Your right to resell your own stuff is in peril
Interesting issue and one which could affect each and everyone of us, and not in a positive way!
CHICAGO (MarketWatch) Tucked into the U.S. Supreme Courts agenda this fall is a little-known case that could upend your ability to resell everything from your grandmothers antique furniture to your iPhone 4.
At issue in Kirtsaeng v. John Wiley & Sons is the first-sale doctrine in copyright law, which allows you to buy and then sell things like electronics, books, artwork and furniture, as well as CDs and DVDs, without getting permission from the copyright holder of those products
The appellate court ruled that such permission was needed. Will SCOTUS uphold that ruling? If so, imagine how it might affect each and everyone of us.

This is stupid!!!
Can you imagine the paperwork involved it they actually tried to enforce it? The requirement for such permission might be put in as a theory but, as a practical matter, probably not (impossible to enforce).
Well, not as tough as you think. The "enforcement" would be left up to the companies, most likely, as they do in trademarks.
And I assure you, the companies sue the living hell out of ANYONE who even comes close to utilizing a trade mark,even CLOSE. And they don't care who it is, or what wealth they have. Millions, or a dollar pizza joint.
If SCOTUS upholds this verdict expect that the companies will begin to enforce it like crazy, for at least the first few years. Once they tear the guts out of a few hundred families, others will follow the law.
Our world. Not very pretty, is it?
[[Thats being challenged now for products that are made abroad, and if the Supreme Court upholds an appellate court ruling, it would mean that the copyright holders of anything you own that has been made in China, Japan or Europe, for example, would have to give you permission to sell it.]]
There is no surer way to discourage future purchasers from buying than this law . Does the US actually need products from China, Japan or Europe or have we become completely dependent on them ?
OMG... I can't moderate on this. It's my hubby's company.
Oh, I know that, EI. But if there is a problem in the article, it would be a conflict of interest.
[[it would be a stretch to think that it would even be attempted to be used in this manner. It would cost producers far too much money for them to try and enforce it. ]]
I expect you're right about the costs but it could legally apply anyway .
This is not engineering and it's not finance . It's about the law which is quite an odd field .
This has been a constant tension as technology comes to grips with what many feel are antiquated copyright, patent, and trademark law.
Essentially, what these companies are saying is that you are not buying 100% of the title to the personal property. Really, all you are buying is the right to personal use of the property.
Think of DVD's, VCR's (for those of us old enough to remember them!) and the warning at the beginning of each movie. Same thing, though that law was passed due to the huge lobbying effort of Hollywood.
I also don't believe this relates ONLY to those things manufactured or purchased "abroad."
Songs, music, we see the same issues. Some artists say fine, you buy, you can copy it, give it away, whatever. Others say NOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO, that's mine and you only bought the right to listen to it, not provide it to others.
Same with photos, eh? You "purchase" a photo, but then can't provide it to others, or sell it to others. So you really haven't "purchased" the photo, you have purchased the right to view the photo.
I don't think this applies only to goods purchased abroad.
Sorry, but I disagree. This is about a person that purchased books in one area of the world, bought them supposedly lock, stock, and barrel, and then resold them at a profit. So what?
Tell me, you purchase a piece of vinyl with music on it. It becomes a collector's item, much more valuable than when you originally purchased it. The statute of limitations is still in effect, this would prevent you from re-selling that product.
And you're also wrong about the cost of enforcement, dead wrong. the cost of enforcement is negligible. Take trademarks, they HAVE to be protected zealously or they are lost. If a company becomes aware, or SHOULD have become aware of the use of the same mark, or even a similar mark, they HAVE to protect it, they HAVE to sue!
And so they make it as public as possible, they slam the other side, and then all they have to do after that is send cease and desist letters.
The cost is absolutely, given the issue and money at stake, negligible. Any assertion otherwise is just incorrect.
Example, I won't give names, but I represented a large company that had trademark X. National company, 200 million plus in sales. It learned, no kidding now, of a street vendor in South Atlanta that was using a barely "similar" mark, and I mean not even really close, but kind of close. The guy had a little ramshackle booth two blocks from his home.
They sued him in Federal Court (original jurisdiction). They won almost immediately, a permanent restraining order was issued, costs were taxed (including attorney fees) against the guy that had the little booth. He couldn't pay them of course, so he filed bankruptcy. The company then had their press team out and the story was all over Atlanta.
