I’m not a scientist... merely an observer. Does that disqualify my observations and conclusions???
I recently saw an article about the FRONTLINE documentary, The Climate of Doubt which highlights efforts to discredit the overwhelming scientific consensus that Anthropogenic Global Warming (AGW) is one of the most serious problems we face today.
While I do have an engineering background, I have no expertise or training in the area of climate science, yet I agree with the findings of the vast majority of scientists. I feel AGW is a very serious problem. In the course of the discussion on the article about the Frontline documentary I said this
I am not a scientist... merely an observer. I don't need to measure the amount of CO 2 we add to the atmosphere to establish my ideas about the impact mankind has on the planet. I simply open my eyes and look around. I also study history a little. It is plain to see we are taking more resources from the planet, using them more rapidly, and producing more waste than we or any other creature in the history of the planet ever has. For every person alive the day I was born there are 3 consuming our planetary resources today. For every person alive the day Jesus was born there are more than 40 consuming our planetary resources now. The problem is not simply that there are more of us, but each individual uses far more on average than any individual prior to the time of the industrial revolution. I don't have any figures on the per capita rate of resource consumption today or in the past... but simple observation reveals it is vastly greater today than it once was. Put in the simplest terms, there are too many people and we are doing too much stuff AGW is one of the results.
To my statement, I am not a scientist... merely an observer, I received this reply
Then MalamuteMan, you are not sufficiently learned or capable of determining
That person had a great deal to say about my capabilities and his own capabilities. That served as the inspiration for this article.
Perhaps the most discouraging observation I've made about human nature is our propensity for molding our beliefs to suit our desires. The scientific credo aspires to discover truths without regard to how they may or may not suit our desires. This does not mean scientists are not susceptible to the same temptations of belief the rest of us have, only that they work hard to avoid that pitfall. They devote their lives to discovering the truth with precision and integrity. When those truths repudiate practices enabling the comfortable and prosperous lifestyle we enjoy, or even the ideas we find comforting, then many of us are tempted to find fault with their discoveries. We become easy prey for dubiously crafted public relations tactics commonly used to mold public opinion.
I assert that 100% of the opposition to AGW stems from a resistance to change. Profiteers resist the prospect of profit limitations, and so fund those dubiously crafted public relations efforts. The rest of us resist limitations to the comfortable lifestyle we enjoy, and so gobble up the propaganda the profiteers feed us. If accepting AGW did not inherently suggest change and sacrifice as a necessary part of the remedy, there would be no challenges to it whatsoever!!!
While this article was inspired by the commentary in another article on the topic of AGW, AGW is NOT the primary topic of this article. If you wish to leave a comment, I ask that you stick to the following topics
- The question posed in the title of this article: Im not a scientist... merely an observer. Does that disqualify my observations and conclusions???
- Do you believe we all are tempted to mold our beliefs to suit our desires???
- Do you believe profiteers fund dubiously crafted public relations" in an effort to protect their profits???
Tags
Who is online
77 visitors

[Mal stops for a rest... snaps a few photos with his Instamatic while he waits...]
Not at all but neither does this mean your observations or conclusions are correct. I say observations because beauty is in the eye of the beholder.
I disagree bwith many of your conclusions and I
am alsoo an engineer.
Your use of the term "profiteers" is a dead givawayy for your anti-capitalist attitude -- as if profit is evil in and of itself. "Dubiously" is another givaway for your faulty premise. Not all profitts are evil and not all advertising is dubious though in some cases both are.
Mal is not a good nickname for someone whiotghinks most businessmen are bad.
Mal MEANS bad in Spanish.
How do you know global warming, assuming it exists, is man made?
The world's topoography and climate is ever changingf.
Certainly the warming from the ice age to here was not human caused --- right?
I agree with you Mal!
For the record, I do not think Capitalism is inherently bad. It is neither good nor bad. Some capitalists behave very honorably, others do not. And while we are on the subject of economic ideology, I feel pretty much the same way about socialism... it is not inherently good or bad. I am a proponent of straightforward candid honest communication. I very much concur with this statement, Len...
To be perfectly frank, I am liberal, and I think I have grown even more liberal as I have experienced may conservatives vilifying my ideas. Just as you gleaned something about my ideology from something I said, I have done the same by reading many things you have said. Because your ideology is different than mine I do not believe you are necessarily bad, I hope you will afford me the same consideration.
Len,
I have known Mal for over 4+ years and while I don't always see eye to eye with him, he isn't bad. In fact, he tries very hard to get to understand the opposing POVs. Mal is just easier than saying Malamuteman.
And we do speak English for the most part... So Mal is just a nickname.
Well from the scientific method, one can observe the results of an experiment, and draw conclusions. But we can't perform experiments on the planet earth, so all we can do is observe and take stats. Look atpreviousrecords found in and on the earth and draw assumptions. Your conclusions are just as valid when compared to anyone else's but I am not sure if anyone's observations including scientists, is a total picture, since we can not control the experiment earth.
Sure. Whether we do or not is a matter of ethics or should I say, how ethical a person is.
Sure. But it can also be said that the scientist are alsovulnerableto suchincentives. Grant money etc. can be as much as an incentive as profit as it keeps them working. Now I am not saying that scientist that believe in AGW are being unethical, just throwing this out there to show that it can rub both ways.
BTW I do believe that we are affecting our environment. But we may also be going through a cycle as well. But since this is our only home, I think that we should take care of it and minimize our impact.
Great article Mal and thanks...woof, woof!
Many times I've gotten into conversations and totally ignore any questions about religion; I would much rather discuss the topic at hand, than the reasons why my or someone Else's religious leaning is grounds for dismissing them (or me!) from having an intellectual exchange. People are constantly attempting to deflect and dismiss the truth, even from themselves.
I am a Christian and also believe that we were commanded to take care of the Garden. I would like to have my statements and thoughts judged of their own accord, not my religious belief. I have had successful conversations with many different kindsa people, regardless of our spiritual thoughts, and completely reliant on just talking with one another.
No. A thousand years ago a scientist may have been a Native American sitting on a rock listening to the wind and waves, gaining understanding of the moons cycles and the fish's spawn. A good scientist is one who understands that the first, most important task is being a good observer. Science has always been about observing first.
Absolutely. I would add though, that desire seems to be a very large motivating factor that has pushed the human species to survive, though I'm not sure if we are using the word "desire" in the same context here.
Yes, on both sides of the aisle. Here is an article I posted not too long ago and exemplifies what worries me about GW. We can and do make observations; how they are used and whether we actually have any kinda proof that their conclusions and remedies are correct, is a different matter. My concern is that we make faulty conclusions about GW, and then offer remedies that are counter-productive. Honest and open debate, devoid of the other baggage is essential to solving this problem.
