╌>

Why I'm A Conservative

  

Category:  News & Politics

Via:  pat-n2  •  13 years ago  •  156 comments

Why I'm A Conservative

I posted this on NewsTalkers back when it was a wee, fledgling Grouply page just struggling to keep technology satisfactory and there was a mere, handful of members.

I thought it beared reposting as some of the insinuations about my background as a "rich girl" are starting to fly again. I hope this gets us past the rich/poor BS so we can focus on the actual topics at hand. It's long...but I hope you'll find my life story worth the read.

--------------------

There once was this young woman who was a budding college student. She scraped together enough for school at a local community college by working two jobs. One was as a waitress at a strip club where the tips were good. In other words, she focused on the short term problem of cash flow rather than a different solution. (That was her first bad decision).

Several months into that job, the club was short a dancer. A lot of the other dancers were also gals just working their way through college, so she figured "what the heck? Might as well. It will help pay the tuition." And it did. (her second bad decision)

About 6 months into that, she met a guy that blew her away. He was "rich", had a nice house, cool cars lots of money and an unlimited supply of cocaine, meth and heroin. Life turned into one big party. (her third bad decision)

A couple months later, she missed a period. A home pregnancy test revealed that she was pregnant. In her drug induced stupor, she thought this was just wonderful news (her fourth bad decision). She went to her boyfriend and said: "Guess what! We're going to have a baby!"

He decided he didn't want to be a dad and vanished. And this young woman..who had always been dependent on someone other than herself....found herself with nothing and no one. She was pregnant. She weighed 98 pounds. She had needle marks in her arms, legs, neck....anywhere she could find a vein that still functioned. Her family wasn't speaking to her and she had no marketable skills.

She did the only thing she could think of. Checked herself into a non-profit, private inpatient treatment facility. (her first good decision).

She went through a horrible detox. Shakes. Hallucinations. Double vision. Vomiting constantly.

Her head finally began to clear and she started realizing the gravity of her situation and started researching government entitlements for when she got out of treatment.

The next step in her treatment process was a halfway house. When she got there, the staff encouraged the women there to go to various social services offices to get "what's due to them". Almost every single woman did, and the young woman didn't blame them for it. At the time, it seemed like the only option. They planned on it just being temporary. Until they got back on their feet. The only reason she didn't the first time is because she overslept and missed the bus.

After that first time, she was suspicious of getting on that bus because she remembered that she had relied on someone else previously, and that didn't work out too well. Plus, she had a lot of stubborn pride. Pride that sometimes got her in trouble and sometimes was a blessing.

She had a total of $5.49 to her name. She took the bus to Goodwill instead and found a halfway presentable maternity outfit for $3.00. She bought it and went back to the halfway house where she proceeded to write her very limited resume by hand 20 times over since she didn't have access to a copy machine or a computer.

The next morning, she put on the maternity outfit, did the best she could with her hair and headed down the stairs. The House Manger looked at her and said: "Where do you think you're going all gussied up like that?" The young woman held her head high and said: "I'm going to go find a job." The House Manager laughed at her and ridiculed her, saying: "Have you looked in the mirror? You're 7 months pregnant! You look like a beached whale. No one is going to hire you! Just go down to the social services office tomorrow. There are a number of programs pregnant women can utilize. Then, you can worry about a job after you have the baby."

This young woman left the halfway house anyway...resumes in hand. It was late August and roughly 95 degrees outside. She didn't have any money left for bus fare, so she walked the 5 miles to downtown.

She pounded the pavement, handing out her pathetic, handwritten resumes to anywhere she could. She was scoffed at by receptionists, outright laughed at by hiring authorities and even kicked out of one building under the accusation that she was a "crazy pregnant street person".

After 6 hours of this, she stopped into a copy machine supply store. She was dejected by this time. Sweaty and in a bad mood. The store was about ready to close when she walked in. Her attitude wasn't the greatest and all pretense of professionalism was gone. She just looked at the man behind the counter, said her name and said: "I need a job. Is the boss here?"

The man behind the counter smirked, and she prepared to get laughed at again. He said to her: "Yes. He's still here. But before I go get him, why in the world should we hire you?" She said: "Because while I might not have a whole lot of business experience, I have something better. I'm hungry, I'm pregnant and I have a huge level of gratitude to anyone who will give me a chance. I will be the world's most loyal employee. And besides, if you don't hire me, you'll be paying for me anyway through your taxes because my last option is welfare. You may as well get something for your dollar".

He laughed at that and said: "My name is Tom. I own the store. I'll give you a chance. You have 30 days to prove to me that you can represent this company in a professional manner while answering the phone. You will be paid minimum wage. If, after that 30 days, you aren't prefoming, your employment will be terminated. If you are performing, the company will purchase a portable crib and take it out of your paycheck weekly so you can have the baby here and not have to pay for daycare. We will allow that arrangement for 6 months and then you will have to get your own childcare."

She jumped at it. She spent the next several months in a crappy, drafty, roach ridden, studio apartment, making her own baby-food because it was cheaper than store bought and living on ramen noodles, hot dogs and macaroni and cheese for herself.

Eventually, she got a quarter raise. And then another...and then another. And then a promotion. And then she had a decent enough skillset that she could get a better job somewhere else. In otherwords, she started at the bottom. Hell..she started BELOW the bottom and worked for every dime she ever got. Today, she consistently clears over six figures a year, owns a 3,000 square foot home on a corner lot, has another 40 acres out in the country to just play on, has a 2012 pick up truck in the driveway and her child is in the US Army.

That woman is me.

I still maintain contact with the women I was in the halfway house with. And after more than 2 decades, all of them are still on some type of government program. Programs they got on with the best of intentions and only planned to be on until life got "better"...but the way those programs are set up, there is no good time to get off.

Some of them are bitter about their lot in life. Some of them blame others. But mostly, they're just sad. They recognize that what got them there wasn't anything anyone did to them, but rather what they failed to do for themselves. Whether it was taking advantage of educational opportunities, job training, not having a willingness to start at minimum wage scrubbing toilets or a whole myriad of other things.

Many say to me: "I thought you were nuts that day you went out to find a job in that goofy looking maternity outfit. We talked behind your back about it and thought that we were so much smarter than you because we had an income coming in from the government and you didn't. But now I wish I would have done what you did".

And THAT is why I am a Conservative. I have seen with my own eyes, the devastation buying into the entitlement society can bring to people's lives. We need safety nets. We don't need the generational welfare that the more liberal segments of society promote without thought to the consequences.


Tags

jrDiscussion - desc
[]
 
Pat N2
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Pat N2    13 years ago

OK. So there it is. My life story laid bare for all to see.

Please be gentle.

 
 
 
markpup
Freshman Silent
link   markpup    13 years ago

Nice story!!

I'm probably somewhere in between. I have close friends now that emigrated here from the Ukraine back in the 80s when the USSR was still in full swing. For the first 4 months they were here, they did collect some assistance but as soon as they possibly could they got off of it. Now between the two of them they easily clear 6 figures and they're forever grateful for the opportunity to be here. They were in Kiev when Chernobyl happened and saw their 2 daughters get sick from the radiation everyone denied was even there (even though the entire KGB left the city within 24 hours after it happened).

Needless to say they're strong conservatives also. They tell me horror stories all the time of different types of socialist indoctrination they had to endure.

But - they did have the few months where they got some assistance because when they first got here they had nothing. It was a transition they needed to get on their feet.

I don't begrudge anyone using money I pay into the system to get that kind of help. Things like student or small business loans or any other contract where the person receiving the benefit has their part to fulfill is OK by me. But I'd agree with you 100% that it's the long term dependence on help that kills. Whenever I see someone that's been on welfare more than a year or two, they start rationalizing they're entitled to that and the spirit just goes right out of them. It's sad to see.

 
 
 
Pat N2
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Pat N2    13 years ago

But - they did have the few months where they got some assistance because when they first got here they had nothing. It was a transition they needed to get on their feet.

I just wish that's the way the system was set up. As a short term assistance program. I think we would have a much more robust society, lower unemployment rates and people would still have their dignity in tact. Kudos to your friends. Theirs is an awesome success story.

Whenever I see someone that's been on welfare more than a year or two, they start rationalizing they're entitled to that and the spirit just goes right out of them. It's sad to see.

I think that's the best I've ever seen it summed up. Thank you for being a much better wordsmith than I am. Smile.gif

 
 
 
Pat N2
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Pat N2    13 years ago

Can I ask what you found humorous?

 
 
 
Pat N2
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Pat N2    13 years ago

Are you rich ? If so, please send cash.

Damn. And here I thought you loved me for brain. Now I know you just want a Sugar Mama.

 
 
 
markpup
Freshman Silent
link   markpup    13 years ago

I think anecdotal stories are the very best way to prove a point. Different strokes I guess.

I don't think Pat N is objecting to targeted short term assistance. I had student loans and grants myself and wouldn't have gotten through college without them. But I had to do my part and complete my coursework to receive that money. And I guarantee I've paid that back many times over in terms of tax contributions over and above what I would have contributed without the education - as it should be.

There - my micro-bit of anecdotal storySmile.gif

 
 
 
evilone
Professor Guide
link   evilone    13 years ago

I wouldn't say government assistance programs were the reason Isucceeded, but I used thembrieflyand now I'm doing pretty good now. I'd like to chalk whateversuccess I have toperseverance in spite of my depression and moderate health issues.

 
 
 
Pat N2
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Pat N2    13 years ago

I wonder if there are stories about people who ended up succeeding in life BECAUSE they had government assistance to help them through tough times. I suspect there are.

To help them through the tought times? I'm sure their are. But this story is about the trap of generational welfare. (Hence, the reason I mention the ladies still on welfare after two decades).

As I said...we need safety nets. But that isn't the way the system is set up. Social service agency success...and thus, their following year's budget...is based on how many people they have ON a program. Not how many people they get off of it.

 
 
 
evilone
Professor Guide
link   evilone    13 years ago

I agree some of this should change, but how? Just pulling money out doesn't help as we end up paying in other areas, i.e. crime, homelessness, etc.

Personally I think more work in education to add critical thinking skills and real world problem solving skills into variouscurriculum. Show our youth they can do things if they think it through (singlyand in groups). But there is a huge tug in too many directions there right now to come to any type of agreement so that ain't going to happen.

 
 
 
markpup
Freshman Silent
link   markpup    13 years ago

I think almost anyone would agree that one anecdotal story isn't conclusive. But I'd say the most critical wisdom I've picked up are from the many many personal stories from just listening to what people have to say.

I'd like to be to a point where everyone's basic survival and safety needs are met. But personally, if someone wants more assistance over and above that from me and and others that are fortunate enough to be doing well, it's not overly demanding for us to expect they're trying their best and doing their part. I'd even add not doing that is enabling in the worst sense.

 
 
 
Pat N2
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Pat N2    13 years ago

It is far too simple to take what was the path for one person and say everyone needs to follow that path or that mode of thinking.

Unless of course, that anecdotal story is meant to convey why THAT PERSON is a conservative and doesn't imply anywhere that everyone should be. (redirects John's attention back up to the top of the article and it's intended purpose)

 
 
 
Pat N2
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Pat N2    13 years ago

I agree some of this should change, but how? Just pulling money out doesn't help as we end up paying in other areas, i.e. crime, homelessness, etc.

I think the ONLY thing we need to do is measure social service agencies by how many people they help to get OFF the system, rather than how many people they have IN the system.

If their bonuses and following year budget is tied to success stories, they will have the incentive to get people into a more productive life-style. Everyone would be better for it. The citizens would have the dignity, income andgrowth opportunities that come with a stable job, a good skillset and providing for themselves, society would have a lower unemployment rate, more money would be infused into the economy and the social service departments would be getting paid for doing good.

As it sits right now, they are rewarded for merely "administering" to people and getting as many people on the programs as possible.

 
 
 
evilone
Professor Guide
link   evilone    13 years ago

They don't get bonuses that I know of and why increase budgets for less people? I think efforts to get people not to use the system in the first place will be moreadvantageousin the long run. I'm not saying your way won't work or mine would. Just musing...

 
 
 
StevieGee
Freshman Silent
link   StevieGee    13 years ago

Maybe applying for a education grant and/or loan from the government would have prevented her from having to resort to working at a strip club and becoming addicted to drugs. In hindsight, figuring the cost of rehab, welfare, medicare and WIC for the baby etc. it would have been quite a bit cheaper for the government. With the progressive agenda it's not about giving people, as you put it, "what's due to them" It's about preventing the need in the first place. If this were the case she could have a college degree now and, instead of a menial job selling ink and toner hoping for mere 25 cent raises, could have a good job making good money, in a higher tax bracket, thereby paying it forward back into the system helping to support the next young woman who is a budding college student.

 
 
 
Pat N2
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Pat N2    13 years ago

Maybe applying for a education grant and/or loan from the government would have prevented her from having to resort to working at a strip club and becoming addicted to drugs.

Nope. Those were my choices. I took the job because it paid well and I got into the drugs because, frankly, I made a stupid lifestyle choice.

In hindsight, figuring the cost of rehab, welfare, medicare and WIC for the baby etc. it would have been quite a bit cheaper for the government.

Ummm...huh? As I mentioned, my treatment was with a non-profit and I didn't take any government assistance. What was "cheapest for the government"...actually, cheapest for the citizens, was the path I took.

With the progressive agenda it's not about giving people, as you put it, "what's due to them" It's about preventing the need in the first place.

You didn't bother to actually READ any of this, did you? The person who said: "get your due" was the House Manager at the halfway house. Not me. I'll thank you for not putting words in my mouth again. Worth noting, is that she was pretty progressive.

If this were the case she could have a college degree now and, instead of a menial job selling ink and toner, could be making good money, in a higher tax bracket,

Nope. You didn't read a word. Merely scanned. And you did a poor job of that, too. Because you obviously missed this part:

Today, she consistently clears over six figures a year, owns a 3,000 square foot home on a corner lot, has another 40 acres out in the country to just play on, has a 2012 pick up truck in the driveway and her child is in the US Army.

 
 
 
Pat N2
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Pat N2    13 years ago

They don't get bonuses that I know of

Jane Paper-Pusher doesn't. But the bomuses at the Director level and higher are massive.

and why increase budgets for less people?

It would be perfect. You have fewer people in the system, but the same amount...or more...money to put toward QUALITY services for those people. Education. Certification. GED classes. Resume writing....The end result would be getting even more people off the system and giving them the skills to make sure they don't wind up back on it.

 
 
 
pat wilson
Professor Quiet
link   pat wilson    13 years ago

Hi Pat,

I recall an article or post from you on NV several years ago where you stated that you had married your high school sweetheart. You said that at some point you were aware that he cheated and you ended the marriage. Was that prior to your community college/waitress experience ?

Please don't take offense, I'm just curious.

Pat (formerly Pat @#$&%@)

 
 
 
krounded
Freshman Silent
link   krounded    13 years ago

I wonder how many folks went through similar times, never went on aid and ended up Liberal?

I know at least one personally - very personally.

Having the fortitude to make it through difficult times without being on aid is not something only a Conservative can do and it is not 100% what Conservatism is all about. Neither is it 100% what Liberalism is all about.

Most people of either political persuasion are loath to be dependent on any entity. The world is not equal for everyone either. But I'll throw my lot in with the group that shows some level of compassion rather than the sink-and-die crowd that rewards the fabulously wealthy while gutting the middle class and poor with scams and intolerance.

 
 
 
Aeonpax
Freshman Silent
link   Aeonpax    13 years ago

Love the pathos.

 
 
 
Pat N2
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Pat N2    13 years ago

I recall an article or post from you on NV several years ago where you stated that you had married your high school sweetheart.

You are extremely mistaken, Pat. And many here can testify to it, including some of the mods. The closest thing in my history to what your saying is my meeting Steve...(the dude sitting three feet from me right now)...about 20 years ago, the two of us being best buddies for a long time...basically football season buddies...eventually getting married because it seemed like the right thing to do then getting divorced but still living together shortly thereafter. And living together to this day. He is the only "dad" Rebecca has ever known. In fact, he adopted her when she was little.

You said that at some point you were aware that he cheated and you ended the marriage.

You have me mistaken with someone else, Pat. Either that, or you are deliberately trying to imply something here. Which is it?

 
 
 
Pat N2
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Pat N2    13 years ago

I wonder how many folks went through similar times, never went on aid and ended up Liberal?

I know at least one personally - very personally.

I'd like to hear your...(oops)..."their"...story. I genuinely would. Smile.gif Tell "them" that if they are up to telling it, they are in a safe haven with me. I get it. And I won't attack them for decisions they made in their life because I know it's hard to lay all that crap bare naked, for everyone to see only to have people question it, rather than using it for a launching point for mature discussion.

Having the fortitude to make it through difficult times without being on aid is not something only a Conservative can do and it is not 100% what Conservatism is all about.

I never said it was. I said it was why I was a conservative. At the top of this article, a person can find these words:

I thought it beared reposting as some of the insinuations about my background as a "rich girl" are starting to fly again. I hope this gets us past the rich/poor BS so we can focus on the actual topics at hand. It's long...but I hope you'll find my life story worth the read.

