is it ok to do something illegal in order to obtain a desired outcome?
I have heard some people argue that the ends justifies the means. I happen to disagree. I think the means must be honorable and legal or the end outcome is irreparably damaged.
Many seem to be unable to grasp the concept. Example, the citizens united decision. The end result of this court decision was bad but it would have been much worse for the SCOTUS to allow unconstitutional legislation to stand.
Another example is how FDR issued nearly 4000 executive orders to bypass a congress that did not agree with his agenda.
I am not asking for your opinion on FDR or citizens united. I want to know, do you feel the end justifies the means no matter what?
Tags
Who is online
112 visitors

Please stay on topic and be respectful
No, not "no matter what". In some cases, it is justified.
Let's say I'm having a heart attack in my car. My husband is a good, careful driver. Rather than pull over and wait for an ambulance, I'm more likely to tell my husband, let's hurry.
So, he is going 40 mpg in a 30 mph and runs a stoplight. If I get to the hospital in time to save my life, I'm going to be glad we broke the law. If I pull over, wait 30 minutes for an ambulance, (the same amount of time I waited last time), and die, I will have made a bad decision. The hospital is only 10 minutes away...
The problem comes from knowing when it is ok to fudge and when it's not. To me, it is a judgement call.
Is it ok to write a cold check, even if you're going straight to the bank to deposit the funds to cover it? Or should you wait until tomorrow, after your deposit clears, even though the item will cost more on it's regular price? Is it ok to walk along the side of a limited access highway, (against the law), if the exit is less than one mile away and you have a flat tire? Or should you wait for someone to come? Is it ok to drink milk that's one day past it's sell by date?
All of that is a matter of judgement, I think.
Me, too.
I agree. There are times when morality trumps law.
And dire necessity? Perhaps?
Indeed. It used to be that LE cut folks a lot of slack with things due to understanding dire need and such. It doesn't appear to be a continuing trend these days.,
I can't quite agree with that thesis. Take Jim Crow law. That was legal. Would you not feel morally obliged to refuse and resist?
As far as the anarchy component, being somewhat of a Wobbly/Anarchist, I don't have much problem with the concept.
"Concentrated power can be always wielded in the interest of the few and at the expense of the many. Government in its last analysis is this power reduced to a science. Governments never lead; they follow progress. When the prison, stake or scaffold can no longer silence the voice of the protesting minority, progress moves on a step, but not until then." Lucy Parsons
Dowser
In the situation you describe it is clear a law is being broken but without criminal intent. To my mind there is a vast difference between dire necessity and criminal intent.
However, running a red light which could lead to an accident, charges and a huge lawsuit if anyone is injured or killed as a result might render it all moot.
You might wish you were dead in the aftermath. It's a judgement call and one not to be taken lightly.
EGilman
The last thing people having heart attacks, other life threatening issues or a woman giving birth in the backseat of a car might think to do is debate on the moral relativism of getting to medical treatment as quickly as possible.
Doubtless, in the scenario above, you would follow the law to the letter and hope for the best result. Good for you, indeed.
However, your inclusion of "the liberal penchant..." in your post is a political statement which unfortunately eliminates any credibility you may have enjoyed in the discussion.
I'd take my ball and go home too but some vile plutocrat done stole it....
Stick around. Ruffle some feathers. I'm for it. I may not agree with you but I, for one, enjoy hearing reality maps that are antithetical to mine.
Spot on tex....
Believe it or not I heard this quote from an ethics class being taught by none other than G. Gordon Liddy.
And he is absolutely correct. And I will add that over the course of time what is illegal/legal, immoral/moral changes in a society.
NAVY:
You know, back in the day when I had a Richard Nixon Dart Board I really didn't like Liddy. After his tour with Timothy Leary and, apparently, becoming a weird comedian, I kinda like him. Not that I'd let him near any lit candles or take care of my dawg or turn my back to him or anything but still. He must be a comedian if he taught ethics.....
In regard, it is my guess that future generations will study our so called "war on drugs" and believe we were barbarians.
EGilman:
Sorry you had to go through that pard. Life puts us in untenable situations at times and we do what we do to survive or perish. You live to feel guilt and in my opinion that is better than taking a dirt nap.
The fellow in Tejas. It is difficult to put any kind of moral judgement to his actions. I don't support killing but I'm Ulster/Scot and were I in his boots I'd probably do the same. The rest of the clan would be right behind me as well.