I am well aware of the Spanish meaning of the word "mal." Nonetheless, I am very proud to be called Mal. As my full handle suggest I am a fancier of Malamutes. I was first drawn to Malamutes because they are the domestic breed that is most similar to wolves (a species I feel is unfairly vilified... much as I feel my liberal views are unfairly vilified). Over the years I have had several Malamutes in my pack (I have no human progeny). I find their very friendly, kind and loyal nature to be very endearing. I aspire to be similar.
I think I explained that about as well as I could have in the article...
AGW may be the most serious result of mankind's impact on the planet... but there are many.
Warming, cooling, and other climactic changes prior to the beginning of the industrial revolution were not, IMO, caused by humans. Beginning with the industrial revolution the impact of humans has been enormous. Because the planet has undergone significant climactic changes without any influence by human activity in the past does not mean the climactic changes we are seeing now are not human caused. Scientists have gone to great effort to understand what mankind is doing to the planet. The overwhelming majority of scientists agree that mankind is having a significant detrimental impact on global climate (not to mention damaging the planetary ecosystem in other ways).
Suggesting I think "most businessmen are bad" simply because I used the term "profiteer" is, to use your terminology, "a dead giveaway" to your bias. I most certainly do not think most businessmen are bad! Most businessmen are just trying to make an honest living. I think businessmen who fund dubiously crafted public relations" efforts in order to protect their profits, even though they know full well they are doing great harm ... those businessmen are bad.
I think it is more a matter of personal discipline.
[Mal shakes his head...]
Perrie.... sheesh!!!! Scientist are human, and they want to keep their jobs just as much as anyone... but that argument is an absurd Red Herring commonly used by AGW opponents. There is no comparison between the incentive a scientist hoping to secure grant money might have and the incentive large corporations have... ABSOLUTELY NONE!!!!! Furthermore, scientists MUST rely on their credibility to ensure they have ongoing funding. Creating false information to secure a grant not only jeopardizes their careers for the long term, but it jeopardizes the credibility of the entire scientific community. The bedrock of science is CREDIBILITY!!! Without it there is no science. Good scientists are quick to condemn members of their community who jeopardize the credibility of the community. Super wealth corporations have no such incentive to be honest and straightforward... in fact they have LOTS of incentive to bend the truth... more and more we are see that telling bald face lies have no downside.
Thanks Larry!!!
I hope you get a chance to see the comment I left on iarnuocon's article about atheism .
Thanks Perrie... Now if Mal can just avoid the rolled up newspaper after Perrie reads the other comment Mal left for her...
[Mal skulks off...]
Mal,
You took a big leap when from an innocent question. It is alegitimatequestion. There is no way to "prove" in the scientific sense, AGW. Any scientist worth their weight would agree. What they can do is extrapolate from what they can find data wise. I am sure that most scientists are honorable men, but I am I have seen faulty data onautismdue tomonetaryincentive of desperate parents. Just recently, a doctor confessed that he falsified the data at Duke for target cancer treatment. ...
Where ever there is money involved, there is a danger of people behaving unethically, and that includes scientists. That is not to say that I believe that is going on with AGW scientist, but it is me trying to show that it rubs both ways and it is always healthy to examine all involved to make sure that they are aiming at the highest standards always.
This article was inspired because people are trying to create doubt. As I said, scientists are human... they do things they shouldn't do just like all the rest of us. But there is a tactic used to discredit a large and highly credible consensus... Create doubt and controversy to combat overwhelming consensus... use that doubt to stall for more time... time to profit... It was pioneered in a big way by the tobacco companies... now it is used by the oil industry and others who see acting to avert AGW as a threat to their profits. Saying things like, "it rubs both ways" feeds the efforts of those who want to create doubt. It saddens me to hear you say that.
If that is true, then that has to apply to pretty much everything scientists say. AGW is about as thoroughly research and validated as any scientific idea.
Then the overwhelming majority of scientists are not "worth their weight."
I gotta tell ya Perrie... I find statements like that... from you... absolutely flabbergasting... absolutely flabbergasting!
You shouldn't. I teach science. The scientific method is the only way to prove a theory. Everything else can point to a theory being a fact, but it doesn't make it a fact. The holy grail of science "The Theory of Everything" can't be proven although there are many physicists believe in it, and are now trying to prove it inSwitzerland. But they know until then, it is just a theory.
The scientific method is outline here:
Well we can't do number 4 or 8.
Now, if you are asking me if I believe that we affect the planet with our activities, I will say yes. I will say that the first 3 criteria are met. But we can't prove AGW. That doesn't mean that I think that we should let human activity go on the way it has, since we can't also prove the opposite, that is, that human activity isn't causing the huge changes in climate that we are seeing. Heck Mal, I am living it, remember? Neither can be proved or disproved. So in the light that this is our only planet, I go with the AGW people, not because there is proof, but because I feel that it is the prudent thing to do.
The point of any article is to have a healthy discussion, and not to be made to feel guilty for saying what they believe. I am sorry that I disappoint you, but I have to be true to myself.
I agree, health discussion is the point. It was not my intention to make you feel guilty, if I did I apologize. Your commitment to being true to yourself is something I admire a lot!!!
I really don't want to argue this point with you any further... but I want you to know I do not agree with your assertion that "we can't do number 4 or 8."
I hope you take some time to look at the FRONTLINE documentary reference in the first paragraph of the article.
Well, I guess we will have to declare an impasse then.
I will. I think I might have seen it, but I am not sure. I am always open to any new information.
[[but I want you to know I do not agree with your assertion that "we can't do number 4 or 8."]]
You disagree with no explanation ? Is that because you realize [in some part of yourself] that you can't explain your position ? If not you need to support your assertion ...
Not necessarily from a scientific standpoint; neither does it in-and-of-itself mean you have wrongly observed nor concluded.
The problem is that the lay-person nay-sayers who reject ideas based on an agenda that is self-serving rather than objective, help perpetuate the self-serving agendas of those who pander to them in exchange for their votes. This phenomenon usually happens despite the adverse affects it has on the very interests of the willing dupes!
I have no doubt that we are all so-tempted; but if bias and ignorance control the outcomes, while desires may be fulfilled initially ... the yielding to temptations may ultimately be disastrous.
In Philly, we have a colloquialism ... "Bull@!$%# walks and money talks." Those who believe that "The marketplace is God," may one day kill the planet ... and consequently, all of us.
This is the conservative boiler plate response for the scientifically challenged! Iceberg and glacial core samples show an increased level of dissolved CO2 that corresponds to the period known as the industrial revolution.
Sorry that Hurricane Sandy is an Inconvenient Truth. For the regressive-right, the denial is a "Convenient Untruth."