Apparently, I need to put those words in a much larger font, as people seem to be missing them.

 
 
 
Pat N2
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Pat N2    13 years ago

Love the pathos.

If you're feeling some sort of pity or emotion, due to my presentation, Aeon...that's on you, babe. Not me.

Now. Do you have anything worth contributing? Or just your normal, tiresome and extremely vacuous one liners? As a fellow blonde, I'd ask you to try a little harder. It's stuff like that, that gives us a bad name.

 
 
 
pat wilson
Professor Quiet
link   pat wilson    13 years ago

I apologize, no implications, I thought for sure it was you, my bad.

 
 
 
krounded
Freshman Silent
link   krounded    13 years ago

Apparently, I need to put those words in a much larger font, as people seem to be missing them.

I never thought it applied to what I said. I've never thought you were rich. It really would not matter.

Life experiences do contribute to one's political proclivity. But the direction that tendency takes cannot be predicted.

 
 
 
J W Welch
Freshman Silent
link   J W Welch    13 years ago

Most "poor people" work.

Very true. There are many, many people who work two or more different low paying jobs just to make ends meet. Barbara Eherinreich (sp?) pointed this out in her excellent book Nickled and Dimed.

The success stories get lost in the shuffle by those who do see government assistance as some kind of right when it is far from that. Stories like Pat's don't get the press they deserve. I have no problem providing people in need with a helping hand on a short term basis. But to make a life of it goes way too far.

Government, regardless of political persuasion, is far too liberal with our money whether it is welfare for the able bodied or for corporations. Both sides have their pets to whom they feel a political obligation to support while railing against the other guy for doing the same.

Personally, I don't see how we can ever change it since no one has come along with the cojones and power to make it happen.

As we seem to have run off the skilled farm laborers who happen to be illegal, I'd like to see the able bodied on welfare sent to the fields to pick me a salad and perhaps a fruit cocktail before they get anywhere near any kind of check. Either that or go hungry. Their choice.

 
 
 
Pat N2
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Pat N2    13 years ago

Life experiences do contribute to one's political proclivity. But the direction that tendency takes cannot be predicted.

Never said it could. I'm not sure how many different ways I need to say this before people get it, but I'll try one more time.

The words above are why I am a conservative. It is the perceptions I obtained from my experinece and through watching the experiences of other people in the same boat that decided to go a different direction. And deciding that my path created a much better end result for me. No where, have I said this tendency could be "predicted" or that anyone else in the same situation should also be a conservative.

We had some good conversaiton going here on the many different ways the "system" effects people's lives and what can be done to improve said system.

Would you like to contribute to that discussion? or would you like to continue suggesting that I am implying that the details of my life can be predicted for others?

 
 
 
Pat N2
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Pat N2    13 years ago

I have no problem with providing people in need with a helping hand on a short term basis. But to make a life of it goes way too far.

(applauds wildly)

I would love to see some way that we could shorten the duration of welfare and take the money saved from that shortened duration and apply it to education, training, etc. There are literally thousands of jobs open right now for CNA's. Thousands for EMT's. Thousands for Medical Transcriptionists. Tens of thousands for skilled trade. Lets find a way to spend less money on giving people a fish and more money on teaching them how to.

 
 
 
Pat N2
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Pat N2    13 years ago

No issues, Pat.

To confuse things even more...Feb. 17th was mine and Steve's 18th "Anniversary". Thats what we decided to call it because saying: "Feb 17th is the day that we would have been married for 18 years if we hadn't had some sort of psychological meltdown caused by a sheet of paper called a marriage license"...is too much of a mouthful. Smile.gif

 
 
 
krounded
Freshman Silent
link   krounded    13 years ago

Would you like to contribute to that discussion? or would you like to continue suggesting that I am implying that the details of my life can be predicted for others?

I answered your comment to me. Nothing more.

I think you posted this story for a reason. That reason had nothing to do with getting the details of your life off of your chest. You made it political from the first sentence. You probably should not be surprised if you are answered in a political way.

Some of them are bitter about their lot in life. Some of them blame others. But mostly, they're just sad. They recognize that what got them there wasn't anything anyone did to them, but rather what they failed to do for themselves

To put this statement in your story and juxtapose it to your title is making a statement...a political statement. You can expect to be answered in a political manner. If you feel this is not contributing to the conversation, that is your prerogative.

Systems do affect people's lives. But as I stated, how it affects one's life cannot be predicted - and should not be assumed.

 
 
 
Pat N2
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Pat N2    13 years ago

I think you posted this story for a reason. That reason had nothing to do with getting the details of your life off of your chest.

Where did I say it was to "get something off my chest"? As mentioned, I originally posted this eons ago.

You're displaying poor reading comprehension, K. I said in the top of this article that it was because the "rich girl BS was popping up again. And you have even posted in the article where I stated I was going to see if Perrie still had the piece. So you are being disingenuous. Unless of course, you think perrie is in on your little conspiracy.

Now. Last time. If you want to continue with this silliness, you can take it up with me in email. Otherwise, drop the conspiracy theories and get back on topic. I hav ebeen nothing but civil to you and your reciprocity with your false claims are ridiculous.

 
 
 
krounded
Freshman Silent
link   krounded    13 years ago

You're displaying poor reading comprehension, K.

I suppose it has nothing to do with your writing skills? You're playing innocent as though you've not pulled a pin on a grenade. Why sugar coat it? You said what you wanted to say, now roll with it.

There's nothing in your story that should automatically make you a Conservative....Unless you have an overarching moral you are trying to impart. I'm saying that moral is not reached by all people.

You've also decided to turn this into personal bashing contest I suppose.

Relax and turn in for the evening.

 
 
 
pat wilson
Professor Quiet
link   pat wilson    13 years ago

I was married once and that was enough for me.Tongue.gif I too have a fabulous daughter.

 
 
 
Pat N2
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Pat N2    13 years ago

already have. Typing this comment from my kindle. Thanks for carrying.

who are you to decide for me what I learned from my own life experiences anyway, k? it's pretty simple. I compared the path I took with the path others took at the time. I was pretty apolitical back then and looking back...even leaned a little left when it came to a number of topics. it wasn't until a few years later that I discovered that due to my life experiences and what I learned from them...my ideology was more in keeping with conservatism. I'm sorry if you don't like it.

oh. And I always feel that revealing gory details about my past is the best way to make a political point. gosh. You figured me out. Yes...that was sarcasm.

goodnight k. I hope you will eventually be able to accept people who are different than you, think differentmy than you and have a different ideology than you. sleep well

 
 
 
krounded
Freshman Silent
link   krounded    13 years ago

I hope you will eventually be able to accept people who are different than you, think differentmy than you and have a different ideology than you. sleep well

Good night. I hope you also will be able to accept people with other views and not so quickly leap to the attack.

You know....if you simply stated that you were telling your story in response to the "rich girl" thing and left out the part about Conservative, I think you would have had the conversation you wanted.

 
 
 
Chucky Stuart
Freshman Silent
link   Chucky Stuart    13 years ago

Great story Pat; you have every right to be proud. Though not a conservative myself (okay, I do have 1 or 2 pet conservative views) I share your love of self-reliance. There was a time earlier in my adult life when I could have received government assistance but chose not to. It really helped my self-confidence. I'm glad things turned out fine for you.

 
 
 
Pat N2
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Pat N2    13 years ago

Thanks Chucky. I don't know if this has been your experience as well...but for me, getting over that scary, first time hump and discovering that I really could do it, has led to actually wanting to do more of it by choice.

back then, I always thought it would be cool to have a big house, fast cars and an opulent lifestyle. Now, I think it would be cool to be as much off the grid as possible, chop my own wood, raise my own food and collect my own water. Lol
and I really think wanting those things are . a direct result of already proving to myself that I can trust ME to take care of me, even in the toughest of times.

I'm glad things worked out well for you. And I'm especially glad that this is something you and I agree on. we need to look for opportunities like this more often.

 
 
 
Pat N2
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Pat N2    13 years ago

I

asked 6 hours ago. prior to you flipping Perrie the cyber bird and claiming you were leaving. since history has proven that you have no desire to engage on a mature level...the answer to your question is "no". I don't want to know. And since you gave me the option...I will take it as a sign of disrespect and a Coc violation if you choose to post it anyway.

 
 
 
Pat N2
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Pat N2    13 years ago

WOW! You had a helluva go of it, too. I loved reading your life story and can relate to so much of it.

The most telling part is how you took baby steps to get where you are today. And I think that's a big part of the key to all of this. You did shit you didn't WANT to do, but knew you HAD to do...you started digging holes and sweeping floors at 4:30 in the morning. You allowed yourself to be treated crappy because you never lost site of the end goal and knew it was called "work" for a reason.

And you ended up owning your own business.

That's the American Dream, hon.

I see way too many people sucking on the giant, sagging teat of the federal government, saying: "I can make more than minimum wage on welfare. So I'm not taking that job". Or "That job is 40 miles away. Thats too far". "Or...(this is the one that floored me)...."Yes, I can relocate, but I'm not moving to cold North Dakota. I don't care that an entry level rig job pays $30/hour and comes with benefits/housing. Besides...the work is too hard".

They sure as hell wouldn't consider digging holes for the wage you dug them for. But then...they also will likely never own their own business in the future like you do now. They think they are "too good" to take menial jobs or they are too lazy to do the work. They want to start at the top and never risk chipping a fingernail

I agree with you that safety nets are needed. An example is the young, Filipino mother of two that lives two doors down from me. She's in her late 30's and just lost her husband to cancer. She's been totally dependant on him the 10 years since they immigrated here. So now she's faced with 2 boys under the age of 7, she doesn't have a skillset and she has a household to maintain. She is getting on assistance while she goes to get her CNA certification. Her ultimate goal is surgical nurse...but she is starting with the certification because she needs to start making money. She is the type of person the system SHOULD help.

And thanks for the "cute" compliment. At my age, I'm not too shy to love a compliment like that. 5.gif

 
 
 
Pat N2
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Pat N2    13 years ago

Steve reminded me last nightthat I screwed up 2/17 is the anniversary of the day we met. Not the day we took the 6 month plunge. That was Aug. 5th.

Talk about embarrassed. Isn't it the woman that's supposed to remember these things? LOL.

With ya on the married thing. I know this sounds wierd, but I think there is something about making it "official" that screws with my brain. Because Steve and I are madly crazy about each other today. I just can't be married to him.

 
 
 
Pat N2
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Pat N2    13 years ago

You know....if you simply stated that you were telling your story in response to the "rich girl" thing and left out the part about Conservative, I think you would have had the conversation you wanted

Do tell, K....how would you suggest I leave the "conservative" part out when (a) that was the original title of the article and it was written well over a year ago and (b) is directly related to the end result?

Are you suggesting I should have changed the title of an original piece and removed all reference to conservatisim because it might make some liberal somewhere uncomfortable?

 
 
 
NYPeach
Freshman Silent
link   NYPeach    13 years ago

Wow Pat, I never knew but I have to admit that I am in awe of you and your journey!!! You took a hard road, but I believe that is what made you who you are today.

Are you in contact with your family today? Grin.gif

 
 
 
Pat N2
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Pat N2    13 years ago

Are you in contact with your family today?

Happy to say..."yes". I had about 5 wonderful years with my dad after all of that mess and before he passed away. When he died, we were closer than ever. And for that, I am very grateful.

Mom and I are best friends and spend a lot of time together. She's a hoot for a 70 year old lady. When I grow up, I wanna be like her. Grin.gif

Brother lives about 2 hours away and we talk often. Not as much as we should. Although, we did go to Christmas at his house and had a wonderful time.

 
 
 
NYPeach
Freshman Silent
link   NYPeach    13 years ago

That is outstanding Pat! I've had a rough journey myself and can relate to your story somewhat. I'm not as close to my family as you but I do have a wonderful husband and a beautiful son who will be 21 come Thursday.

Also, I do want to give your daughter kudos for serving our country.

One more question and if I'm prying...tell me to butt out....does your daughter have any contact with her biological father?

 
 
 
Hal A. Lujah
Professor Participates
link   Hal A. Lujah    13 years ago

It's a good thing that all your halfway housemates decided not to follow your ambitious lead, huh? Just imagine if one of them would have found the only potential employer in town willing to hire a pregnant ex-stripper with a hand written resume and needle tracks before you got there. Your entire conservative philosophy isanchored inbeing at the right place at the right time at one moment in the history of your life. No wonder conservatives with a background like yours are a rarity.

 
 
 
Pat N2
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Pat N2    13 years ago

Just imagine

I don't play in the world of "just imagine". I play in the world of reality. "Just imagine" is liberal territory. But thanks for your input anyway. flame away.

 
 
 
Hal A. Lujah
Professor Participates
link   Hal A. Lujah    13 years ago

Keep pretending that the world we live in is one where every pregnant junkie can find a job in a single day if they just stay determined. Face the facts - yes, your pluck contributed to bringing yourself out of your difficult situation,but alsoyes, you were clearly as lucky to find that employer as a million dollar scratch-off winner is to find a winning scratch-off ticket. John Russel nailed it - your anecdote couldn't be less meaningless in the world of reality. Social programs are neccessary at least on a temporary basis - you even admit that - but the conservative movement would be far more in favor of eliminating them in totality.

 
 
 
OttO
Freshman Silent
link   OttO    13 years ago

77.gif Wow. Just wow! I'm even more impressed with you!

Hetep and Respect (I have no idea what that means - thanks Aunk!)

 
 
 
Pat N2
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Pat N2    13 years ago

Wow. Just wow! I'm even more impressed with you!

Aww hell. Don't be impressed.I made a lot of stupid decisions. I would have never been in that predictament in the first place if it wasn't for my own stupidity. Difference is, a lot of people are living that very same stupidity right now...and blaming everyone else instead of looking in the mirror.

Hetep and Respect (I have no idea what that means - thanks Aunk!)

I have no clue what it means, either. But I always like it. Smile.gif

 
 
 
OttO
Freshman Silent
link   OttO    13 years ago

Yeah, but it's not the stupid decisions that are impressive. We all make stupid decisions, some of them are pretty destructive. But not everyone comes out the other side like you have (and does it with adherence to some personal principles).

My background isn't as dramatic as yours but I've had my share of rock bottom and life is pretty good right now - and it's also because I'm acutely aware of why conservatism isn't just a political position but it's also a way of life. I think your story captures that.

 
 
 
Pat N2
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Pat N2    13 years ago

and it's also because I'm acutely aware of why conservatism isn't just a political position but it's also a way of life.

...and that's really what it boils down to, isn't it? For me, it started off as: "I HAVE to" do certain things that are in line with conservative principle. When I saw those things actually worked, it turned into: "I WANT to" do those things that are in line with concervative principle.

 
 
 
OttO
Freshman Silent
link   OttO    13 years ago

My motto over recent years: "Make good choices."

Sometimes it's not easy to do and requires putting off the quick gratification or emotionally satisfying choices for the long term betterment. But that long term approach almost always works better.

 
 
 
Pat N2
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Pat N2    13 years ago

Sometimes it's not easy to do and requires putting off the quick gratification or emotionally satisfying choices for the long term betterment.

Exactly. It takes a ton of discipline. And really, the difference between the disciplined and the undisciplined is a small but significant difference.

The undisciplined say: "I want..."

The disciplined say: "I want....Now what steps do I need to do to get there?"

 
 
 
Summer
Freshman Silent
link   Summer    13 years ago

Pat N, I'm not sure if you remember me or not- I haven't been around much. I just wanted to say while I am not conservative, and you and I have had our disagreements on topics in the past, I admire you for your hard work on yourself and getting your life together.

I did go through a rough patch in my life - though it did not involve drugs or stripping or anything like that. I graduated high school in 1995, got a great job working for the US Ski Team. I ended up having to leave that job when I was pregnant because the job involved way to much travel, and seeing how my son's father and I split up, traveling was not something I could do as a single parent. I lived for many years without government assistance - it was hard, but I made it fine.

After several years, I met my now ex-husband. We had a son together. I worked hard, my now ex-husband worked hard (at first). Over time, it became obvious that something wasn't quite right - he stopped working consistently, began drinking and eventually began doing drugs. He became very abusive. I eventually left this marriage.

After I left this marriage, I was a single mom (again), with two boys, and no college degree. I was having a hard time finding a job that would take care of us without using government assistance. So, I opted to go to college - at least I could learn skills to make myself marketable for a career that did not require government assistance.

While in undergrad I did accept government assistance. I got a lot of assistance - I started out going to college getting student loans and grants. I also received housing assistance, medicaid, daycare assistance, food stamps and heating assistance for the four years I was in undergrad.

Because of this assistance, I was able to attend school without havinga full-time job. I did work as a work-study while in college - which prevented me from being eligible for cash assistance, but that was ok and more than fair. Anyway, I did very well in undergrad - I graduated with a BS in biology with a health sciences emphasis, and two minors (one in chemistry and one in Spanish). I ended up with a 3.96 GPA, did well on the MCAT, and opted to continue my education in medical school.

