And now for the pro gun side of the coin!
On the correct side, Constitutionally speaking are the following people. Including the people who wrote the Constitution and the Bill of Rights.
No free man shall ever be debarred the use of arms. The strongest reason for the people to retain the right to keep and bear arms is, as a last resort, to protect themselves against tyranny in government Thomas Jefferson, 1 Thomas Jefferson Papers, 334
"Guard with jealous attention the public liberty. Suspect everyone who approaches that jewel. Unfortunately, nothing will preserve it but downright force. Whenever you give up that force, you are ruinedThe great object is that every man be armed. Everyone who is able might have a gun. - Patrick Henry
Arms in the hands of citizens may be used at individual discretion in private self defense. - John Adams
To disarm the people is the most effectual way to enslave them. George Mason, 3 Elliot, Debates at 380
Americans have the right and advantage of being armed, unlike the people of other countries, whose leaders are afraid to trust them with arms. - James Madison, Federalist Paper #46
Necessity is the plea for every infringement of human freedom. It is the argument of tyrants; it is the creed of slaves. - William Pitt, Nov. 18, 1783
The supreme power in America cannot enforce unjust laws by the sword; because the whole body of the people are armed, and constitute a force superior to any band of regular troops. - Noah Webster, 1787
To preserve liberty, it is essential that the whole body of the people always possess arms, and be taught alike, especially when young, how to use them. - Richard Henry Lee, Virginia delegate to the Continental Congress, Initiator of the Declaration of Independence, and member of the first Senate, which passed the Bill of Rights
And now for a few more contemporary supporters. Even a pacifist or two!
That rifle on the wall of the labourers cottage or working class flat is the symbol of democracy. It is our job to see that it stays there. - George Orwell
If someone has a gun and is trying to kill you, it would be reasonable to shoot back with your own gun. - The Dalai Lama, May 15, 2001, The Seattle Times
Among the many misdeeds of the British rule in India, history will look upon the Act depriving a whole nation of arms as the blackest. If we want the Arms Act to be repealed, if we want to learn the use of arms, here is a golden opportunity. If the middle classes render voluntary help to Government in the hour of its trial, distrust will disappear, and the ban on possessing arms will be withdrawn. - Mohandas K. Gandhi
Even a committed pair of pacifists think the right to keep and bear arms has a legitimate place in society. I wonder how the guncontrol crowd will respond to this?

Enjoy'em!
Very good! Unfortunately the gun control crowd know all of this, but don't care. They only try to bend things to suit them.
So true.
They sure do!!
Those are some fascinating quotes by major figures from the 20th century . This has been quite an education ...
Nice M1A, Aubs. Who's the lass?
Ummmmmm the M-1A IS the civillian-legal semi-auto version of the M-14.
Yeah, the pistol grip and folding stock are after market. Did you notice that (probably due to the pistol grip) the girl's right elbow is lower than it should be. That doesn't matter for a low recoil weapon like the AR-15, but it is the reason that I prefer the more traditional stock design for the higher recoiling weapons. If she doesn't get that elbow up and plant the butt into her shoulder socket, she's going to have some really interesting bruises on her upper arm.
Love the new avatar Gunny. That's the kind of Marine I'd like to have covering my back; or front, or pretty much any part of my body.
Great article and some excellent quotes! Of course my favorite quote with regard to bearing arms and liberty was from Benjamin Franklin:
"Democracy is two wolves and a lamb voting on what to have for lunch. Liberty is
a well-armed lamb contesting the vote."
George Mason has it right. there should be more citizen militias.
Though it is my feeling that mental health and our love affair with violence in general are the heart of the issue, there are a few things that are being promoted that do not bother me (yes I am a gun owner).
I see nothing wrong with submitting to a background check on all gun sales nor do I see a problem with a mental health check, common sense for me. Personally I myself have no need of expanded magazines, military knock off weaponry or the like, but that is me and if you feel the need for what ever reason then have at it.
But where I would begin is by enforcing existing gun laws prior to creating new ones. Just a thought anyway.
Neale,
I am a bit of Gandhi fan, so when I read that quote, it struck me as odd. Here is what Gandhi said:
"It is non-violence only when we love those that hate us. I know how difficult it is to follow this grand law of love, but are not all great and good things difficult to do? Love of the hater is the most difficult of all. But by the grace of God even this most difficult thing becomes easy to accomplish if we want to."
