Why Did 138 House Reps Vote No to Extending the Violence Against Women Act?
There's a number of reasons 183 political nit-wits voted against reauthorizing the VAWA, which has always been reauthorized,
almost entirely without opposition, since it was first passed in 1994.
In the first place there is a "new GOP" in Washington. The Republicans' shift to the farther-to-the-Right-than-normal position, is doing them more harm than good. These people think that allegiance to a philosophy is more important than allegiance to their constituents.
The problems they have with the VAWA are mostly about the new provisions added by Vermont Sen. Pat Leahy, calling for the expansion of the law to assure protections for gays, lesbians and transgender people and the authority for tribal courts to prosecute non-Indians for domestic violence on reservations. He also called for an increase in the number of visas allowed for illegal immigrants who are victims of abuse, and those who help police prosecute the offenders.
For many Right Wingers the very mention of the word "Gay" sends shivers up their spines, so to ask them to vote for something that will offer gays protection is just too much for them. Same for illegal immigrants, the Right only wants one thing for illegal immigrants ...... deportation, all 11 million of them.
This is the way they think function (thinking is not one of their strong points) and no amount of common sense or enlightenment is ever going to change their views.
As for expanding the authority of the reservation courts, I don't understand the reason for not allowing crimes committed on reservations by non-Indians to be tried on the reservations. I thought crimes are supposed to be prosecuted in the jurisdiction where they are committed. I mean, it would be like saying if an Indian rapes a woman off the reservation, they should be sent back to the reservation to be prosecuted (?!). But all that is just too much thinking for most Right Wingnuts.
The new provisions that Leahy put in are practical common sense adjustments to the law that reflect the conventional wisdom of the times. Opposition to them reflects the conventional non-wisdom of the Right Wing.
Personally I'm glad to see these shallow thinking, narrow minded people put their philosophy ahead of practical application of the law. It assures me that we will be able to keep the Republicans out of the White House for another decade or two.
Tags
Who is online
134 visitors

For this particular woman, I'm glad they did. Violence against ANYONE is a bad thing and should be prosecuted to the fullest extent of the law. There should be no "special" laws based solely on the fact that the victim pee's sitting down.
Cantor's snark wasn't necessary....I'll grant you that. But I refuse to be put into some special class that implies I am more helpless than a man.
Frankly, I'm surprised that the people who demand everything be equal between men and women, also demand there be special laws for women.
Oooo! I have a "official" disability! I am female! And I'm short! (short people are oppressed. We can't reach the top shelves in stores or see the top of the refrigerator. That's discrimination)
But alas, I'm not a liberal.
So I wouldn't qualify for the 'Bestest People Act'.
Maybe the 'More Betterer People Act"?
Pat, I have seen the top of the refrigerator. You're not missing a thing.
It's comments like this that make me really wish had a "like" button.
That's not fair. We short people never get to experience that joy.
I'm starting a new "Act", dammit. I'm calling it the: "Equal Rights ForThe Vertically Challenged Act".
HA! Those are great! Now THAT is an act I can get behind! I don't need one that gives me special attention because I have ovaries.
I want my Obama-stool, dammit.
Ewww. Wait. That didn't come out right. Our entire economy is essentially "Obama stool" right now.
Why? Because they are stupid.
Gotta disagree, Dowser. If the "Equal Rights for Women" advocates truly want equal rights...then they need to make it all equal and not make laws based on gender.
A good exampleis the recent: "Women should be allowed to have an MOS is the service wherein their main duty is to kill, just like their male counterparts".
If that's the direction people want to go, then they need to quit pretending like women are so helpless, they need "special" laws regarding violence.
How they can say: "Women are perfectly capable of being killing machines" one minute and "women need special laws based on their gender" the next, is really confusing to me and should be to anyone who is truly and consistently in favor of equaliy.
Query:
How do you feel about the Child Protection Act?
Hold on here. I have fought prejudice against women in a male working environment all my working life-- 30 years as a geologist. The law is NEEDED, especially the provisions about tribal lands being able to arrest and try people that come on the reservation and rape women. Speaking of talking out of both sides of their faces-- if the government wishes to recognize the sovereignty (thank God for spell check), of the Native Americans, then quit allowing non-reservation rapists to have diplomatic immunity on a reservation. The Native Americans should be able to police their own reservation, including trying and convicting criminals.
