╌>

When Tragedy Hits

  

Category:  News & Politics

Via:  feddy  •  14 years ago  •  45 comments

When Tragedy Hits

I wrote this response on the comment wall of my group Woman's World to address the sadness expressed there. I decided to go ahead and put it in article form. I figured if I was going to piss people off I might as well do it with style. I will once more say that I do not mean to disrespect anyone, especially the family and friends of the victims, or the victims themselves. I also want to state that I believe that to feel sadness over this tragedy is completely normal. I feel sad about it too. I just have other beliefs regarding this tragedy as well. So here goes nothing:

Well I guess I'm going to have to be the bad guy here. I will state however that I mean no offense to anyone. My opinion is that what happened is awful. A true tragedy. However life does not and should not stop. I'm not just talking about gun control although I am very against gun control. I'm also talking about songs being pulled from the radio, movies not premiering, etc. because of this event. I'm not really against maybe a day of silence or a moment, but life should not halt to a stop. I wish I could fully explain why I feel/think this way, but words fail me. I guess it's mostly because terrible things happen all the time in nature, to all of us, etc. Does the world stop? No it doesn't. It's not meant to. It's just like that saying "Time waits for no man". The world does not stop turning because we're hurt, sad, etc. Having said all that I still feel it is a true tragedy. I think each one of us are deeply saddened by this, and truly feel for the family and friends affected most. There are enough people in that community that are truly affected by what happened. It does them no good if the world stops. What they need is to see that life goes on. We have to show them that.


Tags

jrDiscussion - desc
[]
 
Feddy
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Feddy    14 years ago

I say this in part because when I have been at my lowest it has helped me to see that life goes on. Sometimes that fact was just the kick in the butt I needed.

 
 
 
leonahardware
Freshman Silent
link   leonahardware    14 years ago

What they need is to see that life goes on. We have to show them that.

Very well put!!!! (((((Fed Up)))))

 
 
 
Feddy
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Feddy    14 years ago

Thanks for stopping by Bruce. Sometimes all that's left is the pieces, but the show must go on.

 
 
 
Feddy
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Feddy    14 years ago

Thank you Leona! (((Leona)))

 
 
 
Feddy
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Feddy    14 years ago

Neetu you don't have to agree with me to be my friend. Grin.gif However I too have suffered losses. Not death, but as close to death as anything can be I suppose. So I do think I know of which I speak. I am in no way, shape, or form trying to minimize what these people are going through. Or the grief you feel for that matter. I am of the belief that all feelings are valid. Even if they may not be what most would consider right, normal, etc. I still feel that if anyone has any kind of feeling it is valid. I'm sure that for these people who have been most affected by this time is standing rather still. However when the dust settles and it will settle, they will eventually be able to take comfort in the fact that life goes on. Even though right now I'm sure they'd much rather be with the loved ones they lost. Life will go on rather we choose to move on or not. That's all I'm trying to say. All of us at some point or another are going to have to face rough times. We have two choices when this happens. Some times we can take our time making this choice, some times we don't have that luxury. The choices are to lay down and die, or pick ourselves up and do the best we can to move on. I have tried both options. Personally, I'd rather try to regain some normalcy in my life. It is easier said than done, but it is doable. Even if you have to take life a day, hour, or minute at a time to make it through. There have been times for me that taking life a day at a time has been too much to handle. That's when I break my day down even further. To an hour, or a minute. Unfortunately these people are already having to move on as we speak. They are either planning or have planned a funeral for their loved one. Before long they will have to return to work, to the grocery store, etc. They will even have to send their remaining kids back to that very same school. I do not say any of this to sound harsh or insensitive. Actually I'm quite the opposite. I'm one of the most sensitive, compassionate people you'll ever meet. I just think that we all need to look at reality though. Taking a song off the radio right now because it discusses death is not going to bring these poor souls back. It's like putting a bandaid on a shark bite. It just doesn't work. I for one would rather take these people by the hand, and offer them some solace that things will get better. Even though right now it may not seem like it.

As far as gun control goes I'm sure I can't change your mind any more than you could change mine. We will just have to agree to disagree. Grin.gif

 
 
 
Perrie Halpern R.A.
Professor Guide
link   Perrie Halpern R.A.    14 years ago

While I agree that life goes on, I think that there is a time to mourn. It hasn't even been a week yet. The funerals have only just begun.