Your quote comes from when Gandhi was a lawyer working for the British, before he embraced peacefulresistance. It is not a true representation of who Gandhi was and what he believed in.
That's because the anti-gun nuts base their assertions not on knowledge, but on what intimidates them. They fear guns, they fear law abiding citizens that own guns, they don't own a gun and they don't want anyone else to, either.
Yeah, but does he "need" to ignore them?
damn that is sexy!
I am talking about the gun people.
LOL Neale , im waiting for some of the quotes I gave you to come out , i seem to have lost them .
Now someone in some of these threads has mentioned "common sense " something that isnt that common anymore .
the reason i choose an AR platform here is when i go out working on my property , checking fence and the like , is because of the familiarity with the system , i dont have the most popular version or varient , its set up a lot differently , couple that with that i have a conversion kit enabling me to swap out the bolt , and fire different ammunition ,. i can shoot 22LR or the full sized .223 round , now for some things the full sized round is overkill and a waste , a simple bolt and mag swap and i shoot the more economical round that is not over kill for some of the "varmits" I encounter . common sense would say simply carry both bolts with appropriate mags for the job that needs to be done , a process that takes less than a min . that makes more sense than having to carry 2 seperate fully loaded firearms appropriate for the applications .
another common sense issue for me , is as i have posted elsewhere about what My states statutes say about militia and what the state has set up . if i already have a compatable firearm that uses the exact same things already in the states supply system ,that is one less logistical step of supply that the state does not have to consider if they decide to impliment and activate any of the other than organized militias that exist presently only on paper and in statute. common sense does dictate , that if called , and told to show up with what you have , its best to have something compatable and already in the supply system.
But those people who argued for the second amendment didn't know we'd have AUTOMATIC weapons some day! So their words don't count. (/sarc)
His asshole factor brings him here, Bruce- Luther- the entire problem with background checks is simple- where in the Constitution does it give us the right to deny people their Constitutional rights?
Barb- why should loudmouths advocating for Constitutionally enumerated rights settle down? People are out there actively advocating violating the Constitution in order to strip us of a right, and you want us to be quiet and compromise our right away. Are YOU willing to compromise one of your favorite rights to just "settle down"?
No, Barb, we don't. the 2nd IS un;imited, no matter what Scalia says. i don't give a damn which side of the spectrum a justice is on (because they aren't supposed to be on either side, they are SUPPOSED to be impartial). Does the 2nd amendment say "Shall not be infringed" at the end or not? So, whether Scalia, Thomas, or Sotomayor say it can be limited, for any reason, they lie. Got it?
Exactly- they assume that owning a gun makes you likely to flip out and kill people because that's what THEY would do.
Mark- that's in a different article- I'll check, but I think I have already posted it here!!
I know- every time I suggest it, they freak out, calling it unConstitutional to be required to purchase a card in order to excercise an enumerated right...... the fucking hypocrits.
Well done, Egilman.
My friend- you are preaching to the choir. sadly, the pews are full of people willfully deaf to the words of the founders and framers.
I just wish they'd lived that phrase to the fullest- and recognized the fact that blacks and Indians were also created equal. It took too long to recognize this. But not being perfect is one of the hallmarks of being human.....
I, too, wish people who oppose certain parts of the Constitution (and make up other parts out of whole cloth) would do a little reading (While in posession of a dictionary with "obsolete" definitions for the words the founders wrote.
nothing to worry about.
1. the 2nd amendment is only about hunting
2. criminals aways obey the law
(applause)
Really? Number one isn't even mentioned in the Amednment, and Number two is obviously false. Methinks thou doth engage in sarcasm.
Neale, I'm neither pro or anti gun, but I am pro bow and arrow. I'm damn good with it as well.
This is an argument that will go on forever. Each side pointing out what they believe,neither is going to change their mind.It's kind of like a person pissing on your foot and telling you it's raining.
I'm retiring to the archery range with my recurve Ojibwe longbow.
There is a lot that can be done to prevent gun violence without banning guns. Guns should not be sold to known violent criminals. Gun owners should be held responsible for violence committed with their guns. Unregistered guns should be illegal guns. The Constitution says well regulated militia. I interpret the militia as the armed population of the US. I interpret well regulated as meaning registered.
So, you're okay with being imprisoned for vehicular homicide if someone steals your car and runs over a kid? Get real. And read the definition of "well regulated" at the time the Bill of Rights was written- it mean "well trained and in good working order". NOT licensed and controlled.