I am looking at my very own REALITY-- if a law helps women to gain equality, then I'm all for it. It may take a law to finally get the equality that I've struggled for over the past 30 years. I've heard this BS all my working life, and I'm SICK of it.
I went to a retirement party yesterday for the office manager, a woman. It was an engineering firm, and over 40 people were there. Of that number, there were 4 women who weren't wives, and two of those 4 were secretaries.
YOU DAMN STRAIGHT there should be absolutely no question that domestic violence against women OR men should be fully prosecuted to the letter of the law. Back when I was young, and starting out, my ex threatened to kill me. I went to the police, and they said I could get a restraining order, but it would take more than a threat to get one. Meaning he either had to kill me, or beat me to a pulp before I could get even a minor restraining order against him. Maybe things are different now, and maybe they're not.
I think this law is needed, and I think this ultra conservative BS about women's place is in the home, walking two steps behind her Lord and Master is utterly without any merit. If it takes an official law to get it done, then do it. It shouldn't TAKE an official law to do it-- it shouldn't be needed. But It Is.
Furthermore, you can't paint all women with a broad brush, just based on their gender. I would not be at all suited to serve in the military, and wouldn't have, even when I was young and strong. That wouldn't be what I was good at. But for those who wish to serve in that way, they should have the freedom to make that choice-- no matter their gender.
We had to outlaw slavery once, too. Another thing that shouldn't have required a law to get it done. Our society is, hopefully, learning and growing and developing new sensibilities. Sometimes, it requires laws to get the job done.
It is my opinion, which is also very valuable, that anyone that would vote against this is STUPID. They are, essentially, saying that 50% of their voters are not worth protecting. And to them, I say, Frick them and the horse they rode in on.
And the failure to protect citizens that cannot protect themselves against those that would infringe upon their constitutional rights is anarchy.
The choice is crystal clear.... either you protect all, or you are happy with saying to a segment of our citizens... "Tought-Titty, your rights to live without fear of attack are less than the rights of those that would attack you."
This is the old libertarian circle jerk saying that we don't need laws and regulations, because everyone promises to be on good behavior because if they are, we won't have to have laws and regulations.
And with all due respect, I currently work in a male dominated industry and have for the last (almost) 2 decades. Specialized Transportation. I have never been accosted by a male. I believe if I were, I wouldn't be so defenseless as to handle the situation. That said, my anecdotal evidence is no more "proof" of a law being needed or not needed than yours is.
Fine. I'm willing to compromise. Are you? Have it apply to the tribal lands only. If we want to say violence against a female on tribal lands is somehow more horrible than violence against men on tribal lands, so be it. But don't make a sweeping one size fits all law about violence being "more bad" against women with one breath and then be saying: "It's OK if we desensitize our females in the military to the point that they are perfectly OK with pointing a machine gun at another human being and pulling the trigger"...in another breath.
Children are unable to defend themselves against adults and no one is pushing for "equal rights" between child and adult. Therefore, I'm all for it.
I really do not understand why people elected in a democratic process to represent them and their HUMAN needs as soon as they get inside I-495 forget about those who elected them and walk around with their hands out waiting for corporate $$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$ to fall into them. There is good reason to call the Capital building "The House of Reprehensibles" After all "Congress" is certainly living up to the alternate meaning of the word (a group of Great Apes).
WTF Pat.... The goal of the military is to train people to be violent to someone else if need be. Controlled violence, but violence none the less.
Completely two different animals.
Today's conservative/GOP represents the last dying gasp of the anachronistic WASP mentality. Since the party was taken over by the far religious right, they live in a state of perpetual fear...fear of blacks, fear of Latinos, fear of gays, fear of independent women, fear of Islam; fear of anything or anyone that is not White, Anglo-Saxon, Protestant.
Unfortunately, they will not go gentle in that night but as their numbers decrease, they will leave a wake of damage and destruction the likes that no war has ever visited on this great nation.
This too shall pass but for the moment, vigilant people must work at limiting their ruination.
Well, Pat, you're fortunate. I'm not sure what Special Transportation is, exactly. But, I can tell you that the threat of sexual assault has been prevalent to me through my career. And, the circumstances of my job are a rather conducive environment. Yeah, I'm dressed in so many layers drilling outside in the winter, just peeling all that off would usually deter all but the most determined sexual assault-- but sexual assault is about control and violence. Not sex.