Now in medical school (I'm close to finishing my 3rd year - June 2014 can't get here soon enough, lol), I am no longer eligible for most assistance. My boys are still eligible for medicaid - which saves me a little over $6000 a year in medical insurance premiums (not counting co-pays, deductibles, etc., etc.). I don't qualify for other assistance because I have a bachelor's degree and am considered employable, but not seeking working. I can't work in medical school - outside of it not being allowed by my school, I simply wouldn't have the time (I'm on rotations typically from 6 am - 7 or 8 pm, 5 - 6 days a week, still have to study and still have to be a mom, and sleep when I can).

Anyway, I am very grateful for the assistance I received in undergrad and the assistance I receive now. Without this assistance, I probably would NOT have been in a position to get accepted to medical school. I would not be able to pursue the dream I had since childhood.

Assistance has a time and a place. Yes, I agree there should be reasonable limits on assistance. Yes, I agree that assistance should not be a way of life. I ended up more liberal, in part, because I can see the good that wisely administered assistance can do.

 
 
 
Pat N2
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Pat N2    13 years ago

Sure I remember you Summer!! Good to see you again!

As I said then...and still believe today...you are the type of person that the system should be for. You are doing something for yourself. Smile.gif

 
 
 
Summer
Freshman Silent
link   Summer    13 years ago

Good to see you too Pat :)

And yes, you did say that before - thanks Smile.gif

Sorry to post such a long comment on your article - I just wanted to put up a similar (but clearly different) story than yours and illustrate how it can result in a different view. We are respond to similar circumstances differently

 
 
 
OttO
Freshman Silent
link   OttO    13 years ago

The 'conservative movement'(of which you sound like an expert on) has never been in favor of eliminating assistance in totality. I'm not even sure how you could come to that conclusion when we have been light years away (and moving further) from that scenario for decades.

What conservatives tend to agree on is two fold: (1) welfare and personal assistance should not in any way, shape or form be a role performed by the federal government and (2) should be temporary except in the small number of circumstances where temporary is not an option.

I'll add a third - conservatives also don't think it's productive to defend welfare as if it's the line between life and death for the far too many people who are on it. SNAP? Schools providing free lunch, breakfast and sometimes dinner? I'm not getting where people with $150 sneakers, smart phones, flat tvs, x-boxes, cable television etc. can't perform the basics and feed their families rather than putting the pressure on the working stiffs and a government that is always on the verge of financial collapse.

There's a middle ground between providing no assistance and providing it for anyone who applies and I suspect that most opinions on this are more similar than we'd expect once we move past the dogma.

Maybe not 'every pregnant junkie' but if one can, then why not some pregnant non-junkies or non-pregnant junkies? Are you irritated because Pat's story contradicts the narrative that big government is the blessing that people need to get through life? It's certainly more inspiring (and something to encourage people to aspire to) than those of her friends from the halfway house. Isn't it? 39.gif

 
 
 
OttO
Freshman Silent
link   OttO    13 years ago

I'm going to be the banana in the tail pipe here, so to say, and this is why it's a little dicey when people put up their personal stories. This response isn't personal, it's a view that I've long had. This moves beyond someone needing assistance to keep them safe and alive while they get on their feet.

I think my question is why do people like me need to work to have money taken out of my pocket so someone else can go to college and pursue their dream? Why should that be a burden on tax payers like me who get low-skilled entry level work and then work their way up and struggle in part because Uncle Sam takes a big chunk out of my check to give to someone who doesn't truly need it but wants it so they can do what they want to do with life? I'm feeding my kids discounted meals (that I've earned) so college students can get food stamps and heating assistancewhile they pursue an education so they can end up making six figures?

Again, no offense intended - this is my criticism of the system and why it's broken and why the country is bursting at the seams.

But my question to anyone here who thinks I'm off the deep end on this: based on the end of Summer's post - what is the reasonable limit on assistance? If it's not to recognize the difference between someone struggling to find work and survive vs. someone trying to put themselves through school, where is the line? I don't see one. It's sounds like that if, as a medical student, you still qualified for all of the assistance you would probably take advantage of it. Is that incorrect?

 
 
 
Pat N2
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Pat N2    13 years ago

People in this country need to come to their senses. We are going to have long term high unemployment. In that case, who will hire any sort of "junkie" or troubled person, when there may be others less troubled to turn to? We have a current disgrace of a minimum wage which is equivalent to what it was 45 years ago.

I'm not following you. It sounds like you're saying that people shouldn't take minimum wage jobs.

That aside, there are currently over 550,000 jobs posted on Indeed.com in just the last 7 days. If you plug in the qualifier of a minimum of $30,000 in salary, a total of 1,491,039 pop up.

 
 
 
Deb G.
Freshman Silent
link   Deb G.    13 years ago

Pat, your story could be mine. A bit different in some ways, but also hard and I clawed and scrapped my way through life for the last 40 years. But the blessings I have today I would never have had if I had chosen the easy path. That is why I am a Conservative woman also. You have my respect and admiration. I know, first hand how hard your life was. It takes courage and intestinal fortitude to make it on your own.

Being conservative women, we get it worse than our male counterparts since we are supposed to "get with the program" and believe that all conservatives want us to be barefoot and pregnant with no rights. That conservatives have some sort of "war on women". But you and I know that's all hogwash and just another way to keep women dependent on government and voting liberal. Every program they have, every thing that they do is designed to keep women and minorities dependent and perpetually voting for them. They say that their programs are to help people, but if so, why do so few people ever improve their life and get off welfare? Why has our government spent more than 17 TRILLION dollars fighting poverty and we have more poverty now than when the "war on poverty" started? At that rate, they could have given every man, woman and child a million bucks and still spent less money? WTF eh? Anyway, I'll get off my soapbox. Loved your story.

Deb

 
 
 
Deb G.
Freshman Silent
link   Deb G.    13 years ago

Make it "workfare" instead of welfare. It will shorten all by itself. Grin.gif

 
 
 
Deb G.
Freshman Silent
link   Deb G.    13 years ago

I do not mind my tax dollars going to help people like you Summer. You took the "hand up" and did the WORK. That is what counts. People like you are what those programs are supposed to be for, so don't feel guilty you took the assistance. It's the ones who do nothing for themselves but walk to the mailbox to collect the check (actually don't even have to do that, it is deposited on a bank card now). Those are the ones I object to.

My daughter, her husband and their 3 small children (under age 3) are living in my basement at the moment because he only makes $10 and hour and can't support them. He is qualified for more, but can't find a better job. They get medicaid to make sure those babies are well cared for. I don't mind that either. Meanwhile, he is doing online classes to better himself and he works lots of overtime hours and they are banking their money. This is what you do with a hand up, you make it pay off.

 
 
 
Deb G.
Freshman Silent
link   Deb G.    13 years ago

krounded, you are welcome to "throw your lot" in with any crowd you like, but for the record, you are 100% wrong if you believe that conservatives are not compassionate people. Look up some statistics on charitable giving. You will find the people who open their wallets and give of their time to the needy the most are conservatives. You really must get out and meet a few, you might get a pleasant surprise. MOST conservatives ARE middle class, not wealthy my friend.

And while we are talking about "rewarding the faulously wealthy", why are all the Hollywood libs getting special tax breaks? Why didn't GE pay any taxes last year? WHO is it again that rewards the wealthy? Oh, I forgot, you get a reward if you've donated to a Democrat political campaign because you've proven you care about poor people by attending a $35,000 per plate fund raiser.64.gif

 
 
 
Pat N2
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Pat N2    13 years ago

People who work minimum wage jobs need government assistance to get by.

...and to them I say, they deserve it.They are doing something to help themselves and improve their own situation by agreeing to flip burgers or stock shelves or whatever, for minimum wage. That's who the system was created for. I'm really not sure how many times I need to repeat that.

You didn't mention the over 1,000,000 jobs on Indeed that have a salary north of $30,000. That's well above minimum wage.

Also, what do you think about the fact that a single mom in PA can make as much as $80,000 on welfare? Do you think that's a bit excessive? Where is her incentive to get a job commiserate with her experience and work toward self improvement?

 
 
 
Deb G.
Freshman Silent
link   Deb G.    13 years ago

You didn't read it Stevie. She didn't take ANY money from the Govt, so how could it have been any cheaper?

 
 
 
Pat N2
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Pat N2    13 years ago

Oops. Forgot to address this part:

If you don't want to raise the minimum wage, and with it raise all lower tier salaries, stop complaining about entitlements, and taxes.

So help me out here....are you in favor of companies raising the minimium wage AND all of the lower tier salaries even though the trade off will be cutting jobs and shortening hours?

Or do you believe corporations will just take the increased expense on the chin out of the kindness of their hearts....especially combined with their looming additional expense of healthcare?

 
 
 
Summer
Freshman Silent
link   Summer    13 years ago
Otto, when I am done with school, I will pay back all that was given to me via assistance plus some. I will pay back more than I ever received.Also, no, I would not accept the assistance currently, as my student loans cover our living expenses. I do accept the medicaid for my boys because without that, the student loans would not cover all of our living expenses.Also, without an education, I would NOT have been able to survive without assistance. It's odd that you seem to not consider a single parent going to school, and using assistance while in school, reasonable. The education obtained while in school is done so that someone can get off of assistance.
 
 
 
Deb G.
Freshman Silent
link   Deb G.    13 years ago

I'm sure there are lots of success stories of folks who took temporary assistance to help them. That was not the point of Pat's story. It was to point out that those who STAYED on assistance for years were in the same place they started out in years before. How sad is that? No one is saying that a govt "hand up" insures failure, but it's pretty guaranteed if you stay on it your whole life, not only will you not be a success in life, but you will probably teach your children nothing but a life of dependence as well.

 
 
 
Summer
Freshman Silent
link   Summer    13 years ago
Deb G, Thanks. Also, I can understand that frustration. Believe me, I can not wait until I can give my sons' doctor a private insurance card instead of a medicaid card.
 
 
 
markpup
Freshman Silent
link   markpup    13 years ago

Otto - hi buddy - I'm all for self sufficiency but I'm one of the ones that got student loans I needed to get by while I was in college.

Try working full time and taking 4 or 5 courses in college. It's a commitment. The social contract based on that loan is I'm putting a lot of work into self-improvement which purportedly and most certainly has paid back many times over.

It would have really been a lot easier for me to forego the student loans and the effort to complete a degree. But this way both myself and taxpayers everywhere benefited - I'd say what I'm paying in Federal alone exceeds what I used to make before I started back to college.

I'm generally in favor of helping someone who works hard to help themselves.

I also don't remember getting food stamps and heating assistance - generally I lived on what I earned working full time and the student loans (minus tuition ouch) and it was clearly roommates and ramen - and hoping my old car would make it one more day.

 
 
 
Pat N2
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Pat N2    13 years ago

I'm sure there are lots of success stories of folks who took temporary assistance to help them. That was not the point of Pat's story. It was to point out that those who STAYED on assistance for years were in the same place they started out in years before.

Very well put, Deb.

I'm not sure why some liberals seem to think that if conservatives are against generational welfare and giving benefits to darn near everyone who applies with no burdens or responsibilities placed on the receiver, then that MUST mean we are completely against them and they shouldn't exist at all for anyone.

 
 
 
Deb G.
Freshman Silent
link   Deb G.    13 years ago

The "all or nothing" narrative from the liberals is getting tiresome. "Conservatives hate minorities, conservatives hate old people, conservatives want you to starve and die or make it on your own, conservatives hate puppies and babies, conservatives eat children for breakfast". It has never been nor will it ever be the position conservatives take towards government assistance. I don't know where you get that from, because it's never been what conservatives actually do. It's just a bunch of bald faced lies perpetrated by liberals. There isn't a lick of truth to it. Pat wasn't THAT lucky, there are actually more caring people out there than you realize (how sad that you are so cynical). It's called "paying it forward" and there are many that do just that. They had someone help them when they were down and now they are willing to do the same, paying it forward. I know what a concept! And all without the Government making them do it too!Grin.gif

 
 
 
Hal A. Lujah
Professor Participates
link   Hal A. Lujah    13 years ago

The 'conservative movement'(of which you sound like an expert on) has never been in favor of eliminating assistance in totality.... What conservatives tend to agree on is two fold: (1) welfare and personal assistance should not in any way, shape or form be a role performed by the federal government ...

I'm afraid your statements need some clarification. Are you suggesting that assistance be entirely a function of private sector charity, or that state and local governments somehow manage assistance measures entirely without the assistance of the federal government? In other words, it's okay for the federal tax code to provide welfare to those wealthy and privileged enough to owntheir ownprivate jet, but not okay for the federal government to assist children of poverty.

Are you irritated because Pat's story contradicts the narrative that big government is the blessing that people need to get through life?

No, I'm irritated at how delusional conservatives can be over a success story from one of their own - as ifit could happen to everyone who just applies themselves. The fact is, if every single one of those housemates of Pat's had the initiative that she had, then she would likely not be where she is today. That is the reality that conservatives refuse to admit to, while you advocate for corporations to relocate job opportunities on foreign soil, and attack unions, and attack assistance programs, and stonewall employment by not supporting badly needed infrastructure improvements that could put hopelessly unemployed citizens back to work while averting future public disasters. All in an effort to create the appearance of an ineffective sitting president, who you consistently label as a liberal, but in reality is quite the moderate. And you wonder why your numbers are spiraling into the toilet.

 
 
 
Deb G.
Freshman Silent
link   Deb G.    13 years ago

I work in state govt in the agency that provides those services. There are no bonuses for the top management, but they do get some pretty nice raises every year. The perks are pretty good too. None of it actually tied to helping people though.

All those programs you speak of are already available. But you have to get people to WANT to use them. They require WORK. Those that are habitually on welfare, do not want to work and they have no desire to improve their lives. That's why I truly believe we need "workfare" not welfare, at least for those who are physically able to work. It helps them learn skills and it's not so much like "free money for nothing".

 
 
 
OttO
Freshman Silent
link   OttO    13 years ago

I don't see it as reasonable. I'm a single dad working to earn my money but because you're a single mom that makes you entitled to use my hard earned money to pursue your education?

If you're paying back more than you will ever receive than what am I doing? Isn't it more fair that my money goes to my own education or maybe my children's? Am I going to personally get a check from you when you are done with school? And what if you fail? What if something happens and you have to drop out? What if you get out of medical school and discover due to drastic changes in health care that your career is not going to be as golden as you once thought? Still going to pay that back and then some?

And to you and Mark below - this isn't about loans. Loans in theory get paid back. This is about using a gift system that should be for the needy and applying it to your personal goals. I'd like to start a business soI can do better for my family. Should the federal government give me the money for that? Granted, I'm a white male so the federal government pretty much doesn't classify me as someone who needs assistance but I could use a few hundred grand to pursue my dreams. It'll get paid back and then some.

That's my last point above - where is the line? If welfare is now a tool to help people pursue their dreams than whose dreams are going to be deemed worthy for government assistance and whose aren't?

Look, I am sincerely happy for you in that you know what you want and you are achieving it. Good luck with that. But let's not pretend for a second that it is fair to redistribute income from one person (the earner who may need it for the same reasons you do) to another for so you can have the government fund your choices.

Again, nothing personal (I don't even hold it against you for taking advantage of what's made available) but this system sucks.

 
 
 
markpup
Freshman Silent
link   markpup    13 years ago

Just for giggles - we're focusing on how much assistance is OK.

I remember on Newsvine and several times, I got into a debate about whether having a car or having your own place to live are entitlements. I'm a no on both sides in large part because I've spent a significant part of my adult life without a car and with roommates - sometimes I needed to because I wasn't making that much money and other times it was a nice bit of frugality where I had lots of extra money to do other things.

One more comment about the association here with "conservative". I'd say it's a traditional conservative value to focus on self-reliance and a sense that if we're receiving public assistance, we're doing so as part of a social contract for betterment or serious need and that condition will be temporary and relieved as quickly as possible. Pat N I think that was your point - nothing wrong with owning it to me.

There's another Newsviner who I especially like and I agree with him most of the time, but he believes that anyone at any time should be able to stop working and the net should be there for that. I'd peg him I think fairly as more liberal. And I'll admit I don't at all agree with him on this issue. I think anyone should be putting in the best effort they can.

 
 
 
OttO
Freshman Silent
link   OttO    13 years ago

Roommates and ramen - now that's the spirit! 3.gif

 
 
 
Pat N2
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Pat N2    13 years ago

if every single one of those housemates of Pat's had the initiative that she had,

And therein lies the rub. "IF". But they didn't. I did.

then she would likely not be where she is today.

How precisely, do you make that leap? You begin your comment with a hypothetical and try to somehow tie it to "where I am today"?

I could easily say I would be better off today "if" I found a better job in the beginning and I would be using your same, strawman argument.

As I said before, you can continue to play in the world of "ifs" and "likely". I'll stick with reality.