NOTE: I removed the comment about Len; it's time for detente.
Perrie still wouldn't hit Mal with a newspaper. Friends don't let friends hit each other when they disagree, LOL.
[[or, if they do have all of the expertise and education, they forget that ultimately the goal of acquiring knowledge is to pass the knowledge on.]]
Not really . The ultimate goal of knowledge is to pay back your tuition expenses !
I have offered plenty of explanation in the article and my comments for my approach. There are mountains of scientific information on AGW available from very qualified scientists for those who will look. If that is not sufficient, then I realize in every part of myself that I have no energy or desire to continue beating this poor dead horse. Furthermore... as I said... This article is not really about AGW... Yes, I admit I got hooked into that discussion... My bad.
One more thing... The reason I am so weary with all of this stems from this...
I don't know about you P., but conversation in an environment that is so rampant with confirmation bias really wears me out... it's kind of Sisyphean.
That's Rich Mal. I am not sure if you know that.
Cool word sisyphean. Says it all.
The issue happened because of question 3. Once you have to discussprofiteers fund dubiously crafted public relations, you have to discuss the actual issue. It only matters if the conditionexists, which is the point here.
Perrie ,
Have you had a chance to look at RD's latest heads up ?
And themselves.
The market place is never a good place for a decision like this to be made.
Fair enough! I did not mean to insult you and I apologize for giving that impression. I could not help notice the confluence of your name and what seemed to be your pov. I am glad you moderated that impression.
I am not opposed to liberalism and, in fact, spent most of my life as one. But I am aware of the tendency of individuals to conform to groupthink and tend to lean against the wind. There is a saying: "When everyone thinks alike, everyone is likely to be wrong." A couple o0f books that bear this out are "Great Popular Delusions and the Madness of Crowds" by Charles Mackay, and "The Crowd" by Gustave Le Bon.
The phrasethat best describesliberal conformity is "political correctness." As I saw this tendency enveloping liberalism I took a step back and decided to investigate alternatives.
The first book, written in 1882,provides a history of several great delusions propagated by crowd psychology. These include the South Sea Bubble, the tulipomania, the Crusades, the witch mania and many others. In our era you could add the Florida real estate bubble andthe 1920s and 1990sstock-market frenzies.
I would not put AGW in this category yet because it has not yet avalanched and caused serious harm. It is still an idea and, for all I know, you may be right. However I have learned to be very cautious in trusting experts because one can always find experts who disagree with the other experts. Allow me to present a couple of articles that should make one cautious in jumping to conclusions about AGW.
SURFACE TEMPERATURE RECORDS: POLICY DRIVEN DECEPTION?
by Joseph DAleo and Anthony Watts
Jan. 29, 2010
(111 page Science and Public Policy Institute Original Paper)
S UMMARY FOR P OLICYMAKERS
1. Instrumental temperature data for the pre-satellite era (1850-1980) have been so widely, systematically, and unidirectionally tampered with that it cannot be credibly asserted there has been any significant global warming in the 20th century.
2. All terrestrial surface-temperature databases exhibit very serious problems that render them useless for determining accurate long-term temperature trends.
3. All of the problems have skewed the data so as greatly to overstate observed warming both regionally and globally.
4. Global terrestrial temperature data are gravely compromised because more than three-quarters of the 6,000 stations that once existed are no longer reporting.
5. There has been a severe bias towards removing higher-altitude, higher-latitude, and rural stations, leading to a further serious overstatement of warming.
6. Contamination by urbanization, changes in land use, improper siting, and inadequately-calibrated instrument upgrades further overstates warming.
7. Numerous peer-reviewed papers in recent years have shown the overstatement of observed longer term warming is 30-50% from heat-island contamination alone.
8. Cherry-picking of observing sites combined with interpolation to vacant data grids may make heat-island bias greater than 50% of 20th-century warming.
9. In the oceans, data are missing and uncertainties are substantial. Comprehensive coverage has only been available since 2003, and shows no warming.
10. Satellite temperature monitoring has provided an alternative to terrestrial stations in compiling the global lower-troposphere temperature record. Their findings are increasingly diverging from the station-based constructions in a manner consistent with evidence of a warm bias in the surface temperature record.
11. NOAA and NASA, along with CRU, were the driving forces behind the systematic hyping of 20th-century global warming.
12. Changes have been made to alter the historical record to mask cyclical changes that could be readily explained by natural factors like multidecadal ocean and solar changes.
13. Global terrestrial data bases are seriously flawed and can no longer be trusted to assess climate trends or VALIDATE model forecasts.
14. An inclusive external assessment is essential of the surface temperature record of CRU, GISS and NCDC chaired and paneled by mutually agreed to climate scientists who do not have a vested interest in the outcome of the evaluations.
d
15. Reliance on the global data by both the UNIPCC and the US GCRP/CCSP also requires a full investigation and audit.
Money quotes:
Ronald Coase, Nobel Laureate in economics for 1991, once said: If we torture the data long enough, it will confess.
In addition to the slow degradation of the observing system, there has been a coordinated effort to manipulate instrumental data. This manipulation has produced an exaggerated warming that is blamed on mans influence. ---
I will be the first to admit that man does have some climate effect, but the effect is largely localized. As we will show, half or more of the reported warming since 1900 is attributable to land use changes and urbanization.
(Many of the measurement stations are proximate to warming sources.)
The Climategate whistleblower proved what those of us dealing with data for decades already knew. The data were not merely degrading in quantity and quality: they were being manipulated . The IPCC and the scientists supporting it have worked to remove the pesky Medieval Warm Period, the Little Ice Age, and the period emailer Tom Wigley referred to as the warm 1940s blip. They have also worked to pump up the recent warm cycle that ended in 2001. And inexplicably, adjustments cooled many locations in the early record, which augmented the apparent trend.
WS Journal
REVIEW & OUTLOOK SEPTEMBER 18, 2011, 7:10 P.M. ET
'High School Physics'
Another Nobel laureate breaks from the climate change pack
That's how Al Gore described the science of climate change this week, by which we suppose he meant it's elementary and unchallengeable. Well, Mr. Vice President, meet Ivar Giaever, a 1973 physics Nobel Laureate who resigned last week from the American Physical Society in protest over the group's insistence that evidence of man-made global warming is "incontrovertible."
In an email to the society, Mr. Giaeverwho works at Rensselaer Polytechnic Institutewrote that "The claim (how can you measure the average temperature of the whole earth for a whole year?) is that the temperature has changed from ~288.0 to ~288.8 degree Kelvin in about 150 years, which (if true) means to me . . . that the temperature has been amazingly stable, and both human health and happiness have definitely improved in this 'warming' period."