To every thing there is a season,
and a time to every purpose under the heaven;
1. A time to be born, and a time to die;
2. A time to plant, and a time to pluck up that which is planted;
3. A time to kill, and a time to heal;
4. A time to break down, and a time to build up;
5. A time to weep, and a time to laugh;
6. A time to mourn, and a time to dance;
7. A time to cast away stones, and a time to gather stones together;
8. A time to embrace, and a time to refrain from embracing;
9. A time to seek, and a time to lose;
10. A time to keep, and a time to cast away;
11. A time to rend, and a time to sew;
12. A time to keep silence, and a time to speak;
13. A time to love, and a time to hate;
14. A time of war, and a time of peace.

It is just my personal opinion that the time to grieve isn't quite over until the last of the dead have been buried and their small lives have been given their due.

But I still luv ya Feddy!

 
 
 
Dowser
Sophomore Silent
link   Dowser    14 years ago

Perrie, that is beautiful! I love that part!

Fed Up, I think everyone reaches that conclusion at different times, as people grieve differently. For some people, (like the parents and spouses), it may take a few years to forever. For others, like us, who are deeply saddened by the tragedy, but know none of the families personally, it is easier for us to go on.

I think it will happen, because life just goes on... I think that Perrie is right, too. Let us bury our dead, say our prayers, and then, we have to go on and keep living. Day by day, step by step.

Take care, dear friend!!

 
 
 
Feddy
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Feddy    14 years ago

I love you too Perrie. I never meant to say that they or we shouldn't grieve. That's not what I meant at all. Apparently I'm not explaining myself very well.

 
 
 
Feddy
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Feddy    14 years ago

Dowser as I stated to Perrie I too believe there should be a grieving period. I was not trying to say "Don't grieve". I merely meant that for most of us (who are only watching this on TV), life should go on. Grieve if you must, feel sad, etc. Those are completely normal feelings. However I don't feel that cancelling a violent movie, etc. is the answer. As I stated above it's a bandaid on a shark bite. I guess if that's what everyone wants, so be it. This is all just my personal opinion. If my son died today I wouldn't be concerned about what movie was playing at the theater, or what song is playing on the radio. I'd have bigger fish to fry.

 
 
 
Dowser
Sophomore Silent
link   Dowser    14 years ago

I understood that, dearest Fed up! And I see your point! I appreciate that it was made as a gesture of respect, but they'll still play the movie, just probably at a later date. Hollywood does this kind of thing all the time. They delayed the release of Valkyrie for about a year, and other films have been delayed for various reasons, as well.

There will come a time when the focus will shift to some new and other crisis, and, while these children will never be forgotten, everyone will get all in an uproar over something else. Take care!!!

Note: I think we cross-posted, or something... I'm a bit confused as to why some replies go in different places, and I'm sure I'm doing something wrong. :-)

 
 
 
Perrie Halpern R.A.
Professor Guide
link   Perrie Halpern R.A.    14 years ago

I have always said that the written word can be often misconstrued. No worries!

However I don't feel that cancelling a violent movie, etc. is the answer. As I stated above it's a bandaid on a shark bite.

See, there I totally agree!

 
 
 
Time Lord
Freshman Silent
link   Time Lord    14 years ago

All this conversation about 'Time' an ma ears have been ringin off da HOOK.

A somber and disturbing topic fer sure. Each of us will grapple with, dismiss, divert the emotions associated with this tragedy in many different ways. Few I think, will not be effected. It touches us all when innocence is lost.

I see this reoccurring event as a society who has lost it's innocence. When I look back and compare our culture and society with the days of 'Mayberry' and the Clevers...it becomes obvious to me thaa we have lost our sense of community, safety and commonality. We have devolved into a violent society and a violent nation. We are no longer a nation of 'peace-keepers'. We have become an aggressive, invading warring nation and a nation of warriors.

Wars and warring has become glorified. Our 'independence' has become a cage that isolates us. "Either yer with us...or against us". Does thaa ring a bell? We have become a nation divided by religion, political affiliation, race and ideologies. Our mantra has become...'everyone for themselves', screw yer neighbor.

We seem to have lost our sense of innocence and our souls have become 'hardened' by that. Our children are 'mirrors' to this changing reality. This is sad.

 
 
 
Dowser
Sophomore Silent
link   Dowser    14 years ago

Well said, dearest Timey!

 
 
 
MsAubrey (aka Ahyoka)
Junior Participates
link   MsAubrey (aka Ahyoka)    14 years ago

When I look back and compare our culture and society with the days of 'Mayberry' and the Clevers...it becomes obvious to me thaa we have lost our sense of community, safety and commonality.

