Attacks Against Megyn Kelly are Unfair
Megyn Kelly is not a Journalist. She's an anchor, a hostess and an actress. She does not write the questions she asks, she just gets paid to ask them. She is a good looking commodity that Fox owns and has over the years, reinvented. She has no editorial control over what she says.
If she says something you don't like, blame the network, not poor Megyn.

The three of them said on TV that they spent 8 hours preparing the questions.
I doubt that thetop brass didn't review the questions, or set some parameters.
Journalist study journalism in college or at least Communication. She did not. So she is just a lawyer who got a gig on a news network.
Exactly. She is just like any other (failed) attorney who gets a job on TV. She has no Journalism degree. Considering her law degree, I have always found it puzzling that Fox has never used her as one of their legal on-air pundits other than to say she has occasionally filled in for Greta Van Susteren.
This is all a smokescreen anyways as my point is she has no editorial control over anything she says. Few at Fox do save O'Reilly and Hannity.
Please...explain how my statement of opinion is "sealioning?" This should be interesting.
There are many journalist that are pretty and smart and are true journalist. But the fact that she doesn't have those degrees, just makes her a glorified lawyer.
Next you will be Geraldo is a journalist.
If you can't see how Megyn was sealioning than you don't know what it is. If she is going to put her face on the questions than she needs to own them or refuse to ask them no matter who wrote them.
If you are saying Megyn Kelley was asking questions in "bad faith", I cannot say, because I just don't know.
All I know is that she did not have a say as to what questions she asked.
That makes sense, since she is a lawyer. She can give an educated POV. That doesn't make one a journalist.
Why do you say that when it is indicated she was on the committee that decided what questions to ask?
Oh then every lawyer should be on TV giving us the news?
Pleeze.
My family is swamped with lawyers. I am not impressed. BTW all Ivy league... still not impressed.
When you study journalism, you study the ethics and manner of reporting the news.
And Sean, stop nit picking. I said journalism first, then I said communications. Both study the above... one more about the ethics and one more about the manner of delivery.
Carl Bernstin, whose investigative reporting brought down President Nixon, was not a "real" journalist! He lacked a journalism degree! What a disgrace.
Oh I guess that Megan has his qualifications:
Bernstein was born in Washington, D.C., the son of Sylvia (Walker) and Alfred Bernstein. He attended Montgomery Blair High School in Silver Spring, Maryland , where he worked as circulation and exchange manager [3] for the school's newspaper Silver Chips . He began his journalism career at the age of 16 when he became a copyboy for The Washington Star and moved "quickly through the ranks. [1] " The Star , however, unofficially required a college degree to write for the paper. Because he had dropped out from the University of Maryland (where he was a reporter for the school's independent daily, The Diamondback [4] ) and did not intend to finish, Bernstein left in 1965 to become a full-time reporter for the Elizabeth Daily Journal in New Jersey. [5] While there, he won first prize in New Jersey's press association for investigative reporting, feature writing, and news on a deadline. [1] In 1966, Bernstein left New Jersey and began reporting for the Washington Post , where he covered every aspect of local news and became known as one of the paper's best writing stylists. [6]
NOT!
Back in the day, people interned as journalist. No degree necessary.
Anyone can be a Journalist then. Heck, I have youtube videos of me interviewing people at Occupy Wall St. Hey, I'm a journalist!!
True journalism comes from years of training and study.
This fixation on Kelly really misses IMO, the ''story''.
She and the other two are pawns in a much larger game. That of Fox vs Trump.
If you remember some weeks back, Trump made his comments regarding Mexicans. A few days later Murdoch can out against such comments.
Perhaps, Murdoch sees that with Trump in the race the republican party is coming apart and wants to rectify that by burying Trump as a viable candidate. He can accomplish his through Fox News and the debates. It would seem that he wants Fox to be know as the ''King Maker'' and Trump is upsetting that plan.
Something of a conspiracy plan, but hey it's as good as any other version.
Than of course, there is the Carlos Slim angle.
Oh please BF.
I never had a problem with Katie Couric or Joan Lunden. They both did investigative reporting and they are both pretty. Heck Joan was a beauty pageant winner.
Try again.
Neither of those two would do a GQ spot.
If you want to be taken seriously, than act that way, especially when you are trying to be a journalist.
