DADT - DoD Extends Benefits to Same Sex, Unmarried Couples.
I predicted this on Newsvine. And when I predicted it, I was told that I was being melodramatic and was using it as an exuce for my "bigotry against gays". I was read the riot act by liberals who claimed that gays just wanted EQUAL opportunity to serve and weren't looking for any "special" rights.
I'm owed an apology. Because I was right.
The DoD has now extended benefits to same sex, unmarried couples that are not available to opposite sex, unmarried couples. Not only is that a "special" right, it is a ludicrous additional expense at a time when we are drastically cutting the military budget.
Our military is a joke these days. This administration has taken the strongest military in the world and reduced it to a political experiment.
http://iava.org/blog/department-defense-extends-some-benefits-same-sex-partners
The DoD announced that additional benefits will be available to service members and their same-sex partners who sign a Declaration of Domestic Partnership. This declaration must be signed by both a service member and their partner and states that they are in a committed relationship to one another, share a significant measure of each others common welfare and financial obligations, and have and intend to have a common residence unless prohibited from doing so by the service members military service. Signing this declaration will make same-sex partners and children of same-sex partners eligible for benefits such as receiving a military ID, access to base commissaries, child care programs, and other benefits. The DoD said that all of these changes will be implemented no later than October 1, 2013. Other benefits, such as access to on-base housing, still remain under review.
Tags
Who is online
108 visitors

Rebecca met a new guy in the Army. He's an MP. Gosh. I wonder what would happen if they approached their respective C.O.'s and demanded childcare, disability and death benefit compensation.
Sorry Pat..... "Political Experiment"?
The military has led the way in our society since the introduction of the Tuskegee Airmen, and the 761st medium tank brigade in WWII. Integration followed during the Truman years, and the military continues to lead by example as to what our society should be.
Pat I know better than to call you a racist, because I know that you're not, but when are you and others of the conservative persuasion going to allow this country and our people to become that which our constitution says we are? In other words... equal in every sense of the word!
Regards to you my dear.
Kind of a catch 22 here.
Straight couples can get married.
In most states, gay couples can't.
I would say thesensiblething to do, is grant benefits only to those who can get married. The rest not.
But you can't complain if you don't support gay marriage, since like I started, it is then a Catch 22.
I would adjust that a little bit to read..."grant benefits to those who can get married and DO". Or extend benefits to unmarried straight couples. As it sits right now, it's a special right.
You're right Mike.... There are always small minded people that people that think that every step closer to being equal under the constitution is a step closer to the sky falling.
My favorite was a second-class enginman from Mississippi who over beers admitted that he knew that racism was wrong, but he couldn't change because that wasn't the way he was raised. Your comment and thinking is right there on par with that.
Bullseye, Mike. The original intent of the DADT repeal was to allow gays to serve openly in the military. Period. Nothing more, nothing less. They could no longer be kicked out for admitting openly that they were gay.
And as predicted...that's morphed into special rights.
Imagine if you will....
Homosexual couple meets three months ago. One is depoyed and is tragically killed in combat. The other is automatically entitled to survivor benefits for the rest of their life, merely because they signed a sheet of paper saying they were in a "committed relationship" prior to deployment.
Heterosexual couple has been in a monogomous relationship for 3 years. One is deployed and tragically killed in combat. The other is NOT entitled to a penny of benefits because it doesn't matter if they were in a committed relationship.
NOPE! Nothing unequal there! Nosiree!
What a joke. It's gotten to the pont that I hope Rebecca ISN'T successful in her MEB hearing on March 18th. I feel sorry for her having to be exposed to this nuttiness that's focused more on being politically correct and appeasing special interest groups than it is, the defense of the nation.
Then solve the problem.... Let same sex couples get married in all 50 states.
You owe the very way life you live to people of all different races, religions, and yes, sexual orientation that have put their lives on the line for this country. Many of them made the ultimate sacrifice with their lives. And you want to sit there and bitch now the shoe is on the other foot for a change? Hypocrisy can never taste very good when you are forced to swallow it.
Just as a reminder.... it wasn't too long ago that women were not allowed to be pilots, or be in command of ships, or even allowed into the service academies. I guess women were never special interest groups either? By your logic, women can't or shouldn't be allowed to defend the nation.