Because the First Amendment is important to him, and the 2nd isn't, of course. How about trying to get him to accept ID to vote- bet he cries "That's unconstitutional- you can't license the right to vote, that's a poll tax!", butconsiders licensing another Constitutional right as just fine. .
The Dalai Lama quote in this article is incomplete.
This is actually how that quote came about:
***
That said, while I do not like guns and do not own a gun, I have no problem with someone else owning a gun. I personally do not see the point of some of the guns that are available - but, like I said, I don't like guns.
I do not think restricting the type of gun someone can purchase would be an effective way to control gun violence.
I do think that doing background checks on people purchasing guns is ok. I do think that disallowing people with certain criminal backgrounds or significant mental health history is ok also. All rights have certain limitations placed on them. Just an example, you have freedom of speech, however, certain speech is not protected, such as speech that incites violence. We have already determined that in certain circumstances, rights can be limited. I believe limiting the right to gun ownership to those that can pass background checks is ok.
I also think that gun owners (and I think the vast majority of gun owners already do this voluntarily) - should have to maintain, store and operatetheir guns in a method that is safe. Now, I'm not a gun owner - I don't know how to do these things. If I ever wanted to own a gun, I would willingly take gun safety courses that taught me this as I feel that safe gun ownership is key. I have no problem with licensing and/or registration of guns - IF that licensing and/or registration is done to ensure that the gun owner is a competent gun owner. I have been told that the NRA offers gun safety course that include gun maintenance, storage and operation - I think that showing you've taken an NRA course (or another course that utilizes similar standards), would be sufficient for licensing and/or registration of guns. Now, as far as fees go for licensing and/or registration of guns - since gun ownership is a right, I don't think that there should be a fee to license and/or register a gun.
I also think that most of the laws that would do the above things are already in place, please correct me if I'm wrong. So, if these things are already in place - why not just ensure the current laws are being enforced, rather than adding more laws?
Well stevie , thankfully we dont have to trust your interpertation of what aMilitia is , thats already laid out in US Code title 10 Composition of the militias.
Sec. 311. Militia: composition and classes
-STATUTE-
(a) The militia of the United States consists of all able-bodied
males at least 17 years of age and, except as provided in section
313 of title 32, under 45 years of age who are, or who have made a
declaration of intention to become, citizens of the United States
and of female citizens of the United States who are members of the
National Guard.
(b) The classes of the militia are -
(1) the organized militia, which consists of the National Guard
and the Naval Militia; and
(2) the unorganized militia, which consists of the members of
the militia who are not members of the National Guard or the
Naval Militia.
No where does it mention being armed to be a member of either class so if your male , between the ages specified , YOU are in the militia subject to call for national or state service , and dependant on your own particular state statutes you may be subject to call up to any age limit they determine by statute( my state , 70 is the cut off age). this doesnt even consider the other militias that state statutes can create( mine has in statute since statehood a provision for yet a 3rd militia not subject to national call )
so it follows your interpertation of well regulated means registered is also lacking , so how about registering your penis ? provide a DNA sample for a database ? just because you SAY you would never rape someone , someone else can take your same line of thinking and say but the possability you could is still there because you can . And doing so would make the authorities jobs so much easier.
better yet since it is established exactly what the different classification of militia are by code and law ( not your arbitrary interpertation and opinion), and who is in them , how about we do this? for every militia member , that can prove they are armed sufficiently with suitable arms, they get a 2% tax credit ( those that cant prove it dont get the credit) ( this is after all how the court ruled the ACA fine was actually a tax , and a tax one didnt get because they didnt provide their own ins. and that is a 4% of income based Tax/fine ). Or how about all those that dont wish to arm themselves register? that way the government knows exactly how many arms they need to order to supply them?
Just a pic from a website. Tastefully dressed and looked a bit like me when I had longer hair.
Still not completely equal. Ask those on reservations what they think.
(for the record Neale, I know you knew that already.)
And in 2008 Supreme Court ruled that the 2nd Amendment applies to all law abiding US citizens of adulthood (i.e. - individual rights to defend life, liberty, and perpetual pursuit of happiness).
Wow I'm totally not even gonna read all that copy paste crap.
Sorry, Stevie- but the quotes and decisions of our founders and progenitors in the gun battle are EXACTLY what you MUST read, or else all your pathetic "But they could not have foreseen machineguns, and surely would have banned them!" crap is even more irrelevant.
