╌>

Advocates of same-sex marriages can't back up claims about positive long-term effects.

  

Category:  News & Politics

Via:  len  •  13 years ago  •  116 comments

Advocates of same-sex marriages can't back up claims about positive long-term effects.

A Social Experiment Without Science Behind It

By Nelson Lund

http://online.wsj.com/article/SB10001424127887324557804578376671175549596.html?KEYWORDS=science+gay+marriage+nelson+lund

The claimed right to same-sex marriage is not in the Constitution or in the court's precedents, so the court must decide whether to impose a new law making marriage into a new and different institution. The justices are unlikely to take so momentous a step unless they are persuaded that granting this new right to same-sex couples will not harm children or ultimately undermine the health of our society.

A significant number of organizations representing social and behavioral scientists have filed briefs promising the court that there is nothing to worry about. These assurances have no scientific foundation. Same-sex marriage is brand new, and child rearing by same-sex couples remains rare. Even if both phenomena were far more common, large amounts of data collected over decades would be required before any responsible researcher could make meaningful scientific estimates of the long-term effects of redefining marriage.

The conclusions in the research literature typically amount at best to claims that a particular study found "no evidence" of bad effects from child rearing by same-sex couples. One could just as easily say that there is no reliable evidence that such child-rearing practices are beneficial or harmless. And that is the conclusion that should be relevant to the court.

Social-science advocacy organizations, however, have promoted the myth that a lack of evidence, so far, of bad effects implies the nonexistence of such effects. This myth is based on conjecture or faith, not science.

Nor is the leap of faith from "no evidence" to "don't worry" an accident. The late Sen. Daniel Patrick Moynihan, himself a distinguished social scientist at Harvard, once observed: "Social science is rarely dispassionate, and social scientists are frequently caught up in the politics which their work necessarily involves . . . [T]he pronounced 'liberal' orientation of sociology, psychology, political science, and similar fields is well established."

This orientation has been on rich display in the research on same-sex parenting, which is scientific primarily in the sense that it is typically conducted by people with postgraduate degrees. There are no scientifically reliable studies at all, nor could there be, given the available data. Yet the Supreme Court has been solemnly assured by many scientific organizations, such as the American Psychological Association and the American Academy of Pediatrics, that the overwhelming weight of evidence indicates that same-sex couples are every bit the equal of opposite-sex parents in every relevant respect. The number of studies may be overwhelming but the evidence assuredly is not.

The prominent National Longitudinal Lesbian Family Study, for instance, relied on a sample recruited entirely at lesbian events, in women's bookstores and through lesbian newspapers. Other studies relied on samples as small as 18 or 33 or 44 cases. The effect of parenting by male homosexual couples remains in the realm of anecdotes. Most research has relied on reports by parents about their children's well-being while the children were still under the care of those parents. Even a social scientist should be able to recognize that parents' evaluations of their own success as parents might be a little skewed.

In 2012, sociologist Loren Marks conducted a detailed re-analysis of 59 studies of parenting by gays and lesbians that were cited by the American Psychological Association in a 2005 publication. Mr. Marks, who teaches at Louisiana State University, concluded that the association drew inferences that were not empirically warranted.

There has been only one study using a large randomized sample, objective measures of well-being, and reports of grown children rather than their parents. This research, by Mark Regnerus, a sociologist at the University of Texas Austin, found that children raised in a household where a parent was involved in a same-sex romantic relationship were at a significant disadvantage with respect to a number of indicators of well beingsuch as depression, educational attainment and criminal behaviorcompared with children of intact biological families.

One might expect this work at least to raise a caution flag, but it has been vociferously attacked on methodological grounds by the same organizations that tout the value of politically congenial research that suffers from more severe methodological shortcomings. This is what one expects from activists, not scientists.

As everyone knows, some states have begun to experiment with legalizing same-sex marriage, and public opinion seems to be shifting in favor of the change. Perhaps this will work out well, and the overwhelming majority of states that have been more cautious will eventually catch up. But experiments are never guaranteed to succeed, and one advantage of democracy is that it allows failed experiments to be abandoned. If the Supreme Court constitutionalizes a right to same-sex marriage, however, there will be no going back. The court cannot possibly know that it is safe to take this irrevocable step.

Mr. Lund is a professor at George Mason University School of Law in Arlington, Va. This article is based on an amicus curiae brief in support of the petitioners in Hollingsworth v. Perry, filed on behalf of Leon R. Kass (University of Chicago), Harvey C. Mansfield (Harvard University), and the Institute for Marriage and Public Policy


Tags

jrDiscussion - desc
[]
 
Kavika
Professor Expert
link   Kavika     13 years ago

My ass isn't lily white, more burning bush Red, but I totally agree with you Barb.

With a divorce rate at 50%, foster care overloaded, chldrenleft on their own (streetkids)and this asshat is worried about the effects of a same sex couple having children. He should try to deal with reality.

 
 
 
96WS6
Junior Silent
link   96WS6    13 years ago

So, after repeated failures to provide any evidence..."Yeah, well, you can't prove it has any positive effects, so there!"

Don't like it when others use your tactics? LMAO!24.gif

 
 
 
luther28
Sophomore Silent
link   luther28    13 years ago

Well sinceI believe that the traditional method ends up in approx. a 50% divorce rate (of which I am one), I am quite willing to allow the gay community to try their hand at it. What goes on between consenting adults as long as it harms no other, is of no concern to me, nor should it be to others in my opinion.

With all the woes that beset our Country, perhaps we should put the social nonsense to one side for a moment (forever would be fine with me) and allow everyone to live their respective lives. Put the shoe on the other foot, how would you or anyone else like to be told that you could only marry ablond white woman of Irish origin. My sainted mother would have said MYOB, translated mind your own business.

 
 
 
Kavika
Professor Expert
link   Kavika     13 years ago

Thank you Barb..Grin.gif

 
 
 
96WS6
Junior Silent
link   96WS6    13 years ago

Funny, I swear I remember you asking someone to prove the Easter Bunny is real.

 
 
 
96WS6
Junior Silent
link   96WS6    13 years ago

I was poking fun at you and chose the most extreme example to make a point. Sorry you "didn't get it".

 
 
 
Polly Cooper
Freshman Silent
link   Polly Cooper    13 years ago

Whether or not this "study" was considered by anybody to be realistic, it seems the SCOTUS rejected it. They are (it appears) taking a wait and see attitude about the harm or benefits of children. In fact, everything I have read about the questioning of the Justices indicates that they believe there are NO factual studies which prove either harm or benefits.

We all know that data (especially really immature data) can be made to uphold either side of any argument.

 
 
 
Len
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Len    13 years ago

Marriage is a unique institution designed for a heterosexual couple from the beginning of time. Ithas noasexual implications any more than marrying one's sibling or roomate simply because of affection; certainly not solelyfor monetary advantage.

Toisolate marriage from the potential for biologicalprocreation is to turn the world upside down. Alternative marriage is the absurd ending point for political correctness. Marriage is not an open-ended "right."

If anyone can get married to any other, or any group for that matter (why not?),the word no longer has any meaning. The end result is the end of marriage as we know it and the end of meaningful marriage altogether.

Is it a coincidence that the number of out-of-wedlock births is mushrooming as the popularity of alternative marriage gains sway? If any combination can get married why should anyone get married?

Look to Scandanavia and Hollandfor where we are headed, as this 2004 article shows:

"Gay Marriage has sent the Netherlands the way of Scandinavia.

"D utch marriage is in trouble. Once noted for their low out-of-wedlock birthrates, and touted by scholars as an alternative to the Scandinavian family model, the Dutch are now experiencing a striking rupture in the relationship between marriage and childbearing, practicing Scandinavian-style parental cohabitation in increasing numbers."

 
 
 
Len
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Len    13 years ago

Rights are not open ended.

A white congressman has no right to become a member of the Black Caucus and an amputeeno right to become a player for a professional sports team.

Creating absurd analogies is a transparent non-starter.

 
 
 
Len
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Len    13 years ago

Resorting to an ad mominum attack is the bankruptcy of conversation. Lund is a distinguished law professor with a bio unmatched by most people:

UNIVERSITY PROFESSOR NELSON LUND has written widely in the field of constitutional law, including articles on constitutional interpretation, federalism, separation of powers, the Second Amendment, the Commerce Clause, the Speech or Debate Clause, the Equal Protection Clause, and the Uniformity Clause. In addition, he has published articles in the fields of employment discrimination and civil rights, the legal regulation of medical ethics, and the application of economic analysis to legal institutions and legal ethics.