Mr. Giaever was an American Physical Society fellow, an honor bestowed on "only half of one percent" of the members, according to a spokesman. He follows in the footsteps of University of California at Santa Barbara Emeritus Professor of Physics Harold Lewis, a former APS fellow who resigned in 2010, calling global warming "the greatest and most successful pseudoscientific fraud I have seen in my long life as a physicist."
Other dissenters include Stanford University physicist and Nobelist Robert B. Laughlin, deceased green revolution icon and Nobelist Norman Borlaug, Princeton physicist William Happer and World Federation of Scientists President Antonino Zichichi. Our point is not that all of these men agree on climate change, much less mankind's contribution to it, only that to one degree or another they maintain an open mind about warming or what to do about it.
One of the least savory traits of climate-change advocates is how they've tried to bully anyone who keeps an open mind. This is true of many political projects, but it is or ought to be anathema to the scientific method. With the cap-and-trade movement stymied, Mr. Gore and the climate clan have become even more arch in their dismissals of anyone who disagrees. Readers can decide who they'd rather study physics withProfessor Giaever, or Mr. Gore's list of politically certified instructors.
Len,
I hate it when people use Gore as their reason to dismiss anything that has to do with us affecting the earths climate. I never saw An Inconvenient Truth, but I have read many other papers written by climatologist that have provided some very interesting reasons for why they have come to this conclusion. They weren't channeling Al either. So when somephysicists say otherwise, well other than it not being their field of study, I just don't jump up and say, "Well wow. I was blind and now I can see."
I want to know what they base it on, how they got there, what studies they have done, where did they get their stats. You get the idea.
As I said to Mal, AGW it can't be proved or disproved. So what it comes down to, is if you feel like you want to gamble with the only place we call home.
That is precisely the topic of the FRONTLINE documentary cited in the first paragraph of this article.
I hope you take the time to look at it Len.
See An Inconvenient Truth. It's well worth the effort.
I agree, Mickey!
It is an amazingly well chosen title... It is exactly what I was talking about when I said...
Because they are "inconvenient"... So we...
Thanks for the tip Perrie!
Hey Rich!
That certainly is the irony of all this... If there is dramatic climate change, the well established opportunities to profit will be, at the very least, disrupted. For the record, I have no doubt that one way or another, every last drop and crumb of fossil fuel will eventually be used. Rapa Nui... we're right behind you...
The media is the message. Gore has been the popular voice of human global warming and it is thereforelegitimate to include him in discussion. He is not an impartial observer and is profiting handsomely from the warming industry.
You are correct in referring to the science and that is what I summarized and referenced in the post on surface temperature records. I am a numbers person myself. That post provides a link to a 111 page Science and Public Policy Institute Original Paper you can access here:
...
I am not a gambler myself and I do have insurance. I presume that is what you are talking about. However, first,the premium must be proportionate to the benefits and, second, one has to have an idea of the probabilites of the insured event occurring. In commercial life or health insurance actuaries calculate the rateswith consiideration oflife expectancie, illness rates and care costs. Hiow does one do this with global warming?
I support raising auto mileage but only up to a point. When this is done by making autos flimsy the reduction in carbon emissions is accomplished at the expense of safety. I used to park in tight spaces by jockying my car back and forth till I connected with the adjacent auto's bumper. No more! If you do that now you incur a $2500 repair bill. Even if you don't do it, someone else will and you incur the bill anyway. Even worse, now the flimsybumpers have infrared sensors or cameras adding to the repair expense. If one gets into an accident; forget it.
So not only are cars more expensive to begin withbut the insurance rates are correspondingly higher both because of higher repair costs and the higher frequency of incidents: not only of body damage but also because of the increasing liklihood of injury. And for what? No one can say with any degree of certainty. We don't even agree that there is a problem that needs to be solved.
And who knows how much this "insurance" will retard climatechange? It looks like non-thinking panic is driving the agenda rather than knowledgable rational calculation of the cost/benefit ratio.
>>If that is true, then that has to apply to pretty much everything scientists say. AGW is about as thoroughly research and validated as any scientific idea.
This is simply not true. THE WS Journal editorial above listed Nobel laureate climatologistsand other top scientists who challenge the politically-correct "wisdom," and there has been proof of extensive scientific malfeasance in this field.
Perrie makes good points andI regret your joining Macarthur in character assassination instead of factual rebuttal.
You are again blanketing industry with conndemnation whille giving scientific and political charlatans a free pass.
>>As I said, scientists are human... they do things they shouldn't do just like all the rest of us.
Double standard! You do not include industry with "the rest of us." Scientists are excused from chicanery but industry cannot earn its bread without condemnation.
>>I am a Christian and also believe that we were commanded to take care of the Garden. I would like to have my statements and thoughts judged of their own accord, not my religious belief.
I am a Jew who considers my religious beliefs consistent with my ethical, economic, charitable, scientific and social values.
WRTthe garden please note that God gave Adam two missions. One was to care for it as you say; "to till it and tend it." (Gen. 2:15) But He also commanded Adam to "fill the earth and master it; and rule the fish of the sea, the birds of the sky, and all the living things that creep on earth." (Gen. 1:28)
The history of humanity is a struggle between the two aspects ofAdam's mission.
The cited verses command man to use nature for his benefit and, before we can do this, we have to understand nature. Therefore scientists are encouraged to discover nature's principles and use them to exploit the earth's resources; both living and non-living.
The counterpoint to Gen. 1:26 is Gen. 2:15. Tending means using for one's benefit; but with introspection and preservation rather than exploitation.This apparent discrepancy, or dialectic, was resolved in a brilliant work by Rabbi Joseph Soloveitchik zt'l. In "The Lonely Man of Faith (Doubleday, 1992 -- originally written in 1965)."
"[The contemporary man of faith] looks upon himself as a stranger in modern society which is technically minded, self-centered, and self-loving almost in a sickly narcissistic fashion, scoring honor upon honor, piling up victory upon victory, reaching for the distant galaxies, and seeing in the here-and-now sensible world the only manifestation of being. What can a man of faith like myself, living by a doctrine that has no technical potential, by a law that cannot be tested in the laboratory, steadfast in his loyalty to an eschatological vision whose fulfillment cannot be predicted with any degree of probability, let alone certainty, even by the most advanced mathematical calculations -- what can such a man say to a functional, utilitarian society that is saeculum-oriented and whose practical reasons of the mind have long ago supplanted the sensitive reasons of the heart?...