Haven't had a case since then.
So, no, the cost of enforcement is negligible.
Which side?
Of course it has to do with the "resale" of personal items! Sheesh. You think once SCOTUS rules on this it will be limited? Of course not!
Goodness, spin out the possibilities a bit! That is where this is going.
Haven't read the entire opinion, but does seem to have implications for the fact that if it is produced in a foreign country then the first sale doctrine does not apply.
Hmmm, let's read further.
As far as I am aware, real property is NOT SUBJECT TO COPYRIGHT LAWS that are applied to INTELLECTUAL PROPERTY. The technology of an iPhone is copyright protected, the sale or gifting of my iPhone is not. So I fail to see what this case has to do with copyrights.
And technically, any/all sales and or transfer of real property is subject to taxation ... particularly where a profit is realized.
Mike, I won't disagree that taxation is confiscatory and thus an "attack" of sorts, but are you willing to give up your rights otherwise to ownership of your personal property -- which is not what this case entails.
Ironically, you must first legally own that which is to be taxed ... a technicality perhaps but a reality nonetheless. Stealing (pirating) one of my images (books authored by me, paintings painted by me, etc.) is theft of my property, representing it and marketing it as your own is copyright infringement ... totally separate issues from taxing the sales of those images and or the sale or transfer of same.
That aside, how the fuck does any taxing authority calculate the tax due on the sale of a box of paper clips at a yard sale? If I bought it new for a dollar and sold it for fifty cents, can I take a loss?
Ah, the article is spot on. The ISSUE Iar is not how much the guy made, a red herring that only an apologist would use, but whether or not the first sale doctrine applies to goods manufactured overseas.
Fact is that the split in the circuits is why SCOTUS is taking the case.
And this is the 2nd circuit, a well considered circuit. The "sometimes" is the Ninth Circuit, the most overturned circuit.
Seems to me that given the discussions, it should be decided on an all or nothing at all situation. AFter all, if the goods are made in the USA the first sale doctrine protects the subsequent sale no matter what, for sale in a business or otherwise!
As usual, however, your rhetoric has no real function to it except for you would like to "think" something.
You could purchase ten million cd's and sell them without any "intention" of ever retaining ownership as long as they were made in the USA.
Your distinction is without a difference. I have no idea how the asshats on SCOTUS will decide this case, but clearly if the first sale doctrine protects ALL sales, no matter how large or how small, on goods manufactured in the USA, to say it does not offer the same protection for goods manufactured overseas would be bizarre.
You would have to be checking the serial numbers on your iphones to determine if you could resell it!
Note, I don't have time to read the Costco case, but my understanding of it was that a foreign company imported watches which were made in the USA, then resold them in the USA because the company (OMega) was selling them in the USA for 30% or so more than they were charging in foreign companies. It was the NINTH circuit that held that all goods made in the USA are subject to the first sale doctrine.
From your site.
Yet, in the article about the Wiley case the same site asserts:
Facially contradictory, but may be correct if they are just not making as in depth a description in one article as in another. Of course, would be just like the Ninth Circuit to make such a dumb ass decision when the issue is whether or not the first sale doctrine applies and that is grounded in where manufacture took place.
comment removed for CoC violation (AM)
Comment deleted ... personal attack ...
The related comment has also been deleted.
I have already directed that the personal attack against you be removed ... or that I'll remove it.
Please, you remove yours as well.
Will do. You look good in purple, by the way.
Deleted, but, dear Sir, not forgotten.
But it was such a good attack A.M! I think you should, at least, copy it and send it to me so I can use it again if needed, especially the catheter part, I especially liked that!
I deleted the first one as well.
And, for appropriate definition, my post was not a "personal attack." It was:
"A well defined, deserved, and articulate personal attack against a poster who had, without reason or credibility, initiated a personal attack."
I have removed both comments ... that I believe was the proper and even-handed thing to do.
Got it. You are quick, I must admit.
I have to weigh in on this, since I really don't think you guys understand how John Wiley sets up production anddistribution, which is Matt's job.
First of all, they are one of the largest suppliers of text books. They publish them around the world, each at a different price point, due to production costs in that region. The company is set up that they will produce the certain books at one price point for that region and also import those books and sell them at different price points in other regions.