Professor Lund graduated from St. John's College in Annapolis, Maryland, after which he received an M.A. in philosophy from the Catholic University of America and a Ph.D. in political science from Harvard University. He left the faculty of the University of Chicago to attend its law school, where he served as executive editor of the University of Chicago Law Review and chapter chairman of the Federalist Society for Law and Public Policy Studies. After law school, he held positions at the United States Department of Justice in the Office of the Solicitor General and the Office of Legal Counsel. He also served as a law clerk to the Honorable Patrick E. Higginbotham of the United States Court of Appeals for the Fifth Circuit and to the Honorable Sandra Day O'Connor of the United States Supreme Court. Following his clerkship with Justice O'Connor, Professor Lund served in the White House as associate counsel to the president from 1989 to 1992.

Since joining the faculty at George Mason, Professor Lund has taught Constitutional Law, Legislation, Federal Election Law, Employment Discrimination, State and Local Government, and seminars on the Second Amendment and on a variety of topics in Jurisprudence.

Lundcoauthored the original work with another distinguishd American, Leon Kass.

Leon Richard Kass (born February 12, 1939) is an American physician , scientist , educator , and public intellectual , best known as proponent of liberal education via the " Great Books ," as an opponent of human cloning , life extension and euthanasia , as a critic of certain areas of technological progress and embryo research, and for his controversial tenure as chairman of the President's Council on Bioethics from 2001 to 2005. Although Kass is often referred to as a bioethicist , he eschews the term and refers to himself as "an old-fashioned humanist . A humanist is concerned broadly with all aspects of human life, not just the ethical."

Kass is currently the Addie Clark Harding Professor in the College and the Committee on Social Thought at the University of Chicago and the Hertog Fellow at the American Enterprise Institute . His books include Toward A More Natural Science: Biology and Human Affairs ; The Hungry Soul: Eating and the Perfecting of our Nature ; Life, Liberty, and the Defense of Dignity: The Challenge for Bioethics ; The Beginning of Wisdom: Reading Genesis ; and What So Proudly We Hail: The American Soul in Story, Speech, and Song .

 
 
 
Len
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Len    13 years ago

Your argument is like saying that we ought to strike all the criminal laws against murder and theft because their prohibition are two of the Ten Commandments.

 
 
 
Aeonpax
Freshman Silent
link   Aeonpax    13 years ago

The argument brought up in the OP's article is a false argument, both philosophically and legally but I'm going to comment on the latter.

The Supreme Court does not judge a case by popular sociology, articulated philosophy, sincere religious belief or academic justification, it must decide on the constitutionality of an issue or question. While it can and does entertain arguments afield from the jurisprudence of law, ultimately it must decide if a law violates the US Constitution.

While I do not doubt the allegiance Mr Lund feels about his data and findings and no matter how pristinely he presents it, his argument remains against the concept of same sex marriage as opposed how it fits legally within the constitution.

If one studies the history of arguments brought up before the Supreme court, those cases involving large social change were all decided on legal merit, not academic suppositions of gloom and doom such as predicted by certain academics when the slaves were freed, when blacks and women were given the right to vote and when Jim Crow were struck down.

With deference to the good professor, his findings however important (but incomplete) he feels they are to this issue, they just do not support a legal and constitutional denial based on a supposition that same sex marriage is "an experiment" as opposed to a "legal right."

 
 
 
Len
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Len    13 years ago

Since when is Psychology Today authoritative?

The author, Abbie Goldberg, is herself a lesbian; a problem typical of so-called "scientific studies" partial to homosexuals.

 
 
 
Dowser
Sophomore Silent
link   Dowser    13 years ago

You know, just because something hasn't been "officially" studied yet, doesn't make it untrue.

I mean, I didn't need an "official" study to be able to tell people that extraordinary stress, lack of sleep, etc., all contributed to a heart attack. I had one, I knew what caused it. Yet, since then, everything they come out with, says, "Blahdiddy Blah leads to increased risk of heart attacks." Out of about 20 things, I had 18 of them. So, we're surprised?

Anyway-- there have been "official" studies done that people who live with someone they love, live longer and are happier. They don't seem to differentiate between genders-- or whether the genders have a specific sexual orientation.

Anyway, I think people are going to live longer if they are happy. I think that people who are happy live productive lives and share the joy with others. And, frankly, I'm glad I'm not married to the author of this piece. He doesn't sound very happy to me.

In fact, I have a theory. My theory is that people who are so anti-people really hate themselves, and are afraid of not measuring up, somehow. What they don't realize is that we're all on the same road, going to same way. We may as well hold hands as we travel down the road, and help each other along... Smile.gif

 
 
 
Len
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Len    13 years ago

Opposing the legalization of homosexual marriage is no more discriminatory than opposing polygamy.

It is not discrimination against homosexuals themselves.

But they have no more a right to call their relationship
"marriage" than do polygamous Mormons or Muislims. People who oppose polygamy are not discriminating against Mormons and Muslims.

We are in a culture war and liberals believe that all is permitted. In contrast, the sensible liberal of a bygone era, Sen. Patrick Moynihan, called it "defining deviency downward."

 
 
 
Len
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Len    13 years ago

>>You know, just because something hasn't been "officially" studied yet, doesn't make it untrue.

Neither does it make it true. That was the point of the article. As Justice Alito said, hpomosexual marriage has been around for less time than the Internet or cell phones. It is radical to base a major disruption of settled law on speculation. As the authior of the brief wrote:

"As everyone knows, some states have begun to experiment with legalizing same-sex marriage, and public opinion seems to be shifting in favor of the change. Perhaps this will work out well, and the overwhelming majority of states that have been more cautious will eventually catch up. But experiments are never guaranteed to succeed, and one advantage of democracy is that it allows failed experiments to be abandoned. If the Supreme Court constitutionalizes a right to same-sex marriage, however, there will be no going back. The court cannot possibly know that it is safe to take this irrevocable step."

 
 
 
Len
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Len    13 years ago

What is your source for asserting that Lund works for the FRC?

 
 
 
Len
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Len    13 years ago

YOU are the one pretending that marriage is wrongfully being treated as a religious matter. That is YOUR red herring. Neither Lund, or anyone else here, raised that subject.

What does homosexual marriage have to do with misogyny? Another red herring!

 
 
 
Len
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Len    13 years ago

>>the black caucus, while composed of members of the house, is NOT a government institution, it is a PRIVATE institution. There is no law that enables or disables the black caucuss.

Nobody has the right to play for a sports team,

You are spinning again. The caucus meets on government time in government facilities about government business and policy. If there were a White Caucus you would be the first to condemn it as discriminatory.

You may have heard of the stutterer who sued the PBS for discrimination because they would not hire him as an announcer.Tongue.gif

 
 
 
Len
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Len    13 years ago

Frequently the legal and social/political issues are intertwined.

Someone would have to be blind not to recognize that the SCOTUS blocs are divided among liberal/conservative lines, not legal ones.

 
 
 
Aeonpax
Freshman Silent
link   Aeonpax    13 years ago

One would have to be uninformed as to the nature of law and the ideology of jurisprudence to assume human pomposity does not enter into the picture. Nonetheless, all decisions by the Supreme Court must be made on points of law as they relate to the US Constitution.

At issue here is the expansion of liberty in the form of a constitutional right (same sex marriage), Vs the possible harm to society such a right may ensue. In making that decision, the court uses the Precautionary principle . The good professor, at best, offers a weak objection as his finding do not constitute a scientific consensus which is what would be needed to make a strong objection. His findings alone do not support a majority consensus from the scientific community nor a compelling argument of a clear and present danger to society.

Even then, personal ideology aside, every case must be decided on constitutional law, not ideology. In Roe v Wade for example, both the majority decision and the dissenting minority objections, were based on points of law as opposed to the ideological beliefs as to what constitutes a human being.

However interesting Mr. Lunds ideological treatise is on gay marriage, it does not address the core constitutional issue nor adequately prove any possible harm.

 
 
 
Len
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Len    13 years ago

That is also the author's opinion . Until we know more we should not become all inclusive.

 
 
 
Len
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Len    13 years ago

>>At issue here is the expansion of liberty in the form of a constitutional right (same sex marriage), Vs the possible harm to society such a right may ensue.

Homosexuals have the same liberty that I do. There is no constitutional right to marriage and divorce which have traditionally beenregulated by the states. People used to go to Reno to get divorced because it was much easier there. If someone wanted to get divorced in another state their liberty was not infringed, or their rights violated, because it was more difficult. In NY, where I live, even clergy need a state license to perform marriages.

Since many federal laws, notably regarding taxation, relate to marriage, Congress passed DOMA. Married people have certain tax benefits and homosexual couples want in on those. But if they can obtain them why shouldn't non-married people have a similar right to those benefits?

Why should those benefits not be available to participants in common-law and polygamous marriages? Why shouldn't someone be able to "marry" his sister (or brother or platonicfriend) just to obtain those benefits?