You certainly have the right to your opinion, but I, too, have a right to MY opinion, based on my experiences. Come with me sometime, to a deep mine in Eastern KY, and talk with some of the women miners, and what they go through. You've never stood at a mine adit holding your equipment in hand, and had someone tell you that if you went in, you wouldn't be coming out. I have.
I'm not the one that brought in the military-- which to me, is a separate and distinct issue. I think that all sexual assaults, whether they be perpetrated on men or women, should be prosecuted to the fullest extent of the law. And no, that doesn't always happen.
What about they poor girl that was raped at a high school party last year? She was threatened with jail because she named her attackers on Facebook-- remember? That took place right here in Louisville, my hometown, and is indicative of at least some of the problem, and why this law is needed.
So, you're saying that a woman "chooses" to be raped, and therefore, deserves no special protection?
HUH?
No joke. I'd vote this comment up a million times if I could.
You couldn't hit the nail on the head any more squarely if you tried AP.....
Applause.....great comment AP
No, I was asking if that is what you meant. And you notice the HUH? That meant that I couldn't believe what it sounded like... Giving you the benefit of the doubt.
And about forcing my opinion down your throat, that, too, is a two way street. I respect your opinion, I just don't happen to agree with it, and have tried to express why. Period.
You don't have to agree with it.
Egilman,
I see Dowser asking you for clarification of yourpositions not forcing herpositiondown your throat hence the question mark at the end of her query.
Now as to my query, the reason I ask is because of something that both woman and children have in common. Physical strength. I know that I have my limitations if a man attacks me. Most woman do. In our physical being, we are not equal in strength. Rape of anyone child or adult is disgusting. It is meant to behumiliating.I would say the same thing if a straight guy got jonny mopped.
That is the only issue that I care about here.
Sexualharassmenton the job, yeah I've had it. You got to be tough. But is that right? Should I have to deal with that, just because of my gender? I would say no. But then again, I would say the same thing about age discrimination, which is a sexless offense.
I hope there are some moderates in there, somewhere...
We try to fight against injustice, too!
And it is because of free will that there will always be greed. No amount of disciplining or education or laws or regulations will stop one of the most powerful human motivators. Those that willfully do wrong will not be stopped by any of the aforementioned.
What regulations and laws can do is is set a measure for moral and ethical behavior while providing an engine to collect from the perpetrators of a crime a quantity of measured punishment.
The libertarian world has no counterbalance to greed, thus no real answer on how to protect citizens. And without laws and regulations, Libertarianism does not provide any way to right a wrong.
Good luck writing legislation to make that into viable sentencing option.
Not that I'm disagreeing, but that smacks of Sharia law there does it not?
I'm sorry that I wasn't more clear! I couldn't believe that is what you meant!
And eunochs is a thought...
But it won't solve the control/violence issue. Then, instead of raping someone themselves, they'll just use an implement. Or some other horrendous way of controlling their victims...
Rape is not about sex, it is about control. It's about violence and being in control of a situation against someone who is unable to defend themselves. Sexual assault is the same thing. It's about taking advantage or control over the other person's personal space. Invading them with the tools at the perpetrator's immediate disposal.
And even the threat of rape is frightening-- especially to someone that just wants to do their job.
I'd like to know who took the poll to find out that NAMBLA was a democrat constituency. Talking about throwing junk out there.
I hate partisan stuff like that.
Amen to that!
I was a freak in the '60's. Main stream called us hippies. I am a staunch supporter of feminism, as my wife found out. After we got engaged she told me about her rape by 6 guys (bikers). I fell in love with her even more. That she would trust me after that inhumane attack made her even more beautiful.
After all that I introduced her to friends I had in the LGBT society. She accepted them all. A great woman to be proud of. This May it will be 40 years of marriage.
We are all equal and should be treated as such.
Bravo, Kim!
Bravo Kim...An early ''Happy Anniversity'' to you and your wife.
Unfortunetly Kim, some feel they are more equal then others, as proven by the 138 that voted against this act.
I think that the piece of paper with ink on it is is just as valid as all the other pieces of paper with ink on them-- If it were a law, it may be easier to prosecute those cases. or one more thing to charge them with. Or enable the police to stop domestic violence, rather than just let it go because the woman won't/can't press charges.