I hate being exposed to hypocritical conservative nuttiness everyday too.
I've always been against differing rights for American citizens. To me, telling 2 people who love each other that they can get married while telling 2 other people who love each other that they can't is as un-American as it gets. That being said, 2 wrongs do not make a right. If you allow these rights to unmarried gay couples then they must be allowed to unmarried heterosexual couples. If not, you are merely replacing 1 injustice with another.
Talk to the Waffler In Chief about that one. He refuses to enforce DOMA but also refuses to repeal it. And until he does...this is a case of special rights in the one area that none should exist. EVER.
"Special rights" have no place in our military. Especially when the come at a huge expense during a time when we're supposedly cutting expenses.
And that's supposed to make me say: "Hey! Lets give certain politically correct groups special treatment over those nasty ol' straight people!" With all due respect, Fly...it looks like Mike is right and you have some sort of guilt complex going over your complicity to the racism you saw in the service, you have guilt over it and to make that guilt go away, you believe we should give every special interest group that comes along, special rights.
Newsflash for ya, babe....so did many heterosexual partners in monogomous relationships. But you don't give a rats ass about their parters.
Get over your white, heterosexual guilt complex. Or at least quit projecting it on others.
Exactly. And to take it one step further, here in Iowa, we have gay marriage and you don't have to be a resident of the state to get married.(don't know about the other states)...If these two soldiers really love each other and want to be entitled to the same benefits as married, heterosexual soldiers, apparently they don't love each other enough to take a day or two of leave, come to Iowa and get married.
Un-equal rights? How many conservative... heads up their ass states refuse to acknowledge same sex marriage? The issue Pat brings up wouldn't be an issue if everyone was willing to live up to the ideals of the constitution. Inequality..racism.. it's all the same. American citizens being treated differently because it was okay to do that yesterday.
And no... the engineman had just been at mast because of his racist uttering, we were just discussing his bruises from the ordeal. Hell I got a Chief busted down to E6 in 1983 because he called my LPO a "Flip". He made a mistake in thinking the other guy with me was racist too just because he came from Georgia.
Inequality is just that, and it doesn't belong in America.
EXACTLY.....! Inequality should be Un-American.
Then you AGREE that unmarried same sex couples in the military should not be afforded benefits over and above opposite sex, unmarried couples in the military.
Good to see you're coming around.
No guilt complex here Pat..... just disgust with many of my fellow Americans that scream "Injustice" at the the least little thing when they can politicize it.
Either you are "all in" so to speak in equality or your not. Which is it Pat? Are you one that walks and talks it, or are you still locked into the thinking that "some are more equal than others."?
Wrong! Gays could still be kicked out if they said they were gay. DADT only prohibited the military from harassing or discriminating against closeted homosexuals, and prohibited the military from investigating a person's sexual orientation. Likewise, a service member could not disclose if they were gay or bisexual. If they did, then they run the risk of being discharged from military service.
What "special rights" would those be?
Any legally married spouse of a service member killed in action is entitled to survivor's benefits!
The president cannot repeal a law. Only the SCOTUS can repeal laws passed. The president is well within his authority to not defend DOMA however.
The only reason you posted this article is to politicize it. If we were still talking a bout gay partners not being given benefits, we wouldn't hear a peep out of you.
My biggest problem with Gays in the military is the idea that by walking on others rights you have leveled the playing field. Since when is inequality equal to equality?
You force young Soldiers, Sailors and Airmen to have to strip in front of those who are homosexuals; you force them to shower with them and yet NO ONE would dream of makingheterosexual men and women get naked or shower together.
If they made it equal, they would give everyone of them (all military personnel) their own rooms, births and tents. Allow them thier privacy they all should have.
Can I borrow your crystal ball when you're done with it?
No shit sherlock. Because it would be no different than straight partners not being given benefits. Which would be...(wait for it)....EQUALITY.
The problem is, if a gay couple marries in a state which allows gay marriage, the federal government still will not recognize such a marriage under DOMA. Likewise, a gay marriage will not be valid or recognized in a state that doesn't allow gay marriages.
Apparently not when it comes to military benefits. Because they are now awarding those to gay couples who are merely courting.
If gay couples want the same military benefits as married straight couples, then take a couple days of leave and shag your butt to IA, NY, WA or MA and get married. Is that too much to ask of people who supposedly love each other?