The Adam who follows Gen. 1:26 is aggressive, bold and victory-minded. His motto is success, triumph over the cosmic forces.... The [other] Adam who tends the garden is also intrigued by the cosmos. Intellectual curiosity drives [both Adams] to confront the mysterium magnum of Being. However, while the cosmos provokes Adam the first to seek power and control, making him ask the functional how question, Adam the second responds to the call of the cosmos by engaging in a different kind of cognitive gesture. ... His inquiry is of a metaphysical nature and is a threefold one. He wants to know: Why is it? What is it? Who is it? (1) He wonders: Why did the world in its totality come into existence? ... (2) He asks, What is the purpose of all this? ... (3) [He] keeps on wondering: Who is He who trails me steadily, uninvited and unwanted like an everlasting shadow, and vanishes into the recesses of transcendence the very instant I turn to confront...? ... whose life-giving and life warming breath [I] feel constantly and who at the same time remains remote and distant from all?
While Adam the first is dynamic and creative, transforming sensory data into thought constructs, Adam the second is receptive and beholds the world in its original dimensions. He looks for the image of God in the mathematical formula or the natural relational law but in every beam of light, in every bud and blossom, in the morning breeze and the stillness of a starlit evening. In a word, Adam the second explores not the scientific abstract universe but the irresistibly fascinating qualitative world where he establishes an intimate relationship with God...
The Biblical dialectic is resolved by Rabbi Soloveitchiks conclusion that the two Adams are not two different people ... but one person who is involved in self-confrontation ... the creative, majestic Adam the first, and the submissive, humble Adam the second... God created two Adams and sanctioned both. Rejection of either aspect of humanity would be tantamount to disapproval of the divine scheme of creation that was approved by God as being very good. As a matter of fact, people of faith accepted Adam the first a long time ago. ... Since the dialectical role has been assigned to man by God, it is God who wants the man of faith to oscillate between the faith community and the [scientific community] ...
When Zechariah proclaimed The Lord shall be King over all the earth; on that day The Lord shall be One and His Name One, he referred not to the unity of God, which is absolute and perfect even now, but to the future unity of creation, which is currently torn asunder by inner contradictions. On that distant day the dialectical process will come to a close and man of faith as well as [scientific] man will achieve full redemption in a united world.
How did you arrive at that conclusion??? I made no such distinction!!! I assert that ALL humans are subject to human weaknesses. Please stop putting words in my mouth.
I excuse no one from chicanery!!! AGAIN!!!! Please stop putting words in my mouth!!!
I condemn those who do things for personal gain with abusive or dishonest tactics... whether they be scientist or industrialist. It is true ... I believe any such examples of scientist chicanery are rather considerably less egregious than industry chicanery. That makes good common sense since the "bread" at steak for the industrialists is much greater than it is for the scientists.
That was certainly a very poorly conceived idea!!!!!
I find that particular so-called commandment to be one of the most troubling elements of Judeo-Christian doctrine. I believe it is nothing less than mankind giving itself license to plunder. I find the notion that we should "rule" the other creatures of the planet disgustingly self-serving. We humans have no more right to anything on this planet than any other creature... and we have taken FAR more than our fair share... at the expense of many species which we are personally responsible for driving into extinction.
Somethingstranscendthe cost/benefit ratio. If you had cancer, you would get the treatment you needed. My mother in laws chemo costs $2000 a month. She is 85. Does she meet the cost/benefit ratio?
Theassumptionthat we have a non thinking panic driving an agenda isn't what is happening here. And what possible purpose would this agenda have? Who does it serve? If anything the scientist who say that there is no AGW could be the ones with an agenda, since cutting carbon emmisons cost money. The reality is we have two sets of scientist who are making their best possible guess at the climate changes we see going on around the earth; one says they are man made and the other says they are cyclical. But no matter what, these extreme weather trends are worrisome. To ignore them, would be irresponsible.
Got to agree with you on that one Mal.
There's a dilemma, no question.
Several years ago it was interesting to see the concern about global warming when politicians were feeling the heat over gasoline prices but swearing (on Fox) that the President (then Bush), had no control over those prices; but where the hell were they before and since -- ESPECIALLY REPUBLICANS, who refuse to stop oil subsidies while blaming Obama for the price of gasoline?
When oil companies like Exxon Mobil paid sell-out scientists and media shills to write phony studies that debunked Global Climate Change, and, legal efforts to get the details of the Cheney-Energy company (collusion) meetings went nowhere, where were the righteously indignant right-wingers?
I offer a proposal that will partially address our energy dilemmas and at the same time, give relief to consumers; and anyone who takes issue ... should they do so without offering anything but criticism ... why bother?
Forget reducing the price of gasoline by cutting or lowering the tax-per-gallon. Instead, give tax credits to Americans based on their driving habits. A basic outline is as follows:
As of a designated starting date, say January 1, 2016, on a state-by-state basis, compile lists of drivers and their motor vehicles on the basis of vehicle fuel efficiency; in the age of computer data bases, this is logistically no problem. Registered vehicle owners would be listed with their vehicles and tax credits would be issued based on a sliding scale, i.e.
* NO VEHICLE and/or PUBLIC TRANSIT USER TAX PAYER "JOE SMITH" = LARGEST TAX CREDIT
* 25-35MILES/GALLON Vehicle Owner = NEXT BIGGEST and so on.
* HUMMER, etc. OWNERS BY CHOICE get NO tax credits and pay a per/gallon premium at the pump; the wealthy are not hurt by gasoline prices and they also enjoy the Bush Tax cuts! Insult to injury to America's working poor and middle class!
* Pass legislation that takes a portion of oil company profits on each gallon of gasoline and use it to subsidize the tax credits. Monitor closely that the oil companies/speculators do not manipulate prices to recoup the tax.
I know it's not a perfect plan, but it's a start with rhyme and reason. It would help Americans who need it now and, it would send a message to "Organized Wealth" which is the ugly marriage-of-convenience of money, government and the willingly-pandered-to special interests that sell their souls at the expense of the rest of us thus forestalling things like reduced oil dependency.
Further - if automobile manufacturers can produce one or two vehicle models that get thirty-five or forty miles per gallon, they can produce others. Therefor ...
* Legislate higher efficiency standards, give auto manufacturers tax credits based on a formula incorporating vehicle miles per gallon rating and the number manufactured in a designated time period.
* Businesses in urban areas should consider staggering start times to mitigate traffic congestion and wasted gasoline.
* Traffic tickets issued for speeding should include an additional penalty as fuel is consumed more quickly at higher speeds.
I like the idea AMac... progressive expense based on degree of waist/efficiency... I do see one problem though... Many of the most fuel efficient vehicles have a premium price... also poorer people tend to buy used cars which tend to be less efficient... so the poor are likely to be penalized just because they are too poor to afford more efficient vehicles. Is there some part of your plan that accounts for this???
In areas of greatest concentration/population, the working poor typically take public transportation; an arrangement might be made whereby those individuals could purchase monthly transpasses that would subsequently serve as receipts for tax purposes. The tax credits for those receipts could be progressive ... more receipted expenses, more tax credits per tax year filing.
