Why the GOP should want to lose the Supreme Court's gay-marriage cases
Most members of the Republican Party hope that the Supreme Court will not use the two gay-marriage cases it heard this week to issue a broad ruling affirming the constitutional right of gays and lesbians to marry. However, top officials in the GOP are reportedly praying for precisely that outcome, calculating that it would be the most effective way to remove gay marriage as a political liability.
Republican analysts see the party's opposition to gay marriage as a massive drag on their electoral prospects going forward. A solid majority of Americans now support marriage equality, and most worryingly for the GOP, more than 80 percent of young voters do as well. The Republican National Committee has described gay marriage as a "gateway" issue for a whole generation of new voters to identify with the Democratic Party, possibly doing lasting damage to the conservative party's brand.
But the GOP's base isn't budging, which is why some Republican operatives see their salvation in the Supreme Court, reports Alexander Burns at Politico: - http://theweek.com/article/index/242004/why-the-gop-should-want-to-lose-the-supreme-courts-gay-marriage-case
As I said before in another thread, Congress has the duty and responsibility to legislate. When doing that (their duty) interferes with loyalty to their party, the entire issue gets dragged to court in the hopes that it will settle the matter so their own hands will look unspoiled.
Tags
Who is online
111 visitors

My prediction... DOMA will be struck down and Prop 8 will be ruled narrowly as to only pertain to California. If it does include the entire 9th District, then it would open same sex marriage for, not only CA, but Alaska, Washington, Oregon, Idaho, Montana, Nevada, Arizona and Hawaii. I don't think the conservative justices will go that far.
Lets just hope the court settles this crap once and for all as we have bigger issues to deal with right now. Our constitution says we shouldn't discriminate against anyone. It's about time that we start acting like the country that our constitutions says we are.
I agree. While the article points out the GOP on this particular issue, I have no doubt that the Democratic leadership feels exactly the same way. While social issues can and do distract the voters from much more important concerns so both parties can conduct their chicanery, it does sap both parties resources....resources that help keep them in power.
As an LGBT political activist, it pleases me to no end to see you annoyed.
Sorry EI, I usually agree with you, but he's address the gridlock issue ad nauseum. Neither side will submit a budget that the other will except. The rhetoric has taken over and now the tail wags the dog in Congress. There will be no traction on spending until one party has a majority in both Houses of Congress.
Your addendum stands out more than the content of the seed (to me at least). It essentially sums up the problem with the legislative branch at present. Of late they have collectively abdicated their responsibilities to legislate and assist in moving the Country forward, hence the quagmire we all find ourselves in as a result.
I believe they have forgotten, the people and our Countrytrump party loyalties (on paper at least).
That aside, a Court decision in favor of marriage equality would certainly let them off the hook. Then they can spend the next forty years attempting to undo it as they are with Roe V. Wade.
It is almost time to envoke the Big Club governance clause: If they continue to disavow their responsibilities, a citizen selected by lottery gets to hit the offender (or offenders) along the head with a Big Club.
May not solve the problem, but at least someone would get to feel good.
Romney EI, really? But at this point I am not sure it makes a difference who sits in the oval office. But all my silliness to one side, I do agree(not the Romney part).
They will just come up with another distraction to keep our eyes off the ball.
The call for Romney kind of makes my eyes bleed... but maybe we needed a little devestation at the reigns to really kick things into gear.
Nothing like a little forrest fire to really make you appreciate the national park.
As humans we constantly cry out for change and then cry about it when it happens... such is the measure of happiness.
I was speaking to your previous comment as well as the current one...
I didnt mean you were calling for him specifically... just the embodiment of a good old fashioned government razing through poor management skills that catalize a defined movement from the majority rather than a continual fractionation.
In other words... we might need to put in a guy that everyone hates so that everyone actually does something together.
Awww, poor baby. You can't stand on your own, like all cowards like you are, so you elicit the help of others here, partly because you are a mod and partly because this site tolerates your childish behavior.
You are the classic definition of a HOMOPHOBIC. You hide, like a coward, behind phrases like this;
It just doesn't get anymore intolerant and hateful than that. And of course, very few will stand up to your juvenile behavior, for the reasons I listed above. Now, now I see this thread has attracted all your other homophobic friends. This is good stuff to know.
Let's see....940 member here and about 30, at the most actually post. That's about 3.1% of the members. With people like you in charge and allowed to disrupt threads with your off-topic and demeaning comments, I will not be surprised if sooner or later people who post begins to drop.
Grow up. It's not all about you child.
Bruce,
Wow, you scanned the internet for gays wearing costumes and that proves what? If you don't want gays flaunting themselves in front of you, here's a few tips;
I hate comments like this. Yes, we have other issues that are important, but issues of equal rights are always big issues.
Agreed - which is why I don't think this issue is a lesser issue than other important issues facing our country. This issue speaks to the heart of what out country is supposed to be.