Or could it quite possibly be that they want the "vindication" of special rights, don't want the "hassle" that goes with marriage and want to leverage their stance as a poor, poor *oppressed* minority group?
I'd wager a gay couple seeking military benefits will have to show documentation that they are legally married, just like any other couple. So far, you haven't specified what 'special rights" they are getting.
Substitute the word "Negros" for the word homosexual, and extrapolate from there. That was the thinking back in the second world war. The fight we are having about the LGBT crowd in the military is the exact same fight that was taking place in the 1950s when the services were fully integrated.
As I said in an earlier post....Don't forget that it wasn't long ago that women were not allowed into the service academies, or a host of other areas in the military. We don't think twice about a woman landing a F/A-18 on a carrier today do we?
Sure..... but I never have to use it when you are involved in a conversation.....with one exception....
Let me be more clear...... You could care less if gays were not being awarded the same benefits as straights because in your world.... (wait for it).... that's the way it should be.
Too true!
Oh horse shit. Not even the same!Not even close. Now you are grasping at straws as you try to ignore the differences between homosexuals and heterosexuals is SEXUAL.
Homosexualsprefertheir own sex for sex and hetrosexuals prefer the opposite sex for sex.
There is no difference between forcing heterosexual men and women to strip naked and shower together, then there is for homosexuals to strip and shower with their own gender.
And perhaps you should have read myentire post before commenting. I did not say ban it. I said ban it until you can be truly leveling the field.
Think about it. What a wonderful way to tell our troops thank you by improving their lives with individual rooms. Not to mention stimulating the economy and doing it WITHOUT walking on anyone's privacy rights.
Oh horse shit yourself.....That was EXACTLY the same thinking back in the 1950s.
And for some new news to you.... Homosexuals and heterosexuals have been stripping and showering in front of each other for a long time, or have you been in a cave since DADT was implemented?
Individuality is frowned upon in the military. It's why they make us buy our own uniforms
Bullshit Mike and you know better. You know what a fight it was to integrate the services.
"Negros are not capable of operating technologically advanced equipment such as an aircraft or a tank." was what was stated when the reality of it was that many didn't want to have to bunk and mess with the black soldiers. You hide it well, or is it that 50 years later, you have come to terms with a racially integrated military? By extrapolation I'm guessing we will have to wait another 50 years for you to come to the same conclusion about integrating LGBTs into the military.
The only lies being perpetuated Mike are those of the religious right which you are forced to support. To do otherwise would force you to admit that there is something greatly wrong with the present day GOP.
The do was assumed. The other choice is to go by common law marriage rules. In states that still have it on the books, it's usually 7 years and that would go for both straight and gay couples.
Mike,
Why is that a false comparison? What is your rational?
Until the late 1960's
Did they have to live in the closet to have a normal life. Yes.
If you were known gay were you refused a job. Yes
Are they allowed "civil union" so that they can protect their partners? No. (I won't even go near marriage for the sake of this conversation.
Gays make up 1/10 to 1/9 of the population in the US. That isn't such a minority, given that blacks make up 17% of the population.
Being black is like being homosexual not because of a share American experience, but because of the discrimination against them. Only the M/E and Africa have the same attitude about them. Is that your meter stick? I hope not.
It's just as much for you to prove your case as it is for me to prove mine. Besides, I'm not an ilk... I'm not even an elk.
First of all, I couldn't care less. I can't fathom that comparison. You made the leap from recognizing a gay union to doing away with sex-segregatedbathrooms?
No. It's a state of being. Not something they can change. A physical structural difference of the brain.
OK, with that logic, let's go with Jews. They don't wear their religion on theirsleeves. They only get discriminatedagainst if they tell someone, or if someone was a whiz with Jewish last names. They make up about 2 % of the US population. Is it OK to discriminate against them? Or should they hide theiridentity?
Kind of gets a little gray sometimes, doesn't it?
FLYNAVY,
I am with you and Perrie on this one.
Since two people of the same sex cannot get married legally in many states, the Army is granting benefits to those who can't be married on paper but in all respect, are married.
I am saddened by the conversation here. Honestly.
You are mixing up cause and effect. Black people are black because their genetics tell their bodies to produce moremelanin.