I have long supported disarming the police, and forcing them to rely on the weapons of good citizens for their armed responders. Far too many police officers (though there are many good ones out there, they are severely outnumbered) are just power hungry authoritarians. Far too many have the mentality of the uniforms-vs-the civvies. This leads directly to the (false) belief that they are our bosses. Far too many people have caught evidence of this on smart-phones, private dashcams, and even their own dashcams for any smart person to legitimately deny the truth.
Having been told by a cop that "We can enforce this regulation as we see fit." I have seen this attitude first hand. And removing the power to force compliance physically is the ONLY way to shut this attitude down.
This footage PROVES that the cop acted like a murderer. I can tell what the guy was trying to do. And he tripped coming out of the truck. Shooting a man in the back while he rolls on the ground writhing in pain is murder. Pure and simple. 13 shots in 4.2 seconds is ridiculous unless the man is charging at you. Rolling on the ground is most definitely NOT charging.
Dealing with that right now in my state on the issue of "Shall Issue" v "May Issue". Many of the Bubba-type Sheriff's want desperately to go back to "May Issue". Of course, these were the same Sheriff's that were originally prone to approving permits for their good-ol-boy network of buddies and no one else, regardless of how clear someone's background check came back.
They absolutely pitched a fit when the state went "Shall Issue" instead. And haven't shut up since.
Hell, you can SEE at least one hit while he's rolling on the ground, IN THE BACK!!!
Yup, Pat, they sure do. But it's ALSO sheriffs leading the charge to ignore all federal gun laws in their counties on the grounds that they are ALL unconstitutional.
And to them, I say "kudos". They are definately the good guys. So many of their counterparts refuse to follow and admit that they will blindly implement whatever unconstitutional law the federal government throws at them
love, love love it!
OK. Lets apply it to cars. Everytime you buy a car, you have to submit to an FBI background check, and go through a waiting period.
Same with a boxcutter. Same with a pocket knife. Same with anything flammable. Same with any household cleaners.
Are you getting the picture yet?
What makes a 110 pound woman the physical equal to a 220 pound man intent on rape or assault? 2-3 pounds of Hartford steel, that's what. (Please note, gun-haters, that Hartford is the home of Colt Firearms)
A gun-grabber (also known as gun control advocate, or victim disarmament supporter) finds a woman, dead in an alley, raped then strangled with her own pantyhose, morally superior to that same woman explaining to the cops why there's a dead rapist in the alley while she reloads her pistol.
ANY person who advocates for victim disarmament is NOT a supporter of Women's Rights. That person advocates keeping women subservient to the (generally speaking) bigger muscles of men, by denying her the power to protect herself FROM those muscles without lame-assed "non-lethal" methods such as tasers and puking, pissing, or shitting on yourself to "turn your attacker off". I don't want rapists to leave the scene of an attempted rape any other way than in a bodybag. And I NEVER want to see a successful rape. Now, I know not every woman will carry a gun, and many who do might not use one in extremis, but they ALL have the right to make that decision for themselves.
Bullshit, jack. You can kill MORE people with computer and printer, or even handwritten words, than ever done by means of guns. Want an example? I'll give you two. The Koran and the Bible. More people have used those two sets of written words tocause more deaths than any and all of my guns have ever done. They have been used toorder dashing the skulls of babies against rocks, stoning women for the crime of being raped, killing or converting billions over the centuries, and are being used for the same purposes to this day.
I really need a like button for that. Very well put Neale.
It's insulting to me, how the "equal rights" crowd, suddenly think women are too inept to use a firearm to defend themselves and can't be trusted with one. Whats odd is that it's usually the male gun-grabbers who fancy themselves "equal rights advocates" that do this the most.
You know what I think? I think they fear guns.I think they fear women.And I think they are so ball-less, they really fear women with guns.
Paxton Quigley can tell you all about it. She coined the phrase "No one ever raped a .38." She is one of the leading advocates of armed female self defense.
Well with a car, you do have to be liscenced in order to operate it.Which nowdays requires a 6 month probationary period in which you can only operate in the presence of an adult operator afterwhich you are tested for competence. It also has to be titled and registered with local authorities.
With knives and the like, that is going a bit too far in to hyperbole. They are tools, and they do come with warnings to cover legaleese. It wouldnt surprise me if you are put on a list if you buy from one of those knife selling QVC type channels.
