Nonbelievers seek to take God off currency
March 12, 2013 - The Freedom From Religion Foundation, along with 19 other plaintiffs, is suing the U.S. Treasury for stamping "In God We Trust" on currency. Honorary FFRF board member Mike Newdow is acting as legal counsel in the suit, which was filed in the U.S. District Court for the Southern District of New York on Feb. 1.
The complaint alleges that the religious verbiage is proselytizing, discriminatory and a per se establishment of monotheism in violation of the Establishment Clause.
The complaint, a tour de force of historical research, unequivocally shows that there was a purely religious purpose and intent behind putting God on our coinage. Newdow quotes representatives who voted for the addition as seeking to use the money to proselytize around the world. Rep. Herman P. Eberharter (PA) said: "[T]he American dollar travels all over the world, into every country of the world, and frequently gets behind the Iron Curtain, and if it carries this message in that way I think it would be very good. I think that is one of the most compelling reasons why we should put it on our currency. ... the principles laid down by God and the teachings of our way of life should be kept alive in the hearts and minds of our friends enslaved behind the Iron Curtain." - http://ffrf.org/news/news-releases/item/17021-atheists-seek-to-take-god-off-currency
Generally, I don't care one way or the other about the motto, except that keeping it feeds into this far-right delusion that America is somehow a Christian country that should be under the guidance of biblical laws instead of the Constitution.
For that reason alone (aside from the legal and sociological objections to this motto) I hope this lawsuit prevails.

According to the article, one of the reason for suing is because they view the words "In God We Trust" as proselytizing. In order for one to do that, they have to have an "audience", per se.
Are there REALLY people out there that are so bored, they sit around and read their currency all day long? And are they so stupid, they find the words on it so thought provoking that they are potentially faith changing?
speaking of mob based anti christian zelots: was nice to see carl bernstein taking time off his relentless pursuit of the truth behind benghazi-gate, to go on the obama network this morning and give his experience-based opinions on the Catholic Church
I would hope that most of us believe that we have bigger problems to address than what is or is not printed on our currency.
Agreed.... there has to be bigger fish to be frying up than this......!
Aw.... what a cute puppy.... does he bite?
Actually, this thread has NOTHING to do with the Catholic church and this sub-thread is way off-topic.
In God we Trust, all others we track....
HA! When Rebecca was Intel...their motto was similar: "In God we trust. All others, we monitor."
On the boats, water tight hatches often get a personal touch... Thought you would see the humor.
Who's god, which god? Does it really matter?
God is Christian? Damn! I thought he was Bahai.
LMAO!
JoAnn,
Some things to clear up.
I can't speak about Muslims, but Reform, Conservative and Reconcstructionist Rabbis do marry gay couples. Orthodox Jews don't.. nor do they have to, since anyone who was gay, would be kicked out of the community and they make us the smallest part ofJudaism.
This is true.
Damn.. I should of read down. EI said it.
Never mind.
Good One Fly!
That's a keeper!
John,
What is your station of choice?
Sun~Tzu..... Thanks for the morning laugh. What bothers me is if I had 48-1964 old Roosevelt dimes I could get me one of those $100.00 bills. That's right.....$4.70 in old 1964 Roosevelt dimes could get me one of those bills plus a little extra change to put in my pocket. Dang it.
No, clearly no one thinks about it because most people lives aren't so empty that they sit around reading their currency. Except apparently, for the guy who filed this frivolous, attention grabbing lawsuit.
And even HE doesn't know the very definition of the "offense" he's claiming in the lawsuit. Proselytizing? Really?
I'm not sure the Federal Government is even willing to take responsibility for that, anymore. But even if they are, I will switch to the barter system before I'l use currency that says: "In the Federal Government We Trust".
The American Taxpayer and a little faith from everyone who holds them. I'd say put "In Silver or Gold We Trust". This isn't a pretty picture.
I think Id go back to E Pluribus Unum. ("Out of many, one")
Not only does it speak to the American dream but it also pretty well describes what happens to the money in my pocket when I go shopping
LAMO!
Don't worry Einstenian..... I had Perrie to help me remove the dreaded blue screen. Here is the link instead.