 
 
 
OttO
Freshman Silent
link   OttO    13 years ago

Hi Deb,

Incomes are going down, unemployment is stagnant at best, companies are downsizing positions and laying people off, health care costs are rising, gas prices are rising, food and clothing prices are rising and our tax burden is rising. Where does it work out that millions like me are getting the financial squeeze from government policy but at the same time it's fair that the money getting squeezed from me is being handed off to someone else to better his or her life? Is my own value comparatively so little that I'm not even allowed to fend for myself and my children? That someone who wants to pursue an education is more important than my families well being?

This money is not buried in a ground somewhere on federal land. It shows up on our paychecks as a line item deduction. If you don't mind, then I propose that you cut Summer a check and help her out of your own savings account but let's not dressthis up as fair for those of us who need every dollar we earn.

As I told Summer above, I don't hold it against her for taking advantage of an unfair system. But I think a little guilt is in order. Or a big sincere thank you to the taxpayers who are struggling so people like her can pursue their dreams. But let's not pretend for a second that it's fair. It's the opposite of fair.

 
 
 
Pat N2
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Pat N2    13 years ago

This "let them pull themselves by the bootstraps" exhortation is completely unrealistic to cure what ails America today.

John, if you believe that it is "unrealistic" of me to (a) believe that temporary assistance should be available to those who truly need it and are making some effort to better their lives and (b) expect people to do what is necessary to obtain a skillset, even if it means starting in a low paying job...then I guess there isn't much more I can say and I declare an impasse.

 
 
 
luther28
Sophomore Silent
link   luther28    13 years ago

Pat, I must admit I have been glossing over this article since my arrival here, now I am sorry I waited so long.

Your story reinforces my comment to your article of today, there is a distinct difference between helping one help themself and giving, seperating needs from wants. It would seem you have conquered both. As to your tale, we all have a story and it makes us who we are.

 
 
 
Summer
Freshman Silent
link   Summer    13 years ago
First, I am almost done with medical school - I will not be failing out. Second, when I am done, I will pay more in taxes than I ever received in assistance- which is fair, I should have to pay taxpayers back for the help I received. Third, when it comes to student loans, in order for me to maintain my license, I have to pay them back. Fourth, I have been involved in the medical field for many years, I know what I'm getting into- I'm not going to quit.The line we draw is quite simple - is the person taking proactive steps to get off assistance, and going to get a college degree or other job training is doing this just as much as actively seeking gainful employment is, and if they are obtaining education are the making satisfactory academic progress (which does have a set definition and does not allow for never finishing).
 
 
 
Pat N2
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Pat N2    13 years ago

It would seem you have conquered both.

Ooooooo....I still have PLENTY of wants. lol. And based on experience, I know what I have to do to get them. And it ain't gonna be pretty. In fact, it's going to be downright painful. I may be visiting my ol' friends Oscar Meyer & Mr. Ramen again to achieve them. The goal this time, is to not rely on banks to get them. I figure I achieved one goal without the federal government....I can achieve this one without a bank.

 
 
 
Hal A. Lujah
Professor Participates
link   Hal A. Lujah    13 years ago

This site is making it nearly impossible to respond, because it won't let me quote without deleting the rest of my comment. Third try here, without quoting you, Pat. Your strawman accusation is null and void. If you got your wish, and everyone in American history that has ever felt that they needed some form of public assistance, had instead just shown the ambition you claim to have had, then you would have been in direct competition for that one impossibleemployment opportunitywith an absurd number of others, including your housemates. If that were the case, we would be here reading your diatribe in support of the public assistance that you would be relying on because your odds of getting that job, or any other one considering the condition you described yourself being in, would be next to zero. It seems that "reality" is the only thing that you have to justify your conservativism. If reality were to adhere to your vision of howthings should be, then you would have gotten the shitty end of the stick a long, long time ago, and you would be a die hard liberal.

 
 
 
Hal A. Lujah
Professor Participates
link   Hal A. Lujah    13 years ago

Deb, I assume you are directing that at me, even though I clearly didn't claim that conservatives hate puppies and babies or eat children. Strange you would go to such a ridiculous extreme, to mimic how extreme conservatives aren't? Whatever, though. I wouldn't say that conservatives hate government assistance - I would say that conservatives hate government assistance that doesn't assist THEM. You have got to be kidding me when you make that wild-ass claim that paying it forward will suffice to keep the poor from starving to death, right?! Are you insane?!

 
 
 
Pat N2
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Pat N2    13 years ago

This site is making it nearly impossible to respond, because it won't let me quote without deleting the rest of my comment.

That's wierd. I don't have a problem. Maybe it's you and you aren't really a victim of "the site"?

If you got your wish, and everyone in American history that has ever felt that they needed some form of public assistance, had instead just shown the ambition you claim to have had, then you would have been in direct competition for that one impossible employment opportunity with an absurd number of others, including your housemates.

Again, you are speculating. And your wild speculation assumes that there were no other jobs to be found anywhere in the area in a town of 300,000 people. You seem to think it's perfectly normal to dwell in the hypothetical if it supports your argument, but won't go there if it doesn't. If we're going to play a game of "what if"...."what if"...I had gone to the grocery store down the street (which I didn't hit) and they had a job for a store clerk?

You are basing your fantasy on the assumption that there was one job in the entire city.

It's amazing, the lengths some lengths liberals will go to in inventing fantasy scenarios to support their arguments when a real one conflicts with their ideology.

 
 
 
OttO
Freshman Silent
link   OttO    13 years ago

Bravo! But your stated commitment doesn't change my argument. Somewhere, someone is getting assistance in a similar situation who is going to fail or drop out. And this is to assume that I agree that a college degree is some sort of requirement for a guarantee of success.

Taking all of what you just said - do we then give handouts to everyone who says 'I want a college degree'? Maybe what I see as welfare assistance you see as a jobs program. I don't know.

I'll leave it alone here but you have managed to not even touch on why it should be my (the middle class taxpayer) problem and my children's problem that you need help getting a degree that you can't earn on your own. Which is really at the heart of my complaint and why I disagree with your arbitrary line. This bankrupt country can't afford to prop everyone up while they go to college. That's not me saying it - that's simple math.

Good luck to you though...

 
 
 
markpup
Freshman Silent
link   markpup    13 years ago

If you invest in someone's education and now for years after their income is tripled and Clinton (and now Obama) thinks you're rich, doesn't that also benefit you?

I think there's nothing unfair about it if it's an investment in a person that upholds their end. On average college educated people make more income than those that are not and when your income goes up, so does your tax bracket. And I don't get to be Mitt Romney and get by with 15% on millions either.

In terms of what's "fair" that's quite an abstraction. But I'm confident I've repaid yours and other's taxpayer's generosity many many many times over.

 
 
 
OttO
Freshman Silent
link   OttO    13 years ago

If that's why you work and earn a paycheck so the government can decide that Summer and other's will spend it better than you do, then more power to you I guess. I'm capable of investing my own money and would rather have my tax burden lowered and invest it in my own kids than hand it off to someone else. Why is it fair to have it taken from them so that Summer can go to school?

Again, we're not talking about loans. We're talking about redistribution. If you are talking about redistribution as well, then I would say that you paid it off if you cut a check to the government on top of your minimum tax obligation. Otherwise, you're just paying taxes like the rest of us but you got a bonus to boot.

Apply for a loan or a grant. Don't expect the taxpayer to support your personal causes.

 
 
 
Summer
Freshman Silent
link   Summer    13 years ago

As I said, in order to continue to be eligible for assistance while in school (whether it be a college degree or some other job training), they should have to be making satisfactory academic progress. All colleges that participate in federal financial aid have to have a satisfactory academic progress assessment for students - this is the assessment that the federal government uses (in part) to determine if continuing students are still eligible for federal financial aid. Typically, it has time restrictions on it (meaning they have to be on track to complete their degree within a set period of time), the student has to maintain at least a C average (though, I personally think this should be higher - say a B average), etc., etc.

So, if the person going to school isn't maintaining satisfactory academic progress, then, no, we should not continue giving them welfare. This is because welfare should be given to those actually working toward getting off assistance. If the person isn't maintaining satisfactory academic progress, their chance of dropping out or failing out is extremely high. The standards aren't difficult to meet - if the person is willing to put a little effort into their school work.

btw - of all the comments you've made so far, I've found none of them offensive - until you said "...that you need help getting a degree that you can't earn on your own." Yes, I received financial assistance during undergrad - which allowed me to focus on my studies more. However, I was the one that put the work in on obtaining that degree - I was the one that was able to graduate in 4 years with very high GPA with a strong major and a double minor. I was the one that did research in Inflammatory Bowel Disease, Microbiology and Genetics - of which some of my research has been published in major scientific reseach. I was the one that presented my research at international conferences. I was the one that worked as a work-study 20 hours a week while taking 21 credit hour semesters. Had I opted to not go to medical school, I could've opted to enter the work force or go onto get my PhD - I opted to continue my education (at my expense, other than the medicaid that my children are currently eligible for).

You say it's a matter of simple math - I agree, it is. What is cheaper - paying for less than $1000/month (which is what I received between all forms of welfare assistance during my four years of undergrad) while a person obtains an education that makes them marketable such that they can get off of assistance, or paying some level of assistance for many more years or even several generations?

 
 
 
markpup
Freshman Silent
link   markpup    13 years ago

I get it but thanks to that "bonus" I got, my taxes are a lot higher. So that ended up being a "bonus" for everyone including you.You either get additional government service or you got to forego paying even higher taxes than you do already - all thanks to little old me. Because I went to college and I can earn more money.

Nothing begrudged here either - I'm happy for the opportunity and the new life.

And I'm happy for anyone else that made similar investments. Because I like more government services and lower taxes too.

 
 
 
krounded
Freshman Silent
link   krounded    13 years ago

MOST conservatives ARE middle class, not wealthy my friend.

My discussion has not centered on wealth. I'm not sure why people keep throwing it in there. Only you are talking about someone being fabulously wealthy. BTW....Any political party contains more middle class than wealthy because there are more middle class people than wealthy people in the electorate.

I don't know who you are so I'm not sure why you are using the term "My friend" unless you have sarcasm dripping from it.

Look up some statistics on charitable giving.

Look up the Bible parable about the woman who gave a small pittance to the church and why that found more favor in the eyes of Jesus than the gift from the rich. Wealth is finite and subject to percentages when one decides on an appropriate amount to give. Patting someone on the back for giving .1% of their income is going a bit far.

As far as I can tell, Pat is trying to justify being Conservative by life experience based on an aid program that no longer exists in that form. I simply threw in my opinion regarding life experiences and how they drive/do not drive political affiliation. I know plenty of Conservatives and was made an honorary Conservative by some of them.Smile.gif Kinda funny, but not unappreciated.

Pat said:

Are you suggesting I should have changed the title of an original piece and removed all reference to conservatisim because it might make some liberal somewhere uncomfortable?

I'm not sure it would be the Liberals that are uncomfortable. You are the one that seems to feel the need to justify being Conservative. You wrote the article....You could change the title if you wanted to and drive the conversation toward the benefits/ills of the welfare system. Obviously you can do what you want.

 
 
 
Pat N2
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Pat N2    13 years ago

You wrote the article....You could change the title if you wanted to and drive the conversation toward the benefits/ills of the welfare system.

Why would I want to change the original title of an article? It true. The words contained in it are why I'm a conservative. And I stated what my original itent was. You can stick your fingers in your ears and go: "LALALALALALALALALA!!!!!!!!" all you want...but it is what it is. The original intent wasn't the ills or benefits of the welfare system. That said, I don't mind that the conversation went that way.

And thats the interesting thing here, K. Everyone else is engaging in discussion. And it's flowing where ever it flows. You on the other hand, are still hung up on the title. That's telling.

Obviously you can do what you want.

WHEW! I was beginning to think...with the way you keep carrying on about it...that you didn't feel that way. now that I know you do, can you bring yourself to expand your conversation past the title?

 
 
 
krounded
Freshman Silent
link   krounded    13 years ago

now that I know you do, can you bring yourself to expand your conversation past the title?

Well it's probably easier for me to expand my conversation anyway....

The structure of the welfare/aid system is different than it was years ago. There were a lot of unintended, bad consequences to the old system that did create generational dependence. There still is some, but it now takes the form of disability aid.

This site has some graphs that show the drop off of families on welfare after the changes during the Clinton admin, and relates it to single parent households.

You can remove thy own fingers from ears now.

 
 
 
Pat N2
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Pat N2    13 years ago

This site has some graphs that show the drop off of families on welfare after the changes during the Clinton admin, and relates it to single parent households.

Your chart only goes through 2004.Nearly a decade ago. I fail to see how that addresses the poverty and welfare issues of today, and I fail to see the relevance of poverty data ending 9 years ago when you are dismissing programs that were available in the 90's as irrelevant.

Do you have a chart of current data? Or would you like me to provide one? I think we both know it's gone up significantly in the past 5 years or so. And uless you can tell me the relevance of 9 year old welfare data to this discussion, I think we would be better served with something more recent.

 
 
 
lib50
Professor Silent
link   lib50    13 years ago

I'm liberal and I don't believe anybody can just 'drop out' and receive benefits. I don't know anybody who thinks they are entitled to cars either. The people I know that are having great difficulties are older people who can't get hired (yes, there is age discrimination) or they become part of the working poor because wages are so low. They have problems keeping food on the table because they have no way to factor in the extras like glasses for the kids or illness/injury. And sometimes people are doing their best and it is not enough. Some people make stupid decisions and some just have life dumping on them, not every thing can be controlled. I just prefer more love and acceptance and less criticism and judgement.

 
 
 
krounded
Freshman Silent
link   krounded    13 years ago

...And you are talking about a system even older.

Go ahead, provide one. Do make sure it is one that takes the recession into account. Obviously more people will use the system when the economy was put into the tank.

 
 
 
Pat N2
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Pat N2    13 years ago

Why didn't you use that same qualifier for your charts? They aren't adjusted for recessions throughout the history that's recorded within them.

Moving goalposts again, are we?

 
 
 
markpup
Freshman Silent
link   markpup    13 years ago

All well and good, but at some point there has to be a judgment. I realize that's a difficult thing these days - but I'd prefer to help people that need help and not enable or even support people who don't.

We'll get it wrong sometimes on that I'm sure we'll agree.

And it's not criticism and judgment to avoid enabling people to not work and try when they should be. Enabling in that situation is sure as heck not love and acceptance either.

Right now we have utterly destitute people and as far as I can see, only the churches are helping them. On the other end of the scale are scammers who live off others and know how to play the system (I know some personally so don't tell me they're not there) - so in my humble estimation we're doing it all wrong and we can do a lot better.

 
 
 
krounded
Freshman Silent
link   krounded    13 years ago

No recession matches the one started in 2008.

These charts do include some economic and sociological factors. That's why I mentioned that your's should do the same.

Now you believe the goalposts were moved?....again? You've successfully restricted the conversation you sought to expand by ignoring the fact of the recession. It should be easy to find graphs or articles to back up your point. Please proceed.

 
 
 
Pat N2
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Pat N2    13 years ago

These charts do include some economic and sociological factors. That's why I mentioned that your's should do the same.

Now you believe the goalposts were moved?....

Wait a minute. According to you, we didn't have 3 sucessive quarters of negative growth from the 1960's through 2004? WOW.

And what do "sociological factors" in your charts have to do with your demand for "recession factors" you're demanding from me?

Could it quite possibly be that you already know we have a larger percentage of the population on some type of welfare right now than we have since the depression...you know median household income has slipped under Obama...and you know the cost of living has increased, but you feel such a need to "protect" this politician that you are making silly demands that you're unwilling to provide yourself?

 
 
 
Hal A. Lujah
Professor Participates
link   Hal A. Lujah    13 years ago

That's wierd. I don't have a problem. Maybe it's you and you aren't really a victim of "the site"?

Lol - you don't have a problem ... that's a good one! Stop it - you're killing me!

what if"...I had gone to the grocery store down the street (which I didn't hit) and they had a job for a store clerk?

Yes, because the grocery store is a fine place to nurse your baby while you work. Give it up already - admit that you fell into an opportunity that is virtually nonexistent. In fact, the more you defend your story, the more your story appears to be a complete work of fiction. I'm not accusing you of lying, just pointing out to you that if your story were true, one would suspect that you would be entirely cognisant of justhow incredibly rare theopportunity presented to you was. Instead, you want everyone to swallow that it could happen to anyone who sticks with their job search .... foralmost one entire day. Holy crap are you delusional - there are millions of Americans, even well educated professionals, who are spending 18 months or more to find a job, and sometimes when that opportunity does come along they have to move hours away to get it. It is virtually never as simple as walking through town, suffering a few rejections, and thentelling someone what a great worker you will be, and have them offer you more than you even asked for in return. In light of that, it's amazing the lengths some lengths liberals conservatives will go to in inventing fantasy scenarios to support their arguments when a real one conflicts with their ideology.

 
 
 
Pat N2
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Pat N2    13 years ago

This dude would pull up on his scooter and he'd have Chain saws strapped on his back...ropes tied to the back...and a rake or two in holders that he had fastened to the side. He had a toolbox on the backseat. It was the funniest shit ever!