For household cleaners, flammable chemicals/consummablesand fertilizers, you are put on a watchlist if theyfind you are purchasing too much of it. You also have to be liscenced to purchase large quantities.
Same goes for painkillers and even cold medicine. They are actively watched for purchases as well as regulated by a pharmacist and doctor for use.
They also monitor book purchases, library lists, and other media related consumption. Phone calls, emails and strange amounts of regular mail are monitored as well.
Regulation does exist for things other than guns. Just saying.
Very familiar with Paxton. She is an amazing woman. This is what a TRUE feminist looks like.
Because of her inspiration to women everywhere....there is an event that has sprung up all over the country. (I am now organizing the one here in IA. Hope it turns out good. First time). The event is called "Take A Newbie Shooting Day".
While the day was originally intended for ANY newbie, it's turned into a day that has a heavy focus on women who have never shot before and can get some experience under the guidance of an NRA certified instructor in a non-intimidating environment filled with other women and many friends.
Once these women fire a gun for the first time and get over the fear of it, many have gone on to be awesome competition shooters, and NRA instructors. But ALL of them have gone on to be women that can defend themselves against violence if need be.
Yeah, but you do have to register to vote. Otherwise, you dont show on the rolls and it wont count.
Me too.
But you don't have to go through an FBI background check to buy it. Firearms are the only retail product where a person has to submit to that check every...single...time they want to buy one.
Why? The argument from the gun control crowd is that everyone should have to go through a background check to buy a gun because guns can kill people. If that's the qualifier, then it stands to reason that people should have to go through background checks whenever they buy ANYTHING that can kill someone.
What is worse? A FBI background check taking a week, or the title/registration and driver's education to operate a car taking a few months? I dont have an answer for that question for you... but I think it is perfectly reasonable to make people take some education and submit to some background information in order to operate something as dangerous as a motor vehicle. I would always encourage people to enroll in firearms safety courses; nothing wrong with a little education.
I think that they could do away with an "every time FBI check" if gun owners were willing to be lisenced/registered carriers. I know it used to be you could shortcut some of that in CO if you had been through it once. My husband still has his register cards from IL when they required them (they might still?).
I've been a government worker before, so my fingerprints are already everywhere. For me, registering as a gun owner isnt a big deal. I know it isnt true for everyone, but I have to wonder at the sense of the argument... being... "We shouldn't have to register, but why does it take so long to re-register every time we want to buy a gun? It's good that criminals can't get guns, but why should we have to track our gun purchases?"
Knives are a bit far because you can make a knife out of a rock... (not to mention you could kill someone with a rock)and they require a little more personal finese to use as a deadly weapon. A normal person could only kill someone else with a knife if they were lucky or trained to do so.
I dont think reason is entering this argument, for any of these gun threads. No offense to you personally, but all I've seen is hyperbole on both sides about the ifs, whens and buts about things that are super far-fetched.
I was simply listing out that guns arent the only thing subject to regulation. Hell, I couldnt even get a job with the CDC until i submitted to a very thorough FBI background check... they dont want crazy people running around with access to ebola virus either... go figure...
I'm just looking for consistency in the logic of gun control advocates. So far, I see none.
Want FBI background checks for everyone who buys, trades or inherits a gun because guns can kill people? Fine. Then start advocating for the same set of requirements for anything else that can kill people.
Want to start putting certain verification restrictions on the Second Amendment? Be prepared to put those same restrictions on voter rights.
Want to use the baseless argument that people don't "need" this or that type of gun? Fine. Apply the same criteria to whether or not people "need" to go over the top on some of the *freedom of expression* we see.
When I stop seeing people picking and choosing which Constitutional rights they want to protect and which ones they feel aren't that important...I'll back off. But not until then
Would you mind telling me what OTHER Constitutionally enumerated rights require a license to engage in that right?? Betcha can't name one!!!!! All of these examples (cars, registration of cars, licenses to operate cars) are irrelevant. Cars are NOT a Constitutionally protected right. Owning arms (Weapons of any type) IS. End of story. Pat, you fell for it hook, line, and sinker- rights cannot be licensed. Stop arguing apples to oranges. you weaken your arguments.
Don't have to BUY ID. We know, because all liberals scream bloody murder any time we try to get that as a requirement to vote. Y'all call it a poll tax. But you're FINE with a "poll tax" for gun ownership. Well, voting for the idiot with his finger on the nuclear trigger is FAR more dangerous than a rifle or pistol in the hands of a lunatic.