Gays are gay because the structure of their brains are constructed in such a manner, that their nerotransmitters are different and so they areattractedto their own sex. BTW, I like science. Here is the science behind this:
Mike, hopefully it doesn't end with attitudes like yours. I think Armed Forces uniforms should be the same for both sexes and as far as I can tell, the different uniforms only apply to dress ones. When our troops are in combat the uniforms are all the same and soldiers, men, women, gay and straight all bleed and die the same. Like AeonPax said; "Equal Rights Are Not Special Rights".
Wrong on both points. The Adminsitration does enforce DOMA (which is why they are being sued in Federal Court), they just aren't defending it in court. The President cannot repeal anything. That would take an act of Congress or nullification of the law by theSupremeCourt. The Court did agree to hear arguments on DOMA this year.
I was in 10 years. 4 Army and 6 shipboard in the Coast Guard. I could care less who was looking at me in the shower.
How is it possibly the same thing? Go ahead and educate me on blacks, whites and how they compare in sexual orientation.
You are making a ton of assumptions that are completely wrong. For example:
Right. Like someone who retired from the USAF doesn't know that they give you an allowance for your uniforms or as if some one who was chosen for an elite group in Inventory Management wouldn't know that Flight suits (which are also a uniform) are paid for by the military.
Your answers seem to point to someone who is an officer. If so, then you haven't got a clue what it is like to be enlisted.
"And for some new news to you.... Homosexuals and heterosexuals have been stripping and showering in front of each other for a long time, or have you been in a cave since DADT was implemented?"
Really? So doing wrong makes it right? DAMN! You must be an officer.
I never asked, though looking at things logically - some may have, some may not have and there were probably some that, like me, didn't give a shit.
So where did me or Mike say Gays were stupid?
So using your rule with something I said....
Negroesprefertheir own sex for sex and
hetrosexuals prefer the opposite sex for sex.
See....it doesn't work.
Mike,
I have never joined in the armed forces. I know. I give an opinion that I don't have experience with.
I DID and still am doing for my country what I believe to beMY patriotic duty, which is teach in a public school in an inner city. It is my patriotic duty to serve my country and guarantee a strong future by being a teacher.
Yet, people who aren't teachers comment on my job all the time.
That being said, I seriously doubt a gay manthat is enlisted want to wear a skirt that the enlisted women wear. It is against the military code or rules.. and it isn't ok.
This isn't about that.
We are talking about the fact that since gay or lesbian couples can't legally marry in many states,they are asking for same sex benefits.
I would like to think that gay or straight, any enlisted person in the armed forces gets what they ask for. They deserve it... they deserve our grattitude and respect, because they are giving theirlives in service to the United States.
Peace.
E
Oh, so true Erinn. I too did over 20 years in a inner city school. It's amazing the how much people who never set foot in a classroom seem to know more than I or you do about what our jobs are like day to day.
Sorry Pat, I know off topic rant. You can have me delete it. I won't mind.
Mike... there have been gays in themilitaryall along. They are not dressing in drag. What do you expect to change? Frankly, if it was to go one way or another, I would think that it's woman who would start wearing pants all the time. It's just more practical.
Then you didn't bother to read the article I linked. Or bother to research the topic yourself.
Bottom line is that the military is indeed, extending certain benefits to unmarried gay couples that they are not providing to unmarried hetero couples. All the couple has to do is sign a document attesting to being in a "committed repationship". Yep unmarried straight couples don't get that option.
There is no way to twist this. It's a special right.
Is that all you have left for an argument, Fly? Trying to tell me what I think? What's next, standing in the corner, bottom lip out, stomping your feet?
Let me make this reeeeaaaal easy for you. Here is what I think. I'll try not to use too many multisyllabic words so you can grasp it.
If gay couples in the military want the same benefits as MARRIED straight couples in the military, then they need to get married as well.
If we are going to extend benefits to gay couples that aren't married, then we need to extend those same benefits to hetero couples that aren't married.
Gee. How "unreasonable" of me.
Erinn..if two people love each other, what is preventing them from going to any one of the many states that don't require residency for gay marriage? They can go to IA, WA, MD, NY.
Obviously, the marriage thing doesn't matter to the military, or they wouldn't be extending these benefits to UNMARRIED COUPLES. What do you find so unreasonable about the military saying: "If you want married couple benefits, take a couple days leave and go to one of the states you can get married in". Then we will provide you the benefits.