I wish I had an answer, too. I wish I could wave a wand and it would all go away. But, I don't think there are any easy answers, and I don't think this law will solve everything, but it is a step in the right direction. It's a start. It may afford protection to those who can't protect themselves. Maybe all it says is that officially, we're not going to tolerate domestic violence any more, nor sexual battery, or something.
Hope you have a great day! Take care and be careful out there...
Robert - check this link -
Perhaps, I can help because this was nothing but political posturing and grandstanding "Oh my, so and so voted against protecting women!" to be used in the upcoming 2014 election... It was just to continue the false narrative of the supposed War on Women by the Pubs, and even the Washington Post can admit that.
This bill was first proposed in the Senate, passed and sent to the House. House Republicans had proposed a straight-up reauthorization of the existing (without all the new terms, and nuances) Violence Against Women Act. But that vote failed. The Senate version wanted something far more reaching:
For example with this new bill from the Senate, passed by the House, expands the definition of domestic violence with this bill which now includes causing emotional distress or using unpleasant speech. Really?? Yes, really. It's stupid and redundant. Do we really need ANOTHER layer of laws on top of existing ones? Who gets to decide that? And what of free speech?
Secondly, it includes the "underserved" - that is according to their loose definition -women, men, transgendered, bisexual, and requires ALL agencies, faith based and others, to provide a full range of services for them...now, how will that be possible, in say, a faith based woman's shelter without causing great expense to the very ones who are trying to help, say specifically, women who have been victims and rightly need these important and vital services? The very places that are trying to help may be forced to close.
Thirdly, it givestribal Indian authorities jurisdiction over non-Indians accused of domestic violence within the borders of an Indian reservation (keep off the Indian reservation, folks), which undermines your constitutional rights.
Fourthly, and this also goes to one as well, it means that women, men and those who are... whatever, who "claim" domestic violence - be it physical, verbal, or just "unpleasant speech" (and again, who decides what that is?)temporary visas who are here illegally.
You can read the bil in its entirety here -
Again, this bill is ridiculous. Why not just reauthorize what they already had? because they didn't want to- they wanted this grandstanding ploy of a bill to be used as a billy club.
To be used a bully club the next election - even the Washington Post gets that.
Sounds like the Washington Post has it pegged!
Completely two different animals.
I want you to sit here, and in writing, state unequivocally, that a soldier assigned to an 11B MOS (Infantry) is not (a) desensitized regarding the abiliy to pull the trigger on another human being and (b) doesn't have the main responsibility of killing.
"Specilized Transportation". It's a niche within trucking. Not the dry van freight you see going down the road. Wind tower blades. Huge crane pieces. The type of stuff that needs a police escort and has 13-19 axles.
Yeah. There was one poor dude that was almost hung out to dry in my office.
You know how most offices have the "cool" guy and the "dork"? We had a situation where I overheard the cool guy say to our receptionist one casual Friday: "Whoa Brenda! Lookin' hot today!" She blushed and said: "Oh, it's just these new jeans." He said: "You certainly do have fiiiine genes. Drink after work?" She said "sure".
Later on that day, the "dork" said to her: "You look pretty today, Brenda. Nice outfit". She got up from her desk in a huff, marched straight to the VP of HR and filed a sexual harassment claim.
And you know what? The VP of HR bit. And did what I believe you would have done in that situation because you weren't privvy to either actual event. And I don't blame you for that. Or the VP of HR. She took Brenda's word for it and I got to spend time explaining the whole thing in court.
Women are not te saints in the office that everyone seems to think they are. Especially not in male dominated work environments.
But back to the original issue. Why is violence against a woman worse than violence against a man? How 'bout we apply just as stringent penalties to someone who is violent to a 50 year old male?
Do men "choose" to be beaten and carjacked? Why should their attacker not face the same punishment as the attacker of a female?
Aftger catching up on the comments in this thread, I can only conclude that there are some here that think women are so helpless, that they need special laws made for them regarding crimes committed against them. That violence against this equal gender is somehow worse than violence against a male.
Hmm. I thought the two were supposed to be treated equally. I guess there is a segment of women in society that simply can' handle bein equal in ALL regards.