The following chart shows the closing price of an ounce of gold on the New York Exchange every five years since the year 1800.
I think we should have "In Whiskey, Wine and Women We Trust".
There's always a demand for each one of them. The value never goes down.
Actually the price of gold is still fixed.....it's the value of the dollar that has gone done.
I understand what you are saying. Everything cost more today than it did 100 years ago, but the reason why is because the value of our means of buying it has gone down. The dollar has lost 25% of it's value over the last 5 years. The value of gold in relation to the dollar has increased. Now we could argue forever and say Gold has gone up or we could say the dollar has gone down, but I wish I had a box full of 1964 Roosevelt dimes. I could go buy a dimes worth of merchandise at the store, but I could also melt that dime and receive today for the silver and copper in it at least $2.09. So it really doesn't matter. I guess that's what they meant by saving your dollars back when it was backed up by something other than faith. Now it's buy gold or anything but the dollar.
I understand without the devaluing of the dollar the gold would be worth the same today. I still, under the current situation would rather have gold or silver for that very reason. The dollar is not backed up by either now, so the relationship between the dollar and the other two metals makes the metals the preferable to own and it doesn't look like it is going to change anytime soon. I know if the dollar goes up in value the gold goes down, but I'd put my money on the gold and silver, not to mention many other things other than the dollar.
Well with 7% interest you double your money at about every 10 years. I had known this before but the video which Mike put up I listened to several times as I was busy working and if you take the number 70 and divide it by your earned interest, it will tell you how long it takes to double the value. You can use different numbers to see how long it will take to triple and so on. It would seem a higher inflation would be somewhat the same. Some would benefit and some dealing with purchasing things in the future would not. Anyway, nice chatting with you, but I have to get it on or I'll be getting home tonight way too late. Thanks for the info. I understand a little better what you're saying.
Yes I was when gold went down and I don't think I'll have to worry about that too much in the near future. I just wish I had ESP and had bought a boat load of it back then. It would work for me today. Although gold is high now, it can go down as well. Have a good day Einsteinian.
One more thing Einsteinian I just thought of before I leave. The is just so much gold and silver as we know of available. That's why I said the gold or silver is still worth what it was initially. Now on the other hand if you want to increase the numbers of dollars, we just print a bunch more, let's just say we double the number of dollars there are. Then since they all say $1.00 on them and now we have twice as many in my example aren't those two dollars worth half as much as they were before, ignoring inflation, deflation or any other facts? Just asking. I know all the other factors inflation, deflation, time and so on come into play. I will check back when I arrive home to see if you came back here. Thanks. Are you an economist. That question is not meant to be derogatory, promise. I can learn and I know there are different philosophies about economics. Maybe I could learn from you. You brought to my attention which isn't that great these days an idea I had ignored.
After seeing if she floats, can we go looking for a shrubbery? Not too large a one either!
UGH.
All this does is stir things up. Leave everybody be, for Pete's sake.
I've not seen much that I would consider to be Anti-Catholic-- but then, I'm not catholic. Maybe I'm just oblivious to it. Anti-God, or whatever, is very common...
It is freedom OF religion. Not from. I do not approve of mixing government and religion, but there are a lot of things out there that are just traditional-- who does it hurt? Does leaving "In God We Trust", on the money hurt someone in some way?
And frankly, if they wish to fight proselytizing, come on down! Have I got a few groups to "sic" 'em on.
To be honest, I don't think the Catholic church does anything more hypocritical than the other churches...
Let's face it-- the Catholic church hid the sexual abuse of children, but don't the other faiths do the same? Maybe not "officially", but it happens, just the same.
And yes, it disgusts me-- but I think I'm honest enough to admit that other churches cover up abuse, too.
LOL, except the treasury dept doesn't OWN the money - ever look at a bill? It's a FEDERAL RESERVE NOTE. We just print the monthey for them. The Fed is NOT part of the Federal government, it is a private FOR PROFIT corporation. These people are idiots.
Good observation.
I understand what you're saying, for sure.
Maybe they are an easy target because they are more centralized?
Therefore, they get most of the negativity that is doled out?