I'm getting this image of sort of a "Rambo Landscaper" in my mind's eye. LOL!

In the end, I no longer try to make people understand. The blind can not see and nothing in the world can make them.

I agree. It's frustrating as hell. People want what they want, but they don't want to go through the pain to get it. Not only do I see it in everyday life, I see it in my work, too. Since this is a straight commission business, we rely heavily on motivators. Both long term and short term. It blows my mind how clueless some of the newbies I mentor are. And some of these peeps even have business degrees.

Part of their early on training is to pick a motivator...a goal...and figure out how they're going to get there. What they need to do. So when they say they're finished with that task, I'll ask them: "What's your motivator?" They will say something like: "Get into a new house." I'll say: "Great.What do you need to do to get there?"

That's when it all falls apart. They will say something lame like: "Stay on the phone". Or "make placements". Nothing detailed. They get a whole new perspective when I hit them with: "What is your current monthly expense? How much do you need to bill to just meet that monthly expense? How much extra do you need to bill to save for your motivator? What is your plan for not spending the money you're saving? What can you cut out of your current lifestyle to make it happen quicker? Based on the metrics, how many placements do you have to make to hit the revenue? Based on the metrics, how much phone time and how big of a client base are you looking at?"

They look a little freaked after that. They suddenly realize it's going to take effort on their part. The one's that are satisfied with entry level or mid level paper pushing for a "secure" salary but no real future...quit. The ones who prefer to make something out of themselves and don't expect others to do it for them, stick around and are successful.

I also see an amazing correlation. The ones at work who are comfortable with a boss "taking care of them" are also the same people who are comfortable with the government or someone else taking care of them. The one's who are cool with commission, self sufficiency and having no one to blame but themselves for success or failure, maintain that attitude in all aspects of their life. I realize it's probably not like that in all environments and that might be unique to a commissioned environment, though.

 
 
 
OttO
Freshman Silent
link   OttO    13 years ago

Ok Mark - let's put everyone through college. Or give me the start up money I need for my business. So long as everyone (minus the 44% who don't finish school and the significant percent of businesses that fail) is paying higher taxes lol.

I'm paying higher taxes than many and I haven't taken a dime in assistance so that kind of goes back to my point.

Many of us (including conservatives) oppose federal entitlement spending unless it's the kind of entitlement spending that we like, supports our pet projects or benefits us directly somehow. Then it's championed.

(Though I thought you said yours were due to loans - apples and oranges)

 
 
 
Pat N2
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Pat N2    13 years ago

It amazes me how often I (and others) am mocked for not having a college degree and then subsequently vilified for being successful and part of the "evil rich".

I wish they'd make up their minds.

In truth...unless you're going for a career where a degree is required (Dr., Lawyer, Nurse, etc)....they aren't worth the paper they're written on, anymore.

I can't remember the last time one of my hiring authorities "required" a degree for a senior level position. Even mid level. They tend to prefer the guy who has 4 years of experience in the industry, rather than 4 years of experience in a classroom.

 
 
 
wmolaw
Professor Silent
link   wmolaw    13 years ago

Being conservative women, we get it worse than our male counterparts since we are supposed to "get with the program" and believe that all conservatives want us to be barefoot and pregnant with no rights.

Blacks, other minorities suffer from the same hypocrisy!

 
 
 
Rose Gardener
Freshman Silent
link   Rose Gardener    13 years ago

I'm a progressive. You probably think I'm going to debate you. I'm not. Congratulations - honestly. You're hard work brought you a long way.

I've got a story as well, my story consists of a lot of hard work, people not believing in me and me pushing ahead anyway and believing in myself. My story is a story of success against the odds as well. And yet I am a progressive.

I recongnize the need for self-reliance, self-respect, the willingness to work hard (even at jobs we don't want to do), perseverance, belief in oneself... all of it.

I agree with this statement...

They recognize that what got them there wasn't anything anyone did to them, but rather what they failed to do for themselves. Whether it was taking advantage of educational opportunities, job training, not having a willingness to start at minimum wage scrubbing toilets or a whole myriad of other things.

I am a progressive because progressives make things like education and job training priorities. Progressives expect that minimum wage should be a living wage (not that folks shouldn't take minimum wage jobs). Quite the contrary some of the best skills I learned were in the first jobs I had.

Congratulations on your story ... honestly... but please don't make the assumption that just because a person is a progressive they don't believe in hard work, self-reliance, and all the other attributes you mention.

 
 
 
Rose Gardener
Freshman Silent
link   Rose Gardener    13 years ago

I would love to see some way that we could shorten the duration of welfare and take the money saved from that shortened duration and apply it to education, training, etc. There are literally thousands of jobs open right now for CNA's. Thousands for EMT's.

I just want to make one point here. I live in Wisconsin. Our conservative governor and legislature successfully slashed public employee's ability to negotiate for themselves in the work place. The conservatives also slashed budgets. The end result is that the only jobs available for EMT's in our state are now part-time or volunteer (no benefits).

One young woman I know put herself through college to become a firefighter/paramedic. She started before Walker and company took over. During her training she was volunteering for medium sized community about an hour north of Madison. They promised her they would hire her when she became fully certified.

Walker and company came in, did what they did to public unions and local budgets. This young woman graduated the following year. And the community told her they could only hire her for a part-time postion. That they were no longer offering new employees health benefits - because they couldn't afford to.

So... now she's got the education (and the student loans). She's been looking for a job in her field for two years and is not able to find one. She's looking outside the state of WI and running into the same story - public funding for emergency workers is being cut all over our nation. And in order to pay her student loans, she's working two jobs and still volunteering with local fire departments to keep her resume fresh.

So... those jobs were available - but slashing spending on first responders has pretty much nixed that.

Frown.gif

 
 
 
OttO
Freshman Silent
link   OttO    13 years ago

I absolutely agree. And that is why, as noble as it sometimes is to try and get a good degree, it's not a requirement that the taxpayer should have to foot. It's your agenda, you figure it out. Or do like the rest of us and wiggle your way into the work force.

As a country we need to start drawing lines in the sand...

 
 
 
Rose Gardener
Freshman Silent
link   Rose Gardener    13 years ago

My daughter, her husband and their 3 small children (under age 3) are living in my basement at the moment because he only makes $10 and hour and can't support them. He is qualified for more, but can't find a better job. They get medicaid to make sure those babies are well cared for. I don't mind that either. Meanwhile, he is doing online classes to better himself and he works lots of overtime hours and they are banking their money. This is what you do with a hand up, you make it pay off.

AMEN Deb

As a progressive - I don't see assistance of any kind (whether it be in the form of student loans, tuition grants, medicare, medicaid, or the untold numbers of corporate tax loopholes and subsidies) as something anyone "deserves" and doesn't have to work for.

The way this country spends its money is a sign of our priorities. For me the priorities should be to use our money on things like education, health-care, rebuilding our national infrastructure, making sure children have food on the table and roof over their heads, etc..

We are subsidizing low wage (poverty) wages of corporations and that is wrong. Working people are on welfare because they can't make it on $10/hour. I challenge anyone reading this to pay your own rent, utilities, food, and transportation costs on $10/hour (30 hours a week) because employers won't hire you full-time with health-benefits. You wouldn't be able to take care of yourself, let alone any children you might have.

You think it's wrong to use tax dollars for things like education grants, student loans, medicare, medicaid, etc???? How do you feel as a tax-payer letting businesses off the hook for paying a decent leaving wage?????

Demand that businesses pay a living wage - get the WORKING people off welfare first - then we'll have a discussion about the ones sitting around eating steak on your tax dollars and not working!!!!!!! (That last part is complete sarcasm. Contrary to popular belief most people on public assistance work - they just work poverty wage jobs, with no health benefits).

 
 
 
krounded
Freshman Silent
link   krounded    13 years ago

but you feel such a need to "protect" this politician that you are making silly demands that you're unwilling to provide yourself?

I only feel the need to respond to what you are saying.

You offered to provide the stats. It's hardly a matter of my "unwillingness'. Remember...I provided something.

Wait a minute. According to you, we didn't have 3 sucessive quarters of negative growth from the 1960's through 2004? WOW.

I don't even know what you are referring to. That's not my website. It only shows that the number of people on aid fell after the time you were going to go on it. That's it. WOW.

And what do "sociological factors" in your charts have to do with your demand for "recession factors" you're demanding from me?

Sociological factors are a result of the recession. You offered, no one demanded.

 
 
 
Rose Gardener
Freshman Silent
link   Rose Gardener    13 years ago

I'm liberal and I don't believe anybody can just 'drop out' and receive benefits. I don't know anybody who thinks they are entitled to cars either. The people I know that are having great difficulties are older people who can't get hired (yes, there is age discrimination) or they become part of the working poor because wages are so low. They have problems keeping food on the table because they have no way to factor in the extras like glasses for the kids or illness/injury. And sometimes people are doing their best and it is not enough. Some people make stupid decisions and some just have life dumping on them, not every thing can be controlled. I just prefer more love and acceptance and less criticism and judgement.

Couldn't have said it better myself - agree completely.

 
 
 
Rose Gardener
Freshman Silent
link   Rose Gardener    13 years ago

If their bonuses and following year budget is tied to success stories,

Bonuses??? Social Workers only wish.

Pat, how much time have you spent getting to know what social workers do? Either within non-profit organizations, or within government organizations.

I build databases for a living, and many of my clients are non-profits (I provide non-profit rates) and government agencies. I know many a social worker.

Most nope EVERY social worker I know has more case loads than she/he can handler. Whether in a non-profit setting or in a government setting they all have one thing in common, there are more people needing the help of social workers, than there are social workers to go around.

If you want to incentivize them to create success stories, give them time with their clients, so they can treat their clients like human beings rather than do assembly line social work.

If you're dis-satisified with the social services we currently provide in America, you may want to spend a bit of time talking to the ones who went into social work when they were young and idealistic and are now having to deal with the realities of a culture who doesn't value the work they do.

The realities of a culture who would rather throw people away then deal with the complex reasons people end up needing help in the first place.

The realities of a culture who think there are simple black and white answers to complex problems.

I know one social worker who quit her job and told me she could either be a social worker or she could be a mother to her children, but she couldn't be both. The weight of social work is very heavy, the demands of social work are extreme.

Success stories in the area of our social services will be a lot easier to produce when we start listening to those doing the work.

I'm all for insentivizing social agencies to get people OFF the system - but it's not as simple as doing something with their budgets. There is a lot more to it than that.

 
 
 
Pat N2
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Pat N2    13 years ago

Bonuses??? Social Workers only wish.

This is like the third time someone has said this. So just to set the record straight:

I stated that Jane paper-pusher typically doesn't see a bonus. But Director level and higher does. Government employees who oversee the social workers within the offices.

I hope I've clarified. If there is still objection to this, I can pull from several sites on the internet that talk about how ticked off employees in government provided Human Services office got when Obama cut government bonus structures back in 2010. And there are STILL 16 people in the higher echelon of that department making north of $112,000 in bonuses alone.

 
 
 
markpup
Freshman Silent
link   markpup    13 years ago

I agree with your observation case workers are grossly overloaded.

I have two family members who are chronic welfare recipients and in my estimation should be working, but they're good at scamming the system. I've known many others who are similar. One thing I see is it's the overload the case workers have which helps them get away with it - it's a lot easier to just keep someone going than do the work to really examine the case and help/incentivize/ push someone off. My relatives know this and it's part of their scamming.

To me having sufficient case workers would be a great way to help assure someone that shouldn't be on welfare isn't on it as well as helping people who really need help.

 
 
 
Rose Gardener
Freshman Silent
link   Rose Gardener    13 years ago

John, if you believe that it is "unrealistic" of me to (a) believe that temporary assistance should be available to those who truly need it and are making some effort to better their lives and (b) expect people to do what is necessary to obtain a skillset, even if it means starting in a low paying job...then I guess there isn't much more I can say and I declare an impasse.

I'm not John ..

But I am going to say this. I'm progressive and (a) and (b) are exactly where I am at. In addition I live near Madison, WI. You know the place that Scott Walker and Company label "Madison Liberals". Every single progressive I know would agree with (a) and (b).

In addition - Scott Walker (a conservative) doesn't give a lick about people who truly need it. If he didn't his policies would be a lot different than they are. I know familes who have lost BadgerCare for their children (I'm talking Children here - not adults who can work).

I know young people who have lost Badgercare and their employers don't offer it - nor do they pay wages that make it possible to buy insurance on the open-market.

And most recently - Walker is turning his nose up at money from the Federal Government to make sure those very people have health care - to say nothing of folks who are dis-abled, or elderly, etc...

Your (a) and (b) are things most people agree on (whether progressive or conservative). We simply have different approaches to solving the problems.

As a progressive I get frustrated with mis-conceptions just as you get frustrated with mis-conceptions folks have about conservatives.

Some of the mis-conceptions folks have about progressives follow:

  1. That we don't agree with the points you made on (a) and (be) .. we do.
  2. That we don't believe in hard work, self-reliance, self-respect, etc... we do.
  3. That we don't have "family values" that one really pushes my buttons.
  4. That we think government has all the answers to the world's ills .. we don't.
  5. That we think government is our baby-sitter ... we don't
  6. That we don't believe in honest capitalism - we do. I built my own business from the ground up and am quite successful because I believe in hard-work and competition and excel at both (thank you very much).

And that's just a short list of the mis-conceptions I get frustrated over. I am thankful for places like NT. These boards provide all of us an avenue to get to know each other and learn from each other (and challenge each other).

 
 
 
Rose Gardener
Freshman Silent
link   Rose Gardener    13 years ago

And just to set the record straight - my larger point is thus:

Changing the way you pay the top folks isn't going to change outcome. It's not that simple.

I'm thrilled Obama cut back on government bonus structures (I only wish the banks and other corporations would do the same when their top brass doesn't produce - but that's a whole other discussion).

But - bonus structures don't tackle the larger problem. Go back and read my post about the need to listen to the social workers on the front lines and the size of case loads they have. Until you tackle the real issues - the problems you are pointing out will not be solved.

Do you really believe Social workers are happy with the system as it is now? Do you have any idea what it is like to go into a career with the eyes of idealist only to end up in the situation most of our social workers are in. They want success stories as well... every bit as much as their clients do.

 
 
 
Pat N2
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Pat N2    13 years ago

Changing the way you pay the top folks isn't going to change outcome. It's not that simple.

Then it's a good thing that's not all I said we should do.

I believe I also mentioned that their budget is tied to how many people they have ON the system. Not how many success stories they have of getting people OFF the system. Therefore, the incentive lies with signing more people up. Not getting them self sufficient.

Which is why I proposed not only tying executive level bonuses to successes, but tying the budgets to successes as well. If we do that, there will be less people in the system, more people self sufficient and more money in the system to use for training, education, GED classes, resume writing and interviewing skills, etc. Stuff that will actually BENEFIT people, rather than giving them just barely enough to scrape by on month after month. It would also lessen the load of the typical worker in the department.

Do you really believe Social workers are happy with the system as it is now?

I'm getting a little weary of this line of question that implies I have some sort of axe to grind with the typical social worker. I've mentioned them no where, except to AGREE that they don't get bonuses. And the fact that these questions about social workers keep coming from you is beginning to make me suspect you're trying to start some sort of pissing match over them. I'm not discussing them because I don't know anything about them except they work hard at tough jobs. This is kind of like me asking you questions about the typical horse ranch hand over, and over and over again in an article about livestock as a whole.

I am focusing on the budget of the department, how it's applied and the senior level staff that implement it and offering solutions on how the system might be improved. What's YOUR solution?

 
 
 
Rose Gardener
Freshman Silent
link   Rose Gardener    13 years ago

Which is why I proposed not only tying executive level bonuses to successes, but tying the budgets to successes as well. If we do that, there will be less people in the system, more people self sufficient and more money in the system to use for training, education, GED classes, resume writing and interviewing skills, etc. Stuff that will actually BENEFIT people, rather than giving them just barely enough to scrape by on month after month. It would also lessen the load of the typical worker in the department.

In theory you make it all sound so simple. But it's not. 1stly tying budgets to successes has to also be combined with giving Social Workers what they need to build successes and encourage successes. And (I'm only guessing - but it's based on knowing plenty of Social Workers) my guess is most Social Workers would say that if you want more people self sufficient and more money for training, education, GED classes, you'd also better include more money to hire more Social Workers so their case loads are manageable.

If the case load sizes are not realistic you can throw all the money you want at education, interviewing skills resume writing, etc... and the results will still not improve.

And the thing is conservative Republicans do NOT support increase spending in these areas. They support slashing these budgets.

I'm getting a little weary of this line of question that implies I have some sort of axe to grind with the typical social worker.I've mentioned them no where, except to AGREE that they don't get bonuses. And the fact that these questions about social workers keep coming from you is beginning to make me suspect you're trying to start some sort of pissing match over them

Nope not trying to start a "pissing match" .. just pointing out the obvious. How do you feel when someone like myself (computer programmer) creates a new program and dumps it on your desktop without consulting you (the end user)?

I assume - from your story - that you've risen up in the business world and now supervise people? Do you make major changes to your co-workers or employees work environment without consulting them?