So I'm willing to compromise. To these women who apparently need some sort of special protection from violence and since violence against this segment of females is worse than violence against their male counterparts, then they are free to be covered under some "Act" drawn up in Washington.
In doing so, they are relinquishing their desired "equality", though. Equality is not just about "I can be a fireman or an infantryman or linebacker in pro-football if I wanna!". It's about equal responsibility, accountability and laws, too.
Under the Major Crines Act of 1885 and amended in 1976, the Feds are responsible for jurisdiction over murder, manslaughter, kidnapping, rape, felony child abuse, robbery, incest, sexual abuse of a minor and assault with a dangerous weapon. In Oliphant v. Suquamish Indian Tribe (1978), SCOTUS said that "Indian tribes may not prosecute non-Indians without the express consent of Congress." In Duro v. Reina (1990), SCOTUS said "Indian tribes lacked the inherent authority to prosecute nonmember Indians or non-Indians committing crimes on a reservation." without the express consent of Congress.
70% of violent crimes against reservation Indians are committed by non-Indians (60 percent by whites and 10 percent by other racial groups). Indian tribes are dependent on state and federal officials to prosecute the majority of lawbreakers and those officials have been doing a pi$$poor job of doing so. DOJ agrees that they are only prosecuting 12% - if that much - of violent crimes that occur on reservations. Their reasons? No money, no manpower, no support.
In July, 2010, Obama signed the Tribal Law and Order Act which contains 10 provisions which can/will help tribes, but nowhere in the Act does it contain any provision of handling major crimes perpetrated against Indians by non-Indians.
This Act, VAWA, contains just one of the 13 major crimes that tribes do not have the inherent sovereign authority to enforce because "congress hasn't given them that authority." This Act gives them the authority to arrest, retain/detain, try and punish, in accordance with the Civil Rights Act and the Indian Civil Rights Act (yes, we have a "special" Civil Rights Act of our own and it's not the same as yours), i.e. a fair and speedy trial with no discrimination. Anyone convicted by a tribal court will have the ability to appeal to a state/Fed court (depending on whether you're in a PL-280 state or not) if they feel they have been unjustly/discriminately handled.
That's what Cantor and his 136 buds are afraid of - the Indians actually being able to "Self-Determine" their rights in accorance with treaties and their inherent sovereign jurisdiction.
I agree wholeheartedly. I'm actually kind of insulted that there are people that seem to think that if I'm physically attacked, the criminal should get a harsher sentence than he would if he physically attacked a male, based solely on the fact that I have two X chromosomes.
It's time for the "equality" crowd to quit preaching the ideology of it, and start addressing the reality of it.
A question I hear is - "and what makes you special?" My answer is quite simply - the U. S. Constitution that states that all men are created equal. Too bad our Congressional "Leaders" forgot Constitutional Law 101.
Perrie,
While I'm not a democrat, I too would like to know the tie-in between Nambla and the democratic party.
I did look around for some proof but all I found was evidence by inference. For example, one article stated " In the 2001 San Francisco Gay Pride parade, Nancy Pelosi walked along side of the NAMBLA advocate, ... " and that's not proof.
Then there was the Obama appointee who allegedly has ties to nambla but as it turns out, not quite exactly.
Maybe I'm alone here when it comes to proof but if the democrats do indeed have ties to that putrid organization, they need to be held accountable for it and it will take more than just anecdotal information for that.
I'll admit it's partisan and your replies reflect what appears to be your sincere opinions. Nonetheless, I am entitled to voice my opinions too. Sorry you don't like mine, but as they say; Que sera, sera.
That's your opinion again. It's wrong, in error and displays an ignorance of reality I just haven't seen in awhile...congratulations.
You sorta remind me of a short phrase from the Shakespearean play, Julius Caesar when Caesar says; "The cause is in my will" which was his arrogant way of saying he owed no one an explanation. Mind you, it was about this time, Caesar saw himself as a god and not even the Roman Senate could question him.
For some odd reason, you feel your opinions should be elevated to some kind of untouchable status and are beyond question and reproach. You are only deluding yourself. Like all tin gods, you make the big mistake that there is no one who will challenge your prevarications, your equivocations and to but it bluntly, your illusions.