The times of the Clevers and Mayberry were simply times where media did not have the capacity as it does now. Word couldn't travel as fast. We didn't necessarily know what happened in another state minutes after it happened. That's the only difference really. Crazy things still happened. It always has. We just hear about all of it now and at a much faster rate.

 
 
 
Petey Coober
Freshman Silent
link   Petey Coober    14 years ago

[[The times of the Clevers and Mayberry were simply times where media did not have the capacity as it does now. Word couldn't travel as fast.]]

Yeah , that pony express was soooo slowwww .Tongue.gif

 
 
 
Time Lord
Freshman Silent
link   Time Lord    14 years ago

An interesting topic..."The Speed of Communication Over The Past One Hundred Or so...Years".

The Pony Express was FAST compared to "snail boat, stage and rail mail" of the 'Time'. International news had months of lag time. Domestic and international news spread through travelers. Written and printed news took weeks to months to disperse across the country.

Communication in Morse Code was rapidly sent over a wire that stretched hundreds of miles, usually following the railroad lines. The advent of radio and the telephone were huge advances in communication technology and the speed of communication grew into a vast world wide network with a world wide audience.

This audience and the speed of global communication has exploded exponentially since the 50's and the advent of TV and Computers. The Queen of England doesn't fart or the Pope falls asleep during worship...and it's "twittered" about around the globe in minutes...seconds...milliseconds.

The increased speed of information (communication) has forever changed the complexion of our society...for better or worse, it will never be the same as it once wuz. As we 'knew' it, before the 'collective consciousness' that emanates from the Internets sheer volume/size of exchanged data. Who's data is it anyway...? What constitutes "Privacy"? Ok...I won't 'sell' your information. BUTT...ah will sell you an operating platform. Now this platform gathers and shares personal and random data information with other subscribers who use/operate on this platform. Key word is SHARED...as part of the program/operating platform...so the information (personal or random) is not "sold" in the traditional sense of the word. It's included as part of the platform. If you don't want to 'play'...you've gotta "opt-out". But if you don't know that you've gotta "opt-out"...then yer playin an jus don't know 'bout it.

So here's my question..."when does the 'user' of the game become the game itself, which is then converted and targeted back to better exploit the strengths and weaknesses of the 'user'....?" Jus askin...isn't the user gittin used?......duuUUuh

 
 
 
Petey Coober
Freshman Silent
link   Petey Coober    14 years ago

Yes , the user is getting used ... but there is no reason to expect that services will be completely free .

 
 
 
Time Lord
Freshman Silent
link   Time Lord    13 years ago

ahhhhh, yes...but what exactly is the "COST"...???

 
 
 
Time Lord
Freshman Silent
link   Time Lord    13 years ago

Ah tend ta disagree Miss Aubrey. Knives or brass knuckles may have made it into the high schools back then. There were the occasional fist fights and in some larger cities, gang fights off campus, but there wasn't mass slashing, shootings or killing happening on school campus...and certainly not on the elementary school campus. There wasn't any wide spread personal safety concerns about going to school in the 50's and 60's...barring the racial prejudice issues going on at the time. But that didn't translate into indiscriminate killing of teachers and students in the hallways...white or black. This distinction was reserved for the National Guard shooting unarmed protestors on the college campus. Now THAA made the news...

 
 
 
Kara Shalee
Freshman Silent
link   Kara Shalee    13 years ago

but there is no reason to expect that services will be completely free .

Why not?? It used to be that life wasn't all about consumerism. You may be too young to know, so I'm letting you know that it wasn't always this way.

I also don't buy into (pun not intended) the concept that things were always this way, andwe just didn't have the media to know about them.

No, things weren't always this way. There really WERE gentler times. May we find them again.

And God Bless those that must live on in CT.........the little souls that departed are in Heaven. But their parents, their teachers, their little classmates...........No things like this DIDN'T always happen. This is a representation of complete and utter chaos, and too sad for words. I cried all day when Sandy Hook happened.

 
 
 
Kara Shalee
Freshman Silent
link   Kara Shalee    13 years ago

I'll second what you wrote, Time Lord. No, NONE of this happened in our country in the 50's and 60's. Sure, there was still crime, but none of it on the massive scale that we now must be a part of. I also realize that I look back through some filters that "life was better then". I think EVERYTHING which has materialized today began on November 22, 1963. Life in America forever changed on that date. And, we can't seem to get back what was lost.