I'm a Methodist. I don't understand a lot about the Catholic Church, am clueless about most saints, puzzled about church law, and bewildered by the rituals. Magnum was reared Catholic, but is non-practicing. If they suddenly allowed divorced people to take the sacraments, he may wish to return, but while I would attend with him, I do not ever think I could "convert".
That doesn't mean that the Catholic Church is bad-- but I just don't believe the same things.
I mean absolutely no offense to anyone. But, to me, God is just a name for The Supreme Being. To me, the word "God" is just as valid at Allah, Ra, Moneto, or (insert your name of choice)...
When I say the word, "God", I mean a Supreme Being-- the belief in a higher power. To me, all the rest is just details...
To me, I looked at it as an expression of the president's personal beliefs. So what?
If I were ever inaugurated for anything, I'd like to have something in the ceremony that reflected my personal beliefs. Not that I'd expect everyone else to participate! No sing-alongs... But, I know I would thank God for being there.
Other people may want to thank Shell Oil, or someone...
All the catholic folk I know are hard-partying people...and that's just the clergy.
Question: Who could afford it?
God may have been cheaper back then, or down in value, but egads, who could afford to buy any, or much?
Though I myself am a heathen, I am willing to defer to tradition. That is until as the author states it becomes some type of enabling tool for the religious right. The money itself is fairly much worthless.
This what always makes me daffy, I am always willing to give the road to any true believer as long as they respond in kind. To me, religion is of the private and personal, government the domain of the public and the two mix about as oil and water as the past two thousand years will bear witness. I think enough folks have died and continue to as to the never ending argument as to who's god has the bigger penis (or boobs if you prefer).
"Nonbelievers"? How about "Those who believe in the Constitution"?
I'm no atheist, but placing "God" on a government document, on currency, etc., implies a deity.
So, with all the fervor of the "well-regulated militia," etc., let's not be hypocrites when it comes to strict-constructionism.
Let's have a well-regulated implementation of the Constitution; and after all, you "tyranny" fighters must know that the most tyrannical regimes in history, used religion as a kind of hammer to divide and conquer.
Inquisitions anyone?
And those who, on the one hand want God on a nickel while simultaneously calling Obama a "Muslim," that in order to rally Christians and Jews to their divisive agenda, are thus quite the hypocrites.
It just so happens I do trust in God so I would rather it stays. BTW the reason it is there is because this country was built on Christian principals. Besides at a time when we are struggling in our economy..... do you know how much printing new money costs?!?!? Dowser is right.... we can't afford it!
Irrelevant; the Constitution is a doctrine built on reason, including the provision "Congress shall make no law respecting an establishment of religion."
Whether or not a change in the printing and minting is logistically and/or economically feasible is not a Constitutional issue.
Congress
If the issue gets to the SCOTUS, it will be interesting to see if the motto on coins/paper is ruled as Constitutional.
The "fucking leeches" are the corporate-welfare tax-dodger-job-outsourcers pimped for by the right-wing legislators who get their greatest support from the religious right.
Taking Jesus while screwing the poor, middle class and elderly is the true fucking.
"For that reason alone (aside from the legal and sociological objections to this motto) I hope this lawsuit prevails."
I agree.
"Concerned Democrat"
*snort*
Anyway, why would THE BLACK WOMAN WHO CREATED THE UNIVERSE" care one way or another if her name appears on pocket change.
Isn't that nickeling and diming such an entity?
But let's do it this way; the Tea Party/Republicans have tried to repeal the PPACA (Obamacare) more than 30 times and they're at it again, and, we all know how Republicans feel about the "47%." So what does Christian ideology say about that.
The hypocrites are those who pander to religion and religionists, who then, empowered by the votes of those to whom they pander, turn around and thwart the very legislation that manifest the religious doctrines their hypocritical base purports to believe.
Don't just declare "both sides do it." The Democrats put their money where their mouths are; they advocate health care, better wages to bring people out of poverty ALL POLITICIANS BULLSHIT THE ELECTORATE, on that count, you're right, it's a draw. BUT THE REAL BOTTOM LINE IS HOW THEY VOTE AND WHO AMONG THE MIDDLE CLASS AND POOR BENEFIT, OR ARE HURT, BY THEIR VOTES.