The reason I keep bringing up Social Workers is because they are on the front lines. The reason I asked if you think Social Workers like the system as it is now, is because the ones I know don't. They are fighting cynicism on two fronts.

  1. They are fighting cynicism because our culture does not appreciate or honor their work.
  2. They are fighting cynicism because a good number of the people on their case roles DO take advantage of the system.

What keeps them going is that they also help people, their successes give them purpose. They want more successes, just as you and I do.

I'm not discussing them because I don't know anything about them except they work hard at tough jobs.

Most American citizens don't know anything about them, that is why they need to be consulted on how to change the system.

I am focusing on the budget of the department, how it's applied and the senior level staff that implement it and offering solutions on how the system might be improved. What's YOUR solution?

My solution is as follows:

  1. Agree with you that there needs to be dramatic change, what we are doing now is not working.
  2. But.. remind you that it is not as simple as changing the way bonuses and/or budgets are handled (although I do agree that can be part of the solution).
  3. Remind everyone involved that (in general) the end-user knows more about how to change the system for the better than the developer (speaking in my language nowSmile.gif ). And strongly recommend that front-line social workers, people who have successfully graduated from the "system" and others be consulted to develop overarching "outcome goals" to measure success. DO NOT Depend on the top brass to do this - anymore than you would depend on the top brass in an IT department to build a user-friendly database.
  4. Build in flexibility - so that local governments have enough control to manage outcomes within the context of their own communities.
  5. And - very importantly - recognize going into the whole thing that case load sizes are a HUGE factor. Unless our culture is willing to spend the money to reduce case load sizes, all the above will NOT work. That is a simple reality.

Pat - I am not trying to "start a pissing match". I am trying to remind you of a basic concept when it comes to change. The folks on the front-line are most capable of coming up with valid solutions. THEY have to part of searching for a solution, they just have to be. If they are not brought in and listened to, if their case loads are not brought to manageable levels - any money we throw at it (as a culture) will be wasted.

 
 
 
Pat N2
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Pat N2    13 years ago

Most American citizens don't know anything about them, that is why they need to be consulted on how to change the system.

I agree that they do. But you know as well as I do,that when it comes to the government...change comes from the top. They don't give a rat's ass what the front line employees think will work any more than the top brass at the Pentagon gives a rats ass what the private on the front lines thinks. That's why I'm focusing on the top. That's where the change needs to begin.

Face it...the top echelon in human services is just as greedy as the top echelon in the private sector. If you dangle a specific carrot in front of their face...money....they are going to find a way to grab it.

If that carrot is directly tied to their own income and their budget in the form of successes, everyone wins.

A) The social workers have less of a load because fewer people are in the system.

B) The parasites that suck off of the system and abuse it are forced into change and doing something to help themselves.

C) The people in the system who need a skillset, education or interviewing skills get it, because with fewer people in the system, there is more money to give these people what they really need.

D) The top echelon is happy because they get their exhorbatant bonus and their depatment gets a fatter budget nxt year, potentially meaning higher salaries for the social workers.

E) The taxpayer feels like they are actually getting something for their dollar because they see the results.

 
 
 
Rose Gardener
Freshman Silent
link   Rose Gardener    13 years ago

Posting here - because your quoted comments didn't have a "reply"....

I agree that they do. But you know as well as I do,that when it comes to the government...change comes from the top. They don't give a rat's ass what the front line employees think will work any more than the top brass at the Pentagon gives a rats ass what the private on the front lines thinks. That's why I'm focusing on the top. That's where the change needs to begin.

Generally speaking, I would agree with you. But... there is another model that includes front-line employees. You may want to check out this article: Newark teachers union approves landmark contract offering merit pay...

The three-year deal, which awards merit pay to teachers who earn a rating of highly effective, was approved, 1,767-1,088, with almost 62 percent of those who voted supporting it. More than 2,800 of the nearly 4,700 union members turned out at union headquarters on Broad Street in Newark throughout the day to cast ballots.

The contract, which sparked strong opinions on both sides, will be the first in the state and one of the first in the nation to base teacher pay on classroom performance, including student progress.

Union President Joseph Del Grosso called it a step in the right direction for the teaching profession.

Im happy. Were finally going to have a say in our own destiny ... how were evaluated. Its the start of us getting back control of our profession, he said minutes after the votes were counted.

I believe we have taken a huge step toward raising student achievement, Superintendent Cami Anderson said in a statement. I am thrilled for our teachers here in Newark and for the teaching profession as a whole.

The vote was originally scheduled for Oct. 29, but was delayed because of Hurricane Sandy.

The contract uses the new four-tier teacher rating system being ushered in across the state. It includes a 13.9 percent salary increase over three years for those rated effective, with additional merit bonuses for those rated highly effective. Teachers who are rated as highly effective, who work in one of the citys lowest-performing schools and who teach a hard-to-staff subject, could earn as much as $12,500 per year in incentive pay.

Teachers would also have a say in the review process.

Now - it is not my intent to get off topic. My point is there is a way to include front-line workers and still demand accountability. Contrast that to the "top down" approach applied her in WI. Walker and company take away the rights of public employee unions to negotiate contracts. Now 2-years into this we have local school boards writing "Employee handbooks" with no input from employees. Some of the employee handbooks that have been in the papers are horrid - they have more to do with creating a dictatorial working and learning environment than student outcomes.

Some weeks back I had the chance to visit with my nephew who goes to a school district in a suburban community. His class sizes are now up to 30 (he's 14 years old). How well do you think his teachers can teach in that environment? I wouldn't want to try and control (let alone teach) a group of thirty 14 year-olds. Even at 14 he knows something is wrong, he knows that the teachers are overloaded and that some of the kids are ruining it for all of the kids.

All that because of budget cuts, top down decisions and very little (if any) teacher and parent input ....

Pat - I am not trying to start an argument. You and I agree more than we disagree. But if the only motivating factor for change within our social services systems is money pushed at the top echelon, than the failure will be massive. Because they will push people out of the system just to get the numbers they need for bonuses. They will push people out of the system without regard to personal circumstances, without attention to who needs to be there and who doesn't. They will not be discerning in any way with their top-down decisions. They will increase the "assembly line" mentality that already exists, rather than focusing on real solutions, solutions which help the people both you and I want to help.17.gif

 
 
 
Pat N2
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Pat N2    13 years ago

In the end, your progressive thinking does not account for the laziness of our society.

That's not fair! Just wanting something should be good enough! Other people have it! Betchya they didn't work for it! It just materialized in their life! I shouldn't have to work for it or sacrifice anything for it either!

Ya mean that kind of progressive thinking? Smile.gif

 
 
 
wmolaw
Professor Silent
link   wmolaw    13 years ago

True, add to that, the fact that the government should not just pay money, but provide the services, the home/apt to live in, etc. You give money to a person, there is no assurance, NONE, that it will be used for the intended purpose.

 
 
 
wmolaw
Professor Silent
link   wmolaw    13 years ago

@Rose:

The public unions should not be allowed to strike or collectively bargain, simple stuff.

Note, Wisconsin was going down the shithole. Walker has saved it, so far. One anecdotal example, a policy does not make.

Hell, even George Meaney didn't think public unions should be able to strike or collectively bargain. Can you not see the HUGE conflict of interest?

Hell, even FDR was on Walker's side of this debate!

 
 
 
wmolaw
Professor Silent
link   wmolaw    13 years ago

I'm willing to talk at a mature level

24.gif 24.gif 24.gif 24.gif 24.gif 24.gif 24.gif 24.gif 24.gif

 
 
 
Leotie
Freshman Silent
link   Leotie    13 years ago

Those are great stories, and inspiring. I understand all too well what you mean with them. I ended up homesess for awhile in the 90's. It made me madder than 40 hells, and I decided I was going to get out of that come hell or high water. I took a job cleaning houses, one led to another and another and so on. I had more than I could do by myself, so I went back to the shelter I was in and tried to get some of th women there to help me. NONE, NOT ONE of them wanted to work with me, even though they would have made decent money.

I did that for a long time, then moved back to NY where I knew I could make better money. My health had been not so good for a while, and I finally had to wuit to go on disability. I had been advised for 9-10 years to do that, but I refused for that many years. It got to the point that I had no choice, but I do miss working. It's hard, and it's depressing as hell not being able to work; anyone that CAN and WON'T is a leech in my book. Bottom line. And yes, I am a republican also.Grin.gif

 
 
 
Leotie
Freshman Silent
link   Leotie    13 years ago

Pat N., I read your story and first of all I want to say good for you for doing what you did; it screams volumes about your character. You have a right to be proud of yourself and you should.

I read Summer's story also, and the more I read, the more I wanted to scream at the top of my lungs in anger and frustration because of what I went through.

At 17 years of age, this state decided that the best thing it could do for me was to sterilize me against my knowledge and will during the eugenics fad that was going on. That was in 1965.

31 years later, I ended up in the ER with severe pain in my left wrist, and left with a diagnosis of lung cancer with orders to have surgery ASAP. I had no insurance and was told to go apply for medicaid. I did that and was asked the questions in this order: Are you pregnant, do you have minor children, are you a drug addict, an alcoholic, legally blind or mentally ill. When I had to answer NO to all the questions, the woman told me that there was no way they could/would help me. I asked her if cancer counted for anything, she said NO. I then called my state rep and asked for help, his answer was "Do you want us to take a child off medicaid so you can get help?" I called the governors office and the lady there told me that all I had to do was get pregnant and I could have anything I wanted. I had the surgery, ruined my credit because of it and found out that it was not cancer but came from an airborne fungus from when I lived in Arizona! But I lost half my left lung anyhow.

I thought about all the years I had put in working and paying a huge amount of taxes taken out as a single person, no dependants. Now, I was disabled, diagnosed with cancer and they essentially told me to F*** off!

So, Summer's story makes me want to puke. I read that, remembering what I went through, remembering when I was homeless, I was denied housing, medicaid, everything! I had no kids, so I was worthless to this government. Summer goes to school, get's housing and everything else because she has kids she couldn't afford at the time. I can just about guaranteewhen she does become a doctor,she will not be taking care of people with no money, (unless, of course, they have kids). Yeah, I'm angry over it. I researched it and found out that EVERY STATE IN THIS COUNRY TREATS WOMEN WITH NO KIDS THE SAME DAMN WAY.

 
 
 
Kim Lyvang
Freshman Silent
link   Kim Lyvang    13 years ago

Why was no contraception used? That would be your fault since you said yes. Also, he should have used a condom.

I am a liberal because I believe in education and equality.

Here is an answer why.

Knowledge is more important than faith.

 
 
 
Summer
Freshman Silent
link   Summer    13 years ago

Susan Williams, First, let me say I am so sorry that you had to go through that. It is my opinion that you should have been provided for during your time of need.

Second - I'm sorry my story makes you want to puke - however, I will say yes, I had two kids. I was married - my now ex-husband started drinking heavily, began using drugs and eventually became abusive all during the marriage. When I married him, he was NOT like that. I divorced him because it was an unsafe environment for my children and me. What did you expect me to do? Stay in an abusive marriage? Get divorced, but not go to school in order to improve my family's position in life?

I find it odd that some people seem to resent the fact that I did well enough to get into medical school and actually took steps to get OFF of assistance. It's odd because so many of these samepeople say work hard to improve your situation so that you don't need assistance - I did just that, and for some reason they seem to be angry that I actually have succeeded in doing just what they claim they want people to do.

btw - when I become a physician, I absolutely plan on providing care for people that cannot afford care, especially once my student loans are paid off and I can better afford to do it. In fact, if I ever get to the point where money is not a concern for me, I plan to entirely volunteer my time, skills and knowledge to people that are unable to afford health care. Prior to that, I do plan on working as much as I can afford to work in free clinics and providing services precisely for the people that cannot afford care.

Very nice of you to be presumptuous.

 
 
 
sixpick
Professor Quiet
link   sixpick    13 years ago

I would suggest the young lady see if she can get into the military choosing the branch she would most prefer first. She may be surprised that with the 4 year degree, I assume she has, she could also apply for officer's training school and become an officer. They have EMTs and firefighters as well. I googled EMTs and firefighters and it looked like 2 years of looking and not finding, maybe she is doing something wrong. I don't know. I'm not pursuing it, but what's wrong with the military?

 
 
 
sixpick
Professor Quiet
link   sixpick    13 years ago

You can, but I doubt you'll get a reply. Although I am at the bottom of this page and it may be on the next page. LOL.

Very damn good success story! You make me proud to be conservative. This is my philosophy: By all means help those that can not help themselves and help those that can.......... do it and stop the cycle.

 
 
 
sixpick
Professor Quiet
link   sixpick    13 years ago

Not really Hal.... I know I have more respect for someone trying to do their best. A person can tell if someone is sincere or just trying to get over. I'd give anyone a chance that looked like they were sincere and needed that chance. I'm a conservative and I wouldn't want to eliminate the opportunities for anyone willing to take advantage of them. and by opportunities I mean make their life better, because if they do that then they will make other people's lives better. We're not as hard hearted as the people you have been listening to have told you.

 
 
 
sixpick
Professor Quiet
link   sixpick    13 years ago

Folks.....this is the reason I got banned from NV. It may not seem to have anything to to with Pat's story but it does. How could anyone ban you for putting this up. You may be able to click on the avatar and see the whole article and see where I came in. I have most of the deleted comments from people that stood up for me before Dear Tyler deleted them. I never called anyone on the vine by a name or made a personal attack after 1.5 year and over 6100 comments. Here it is.

sixpick C Although I have put this on the vine a couple of times in the last year and a half, I received positive responses. I never received not one negative response. How could a nyone respond in a negative way to something so positive? I accidentally moved my star somehow in my formatting with 6 votes on this comment.

HELP ME LIVE MY LIFE THIS WAY

Ideas from a real good book by OG Mandino The Greatest Salesman In The World

After a time, sometimes we, without realizing it, dont put enough good thoughts into our heads, and thus allow bad thoughts to set up house. Here are some good things to make habits of.

When I feel bad, think only good thoughts.

I can only think one thing at a time. Why not make that thought one that enhances my life.

Anytime I have a bad thought, replace it with a good one.

Anytime I have bad feelings or thoughts, say to myself, "Cancel, cancel that thought!"

Abraham Lincoln said. "A person is just about as happy as he wants to be."

Never accept can't. Always realize can't never could.

Always realize, I am as everyone else. No one better than the other. No one worst.

Tell myself only the good things in life. Discard the things that dont make something or someone better off.

Try, hard as it may be sometimes, to feel no hate for another. And someday it will not be hard anymore.

Greet each day with love in my heart.

Bite my tongue when I am tempted to criticize.

Admire each person, for each has qualities to be admired, even though they may be hidden.

Love thyself. Zealously inspect all things that enter my body and mind.

Persist until I succeed. The prizes of life are at the end of each journey and it is not given to me to know how many steps are necessary to reach my goal. Failure I may still encounter at the thousandth step, yet success hides behind the next bend in the road. I will always take another step toward success.

I am natures greatest miracle. I am not on this earth by chance. I am here for a purpose and that purpose is to grow into a mountain, not to shrink into a grain of sand.

I will seek constantly to improve my manners and graces.

I will concentrate my energies at the moment at hand.

I am natures greatest miracle. I have been given eyes to see and a mind to think and now I know a great secret of life, for I perceive at last that all my problems, discouragements, and heartaches are in truth great opportunities in disguise. I will no longer be fooled by the garments they wear, for my eyes are open. I will look beyond the cloth and I will not be deceived.

With each victory the next struggle becomes less difficult.

I will live this day as if it is my last. I will not dwell on yesterday or tomorrow, only today.

Doubt I will bury with faith.

Today I will praise my loved one with sweet kisses. Tomorrow they will be gone and so will I.

I will live this day as if it were my last. And if it is not, I will fall to my knees and give thanks.

I will be master of my moods. My emotions will not be my master. For if my mood is not right I will be a failure. I will master my moods.

So that everyday is a happy day and a productive one, I will learn this secret of the ages. Weak is he who permits his thoughts to control his actions. Strong is he who forces his actions to control his thoughts. Each day when I awake, I will follow this plan of battle before I am captured by the forces of sadness, self-pity, and failure. If I feel depressed--I will sing. If I feel sad--I will laugh. If I feel ill--I will doubt my labor. If I feel fear--I will plunge ahead. If I feel inferior--I will wear new

garments. If I feel uncertain--I will raise my voice. If I feel poverty--I will think of wealth to come. If I feel incompetentI will remember past success. If I feel insignificant--I will remember my goals. Today I will be master of my emotions.

I will understand the moods of others. I will make allowances for their anger and irritations of today for they know not the secret of controlling their minds.

My knowledge of this secret will be my key to a greater understanding of life. Today I will be master of my emotions. Henceforth, I will recognize and identify the mystery of our moods in all mankind and in me. I will master my moods with positive action. And when I master my moods, I will control my destiny.

I will laugh at the world. No living creature can laugh, except man. I will cultivate the habit of laughter.

