╌>

Representation without Taxation. Have we gone too far?

  

Category:  News & Politics

Via:  polly-cooper  •  13 years ago  •  34 comments

Representation without Taxation.  Have we gone too far?

This country started a veritable revolution because we were being taxed without having representation in government. Remember the Boston Tea Party?

Well, now we've gone to the other end. 49% of Americans HAVE representation in government - very VOCAL representation - without the burden of paying Federal Income Tax.

I say we've gone too far. You don't pay at least $1 in Federal tax, then you're not entitled to "Representation".

And please don't give me any crap about the "poor" not being able to pay that $1 a year. I'm sure they would be able to save a measly dollar out of the thousands of dollars of entitlements they receive


Tags

jrDiscussion - desc
[]
 
Polly Cooper
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Polly Cooper    13 years ago

Logic has flown out the window. What happened to fairness?

 
 
 
luther28
Sophomore Silent
link   luther28    13 years ago

In truth in would seem that we have representation without representation.

I no longer know whom it is our government represents, but for sure and certain it is not us, or me at least. My train of thought tends to be less reactionary, quite a bit saner and I do not create moments of crisis where none exist, but that is me.

 
 
 
Polly Cooper
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Polly Cooper    13 years ago

Government represents special interest groups. That it all

 
 
 
JoAnne Odel
Freshman Silent
link   JoAnne Odel    13 years ago

i could not agree more. with no skin in the game, there is no sacrifice for "the greater good"

check this out:

Dr. Ben Carson (about whom Chris Matthews said "who the ______ does he think he is")

likened a flat tax to tiding in the Bible.

he is absolutely correct. no only would everyone have skin in the game, but it would be much harder for DC to increase taxes if we all had to pay!

 
 
 
luther28
Sophomore Silent
link   luther28    13 years ago

Yup and with it went fairness.

 
 
 
Andrew-116
Freshman Silent
link   Andrew-116    13 years ago

Everyone's personal income taxes are at the lowest rates in years, however even those people who nominally pay zero in income taxes are still paying payroll taxes, which pay for the biggest line items in the federal budget anyway, social security and medicare. If you want to talk about specific exemptions that should be eliminated then lets talk about concrete changes that should be made rather than just demonizing the awful 47%. I personally think the mortgage deduction should go away in principle, though I recognize that probably half the home owning public has their finances currently set up in a manner that they would be bankrupted if it was suddenly eliminated, so I think it should probably incrementally disappear rather than simply be axed immediately to satisfy a principle. Similarly at a time when the cost of the food stamp program is going up year after year, eliminating the child tax credit would probably result in additional costs somewhere else, so if you're going to eliminate that particular credit make sure you have plans in place to deal with what it will do to families across the country.

 
 
 
Polly Cooper
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Polly Cooper    13 years ago

Yeah, that's the "argument du jour", they still pay payroll taxes. If that was ENOUGH, then NONE of us would pay income tax. Again, lets say nobody pays less than $1 which means no family would get back $8,000-$13,000 that they never paid in the first place.

 
 
 
Perrie Halpern R.A.
Professor Guide
link   Perrie Halpern R.A.    13 years ago

When your work deducts taxes from your check, you have paid into the system. If you are single and made $100 for the year, you have paid $11 to theGovernment. If your employer has taken more than that out of your check, you get money back. If they have not, then you get nothing back. So, everyone pays federal taxes...

Not sure? Here is the 2012 table:

 
 
 
Polly Cooper
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Polly Cooper    13 years ago

Everyone does NOT pay Federal INCOME tax. Read that again because I am talking specifically about Federal INCOME tax. If you do not pay you should not be able to play.

And while we're at it, lets go one step further. If you pay $700 in those other taxes - medicare, etc and get back $10,000 in federal INCOME tax refund, have you actually paid in anything? I think not.

 
 
 
AmericanDreamsShattered
Freshman Silent
link   AmericanDreamsShattered    13 years ago

Lets see the facts and numbers, about those who pay no INCOME TAXES!