What has been going on, is that people are getting loads of these books in cheaper regions for the purpose of resale in other regions, in mass, and cutting into Wiley's market. This isn't about a guy who wants to sell a CD at a garage sale, or even and ex-employee wanting to sell 30 copies of a book he has, but we are talking about millions of books world wide, and especially effecting the American market place, where the books cost much more.
That is why it's about the "gray market".
Matt, now has to analyze the amounts of books being asked for release from Asian markets and see how well they have matched in the past, since this is where it isoccurringthe most. If there is a sudden increase in the need for a bio-chem book, they are now assuming that it is meant to be shipped back to the US and by pass Wiley for American sales. That is copyrightinfringement.
I would respond, but A.M. would delete my post.
Let me just say that you should read some more. Try:
That case is directly on point with your analogy.
Perrie, the issue is clearly that the books made by Wiley in Thailand and meant for distribution there were cheap as hell.
So, the dude got his buddies to send him all of the books they could lay there hands on and he sold them on e-bay, and possibly otherwise.
The issue is quite simple, does the first sale doctrine apply to goods manufactured outside the USA?
One could get pissed at Wiley for selling the books in Thailand for X dollars and in the USA for 3X, but I understand that though the text is identical, the actual quality of the book is very, very different.
Note, we don't KNOW yet if this is copyright infringement, do we?
Here's a pretty good layman's explanation:
Note the issue in Quality King, manufactured here, First Sale Doctrine applies.
What is now at issue is the clear issue (Omega might have answered it but for the recusal) is whether or not goods manufactured OUTSIDE of the USA are subject to the first sale doctrine.
Just consider the incentive for American companies to shift their manufacturing overseas if SCOTUS holds with the second circuit! WOW
you don't know of what you are talking, comment removed for CoC violation (AM) and you also can't fricking READ.
Can you see the word "copyright" there?
Now go away.
Terry,
This goes to intent. If your talking about a college kid who happens to have a few books to sell, on ebay, no biggie. If you are talking about a company buying thousands of books to be sold on ebay in the US at a deep discount, then not OK. It's a gray market.
And the books are of a different quality. Most kids don't realize that until the spine breaks.
Oh, and Matt just corrected me, the books are being made in Singapore.
Iar,
Basically, yes.
In the event the SCOTUS hears this case, the phenomenon of copyright itself may end up on trial.
The distinction between personal and intellectual property, in my opinion, cannot be avoided.
If a product or idea is forged or counterfeited and then marketed by the forger or counterfeiter as his own, that's clear copyright infringement.
If an authorized car salesmen sells a used Toyota, does Toyota have a copyright issue?
Both name-calling and attacks on an individual's competence outside of the discussion itself, are violations of the CoC as they make things "personal."
Unless he specifically stated he is an attorney, and I don't think he did, you cannot bring that into the discussion. Correct me if I'm wrong, but it was you who stated that he may have mentioned it on NV. Even if he had stated it himself, based on a discrepancy in the argument between the two of you, you can neither assess his legal efficacy nor any other aspect of his work/life outside of this discussion.
Argue the points of the case and relate them to your position ... not to what you think are the skills of the messenger.
This applies to ALL MEMBERS IN ALL DISCUSSIONS.
That adds an unnecessary layer to the issue.
The right to sell or resell a product as it applies to copyright infringement is the issue. Assuming the original purchaser has legitimately procured the product(s), upon reselling them at a legitimate point-of-purchase, manufacturer copyright is not an issue.
If the salesman had bought Toyotas and replaced the engines with Hugo engines, etc. and sold them as Toyots, then subsequently buyers attempted to sue Toyota for fraud and related malfunction damages, Toyota could legitimately claim that the reseller misrepresented its product and thus had no culpability, as its engine design (its copyright, in essence) was not at fault, rather at fault would be the salesperson (and not even Hugo, whose engines placed in other manufacturers' vehicles, thus had no liability).
A product reseller as such, is bound by agreement with the copyright holder/manufacturer/etc. . But once the product is purchased from the reseller, IMO it becomes the personal property of that purchaser. As long as no fraud is involved in the subsequent sale of the product as an item of personal property, I fail to see where copyright conceivably applies.
But I'm still following the discussion ... so we'll see.
That is exactly the issue, Iar. What is fascinating, as I stated in a prior post which was point was raised in an article, is if the Second Circuit is upheld, will domestic manufacturers who may be marginal, seek to move their facilities to a different country so as to be able to deny purchasers the "first sale" exemption?