I dont know what buying an ID has to do with registering to vote.
I agree that voting is far more dangerous, which is why they require you to register... so you only get one dangerous vote.
I also dont care what weapons you own... you can own a tank as far as I'm concerned... I do think that the weapons you own should be traceable and you should be declared fit through some sort of background and even a mental health check.
That's just my opinion on it.
Jack:
Didn't The Arab Spring kill a buncha folks?
Dang. These replies never seem to get where I intend them to get.
anyhow,
best your way
JR- you you you said something correct- what's wrong with you?? LOL.
Indeed. Though somewhat amusing these anti/pro discussions are somewhat masturbatory in nature.
I'm a fan of the stick bow myself. Thanks to the old recurve I think I've fried up all the rabbits in my neck o the woods. I'm sure there'll be more come spring though.
later gator
There is a long list ofprecedents and requirementsto each amendment. I dont know of a single consitutional right that doesnt have clarification casesomewhere (except maybe the third amendment, but you have to title your property to make sure it isnt immenant domain... so...), a right of enacted power (through registration, training, court order or otherwise)and/or laws enacted to ensure that clarification.
To pretend any of them are used at face value is a little disingenuous.
For an example... For the first amendment: see The Lemon Test, RFRA, The Vietnam war and Cohen v. California, the Foreign Agents Registration Act, Citizens United, United States v. Eichman, etc. etc. court cases dealing with each part.
So what? We've tolerated unConstitutional limitations of Constitutionally enumerated rights. And that is exactly why we need to shut them down NOW. We have allowed OUR SERVANTS to become, in their mind, OUR MASTERS. We, the People, have enumerated rights that neither Congress nor that petty dictator in the Whitehouse (no matter which one is there at the moment) have the right to license, limit, or control. For some reason, certain members of society have determined that we cannot function without Big Brother telling us what we can do, placing limits on what extent we can do it, and requiring us to buy permission to do it. This is counter to every founding principle this country has. And anyone who actually studies the writings of our forefathers knows this fact. If you doubt me, just search through this very comment section for Egilman's copies of many of the writings and court decisions of those very forefathers. They make it CRYSTAL clear that IF we allow our government to regulate, control, limit, license, or restrict our right to own ANY weapons, of ANY grade, up to and including military grade weapons, we have opened the door to tyranny. They ALSO tell us NOT to tolerate a large standing army, as it has alwaysbeen, is, and always shall be the the tool of tyrants and dictators.
I'm trying to be nice, dammit.
BTW. Just got my hands on a Beretta 9mm PX4 Storm. Brand new. $475.00
Miss D....basically what it boils down to is the fact that the 2A couldn't be written anymore clear. The right of the people to keep and bear arms shall not be infringed. Period.
And it's been challenged over and over and over again in the courts. And upheld.
In fact, a Federal Appeals Court recently ruled IL's ban on concealed carry unconstitutional.
There are no shades of grey or applicable comparison that applies. People have tried and failed in the courts.
Now...if the gun control crowd wants to think outside the box a little, quit coming up with worn out, old ideas that only burden law abiding citizens, and start coming up with ideas that address criminals and the mental health system...THEN we might be willing to listen.
JR- how many times do I have to tell you that I don't care WHAT a SCOTU justice may say- read the writings of the people who demanded the 2nd Amendment, who wroet the 2nd Amendment, and what the several states legislatures said when THEY did the same. Scalia can whine and kiss the ass of anti-gunners all he wants. He is neither the end-all nor the be-all of jurisprudence or the Constitution. Again, just for one example, I reference Dredd-Scott. That alone shows us that the SCOTUS violates the Constitution. And in this case, they have done it again.
Something im thinking here , Government derives its authority from the consent of the governed , in this matter , i dont think the governments gonna get consent , so they will have to think of what they will do. i exersize my non consent by not living in those states with restrictive regulations and laws . but their jurisdiction either ends , at their state lines , or city limits .
We all know your opinion. But the fact is, if you violate the Constitution, your credibility disappears as a Constitutional enforcer/interpreter. By saying he can "justify" or acknowledge anything other than original intent as a basis for a decision, he places himself in the marginalized position. And if a "quadrillion people" disagree with me, that's fine. A quadrillion people are willing to marginalize their rights away. I am not willing to do so.
I miss my Beretta... I told the hubby the other day we should go looking for some new arms for funzies.