I haven't got any answers here, either. I don't think anyone has, or else it wouldn't be happening...........that this has gotten to the level of our elementary schools is not only outrageous, it's just that we can't allow it any more. And we have to find answers. Or we're gonna proceed to complete anarchy.

I don't think that "gun control" is the answer either, since then only the criminals have the guns. But I am very much against the multiple round automatic clip firearms. Don't need those to hunt for food, nor to protect your family. And, the criminals still have them, no matter what steps are taken to remove even those.........so no, I don't have any answers. A whole lot of questions.........

 
 
 
Kara Shalee
Freshman Silent
link   Kara Shalee    13 years ago

Neetu, I agree with paragraph one here. But I'll go ahead and challenge you on paragraph 2.

I will also say I am for gun-control, 100%. Always was and always will be. But that is just how it is. And I will fight for it, in my own way, without guns and without violence. I still think of you as friend, although we may not agree.

Let me ask you a thought provoking question. Suppose, God forbid, an armed burglar broke into your home? What would you do? Go ahead and let him proceed? What if something startled him and he got a bad case of the nerves and, as you were now bound and gagged, you could do nothing to save your family? If you'd had a loaded gun behind you (or even one that you could brandish that wasn't loaded) or one placed under a table exactly for this scenario, are you saying that you wouldn't use it to protect your family? Maybe you wouldn't, and that's a valid response. I'm just wondering. I too, used to be for gun control. Then my husband made me think it through. We are now locked and loaded for bear..........and I've done a 180 on my position.

 
 
 
Kara Shalee
Freshman Silent
link   Kara Shalee    13 years ago

Fed, I really had to take awhile on this. I didn't understand your position. Then it became crystal clear...........YOU my dear, are a Pioneer. I'm not. You would have made it over the Donner pass, and I woulda been eaten. I'm no Pioneer. And Pioneers are I guess what make life go on in the face of horrible tradgedies.

 
 
 
Feddy
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Feddy    13 years ago

Thank you Kara. I do think you underestimate yourself though. I have always had an extremely strong survival instinct. It amazes me how many people don't though. I thought that everyone was born with it. But they aren't. I guess that's why it's survival of the fittest. I believe I hit a nerve with this article. Perhaps I wrote it too soon after the tragedy. I was never trying to say that people shouldn't grieve, or that the mother of one of these children should go right back to work the very next day. To be honest I was a little irritated that hardly anyone understood my position. I thought I had articulated myself well. But I think the real reason this article didn't go over well is because in our culture death is taboo. We don't deal with it well at all. We don't even like to talk about it. Which is a real shame because we will all die and have to face the death of loved ones eventually. I think we need to take a good, hard look at ourselves, and face reality. Because that is another area that our culture is strongly lacking. A lot of us are very removed from reality. We prefer to ignore things rather than deal with them.

 
 
 
Kara Shalee
Freshman Silent
link   Kara Shalee    13 years ago

But I think the real reason this article didn't go over well is because in our culture death is taboo. We don't deal with it well at all. We don't even like to talk about it. Which is a real shame because we will all die and have to face the death of loved ones eventually. I think we need to take a good, hard look at ourselves, and face reality. Because that is another area that our culture is strongly lacking. A lot of us are very removed from reality. We prefer to ignore things rather than deal with them.

Yes, I agree. And I don't think it's healthy at all. If we were back to being a series of villages, then I think it would be a whole lot different. Villages handle death entirely differently. They grieve, and grieve hard, and support each other fiercely. But they know that another death will be coming soon. They help each other to go on. We in this Country have largely lost this ability. We are no longer a series of villages. So, I think this might be one reason why we don't know what to do nor how to handle it. And, that can be a tragedy in itself. For most people, when tragedy stikes them personally, it's as if they are a hot stove, and people leave them alone. Initially, this might be the right thing to do. But, after that, people need each other around them. It's tragic also that a lot of people in this Country have no family or friends close by them............so you have described a lot of tragedies within tragedies here.

Actually, I think your article can turn out to be well received, and generate some good discussion. I hope so. There's a lot to this subject.

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    13 years ago

I don't know why I'm just seeing this for the first time ...

But, my response to tragedy that is NOT inevitable ...

An Ounce of Prevention is Worth a Pound of Cure

Because there are precautions that will not have much effect does not mean there is any sanity in rejecting all precautions.