"Compassionate Conservative"
* snort, snort*
Good riddance as far as I'm concerned.
Bruce I think you are missing the point of our founding documents. The Forefathers of our country understood the risk presented by the rabid majority, so they tried their best to write in protections, Protections for Americans who might hold a minority position.
The goal of what they sought was a set of rules that would allow our new country to move forward under a common banner while, at at the same time, protecting the Least of these citizen, a position you might remember that the teacher called Jesus once extolled..
Any mention of any religion, by our secular government, in any of the things they do is just wrong. A thing contrary to the wishes of our founding rule writers.
Very well put. I hope this image illustrates that.
Well Bruce, now that you mention it, yes just like the things you note.
The Star-Spangled Banner became our National Anthem in 1931, which means that we were fine as a Nation for over 150 years without God being mentioned in the last verse that most people dont even know is there.
Same story for the Pledge of Allegiance. Under God wasnt added until 1954 @ which time Pres. Eisenhower stated:
Looks like that after 178 years without a need to Preach our Government suddenly felt it should be doing so.
The Ten Commandments are an ancient set of laws. The frieze in the Supreme Court building showing Moses with the stone tablets is just one of several showing law givers of the ancient world. The motif is about law givers, not the ten commandments, thats why the court has ruled that what they have is legal while monuments to just the 10 commandments on Government property are not.
As to the praying in Congress and the National Chaplin, well that goes back to before we had a Constitution and has been kept every since. Even Pres. James Madison understood that, after the Constitution was written that the National Chaplin and the services they do was Un-Constitutional, as he noted in his Detached Memoranda .
The Supreme Court has ruled that we still have these things, despite what the Constitution says, because the use of God in these Governmental settings is nothing more than old traditions of a ceremonial character or because they have lost, through rote repetition, any significant religious content.
I dont believe I did Bruce.
It was a rabid majority that put Americans of Japanese heritage into prison camps or who worked against equal rights for their fellow Americans who just happen to be different than the majority, in one way or another. Just to name a quick two examples.
Lol, Works for me.
I only suggested going back to E Pluribus Unum, because it worked well for nearly 200 years, much better I believe than the young Whiper Snapper, In God We Trust.
Actually, Islam is the largest.
LoL Dowser. I bet you do!
Amen and leave the church out of it or the mosque or anything else. I don't remember the last time I've read "In God We Trust" actually, I usually just look at the number on it and how many I have.
For my part, I see no valid reason to have mention of god on our currency. I hope it gets removed.
I fail to understand why people and their personal relationship with god needs to be continually forced down everybody's throats anyway. Let their relationships with god remain personal and not advertised everywhere. Besides, as wealthy as the Vatican and Christianity is, I hardly think they need free advertisements on our money.
What would Jesus (PBUH) do?
Or worse yet-- Mohammed!
According to the article, one of the reason for suing is because they view the words "In God We Trust" as proselytizing. In order for one to do that, they have to have an "audience", per se.
Are there REALLY people out there that are so bored, they sit around and read their currency all day long? And are they so stupid, they find the words on it so thought provoking that they are potentially faith changing?
speaking of mob based anti christian zelots: was nice to see carl bernstein taking time off his relentless pursuit of the truth behind benghazi-gate, to go on the obama network this morning and give his experience-based opinions on the Catholic Church
I would hope that most of us believe that we have bigger problems to address than what is or is not printed on our currency.
Agreed.... there has to be bigger fish to be frying up than this......!
Aw.... what a cute puppy.... does he bite?
Actually, this thread has NOTHING to do with the Catholic church and this sub-thread is way off-topic.
In God we Trust, all others we track....
HA! When Rebecca was Intel...their motto was similar: "In God we trust. All others, we monitor."
On the boats, water tight hatches often get a personal touch... Thought you would see the humor.
Who's god, which god? Does it really matter?
God is Christian? Damn! I thought he was Bahai.
LMAO!
JoAnn,
Some things to clear up.
I can't speak about Muslims, but Reform, Conservative and Reconcstructionist Rabbis do marry gay couples. Orthodox Jews don't.. nor do they have to, since anyone who was gay, would be kicked out of the community and they make us the smallest part ofJudaism.