But let me clear up a misconception here. I don't blame her for the line of questioning during the debate. They all worked together on that.
Trump is upsetting the plans of the political machine that includes the Kochs, Erick Erickson and the "established" right wing propaganda outlets.
Wow, such a riveting debate about whether or not Megan Kelly is a journalist. Its almost enough to make me care. Almost.
You must know some really dumb journalists then Sean. Gotta sister and niece who are communications majors - you can't understand a word they're saying or a word they're writing and both "want to be" journalists but the dull backwoods Mississippi/Alabama/Tennessee newspapers/communications channels won't hire them 'cause their degree ain't in journalism.
Go figure - and, no, communications degrees are NOT a piece of cake.
The four of them sat in a room for three days devising the questions and to which candidate/contestant they would ask it.
Trump got the most - Cruz the least.
I agree, I like her.
I predict that she will outgrow the limits of Fox and move on.
I would like to see her go to CNN.
It's summertime John. Everybody take a
in thethe summer.
Wait till Sept 8th when the
and the
come back.
Based on her demeanor, she would be a good assistant prosecuting attorney, not a good defense attorney - and she is not a journalist - too much anger and little finesse. She and Nancy would make a good tag team.
I say; "Yeah, right."
Here ya go . Have a fish and may I point out how sleek and streamlined you look :
Guess what? The corporately owned MSM, especially the TV medium, stopped hiring journalists long time ago. You no longer have Walter Cronkite, David Brinkley and Edward R. Murrow types involved in news. Bernstein was a bona fide investigative reporter.
You have no idea what the difference is between a reporter and a journalist.
Considering comments like your's, it's no small wonder why it's only a small group of people that post here.
Remind me to make the same comments about your long-winded, bloviated posts.
Good thing you don't make a living predicting things...you'd be broke.
Actually there's another aspect to this-- although people would only know about it if they actually watched the debate.
In addition to which questions were asked, here's another aspect to this: the way in which the questions were asked. Megan Kelly was obviously in "attack mode" when questioning Trump. It was obvious that "she was out to get him". I was really surprised, because she wasn't like that with any of the other candidates.
She was obviously biased-- and unfair. (However, this is just an observation-- I "Don't have a dog in this race"). I don't care is he was unfair and out to get him-- but the fact is, she was.
I wonder if anyone who didn't actually watch it would care to comment on her demeanor or her tone of vice, facial expressions, etc?
Which proves my original statement that Kelly is a "commodity" that can be bought, sold and traded to the highest bidder.
Here is a list of either reporting or journalism awards she has won:
Exactly.
There are very stringent standards for journalists. That's why world reknowned journalists like Rush Limbaugh and Alex Jones are so revered-- throughout the known world-- and beyond! Throughout the Entire Galaxy, even.
Its true. There are invisible spacecraft hovering far above the earth's magnetic field, with powerful infernal machines buried deep within their bowels, that send down powerful rays to earth that control her very thoughts!
And that means what? Kelly has NO editorial control over what she says. Unlike Hannity and O'Reilly whom are listed and credited with being editors of their own programs, Kelly is given no such credit. Her resume and biography at Fox news states no such experience or duties.
If you have any evidence to suggest otherwise, please show it.
Megyn Kelly makes an annual salary of 6 million a year and has a net worth of 15 million. - source I'm sure she's crying all the way to the bank.
Sean,
One requires you to do your own footwork, find out information no one else has and compose either an article or expose' and the other requires you of a prompter.
LMAO
So if I understand you, you believe Carl Bernstein is a reporter and not a journalist while Walter Cronkite and Megyn Kelly are journalists but not reporters.
Frankly, I don't think that distinction would be recognized by any professional journalism organization anywhere.
First of all, this has nada to do with feminism. Second, this is about professionalism, not feminism. Last of all, there is nothing wrong with being beautiful and smart. But being beautiful doesn't make you qualified for any position and that is what we are discussing here.
Trump is a blowhard who will kill his own hopes (if he even has the aspirations for anything but facetime with the public) of becoming President of the US if he is given the camera and microphone.
This is just the initial circus, the real three ring show will begin in January.
OK Bf,
So nice of you to take this to a cheap base level. No one called her a single name, just that she isn't a journalist.
Let's put it this way. Would you feel comfortable going to a vet for a medical procedure?