The main reason government regulates marriage is the same one for which it regulates education; the furtherance of a quality next generation of citizens.

If the government redefines marriage it opens a can of worms with unforeseen consequences to civilization. As I noted elsewhere, this redefinition in the Netherlands and Scandanavia has resulted in more and more people avoiding marriage altogether and an explosion in out-of-wedlock births which, incidently, are also increasing here.

I suggest you also read the more comprehensiive:

Amicus Brief of Leon R. Kass, Harvey C. Mansfield and the Institute...

 
 
 
Len
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Len    13 years ago

Conservative radio talk-show host Rush Limbaugh declared on Thursday that gay marriage in America was inevitable.

This issue is lost, he said on his afternoon talk show. I don't care what the Supreme Court does, this is now inevitable and its inevitable because we lost the language on this.

He talked about the many terms that are being bandied about on the issue: opposite-sex marriage, traditional marriage even hetero-marriage.

We lost the issue when we started allowing the word marriage to be bastardized and redefined by simply adding words to it because marriage is one thing, and it was not established on the basis of discrimination. It wasn't established on the basis of denying people anything.

Marriage is not a tradition that a bunch of people concocted to be mean to other people with, Limbaugh added. But we allowed the left to have people believe that it was structured that way.

Once we started talking about gay marriage, traditional marriage, opposite-sex marriage, same-sex marriage, hetero-marriage, we lost. It was over. It was just a matter of time, Limbaugh said.

Once you decide to modify the word marriage, then the other side has won or at least theyre 90 percent of the way home.



Read Latest Breaking News from Newsmax.com
Urgent: Should Obamacare Be Repealed? Vote Here Now!

 
 
 
Len
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Len    13 years ago

If you wish to characterize my reasoning oppositely to its intention be my guest.

I stand by what I said. DOMA relates to intrinsictaxing power. It's all about money.

"Equal treatment" does not allow me to obtain the tax benefits of non-profit corporations. Taxing inequalities are formed to produce social benefits, not to disadvantage some groups, though that is the outcome.

Married couples have been an advantaged group to facilitate a next generattion of children beneficial to the USA. That is how it should stand.

 
 
 
Erinn Rich
Freshman Silent
link   Erinn Rich    13 years ago

Morning all!

He can kiss my ass on this. I agree with you Kavika and Barb.

I have two dads... amazing and wonderful men. They have been together for almost 30 years now. Married only for about three. Because it wasn't legal yet.

 
 
 
Aeonpax
Freshman Silent
link   Aeonpax    13 years ago

A) Homosexuals have the same liberty that I do. There is no constitutional right to marriage and divorce which have traditionally beenregulated by the states. People used to go to Reno to get divorced because it was much easier there. If someone wanted to get divorced in another state their liberty was not infringed, or their rights violated, because it was more difficult. In NY, where I live, even clergy need a state license to perform marriages.

B) Since many federal laws, notably regarding taxation, relate to marriage, Congress passed DOMA. Married people have certain tax benefits and homosexual couples want in on those. But if they can obtain them why shouldn't non-married people have a similar right to those benefits?

C) Why should those benefits not be available to participants in common-law and polygamous marriages? Why shouldn't someone be able to "marry" his sister (or brother or platonicfriend) just to obtain those benefits?

D) If the government redefines marriage it opens a can of worms with unforeseen consequences to civilization. As I noted elsewhere, this redefinition in the Netherlands and Scandanavia has resulted in more and more people avoiding marriage altogether and an explosion in out-of-wedlock births which, incidently, are also increasing here.

A) I would suggest you read the legal definition of Liberty. If it were true that homosexuals had the same liberties as you, this would not be an issue before the Supreme Court.

Furthermore, as I stated before, this case is about the EXPANSION of liberty, in other words, new Constitutional territory. You may infer all you want about the way things were or are now but none of that precludes to nor rises to the level of a reasonable objection.

B) Again you are mistaken. Have you actually been reading about this case?

At the Supreme Court hearing this week, Justice Elena Kagan, read from the House Report from Congress when it passed the law in 1996, which summarized DOMAs entire legal underpinning: Congress decided to reflect and honor a collective moral judgment and to express moral disapproval of homosexuality. DOMA was never about taxes, its been about a moral disapproval of homosexuality by a majority party. This entire case is a redress to the discriminatory effect of the DOMA law which is why its constitutionality is being challenged.

C) This is a slippery slope argument and the most ridiculous of them all. Gays want the same rights as straights. Incest will still be disallowed. Bestiality will still be disallowed. Common-Law for both hetero/homosexual unions will continue to be the domain of the states. Marriage should be the committed relationship between two persons of consenting age which is lawful in all other ways.

D) How can the government redefine something it has never defined in the first place? On one hand you state there is no constitutional right to marry, then you imply the government has already defined marriage which would take an act of congress to do, ergo, it would be a constitutionally approved law. Which is it?

 
 
 
Dowser
Sophomore Silent
link   Dowser    13 years ago

Len-- I read NOTHING, watch NOTHING, hear NOTHING that Rush Limbaugh says. His credibility with me is ZERO. In fact, I keep waiting for someone to shoot him, but, Uh Oh, all the nuts that would do such a thing listen to him and suck up his BS as if God Has Spoken.

So, if you decide to quote someone to ask me to discuss something-- don't let it be Limbaugh. Instead, let's look at the Harvard Review or some sort of scholarly work-- not some drug-induced, hate-filled rant by a bitter fat man.

Just because something has yet to be proven, doesn't make it true OR false. So, what's your point? Mine was that people who are happy have a tendency to live longer. What skin is it off your nose that gay people want to marry?

 
 
 
ArkansasHermit
Freshman Silent
link   ArkansasHermit    13 years ago

Marriage in all the scandinavian countries have been dropping, and it has absolutely nothing to do with homosexuality. It has to do with people shedding the shackles of an 'institution' that is no longer relevant to them, and as a result 'STRAIGHT couples' are no longer getting married in the numbers that they did in the past.

There is also the factor of the Nordic countries strong social "safety net".

When you live in a Country where free education and universal healthcare, among other things, is part of the social contract the people have with their government I can see more marriages based on love and fewer based on economic needs.

Rushing into or staying in destructive marriages for economic reasons has been all too common here in America, based on my experience.

 
 
 
Aeonpax
Freshman Silent
link   Aeonpax    13 years ago

Semantics. Marriage has it's root in Latin, "matrimony". No one owns a word, not a country, not a culture and not a religion.

 
 
 
Polka-san
Freshman Silent
link   Polka-san    13 years ago

People want decades of study to determine if granting the same rights to some humans that other humans already possess is "acceptable" but wouldn't do the same with the truly new invention of GMO "foods" that has become pervasive everywhere people buy food.

 
 
 
Dowser
Sophomore Silent
link   Dowser    13 years ago

It may be lucid for RL, but I don't pay any attention to him. Yes, he is looking at this from a strategic point of view-- good, for him, that's something. But, the man is a hate-monger and I have no time for him.

I know many gay couples that want to marry, and can't, because it isn't allowed in my state. Frankly, a civil union is fine with all of them-- and let the individual churches decide if they wish to have a religious ceremony recognizing it.

However, in my state, unless the Federal Government acts on this in some way, it will never get through our state house in any form or way. Recognize a civil union and civil commitment. That is fair and equitable. Let the religions do with it what they will. If a particular faith does not wish it to be recognized as a viable union in their church, then don't. Pffftt on them.

I think the Episcopalians have a "blessing" ceremony, with vows and everything. It can be as formal or as informal as the couple wishes. Frankly, my friend's sex lives are none of my business. I love them, period. It is no skin off my nose what they decide to do, whom they decide to marry, or how they wish to live their lives, as long as they aren't physically hurting anyone. (I'm not condoning murder-- but normal people should have the ability to make these choices for themselves.)

If a civil union would allow a partner to be the legal, "next of kin", legal heir, why not? I would rather my husband make those decisions for me, because he loves and knows me, rather than some distant cousin, or my mother who suffers from dementia. Why shouldn't gay people have the same right of inheritance and responsibility? Smile.gif

 
 
 
Dowser
Sophomore Silent
link   Dowser    13 years ago

Why is it that social 'progress' is always impeded, but scientific 'progress' isn't? Funny, isn't it? (As in funny "peculiar", not funny "hahaha".) Smile.gif

 
 
 
Perrie Halpern R.A.
Professor Guide
link   Perrie Halpern R.A.    13 years ago

(As in funny "peculiar", not funny "hahaha".)

Hey, I always say that!Grin.gif

 
 
 
Perrie Halpern R.A.
Professor Guide
link   Perrie Halpern R.A.    13 years ago

Except that it's been going on in Europe for years and the of spring are no more or less "normal" than those raised by straight couples....