No they have not. They are still being denied equal treatment as outlined by the constitution that is their right as citizens. Who gives a damn what you find is abhorrent. It is your obligation as a citizen to live and let live in the same manner as you want to be treated under the Constitution. I despise those that burn the flag, but damned if I won't stand up for their right to do so.
Sometimes it takes getting in someone's grill to get them to accept reality. Think back to civil rights implementation in many parts of the South. They still hate it, but forcing the issue was the only way to make headway.
Maybe if there weren't so many that want to deny them equal treatment under the Constitution, the fucksticks as you put it wouldn't have to be so "In your face"....
Okay Summer.....
I accept the hit on my first comment because you are right. But I am soooooo tired of having to having to listen to and deal with other people that just don't understand that our Constitution says we should live and let live.
Way out of line Mike!!!!!
For someone that touts their rights under the first and second amendments on an endless basis, you sure seem bent on voicing your thoughts and opinions that would limit the rights of others under the first and fourteenth amendment.
Why should the LGB community not expect you to sit still and accept their efforts to attain equality when you expect them to do the same for you?
In short YOU are part of the problem in this country Mike because you refuse to be part of the solution. Your Darwinist approach to living in America is about as far from what is beneficial to this country as is possible.
Hell, as a Marine I would figure that you would have this all figured out by now. In the Marines what was more important, the individual, or the objective?
Using that comparison, what is more important, the individual, or precepts of the constitution?
I totally understand what you are saying. I get soooo tired of hearing people attempt to justify discrimination against people simply because of their sexual orientation.
Fair enough..... I'm a gun owner that burned his NRA card back in the early 1990s because of their positions.
And yes Mike.... I did read all of your posts on this topic.
Let me jump in here. First, moderators are also members and when commenting as members, they have the same rights and latitude as every other member. It's inappropriate to bring a moderator's status as such into a conversation if that moderator is not acting in both capacities simultaneously -- as moderator and member.
Second; A comment that arises in the flow of a discussion/debate that either directly challenges/requests another member to respond is par for the course. BUT, if the challenge/request goes unanswered, so be it. A non-response can be construed in any number of ways -- but I consider it bad form to taunt in order to evoke a response.
A word to the wise.
Well this whole thread has turn to hell! Let me just go over some of the highlights and make this a learning experience...
Aeon, I had this problem earlier on in the week when I was in a discussion with Pat. Mods are just members when they are not posting in purple. Right now, I am a mod. I realize that some of the new comers here might not get that.. Mike is just another member when he is posting in black. And no, mods don't get special consideration. FYI, our mod team is made up of 2 conservatives, 2 moderates and 2 liberals so that if there is a problem we always have someone look at it, who is not emotionally invested in the commentf BTW calling Mike a coward is a CoC violation. I let it stand because of what followed.. I want to show how these discussion fall apart quickly when you don't get a mod.
Actually, we have 592 members and about 120 postregularly at different times and notjust not in the forum. Also you don't have to show as "Online". That is just for those who also want to chat. Just FYI.
Now onto Mike:
Taunting Mike? Really? That whole second post is a CoC violation, too! You should have gotten me, but instead you doled out Mike justice. WRONG! Those two post are a CoC melt down and your graphic is not only off topic, it is meant asharassmentwhich is also a CoC violation. KNOCK IT OFF!
Now this should make it very clear, about what happens when a mod is called in (yes a by stander member had the common sense and notified me about this mess of postings), and that mods gets no breaks when they break the CoC. The only reason that this whole thing is deleted, is that I would like people to learn from this.
"Is 'bad form' an addendum to the CoC?"
"Moreover, I consider a post that is 100% insulting, and also completely devoid of comment to the subject at hand as 'bad form'."
I addressed improprieties on both sides of the exchange; it's not a matter of what I "don't like," it's a matter of maintaining a decorum that doesn't hurt the site.
"It is inspiring to see all you fine gentlemen leap to poor Aeon's defense, while ignoring her initial transgression, that actually DOES break the CoC."
I'm happy you found inspiration but because I castigated both parties in the fray, you can't justify your accusation that I leapt to either side's defense.
Mike:
Did you miss this:
So no... I got Aeon's direct CoC violation... There were just so many that I didn't address them all from the both of you. One of the mods should have been gotten into this discussion before it fell apart so badly.
I chose not to pick apart all of the CoC violations made by both parties; Would you like me to do that? Neither did I think it necessary to go through the chronology and sequence since, once the smoke cleared, both combatants had broken the rules. Again, my objective was and is to maintain a civil environment -- we know from history that it's the lack of civility more than anything else that erodes these web sites.
Were I to copy and paste every comment in the cited exchange that violated the CoC, any neutral third party would see the problems emanating from both sides. Be it a personal insult or a taunt and reciprocation-in-kind, each warrants appropriate caveats which I issued without taking a side.
Reject away.. next time all comments will be in purple and removed. I actually did this more for Aeon's understanding than yours. You want to behave in this manner, you know what the outcome will be.
[slaps forehead]
OY.
That's ENOUGH!