 
 
 
Andrew-116
Freshman Silent
link   Andrew-116    13 years ago

Not everyone pays property tax either, that doesn't mean renters shouldn't be able to vote in town elections. Not everyone pays gas taxes, that doesn't mean they shouldn't have a say in where a road is built. Not everyone pays capital gains taxes, but they should still have a say in market regulation. Everyone pays some taxes. The people you're saying shouldn't have a say pay thousands of dollars in payroll taxes, sales taxes, property taxes, and state income taxes every year. Saying they shouldn't have a vote because they don't pay one tax that you do is ridiculous. Many of the wealthiest in this country only pay capital gains and no income tax - should their vote be censured? Frankly what you're suggesting, that the right to vote should be dependent on paying a particular tax is in violation of the 24th amendment anyway. No pay - no vote is essentially a call for a poll tax, something we did away with in this country fifty years ago.

 
 
 
AmericanDreamsShattered
Freshman Silent
link   AmericanDreamsShattered    13 years ago

Here,Here! Spot on!

 
 
 
bondibox
Freshman Silent
link   bondibox    13 years ago

they still pay payroll taxes.

Indeed. Since the GOP Congress has spent the SSI and Medicare surpluses as part of the general fund, with no intention of paying them back, the whole premise of this article is bunk.

OTHERWISE, it's really saying that Congress should honor all earned benefits program debts.

 
 
 
J W Welch
Freshman Silent
link   J W Welch    13 years ago

I'll never understand how someone can get a refund far in excess of what they may have paid in taxes.

Where does one sign up for this giveaway?

 
 
 
Polly Cooper
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Polly Cooper    13 years ago

To all of you who keep blah blah blah, everyone pays some taxes, blah blah blah... lets get back to the REAL problem here. 47% or 49% depending on which source you use pay NO FEDERAL INCOME TAX. When I'm in Canada and pay sales tax on a souvenier does that mean that I should be able to take part in their political process? Get real people. And AmericanDreamsShatters, it's really easy to google this, but I'll help you with the chart from 2011 showing the groups who had no tax liability:

Here, you won't even have to look at the link (because I suspect you don't want to learn the truth)

Who pays income taxes?

Here is the entire report from the Tax Policy Center.

 
 
 
Polly Cooper
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Polly Cooper    13 years ago

Yes I would.

 
 
 
Buckeye Voter
Freshman Silent
link   Buckeye Voter    13 years ago

Not only that, but the relatively modest tax break that the poor enjoy was bribery for giving the rich greater tax breaks.

 
 
 
Buckeye Voter
Freshman Silent
link   Buckeye Voter    13 years ago

Over charging the working class for SSI helped offset lowering the taxes for the wealthy.

 
 
 
Buckeye Voter
Freshman Silent
link   Buckeye Voter    13 years ago

Why is this a problem? What was the breakdown in the past?

As many people have pointed out, there are myriad taxes that we pay, for all levels of governance. The Constitutionally-protected right to vote is not subject to denial on the basis of income level or as a matter of tax law.

 
 
 
Buckeye Voter
Freshman Silent
link   Buckeye Voter    13 years ago

We aren't in danger of being unable to defend ourselves against foreign attack. That's just silly.

 
 
 
Polly Cooper
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Polly Cooper    13 years ago

And the discussion is right back to blah blah blah blah. I'm sorry, Buckeye voter, but exactly what is so difficult about the concept that I am speaking EXCLUSIVELY of Federal Income Tax. If it's no problem that half of America doesn't pay any, then I suggest that 100% of America should pay none.

 
 
 
Polly Cooper
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Polly Cooper    13 years ago

Well this has absolutely positively NOTHING to do with Federal Income Tax. But since you brought it up, why not look into the SCOTUS decision back in the 1930s that said Social Security could NOT have a "trust fund" and that everything had to be paid from the General Fund. It was part of the whole "is Social Security Constitutional" issue. But hey, don't mean to muddy the waters with technicalities and legalities here.

 
 
 
Polly Cooper
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Polly Cooper    13 years ago

Red Herring and pretty much bullshit if you look at the chart I posted

 
 
 
Buckeye Voter
Freshman Silent
link   Buckeye Voter    13 years ago

If it's no problem that half of America doesn't pay any, then I suggest that 100% of America should pay none.

That is an irrational argument.

 
 
 
Polly Cooper
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Polly Cooper    13 years ago

Its about as rational as your argument that paying sales tax is the same as paying income tax. They are not the same now and never will be.

 
 
 
Perrie Halpern R.A.
Professor Guide
link   Perrie Halpern R.A.    13 years ago

I'll never understand how someone can get a refund far in excess of what they may have paid in taxes.