 
 
 
Broliver "TheSquirrel" Stagnasty
Freshman Silent
link   Broliver "TheSquirrel" Stagnasty    13 years ago

What an ass-wipe this guy is.

From the article:

The conclusions in the research literature typically amount at best to claims that a particular study found "no evidence" of bad effects from child rearing by same-sex couples. One could just as easily say that there is no reliable evidence that such child-rearing practices are beneficial or harmless. And that is the conclusion that should be relevant to the court.

This man is a law professor? His grasp of logic seems tenuous at best. What part of

No evidence of bad effects

leads one to believe that

One could just as easily say that there is no reliable evidence that such child-rearing practices are... ...harmless.

How does one use logic to justify making both statements?? The second statement implies harmful effects while the first says there is no evidence of harmful effects.

Quite frankly, I didn't read much more after that,becausehe sothoroughlydiscredited any argument that he may make.

 
 
 
Dowser
Sophomore Silent
link   Dowser    13 years ago

Off topic!!!

Brolly, did you get my email? Smile.gif I know, but it was something, and it IS cheaper to live here than in NY... Smile.gif

 
 
 
Broliver "TheSquirrel" Stagnasty
Freshman Silent
link   Broliver "TheSquirrel" Stagnasty    13 years ago

Yes I did, Dowser. Thank you.

 
 
 
Dowser
Sophomore Silent
link   Dowser    13 years ago

I'm keeping my eyeballs peeled... Smile.gif

 
 
 
Kim Lyvang
Freshman Silent
link   Kim Lyvang    13 years ago

When I read this tripe, my first thought was "Who is this idiot?" How dare he insult fellow humans! They are all around us and most of us do not know who they are and probably never will. They only become a problem to these idiots when they want to be treated as equals. And so they should be.

The separation of state and religion must be enforced. Preach your garbage in your church and let everyone else be equal.

There is a young gay gentleman that we met years ago. His father and brother tried to beat him straight years ago. It didn't work, so they disowned him. We became friends. He now calls us Ma and Pops. We call him son, and proudly so. We have two daughters and now we have a son. We love all three of them.

BTW, his being married to another man hasn't affected our marriage. Forty years in May.

 
 
 
Len
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Len    13 years ago


No Explanation
Gay Marriage has sent the Netherlands the way of Scandinavia.

Stanley Kurtz, NRO

D utch marriage is in trouble. Once noted for their low out-of-wedlock birthrates, and touted by scholars as an alternative to the Scandinavian family model, the Dutch are now experiencing a striking rupture in the relationship between marriage and childbearing, practicing Scandinavian-style parental cohabitation in increasing numbers. The bulk of the change has come in the past seven years just as Holland adopted registered partnerships, and then full and formal same-sex marriage.

More:


You may think, as another here does, that marriage should be dispensed withy altogether. But if you don't, you should note that introducing nnew kinds of marriage ends up in devaluing ALL marraige as the European experience shows. Even in the US out-of-wedlock births are rapidly climbing.

Changing patterns of nonmarital childbearing in the United States Adobe PDF file [PDF - 660 KB]

 
 
 
Len
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Len    13 years ago

Marriage Looks Different Now

By ROSS DOUTHAT -- Published: March 30, 2013

Excerpts:

--- for an argument that has persuaded so few, the conservative view has actually had decent predictive power. As the cause of gay marriage has pressed forward, the social link between marriage and childbearing has indeed weakened faster than before. As the publics shift on the issue has accelerated, so has marriages overall decline .

Since Frum warned that gay marriage could advance only at traditional wedlocks expense, the marriage rate has been falling faster, the out-of-wedlock birthrate has been rising faster, and the substitution of cohabitation for marriage has markedly increased. Underlying these trends is a steady shift in values: Americans are less likely to see children as important to marriage and less likely to see marriage as important to childbearing (the generation gap on gay marriage shows up on unwed parenting as well) than even in the very recent past.

 
 
 
Len
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Len    13 years ago

You write like a religiouis zealot.Grin.gif

"From the beginning of time" is:

"Hence a man leaves his father and mother and clings to his wife so that they become one flesh." (Gen. 2:24) As you listed first!

From then to now there were some deviations but, based on experience, the original became largely, though not exclusively, settled practice.

  • A man and his brother's widow (Genesis 38)
  • A rapist and his victim (Deuteronomy 22)
  • Soldiers and their prisoners of war (Numbers 31, Deuteronomy 21)
  • Whoever a person's "owner" decides they should marry (Exodus 21)

These are all a man and a woman.

As of March 2013, eleven countries ( Argentina , Belgium , Canada , Denmark , Iceland , Netherlands , Norway , Portugal , Spain , South Africa , Sweden ), and several sub-national jurisdictions (parts of Brazil , Mexico , and the United States ), allow same-sex couples to marry. Bills allowing legal recognition of same-sex marriage have been proposed, are pending, or have passed at least one legislative house in Andorra , Colombia , Finland , France , Germany , Luxembourg , Nepal , New Zealand , Taiwan , the United Kingdom , and Uruguay as well as in the legislatures of several sub-national jurisdictions (in Scotland as well as parts of Australia , Mexico , and the United States ).

As Ross Douthat writes in today's NY Times:

"--- for an argument that has persuaded so few, the conservative view has actually had decent predictive power. As the cause of gay marriage has pressed forward, the social link between marriage and childbearing has indeed weakened faster than before. As the publics shift on the issue has accelerated, so has marriages overall decline .

"Since Frum warned that gay marriage could advance only at traditional wedlocks expense 9in 1997), the marriage rate has been falling faster, the out-of-wedlock birthrate has been rising faster, and the substitution of cohabitation for marriage has markedly increased. Underlying these trends is a steady shift in values: Americans are less likely to see children as important to marriage and less likely to see marriage as important to childbearing (the generation gap on gay marriage shows up on unwed parenting as well) than even in the very recent past.

"Correlations do not, of course, establish causation. The economy is obviously playing a leading role in the retreat from marriage the shocks of recession, the stagnation of wages, the bleak prospects of blue-collar men. Culturally, what matters most is the emergence of what the National Marriage Project calls a capstone understanding of marriage, which treats wedlock less as a foundation for adulthood and more as a celebration of adult achievement and which seems to work out far better for our disciplined upper class than for society as a whole .

"But there is also a certain willed navet to the idea that the advance of gay marriage is unrelated to any other marital trend. For 10 years, Americas only major public debate about marriage and family has featured one side judges and journalists, celebrities and now finally politicians pressing the case that modern marriage has nothing to do with the way human beings reproduce themselves, that the procreative understanding of the institution was founded entirely on prejudice, and that the shift away from a male-female marital ideal is analogous to the end of segregation."

 
 
 
Len
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Len    13 years ago

For GMO foods people vote with their wallets.

You can blame the FDA for that. It ios a health issue, not a social one.

 
 
 
Len
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Len    13 years ago

I commend you for putting 'progress' in scare quotes.

 
 
 
Len
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Len    13 years ago

There have been some devastating studies about the outcomes of such children. Lund cited one such, the largest yet,but concluded, tolerantly, that we just don't know enough.

Here are two more:

 
 
 
Perrie Halpern R.A.
Professor Guide
link   Perrie Halpern R.A.    13 years ago

OMG Len,

Could you find two more bias studies?

How about some from the medical community?

Of course there are those who judge gay parents with a different measuring stick:

Anyway... there are so many screwed up individuals from straight marriages, what's the big deal? They couldn't do any worse.

 
 
 
Carol-99
Freshman Silent
link   Carol-99    13 years ago

The right to same-sex marriage isn't in the Constitution-- nor is the right to opposite sex marriage

That was my first thought when I read this article.

 
 
 
Carol-99
Freshman Silent
link   Carol-99    13 years ago

Like I have said, I don't mind if we have gay marriage, and it is no skin off my nose, as they say, but neither do I see a compelling argument to change the definition of marriage. The issue is not so much about definitions as it is about forcing the entire population to "accept" homosexuality. They may be fine too, but you can't "force" people to accept lifestyles they don't approve of.

No one is forcing " people to accept lifestyles they don't approve of". We just want them to accept that homosexuals have the same rights as everyone else, and that means that the legal definition of marriage should be changed.

The legal status, condition, or relationship that results from a contract by which one man and one woman, who have the capacity to enter into such an agreement, mutually promise to live together in the relationship of Husband and Wife in law for life, or until the legal termination of the relationship.

I'm not legal expert, but I would suggest something like:

The legal status, condition, or relationship that results from a contract by which two consenting adults, who have the capacity to enter into such an agreement, mutually promise to live together in the relationship of Spouse & Spouse in law for life, or until the legal termination of the relationship.