For people like you, the only refuge from a reality you disagree with, is your opinionated illusions. You poor people have mistaken shadows for substance for so long, the two have become indistinguishable. You really cannot see your errors and that's scary.
That's a hard nut to crack, not that I'm going to even try, but I will call you out every time you present a falsehood as a fact or every time you feel your opinions need not be proven because it's you who is saying them.
Peace.
Your comment got way to personal. It's not an excuse for Mike's followup but I can see how it could escalate. Since you are a new member, I am leaving this unedited. Next time there will be a lot of purple pen for personal remarks made.
..and don't forget that if you suggest to the same people that 18 year old girls should now have to register for selective service since combat roles are open to them, the "equality" people raise a fit.
Yep. Men had access to shovelfuls of free condoms prior to all of that nonsense. So did women. THAT was equal.
It's funny. When I ask someone to tell me who had more women in their Cabinet, Bushor Obama? They go eerily silent. I wonder whyits soo hard for Obama to find equally qualified women?
Absolutely amazing how an actual discussion dealing with the passage of the act doesn't even get addressed - guess when you talk of the group that is hardest hit, unless you're part of that group, well, "It ain't me", eh?
....So says the guy who feels the need to chastise me for responding to a different article, claiming I wasn't addressing what HE was talking about when I wasn't even responding to him.
Also, just as a side note, it was HW Bush that signed the ADA. July 26th, 1990.
This is a classic example of liberals taking credit for something if they had the idea for it, but didn't sign it into law. Funny thing, they don't give credit to republicans if the reverse is true and the republicans came up with an idea but a Dem signed it into law. In that case, they also give credit to the Dem.
Go figure.
''keep off Indian reservations folks''....Great idea, except that 43 percent that live or work on reservations are white...Let's get them off. Or do you mean that Indians are notcapable of conducting a fair trail for a non Indian? The old stereotype of us being savages. Itdoes not undermine your constitutional rights Elmer.
If you plan on coming on to the rez to committ rape or domestic abuse, then your right, stay the hell off, because now you will be subject to being arrested and tried by a Tribal Court.
Perhaps we should reverse the law and let us Indians go off rez and rape, but the law doesn't pertain to us, sowe arescot free to do it.
Think about that Elmer.
So women are "weak"?
Now there's the insult of the day.
forgot the /s tag.
Yes, where it is conducted Robert and by whom, and that Tribal Policecan arrest the perp.The if part has been the problem in the past, that's why the VAWA addressed it. (Sigh)
I think that you should review the ''Major Crimes Act'' Robert, to see what the fed's are responsible to cover on the rez....
Mike -
As an alternative to Johns suggested reading material, might I suggest: "The Power of a Positive No".
I think you'll find it more realistic and containing less pandering.
I would have voted against as well. Special treatment is special treatment. You want everything to be equal, then just friggin enforce the laws on the books. Sorry, guys, but today's women don't need to be coddled and treated like helpless fainting damsels in distress.
Robert - check out the Trial and Order Act - it's updated a lot of what you've posted - such as retention/jail for up to five years.
VAMA only gives tribes jurisdiction over non-Indians in rape cases - nothing else. Congress refuses/has refused to allow Indians to try non-Indians - see Oliphant v. Suquamish Indian Tribe, Dura v. Reina, Lara v. United States.
Robertmuch of whatyou posted has been updated. Tribal Law and Order act. Under VAWA rape/sexual assualt is the only thing covered, period.
As for Leahy living on ancient tribal lands, you do as well...
All due respect, kavika, my friend, but do you think the VAWA is the appropriate law to deal with tribal concerns? Perhaps a law dealing with tribal issues is a better solution
I don't know of any tie. Hence my remark.
As long as there are glass ceilings, religionist dogmas that want women to be subservient to men and politicians who pander to those working to maintain such inequities, WOMEN NEED LAWS TO ATTAIN EQUAL MANY THINGS.
So sadly, probably true.
LOL. Thanks for the laugh.
Sadly, your comment has no basis in reality
Pat N.,
As I said in the article, Right Wingers don't think to well, and your are clearly a Right Winger. The law is not designed to put women is a "special class", the law is designed to take women out of a special class.
If you don't recognize that there is a need to enhance the law to insure women are protected as equally as men, then you are reinforcing the contention of the Left that Right Wingers refuse or are unable to accept any facts or realities that might controvert their beliefs.
