What are we greedy for?
What are we greedy for?
by Charles Eisenstein
http://charleseisenstein.net/what-are-we-greedy-for/
"A lot of people reacted to my comment on Facebook the other day that greed is more a symptom than a cause of our current system, with all its inequities. Im asked, What is the cause of greed? First Ill say what I think greed is: Greed is the insatiable desire for that which one doesnt really need, or in amounts beyond ones needs.
When we are cut off from the fulfillment of our basic needs we seek out substitutes to temporarily ease the longing. Bereft of connection to nature, connection to community, intimacy, meaningful self-expression, ensouled dwellings and built environment, spiritual connection, and the feeling of belonging, lots of us over-consume, overeat, over-shop, and over-accumulate. How much do you need to eat, to compensate for a feeling of not belonging? How much pornography to compensate for a deficit of intimacy? How much money to compensate for a deep sense of insecurity? No amount is enough."
-- continued at http://charleseisenstein.net/what-are-we-greedy-for/

I think there is a distinction between being rich and being greedy.
What makes one rich? What makes one greedy? What makes one wealthy? Is there a level of money reached that signifies richness or wealth? What context is usedin determining any of the above?
I know people who make a million or more a year, and of those, many of them are not greedy. I know other who make much less than that, who are very greedy.
Greed is wanting selfishly without any social consciousness or caring about your fellow man, and not giving back.
Yup. That filthy fuckin' rich Gates is nothing but a greedy prick , just like every person who has more than they need to survive.
Bastid! Warren Buffet too!
There is no harm in earning. But it is wrong to not recognize that even though you were fortunate, there are those who are not, and could use some help.
I admire self made people, not envy them. But I also understand that greed is disgusting. That is why it is one of the 7 deadly sins. And a person who is greedy, is never really happy as it is never enough for them either.
The Gates foundation will do more for mankind than most nations will. I admire that.
Of course the idea that...
...as the definitionofgreed is purely subjective. I would argue that you could probably survive in a tent rougy, but probably don't. Does that make you greedy?
How clueless.
I highly doubt very many financially successful people are greedy. In my observations the greedy man doesn't have the self control needed to become a wealthy man. I would say some of the most successful people I know and have known are the least greedy.
I wouldn't say I'm greedy or covet wealth but I've spent my whole life so far working hard to acquire wealth, many times at the risk of my own safety and health. I've spent way too much time away from my family, working, going to school/seminars and traveling to earn wealth. But it has already paid off.
I'm not rich in the colloquial sense of the word, but I am well off and can afford luxuries others cannot. But I do share my wealth directly with those in need.
However, I would be remiss by not pointing out I am blessed with good health as are my daughters, whom I live for. I am surrounded by those who love me and in return, I reciprocate that love. While I'm not into organized religion, I still nonetheless believe in a supreme divinity that transcends my mortal existence.
I've learned, the hard way,
that some poems don't rhyme,
and some stories don't have a clear beginning,
middle, and end.
Life is about not knowing,
having to change,
taking the moment and making the best of it,
without knowing what's going to happen next.
Delicious ambiguity.
~ Gilda Radner ~
I recently heard a college commencement speech at Catholic University in DC, which closed with the following remark: "Now go out there and earn lots of money, and bring it back here." Somehow, I doubt that the pope will address this blatant conflict of morality when he visits CUA in September.
Way to twist my words. Becoming rich off the backs of others is wrong. That is the definition of greed. But there are other business people who didn't do that.
The Bill & Melinda Gates Foundation does good things. But Microsoft Corporation has made its billions in large part by doing not-so-good things.
"The main objection is based solely on envy." Ayn Rand?
My definition of greed is different. If others (human or non-human, living or in the future) are harmed - or even neglected -- in the creation of pseudo-wealth (it can't be true wealth under such conditions, in my preferred usage), then there is greed involved. If no one is harmed or neglected, it's not likely to be greed.
I suppose you could say "If others or one's self...," but look how many qualifiers I used already!
________________________________
A whole culture or civilization can be greedy by my definition. And I think the USA is a very greedy society ... because it's producing "wealth" by burning massive amounts of fossil fuels, even though we know that doing so is forcing catastrophic climate change and putting most Earth-life (biodiversity) at risk.
People who get really , really, rich, are crooks
That's the other side of the bigotry coin that says "people who are really, really poor are lazy".
Why don't you try casting your net a little wider, fool?
Did any of you read the Charles Eisenstein article in the opening post?
Feronia :"His solution beneath the quote above sounds a bit like collectivism at a glance."
Centuries old habits of "thinking" in the West have most of us associating "collectivism" with diminished individual freedoms, oppression, rigid social control..., while associating individualism with the opposites (antonyms) of these terms. I think this unfortunate, as individual freedoms require the support of a collective (a community) to be sustained, and rampant individualism of a certain variety can result in the utter degradation of life for both communities and the individuals who dwell within them.
What I think our society needs is the proper mix of the best of individualism AND collectivism. But, alas, I must admit that I'm basically a decenralist at heart -- a left decentralist like K. Sale.
Decentralism has many problems to solve, for sure. And many of these relate to the left versus right views of decentralism, it appears. Right decentralists seem to hate "collectivism," ... socialism, etc.... I'm all for it! Only I don't it orchestrated from within a massive centralized state. Like right decentralists, I'd like to see less government -- of a certain kind! But not less social control over the use of resources and management of our social lives. In simple terms, I would not follow the rght-decentralist path of the Libertarian Party, which would seem to want to do away with all public control over all aspects of society and economy -- with many Libertarians wanting to eliminate the E.P.A (USA), etc. Problem is, the EPA is too weak, not too strong, in these corporatist days. It does too little, not too much, to protect people and planet. Eliminate the EPA without taking care to "regulate" things appropriately at the smaller, more local, scales and you end up with an even worse catastrophe than we already have. But this is just one among hundreds of examples we could discuss.
Feronia:
Your characterization of this person "on the other side of the spectrum" is too vague for me to know how to respond. I'd need much more specificity. "maintains a lifestyle on the government's largess via taxpayer contribution" ... can't imagine what sort of "lifestyle" you're referring to, be it that of a millionaire or aghetto-dwelling single mother on food stamps and welfare(?). Both exist. And both, taken as particular individuals, could indeed be "greedy" by my definition. It depends! It's complicated!
Again, more specificity is necessary. "The current lifestyle" can mean so very many things! In the USA, "the current lifestyle" for a vast number involves massive fossil fuel consumption, which, by all honest and reasonable accounts, is putting the biosphere as we know it at risk of utter ecological collapse. So ANY fossil fuel consumption is more than we can really afford at this point. Thus "the currentlifestyle" for typical Americans is very greedy indeed.
I believe we can do much to improve our quality of life while reducing our use and dependency upon fossil fuels, so it's not a simple matter of us giving up "the good life" so much as redefining it.
"Animals may be satisfied by having their needs filled. Humans have wants and dreams beside."
Perhaps you are lost somewhere between denotation and connotation? Maybe you think "needs" refers merely and restrictively to survival needs? But the word "needs" need not be so restrictive in its use. Think, for example, of Maslow'shierarchy of needs . It's not so restrictive.
"I find his points silly."
Of course you do! He's a sensitive man.
In the era of frivolous lawsuits no amount of wealth is ever enough ...
Now who is silly?