Historically speaking the defense of "he deserved to be killed" has won cases before in the Lone Star. Or, at least Texans believe it. Maybe it's true. Perhaps he will get through the legal system but his life is a black hole on all account.
later gator
Egilman.... Something I have always wondered about.
We send kids into combat with a weapon in hand, and they are able to walk out of it. They do their jobs, follow their orders, and when it is all over they will carry a sense of guilt with them for the rest of their lives for those that they have killed, and their brothers that never get to go home. It has to be way different when you kill at close range vs. at 3000 feet and traveling 400 knots while pushing a button.
In sonar school in the 1980s, a tape was played back to us of a submarine reaching crush depth. It is a very unique sound and one that means that some 100 plus men died a horrible death. My daughters bought me a submarine game to play on the computer some 20 yeas later that made use of that very same tape. I never played that game again.
Tex...
You need to read Liddy's autobiography sometime. A couple of things I remember from it.... As a child he was scared of lightning, and to cure this he tied himself into a tree in a storm. He also supposedly also was scared of rats. He claims to have caught one, dressed it, and cooked it on a a spit for his consumption to eliminate his fear of rats. Rat.... its whats for dinner!
FLYNAVY.
I must have read the same article as you. That's where he justifies his statement by breaking down actions into two general categories: malum prohibitum and malum in se. The former meaning wrong as prohibited by law or statute and the latter, wrong or evil in itself. Speeding would be considered malum prohibitum whereas murder would be considered malum in se.
Sounds very much like it.
Hope you are doing well today.
I quite agree there "D",, there must be an element of common sense involved in everysituation and Idon'tthink that everyeventis black and white. Most people have an inbuilt, naggingsuspicionof whatconstitutes as a morally good or for that matter, bad, action, its how you act when those presented with that event that counts.
Generally speaking, people weigh up theconsequencesof an act, running a red light going to an hospital for instance, and act accordingly. I guess its just a matter of scale
Tesla......
Back, many moons ago, we never had to teach ethics in engineering school or business. IMO it speaks volumes as to how our society has changed, and not necessarily for the better.
If it's Tuesday, then I'm alive and kickin.
Really good post, flameaway!
hello, JW. i think you got to the meat of what i was talking about here. what concerns me is not so much rushing to a hospital to save a life, but rather things like our politicians completely ignoring the constitution and WE THE PEOPLE embracing that. for instance, while Westboro church has an agenda that i find abhorent, do we have any right to stifle their 1st amendment rights? we are basically guaranteed the right to be "stupid" to refuse to serve blacks, to refuse membership to women, to hire whom we want regardless of quotas. in short, the Constitution guarantees that the minority opinions will not be silenced.
despite what we may find morally offensive, does stripping away the right of others in order to obtain some currently politically correct outcome ultimately harm us all more than it felps.
good to see you boudicea after all this time. Marshall James here. and the end never justifies the means.
Glad you decided to hang with us goobers.
Marshall James, as I live and breath! Welcome and good to see you. FR sent.
B - I agree with you, I asked someone recently - "Do they attend Ethics Classes at Law School or what?" As Cicero said "For where is there dignity, unless there is honesty?" One of my favorite quotes & FYI - if you can find it a poem by Edgar Guest "Myself" - I believe you would love it
as it speaks to the heart of your inquiry! I'm not known for my brevity
Although you did not ask, I will share any - who - Citizen's United - really - I believe the test there for SCOTUS, "WE" the people and the petitioning complaint - Can they then be sued as -Individuals? Do the research, I am sure that question- like the voodoo they did to get the ruling - will be in their favor!
As for FDR, I like that he took initiative - when one has a DO NOTHING, OBSTRUCTIONIST body of Government, I would not consider going around them "a means to..." more like "the end of this crap!" Great question and article!
Welcome and thank you for your input. FYI, "ethics" in Law has become a real conundrum. I have seen cases my previous firm should have dumped - really dumped with a slap on the hand to the "client" with a good talking to "How dare you try and scam the system, there is nothing wrong with you - ten doctors said so" but instead we kept the case because IF we won, it was a big fee. No, there is no "ethics" in law as long as there is a monetary benefit. You can't AFFORD to be ethical if you need to pay your bills and your employees.