 
 
 
Carol-99
Freshman Silent
link   Carol-99    13 years ago

As Justice Alito said, hpomosexual marriage has been around for less time than the Internet or cell phones.

Shouldd we outlaw cell phones and the Internet until studies have shown that they are beneficial for children?

 
 
 
Perrie Halpern R.A.
Professor Guide
link   Perrie Halpern R.A.    13 years ago

Carol watched Jon Stewart last night, LOL!

 
 
 
Perrie Halpern R.A.
Professor Guide
link   Perrie Halpern R.A.    13 years ago

What does gay marriage have to do with straights not getting married. I find the whole thing rather ironic. Gays seem to want the traditional values that you so want us to have, while straights are shunning them. But you can't blame that on gays. You would do far better pointing to Hollywood as a reason.

 
 
 
Dowser
Sophomore Silent
link   Dowser    13 years ago

See? I've always thought we were twins, separated only by birthdates... Smile.gif

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    13 years ago

A significant number of organizations representing social and behavioral scientists have filed briefs promising the court that there is nothing to worry about. These assurances have no scientific foundation. Same-sex marriage is brand new, and child rearing by same-sex couples remains rare.

That's not how the legal system works in America; when an allegation is leveled, the plaintiff must satisfy a burden-of-proof validating the veracity of that allegation. There is NO PROOF THAT SAME-SEX MARRIAGE IS DETRIMENTAL! When questioned by one of the SCOTUS justices, the attorney for those opposing same-sex marriage (that is, those in favor of California's Prop 8 Constitutional Amendment banning same-sex marriage), that attorney could not cite one example of harm in conjunction with same-sex marriage.

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    13 years ago

Love is love, regardless of who it is directed towards.

Well-reasoned and well-stated.

 
 
 
JbBirder
Freshman Silent
link   JbBirder    13 years ago

Using this same argument, I see very little positive out come of heterosexual couples raising children.

If a same sex couple spends all the time fighting for the right to be married, the right to have/adopt a child and to raise it safely and equally in our society, it only seems like their interests and care would go above and beyond most heterosexuals who have put as much thought into procreation as a moment of passion in the back of a car or a drunken struggle in a bar's restroom.

 
 
 
Kavika
Professor Expert
link   Kavika     13 years ago

My ass isn't lily white, more burning bush Red, but I totally agree with you Barb.

With a divorce rate at 50%, foster care overloaded, chldrenleft on their own (streetkids)and this asshat is worried about the effects of a same sex couple having children. He should try to deal with reality.

 
 
 
96WS6
Junior Silent
link   96WS6    13 years ago

So, after repeated failures to provide any evidence..."Yeah, well, you can't prove it has any positive effects, so there!"

Don't like it when others use your tactics? LMAO!24.gif

 
 
 
luther28
Sophomore Silent
link   luther28    13 years ago

Well sinceI believe that the traditional method ends up in approx. a 50% divorce rate (of which I am one), I am quite willing to allow the gay community to try their hand at it. What goes on between consenting adults as long as it harms no other, is of no concern to me, nor should it be to others in my opinion.

With all the woes that beset our Country, perhaps we should put the social nonsense to one side for a moment (forever would be fine with me) and allow everyone to live their respective lives. Put the shoe on the other foot, how would you or anyone else like to be told that you could only marry ablond white woman of Irish origin. My sainted mother would have said MYOB, translated mind your own business.

 
 
 
Kavika
Professor Expert
link   Kavika     13 years ago

Thank you Barb..Grin.gif

 
 
 
96WS6
Junior Silent
link   96WS6    13 years ago

Funny, I swear I remember you asking someone to prove the Easter Bunny is real.

 
 
 
96WS6
Junior Silent
link   96WS6    13 years ago

I was poking fun at you and chose the most extreme example to make a point. Sorry you "didn't get it".

 
 
 
Polly Cooper
Freshman Silent
link   Polly Cooper    13 years ago

Whether or not this "study" was considered by anybody to be realistic, it seems the SCOTUS rejected it. They are (it appears) taking a wait and see attitude about the harm or benefits of children. In fact, everything I have read about the questioning of the Justices indicates that they believe there are NO factual studies which prove either harm or benefits.

We all know that data (especially really immature data) can be made to uphold either side of any argument.

 
 
 
Len
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Len    13 years ago

Marriage is a unique institution designed for a heterosexual couple from the beginning of time. Ithas noasexual implications any more than marrying one's sibling or roomate simply because of affection; certainly not solelyfor monetary advantage.

Toisolate marriage from the potential for biologicalprocreation is to turn the world upside down. Alternative marriage is the absurd ending point for political correctness. Marriage is not an open-ended "right."

If anyone can get married to any other, or any group for that matter (why not?),the word no longer has any meaning. The end result is the end of marriage as we know it and the end of meaningful marriage altogether.

Is it a coincidence that the number of out-of-wedlock births is mushrooming as the popularity of alternative marriage gains sway? If any combination can get married why should anyone get married?

Look to Scandanavia and Hollandfor where we are headed, as this 2004 article shows:

"Gay Marriage has sent the Netherlands the way of Scandinavia.

"D utch marriage is in trouble. Once noted for their low out-of-wedlock birthrates, and touted by scholars as an alternative to the Scandinavian family model, the Dutch are now experiencing a striking rupture in the relationship between marriage and childbearing, practicing Scandinavian-style parental cohabitation in increasing numbers."

 
 
 
Len
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Len    13 years ago

Rights are not open ended.

A white congressman has no right to become a member of the Black Caucus and an amputeeno right to become a player for a professional sports team.

Creating absurd analogies is a transparent non-starter.

 
 
 
Len
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Len    13 years ago

Resorting to an ad mominum attack is the bankruptcy of conversation. Lund is a distinguished law professor with a bio unmatched by most people:

UNIVERSITY PROFESSOR NELSON LUND has written widely in the field of constitutional law, including articles on constitutional interpretation, federalism, separation of powers, the Second Amendment, the Commerce Clause, the Speech or Debate Clause, the Equal Protection Clause, and the Uniformity Clause. In addition, he has published articles in the fields of employment discrimination and civil rights, the legal regulation of medical ethics, and the application of economic analysis to legal institutions and legal ethics.

Professor Lund graduated from St. John's College in Annapolis, Maryland, after which he received an M.A. in philosophy from the Catholic University of America and a Ph.D. in political science from Harvard University. He left the faculty of the University of Chicago to attend its law school, where he served as executive editor of the University of Chicago Law Review and chapter chairman of the Federalist Society for Law and Public Policy Studies. After law school, he held positions at the United States Department of Justice in the Office of the Solicitor General and the Office of Legal Counsel. He also served as a law clerk to the Honorable Patrick E. Higginbotham of the United States Court of Appeals for the Fifth Circuit and to the Honorable Sandra Day O'Connor of the United States Supreme Court. Following his clerkship with Justice O'Connor, Professor Lund served in the White House as associate counsel to the president from 1989 to 1992.

Since joining the faculty at George Mason, Professor Lund has taught Constitutional Law, Legislation, Federal Election Law, Employment Discrimination, State and Local Government, and seminars on the Second Amendment and on a variety of topics in Jurisprudence.

Lundcoauthored the original work with another distinguishd American, Leon Kass.

Leon Richard Kass (born February 12, 1939) is an American physician , scientist , educator , and public intellectual , best known as proponent of liberal education via the " Great Books ," as an opponent of human cloning , life extension and euthanasia , as a critic of certain areas of technological progress and embryo research, and for his controversial tenure as chairman of the President's Council on Bioethics from 2001 to 2005. Although Kass is often referred to as a bioethicist , he eschews the term and refers to himself as "an old-fashioned humanist . A humanist is concerned broadly with all aspects of human life, not just the ethical."

Kass is currently the Addie Clark Harding Professor in the College and the Committee on Social Thought at the University of Chicago and the Hertog Fellow at the American Enterprise Institute . His books include Toward A More Natural Science: Biology and Human Affairs ; The Hungry Soul: Eating and the Perfecting of our Nature ; Life, Liberty, and the Defense of Dignity: The Challenge for Bioethics ; The Beginning of Wisdom: Reading Genesis ; and What So Proudly We Hail: The American Soul in Story, Speech, and Song .

 
 
 
Len
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Len    13 years ago

Your argument is like saying that we ought to strike all the criminal laws against murder and theft because their prohibition are two of the Ten Commandments.

 
 
 
Aeonpax
Freshman Silent
link   Aeonpax    13 years ago

The argument brought up in the OP's article is a false argument, both philosophically and legally but I'm going to comment on the latter.

