't count the number of times that I've read them. I still like the feel of a quality book.
So do I Kavika. So do I.
I understand exactly what you mean!
Uncle Louie, as he read the books, would mark in faint pencil, the definition of words that he thought I might not understand, or pages to another book for a reference, or, on occasion, draw very faint pencil sketches of whatever the book was discussing. He once glued quarters on top of the balls that a cat was playing with. He would put in newspaper clippings, pertinent to the book, pictures, postcards of places...
Opening his books is like opening a treasure trove! He died when I was 11. Will he ever know the absolute richness of the legacy he left me, and my son?
That's not a good comparison. Back then (when only the rich could afford books) ye old Gutenberg Press could crank out a book a day. As soon as technology caught up, the price fell and everyone could afford a book.
As for business not profiting from copyrighted material, remind me to come back and debunk that myth someday when I'm not too busy.
If you are a new author, it is extremely difficult to get a publishing house to even look at your book. At least Amazon gives you a chance. How you self-promote is up to yourself. If you are not a NYT bestseller,thepublishing house is going to do very little to promote your book.
I wish I had time to read. For the last few years my work commute has been between 4 and 6 hours per day, leaving hardly any time for the mandatory things thathome ownership require, much less actually sitting down and reading a book. I'm a big audio book fan now, since I sit in front of a car stereofor hours a day and I can no longer stand excessive radio advertising. Last year I went through about 120 audio books from the library. At first I thought it would be hokey to be read to, but I have found that certain narrators add a layer of interest that I don't always achieve when I read myself - however, there's one or two that are like fingernails on a chalkboard for me. Being that 95% of the audio books I listen to come from the library, I'm not exactly part of the profit system - but I hope that the system doesn't collapse nonetheless.
It is a sad story, Perrie. As we feel the ax drop on our publishing houses, copyrights, authors, we have to wonder which way these winds of change will blow all of us.
$4 million is well above average.That figure might be right for a highly illustrated first edition supported by add-ons (often lecturers are given teaching resources for free when they set a textbook) with a lot of market potential. A figure in the high tens of thousands or low hundreds of thousand would be more typical.
That sort of investment will likely die as publishers' struggles worsen. That is already happening though. For a long time, publishers have relied on increasing prices to keep their profits growing. Over recent years they have relied more and more on cutting costs (cutting jobs, outsourcing, offshoring and being less willing to publish texts that target smaller market segments).
They used to have some "Trade" books, like Fromers and "For Dummies" books but Amazon forced a buy out of those divisions so, yes they they only haveacademic, scientific and engineering books (both textbooks and non textbooks).
I think journals need to be looked at in a different way to books. The peer review process doesn't really need publishers. The production processes for a journal or journal article are straightforward. Journal publishers make a lot of money for contributing very little and their role is already being dismantled by moves to openly, freely publish academic 'journal' articles.
Profit is not a dirty word. In fact, there is no business without profit. But what you are not addressing is that the writers will suffer, too. I happen to know authors, and already they are not making theroyaltiesthey did 10 years ago.
Hi J, nice to meet you!
This is true. Many publishers are shrinking in the US already. Wiley has closed whole divisions even before this judgement. While everyone cries we need more jobs, they seem to have no problem when business that provide them close or contract. I do find that odd. And lets not think about how we expect authors t make a living.
Are you sure about For Dummies?
Wiley's sold bits and pieces of its trade business, but it's hard to imagine them selling the For Dummies business.
Hi Hal,
Audio books are fine, and whether you realized it or not, you are part of the profit system. The library had to purchase those tapes.
If publishing dies, we will be the big losers. Text books will have to be imported, and so no money will be saved there, and non fiction will go the way of vanity presses, which often produces less than great literature.
Tell me about it EI, says the mom with twin in college, who are planning on grad school.
That is still a far above average cost for vetting the content.
Publishers play a facilitating role in the vetting process (whether textbooks, reference books, other technical books or journals); they don't do the actual work themselves. I think it is inevitable that academic societies and journal editorial boards will eventually take back control - whether because they want the articles freely available, because they don't see that publishers are adding much value, or because the quality of publishers' vetting process starts to fall away as they look to cut costs in that area as well.
I'd say that publishers' core competencies are marketing, production and distribution. Production is increasingly outsourced. Physical distribution should be outsourced. Electronic distribution is new and I'm not seeing publishers prove that they are expert at it. It leaves marketing as their core. Their other asset is their collection of content built up over years.
Yes, agreed, publishers should (and do) vet technical books - indeed, even a lot of non-technical books - for accuracy, but (your friend's book aside) that process is also in decline.
The other aspect to note is that the printing of these books is a relatively small part of their overall cost and therefore contributes a relatively small amount to their final price. The price differential between rich markets and developing markets is far greater than the difference in manufacturing costs.
Publishers are trying to get a foothold in developing markets, as they see them as their source of future profit growth. For now, profits are mainly derived from rich markets and the costs of developing and producing a book are absorbed in those same rich markets. Publishers believe (or at least hope) that in the longer term developing countries will become more profitable for them.