I'M saddened that you seem to believe gay troops should get all of the benefits of marriage with none of the obligations of it
Mike,
Those are transgender issues, not gay issues. And even the Girl Scouts no longer wear dresses.
I think that a firm code of dress isn't discriminatory, since you opt into the Marines.
Besides we digress. This was about benefits to gay couples v straight couples.
OMG... this is one of the most convoluted discussions I have seen in a long time.
Really easy to clear up.
1. The Military shouldn't be granting benefits to gay couples that they don't give straight couples so...
2. Gay couples should be allowed to enter into gay unions or marriage, anywhere. Why should they have to trek into one of 5 states to get married when straight couples can get married anywhere and strangely many choose not to.
That take the "special treatment" out of the discussion and levels the playing field.
Mike,
Affirmative action? Only time will tell that. The above is the logical way to handle this issue.
Well, kind of...
Any straight couple can get married anywhere. For a gay couple to get married they have to trek to one of 5 states to do so. Make civil union/marriage easy as easy as it is for straights, then you would have a rock solid case.
The system has gone topsy tervy because of the gay civil union/marriage issue.
Not a thing. But their marriage may not be recognized or valid outside of those states, or even in the military, at least until DOMA is repealed. DOMA prohibits federal recognition of gay marriage, regardless of the state. Once DOMA is repealed, this issue will be moot!
Mike,
Transgender issues have been intertwined by a small minority of the gay community. It is not part of the mainstream gay community.
Also, the AMA has not made any clear decisions on what transgender is.
Besides, this wasn't about transgender.. it was aboutmilitarypolicy on marriage.
That's precisely my point! Obviously, recognition of marriage doesn't matter in this case or they wouldn't be extending the benefits to UNMARRIED couples to begin with!
Since they are willing to extend these benefits to unmarried gay couples, then they need to extend them to heterosexual couples.
It especially ticks me off that the military, in all of its "common sense", said it was too broke to give ANY of our troops a raise, but they have enough money to extend benefits to UNMARRIED couples, but only if they are the same sex?
I am obviously having difficulty communicating here. Marriage is a non-issue because the military is awarding these benefits anyway. But they AREN'T awarding them to straight couples.
Hence...whether or not the federal government recognizes the marriage doesn't matter. What DOES matter is the inequity of it all. Either make gay couples go to gay marriage states, get married, have all of the obligations that go with it or award the benefits to hetero couples as well.
Definately "all in". If benefits are going to be extended to gay unmarried couples, they should be extended to straight unmarried couples. If benefits are going to restricted to straight married couples only, then they should be extended to gay married couples only.
What do you find "unequal" in that stance?
What part of this do you not get, Gordy? The benefits are being extended to UNMARRIEDS.
At least you freely admit you want special rights, not equal rights for gays in the military
FYI Special Rights is NOT a legal term. Its an ideological term, originally used by libertarians to describe laws granting rights to one or more groups which are not extended to other groups, for example Affirmative Action. The conservative right uses it in a pejorative manner to express their anger over idealism's that conflict with their archaic beliefs. See;
"Equal Rights" is however, a legal term. See;
Actually, I don't think that there is a massive amount of gays who do want to enter the military...but then again I didn't start the discussion. But I do think it has merit, since we are talking about ethics, and ethics matter to me.
Actually Mike, what I do is not assume peoples behavior until proved otherwise. I have interacted with some of the worst and disgusting people, and then again, some of the most wonderful and quite often, just on the cover, you really can't tell one from the other. You find it easier to deal with the world in broad strokes. I like looking at the fine lines.
Same with the term "assault rifle". It was invented by the anti-gun lobby prior to the last assault weapons ban. What's your point?
If you are implying that people aren't "allowed" per the "Law of AeonPax" to talk about their ideology in their own articles, I would say that's a hair arrogant on your part.
It's the term I use for gay unmarried couples getting preferential treatment over hetero unmarried couples in the military. Live with it and quit trying to reduce the discussion to symantics.
That is such a cop out. Give me a real answer.. not a sound bite.
Here is what you should be asking yourself...
Why is it, that straight folk are opting for marriage less and less, while gays actually want to get married? Who seems to have more "family values"? The defect is with the straight couples and not the gay ones.