I have two super smart beautiful daughters that are pre-med. If they follow through they will be two beautiful doctors. But you wouldn't go to them for legal issues.
Sean,
Both Bernstein and Cronkite came up the old school way of doing apprenticeships. They had to prove that they could do investigative reporting before they became who they were. Wiki them and see what they had to do. That isn't what Megyn did nor did she study it in college. I am sure she is a competent lawyer. But I will ask you the same thing that I asked BF. Would you go to a vet for a medical procedure?
That is total Bullshit. This has zero to do with her being pretty. You are making this about her looks, not me. My point is her qualifications.
Bull!
And I really resent you representing my POV that way.
I totally agree. It started right out of the gates when they asked their first question, which they all knew would trap Trump. I don't like Trump, but that wasn't fair.
You need to reread my comment. I am not going to spell it out for you.
BTW, there are a whole load of these so called journalist out there today, and this is a big problem. It is not just Megyn... and that is why we no longer have journalistic integrity.
That's a bullshit evasion to a simple question. I understand why you won't answer it. If you claim Bernstein isn't a journalist, you look like an idiot and if you admit that he is, than the whole imaginary distinction between reporters like Bernstein and "real, authentic" journalists like Cronkite and Kelly breaks down. That's using your own definition of a journalist as someone whose work requires a prompter.
This whole silly thread hinges upon an imaginary distinction between reporters and journalists in pursuit of some logically impossible claim that Kelly, who is a textbook example of the dictionary definition of a journalist, is somehow not a journalist.
Your refusal to address the logical conclusion and implications of your own definitions pretty much puts the matter to rest. .
Sean,
I went through the trouble of explaining that there was an old school way to be a journalist of which Bernstein and Cronkite did. They did an apprenticeship and worked their way up. This is no longer done and usually a degree is the necessary route. Right now, anyone with a background in a matter can make a commentary. That isn't journalism. And I have the same complaint about men as I do about woman in the press.
But since you are fixated on this, here is Bernstein's bio. Please take note that he had to work up his entire working career to become a journalist, and even then The Star, wanted him to have a degree.
He attended Montgomery Blair High School in Silver Spring, Maryland , where he worked as circulation and exchange manager [3] for the school's newspaper Silver Chips . He began his journalism career at the age of 16 when he became a copyboy for The Washington Star and moved "quickly through the ranks. [1] " The Star , however, unofficially required a college degree to write for the paper. Because he had dropped out from the University of Maryland (where he was a reporter for the school's independent daily, The Diamondback [4] ) and did not intend to finish, Bernstein left in 1965 to become a full-time reporter for the Elizabeth Daily Journal in New Jersey. [5] While there, he won first prize in New Jersey's press association for investigative reporting, feature writing, and news on a deadline. [1] In 1966, Bernstein left New Jersey and began reporting for the Washington Post , where he covered every aspect of local news and became known as one of the paper's best writing stylists. [6]
This is when journalism mattered. When they had the skill to do investigative reporting and not reading off a prompter. When they didn't have staff writers. This is what is wrong with journalism today. For me, this isn't what is wrong with just Megyn, but what is wrong with journalism all together. This is why the whole Brian Williams thing happened. Should I not pick on Brian because he is handsome?
BF,
She had an apprenticeship also. Here is what she did before siting in front of a camera:
In 1951 she received a B.A. in English from Sarah Lawrence College [24] and immediately looked for work in New York City. After about a year at a small advertising agency, she began working at the NBC network affiliate in New York City, WNBT-TV (now WNBC ), doing publicity and writing press releases. She began producing a 15-minute children's program, "Ask the Camera," directed by Roone Arledge in 1953. She then produced for TV host, Igor Cassini/Cholly Knickerbocker, but left the network due to pressure from her boss to marry him, and his fist-fight with a man she preferred to date. Then she went to WPIX to produce the "Eloise McElhone Show."; it was cancelled in 1954. She became a writer on "The Morning Show" at CBS in 1955.
