╌>

U.S. weighs in favor of right to record police

  

Category:  News & Politics

Via:  z  •  13 years ago  •  22 comments

U.S. weighs in favor of right to record police

Note - Open and intelligent discussion encouraged, but not required. Courtesy is expected.

The Justice Department is urging a court to affirm individuals rights to record police under the First Amendment, filing a statement of interest in support of a journalist suing over his arrest while photographing Maryland officers.

In the statement filed this week in a federal court in Maryland, the Justice Department argues that not only do individuals have a First Amendment right to record officers publicly doing their duties, they also have Fourth and 14th Amendment rights protecting them from having those recordings seized without a warrant or due process. The DOJ urges the court to uphold these rights and to reject a motion to dismiss from Montgomery Co. in Garcia v. Montgomery Co. , a case that has implications for an increasing crop of litigation on the subject in the era of ubiquitous smartphones.

The United States is concerned that discretionary charges, such as disorderly conduct, loitering, disturbing the peace and resisting arrest, are all too easily used to curtail expressive conduct or retaliate against individuals for exercising their First Amendment rights. Core First Amendment conduct, such as recording a police officer performing duties on a public street, cannot be the sole basis for such charges, wrote the DOJ Civil Rights Division. - http://www.politico.com/blogs/under-the-radar/2013/03/us-weighs-in-favor-of-right-to-record-police-158828.html

Being a cop, is not an easy job, to say the least. However dangerous and stressful it is, it does not excuse a police officer from violating your civil rights. Proving that in a court of law used to be near impossible until the advent of the miniaturized camera. Now, anyone can take pictures and videos of events as they happen that can be instantaneously broadcast online, much to the chagrin of those officers who violate the law themselves.

The backlash against being recorded has resulted in a flurry of arrests of people guilty of nothing more taking pictures of officers while in the public performance of their duties....this being done as a response to court action and lawsuits being filed by citizens whom have witnessed police violations of law.

I fully support the administrations position on this issue.


Tags

jrDiscussion - desc
[]
 
Wheel
Freshman Quiet
link   Wheel    13 years ago

Before the Vine, in their infinite idiocy, decided to do away with my clippings I had a half dozen links to relevant stories on this very topic.

I will say that this topic has been in the news since the 2000 elections, AT LEAST, and it's really been heating up in the last 5 or 6 years.

 
 
 
Wheel
Freshman Quiet
link   Wheel    13 years ago

John, I think the biggest concern the police have is that more and more people are being made aware of how often they exceed their authority and engage in brutality. If they're doing their job properly then the records will show that.

As for people getting in the way, are you aware of the story that was reported just last year in which a woman was tased, beaten and arrested for taking pictures IN HER OWN YARD of her car and another car that had been involved in a high speed chase after it crashed into her car?

The police in this country are out of control and records of their behavior are very necessary because the courts, (just as corrupt as the police) will NOT take the testimony of a civilian over the word of a cop without compelling and irrefutable evidence.

In other words, police lie routinely, they lie to the public, they lie under oath, and it takes really powerful evidence to overcome their lies. Of course, if the video backs up the story, what's the problem?

Some of the cases I've heard of include the police beating and arresting a professional journalist for standing in his own yard recording a traffic stop going on across the street.

The fact is, the police are a big part of the violence problem in this country and this ruling can play a pivotal role in curbing that police violence.

 
 
 
stephanie (o'stephanie)
Freshman Silent
link   stephanie (o'stephanie)    13 years ago

Video is vital. Believe it or not but police sometimes lie in court and the video can support the innocent.

With the ACLU finally investigating the militarization of the police, I am glad that the Admin supports our right to video the police--backed up by three Amendments.

 
 
 
Wheel
Freshman Quiet
link   Wheel    13 years ago

...and their own videos will show that. I'm much more concerned with abuse by the police than I am about someone trying to 'get the shot'. As for frivolous charges, once again the video will quickly put the bunk to those too, won't it?

 
 
 
Foy 49
Freshman Silent
link   Foy 49    13 years ago
 
 
 
Wheel
Freshman Quiet
link   Wheel    13 years ago

...and a badge is not a license to be brutal either, but too many times it's treated as such.

 
 
 
Summer
Freshman Silent
link   Summer    13 years ago

I have a little brother who is a police officer. He and I have discussed this very issue in the past. He has told me that he has absolutely no problem with being video taped, as long as the person doing the taping is nointerfering with him doing his job. He's been recorded by people in the past - usually the person recording the incident stay back and allow him to do his job without a problem. He has had one time where the person doing the video recording decided to try to stop him from putting handcuffs on a person he was arresting for murder. That was the only time it bothered him - just because it could make the situation unsafe.

One time someone was videotaping an arrest he was involved in, and the person being arrested said "when I get out of jail, I'm going to track you down and kill you and your family." My brother hadn't broke any law when performing this (or any other arrest) - this video recording by a witness was used by federal prosecutors to charge the guy with even more crimes (threatening to kill someone is illegal too).

These recordings can both help both the police and others.

 
 
 
Aeonpax
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Aeonpax    13 years ago

113.gif

 
 
 
Chucky Stuart
Freshman Silent
link   Chucky Stuart    13 years ago

Here's an interesting thought. Do "stand your ground" laws apply to citizen interactions with police when the police are in the wrong? I'd be curious about that.

 
 
 
NC Slim
Freshman Silent
link   NC Slim    13 years ago

@Wheel

You are correct about NV and this same issue. One of the biggest cases happened in Massachusetts. This was the slug on the story: City of Boston pays $170,000 to settle landmark case involving man arrested for recording police with cell phone

This man did not impede the police. He was across the street.

What about the 65 year old woman who took pictures from her own front yard? A car crashed into her SUV in her driveway and then through her fence. The vehicle burst into flame. Two people were in the car, one dead. She called 911. She took pictures after the fire was out. The police arrested her. She spent the night in jail for alleged interference.

 
 
 
Wheel
Freshman Quiet
link   Wheel    13 years ago

Which could have, (and probably would have), gotten her tazed, choked out, clubbed or even shot. Happens all the time.

 
 
 
Broliver "TheSquirrel" Stagnasty
Freshman Silent
link   Broliver "TheSquirrel" Stagnasty    13 years ago

Well, since we have made it abundantly clear that any one in any kind of a public space has no reasonable right to not be photographed or recorded, it only goes to follow that a private citizen would have the same rights too.

That video where the cop tries confiscating the guys phone, that is just wrong on so many levels. The most obvious being that he was in his own garage on private property. Got a Warrant? No? Go get one.

What I find most upsetting about this whole issue is that some police seem to think that they are the law, not the enforcement branch of the law. They are the means, not the makers or arbiters. Kind of might makes right on a lesser scale, only,if that is the pervasive belief, then it acts upon a lager stage.

These people (law enforcement) are public servants, not public controllers.

 
 
 
Wheel
Freshman Quiet
link   Wheel    13 years ago

Is it just me or did that cop appear out of nowhere? He didn't walk straight over from the scene. He seemed to be trying to sneak up on the guy in the garage.

 
 
 
Broliver "TheSquirrel" Stagnasty
Freshman Silent
link   Broliver "TheSquirrel" Stagnasty    13 years ago

His car came from the right hand side of the shot. You can see it towards the end of the video. Not sure if that was one of the ones that was audible in the first part of the video.

Still does not excuse his behavior.

Get out of my garage, get off of my property, and get a warrant.

 
 

Who is online







137 visitors