Also ... four day work weeks, more jobs in cyberspace (home offices) ...
There's no perfect solution ... but neither denial nor bitch-and-moan are better than what I propose.
I can't argue with that!
I like the plan too.
One issue I see though are the working poor that have to use large vehicles in their everyday labors. Landscapers, roofers, the person who fixes the dishwasher, crop-pickers, pool cleaners...all these people need larger vehicles for their livelihood; and, many of them do not make much money at all.
I believe they are able to deduct related expenses and depreciation of equipment -- verifiable business expenses could receive upgraded credits; as I said, my idea is not perfect, but it's closer to perfection than denial and bitchin' and moanin'.
I like that I think better than deductions, more money stays in our pockets that way.
For our family fuel is an expense that is budgeted like our other expenses; it has to be as it is so expensive. Much of our own bitchin' and moanin' was alleviated when we decided to buy more fuel efficient vehicles, and drive less.
[Mal bows down to iarnuocon...]
Mal is very grateful for Iar's truly excellent explanation!
Mal,
In actuality the word "master" or "lord" has a two way meaning. To lord over something didn't mean only to rule it, it also meant to be responsible and maintain it...this is integral to understanding that ruling was a responsibility. Yes we are meant to prosper, but it's the WHOLE garden that is meant to prosper, and humans are supposed to be the ones responsible for doing that.
I like your interpretation a lot Larry!!! Sadly, I think there are many people who interpret that passage differently.
The passage as quoted by Len does actually say "...rule the fish of the sea, the birds of the sky, and all the living things that creep on earth." Still, I would not find it so problematic if more people looked at it as a responsibility to care for the planet and all its creatures.
I would love to get into the root meanings of the words, the context and theology; this article isn't for that though. :~) What is relevant however is an alternative understanding, to the basic Biblical Creation Event. Say the entire scenario is symbolic of our species movement from hunter-gatherer to farmingsocieties. It does throw a different spin on things sociologically/anthropologically; and, gives probablecause to understanding the wisdom that can be gleaned from ancient texts. Genesis as an archetypicalrenditionof human evolution...I like that!
What goes around comes around.
Perhaps you missed the cause that precipitated the effect, namely ...
Guess who authored that gem.
Actually, it would be libellous ... except the actual wording would not hold up as such in any adverse action, because there is more factual implication supporting my assertion, that based on the history of his comments, than there is anything in my assertion that is demonstrably false.
Hey ... if you're going to be his counsel, you ought to know the actual charge you're prosecuting.
Big night for you ... your horizons just keep on broadening.
I am happy to be redistributing the knowledge.
Night for now counselor.
[[So it isn't a matter of whether or not we can "prove" AGW. Science never "proves" anything. It's a matter of whether or not the available data disconfirms the theory. And it doesn't.]]
It depends on how one examines the data . The "theory" claims that warming should be continuing or even accelerating . But global warming has plateaued . Muller's colleague has confirmed as much with the BEST data .
Provided he actually speaks knowledge.
Otherwise, he can go sit the fuck down.
[Mal gasps for air...]
Help!!! Mal is laughing too hard...
Sorry if I misinterpreted you but I based my view on the number of words and intensity you used in attacking industry vs. the exculpatory nature of scientific chicanery.
>>Profiteers resist the prospect of profit limitations, and so fund those dubiously crafted public relations efforts. The rest of us resist limitations to the comfortable lifestyle we enjoy, and so gobble up the propaganda the profiteers feed us.
>>As I said, scientists are human... they do things they shouldn't do just like all the rest of us.
I will leave it to others to decide how evenhanded you have been but I welcome your recognition that all groups fail some of the time.
>>Claiming, "but some people disagree" isn't a refutation of the science. Some people ALWAYS disagree. There are idiots who think evolution is "politically correct", and not demonstrable. And I'm sure you could find an editorial somewhere that agreed with them.
Your equating Nobel laureate opponents of the politically correct AGW movement with "creationists" is a dead giveaway of your irrational argument.
Len>>there has been proof of extensive scientific malfeasance in this field.
>>No, there hasn't. There has been extensive bullshitting by cranks who pretend that there is proof of extensive scientific malfeasance, but those are cranks who spend a lot of time bullshitting. For example, of the many investigations of the so-called "Climategate" nonsense, none found any "scientific malfeasance".
Yes there convincingly has and, to deny it, puts YOU in the company of the "creationist idiots." For example see the following excerpts:
Climategate: the final nail in the coffin of 'Anthropogenic Global Warming'?
"The conspiracy behind the Anthropogenic Global Warming myth (aka AGW; aka ManBearPig) has been suddenly, brutally and quite deliciously exposed after a hacker broke into the computers at the University of East Anglia's Climate Research Unit (aka CRU) and released 61 megabytes of confidential files onto the internet. (Hat tip: Watts Up With That )
When you read some of those files including 1079 emails and 72 documents you realise just why the boffins at CRU might have preferred to keep them confidential. As Andrew Bolt puts it, this scandal could well be "the greatest in modern science". These alleged emails supposedly exchanged by some of the most prominent scientists pushing AGW theory suggest:
One of the alleged emails has a gentle gloat over the death in 2004 of John L Daly (one of the first climate change sceptics, founder of the Still Waiting For Greenhouse site), commenting:
But perhaps the most damaging revelations the scientific equivalent of the Telegraph's MPs' expenses scandal are those concerning the way Warmist scientists may variously have manipulated or suppressed evidence in order to support their cause.
More at:
You feel that way because you are focusing on just one part of the whole and ignorind the other part: "to till it and tend it."
Life and progress ofteninvolves a dialectic between competing ideas. As Hegel put it, there is thesis and antithesis that is resolved by synthesis. That is what the incisive exegesis I provided does and I regret that you and Perrie don't get it.
As an engineer you should be the first to recognize that our current technological civilization, our comfortable lives,are products of mastering the earth. Unless you are a vegetarian, have never had a pet or ridden a horse,you have no standing to protest our ruling of the other creatures.
Without the extinction of dinasours we likiely would not be here. Many species became extinct without human intervention. I am as opposed to poaching and killing elephants for their ivory as you are. Again, we need to curb the abuses while not throwing out the baby with the bathwater.
Right on, Larry!
I am not a vegetarian... Nearly every life form must consume other living things to live. My objection it to cruel exploitation of animals.
I have had many pets, and I dare say they have all been very glad to have me as a member of their pack. If you want to know how I look after my pets, you may want to read this... Sarge, The Mayor of Maxwelton Beach
That is little comfort when I consider the species that have gone extinct because of selfish human actions.