Defensive, aren't we. In this case, since we are dealing with law, specifically the one(s) that will allow same sex couple to receive federal benefits, the distinction in terminology is important. IF you want to make a legal case against laws which will allow such benefits, and at least sound plausible in your argument, "Special Rights" carry's no weight because such a thing does not exist. Women voting would have been considered a "Special Right" by your definition.
We? I don't know about "we". Are you? Your posts seem a bit passive/aggressive and tap-dance around the entire topic at hand, preferring to go the route of slogans, pictures and legal terminology.
Not for the purpose of this article. This is not a "legal" debate in a formal setting. It's a discussion on a blog. (i know, I know...hard to believe, huh?)
You apparently haven't read any of my posts. Which is pretty much par for the course. I'm not a lawyer and I don't play one on TV. I do however, find it astounding that our military is extending benefits to unmarried gay couples and not extending the same benefits to unmarried straight couples.
I'm not sure how many different ways I need to say that before you get it.
Would it make you happier if I used "flavor-of-the-day special interest group, preferential treatment" instead?
(snort!) Good think I wasn't drinking anything when I read that.
It always makes my day, knowing I made someone smile.
Some of us are capable of speaking in the vernacular of the topic. I can dumb down my writing so you can understand it better.
As you are NOT the author of the blog, you are not qualified to speak in their behalf..I know, hard to believe, eh? You can interpret it any way you want but alas, you'll someday find out, yours is not the only one.
A open discussion can go any way and in any direction. Perhaps you need to be enlightened on the subtleties of these basic things. I can help.
Unfortunately, I have. You are long on opinionated rhetoric and very short on facts, which considering your ideology. is par for the course.
Could have fooled me, I mean on TV.
Now that's the first thing you've said straight out. You offer your opinion. I respect it but disagree. Isn't that easy?
Oh, I understand that. What I don't understand is why you keep repeating it. Once is enough.
Actually, no. Instead of repeating those conservative talking points you have memorized, how about explaining as to why? My guess is that you don't like gays. That would be an honest answer from you, which I don't expect, but it would be a good start.
Good Christ. How many times do I need to repeat this before people listen?
Obviously, marriage doesn't matter to the military or they wouldn't be extending benefits to unmarried, gay couples in the first place. Add to that equation, the Obama admin has said he's not going to defend DOMA in court.
It's really pretty simple, Mickey.If the military is going to require striaght people to be married to get these benefits, then they need to require gay people to go to one of the many states that has gay marriage with no residency requirements and tie the knot, too.
If they don't want to do that, then they need to extend these benefits to unmarried straight couples as well.
Try to read slowly this time..
MARRIAGE.....ISN'T....A.....QUALIFYING.....FACTOR....FOR....THESE......BENEFITS.
And your above sentence is a flatout falsehood. Gays can indeed, get married in 5 states that I know of, whether they are residents of the state or not.
And who CARES if it's purely symbolic as far as the federal government is concerned. the Military is willing to extend these benefits without the marriage.
I say make the couple at least do SOMETHING to get them. If they really love each other, what's two days leave and a trip to Iowa?
If they don't want to take that minimum step, then extend the benefits to unmarried heteros.
(sigh).....obviously, I need to rephrase this, because you keep repeating yourself and what I'm saying is going right over your head.
It doesn't matter whether or not they are married. They are getting the benefits anyway. So marriage is a moot point.
But IF they aren't going to extend these benefits to straight courting couples as well, and they will only be extended to straight, married couples...then gay couples need to go get married. Even if it's only in one state and even if it's only SYMBOLIC in the eyes of the federal government.
In other words..show some committment to each other. Take the psychological leap. Pay the marriage penatly taxes on your limited soldier income just like married, straight troops have to. be faced with divorce proceedings if you wide up despising each other.
Either that, or give the benefits to everyone.
The larger picture here, is that the military said they were too "broke" to give ANYONE a raise. Yet they can afford to extend benefits to some unmarrieds, but not others?
Alright. We're going to take this piece by piece.
That doesn't matter. They are getting the benefits whether they are married or not. So make them get married, or extend benefits to straights.