The Supreme Court does not judge a case by popular sociology, articulated philosophy, sincere religious belief or academic justification, it must decide on the constitutionality of an issue or question. While it can and does entertain arguments afield from the jurisprudence of law, ultimately it must decide if a law violates the US Constitution.

While I do not doubt the allegiance Mr Lund feels about his data and findings and no matter how pristinely he presents it, his argument remains against the concept of same sex marriage as opposed how it fits legally within the constitution.

If one studies the history of arguments brought up before the Supreme court, those cases involving large social change were all decided on legal merit, not academic suppositions of gloom and doom such as predicted by certain academics when the slaves were freed, when blacks and women were given the right to vote and when Jim Crow were struck down.

With deference to the good professor, his findings however important (but incomplete) he feels they are to this issue, they just do not support a legal and constitutional denial based on a supposition that same sex marriage is "an experiment" as opposed to a "legal right."

 
 
 
Len
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Len    13 years ago

Since when is Psychology Today authoritative?

The author, Abbie Goldberg, is herself a lesbian; a problem typical of so-called "scientific studies" partial to homosexuals.

 
 
 
Dowser
Sophomore Silent
link   Dowser    13 years ago

You know, just because something hasn't been "officially" studied yet, doesn't make it untrue.

I mean, I didn't need an "official" study to be able to tell people that extraordinary stress, lack of sleep, etc., all contributed to a heart attack. I had one, I knew what caused it. Yet, since then, everything they come out with, says, "Blahdiddy Blah leads to increased risk of heart attacks." Out of about 20 things, I had 18 of them. So, we're surprised?

Anyway-- there have been "official" studies done that people who live with someone they love, live longer and are happier. They don't seem to differentiate between genders-- or whether the genders have a specific sexual orientation.

Anyway, I think people are going to live longer if they are happy. I think that people who are happy live productive lives and share the joy with others. And, frankly, I'm glad I'm not married to the author of this piece. He doesn't sound very happy to me.

In fact, I have a theory. My theory is that people who are so anti-people really hate themselves, and are afraid of not measuring up, somehow. What they don't realize is that we're all on the same road, going to same way. We may as well hold hands as we travel down the road, and help each other along... Smile.gif

 
 
 
Len
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Len    13 years ago

Opposing the legalization of homosexual marriage is no more discriminatory than opposing polygamy.

It is not discrimination against homosexuals themselves.

But they have no more a right to call their relationship
"marriage" than do polygamous Mormons or Muislims. People who oppose polygamy are not discriminating against Mormons and Muslims.

We are in a culture war and liberals believe that all is permitted. In contrast, the sensible liberal of a bygone era, Sen. Patrick Moynihan, called it "defining deviency downward."

 
 
 
Len
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Len    13 years ago

>>You know, just because something hasn't been "officially" studied yet, doesn't make it untrue.

Neither does it make it true. That was the point of the article. As Justice Alito said, hpomosexual marriage has been around for less time than the Internet or cell phones. It is radical to base a major disruption of settled law on speculation. As the authior of the brief wrote:

"As everyone knows, some states have begun to experiment with legalizing same-sex marriage, and public opinion seems to be shifting in favor of the change. Perhaps this will work out well, and the overwhelming majority of states that have been more cautious will eventually catch up. But experiments are never guaranteed to succeed, and one advantage of democracy is that it allows failed experiments to be abandoned. If the Supreme Court constitutionalizes a right to same-sex marriage, however, there will be no going back. The court cannot possibly know that it is safe to take this irrevocable step."

 
 
 
Len
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Len    13 years ago

What is your source for asserting that Lund works for the FRC?

 
 
 
Len
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Len    13 years ago

YOU are the one pretending that marriage is wrongfully being treated as a religious matter. That is YOUR red herring. Neither Lund, or anyone else here, raised that subject.

What does homosexual marriage have to do with misogyny? Another red herring!

 
 
 
Len
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Len    13 years ago

>>the black caucus, while composed of members of the house, is NOT a government institution, it is a PRIVATE institution. There is no law that enables or disables the black caucuss.

Nobody has the right to play for a sports team,

You are spinning again. The caucus meets on government time in government facilities about government business and policy. If there were a White Caucus you would be the first to condemn it as discriminatory.

You may have heard of the stutterer who sued the PBS for discrimination because they would not hire him as an announcer.Tongue.gif

 
 
 
Len
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Len    13 years ago

Frequently the legal and social/political issues are intertwined.

Someone would have to be blind not to recognize that the SCOTUS blocs are divided among liberal/conservative lines, not legal ones.

 
 
 
Aeonpax
Freshman Silent
link   Aeonpax    13 years ago

One would have to be uninformed as to the nature of law and the ideology of jurisprudence to assume human pomposity does not enter into the picture. Nonetheless, all decisions by the Supreme Court must be made on points of law as they relate to the US Constitution.

At issue here is the expansion of liberty in the form of a constitutional right (same sex marriage), Vs the possible harm to society such a right may ensue. In making that decision, the court uses the Precautionary principle . The good professor, at best, offers a weak objection as his finding do not constitute a scientific consensus which is what would be needed to make a strong objection. His findings alone do not support a majority consensus from the scientific community nor a compelling argument of a clear and present danger to society.

Even then, personal ideology aside, every case must be decided on constitutional law, not ideology. In Roe v Wade for example, both the majority decision and the dissenting minority objections, were based on points of law as opposed to the ideological beliefs as to what constitutes a human being.

However interesting Mr. Lunds ideological treatise is on gay marriage, it does not address the core constitutional issue nor adequately prove any possible harm.

 
 
 
Len
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Len    13 years ago

That is also the author's opinion . Until we know more we should not become all inclusive.

 
 
 
Len
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Len    13 years ago

>>At issue here is the expansion of liberty in the form of a constitutional right (same sex marriage), Vs the possible harm to society such a right may ensue.

Homosexuals have the same liberty that I do. There is no constitutional right to marriage and divorce which have traditionally beenregulated by the states. People used to go to Reno to get divorced because it was much easier there. If someone wanted to get divorced in another state their liberty was not infringed, or their rights violated, because it was more difficult. In NY, where I live, even clergy need a state license to perform marriages.

Since many federal laws, notably regarding taxation, relate to marriage, Congress passed DOMA. Married people have certain tax benefits and homosexual couples want in on those. But if they can obtain them why shouldn't non-married people have a similar right to those benefits?

Why should those benefits not be available to participants in common-law and polygamous marriages? Why shouldn't someone be able to "marry" his sister (or brother or platonicfriend) just to obtain those benefits?

The main reason government regulates marriage is the same one for which it regulates education; the furtherance of a quality next generation of citizens.

If the government redefines marriage it opens a can of worms with unforeseen consequences to civilization. As I noted elsewhere, this redefinition in the Netherlands and Scandanavia has resulted in more and more people avoiding marriage altogether and an explosion in out-of-wedlock births which, incidently, are also increasing here.

I suggest you also read the more comprehensiive:

Amicus Brief of Leon R. Kass, Harvey C. Mansfield and the Institute...

 
 
 
Len
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Len    13 years ago

Conservative radio talk-show host Rush Limbaugh declared on Thursday that gay marriage in America was inevitable.

This issue is lost, he said on his afternoon talk show. I don't care what the Supreme Court does, this is now inevitable and its inevitable because we lost the language on this.

He talked about the many terms that are being bandied about on the issue: opposite-sex marriage, traditional marriage even hetero-marriage.

We lost the issue when we started allowing the word marriage to be bastardized and redefined by simply adding words to it because marriage is one thing, and it was not established on the basis of discrimination. It wasn't established on the basis of denying people anything.

Marriage is not a tradition that a bunch of people concocted to be mean to other people with, Limbaugh added. But we allowed the left to have people believe that it was structured that way.

Once we started talking about gay marriage, traditional marriage, opposite-sex marriage, same-sex marriage, hetero-marriage, we lost. It was over. It was just a matter of time, Limbaugh said.

Once you decide to modify the word marriage, then the other side has won or at least theyre 90 percent of the way home.



Read Latest Breaking News from Newsmax.com
Urgent: Should Obamacare Be Repealed? Vote Here Now!

 
 
 
Len
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Len    13 years ago

If you wish to characterize my reasoning oppositely to its intention be my guest.

I stand by what I said. DOMA relates to intrinsictaxing power. It's all about money.

"Equal treatment" does not allow me to obtain the tax benefits of non-profit corporations. Taxing inequalities are formed to produce social benefits, not to disadvantage some groups, though that is the outcome.

Married couples have been an advantaged group to facilitate a next generattion of children beneficial to the USA. That is how it should stand.

 
 
 
Erinn Rich
Freshman Silent
link   Erinn Rich    13 years ago

Morning all!

