╌>

Does reading the comments affect your judgment?

  

Category:  News & Politics

Via:  z  •  13 years ago  •  28 comments

Does reading the comments affect your judgment?

A study reveals the "polarizing" effects of rude comments

...Whats new about this study, however, is that it offers validation of what for many of us has been a gnawing fear: that the trolls really do hold tremendous power of persuasion. Why try to craft a well-reasoned argument, using facts and grammar, when the real way to influence how a person feels is a well-aimed Kill it before it lays eggs, or the classic Your stupid? Even if the effect is divisive, at least its substantial to the point that it can strongly affect how one feels about the original piece itself.....

Source - http://www.salon.com/2013/03/04/does_reading_the_comments_affect_your_judgment/

My first time on the web came in 1997, January. I was a sophomore in high school, using WIN 95 and the Netscape browser. I got drawn to the "Newsgroups" (USENET) early. With eight hierarchies, usenet back then hosted some 65,000 different newsgroups. It was the precursor to today's forums, like this one.

None of the groups I frequented were moderated and everything goes. Post the wrong thing and you could easily suffer the abuse of any number of dysfunctional characters. With no mod or owner to run to, either you learned how to take the abuse and dish it back or got off. Me? I'm stubborn and learned to hold my own very well.

However rough it was, it was a great place to exchange ideas and learn things, among them, how to identify and avoid the multiplicity of different types of trolls that haunted usenet.

The "newsgroups" have decreased in popularity with the advent of programming on the "web" that set up moderated discussion forums. Still the troll exists and as the article points out, many times can kill a thread by tossing in a few well aimed verbal grenades, so " Why try to craft a well-reasoned argument, using facts and grammar ?" Good point.

There are different types of trolls trying to do different things. First thing is to realize not all people whom a person sees as disagreeable are trolls and secondly, some trolls now a days are paid to deliberately push a point or ideology. Conversely, they will also deliberately try to prevent points and ideologies that run contrary to theirs. This has spawned terms such as internet "shills", "sockpuppets", "astroturfers" and "false flaggers." The traditional troll, the ones who get a kick out getting a rise out of people, are also still around.

Personally, I read the a sourced link before reading any comments. Then, after reading the comments, I decide whether to post or not. While responses using logic, well formulated opinions and proof get my attention, even if they are argumentative, a stream of bloviated vulgarities, pointless criticism and repetitive diatribes have the opposite effect.

Now for me, like I said, I can take and I can dish it back, but that's me. However, as the article mentions, rude and senseless comments turn many people off...people that might otherwise have a lot to add but are scared of being insulted.


Tags

jrDiscussion - desc
[]
 
Perrie Halpern R.A.
Professor Guide
link   Perrie Halpern R.A.    13 years ago

Hi Aeon.

Well, I guess that I am a bit well versed in the business of comments, so I was immediately drawn to your article. I would argue, that even with the most aggressive posters, they are not a troll. To me, a troll is a person who purposely and with no other purpose, tries to derail a discussion with comments like "Hey you wanna hear me fart...don't bother, this whole article is a bomb".

Everything else falls into specificcategories. You have your sensationalist poster. They are meant to draw your attention away from the topic by infusing emotion. You have your bombastic poster. They are going to beat you over the head with theiropinions and mock yours. You have the, No matter what you say, WRONG poster. And the ever popular strawman poster. But these people are not trolls. Now you might be wondering why I say that, since everyone seems to like the word troll. I have dealt with posters that would have been considered trollish by general description used in the salon article. Most are truly shocked when I admonish them. In fact, most don't even get what they have done wrong.

Now I do have some interesting characters, that do know what they are doing. It's a class all of it's own. It's called "PotStirrers. They just let it out there and what the reaction. They know what they are doing.. but then again, no one forces anyone on the internet to engage with a person, do they?