After a few years as a publicist with Tex McCrary Inc. and a job as a writer at Redbook magazine, Walters joined NBC 's The Today Show as a writer and researcher in 1961. [19] She moved up to become that show's regular "Today Girl", handling lighter assignments and the weather. In her autobiography, she describes this era before the Women's Movement as a time when it was believed that nobody would take a woman seriously reporting "hard news". Previous "Today Girls" (whom Walters called "tea pourers") included Florence Henderson , Helen O'Connell , Estelle Parsons and Lee Meriwether . [25] Within a year she had become a reporter-at-large developing, writing, and editing her own reports and interviews. One very well received film segment was "A Day in the Life of a Novice Nun," edited by then first assistant film editor Donald Swerdlow (now Don Canaan) who was subsequently promoted to become a full film editor at NBC News. [19] She had a great relationship with host Hugh Downs for years. When Frank McGee was named host, he refused to do joint interviews with Walters unless he was given the first three questions. She was not named co-host of the show until McGee's death in 1974, when NBC officially designated Walters as the program's first female co-host.
Does that read like Megyn's resume. I think not.
Here is her bio:
In 2003, Kelly moved to Washington, D.C. , where she was hired by the ABC affiliate WJLA-TV as a general assignment reporter. [18] While there, she covered significant national and local events, including live coverage of the confirmation hearings for U.S. Supreme Court Justice Samuel A. Alito, Jr. and Chief Justice John G. Roberts ; the retirement of Justice Sandra Day O'Connor ; the death of Chief Justice William Rehnquist ; and the 2004 presidential election . [19]
After working as a journalist for WJLA, Kelly then applied for a job at Fox News Channel in 2004. [1
So she spent 1 year "reporting". That means she is just saying what she saw, and we are not even sure if she wrote her own material. Compare that to Barbara Walters, or Bernstein. But she is no different than Brian Williams. They are nothing more than glorified talking heads.
It was a set up to get Trump, plain and simple. He has already said that publicly, and they knew he would be the only one to own up to it. Phrasing it as :You would do that even if it would hurt the GOP" was the clincher. That was a public lynching.
On the other hand, he was a pig about what he said about Megyn.
Not every lawyer is smart. There are plenty of crap lawyers out there, which is one of the reasons they have such a bad rap.
But let's say she is a good reporter. Going on Howard, is a good way of cheapening one's self.
You defined a journalist as someone who just reads prompters. Isn't that what you claim kelly does? (Pretending for a moment that she doesn't interview newsmakers, which is one of the primary functions of a reporter).
No matter how you try and murder the definition, kelly and brain Williams for that matter fits the dictionary defintion of a journalist. If you want to argue she is a bad journalist, that's fine. I don't watch her show as often as you do ot have such a strong opinion. But trying to claim that she is not a journalist, is just silly.
BF
yeah, it curious why only Kelly is singled out among the three Fox anchors for not being a "journalist" and not being responsible for the questions that were asked.
Woodie
Had Kelly stayed as a lawyer, she would have been earning significantly less, than the 6 Mil a year now she earns at Fox. She found her niche at Fox. Business wise, it was one of the smartest moves she ever made.
Kelly is no Christiana Amanpour and she knows it. However, she is good at what she does do and doesn't pretend to exceed her limitations. To that extent, Comment removed for COC "PersonalAttack" "96" .
Make no mistake, I don't like hardly a single thing she stands for or believes in. That said, what Trump said to her during the debate and the next days was way out of line and disgusting. And if anyone believes that he meant her nose when he said "wherever", then they are a fucking idiot, because it is obvious that even he doesn't believe it.
I hope the GOP is stupid enough to nominate him or that he runs as a third party candidate, because in either case it would be the biggest landslide victory for a party, in this case the Democrats, since Nixon defeated McGovern.
I actually agree with Jefferson on something. All of the candidates had gotcha questions and if Trump knew he would get one (and there is no doubt he should have seen one coming), then he shouldn't have responded to it the completely ignorant and insulting way he did. They held up a fist to all of the candidates and Trump was the only one stupid enough to punch himself in the face with one. He shot himself in the foot at the debate and just kept firing the gun over and over again, hitting his own feet over and over again, the next few days, as I'm sure he'll keep doing it. He's really is a blowhard and a clown.
I'd do her.
You haven't got a clue what "she stands for or believes in" . There ya go . No mistake .
I know.
Because that was the topic of the article.
Sean ,
The same could be said about Obama ...
Hell, I'd do just about any of the Fox News females. Even Greta.
Apparently a lot of Republicans do. (Strange as it may seem, everyone does not have the same opinions as you do...weird, eh?)
So...apparently you didn't actually watch the debate??