I will laugh and my life will be lengthened. For this is the secret of long life and now it is mine.

I will laugh at myself for man is most comical when man takes himself too seriously. Never will I fall into this trap of the mind.

Will my concern for this day not seem foolish ten years hence? Why should I permit petty happenings of today disturb me.

Four words I will train myself to say until they become habits so strong that immediately they will appear in my mind whenever good humor threatens to depart from me. These words passed down from the Ancients will carry me through every adversity and maintain my life in balance. These four words are: THIS TOO SHALL PASS. I will laugh at the world. For all worldly things shall indeed pass. When I am heavy with heartache I shall console myself that this too shall pass. When I am puffed with success, I shall warn myself that this too shall pass. Yea verily, where is he who built the pyramid? Is he not buried within the stone? And will the pyramid one day not also be buried under sand? If all things shall pass, why should I be of concern for today? I will laugh at the world. I will paint this day with laughter. I will frame this night in song. Never will I labor to be happy. Rather I will remain too busy to be sad. I will enjoy today's happiness today. It is not grain to be stored in a box. It is not wine to be saved in a jar. It cannot be saved for tomorrow. It must be sown and reaped on the same day and this I will do, henceforth.

Only with laughter and happiness can I enjoy the fruits of my labor.

I have the power to choose my own destiny.

Let me act now, even though my actions may not bring happiness or success, for it is better to act and fail than not to act and flounder. Happiness and truth may not be the fruit plucked by my actions, yet without action, all fruit will die on the vine. I will act now!

Never will I pray for the material things of the world. Only the guidance will I pray.

Help me count my blessing of today.

Guide me and direct me in the right direction.

Give me patience with others and myself.

Help me to live this day as if it is to be my last.

Help me to remain humble.

Allow me the courage to laugh at my misgivings.

Silence me from gossip.

Guide me in my words that they may bear fruit.

Discipline me in the habit in trying and trying again.

Bathe me in good habits that the bad ones may drown.

Grant me compassion for weakness in others.

Suffer me to know that all things shall pass.

Fill my cup with love to turn strangers into friends.

Guide me, help me and show me the way. Let me become all you planned for me when my seed was planted and selected to sprout in the vineyard of the world.

... This is my link for the comment.

  • 6 votes Notice I received 6 votes in favor of it and a star. Do you think any of these people gave me a positive vote? No. So many people read, but dont post. There are far more liberals than conservatives on here right now. They all condemned me. I did nothing wrong. This looks like it took a couple of screens but it didnt. Several of the comments below were on the same screen.
 
 
 
Perrie Halpern R.A.
Professor Guide
link   Perrie Halpern R.A.    13 years ago

Susan,

The fact that you were treated so poorly because you didn't have kids, shouldn't make you angry at Summer, it should make you angry that no hospital near you would take you on. Here in NY, if you are homeless you get medical care free of charge. On the other hand, I paid for years into both my fed taxes, FICA, etc, and had my own insurance and still had to pay out $36,000 for my medical care, in a single year and I have kids. Obviously someone intervened on your behalf, since you ended up getting surgery, but you shouldn't have been treated like a cast away either.And I agree that there shouldn't be a double standard for single people without kids.

You don't know Summers story. All you know is that she had kids. We shouldn't make snapjudgementabout people without hearing their story. And I agree that there shouldn

 
 
 
Pat N2
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Pat N2    13 years ago

That still doesn't negate what Mike said, John. If it did, then all of your opinions that you arrived at based on your own life experience, wouldn't mean a thing.

Any abuses you were privvy to that caused you to disrespect a company? Doesn't mean squat. Your opinion is null and void. Any exploitation by the rich that you believe was wrong? Again, your opinion and conclusions wouldn't mean squat.

I personally believe your life experiences DO matter. And without them and the conclusions you've drawn from them...you wouldn't be who you are today.

 
 
 
Pat N2
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Pat N2    13 years ago

i have yet to meet a conservative that remembers they are conservative once they take office.

I've met one and only one. And they were on the local level. This is her. Retired Brig. General, Jodi Tymeson. She was a Rep in the Iowa House and now leads the Dept. of Veteran Affairs. She has a pretty amazing story as well.

 
 
 
Deb G.
Freshman Silent
link   Deb G.    13 years ago

"But I'll throw my lot in with the group that shows some level of compassion rather than the sink-and-die crowd that rewards the fabulously wealthy while gutting the middle class and poor with scams and intolerance."

This is the sentence that prompted my remark of "MOST conservatives ARE middle class, not wealthy my friend." And yes, when answering what you said above, I did mean it with sarcasm. Your remark implies that conservatives are the "sink-and-die" crowd and lack compassion. Sorry, being a very compassionate and generous person and ALSO a conservative and also know many many other compassionate conservatives, I may take a bit of umbrage with that comment. They are not by any stretch of the imagination the people you paint in that remark. Again I tell you to look up some real statistics and you will see on PERCENTAGE of income, conservatives give much much more to charity than liberals do.

Also, being as most conservatives are also Christians, it is in our religion to give at least 10% of our income to charity. HARDLY the "sink-and-die" crowd.

 
 
 
Pat N2
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Pat N2    13 years ago

Again I tell you to look up some real statistics and you will see on PERCENTAGE of income, conservatives give much much more to charity than liberals do.

Yep. And liberals have an average income thats 6% higher than conservatives. So I never did understand their meme that conservatives are the "party of the rich".

 
 
 
Rose Gardener
Freshman Silent
link   Rose Gardener    13 years ago

Again I tell you to look up some real statistics and you will see on PERCENTAGE of income, conservatives give much much more to charity than liberals do.

As someone who works with numbers and databases day-in and day-out I've found one consistent truth. Data (like many other things) shows us what we want to see. You all may want to check out the this study: Who Really Gives? Partisanship and Charitable Giving in the United States

Charitable contributions are the lifeblood of many nonprofit organizations; however, little attention has been paid to how political attitudes affect donations. In this paper, we first show that conservatives and liberals are equally generous in their donation habits . This pattern holds at both the individual and state level, and contradicts the conventional wisdom that partisans differ in their generosity. Second, we show that while levels of giving are roughly equivalent, liberals are much more likely to donate to secular organizations, and conservatives are more likely to donate to religious causes , especially their own congregation . Finally, we examine the dynamic relationship between political control and individual partisanship. We find that charitable contributions fluctuate based on the political landscape: Democrats (Republicans) donate less money when a Republican (Democrat) occupies the White House. Conversely, having a co-partisan in the White House increases the average and total donations to nonprofits at the state level. In addition to furthering our understanding of partisan bias, our findings demonstrate that the results of a presidential election could have significant consequences for nonprofit organizations and the populations they serve.

When you all find a meta-study which shows that conservatives give more to charity than liberals do, then come talk to me. After years of working with data, one study (showing either point of view) does not make objective fact. N ot even a few studies can show conclusive proof, that's why meta-studies were developed.

Secondly - and I really want to emphasize this point - there was a time in my life when I belonged to a church. I am no longer a member of a church. Al though - I still donate a good percentage of my income to charity, I do not donate to a church. And there is a difference in my mind between supporting a local social services organization which works with families in crisis and supporting a church where most of the money goes to the church itself, building upkeep and m aintenance and paying a pastor's salary.

There is a major difference. On the whole, over 85% of the money I give to charity now goes directly to easing the pain of other human beings. When I was giving most of my donations to the church over 85% of the money was used to maintain the church and provide for church salaries. There is a difference, it is substantial. And even if a meta-analysis showed that conservatives gave more to charity (and I don't believe it would), the fact that most of what they give goes to church salaries for church staff and keeping a facility up, diminishes any difference.

 
 
 
Pat N2
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Pat N2    13 years ago

When I was giving most of my donations to the church over 85% of the money was used to maintain the church and provide for church salaries.

That's all fine and dandy...but even your own highlighted portion from your source says "conservatives are more likely to donate to religious causes, especially their own congregation".

It does not say church. And I respectfully submit that you are interpretting "church" because it says "congregation".

Fact of the matter is, many hospitals, (ie: St Judes) are part of the Catholic Church. Many soup kitchens, battered womens shelters, missions, St. Vincent thrift shops, etc...fall under the scope of a religious organization.

The treatment and the halfway house that I mention in this article were under the umbrella of a religious organization. So if your telling me that I have conservatives to thank for that more than liberals, then so be it.

But personally? I thank whoever contributed a dime to it. And find this bickering about who's political party is more "generous" a hair obnoxious.

Newsflash for all. Charity comes from the heart. Not from the D or R on your voter registration card.

 
 
 
Rose Gardener
Freshman Silent
link   Rose Gardener    13 years ago

Newsflash for all. Charity comes from the heart. Not from the D or R on your voter registration card.

And there you and I agree - completely.

One other note - I've read many comments in this thread about common misconceptions, generalizations and stereotypes attributed to Conservatives.

Conservatives, in general, would get a lot more of my sympathy if they allowed for the fact that they harbor their own misconceptions, stereotypes and biases about Progressives.

We are all human - we all have our misconceptions and stereotypes. One of the things that attracted me to NT - after leaving NV - is folks seemed a bit more civil here. They still do (for the record -you seem very civil). But ... if this board is going to grow a real community, we might all be better off if we look in the mirror and own up to the stereotypes we harbor about those who are different from us.

You started this thread to explain why you are a conservative. It is a valid point of of discussion. But ... it is also a beneficial discussion to ask the Progressives on this board why they are progressive. Every human has their story, the path they took. And their path is no less valid than yours.

 
 
 
Pat N2
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Pat N2    13 years ago

But ... it is also a beneficial discussion to ask the Progressives on this board why they are progressive.

Believe me. I tried. Only two people stepped up to the plate. Both girls. One name I will metion since she is here in this thread...(Summer) and the other will remain anonymous since they aren't here. And I respected both of their stories.

I think it's important for all of us to remember that regardless of political persuasion, many here get up to a screeching alarm clock, get the kids ready for school, trudge off to jobs (that some of them hate), worry about how to pay the bills, cringe every time they fill up at the pump, come home, spend time with the kids, help them with homework, send them to bed with a kiss, have hopes, dreams and fears.

A (D) or an (R) does not exempt a person from any of it. An (R) does not mean a person is "for the rich" or heartless and a (D) doesn't mean a person is lazy or on entitlements.

I had a real eye opener on this just this evening. Someone who knows I have a couple of neurological issues was reduced to saying: "Maybe it's time to get that CAT scan scheduled, Pat". In response to a stupid political debate.

If that's how far the divide in this country has gotten...there's no hope.

 
 
 
Rose Gardener
Freshman Silent
link   Rose Gardener    13 years ago

Believe me. I tried. Only two people stepped up to the plate. Both girls. One name I will metion since she is here in this thread...(Summer) and the other will remain anonymous since they aren't here. And I respected both of their stories.

Pat - thank you. I'm new here and not familiar with that thread. People may be hesitant to "step up to the plate" for a few reasons.

  1. With the influx of new members (refugees from the vine) they may not yet feel comfortable enough in their new "home" to share.
  2. Also - with the general animosity in this country between all political persuasions folks may fear being attacked.

I will tell you one bit of my personal story (only because it is applicable to this discussion). I am a private person - which is one reason I don't tell my whole story. And under normal circumstances would feel no desire to participate in an online discussion board such as this. At Newsvine, I mostly seeded and didn't discuss. The anger over there just irritated me.

But NT attracted me because of its civility. I am trying to participate more in discussions for a personal reason. I come from a VERY conservative extended Catholic family. My parents and siblings, my husband and children are all progressive. But my cousins are as conservative as they come.

I am hoping to get some insight into my own family in "safer" discussions with people I'm not related to. I can't discuss some things with my cousins - we're family the history is just too much.

For example, I've a brother who is gay. He and his partner have been in a loving and committed relationship for years. Their relationship means as much to them as my relationship with my husband means to me.

And a few cousins (in particular) have said and written some very hurtful things over the years. And what's really sad is that I don't think they even know how hurtful they've been. They are so caught up in their religion, they can not see the pain they've caused other people.

For once, I'd like to find one place, where I can have a frank and honest discussion with a conservative and search for peace (instead of righteousness).

 
 
 
Pat N2
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Pat N2    13 years ago

For example, I've a brother who is gay. He and his partner have been in a loving and committed relationship for years. Their relationship means as much to them as my relationship with my husband means to me.

And a few cousins (in particular) have said and written some very hurtful things over the years. And what's really sad is that I don't think they even know how hurtful they've been. They are so caught up in their religion, they can not see the pain they've caused other people.

I want to preface this by saying I subscribe to no religion and am about as bare bones Deist as a person can get. My entire religious philosophy can be summed up in one sentence. "There is a God and I'm not it".

So being a neutral third party, and without knowing your cousins, ny first question would be: "Who is civility more important to?"

If it's your brother and his partner, then they need to be the one's to accomodate and redirect. If it's your cousins, then making the mend is up to them.

While I completely understand the relationship between your brother and his committed relationship...I also understand that your religious cousins believe their very existence rests on the tenets of their faith. That's a pretty heavy thing.

Even if you don't believe their existence rests on their belief system...or I don't...it doesn't matter. They believe in their relationship with God as much as your brother believes in his relationship with his partner. Neither one is wrong and both view the others position as a personal affront..

So. An Impasse.

Which is why it needs to be reduced to: "Who's it more important to?"

Write an article on it. I think you'd be surprised at the other input you get.

 
 
 
Rose Gardener
Freshman Silent
link   Rose Gardener    13 years ago

"Who is civility more important to?"

My cousins would say civility is VERY important to them, my brother and his partner would as well, and so would I. I don't discuss the issue with my cousins (nor do my brothers and sisters) because of our desire for civility. On a very few occasions I a have "said my piece" but only to put an end to self-righteous and hurtful behavior. And when I've "spoken my piece" I've done it in a way that reminds them we are all children of the same Grandparents and we've a duty to honor the compassion and love our Grandmother and Grandfather taught us.

But ... all that was not my point. My overall point was the following:

For once, I'd like to find one place, where I can have a frank and honest discussion with a conservative and search for peace (instead of righteousness).

This country is divided. Religion is used to pit one group of people against another group. Money and Power dominate our elections and electoral processes (Citizens United opened up the flood gates). The discrepancy between the wealthiest and poorest in this country is the largest it's been in over 50 years.

We have real problems, that affect 98% of Americans, and yet we are allowing ourselves to be divided by those who would use religion and social issues to convince us we're enemies.

Our politicians are dysfunctional (to say the least) and most people on discussion boards spend more time siding with the politicians they voted for, than with the 98% of people in this country that are just trying to get through life. 17.gif

 
 
 
Pat N2
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Pat N2    13 years ago

This country is divided. Religion is used to pit one group of people against another group. Money and Power dominate our elections and electoral processes (Citizens United opened up the flood gates).

I agree that the country is divided more than ever before. But you're starting to play the blame game again. The religious. "Citizens United".

And I refuse to go there.

Until you can accept others...completely accept others...whose religious beliefs and political affiliation differs from yours, you can't reaslistically accept them to accept yours.

Someone has to take the first step. It can be you.

If you want.

I personally, can't be that person. I've taken an honest character assessment, know my faults, and know I will always be the sum total of my life experiences and the beliefs that come with them.

So be homest with yourself. Can you truly give up the stereotypes that you want others to give up?

Remember...by saying "yes" to that question, you are saying you can willingly set aside the very beliefs by with you live your life. The core of what makes you, you.

If you aren't willing to do that, you can't expect it of others.

 
 
 
Rose Gardener
Freshman Silent
link   Rose Gardener    13 years ago

Pat:

I agree that the country is divided more than ever before. But you're starting to play the blame game again. The religious. "Citizens United".

And I refuse to go there.

How is citing the effect of "Citizens United" playing the blame game. Factually speaking - Citizens United opened the flood gates of money in our campaigns for ANYONE with MONEY in this country. (It did not differentiate between liberal and conservative corporate spending - it simply opened the flood gates and allowed it ALL in). That's just a simple reality. And as far as where the spending is coming from ... there's plenty ... ... of blame to go around. It is not limited to one party or one political view point.

To say nothing of the fact that most people in this country, regardless of political persuasion, think there is too much money in politics and want more controls on campaign giving and spending.

So... your assertion that I'm "the blame game" is off base. Corporations and Unions (and other artificial entities) wouldn't spend money in campaigns if they didn't feel they'd get something in return. That's just simple common sense.

Until you can accept others...completely accept others...whose religious beliefs and political affiliation differs from yours, you can't reaslistically accept them to accept yours.

Someone has to take the first step. It can be you.

If you want.

Some days I'm gracious enough that it can be me. Other days, not so much.

I personally, can't be that person. I've taken an honest character assessment, know my faults, and know I will always be the sum total of my life experiences and the beliefs that come with them.

The "sum total" of yours (and my) life experience has not yet been calculated, Pat. And it won't be calculated until we are laying in our coffins.

I assume you intentionally participate in these types of on-line discussion boards for a reason? If you were the type of person who only cared about hearing what you already believe echoed back to you, the last thing you'd do is start a thread entitled "Why I'm a Conservative".