Of course sheerrudenessand nastybehavioris never conductive to a good discussion and I am sure it does turn off some people. As a mod here, my main goal is to keep those comments at a minimum. But as a indie, I find that most people on the net, don't want to have a discussion where there might be a point of enlightenment. They want to convince people of theirs POV, or at least defend their POV. So in that way.... even when bring real backup for their views, the chance of changing those folks POV is almost zip. But debating is fun, and sometimes I have walked away with a different POV.. but then again.. I am a indie.

 
 
 
Kim Lyvang
Freshman Silent
link   Kim Lyvang    13 years ago

I remember only using DOS. I also remember windows 3.1. We had discussions back then. Now it is a am right and you are wrong" world. I do not like it.

 
 
 
pat wilson
Professor Quiet
link   pat wilson    13 years ago

During my four years at Newsvine I've observed that the best way to deal with a troll is to simply ignore it. I saw this many times, a troll would toss a bomb and the others in the thread just stepped around it, and continued their debates/conversations. Before long the troll would go back under its bridge.

I do think moderation is necessary when one poster attacks another.

 
 
 
Perrie Halpern R.A.
Professor Guide
link   Perrie Halpern R.A.    13 years ago

I totally agree with you Pat on all accounts. I wouldn't want to be on an unmoderated site.

 
 
 
Aeonpax
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Aeonpax    13 years ago

Perrie

You might get a kick out of this link: Flame Warriors

 
 
 
Dowser
Sophomore Silent
link   Dowser    13 years ago

Reading comments often gives me many different points of view that I need to think of, but don't often come up with, on my own. I'd say that the comments sometimes helps me to hone my opinion, or think of things that I normally wouldn't think of.

But, when someone is just rude and nasty, I could care less. Even if they have a good point, the point is lost in the hatefulness, and I have a tendency to discount the opinion, just because it is delivered poorly.

Most of the time, I, like many others here, I follow my heart and personal experience. Some things, i don't have the experience to have a real opinion!

Take care! Great article! Smile.gif

 
 
 
pat wilson
Professor Quiet
link   pat wilson    13 years ago

Some writers do attract a virulent strain of trolls, you aren't the only one.. Did you try ignoring them?

 
 
 
pat wilson
Professor Quiet
link   pat wilson    13 years ago

Thank you Perrie.

BTW I love the spell check here, it's much "smarter" than the other placeSmile.gif

 
 
 
Miss_Construed
Freshman Silent
link   Miss_Construed    13 years ago

I dont step in if the subject is already waist high in shit (hundreds of OMG comments already)... I do like reading the "good" point and counterpoint arguments to give me things to think about. I've alwaysthought that if you can't argue for both sides of an argument, you really dont understand it enough to argue about it in the first place.... or you are too fanatical about it to do it much good in a normal set of circumstances anyway.

Just my personal opinion on the matter.

 
 
 
Dowser
Sophomore Silent
link   Dowser    13 years ago

That is very interesting, Miss-Diagnosed! I like to see as many sides of a question as possible...

That makes sense! Not that I can do it, but that makes a lot of sense... Smile.gif

 
 
 
MsAubrey (aka Ahyoka)
Junior Participates
link   MsAubrey (aka Ahyoka)    13 years ago

NO. Reading the comments do not waiver my judgement. I write out a response far before I read comments.

 
 
 
MsAubrey (aka Ahyoka)
Junior Participates
link   MsAubrey (aka Ahyoka)    13 years ago

Pot Stirrers are also called Spoons where I work.Grin.gif

I highly enjoy philosophical debate, but I try to stick to debating with those that I have found over time won't stoop to ad hominem in the first place.

 
 
 
Strangerthanfiction
Freshman Silent
link   Strangerthanfiction    13 years ago

It usually doesn't change my opinion but it may affect if I comment or not. If it has just turned into a mudslinging contest or like usually happens on NV that no matter what the story is it's President Obama's fault I just stop reading comments and go to another article. I do like a witty repartee between different opinions and some of the so called "trolls" make me laugh. 24.gif

 
 
 
Aeonpax
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Aeonpax    13 years ago

Too often, there is no right or wrong on a lot of political issues. In a debate type discussion, the best you can say is that one person presents a stronger case than the other.