Neale... you asked for the amendments that were taken unabridged. Okay... stop... you actually asked if any other amendments require licensing and I didnt actually answer that.
So... the first amendment... the government requires license for broadcasting.
Why are military grade weapons your line by the way? The second amendment doesnt mention a difference between military grade and non. In fact a militia would carry military grade weapons? Just wondering how you draw that line in the sand.
There are no amendments that are taken unabridged... that is what the court system is set up for... to interpret the laws and use judgement to abridge and clarify.
If 2A were Crystal Clear as everyone asserts, there wouldnt be laws clarifying who can own a weapon (felons?) or under what circumstances it is or isnt okay (age?).
I do not believe in black and white issues.
I dont know why you quoted me here.
I am not against the second amendment. I do believe it was set up to provide a check against tyranny.
Not really sure what that point has to do with abridged versions of amendments being part of the process of government or me pointing out that all of the amendments are subject to that form of regulation and amending.
Well color me confused too... but oh well... there are a lot of backward and forward circles in these discussions.
And we wonder why congress gets gridlocked...
Trite to some, deadly serious to me and others.
And what does it do to the mindset of the people who believe that cops are there to protect us, and the courts are there to ensure that criminals pay their "debt to society"? It proves to those of us who do not, can not, and will not trust the government primarily BECAUSE of actions like this that result in decisions like this.
Miss D- I think we're BOTH missing the point of the other- I was asking you to tell me where IN THE CONSTITUTION there are provisions to license rights. And you were pointing to precedents set and accepted despite their (at least to me) obvious unConstitutionality.
Here's (my) point- the Constitution does not grant the government the right to license enumerated rights. Even that "well regulated militia" phrase so belived of liberals like JR does not mean what it would mean if written today. Words change with time. "Regulated" means, in the lexicon of 1789, well trained and in good working order. "Militia" has two parts- regular and irregular. BOTH equally important to the writers of the 2nd Amendment.
Regular Militia is the one that you read about drilling on the town square. Available for call-up by the town for defense against Indian raids and to help fight fires and other emergencies. It can also be called up by the governor, and seconded(transferred) to federal control at the request of the president in time of national emergency. It could also be used BY the governor to defend the state against incursions on the state BY the federal government. This consisted of any male citizen age 16 to 45. Some claim the national guard now fills this purpose.
Irregular Militia is any and all males age 16-45 who are or declare they will become citizens and intend to defend their state (and country), using those same criteria. The irregulars are responsible for training themselves with their weapons.
Both types reportusing their own personally owned weapons.
Today, citizens are both male or female. And healthily able to respond for the calls much later in life.
Just today, HF-81was brought to the Iowa House Judiciary Committee. As you know, Iowa has been a blue state the last two elections.
HF-81 was a bill that protects the confidentiality and private information of permit-to-acquire applicants and concealed carry permit holders.
It passed by a vote of 20-0. Ever single member of the IA House Judiciary Committee voted for it.
In IL, the state with the tightest gun laws in the country, a Federal Appeals court has ruled that IL's concealed carry laws are unconstitutional and ordered the state to implement concealed carry within 180 days. That 180 days is up in four more days.
If those two things aren't black and white, what is? D.C. v Heller was black and white as well.
There comes a time that gun control advocates need to realize that it is indeed, black and white, the constitution is not a complex document filled with "secret messages" or meant to be decoded and start focusing on what we can do to reduce gun crime in this country rather than putting forth ideas that won't work or infringe on he rights of law abiding gun owners.
Well there is no original provision in the consititution for any of the original rights. Why would they write an amendment, and then immediately provise it with all the applicabilities for it? That seems very finalized; the opposite of what was intended.
The framers intended the document to be amended. They also intended it to be interpreted (hence the judiciary branch even existing). Otherwise, what would the Judiciary do?
Interpretation of the law is varied. While your interpretation includes a bunch of interesting (and perfectly valid) frameworks for age requirements and background (i.e. your whole post) those definitions werentspelled outin the constitution as an appendix either. That is your (and judiciary) interpretation of the law that is based on phrasing and applicability of wording at the time.
So if you meant your question to be set up in a way that it is unanswerable just to prove some arbitrary point, that is hardly condusive to constructive conversation on the matter.
Further, I assert that there is no law that is not open to interpretation hence the judicial system. I also assert that there is no right thatis above and beyond the preambleframework of this civilized society being:
"We the People of the United States, in Order to form a more perfect Union, establish Justice, insure domestic Tranquility, provide for the common defence, promote the general Welfare, and secure the Blessings of Liberty to ourselves and our Posterity, do ordain and establish this Constitution for the United States of America."