This is true.
Damn.. I should of read down. EI said it.
Never mind.
Good One Fly!
That's a keeper!
John,
What is your station of choice?
Sun~Tzu..... Thanks for the morning laugh. What bothers me is if I had 48-1964 old Roosevelt dimes I could get me one of those $100.00 bills. That's right.....$4.70 in old 1964 Roosevelt dimes could get me one of those bills plus a little extra change to put in my pocket. Dang it.
No, clearly no one thinks about it because most people lives aren't so empty that they sit around reading their currency. Except apparently, for the guy who filed this frivolous, attention grabbing lawsuit.
And even HE doesn't know the very definition of the "offense" he's claiming in the lawsuit. Proselytizing? Really?
I'm not sure the Federal Government is even willing to take responsibility for that, anymore. But even if they are, I will switch to the barter system before I'l use currency that says: "In the Federal Government We Trust".
The American Taxpayer and a little faith from everyone who holds them. I'd say put "In Silver or Gold We Trust". This isn't a pretty picture.
I think Id go back to E Pluribus Unum. ("Out of many, one")
Not only does it speak to the American dream but it also pretty well describes what happens to the money in my pocket when I go shopping
LAMO!
Don't worry Einstenian..... I had Perrie to help me remove the dreaded blue screen. Here is the link instead.
The following chart shows the closing price of an ounce of gold on the New York Exchange every five years since the year 1800.
I think we should have "In Whiskey, Wine and Women We Trust".
There's always a demand for each one of them. The value never goes down.
Actually the price of gold is still fixed.....it's the value of the dollar that has gone done.
I understand what you are saying. Everything cost more today than it did 100 years ago, but the reason why is because the value of our means of buying it has gone down. The dollar has lost 25% of it's value over the last 5 years. The value of gold in relation to the dollar has increased. Now we could argue forever and say Gold has gone up or we could say the dollar has gone down, but I wish I had a box full of 1964 Roosevelt dimes. I could go buy a dimes worth of merchandise at the store, but I could also melt that dime and receive today for the silver and copper in it at least $2.09. So it really doesn't matter. I guess that's what they meant by saving your dollars back when it was backed up by something other than faith. Now it's buy gold or anything but the dollar.
I understand without the devaluing of the dollar the gold would be worth the same today. I still, under the current situation would rather have gold or silver for that very reason. The dollar is not backed up by either now, so the relationship between the dollar and the other two metals makes the metals the preferable to own and it doesn't look like it is going to change anytime soon. I know if the dollar goes up in value the gold goes down, but I'd put my money on the gold and silver, not to mention many other things other than the dollar.
Well with 7% interest you double your money at about every 10 years. I had known this before but the video which Mike put up I listened to several times as I was busy working and if you take the number 70 and divide it by your earned interest, it will tell you how long it takes to double the value. You can use different numbers to see how long it will take to triple and so on. It would seem a higher inflation would be somewhat the same. Some would benefit and some dealing with purchasing things in the future would not. Anyway, nice chatting with you, but I have to get it on or I'll be getting home tonight way too late. Thanks for the info. I understand a little better what you're saying.
Yes I was when gold went down and I don't think I'll have to worry about that too much in the near future. I just wish I had ESP and had bought a boat load of it back then. It would work for me today. Although gold is high now, it can go down as well. Have a good day Einsteinian.
One more thing Einsteinian I just thought of before I leave. The is just so much gold and silver as we know of available. That's why I said the gold or silver is still worth what it was initially. Now on the other hand if you want to increase the numbers of dollars, we just print a bunch more, let's just say we double the number of dollars there are. Then since they all say $1.00 on them and now we have twice as many in my example aren't those two dollars worth half as much as they were before, ignoring inflation, deflation or any other facts? Just asking. I know all the other factors inflation, deflation, time and so on come into play. I will check back when I arrive home to see if you came back here. Thanks. Are you an economist. That question is not meant to be derogatory, promise. I can learn and I know there are different philosophies about economics. Maybe I could learn from you. You brought to my attention which isn't that great these days an idea I had ignored.
After seeing if she floats, can we go looking for a shrubbery? Not too large a one either!