The facts are that women are stalked, beaten, battered, raped, forced into sex slavery and abused in other manners, however crimes of this nature have not been adequately and equally enforced in cases involving women, leaving women more vulnerable to these crimes than men.
The violence Against Women Act, first passed in 1994, is designed to insure that that the police, prosecutors, judges and other law enforcement officials properly apply the law equally to both genders.
Pat N.,
As I said in the article, Right Wingers don't think to well, and your are clearly a Right Winger. The law is not designed to put women is a "special class", the law is designed to take womenoutof a special class.
If you don't recognize that there is a need to enhance the law to insure women are protected as equally as men, then you are reinforcing the contention of the Left that Right Wingers refuse or are unable to accept any facts or realities that might controvert their beliefs.
The facts are that women are stalked, beaten, battered, raped, forced into sex slavery and abused in other manners, however crimes of this nature have not been adequately and equally enforced in cases involving women, leaving women more vulnerable to these crimes than men.
The violence Against Women Act, first passed in 1994, is designed to insure that that the police, prosecutors, judges and other law enforcement officials properly apply the law equally to both genders.
You guys just don't seem to get it! Or is this thing too fucking complicated for you??!!
This law is not a law that give special treatment to women. It is a law to insure that crimes committed against women are prosecutedequally.
I posted a response to Pats' stupid comment, but it ended up on page 2. It says in part;
"The facts are that women are stalked, beaten, battered, raped, forced into sex slavery and abused in other manners, however crimes of this nature have not been adequately and equally enforced in cases involving women, leaving women more vulnerable to these crimes than men."
"The violence Against Women Act, first passed in 1994, is designed to insure that that the police, prosecutors, judges and other law enforcement officials properly apply the law equally to both genders."
tes la013 ,
I can't respond to your comment because there is not an ounce of intelligence behind the convoluted bullshit you have conjured up regarding this issue.
This whole thing seems to be over your head, I would suggest you find something you understand to comment on .... if you can.
flameaway ,
That'a not what it's about at all Scream.
The law is not designed to give added protection to anyone. It is designed to insure that prosecution of the law is equal.
He's not pretending .... he really doesn't get it.
Is that about right?
NO.
Admission of what?!
rls8r ,
Thank you for that. It's a relief to know that there is someone intelligent on this site. I was beginning to think, with the exception of a few enlightened members here and there, I signed on to a site inhabited primarily by knuckle draggers.
what's that supposed to mean?
It's not that simple,.....
.... the laws on the books are not enforced equally .... and therein lies the problem. Crimes against women often go unpunished for a number of reasons, and the VAWA attempts to correct that problem. Granted it doesn't do so in every case, but without the law, women would be more vulnerable to violent crimes than they already are.
And it's not a new law, if you read the article you would know the law has been on the books since 1994. the issue now is an amendment that calls for the inclusion of the LGBT community and illegal immigrants. The revision also calls for prosecuting non-Indian perpetrators who commit crimes on Indian reservations to be tried on the reservations.
I would say the answer to that is you are easily confused and this issue is just too complicated for you to understand.
(?!) Could you please explain exactly how this law makes everyone unequal?
(I can't wait to hear this one)
I would not go as far as saying "all" all Republicans and conservatives are misogynists or even "some", but there are three factors I believe have heavy influence here; a) Ignorance b) Male Pride and c) the far religious right.
Ignorance - If one looks at the Republican rape comments over the last year (a collection is Here ) it shows an absolute ignorance on what rape is to a woman and the physical violence it represents. Such ignorance is "willful" on the part of these male politicians.
Male Pride - Historically, gender roles in any society have always favored the male over the female in all things. Within the last one hundred years, that has changed. Now millenniums of traditions and conditioning are being replaced as woman take their rightful place as mans equal. There will be resistance to that change, much of it rooted in pride.
The Far Religious right 's culpability here cannot be overstated. Where ignorance can be cured with knowledge, and pride healed in time, the evangelical belief that the Bible gives men complete control over women, involves a deep faith. Such faith is not easily overcome especially by those whom sincerely believe they are doing their Gods work.
Right! Your more observant than I thought Egilman .
Don't tell me this is too complicated for you. The law needs to be enhance because it is not applied equally to women.