He can kiss my ass on this. I agree with you Kavika and Barb.

I have two dads... amazing and wonderful men. They have been together for almost 30 years now. Married only for about three. Because it wasn't legal yet.

 
 
 
Aeonpax
Freshman Silent
link   Aeonpax    13 years ago

A) Homosexuals have the same liberty that I do. There is no constitutional right to marriage and divorce which have traditionally beenregulated by the states. People used to go to Reno to get divorced because it was much easier there. If someone wanted to get divorced in another state their liberty was not infringed, or their rights violated, because it was more difficult. In NY, where I live, even clergy need a state license to perform marriages.

B) Since many federal laws, notably regarding taxation, relate to marriage, Congress passed DOMA. Married people have certain tax benefits and homosexual couples want in on those. But if they can obtain them why shouldn't non-married people have a similar right to those benefits?

C) Why should those benefits not be available to participants in common-law and polygamous marriages? Why shouldn't someone be able to "marry" his sister (or brother or platonicfriend) just to obtain those benefits?

D) If the government redefines marriage it opens a can of worms with unforeseen consequences to civilization. As I noted elsewhere, this redefinition in the Netherlands and Scandanavia has resulted in more and more people avoiding marriage altogether and an explosion in out-of-wedlock births which, incidently, are also increasing here.

A) I would suggest you read the legal definition of Liberty. If it were true that homosexuals had the same liberties as you, this would not be an issue before the Supreme Court.

Furthermore, as I stated before, this case is about the EXPANSION of liberty, in other words, new Constitutional territory. You may infer all you want about the way things were or are now but none of that precludes to nor rises to the level of a reasonable objection.

B) Again you are mistaken. Have you actually been reading about this case?

At the Supreme Court hearing this week, Justice Elena Kagan, read from the House Report from Congress when it passed the law in 1996, which summarized DOMAs entire legal underpinning: Congress decided to reflect and honor a collective moral judgment and to express moral disapproval of homosexuality. DOMA was never about taxes, its been about a moral disapproval of homosexuality by a majority party. This entire case is a redress to the discriminatory effect of the DOMA law which is why its constitutionality is being challenged.

C) This is a slippery slope argument and the most ridiculous of them all. Gays want the same rights as straights. Incest will still be disallowed. Bestiality will still be disallowed. Common-Law for both hetero/homosexual unions will continue to be the domain of the states. Marriage should be the committed relationship between two persons of consenting age which is lawful in all other ways.

D) How can the government redefine something it has never defined in the first place? On one hand you state there is no constitutional right to marry, then you imply the government has already defined marriage which would take an act of congress to do, ergo, it would be a constitutionally approved law. Which is it?

 
 
 
Dowser
Sophomore Silent
link   Dowser    13 years ago

Len-- I read NOTHING, watch NOTHING, hear NOTHING that Rush Limbaugh says. His credibility with me is ZERO. In fact, I keep waiting for someone to shoot him, but, Uh Oh, all the nuts that would do such a thing listen to him and suck up his BS as if God Has Spoken.

So, if you decide to quote someone to ask me to discuss something-- don't let it be Limbaugh. Instead, let's look at the Harvard Review or some sort of scholarly work-- not some drug-induced, hate-filled rant by a bitter fat man.

Just because something has yet to be proven, doesn't make it true OR false. So, what's your point? Mine was that people who are happy have a tendency to live longer. What skin is it off your nose that gay people want to marry?

 
 
 
ArkansasHermit
Freshman Silent
link   ArkansasHermit    13 years ago

Marriage in all the scandinavian countries have been dropping, and it has absolutely nothing to do with homosexuality. It has to do with people shedding the shackles of an 'institution' that is no longer relevant to them, and as a result 'STRAIGHT couples' are no longer getting married in the numbers that they did in the past.

There is also the factor of the Nordic countries strong social "safety net".

When you live in a Country where free education and universal healthcare, among other things, is part of the social contract the people have with their government I can see more marriages based on love and fewer based on economic needs.

Rushing into or staying in destructive marriages for economic reasons has been all too common here in America, based on my experience.

 
 
 
Aeonpax
Freshman Silent
link   Aeonpax    13 years ago

Semantics. Marriage has it's root in Latin, "matrimony". No one owns a word, not a country, not a culture and not a religion.

 
 
 
Polka-san
Freshman Silent
link   Polka-san    13 years ago

People want decades of study to determine if granting the same rights to some humans that other humans already possess is "acceptable" but wouldn't do the same with the truly new invention of GMO "foods" that has become pervasive everywhere people buy food.

 
 
 
Dowser
Sophomore Silent
link   Dowser    13 years ago

It may be lucid for RL, but I don't pay any attention to him. Yes, he is looking at this from a strategic point of view-- good, for him, that's something. But, the man is a hate-monger and I have no time for him.

I know many gay couples that want to marry, and can't, because it isn't allowed in my state. Frankly, a civil union is fine with all of them-- and let the individual churches decide if they wish to have a religious ceremony recognizing it.

However, in my state, unless the Federal Government acts on this in some way, it will never get through our state house in any form or way. Recognize a civil union and civil commitment. That is fair and equitable. Let the religions do with it what they will. If a particular faith does not wish it to be recognized as a viable union in their church, then don't. Pffftt on them.

I think the Episcopalians have a "blessing" ceremony, with vows and everything. It can be as formal or as informal as the couple wishes. Frankly, my friend's sex lives are none of my business. I love them, period. It is no skin off my nose what they decide to do, whom they decide to marry, or how they wish to live their lives, as long as they aren't physically hurting anyone. (I'm not condoning murder-- but normal people should have the ability to make these choices for themselves.)

If a civil union would allow a partner to be the legal, "next of kin", legal heir, why not? I would rather my husband make those decisions for me, because he loves and knows me, rather than some distant cousin, or my mother who suffers from dementia. Why shouldn't gay people have the same right of inheritance and responsibility? Smile.gif

 
 
 
Dowser
Sophomore Silent
link   Dowser    13 years ago

Why is it that social 'progress' is always impeded, but scientific 'progress' isn't? Funny, isn't it? (As in funny "peculiar", not funny "hahaha".) Smile.gif

 
 
 
Perrie Halpern R.A.
Professor Guide
link   Perrie Halpern R.A.    13 years ago

(As in funny "peculiar", not funny "hahaha".)

Hey, I always say that!Grin.gif

 
 
 
Perrie Halpern R.A.
Professor Guide
link   Perrie Halpern R.A.    13 years ago

Except that it's been going on in Europe for years and the of spring are no more or less "normal" than those raised by straight couples....

 
 
 
Broliver "TheSquirrel" Stagnasty
Freshman Silent
link   Broliver "TheSquirrel" Stagnasty    13 years ago

What an ass-wipe this guy is.

From the article:

The conclusions in the research literature typically amount at best to claims that a particular study found "no evidence" of bad effects from child rearing by same-sex couples. One could just as easily say that there is no reliable evidence that such child-rearing practices are beneficial or harmless. And that is the conclusion that should be relevant to the court.

This man is a law professor? His grasp of logic seems tenuous at best. What part of

No evidence of bad effects

leads one to believe that

One could just as easily say that there is no reliable evidence that such child-rearing practices are... ...harmless.

How does one use logic to justify making both statements?? The second statement implies harmful effects while the first says there is no evidence of harmful effects.

Quite frankly, I didn't read much more after that,becausehe sothoroughlydiscredited any argument that he may make.

 
 
 
Dowser
Sophomore Silent
link   Dowser    13 years ago

Off topic!!!

Brolly, did you get my email? Smile.gif I know, but it was something, and it IS cheaper to live here than in NY... Smile.gif

 
 
 
Broliver "TheSquirrel" Stagnasty
Freshman Silent
link   Broliver "TheSquirrel" Stagnasty    13 years ago

Yes I did, Dowser. Thank you.

 
 
 
Dowser
Sophomore Silent
link   Dowser    13 years ago

I'm keeping my eyeballs peeled... Smile.gif

 
 
 
Kim Lyvang
Freshman Silent
link   Kim Lyvang    13 years ago

When I read this tripe, my first thought was "Who is this idiot?" How dare he insult fellow humans! They are all around us and most of us do not know who they are and probably never will. They only become a problem to these idiots when they want to be treated as equals. And so they should be.

The separation of state and religion must be enforced. Preach your garbage in your church and let everyone else be equal.

There is a young gay gentleman that we met years ago. His father and brother tried to beat him straight years ago. It didn't work, so they disowned him. We became friends. He now calls us Ma and Pops. We call him son, and proudly so. We have two daughters and now we have a son. We love all three of them.

BTW, his being married to another man hasn't affected our marriage. Forty years in May.