UGH.
All this does is stir things up. Leave everybody be, for Pete's sake.
I've not seen much that I would consider to be Anti-Catholic-- but then, I'm not catholic. Maybe I'm just oblivious to it. Anti-God, or whatever, is very common...
It is freedom OF religion. Not from. I do not approve of mixing government and religion, but there are a lot of things out there that are just traditional-- who does it hurt? Does leaving "In God We Trust", on the money hurt someone in some way?
And frankly, if they wish to fight proselytizing, come on down! Have I got a few groups to "sic" 'em on.
To be honest, I don't think the Catholic church does anything more hypocritical than the other churches...
Let's face it-- the Catholic church hid the sexual abuse of children, but don't the other faiths do the same? Maybe not "officially", but it happens, just the same.
And yes, it disgusts me-- but I think I'm honest enough to admit that other churches cover up abuse, too.
LOL, except the treasury dept doesn't OWN the money - ever look at a bill? It's a FEDERAL RESERVE NOTE. We just print the monthey for them. The Fed is NOT part of the Federal government, it is a private FOR PROFIT corporation. These people are idiots.
Good observation.
I understand what you're saying, for sure.
Maybe they are an easy target because they are more centralized?
Therefore, they get most of the negativity that is doled out?
I'm a Methodist. I don't understand a lot about the Catholic Church, am clueless about most saints, puzzled about church law, and bewildered by the rituals. Magnum was reared Catholic, but is non-practicing. If they suddenly allowed divorced people to take the sacraments, he may wish to return, but while I would attend with him, I do not ever think I could "convert".
That doesn't mean that the Catholic Church is bad-- but I just don't believe the same things.
I mean absolutely no offense to anyone. But, to me, God is just a name for The Supreme Being. To me, the word "God" is just as valid at Allah, Ra, Moneto, or (insert your name of choice)...
When I say the word, "God", I mean a Supreme Being-- the belief in a higher power. To me, all the rest is just details...
To me, I looked at it as an expression of the president's personal beliefs. So what?
If I were ever inaugurated for anything, I'd like to have something in the ceremony that reflected my personal beliefs. Not that I'd expect everyone else to participate! No sing-alongs... But, I know I would thank God for being there.
Other people may want to thank Shell Oil, or someone...
All the catholic folk I know are hard-partying people...and that's just the clergy.
Question: Who could afford it?
God may have been cheaper back then, or down in value, but egads, who could afford to buy any, or much?
Though I myself am a heathen, I am willing to defer to tradition. That is until as the author states it becomes some type of enabling tool for the religious right. The money itself is fairly much worthless.
This what always makes me daffy, I am always willing to give the road to any true believer as long as they respond in kind. To me, religion is of the private and personal, government the domain of the public and the two mix about as oil and water as the past two thousand years will bear witness. I think enough folks have died and continue to as to the never ending argument as to who's god has the bigger penis (or boobs if you prefer).
"Nonbelievers"? How about "Those who believe in the Constitution"?
I'm no atheist, but placing "God" on a government document, on currency, etc., implies a deity.
So, with all the fervor of the "well-regulated militia," etc., let's not be hypocrites when it comes to strict-constructionism.
Let's have a well-regulated implementation of the Constitution; and after all, you "tyranny" fighters must know that the most tyrannical regimes in history, used religion as a kind of hammer to divide and conquer.
Inquisitions anyone?
And those who, on the one hand want God on a nickel while simultaneously calling Obama a "Muslim," that in order to rally Christians and Jews to their divisive agenda, are thus quite the hypocrites.
It just so happens I do trust in God so I would rather it stays. BTW the reason it is there is because this country was built on Christian principals. Besides at a time when we are struggling in our economy..... do you know how much printing new money costs?!?!? Dowser is right.... we can't afford it!
Irrelevant; the Constitution is a doctrine built on reason, including the provision "Congress shall make no law respecting an establishment of religion."
Whether or not a change in the printing and minting is logistically and/or economically feasible is not a Constitutional issue.
Congress
If the issue gets to the SCOTUS, it will be interesting to see if the motto on coins/paper is ruled as Constitutional.