Len,
I have been avegetarianon and off for a while now, since I don't enjoy knowing that I took an animals life. Actually, my sister feels even stronger about this than even I do. And I have to agree with Mal when he says:
We are fishing our waters to near extinction. There are areas that the plankton is dying. You might think that stories like "Soylant Green" are improbable, but I actually think we are heading in that direction. BTW... even the human race can go extinct, and I truly doubt that nature would care. It might even be relieved.
There will come soft rains and the smell of the ground,
And swallows circling with their shimmering sound;
And frogs in the pools singing at night,
And wild plum trees in tremulous white;
Robins will wear their feathery fire,
Whistling their whims on a low fence-wire;
And not one will know of the war, not one
Will care at last when it is done.
Not one would mind, neither bird nor tree,
If mankind perished utterly;
And Spring herself, when she woke at dawn
Would scarcely know that we were gone.
Absolutely perfect, Perrie!
I agree about cruel exploitation and I am not complacent when it comes to factory farms with calves in tight cages, chickens, animals and fish fed massive antibiotics, and Perrie's good point about overfishing. Most of the fish Ieat are now farm bred and there have been problems here too.
When you have a pet you are its master no matter how kindly you treat it.
I am not foolish enough to say there are no problems. But they are managable. Don't make yourself a peaceful version of the unibomber who was so bitter aboutmodernization and industry that he began killing people and writing long tracts about the "evil nation."
Len,
That is a huge jump in anything that I or Mal is saying and quite insulting, so please don't try to compare us to some lunatic that lived in a cabin and killed innocent people. I am using a computer, using electricity, own a car. Mal is a computer programmer. But if we can make those things work better and reduce nasty by products, then we should do that as responsibletenantsof this planet.
Well ... maybe not perfect . Poets are not expected to be able to project into the future . That is a job for scientists and engineers .
Here is what I project . If mankind were to disappear , housecats would start to breed a lot more because no people would be there to spay/neuter them . They would also be much more predatory because they would have no people to feed them . The result would be a lot more of those "swallows , frogs and robins" would die in the clutches of those cats .
I read some of those long tracts and Mal's seed brought them to mind.
I did say "a peaceful version" didn't I.
Peaceful or not Len, to compare either of us to a mad man is an insult.
IMO [who the hell asked me ?!] it is a little mad to not see the implications of your proposal . Sacrificing people for some utopian ideal about how the world is "supposed to be" is nuts .
Again, another leap in what I am saying. No where do I think that we should be sacrificing people. What I am saying is that people are not taking care of the planet they live on. Utopia? Never possible. Humans are way to flawed.
Comment removed for CoC violation
Our lives depend on whether safety standards at a nuclear power plant are properly maintained; on how much pesticide is allowed to get into our food or how much pollution into our air; on how skillful (or incompetent) our doctor is; whether we lose or get a job may depend on decisions made by government economists or corporation executives; and so forth. Most individualsare not in a position to secure themselves against these threats to more [than] a very limited extent. The individual's search for security is therefore frustrated, which leads to a sense of powerlessness.
[W]e can't claim that today'sacquisition-oriented culture is exclusively a creation of the advertising and marketing industry. But it is clear that the advertising and marketing industry has had an important part in creating that culture. The big corporations that spend millions on advertising wouldn't be spending that kind of money without solid proof that they were getting it back in increased sales. One member of FC met a sales manager a couple of years ago who was frank enough to
tell him, "Our job is to make people buy things they don't want and don't need." He then described how an untrained novice could present people with the facts about a product, and make no sales at all, while a trained and experienced professional salesman would make lots of sales to the same people. This shows that people are manipulated into buying things they don't really want.
13. (Paragraph 66) Conservatives' efforts to decrease the amount of government regulation are of little benefit to the average man. For one thing, only a fraction of the regulations can be eliminated because most regulations are necessary. For another thing, most of the deregulation affects business rather than the average individual, so
that its main effect is to take power from the government and give it to private corporations. What this means for the average man is that government interference in his life is replaced by interference from big corporations, which may be permitted, for example, to dump more chemicals that get into his water supply and give him cancer. The
conservatives are just taking the average man for a sucker, exploiting his resentment of Big Government to promote the power of Big Business.
Should we invite Ted to post his thoughts here?
Actually, Len, Madmen in prison for murdering people are not allowed on the site... not even so you can make cute little jabs that are totally uncalled for. This is your last warning about comments like that.
You are taking the comments in the mostsuperficialway. The earth, just like the body, is in balance. In the body, when everything is working well, it is callhomeostasis, which simply put, means that the body is in balance and all parts are working the way that they should. On the earth, each element be it animal or plant or the gasses we breath, have a balance. If you ruin the balance you throw off the earth'shomeostasis. It's not that the animals are created equal to humans on a balance sheet, but that they are part of a necessary working system that keeps the earth in balance.
I am not anything like the unibomber... not even a "peaceful version of the unibomber."
Please refrain from making any such backhanded vilifying comparisons!
I said this in another article...
HA HA HA!!! Isn't that funny... How clever... *sarc*
I gotta tell ya Len, you are making it very difficult for me to treat you respectfully!!!
As if that would help! If everyone like me "offed themselves" there would be nothing but humans with a self-serving sense of entitlement left... the overwhelming majority.
If I had any good ideas I would gladly offer them... Just because I see a problem and have no solution for it does not mean there is no problem, or that it is inappropriate to call attention to the problem.
Robert,
Obviously, the aim would be zero population growth.Ironically, that is where most western nations are or even less than that. Trying to get the rest of the world to go along with that, would be a whole lot harder.
Not so! Raising the standards for Estimated Miles Per Gallon in the manufacturing of automobiles, wind and solar energy development, car pooling, improvements in mass/public transportation ... but a few of the sabotaged efforts, efforts trash-talked, initiatives killed by shill-legislator-pimps for the oil companies.
Spot on Mac.
Which is true.
So that is a reason not to strive for greater efficiency and renewable energy sources???
How unsafe will you settle for to get your mileage up to 50?
No, Mike ... you said no one tried anything but taxing carbon; I corrected that. The right-wing pimps sabotaged and lied about the efforts. And your demagoguery doesn't change any of it.
The haters fuck the whole country ...
"Let them eat cake" ends poorly.
They companies that manufacture and sell high efficiency vehicles to other countries could sell them here as well if the political whores didn't get in the way.
I have said that we need fewer people or we need to do less stuff or both... Those are VERY general ideas and do not propose any sort of real solution. I do agree with very modest efforts to control population through education and making birth control widely available... I also agree with such things as seeking greater energy efficiency and renewable fuels... But I believe those sorts of things will only forestall disaster. This is not an effort to "feel better" on my part (although I am no less susceptible to the temptation to feel good than anyone else). I have said on many occasions that I feel disaster is inevitable, not only for humans but for many other creates who will also suffer the perils of a rapidly changing planetary ecosystem. I have drawn that conclusion from my observations of human nature.