P.S. Yes, you can sue the individual executives of corporations. It's called piercing the corporate veil and it's been around for year and years and years
In my mind, the ends justify the means. This does not mean that the ends cannot be sullied by the means, but that it is the result that is truly important.
So we should ignore the Constitution whenever we want? You know somebody has a gun used in a crime, just ignore the search and seizure requirements?
In a way, I would say sometimes the ends justifies the means. However, the person committing the act should be aware and ready to face the consequences of their actions, regardless of the injustice of the punishment.
Not whenever we want, not whenever it's convenient. I said the ends justify the means, but what would be the ends of ignoring the constitution? In the short term, that criminal may be apprehended, but what would be the larger ends of ignoring the constitution?
imho, strive to change a law, not break one.
A weapon obtained as evidence without a warrant is inadmissible as evidence. That is judicial law 101. I doubt that there is a single judge in America that would accept the gun as evidence as upon appeal, the case would be thrown out for that single technicality. Judges do not like having their rulings overturned.
Go back and read up on the "Scopes Monkey trial". We have the exact same thing happening again in many of the southern states attempting to make sure that the teaching of evolution and the science that supports it is not taught in public schools by introducing bills that make it a crime to teach the same. Under these conditions it is right to break the law.
Hope you are well Jo.
Bingo
But your reply is based on a judge. NOT ignoring the law
If your goal is to obtain the weapon as evidence towards a conviction, why risk losing the chance of that conviction by breaking the law?
I'm looking at it from the standpoint of a criminal investigator. As such, that job requires that it produce viable evidence to warrant prosecution towards a conviction.
Take a look at my reply to JoAnne Odel below and comment on it if you would. This is where I suggest breaking the law.
As Dowser noted, it is a multi-faceted question with no easy answer. But as a general rule unless there are extenuating circumstances, I myself would have to say no the ends do not justify the means.
What you have described is the reverse as they are using the means to justify their end. Ideally one would think that fact would trump fiction, but I suppose we are still a work in progress.
If a law is unjust then there should be no ethical reasons not to feel upset over violating it.
Luther...Try and get your head wrapped around just such a case being forced up to the SCOTUS today. And it will one of these days by the religious fundamentalists, mark my words.
There is already precedence set by the courts because of the Scopes Monkey trial. BUT....one of these days, these yahoos are going to force a decision based upon the first amendment on evolution vs. creationism in the public schools.
Ah, but unjust in whose mind?
Go back to my point of the Scopes Monkey trial where the teacher purposely violated the local law of it being a crime to teach evolution in the public schools. The law was unjust and determined to be so by an appeals court ruling.
It was an unjust law in the face of evidence supported by science.
There is scientific evidence supporting evolution. There is no scientific evidence that God doesn't exist. So once again, I ask, "unjust in whose mind"
I have heard some people argue that the ends justifies the means. I happen to disagree. I think the means must be honorable and legal or the end outcome is irreparably damaged."
It really depends on the situation. Breaking the law isn't necessarily dishonorable.
Jim Crow laws for example are dishonorable. Rosa Parks was arrested for deciding to break the law and sit in the front of the bus. Do you feel she was wrong? I don't.
It was a bad law,
it was being upheld, and it couldn't be changed by blacks through voting because other laws were preventing them from voting
, and they were a minority.
Its the intent of the law that matters and it is the reason and the way in which it is broken relative to the circumstances. Very few things are black and white.
Boudicea..... you know better than to try to prove a negative. Try a different tact.
Our country was founded through breaking the law.
I believe unjust laws should not be followed and it is honorable not to follow those laws.
Also, search and seizure laws have limits . They are called extingient circumstances. There are times when it is unreasonable to expect law enforcement to get a search warrant. If the police are chasing a shooter and that shooter runs into someone's house they can enter without a warrant. Anything they find that's illegal like an unregistered fire arm or illegal drugs can bring charges and can, and will, be used against you in a court of law.
Well hell, Flyboy, it was worth a shot, wasn't it?
Yes, Jim crow laws were bad. They were ultimately Unconstitutional, weren't they? And yes, they were a perfect example of trying to justify an end through a bad "means". But what if the SCOTUS had NOT overturned them, despite their unconstitutionality? Then we would have had a situation where all Americans lose.