In order to establish justice and insure domestic tranquility a lot of laws were/are put into place including restrictions on the rights outlined in the amendments.
I ask again why you draw your line in the sand at military grade weapons? Nevermind, I see you edited that.
Quoting old dead guys isn't gonna reduce gun violence in our cities and it's not an excuse for doing nothing. I haven't advocated banning any guns but I do think that there are things we can do to reduce the killing. The "We have a second amendment so we'll shoot anything we want" crap isn't going to do it.
This argument from gun grabbers is getting tiresome. How precisely, do you plan to compel criminals to go through a "universal background check" when purchasing weapons from each other or trading them? How precisely, do you plan to compel criminals to voluntarily register their firearms? How precisely, do you plan on keeping guns out of their hands when there are well over 200,000,000 in circulation?
Gun rights advocates have expressed time and time again, a willingness to listen to proposals that address the criminal element and the broken mental health system without infringing on the rights of law abiding citizens.
So far, all the gun control crowd has floated are ideas that have no method of compelling criminals to comply and only burden the law abiding citizen.
Pat N
Decisions can be black and white... they have to be... either it happens or it doesnt.
This issue is clearly not black and white... otherwise the law wouldnt have "tried" to go into place in the first place.
Obviously someone thought (wrongly) that it was well within constitutionality to institute on it's face. After consideration, the issue was decided to be unconstitutional.
If anything, this is a very apt example of a shades of grey area where legislative is trying to clarify an unclear judicial point, but judicial is answering that the new legislation violates other prior legislation.
I see it from a different perspective. A law is a law is a law, unless it is challenged AND overturned. At that point, a court rules on the constitutionality.
Say legislators write a law that a condition of citizenship is that every household has to catch a squirrel, paint it purple and keep it in their livingroom. If no one challenges that law...it is what it is. Period. No grey. It is black and white. Get a squirrel, paint it purple or be kicked out of the country.
ONLY if that law is challeged, the courts agree to hear it AND it's overturned, could anything resembling "grey" enter the picture. And then it's just during the deliberation process until the court rules one way or the other.
See, but in your example... I catch a squirel and I paint it red, then blue. In the end it dries purple. Is that following the law the way it was writtenor is that following the law in a way that I want to follow it? Maybe all I had was red and blue paint... maybe the purple paint had a toxin in it that I didnt want to use. Regardless of the justification, this is not a black and white issue.
I'm not saying these things to be contrary. Just saying that to live a life in absolutes is impossible. There are many, many ways to skin a cat and not all of them would follow the exact way that you would follow to do it.
The framers realized this so they left the documents both open to interpretation and open to amendment. To insist that the only way to read, interpret and follow the law is your own way is not the truth in life.
Hell, in Detroit, an officer sighting is like Bigfoot... People claim to have seen them, but you cannot believe until you see for yourself. So, with MI laws being one of the most lax for concealed carry, people certainly take advantage of that and take things into their own hands as needed. Most often, the citizens do a better job.
Stevie- but there, you are dead wrong. Over the last 10 years, violent crime has decreased 4% average per year. During that same time, we have INCREASED the number of "Must Issue" concealed carry states to 37. ONLY in states that prohibit gun carry, or states in which certain cities prohibit it, does violent crime rise. The toughest anti-gun laws are in Chicago. And the highest violent crime rates (and the highest gun crime rates) are in Chicago. Those "old dead guys" are the ones who recognize this fact, and established, via the 2nd Amendment, our right to remain armed. It is people who willfully and deliberately twist facts that cause more crime to occur. Even Obama has said the proposed assault rifle controls won't stop mass killings, "but we HAVE to do something!" The fact that that something violates the Constitution, punishes law-abiding citizens, and actually INCREASES crime is irrelevant. We have done SOMETHING!
Prove it.
Damn...just what I was thinking...I need a way to "like" Neale's comment!
Any unregistered weapons would become illegal weapons. Currently, law enforcement cannot seize the weapons of criminals as long as they are being transported legally. Registered weapons found in possession of someone other than the registered owner could be confiscated and released only to the registered owner. I'm not saying that this is a magic pill that's gonna turn the world into candy land. It's just a tool for law enforcement to help them get illegal guns off the streets.