That's simply not true. These couples have to sign a sheet of paper saying they are in a "domestic partnership and are committed to each other". Then they get the benefits. Give the same option to sign the same sheet of paper to straight couples. That's equality.
It doesn't take recognition of the marriage to get the benefits. They are getting them anyway.
And so is marriage in this case. What's your point? The only way the issue is related to marriage is if the military makes it that way. if they decide it's for married straight couples, then it should be for married gay couples. If they decide it's for unmarried gay couples, then it should be for unmarried staight couples.
Again...recognition of marriage isn't necessary in this case because married gay couples will be getting the benefits as well as unmarried gay couples. The military is not differentiating between a married gay couple or an unmarried gay couple. It should be the same for straights.
"I'M saddened that you seem to believe gay troops should get all of the benefits of marriage with none of the obligations of it"
Not sure if you understood me and my opinion of this issue. Where did you find that word 'obligation' in my post? Please don't twist my words, or put verbage in my posts that wasn't there.
Typing from my kindle so this will be short. which is good, since I didn't need to go past your second paragraph where your vacuous response to my comment that this is not a formal legal discussion, but a DISCUSSION on a blog, was..."You are not the author of the blog". no shit Sherlock. I am however, the author of the discussion. And it's not a legal forum and if that's to much for you to grasp, then it's safe to say that having a logical discussion with you would be about as fun as having a root canal. I simply don't have the patience to explain every detail to someone who doesn't know what a discussion is and has a tendency to speak in cutesy Facebook pictures and one liner sound bites.
if you want to step it up a little...let Me know
The article in question, Department of Defense Extends Some Benefits to Same-Sex Partners by Kate O'Gorman of the Iraq Afghanistan Veterans of America organization, is an informational piece that takes no position on same sex benefits in the military. It is decidedly neutral.
The article however, deals with the lawthe DADT and DOMA laws. While you used this article to launch into an ideological objection to extending benefits to gays, it still does not preclude the fact that we are talking about LAWS which affect ideology. It would be disingenuous to expect a reader not to respond by using the law in a rebuttal to your objections.
As you did not state at the beginning that the logical use of laws in is not wanted, as a condition to post in this thread, I used itwhich you now object to.
Thats called; Moving the goalposts and is a logical fallacy.
So now you're claiming the article I linked is some sort of legal document, Aeon? Wow. Your argument justifying you screwy stance that people "must use" only recognized legal terms is getting wierder and wierder.
It's a blog, Aeon. The article I linked is from a blog. It is not a peer reviewed study. It is not a white paper. It is not a notarized legal document. Same with this site. Same with this discussion.
So tell me again what your logic is for demanding legal terminology? Is this some wierd fetish you have that causes you to demand everyone use legal terminology on any blog article that discusses any law? Because I haven't seen it anywhere else from you.
Or is it just the weak strategy you use when you've run out of canned talking points and facebook pictures?
Pat N,
Sadly, your replies are getting more off the wall as this continues. Not only did I not state the things you imagined I said or implied, you are reaching all over the place to dig yourself out of the hole you created yourself.
Take this for example a blog. A blog is a discussion or informational site published Web. It can contain pictures, journals or in this case, articles. This blog or article contains information on some of the benefits the DoD allows for same-sex couples. The fact is, the author even states;
This means that the DoD cannot currently allow, by LAW, all the benefits that are available because of the DOMA law.
You are way over complicating this, for reasons unknown. Take a chill pill girl.
Precisely what I said in an earlier post. Therefore, there is no requirement to use legal terminology as you are claiming. In fact, I could insert a really good blonde joke here for your insistence (which seems to be genuine) that legal terminology must be used in discussions on blogs.
No kiddin'! WOW! I never knew that! Will wonders never cease! So in your world, that means the term "special rights" must not be used because it's not a *legal term*. (face/palm)
Is the term "assault rifle" a legal term? Does the current gun control debate center around law? I will be looking for you to chastise the gun control nuts on this site when they use the term and insisting that they use the correct legal term in their discussion on a blog.
Face it, Aeon...you grasped at terminology because you no longer have an intelligent debate on the issue. You ran out of Facebook pictures. And original thought on the issue is just too damn hard.
I invite you to get back on topic or find a different thread. You have displayed that there is a possibility that you have no clue what the topic is, so I feel obligated to tell you that its about equality in the distribution of military benefits.