 
 
 
Len
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Len    13 years ago


No Explanation
Gay Marriage has sent the Netherlands the way of Scandinavia.

Stanley Kurtz, NRO

D utch marriage is in trouble. Once noted for their low out-of-wedlock birthrates, and touted by scholars as an alternative to the Scandinavian family model, the Dutch are now experiencing a striking rupture in the relationship between marriage and childbearing, practicing Scandinavian-style parental cohabitation in increasing numbers. The bulk of the change has come in the past seven years just as Holland adopted registered partnerships, and then full and formal same-sex marriage.

More:


You may think, as another here does, that marriage should be dispensed withy altogether. But if you don't, you should note that introducing nnew kinds of marriage ends up in devaluing ALL marraige as the European experience shows. Even in the US out-of-wedlock births are rapidly climbing.

Changing patterns of nonmarital childbearing in the United States Adobe PDF file [PDF - 660 KB]

 
 
 
Len
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Len    13 years ago

Marriage Looks Different Now

By ROSS DOUTHAT -- Published: March 30, 2013

Excerpts:

--- for an argument that has persuaded so few, the conservative view has actually had decent predictive power. As the cause of gay marriage has pressed forward, the social link between marriage and childbearing has indeed weakened faster than before. As the publics shift on the issue has accelerated, so has marriages overall decline .

Since Frum warned that gay marriage could advance only at traditional wedlocks expense, the marriage rate has been falling faster, the out-of-wedlock birthrate has been rising faster, and the substitution of cohabitation for marriage has markedly increased. Underlying these trends is a steady shift in values: Americans are less likely to see children as important to marriage and less likely to see marriage as important to childbearing (the generation gap on gay marriage shows up on unwed parenting as well) than even in the very recent past.

 
 
 
Len
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Len    13 years ago

You write like a religiouis zealot.Grin.gif

"From the beginning of time" is:

"Hence a man leaves his father and mother and clings to his wife so that they become one flesh." (Gen. 2:24) As you listed first!

From then to now there were some deviations but, based on experience, the original became largely, though not exclusively, settled practice.

  • A man and his brother's widow (Genesis 38)
  • A rapist and his victim (Deuteronomy 22)
  • Soldiers and their prisoners of war (Numbers 31, Deuteronomy 21)
  • Whoever a person's "owner" decides they should marry (Exodus 21)

These are all a man and a woman.

As of March 2013, eleven countries ( Argentina , Belgium , Canada , Denmark , Iceland , Netherlands , Norway , Portugal , Spain , South Africa , Sweden ), and several sub-national jurisdictions (parts of Brazil , Mexico , and the United States ), allow same-sex couples to marry. Bills allowing legal recognition of same-sex marriage have been proposed, are pending, or have passed at least one legislative house in Andorra , Colombia , Finland , France , Germany , Luxembourg , Nepal , New Zealand , Taiwan , the United Kingdom , and Uruguay as well as in the legislatures of several sub-national jurisdictions (in Scotland as well as parts of Australia , Mexico , and the United States ).

As Ross Douthat writes in today's NY Times:

"--- for an argument that has persuaded so few, the conservative view has actually had decent predictive power. As the cause of gay marriage has pressed forward, the social link between marriage and childbearing has indeed weakened faster than before. As the publics shift on the issue has accelerated, so has marriages overall decline .

"Since Frum warned that gay marriage could advance only at traditional wedlocks expense 9in 1997), the marriage rate has been falling faster, the out-of-wedlock birthrate has been rising faster, and the substitution of cohabitation for marriage has markedly increased. Underlying these trends is a steady shift in values: Americans are less likely to see children as important to marriage and less likely to see marriage as important to childbearing (the generation gap on gay marriage shows up on unwed parenting as well) than even in the very recent past.

"Correlations do not, of course, establish causation. The economy is obviously playing a leading role in the retreat from marriage the shocks of recession, the stagnation of wages, the bleak prospects of blue-collar men. Culturally, what matters most is the emergence of what the National Marriage Project calls a capstone understanding of marriage, which treats wedlock less as a foundation for adulthood and more as a celebration of adult achievement and which seems to work out far better for our disciplined upper class than for society as a whole .

"But there is also a certain willed navet to the idea that the advance of gay marriage is unrelated to any other marital trend. For 10 years, Americas only major public debate about marriage and family has featured one side judges and journalists, celebrities and now finally politicians pressing the case that modern marriage has nothing to do with the way human beings reproduce themselves, that the procreative understanding of the institution was founded entirely on prejudice, and that the shift away from a male-female marital ideal is analogous to the end of segregation."

 
 
 
Len
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Len    13 years ago

For GMO foods people vote with their wallets.

You can blame the FDA for that. It ios a health issue, not a social one.

 
 
 
Len
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Len    13 years ago

I commend you for putting 'progress' in scare quotes.

 
 
 
Len
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Len    13 years ago

There have been some devastating studies about the outcomes of such children. Lund cited one such, the largest yet,but concluded, tolerantly, that we just don't know enough.

Here are two more:

 
 
 
Perrie Halpern R.A.
Professor Guide
link   Perrie Halpern R.A.    13 years ago

OMG Len,

Could you find two more bias studies?

How about some from the medical community?

Of course there are those who judge gay parents with a different measuring stick:

Anyway... there are so many screwed up individuals from straight marriages, what's the big deal? They couldn't do any worse.

 
 
 
Carol-99
Freshman Silent
link   Carol-99    13 years ago

The right to same-sex marriage isn't in the Constitution-- nor is the right to opposite sex marriage

That was my first thought when I read this article.

 
 
 
Carol-99
Freshman Silent
link   Carol-99    13 years ago

Like I have said, I don't mind if we have gay marriage, and it is no skin off my nose, as they say, but neither do I see a compelling argument to change the definition of marriage. The issue is not so much about definitions as it is about forcing the entire population to "accept" homosexuality. They may be fine too, but you can't "force" people to accept lifestyles they don't approve of.

No one is forcing " people to accept lifestyles they don't approve of". We just want them to accept that homosexuals have the same rights as everyone else, and that means that the legal definition of marriage should be changed.

The legal status, condition, or relationship that results from a contract by which one man and one woman, who have the capacity to enter into such an agreement, mutually promise to live together in the relationship of Husband and Wife in law for life, or until the legal termination of the relationship.

I'm not legal expert, but I would suggest something like:

The legal status, condition, or relationship that results from a contract by which two consenting adults, who have the capacity to enter into such an agreement, mutually promise to live together in the relationship of Spouse & Spouse in law for life, or until the legal termination of the relationship.

 
 
 
Carol-99
Freshman Silent
link   Carol-99    13 years ago

As Justice Alito said, hpomosexual marriage has been around for less time than the Internet or cell phones.

Shouldd we outlaw cell phones and the Internet until studies have shown that they are beneficial for children?

 
 
 
Perrie Halpern R.A.
Professor Guide
link   Perrie Halpern R.A.    13 years ago

Carol watched Jon Stewart last night, LOL!

 
 
 
Perrie Halpern R.A.
Professor Guide
link   Perrie Halpern R.A.    13 years ago

What does gay marriage have to do with straights not getting married. I find the whole thing rather ironic. Gays seem to want the traditional values that you so want us to have, while straights are shunning them. But you can't blame that on gays. You would do far better pointing to Hollywood as a reason.

 
 
 
Dowser
Sophomore Silent
link   Dowser    13 years ago

See? I've always thought we were twins, separated only by birthdates... Smile.gif

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    13 years ago

A significant number of organizations representing social and behavioral scientists have filed briefs promising the court that there is nothing to worry about. These assurances have no scientific foundation. Same-sex marriage is brand new, and child rearing by same-sex couples remains rare.

That's not how the legal system works in America; when an allegation is leveled, the plaintiff must satisfy a burden-of-proof validating the veracity of that allegation. There is NO PROOF THAT SAME-SEX MARRIAGE IS DETRIMENTAL! When questioned by one of the SCOTUS justices, the attorney for those opposing same-sex marriage (that is, those in favor of California's Prop 8 Constitutional Amendment banning same-sex marriage), that attorney could not cite one example of harm in conjunction with same-sex marriage.

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    13 years ago

Love is love, regardless of who it is directed towards.

Well-reasoned and well-stated.

 
 
 
JbBirder
Freshman Silent
link   JbBirder    13 years ago

Using this same argument, I see very little positive out come of heterosexual couples raising children.

If a same sex couple spends all the time fighting for the right to be married, the right to have/adopt a child and to raise it safely and equally in our society, it only seems like their interests and care would go above and beyond most heterosexuals who have put as much thought into procreation as a moment of passion in the back of a car or a drunken struggle in a bar's restroom.

 
 

Who is online


Snuffy


123 visitors