That is simply not true and research has been done to support that opinion. See also ;
As I pointed out before, it isn't a new law, and yes, women are more vulnerable to these crimes, however, historically these crimes have not been prosecuted equally.
It's not about bullshit and its not about semantics, it's about you either understand what this law is all about or you don't. You obviously don't.
BINGO! You got it! The laws already in place are NOT enforced when it come to crimes committed against women. That's the reason for the VAWA.
BINGO again.
Three BINGOS in a row!
Yes. Don't make me look them up.
Good idea, it's obvious this is over your head.
Unfuckinbelievable.
(and I thought Newsvine was a challenge)
Where the hell did that come from?!
The only reference to tribal lands is the amendment calling for crimes committed on tribal lands by non-Indians be tried under tribal jurisdiction.
(I doubt you understand the reason for that)
Because your local court is only a Justice Court, with a Justice of the Peace presiding. A Justice Court is limited to misdemeanor and lesser charges, whereas County courts are designed to try felonies. County court judges almost always have a law background and are better equipped to handle felony cases.
Sorry telsa, I can't read that huge, grey block of words, you need to learn how make your comments more readable.
Read this article by website designer Christopher Merrill;
Break Up Your Text to Make it Easy to Read
I can only think of one: Idiocy.
That's an easy thing to say, but we both know what went on over there, with people making asinine, troll-like comments every day.
If you think you deserve a compliment for that asinine comment, your living in a bubble.
The comment is unfuckinbelievable, .... period!
Let's start with the United Stats Constitution.... there are a few words written on that piece of paper that protect about 320 million people every day.
It's nice to see we agree on something.
Why did you even introduce it to the conversation?
Forget it Egilman, you've take taken the conversation off topic.
Clearly demonstrates you are living in a bubble Ebeneezer , you should take heed that so many here agree with AP.
It's good to have you here ES , it gives us all a sense of why we are so passionate about informing those that are ignorant to what is really going on in this country.
You, Ebeneezer Scroogeski , or whoever you are,are one sick, delusional, blind, bigoted example of what is wrong with this country. You have absolutely no idea what a real American is, but I will tell you right now, YOU, without question, do NOT represent a real American.
Actually, you represent the sick underbelly of American society, the sub-culture of ignorance that is deterring our society from moving forward and prospering.
Have a nice day.
I don't know how "successful" you are, but if you mean financially ... that only take greed. As for "lucid" .... I hardly think so.
So, I guess we have to let you stay here.
It's more about the "sick underbelly of American society".
That explains why your post is so fucked up.
We just had it ..... you lost.
You just made it for me, thanks.
I think Kings' march at Selma, Ghandis' march to the sea and Rosa Parks' boycott successfully controverts that comment.
I believe my comment was laced with an adequate amount of humor, as for "fair" (?!) Since when do we have to play "fair"? That would ruin everything!
Don't bullshit me, you know you always retreat from our debates psychologicallybruisedand battered.
She is clearly winning this debate, she obviously is getting to him.
Mike, if she is so young and naive, how is it she is getting get you so pissed off?
Are you suggesting that none of those events should be characterized by history as successful?
Thumbs up is intended for a comment made by AP farther back on the thread.
Hey-when we get a whole bunch of men that are beaten and raped by women, we can get a violence against men act.
Till then, I'm thinking the biggest number of beatings and rapes are towards women. In my 65 yrs I've never seen a a whole lot of beaten men looking to get away from an abusive woman. I'm sure there are some out there, but surelynot the same number as the beatings and rapes of women. To suggest otherwise is just silly.
Screaming-come back into the light. The mother ship from bizzarro land will not be here till later in the week. You can board then.
Geez-what a way to twist things around. WOW. You guys are so hell bent on disagreeing with everything, you don't even make sense anymore.
I don't play stupid games, you should know that by now.
Go fine something else to be wrong about, something that is a bit of a challenge (not that your ever really much of a challenge
)
Agree dowser-double huh????? That comment was a jaw dropper.
I guess using Egilmansmindset women choose to be beaten too. Wow.
Mike-your filthy language is deplorable. It's way beyond what anyone else posts. If you have nothing intelligent to add to the conversation, then don't add anything.
No one is impressedwith a disgusting, dirty mouth no matter how much you think it impresses everyone. Try to clean it up sport.