The "fucking leeches" are the corporate-welfare tax-dodger-job-outsourcers pimped for by the right-wing legislators who get their greatest support from the religious right.
Taking Jesus while screwing the poor, middle class and elderly is the true fucking.
"For that reason alone (aside from the legal and sociological objections to this motto) I hope this lawsuit prevails."
I agree.
"Concerned Democrat"
*snort*
Anyway, why would THE BLACK WOMAN WHO CREATED THE UNIVERSE" care one way or another if her name appears on pocket change.
Isn't that nickeling and diming such an entity?
But let's do it this way; the Tea Party/Republicans have tried to repeal the PPACA (Obamacare) more than 30 times and they're at it again, and, we all know how Republicans feel about the "47%." So what does Christian ideology say about that.
The hypocrites are those who pander to religion and religionists, who then, empowered by the votes of those to whom they pander, turn around and thwart the very legislation that manifest the religious doctrines their hypocritical base purports to believe.
Don't just declare "both sides do it." The Democrats put their money where their mouths are; they advocate health care, better wages to bring people out of poverty ALL POLITICIANS BULLSHIT THE ELECTORATE, on that count, you're right, it's a draw. BUT THE REAL BOTTOM LINE IS HOW THEY VOTE AND WHO AMONG THE MIDDLE CLASS AND POOR BENEFIT, OR ARE HURT, BY THEIR VOTES.
"Compassionate Conservative"
* snort, snort*
Good riddance as far as I'm concerned.
Bruce I think you are missing the point of our founding documents. The Forefathers of our country understood the risk presented by the rabid majority, so they tried their best to write in protections, Protections for Americans who might hold a minority position.
The goal of what they sought was a set of rules that would allow our new country to move forward under a common banner while, at at the same time, protecting the Least of these citizen, a position you might remember that the teacher called Jesus once extolled..
Any mention of any religion, by our secular government, in any of the things they do is just wrong. A thing contrary to the wishes of our founding rule writers.
Very well put. I hope this image illustrates that.
Well Bruce, now that you mention it, yes just like the things you note.
The Star-Spangled Banner became our National Anthem in 1931, which means that we were fine as a Nation for over 150 years without God being mentioned in the last verse that most people dont even know is there.
Same story for the Pledge of Allegiance. Under God wasnt added until 1954 @ which time Pres. Eisenhower stated:
Looks like that after 178 years without a need to Preach our Government suddenly felt it should be doing so.
The Ten Commandments are an ancient set of laws. The frieze in the Supreme Court building showing Moses with the stone tablets is just one of several showing law givers of the ancient world. The motif is about law givers, not the ten commandments, thats why the court has ruled that what they have is legal while monuments to just the 10 commandments on Government property are not.
As to the praying in Congress and the National Chaplin, well that goes back to before we had a Constitution and has been kept every since. Even Pres. James Madison understood that, after the Constitution was written that the National Chaplin and the services they do was Un-Constitutional, as he noted in his Detached Memoranda .
The Supreme Court has ruled that we still have these things, despite what the Constitution says, because the use of God in these Governmental settings is nothing more than old traditions of a ceremonial character or because they have lost, through rote repetition, any significant religious content.
I dont believe I did Bruce.
It was a rabid majority that put Americans of Japanese heritage into prison camps or who worked against equal rights for their fellow Americans who just happen to be different than the majority, in one way or another. Just to name a quick two examples.
Lol, Works for me.
I only suggested going back to E Pluribus Unum, because it worked well for nearly 200 years, much better I believe than the young Whiper Snapper, In God We Trust.
Actually, Islam is the largest.
LoL Dowser. I bet you do!
Amen and leave the church out of it or the mosque or anything else. I don't remember the last time I've read "In God We Trust" actually, I usually just look at the number on it and how many I have.
For my part, I see no valid reason to have mention of god on our currency. I hope it gets removed.
I fail to understand why people and their personal relationship with god needs to be continually forced down everybody's throats anyway. Let their relationships with god remain personal and not advertised everywhere. Besides, as wealthy as the Vatican and Christianity is, I hardly think they need free advertisements on our money.
What would Jesus (PBUH) do?
Or worse yet-- Mohammed!