 
 
 
luther28
Sophomore Silent
link   luther28    13 years ago

I would not say they affect my judgement.A rude or disparaging comment may cause me to think poorly of the writer, while a well thought out one may give me pause to re-think a particular position I may hold.

If the point must be made with rudeness, then it is most likely a point not worth making, in my opinion anyway.

 
 
 
Merleliz
Freshman Silent
link   Merleliz    13 years ago

A dear and close friend of mine once told me "You always think your way is the right way!"

To which I could only respond..."Well, honey, if I thought my way was wrong I wouldn't be doing it that way, now would I?"

On one occasion, I had my pro-choice beliefs challenged by a young man who did open my eyes to the fact that there are many men who are devastated by their partner choosing abortion...somehow I had never considered that before. I do now sympathize more with their helplessness in being unable to alter the outcome, when they may honestly and sincerely want a child of their own...where previously I hadn't given their emotional investment in the pregnancy a second thought.

It didn't change my opinion on abortion...I am still pro-choice, because I don't feel any child should be born without parents that want, love and are able to provide decent care for them...but it did shock me to realize that I had been totally inconsiderate of their views...I hadn't in fact, considered them at all.

I have learned more about how others feel when they post a considered and reasonable opinion of their own, and I don't mind anecdotal posts, because they often provide more insight into "why" a person feels the way they do than a regurgitated talking point from the media. Trolls I just ignore...and to me a troll is anyone who posts nothing but ad hominen attacks and insults against either the poster or the opposing ideology.

 
 
 
Pat N2
Freshman Silent
link   Pat N2    13 years ago

Unless you are plagued by a "Stalking Troll

Wow. Does THAT bring back memories! Smile.gif

My favorite "stalking trolls" were the ones that would publically announce to the world: "I'm putting you on ignore, dammit!"...forget they made that little declaration and two days later, start nipping at your heels on damn near every article you post in.

Ahhhh the good ol' days. LOL.

It was that scenario that inspired me to write one of my most popular articles over there entitled: "5 Surefire Ways To Look Like A Newsvine Loon".

 
 
 
Pat N2
Freshman Silent
link   Pat N2    13 years ago

Typically, I won't even click on an article unless the title grabs me and suggests it might be something I'm passionate about.

Since I'm passionate about the subject matter to begin with, very little has the potential to sway me from my opinion on the topic and bombastic comments from others sure aren't going to do the trick. In fact, they will just make me dig my heels in further.

 
 
 
Moonchild63
Freshman Silent
link   Moonchild63    13 years ago

Thanks Aeon being new to this forum (in general not just NT) I have not always understood the lingo and now the whole troll etc. has been explained, I saw sockpuppet the other day - thought it had to be something derogatory - now I know.

I personally read what interest me & sometimes because I can not believe that.....

I like you also think that if you can "dish it" you should be able to "take it" & if you do, say or act upon something - then you should OWN IT! I am going to continue to be me & do the Internet thing the way it suits me - simply because ULTIMATELY, I am responsible & will be accountable for ME! Edgar Guest has a wonderful poem called "MYSELF" "...so whatever happens, I want to be SELF-RESPECTING and CONSCIENCE FREE."

LOL 24.gif when I first heard or was called a "troll," I was offended because -I thought they meant the fictional creature that lives under bridges and then I saw it used more & more - so I looked it up & it was not as bad, yet the implication couldn't have been more wrong - I do not have an investment (as some seemingly do!) in these conversation, articles, seeds etc. (even when I write them) - I put them out there and although I own my opinions, position or comment -it is done & what's done is done! I like a good commentator should will monitor my articles, seeds and sometimes comments when alerted that someone has responded, but they are not my LIFE! Others will do the same, yet I have no respect for those who bully or try through justifcation or stubborn not own their positions or not be flexable re: same like the mantra: OBAMA is the devil.......