 
 
 
Feddy
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Feddy    13 years ago

Thank you for coming by Mac. I agree with you to a point. I disagree that tragedies are not inevitable. There have been tragedies since before you or I was even thought of. It is unfortunately the nature of the beast. I wish as much as anybody that some sort of solution can be found. Somehow I don't think you and I would agree on what kind of a solution, but that doesn't mean we can't be friends. I also think we both mean well. Grin.gif

 
 
 
Feddy
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Feddy    13 years ago

Thank you Kara. I'll have to think about it, but I might write another article. I have some questions now that I didn't think of before. I, like everybody else, was concerned with the tragedy at hand. None of us were thinking of the bigger picture. Perhaps there is more to be said.

 
 
 
Time Lord
Freshman Silent
link   Time Lord    13 years ago

Robear...it's been a loooooong 'Time' since our paths have crossed. It's so good to see and hear yer voice again. Know you've been missed.

Yes, living an life wasn't so good for blacks back in the day and I think ah alluded to thaa. They were the focus of much hatred and violence. Prejudice and the associated hatred and violence goes way back. The only thing that changes seems to be the targeted minority...but the US doesn't have a monopoly on prejudice and hatred, as ah'm sure you'd agree.

The seat belt comment made me chuckle. It's funny, but true. Whatta wit...

 
 
 
Kara Shalee
Freshman Silent
link   Kara Shalee    13 years ago

The 50s and 60s were better... for Whites...

Agree 100 percent here, Bob. For most Blacks, they were living through a nightmare. Not confined to the South, either, although it was much worse there. In the North, there wasn't the separation of drinking fountains, restaurant lunch counters, bars, etc that simply wouldn't serve Blacks. What a complete disgrace. In The Northern States, however, plenty of "de-facto" segregation took place. While it wasn't as bad, it was still quite apparent, even to a child, that blacks were seen fit for only certain jobs. Then as well, Mexicans were confined to being migrant field workers with no chance for a future, and treated not much better at all. Native Americans.........well many, including in my Dad's family, had to "hide" that they were Native Americans at all.

You are very spot on re selective memory. I DO think it quite tragic when all of the assasinations took place in the 1960's, along with the Vietnam war. And, I am of the position that had JFK lived, all that followed would NOT have taken place.

Thankfully we are better off in these directions now, but I still hear racism creep into discussions. And when I do, I speak up. Maya Angelou taught me to do that. And I follow her lead. That is all that the individual can do. The ignoramuses will unfortunately always be with us. While I can't talk sense into them, I can state my position, and if they continue to be unreasonable, or unteachable, then I just cross them off my list.

 
 
 
Feddy
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Feddy    13 years ago

No Bob I am not a heartless bastard contrary to belief.

 
 
 
Feddy
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Feddy    13 years ago

I do appreciate you not jumping on me. There's plenty of other people that do that here and in real life. I really don't need another one. lol I never meant to sound heartless. In real life I'm actually a very warm, caring, and compassionate person. I've cried over dogs that I didn't even know that have been run over before. My point was that I do feel some people go overboard (especially those who don't even truly know the deceased), and that yes eventually life must go on. I never said do not grieve, or that grieving was pointless. Quite the contrary. I think grieving is a very important part of death. I cry at funerals. You know it's funny because everyone seems to misunderstand me on here, but in real life when I explain my position about things people get me. I'm not sure why that is. Maybe because in real life I have body language to go along with what I'm saying. That and the people that know me really do know me.

 
 
 
Feddy
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Feddy    13 years ago

They do say that patience is a virtue. Grin.gif

 
 
 
MsAubrey (aka Ahyoka)
Junior Participates
link   MsAubrey (aka Ahyoka)    13 years ago

Grin.gif Good reply Bob.

How 'bout those 'Nam Vets upon return too?

I hadn't read all of the mention of 'Nam Vets before I typed that!

 
 
 
MsAubrey (aka Ahyoka)
Junior Participates
link   MsAubrey (aka Ahyoka)    13 years ago

Or... The 80's and Gay Hate crimes (which continue to take place but people are a bit more careful about it now)..... Senseless violence has ALWAYS been present. That is all I was trying to point out.

 
 
 
MsAubrey (aka Ahyoka)
Junior Participates
link   MsAubrey (aka Ahyoka)    13 years ago

Thank you for serving Sir. I truly mean that. Too many upon return did not receive the welcome and thanks that all so deserved. It's sad when you are trying to help and get shit on for it (pardon my word vulgarity).

 
 

Who is online




Nerm_L


119 visitors