You can't.

 
 
 
Polka-san
Freshman Silent
link   Polka-san    13 years ago

Income tax should be abolished. So no, our freedoms should not be tied to paying the state. That is very authoritarian of an idea.

 
 
 
Polka-san
Freshman Silent
link   Polka-san    13 years ago

Good. The US should be disarmed.

 
 
 
volfan
Freshman Silent
link   volfan    13 years ago

 
 
 
retired military ex Republican
Freshman Silent
link   retired military ex Republican    13 years ago

For one month just allocate what ever your local, unemployment check woud beand use it to pay rent buy food clothes for the kids shoes. School supplies school class trips. Are their avenues of help food banks go see what they have on their shelves you cannot buy it but have a look usually they will be more than helpful.

The federal number given out is 1 in 5 chiildren don't have enough to eat. People who have lost their homes have no place to live. Familys Sleeping in the car yes it still exists. Just how much should a person who makes 13,000 dollars a year pay in. Unemployment ran out for many. Some like my daughter works two jobs. Still in the poor catagory.

Some of those who pay nothing make over $100,000 or $200,000 or more per year thats not big money not any more. Tax loopholes favor those who make the most isn't that backwards. The Deficit gets bigger we cut taxes on the rich to hope they will spend more of that money. The few I know send it to the Caymens directly to their accounts.They won't eat any morethey employ nobody don't need to.If you beat the Goverment out of the money thats neat. Those who make so little still pay gas tax, fuel oil tax, Ohio tax on bottled water soda. Tax on clothes tax on everything but food like you and me. No sanitary sewer tax or is there. Property tax tax on phone bill tax on electric bill so of what tax are you speaking. Federl Tax I would guess. The 1$ they would pay would be a much higher percentage of their income than what the top 3% pay. Do the Millionaires draw social security the money thats a safety net you bet your ass they do they invest it doubtfully in US of A maybe India China Cambodia Russia, 152 + other countries where they get max dollar return without paying any taxes.

 
 
 
Buckeye Voter
Freshman Silent
link   Buckeye Voter    13 years ago

A dollar paid in income tax and a dollar paid in, say, gasoline tax is still a dollar. In that sense, yes they are the same.

Their impact on the economy, however, may be very different - since sales taxes are (typically) regressive and income taxes are (usually) progressive in nature.

But a buck is a buck. Both go towards the function of our country.

You, also, didn't state why any of this was a problem - you just asserted that it was. Why is it a problem that 47% of the USpopulationdoes not qualify for paying income tax?

 
 
 
Buckeye Voter
Freshman Silent
link   Buckeye Voter    13 years ago

Yes. Irrational.

If [this thing] then [this other thing] isn't a logical argument, lacking a causal element.

 
 
 
Buckeye Voter
Freshman Silent
link   Buckeye Voter    13 years ago

The size of the US Navy versus thenaviesof other countries is...?

The optimum size of the US Navy is...?

At what readiness level is the US placed into military jeopardy?

Yes, I called your assertion silly.

 
 
 
Polly Cooper
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Polly Cooper    13 years ago

Oh, for chrissakes, people, do some investigation on the Dept of Def and sequester spending:

"If sequestration does go into effect, DOD will have to cut from March 1 until the Sept. 30 end of the fiscal year about $46 billion from the level of funding provided on the fiscal year 2013 continuing resolutio n. The continuing resolution is funding the Defense Department in the absence of a budget that Congress and President Barack Obama can agree on.

By law, Little said, the sequester will apply to the entire DOD budget, including wartime spending, but excluding all military personnel funding , thanks to an exemption that Obama said he would grant. The DOD current estimate, Little added, is that the cuts will amount to 9 percent.

The law also mandates that the cuts be applied in a rigid, across-the-board manner, account by account, item by item, the press secretary said.

For the investment portions of the budget, he added, the dollar cuts must be allocated at a line-item level of detail. That means more than 2,500 programs or projects that are separately identified as line items [must] be reduced by the same percentage.

So that's about $7.5 billion per month for 6 months. Divide that by 2500 projects each getting cut 9% and you don't have that fucking much to whine about!

AND, if you want to see EXACTLY what we're talking about, why don't you take a look at the 2013 DoD Budget Release by the DoD?

 
 

Who is online

afrayedknot


104 visitors