I can picture future purchases (if the second circuit is upheld) being in different formats, one where the purchaser not only purchases the foreign manufactured product for X, but may, in addition, purchase a license for a one time sale (or more) for X+1, or X+10, depending on the number of potential future sales.
Well, not if you live in the second circuit, that's for sure. Right now, one undertaking that action would be liable. If you live in the Ninth or the Third, depending on your "scheme" you might be able to get around it. Depends, however, on how SCOTUS actually rules and whether its holding is retroactive. A bizarre area in its own right!
Link here
That's true of so many everyday incidents in the USA. Take, for example, a friend goes to NYC where the electronics are cheap as hell and buys three Nikons, each for $300. The same Nikons in, for example, Charlotte (assuming no ability to buy as cheaply on the net) cost $500 each. He sells them to his buddies for $450.
That's legal due to the "first sale doctrine."
This guy did the same thing, except from Thailand. Note, they were not (I don't believe) the exact same as Wiley was selling in the USA, they were of inferior quality, but the TEXT was the same and, after all, they were text books, who the hell cares about the quality of them, as long as they last the semester, right?
Frankly, and with all due respect to Perrie's hubby, textbooks are fricking rip offs!
Sorry Perrie.
My understanding is that if these textbooks had been manufactured in the USA, shipped to Thailand and then we assume the same set of facts, no issue.
Your assessment is nevertheless subjective and personal ... let the merit of his arguments or lack thereof stand on their own ...
I deleted the pejorative term you cited.
So noted and deleted.
[[It may turn out that SCOTUS affirms the conclusion that right of first sale applies irrespectively of where the material was made or purchased. If so, expect copyright owners to respond by creating new ways to lock down control of their material, probably by reverting to a "pay for use" model in which you no longer purchase an object, but merely purchase a license for reading, looking at, or listening to the intellectual property. In that case, your right to resell your own stuff won't be impacted, at all. Rather, your right to purchase copyrighted material will be. As in you'll no longer "own" a book, but merely own a license to access its content.]]
Oh well ... I guess libraries would then become illegal . Oops !
[[no, libraries are given specific rights in copyright legislation to do what they do. That is part of the 'exchange' of rights that is given through copyright in the first place.]]
This applies to ownership of physical books how exactly ? Libraries own their books . They are free to lend them out because they paid for the physical books .
[[That is actually what happened with computer software. ]]
Yes it did . But that doesn't stop computer owners from selling their computers with software installed even though that is technically illegal .
Libraries aren't resellers ... they're repositories that allow free access to copyrighted information.
But what about when they hold book sales as fundraisers? Don't know the answer to that?
And software may be legally transferred when sold installed along with a personally-owned computer as long as the seller hasn't retained copies of that software installed on other computers ... good luck enforcing although via cookies and the particular software, I guess it's logistically possible.
comment removed for CoC violation (AM)
I know A.Mac, go ahead.
Yup.
[[All I stated is that libraries are treated explicitly in the law that allows them to do exactly what they do. ]]
So what's to stop this book reseller from claiming the status of a library . He is not selling books ... he is only loaning them out with a deposit fee ... a fee that is never refunded because the books are never returned .
Sometime, somewhere, when the purple pen has run out of ink, I'm going to use the catheter line!
You may be right about the sale of high end software but that doesn't prevent people from selling it anyway .
I was once offered a PC for sale with a copy of SAS installed on it . As long as I kept revising the current date on the computer the enforcement of the license to use SAS would not work . I did not make the purchase but these things do happen .
They were not printed in the USA, if you read the case you would know that, hence, you don't know what you are talking about.
Perrie corrected herself, a little oversight on your part.
Wake up, smell the roses. The issue before the case is quite simple, does the First Sale Doctrine apply to product manufactured overseas/in a different country.
No matter how you try to moondance, that's the issue. No matter how you try to prevaricate, that's the issue.
It is an axiom that:
I respectfully believe you should begin to adhere to axioms.
God it's tough to determine where the appropriate "reply" should be!
Technically, it is subject to an exception. It was a common law exception which was later codified.
But it is CLEAR that the same actions would come under the umbrella of that exception if the books were manufactured in the USA, do we agree on that? Let's say that Wiley manufactured them in Boston, sold them at Harvard for X, but at Princeton for X+1. Can we agree that if a student bought 10,000 of them at Harvard, drove to Princeton and sold them he would come under the First Sale Doctrine?