The title of this thread lead me to believe that you are an open-minded Conservative, one willing to accept the legitimacy of other people's experiences and work towards (at the very least) getting to know each other, finding each others humanity.

So be homest with yourself. Can you truly give up the stereotypes that you want others to give up?

Remember...by saying "yes" to that question, you are saying you can willingly set aside the very beliefs by with you live your life. The core of what makes you, you.

If you aren't willing to do that, you can't expect it of others.

If I weren't willing to have my own stereotypes challenged, why would I have responded to this thread, entitled "Why I'm a Conservative"?

If you weren't willing to have your own stereotypes challenged, why would you have started the thread???

 
 
 
Pat N2
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Pat N2    13 years ago

Some days I'm gracious enough that it can be me. Other days, not so much.

It has nothing to do with graciousness. It has to do with being willing to completely set aside the very ideology that guides your life. Your sense of right and wrong. The principles you live buy.

Because that's what you're asking others to do. Set aside their ideology in order to accomodate others. Your cousins, for example....believe that homosexuality is a sin and that knowingly committing a sin without repenting will lead to an eternity of damnation. They believe this as much as you believe you need air to breathe.

But because you don't believe as they do, you want them to set aside their strongly held beliefs in order to accomodate someone else. You can't realistically ask someone else to do that without being willing to do it yourself.

Since you say you can be gracious enough on some days, but not so much on others, then that's really all you can expect of them.

 
 
 
Rose Gardener
Freshman Silent
link   Rose Gardener    13 years ago

It has nothing to do with graciousness. It has to do with being willing to completely set aside the very ideology that guides your life. Your sense of right and wrong. The principles you live buy.

It has everything to do with graciousness. One can not set aside the "ideology that guides ones life, ones sense of right and wrong, the principles one lives by" without grace. In fact one definition of grace might just be the willingness to set aside our personal beliefs and principles in order to become more intimately acquainted with another human being.

Because that's what you're asking others to do. Set aside their ideology in order to accomodate others. Your cousins, for example....believe that homosexuality is a sin and that knowingly committing a sin without repenting will lead to an eternity of damnation. They believe this as much as you believe you need air to breathe.

Pat ... let's be clear. I am not asking my cousins to do a darn thing. In fact, when I first brought my cousins up it was as an example of a personal situation where I did not feel I could talk to them. I specifically said ...

I am hoping to get some insight into my own family in "safer" discussions with people I'm not related to. I can't discuss some things with my cousins - we're family the history is just too much.

For the most part I refuse to get into political conversations with my cousins, because my first expectations in dealing with them is that we are family. That we owe it to our common heritage to love each other in a transcending way, one that puts politics aside and remembers that we played together as youngsters, that our parents are siblings, that our grandparents (Grandmother and Grandfather) were two of the most compassionate and accepting people that we (as cousins) have ever known. That if we can accept our common heritage - it is from there that we will learn to accept our differences, to not judge. This is a daily struggle for me (and I am sure for them).

So... what I was trying to say had little immediately to do with my cousins and more to do with why I am trying to participate in more on-line discussions like this. It's safer here, I don't have to worry about damaging intricate family relationships.

But because you don't believe as they do, you want them to set aside their strongly held beliefs in order to accomodate someone else. You can't realistically ask someone else to do that without being willing to do it yourself.

I don't expect my cousins to do anything except follow the Golden Rule - and I expect that of myself as well. I can realistically ask any other human being to treat me with the same respect and dignity that they expect for themselves, and I can strive for the same from myself. The Golden Rule transcends all cultures and all religions. It is a universal human principle and one that we are all capable of living up to (in our most gracious moments).

Since you say you can be gracious enough on some days, but not so much on others, then that's really all you can expect of them.

That's all I really expect of anyone. We are all human are we not? As my mother says, "Most of the time, most people are doing the very best they can do".

But back to my questions for you ...

If I weren't willing to have my own stereotypes challenged, why would I have responded to this thread, entitled "Why I'm a Conservative"?

If you weren't willing to have your own stereotypes challenged, why would you have started the thread???

 
 
 
Pat N2
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Pat N2    13 years ago

That's all I really expect of anyone. We are all human are we not? As my mother says, "Most of the time, most people are doing the very best they can do".

Then I'm not sure why you have a problem with your cousins. You stated that they don't even seem to know how mean they are being. So that tells me there is no malecious intent behind their words and they are in fact, being gracious, per their definition of the word.

All that would be left is that you want them to drop their core values. And you are saying you don't want them to do that. So this situation with them should be a non issue.

If I weren't willing to have my own stereotypes challenged, why would I have responded to this thread, entitled "Why I'm a Conservative"?

Again, I'm not talking about having your stereotypes challenged. That implies that you believe in your core values strong enough that you can defend them with confidence. I'm talking about exactly the opposite. Being willing to GIVE UP your core values if you want others to do the same.

If you weren't willing to have your own stereotypes challenged, why would you have started the thread???

Again, as I stated earlier, I most definately AM willing to have them challenged. And I refuse to waiver from them. That's why I am willing to have them challenged.

But I don't have the same situation you have. I'm stubborn in my own core values and have no plans on changing them for someone else. Likewise, I don't expect anyone to change their core values for me.

I also have a family member that drives me batshit crazy with their stance on things. But it is what it is. They aren't going to change their core values for me, and I'm not going to change mine for them. And that's as it should be. So the next question was....."Who's it more important to?" I deciced that *winning* the debate was more important to Rick than it was to me, so I was the one to step up to the plate, take the high road, allow him to *win* and we now get along fabulously.

 
 
 
Rose Gardener
Freshman Silent
link   Rose Gardener    13 years ago

Then I'm not sure why you have a problem with your cousins.

Pat - again - to clarify - I don't have a problem with my cousins (in the sense that I expect them to change.) All I expect from them is to treat me (and my siblings) the way they want to be treated themselves. That's it. I learned a long time ago that they are not going to change (thanks in no small part to the graciousness of my own parents who taught me to simply accept them where they are at).

The ONLY reason I brought up the situation with my cousins is to point out why I am intentionally participating in conversations like this. These conversations are simply safer, I don't have to worry about damaging intricate family relationships. That's it ... very simple actually.

All that would be left is that you want them to drop their core values. And you are saying you don't want them to do that. So this situation with them should be a non issue.

Saying any family relationship is a "non issue" is comical. Family relationships are some of the most complex and complicated relationships there are. For better or worse we are plunged into a group of people with whom we may (or may not) share common interests and beliefs. And it is those very relationships that teach us how to love unconditionally, to accept others where they are at, and expect the same in return. It is these very relationships that teach us the meaning of grace.

Again, I'm not talking about having your stereotypes challenged. That implies that you believe in your core values strong enough that you can defend them with confidence. I'm talking about exactly the opposite. Being willing to GIVE UP your core values if you want others to do the same.

The willingness to have ones beliefs challenged also implies a willingness to let go of (or give up) core values - if those values are shown to be failing in some way. That is why I made this statement:

The "sum total" of yours (and my) life experience has not yet been calculated, Pat. And it won't be calculated until we are laying in our coffins.

I assume that you plan on maturing and growing throughout the rest of your life? If we both plan on maturing and growing, we may very well be called upon to GIVE UP some of our core values before we let go of life itself. I am prepared to do so, when (and if) any of my current core values are shown to be failing in some legitimate way. If I were not willing to entertain the possibility of changing my mind about some fundamental things, why would I even have a conversation with someone like yourself (who sees the world through a different lens)? Why would you even be willing to have a conversation with someone like myself? (Unless of course you want to "convert" me - and you don't strike me as that type of individual).

 
 
 
Pat N2
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Pat N2    13 years ago

Pat - again - to clarify - I don't have a problem with my cousins (in the sense that I expect them to change.) All I expect from them is to treat me (and my siblings) the way they want to be treated themselves. That's it.

How are they not doing that? Given their faith, I'm sure they would want someone to let them know if something they were doing was considered an abomination against God's will.

The willingness to have ones beliefs challenged also implies a willingness to let go of (or give up) core values -

Actually, no. Read a little from the Dalai Lama. Relinquishing one's way of thinking and core values is an internal process if it's going to be genuine. It's based on enlightenment. Not what someone else says to you.

If we both plan on maturing and growing, we may very well be called upon to GIVE UP some of our core values before we let go of life itself.

I agree. To an extent. Which is why I'm urging you to rethink your cousins and realize they ARE treating others the way they want to be treated. They just aren't treating others they wayYOU think others should be treated.

Here's an example:

I personally, will not change my mind about religion based on a religious fundamentalist spouting scripture at me or by a well meaning athiest telling me God is no more real than the Easter Bunny. Ain't gonna happen.

So that takes the "change your thinking" thing out of the equation. What's left is merely debate on the issue.(Challenging ideals, that we mentioned earlier).

Since we are now down to only debate, eventually, the debate has to end. I DO have a choice on how that debate ends. I can either continue beating my head against the wall, expecting the other person to conform to what I think is the "right way to act", I can allow the debate to die a natural death and simply refuse to continue it, or I can relinquish the debate to the other person.

Are you willing to stop doing the first one with your cousins and look at one of the other two choices?

(side note: the only reason I keep using your cousins as an example is because you mentioned them as a good example of what were discussing).

 
 
 
Rose Gardener
Freshman Silent
link   Rose Gardener    13 years ago

(side note: the only reason I keep using your cousins as an example is because you mentioned them as a good example of what were discussing).

Just as a clarification - I mentioned my cousins as an example of why I will NOT have frank political discussions with my family members. I come here because it is safer to have frank political discussions.

"Pat - again - to clarify - I don't have a problem with my cousins (in the sense that I expect them to change.) All I expect from them is to treat me (and my siblings) the way they want to be treated themselves. That's it."

How are they not doing that? Given their faith, I'm sure they would want someone to let them know if something they were doing was considered an abomination against God's will.

I did not say they weren't doing that - at least from their own perspective. On the very few times I've felt the need to "speak my piece" it has been with gross dis-respect. IE... using a family newsletter that goes out to literally 100s of people in this country and others .. to spout their political views. The email newsletter is specific in nature, when it was started it was specifically stated that the newsletter was a way for us to stay connected - it was NOT for political debate. And the reason that was stated up front was BECAUSE we have a large and diverse family with many different political and religious positions.

My most conservative cousins started the email newsletter, declared up front that the newsletter should remain free of political and religious debate and then the minute a presidential election comes along - toss the rules they made up out the window.

So...YEP ... I stepped up, called them out, reminded them of their own rules, reminded them of the GOLDEN RULE, reminded them that we are all descendents of two people who taught us through their actions of the need for compassion, open-mindedness, and accepting others for who they are (our Grandmother use to say - on quite a frequent basis - "God makes every person the way they are for a reason"). And I would do it again.

Actually, no. Read a little from the Dalai Lama. Relinquishing one's way of thinking and core values is an internal process if it's going to be genuine. It's based on enlightenment. Not what someone else says to you.

So you like the Dalai Lama as well. Smile.gif

I agree with you - relinquishing one's way of thinking and core values is an internal process, if it's going to be genuine.

I would only add that one encounters many folks s/he disagrees with along the road to Enlightenment, and those encounters cause us to look deeply within ourselves.

Since we are now down to only debate, eventually, the debate has to end. I DO have a choice on how that debate ends. I can either continue beating my head against the wall, expecting the other person to conform to what I think is the "right way to act", I can allow the debate to die a natural death and simply refuse to continue it, or I can relinquish the debate to the other person.

Are you willing to stop doing the first one with your cousins and look at one of the other two choices?

Pat - I stopped doing the first with my cousins a long time ago. Which is why I said earlier in this conversation, that I rarely discuss politics or religion with them. It literally is NOT worth the energy - and I say that in complete seriousness.

__________________________

And ... now - even though we're having a snow day here in Madison, WI ... I must go to work. That's the downside of having a home based business. Talk to you later.

 
 
 
Pat N2
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Pat N2    13 years ago

Rose...starting a new thread for this discussion, since the "reply" button is so far back:

I come here because it is safer to have frank political discussions.

Isn't that what we're doing?

I did not say they weren't doing that - at least from their own perspective. On the very few times I've felt the need to "speak my piece" it has been with gross dis-respect. IE... using a family newsletter that goes out to literally 100s of people in this country and others .. to spout their political views.

Then I don't get why there is a problem. (A) You believe they are treating others as they want to be treated. (B) You believe they have no malecious intent behind telling others their political beliefs. (C) Yet you admit to having occasionally, shown them gross disrespect. (Which indicates malecious intent)

So...YEP ... I stepped up, called them out, reminded them of their own rules, reminded them of the GOLDEN RULE,

I can see reminding them of their own rules. But as you admit, you did it with gross disrespect. Since the golden rule is important to you, should you then logically expect gross disrespect in return? If you had gently reminded them of their own rules...maybe the response would have been gentler.

And ... now - even though we're having a snow day here in Madison, WI ...

Small world. I'm originally from Manitowoc. Smile.gif

 
 
 
Rose Gardener
Freshman Silent
link   Rose Gardener    13 years ago

Yet you admit to having occasionally, shown them gross disrespect. (Which indicates malecious intent)

Smile.gif

I did not say they weren't doing that - at least from their own perspective. On the very few times I've felt the need to "speak my piece" it has been with gross dis-respect. IE... using a family newsletter that goes out to literally 100s of people in this country and others .. to spout their political views .

OK .... (Laughing because I can see the syntax of my sentence would cause confusion) ... when I said "gross dis-respect" ... I meant on the part of my cousins. They started the family newsletter, they announce at the beginning that it was to be free of political &/or religious debate, they affirmed at the beginning that we are all descendents of two wonderful grandparents and that the newsletter should be used to build relationships instead of destroy them, and then when the first presidential campaign starts (after the newsletter is up and running) they throw all their own rules and words and cautions out the window.. That is the "gross dis-respect" that I am talking about. ;)

My response to them - in that situation - was carefully worded. In fact, it took days for me to word it and send it off. (Like I've said before, I don't talk about things like this with them because it's not safe. There are bigger family relationships to take into consideration ... elderly aunts/uncles and parents to begin with. So... when I responded I was intentional in my wording and brought up the line my Grandmother used to say so often, "God makes every person the way they are for a reason". And then I reminded them that ALL of her Grandchildren are who they are for a reason - ALL of us - no exceptions. With that I ended my response and my response ended their misuse of the family newsletter.

Small world. I'm originally from Manitowoc

Wisconsin is a wonderful State, it is not my birth State, but I can't imagine ever leaving it. I've become extremely fond of the people and the culture and the beautiful geography.

 
 
 
Pat N2
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Pat N2    13 years ago

OK, so I gotta ask.

When you view your cousins in your mind, do you view them from the position of: "these are good people. I choose to see the good in them and any commonality we may share, focus on that, and ignore things they do or say that I don't agree with." Or do you view them from the position of: "What they did was wrong. They violated their own rule. And I must be my brothers defender and the defender of everyone else in the family that may not share my cousins political views".

 
 
 
Rose Gardener
Freshman Silent
link   Rose Gardener    13 years ago

When you view your cousins in your mind, do you view them from the position of: "these are good people. I choose to see the good in them and any commonality we may share, focus on that, and ignore things they do or say that I don't agree with."

Pat - family relationships are not that cut and dried. For the most part I remember some of these cousins as the youngsters I used to play with, and how much simplier it was when we were children. I remember what my Grandmother always told us... "God makes every person the way they are for a reason".

I remember the lessons my own folks have taught me about non-judgement and accepting others for who they are.

I try to live up to those ideals, some days I'm more successful than others. On days I'm not so successful I can be judgemental. On other days I can be pretty pragmatic.

Or do you view them from the position of: "What they did was wrong. They violated their own rule. And I must be my brothers defender and the defender of everyone else in the family that may not share my cousins political views".

The particular situation I talked about above (family newsletter) none of what you said. When they first used the Newsletter to push their political and religious views, I saw it come through my email, read it, rolled my eyes and closed the email. Then email responses started coming through from other cousins. (My brother and other siblings stayed out of it, as I did, until they pushed the wrong button).

The cousins who did respond were supportive of the rights of same-sex couples. At one point my conservative cousin, who was trying to defend his position after another cousin asked how same-sex couples were hurting him, or his family said he, "didn't want his children exposed" to same-sex couples. He didn't want his kids to see same-sex couples "kissing" or showing affection.

That is when I stepped in because my children have grown up with my brother and his partner as their Uncles. And my children are better for it. I stepped into the "very heated debate" at this point, and explained how blessed my children are to have their uncles, and then I defaulted to the overall big picture, that the newsletter was set up with rules and that we are all descendents of two wonderful people who taught us to be respectful and accepting of other human beings and if they wanted the newsletter to be free of political and religious debate and strife, then they needed to heed their own advice.

I would do the same thing all over again, I would take the same amount of time to word things as carefully as I could. I would feel the same hurt and anger at their actions, but I would try very hard to rise above it, to the wisdom of my parents and grandparents. And I hope they would do the same for me.

 
 

Who is online

afrayedknot


104 visitors