Today, so many times, Americans do want to enforce their own agenda through "laws". How many more damned laws do we need? YOU might believe abortion is bad, but I may not. YOU may believe that we need helmet laws but I may not. YOU may believe that the government has a right to tell me what I can fry my battered Chicken in, but I may not.
It is imperative that we look at the method we are using to try and force our own beliefs on other people (often times they are the politically correct belief du jour) and say, "Hey, does the Constitution allow us to do that?"
What people sometimes forget is that when we allow government to limit the rights of the minority it is only a matter of time until we have no choice but to allow them to limit the rights of the majority. THEN we have.....????? The Second Declaration of Independence.
Thanks Boudicea! I was being rhetorical when I was asking that question - as a former Paralegal & now MT (Massage Therapist), which both courses require "Ethics" classes - I do notTHINK that they (ethics) are interchangable for any consideration - asthey are like S tandards O f P rocedure/Practice. Having worked within the legal system - I understand & find it a disgusting practice - as well -to put any financal concernabove a duty boundethical one - part of the reason, I left it behind!
I think it a "means to an ends" question that has only - 1 answer, yet that's just me. I note that others added some unjust law etc., yet I did not think it was within the scope of your question, but in the military we are told that we "don't have to follow an unsafe act or order," yet as I said, I do not believe that was the compromise/comparison you were referring to.
As for Citizen United and the individual executives being sued per se - offering up (added, excessive or undue/unfair via $$$$ influence - as they already have same through their individual VOTE!) so called political opinionand building these PACS etc. when you consider that the transparency etc. in itself is iffy at best (as "WE" can see) should have been a CAUTION ALL TOGETHER &that trying to sue them individually would be a - GOOD LUCK WITH THAT - skewed proposition
Hopefully the rational, the ethical and thosethat have been suffering from unjust laws.
Hope you are well my lady.....You been bothering Vlad much?
Since Tyler booted me almost 2 years ago I haven't had the chance to talk with more than a handful of my old friends. Sadly, Vlad wasn't one of them. On the positive side, it's really nice to see so many of you remember me.
Remember you......? I remember one discussion with the three of us where (in humor) you were threatening to drive to Vlad's neck of the woods and turn him into a gelding!!!!
That wasn't me. I LOVE Vlad
Running over some one who is shooting into a group of people is murder in fact probably justiciable homiside. You cannot make that call only a court can. Violence begits violence. If you pull a gun on a burgular if he is armed theypossibly shoot you if they can. If you physically harm a person who is stealing baby food to feed their baby in a grocery store. You in my mind are both wrong. Police who use undue force while making an arrest have no business beig a policeman. They want to be judge and jury. Go to LA they have been proving police brutality or Police making unwanted sexual advances to women they have in handcuffs. Making a child carry a fetus to birth following a rape is wrong on all counts.
Using a drone to kill an American citizen training Terrorists I'm ok with. I don't like it but its preferable to invading another country. I prefer the way Obama authorized them to go in and kill Binladen.
Some people who do something wrong to achieve an end goal are heroes most are known as prisoners some even end up on death row. Fix the problems at the polls no one can buy your vote if you won't let them.
Doing something bad to stop something against your religion is just plain stupid.
is it ok to do something illegal...
like smoke'n bud...?
in order to obtain a desired outcome?
...like ta be gittin'n haayh...?
eeeeeyup
Most constitutional issues are decided on whether the act in question 'infringes' on the rights of others.
The example of 'refusing to serve blacks and membership to women' do exactly that, infringe on the rights of blacks and women. As I understand it, your rights are not valid, constitutionally, if they harm or affect the rights of others.
I think we have abundant examples today to show that legal and moral do not overlap. Not even close.
I'd like to think anyone will do what's moral first and worry about legal later. Amongst other things that would improve the moral standing of the whole society since special interests that twist the truth to make what they want "legal" would be a lot harder to do.
Every time I see someone in Congress explain what they're doing is legal, I cringe. There's a gigantic crap pile waiting just under that.
Actually, forcing someone to serve someone they don't want to serve infringes on their rights as well. I don't believe that the "civil rights" legislation has ever been challenged in the SCOTUS - except for one case that was decided not on civil rights at all but rather on the commerce clause.
Having a piece of legislation enacted by Congress doesn't mean it's Constitutional. There are unconstitutional laws passed every day. Unless they are challenged and the SCOTUS agrees to hear them, they just stay law.