If we can agree on that, and I would hope we could, then what is the difference where the manufacture is outside of the Country?
Is it just that the difference can be so GREAT that the person actually undertaking the resale can make a ton of money? Is that it?
Note, certain folks continue to maintain that this issue does not impact libraries. Of course it does, or at least the Association of Research Libraries believes it does.
Now, as to your stated issues, of course it is about the gubbmmint preventing you from selling your own shit, if that shit is manufactured outside this Country. After all, it is FEDERAL LAW, a/k/a the gubbimint!
Also, the reach of, say, a complete affirmance of the Second Circuit would be incredible! No matter what those posting here who have no clue of what the issue is, the issue is the First Sale Doctrine.
Here is the actual holding of the Court:
So, if that holding is upheld, then NO sale of a product in the USA which may have such protection manufactured outside of the USA, no matter the number of those products sold (there is no "amount" limit in the exception, sec. 109), would have protection under the First Sale Doctrine.
ALL such sales would be illegal, whether it is one iphone, or a thousand.
Important case, no matter how you cut it. And not only for those dealing in large numbers for enforcement is enforcement. Many times, such as in marks, if you are aware of a violation of your mark no matter how small, how insignificant, and don't take action to address it, you could lose your mark.
Actually it would be kind of tough. Say I resell a DVD to someone. How is the company going to prove he didn't buy it from a store? They would actually require evidence for such a suit. Since there are no names on such things, that evidence might be kind of hard to come by. Of course, they might give second hand stores a hard time, but that would simply trigger a black market.
Maybe I wasn't as clear as I could have been.
Sure, it would be tough to enforce if they had to enforce it in every case for enforcement to be effective.
But they don't. They just need to sue the living heck out of one, two, three, maybe ten in different areas of the Country, get judgments, ruin some lives, and have the papers report the results in excruciating detail and "enforcement" would become one heck of a lot easier after that.
It's like "stealing" cable. Ten years ago it was prevalent as hell, ten bucks for a splitter, $30 for some cable and, bam, you have cable in several areas of your house. Or, even better, buy a black box from a side street vendor which can be used to intercept signals and "steal" cable in that way.
And that was happening like crazy, until the industry went after folks, every day folks. and the word spread, and the incidence of such "theft" dropped hugely.
Most folks won't take the chance if they know companies are up to suing them.
Penalties for fraud.
You did see my link re: libraries, didn't you?
It would not be a rental agency if he claimed he was lending for free . The fact that almost everyone kept their books and forfeited their deposit fee does not disprove he was lending for free . If only one person returned their book and got back their deposit then it shows he was lending and not selling [from a legal standpoint] .
[[ That copy of SAS was not legit in the first place]]
I don't know what makes you say that . SAS used to make a PC based version of their famous software . This individual had purchased a license for a single copy of SAS for PC . This had nothing to do with ebay . It was someone I met in a computer club meeting .
REad:
[[or the ambiguous exception in 17 USC 602(a)(2)(C) that allows a library to import 5 copies (except audiovisual works) for lending purposes, but doesnt specifically allow the library to actually lend those copies.]]
Huh ? Can you translate that into English ?
[[but doesn't actually state that the library is able to lend those copies out. ]]
It also doesn't say they can't lend them out . They can purchase them to lend them out but are not actually granted the authority to lend them ... Very confusing .
[[The except audiovisual works part should be obvious. ]]
Based on ?
[[Essentially if you need to muck with the date, the license has expired.]]
That does not surprise me . And it is a fair rule . But they don't do that with most software apps for PCs . Most don't include a date of expiration at all . Those are pretty much keepers with the PC they are installed on from my POV and what most PC sellers do .
The last I heard SAS withdrew it's PC based version from the market quite a few years back but I haven't kept up with this .
[[As for SAS, if SAS pulled the PC version, then SAS wouldn't still be in business. ]]
SAS has a large installed base of mainframe users . Pretty much every college and university uses SAS . There is a good reason for that . Their advanced statistic mods are renowned . They are far more sophisticated than anything SPSS makes .
But I have not kept up with this app . I googled it and it is still in production . The license fee is only about $35 / year for a single use . Not bad ... But it must be extra for the special stats mods ...
[[simple reality is that most customers don't need SAS]]
I can't argue with that . It is the customers who use the specialty mods that need SAS .