The different kinds of posters etc. is also subjectively perjorative asnew-bies or the literal peoplelike me aren't "trolling" for anything other than what is out there to be seen or commented on and if we stop to graze, post, write or comment - it is simply because something caught our eye, ear, attention or passion& isn't that what this is suppose to be about?

Again thanks for the lingo lesson and the enlightenment & your article was most AWESOME @ least speaking soley for myself devoid of any trolling for anything!113.gif

 
 
 
Polly Cooper
Freshman Silent
link   Polly Cooper    13 years ago

Reading the comments affect my judgment to the extent that I will judge the poster. Anybody who assumes they know me, my position on something, my political affiliation, etc having never met me or read any of my comments annoys the hell out of me. And when they tell me I am lying, again without knowing me, it does make me angry. I am opinionated, but willing to change my thinking when given facts. When insulted for no reason, I will go on the attack. Sorry, but that's the way I roll.

 
 
 
Miss_Construed
Freshman Silent
link   Miss_Construed    13 years ago

I'm going out a limb here... and this isnt an insult, but... in judging the poster based on a few comments... arent you essentially doing to others what you hate to have done to yourself? That is, assuming you know them better than they know themselves through a comment?

Not saying that everyone doesn't do it. Not blaming you for doing it... just curious about your take on it.

BTW... I remember you from NV andI'm pretty sureyou were on my friend list. I think (I remember anyway) that I liked you because you werent afraid to test your beliefs by thinking about things differently, but you stood up for your beliefs regardless.

 
 
 
Polly Cooper
Freshman Silent
link   Polly Cooper    13 years ago

Hi Miss Diagnosed. Yes, you were on my friend's list and hope you will be again.

To clarify, I judge the poster based on whether their comments to others were polite, civil, on topic, etc. When I see someone post "You're a Lying A$$hole and a Jerk" it's pretty certain that they aren't going to be spending a lot of time in civil debate. And when it is directed at me by someone I don't know, I have a tendency to go Postal.

 
 
 
Kara Shalee
Freshman Silent
link   Kara Shalee    13 years ago

BTW I love the spell check here, it's much "smarter" than the other place

And either you are much smarter than I am (probably so) or this is a "gotcha" moment that I'm too dumb to pick up on. I've never been able to find the spellchecker here............oh my!!

Nonetheless, I agree with you about things being smarter than the other place :)

 
 
 
Kara Shalee
Freshman Silent
link   Kara Shalee    13 years ago

So that was the start of my issues with Sally.

My opinion is that she may be in over her head, Bruce. And that would be a very very mild way of putting it. I could put in in other ways, and I'd really like to, and maybe I will. I was just kind of blown away when I read on another discussion here today (can't remember where cause I'm rather debilitated, lol) that a viner was outright BANNED without any warning, suspensions, or anything. WOW, huh?

 
 
 
Pedro
Professor Quiet
link   Pedro    13 years ago

Spoon is actually what you do with your significant other after a long day of stirring the pot.

 
 
 
Disturbed Librarian
Freshman Silent
link   Disturbed Librarian    13 years ago

I like your definition best and so does my significant other (husband).

 
 
 
Pedro
Professor Quiet
link   Pedro    13 years ago

For me, reading the comments will typically determine what direction I'm going to take with my own comments. I'm more than capable of being any of those archetypes described by Perrie on page one of this article. Other than that, my own posting style is determined by the mood I'm in.

I dont however, let the tone or disposition of an article determine whether I participate or not. That also is strictly determined by my moods as well.

 
 
 
Pedro
Professor Quiet
link   Pedro    13 years ago

Lol, what can I say.....I'm a man of the people. :)

 
 

Who is online









134 visitors