No more effective at providing a real solution to the big overarching problem than another... true... I completely agree. Neither "offing myself" or shouting to the hilltops about the dangers of AGW will make any difference in the long run... because the vast majority of people... not even the most ardent proponents of green technology and prudent use of our resources see the problem as I see it... nobody has a solution that they would consent to implement, and even if they were willing... they know they would never convince enough people to remedy the problem.
I would never support someone who advocated war, famine, and disease... but I don't need to... sadly, that will come along in due time.
Oh come on Jedi... Why would so many scientists, for whom credibility in their assertions is the foundation of their careers, choose to "lie"?????? If you want to say they are suffering from mass error... well that might have a grain of credibility... but asserting that it is a lie just holds no water.
Come on man... you are showing that you are either grotesquely ignorant or completely blinded by your bias... I'll give you the benefit of the doubt and say I think it is probably the latter...
I gotta run, but I will try to get back to answer the rest of this diatribe... or maybe I will just leave this stupid rock down here at the bottom of this hill...
So you've never seen wind farms, solar panels, hybrid cars ... never heard/read about mandated higher mileage standards ... and those who voted to keep the standards lower?
What is it that "everybody knows" then?
[[Again, another leap in what I am saying. No where do I think that we should be sacrificing people. ]]
What you may not understand is that certain policies which negatively affect the economy can easily result in sacrificing peoples livelyhoods if not their actual lives ...
That isn't what we are discussing, Rich. This was the comment made by Len:
And no where did I ever mention utopia or anything close.
"Do you believe we all are tempted to mold our beliefs to suit our desires???"
Yes. Humans are selfish.
That all actually seems quite rational and well-thought out. However, I drive a 40 mpg Fiesta. My husband has a 15 mpg F-150. How would that work considering we only use my husband's truck in emergencies or for travel with our pull behind travel trailer?
And fyi Mal... My 2012 Fiesta (after A-plan) was $17,500 and I have the top model 5-door. I could have gotten a $10,000 sedan. Not all fuel efficient vehicles are high dollar. $10,000 @ 4.9 APR was only $190/month over a 60 month term. Insurance on that vehicle was only $10/month than my 2002 Saturn Vue.
I think this way too. It's not ONLY one or the other. It's a combination of the two.
It's a natural cycle/process that we as humans are speeding up.
And to err is human.
Interpretation is everything and nothing at the same time.
Have I told you lately that I you?
Natural cycles are just that ... but they can be exacerbated by human activity! The point is, any/all man-generated phenomena that are both global in scope and excessive in volume as compared to what occurs naturally, both logically and in reality have potential consequences.
Lightning for example appears to be a natural phenomenon that periodically clears dense forests so that light can reach the forest floor and enable the growth of younger trees thus perpetuating that forest.
An inordinate number of forest fires due to droughts ... a number that greatly exceeds what has occurred in the ancient and more recent past, accompanied by excessive rain and flooding globally is a signal. Drought causes ground water to evaporate and accumulate in excessive quantities in the atmosphere; this moisture eventually condenses and produces huge precipitation events that cause flooding while the areas left arid burn at some point.
Record lake-effect snows in recent years happen because large lakes that once froze solid in winter, don't, because of warmer winters. When air cold enough to freeze surface water blows over one of these lakes, it picks up the surface water, turns it to snow and produces huge accumulations in populated (et al) areas in proximity to the lakes.
Nature by itself does what it does; humans that build communities and design those communities in deference to nature will still be at its mercy from time-to-time. But humanity that exploits and pollutes nature, if it does so to excess and blindly, will in time be kicked in the ass by the power of nature combined with the manifestations created by his own greed and stupidity.
It is true like that old tv commercial warned -- "it's not nice to fool Mother Nature."
It is also potentially disastrous to think we can.
You guys are making my brain hurt with all this making sense business.
When Michigan passed the no-helmet law, my immediate thought was, "Thin the herd... thin the herd."
This statement made meguffaw. Thank you for that chuckle. Would it be ok to reuse this at some point?
Yup. I noticed that our public transit (which is virtually nil in Michigan BTW) began using hybridbio-diesel/electric buses. Taxi companies have hybrid cars now in some cities too. I sure wish the taxi companies would use say... A Chevy Volt or a Focus electric for their fleet, but sadly... They are using Toyota Prius hybrid/electric.
Every single one of these cars gets at least 40 mpg. Most of these on this list are under $20,000 and have 5 star crash rating. Every day, these car makers are coming up with better ways to save fuel. We DO NOT have to get our vehicles from overseas to do so.
[[They companies that manufacture and sell high efficiency vehicles to other countries could sell them here as well if the political whores didn't get in the way.]]
You certainly have a colorful description of events ... and so much moralizing . But most of the blame needs to placed on the US consumer . He wants big bad muscle cars . Even the average soccer mom wants a large gas hog of an SUV .
We had virtually no winter last year. Including lake-effect snow. I think we are doomed to have a hell of a snowy winter this year. In the 80's we used to get FEET of snow every week in the winter months. The past decade or so, not so much. But in the 1800's in Michigan, there were recorded decades of mass snow-fall and then not much for the next decade. We do however, need a ton of snow just torejuvenate places like Tahquamenon Falls. It was SO dry this year. There were places that just 5 years ago, you could take a boat across, where you could not this year.
There is a comedian that said once, "You'll never convince a Michigander of global warming." I find it comical, but I have watched our state's climate change drastically over the past 20 years.
That's strange . I replied to this comment but my reply is no longer there ...
That's been a problem for me at times also Rich. What I've been doing is copying my comment before hitting "Add Reply," then if it disappears, I refresh the page, then paste in the comment and try again. I think it's a Ning issue that will hopefully be resolved.
It's a good thing neither of us is paranoid ! The trick in this case is , how long to save the comments .
When I 1st entered the comment it showed up just fine so I wrote over the saved comment . But it seems I will need to be more retentive . No anal retentive jokes please ...
First and foremost, scientists are observers. Yes, they come up with different experiments and ideas, but they still have to try them out and make observations. A degree does not wipe out bias.
Of course we are, we wouldn't be very human if we weren't. On NV I was told several times I should change my political views because of my situation. It is very tempting,
To me, public relations is nothing more than a propaganda machine. Of course it is meant to build up profits, whether in monetary or human capital.
I remember my grandfather stating that he believed the farming techniques of his time had changed the weather patterns in his part of the world (eastern New Mexico). This was over 50 years ago. Turns out, he may have been correct in his observations. Not bad for a man who had an 8th grade education.