Six people were stabbed at the annual Jerusalem Gay Pride Parade on Thursday by an ultra-Orthodox man who perpetrated a similar stabbing at the 2005 march.
Yishai Schlissel, of Modiin Illit, was released from prison several weeks ago after serving 10 years in prison for his last attack, which wounded three people.
I saw an ultra-Orthodox man stabbing everyone in his way, Shai Aviyor, a witness, told Channel 2. We heard people screaming, everyone ran for cover, and there were bloodied people on the ground.
Police and medics said the attacker wounded six people.
Two were taken to hospital in serious condition, including a 17-year-old woman, said a doctor at Shaare Zedek Medical Center, where the victims were being treated.
The procession of thousands which started at Independence Park in downtown Jerusalem shortly after 6:30 p.m.
was heading down Keren Hayesod Street when Schlissel lunged into the crowd, wildly stabbing the victims before being tackled by police. As police arrested him and cordoned off the crime scene, including all traffic on the major thoroughfare, Magen David Adom paramedics tended to the wounded before transferring them to the hospital.
Following the attack, the Judea and Samaria Police District said they were not required to track Schlissel following his release, even though he lives in their jurisdiction, because he committed his crime in Jerusalem.
Jerusalem District Police chief Moshe Edri said police didnt have concrete intelligence that Schlissel was in attendance at the parade.
We were prepared for every scenario, but our perimeter was breached, he said. This is a severe incident, and we will investigate to find out what caused this breach.
Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu promptly condemned the stabbings as a most serious incident that is antithetical to Israeli values.
A despicable hate crime was committed this evening in Jerusalem, he said. In Israel everyone, including the gay community, has the right to live in peace, and we will defend that right. I welcome the Israeli religious leaderships condemnation of this terrible crime, and I call on all those in positions of leadership to denounce this contemptible act. In the name of all of Israelis, I wish the wounded a full and speedy recovery.
Netanyahu added that in the State of Israel, the individuals freedom of choice is one of the countrys basic values. We need to ensure that every man and woman in Israel can live in security any way they choose. That is how we acted in the past, and how we will continue to act.
The prime minister vowed to prosecute those responsible to the full extent of the law.
President Reuven Rivlin also issued a statement condemning the attack.
We came together today for a festive event, but the joy was shattered when a terrible hate crime occurred here in Jerusalem, the capital of Israel, he said. People celebrating their freedom and expressing their identity were viciously stabbed.
We must not be deluded a lack of tolerance will lead us to disaster. We cannot allow such crimes, and we must condemn those who commit and support them. I wish the injured a full and speedy recovery.
Schlissel reportedly wrote and published a letter last week saying that there is an obligation to stop the parade of sin at all costs. It is the obligation of every Jew to keep his soul from punishment and stop this giant desecration of Gods name next Thursday, he wrote according to Maariv. He said the parades were happening because of our enormous sins.
Jerusalem Mayor Nir Barkat described the stabbing as an affront to human rights.
The criminal act this evening in Jerusalem is an attempt to disrupt social life in the city and to suppress the basic human right of freedom of expression, he said. We will not tolerate any excuse for violence of any kind. In Jerusalem, there is a place for everyone, and together with the Israel Police, we will continue to target anyone who violently attempts to hurt others.
Chief rabbis David Lau and Yitzhak Yosef denounced the attack, stating that it violated Jewish law, and called on the legal authorities to deal with the attacker with utmost severity.
The Torah of the Jewish people forbids all violence and [attempts to] injure any person, and especially someone who tries to kill another person, said Lau.
Yosef said the attacker should be considered like any other murderer.
Its unthinkable that a man can lift up his hand against another Jewish soul in the name of religion, said the rabbi. I am praying from the bottom of my heart for the full recovery of those who were injured, and in the face of this type of hatred I call on the entire Jewish people to return to unity in kindness and tolerance.
Minutes after the attack, thousands of grieving and shaken participants gathered in a nearby park to collectively process the violent episode.
It shouldnt be like this, said Guy Sheffer, 28, who marched in the parade. When I came here I had a smile, now I feel were under attack. Why are we under attack? It doesnt register in my mind that we cant express ourselves as human beings.
Eitan Buchvall, a 44-year-old gay man from Jerusalem, said he thought such violence was behind the capitals gay community.
Im still in shock, he said.
We thought these kinds of actions would not happen again; not only because of the increased police presence, but also because we thought different communities in Jerusalem including the Orthodox community believed that Jerusalem is a city of minorities, and we have to live together peacefully.
Hadas, 18, who requested her last name not be published, said she blamed the violence on an anemic police presence when the parade began.
For a man to run into a crowd and stab six people, clearly there was not enough of a police presence, she said.
In Tel Aviv, left-wing demonstrations with just three people have the entire police force.
Julie, a 25-year-old who requested her last name not be published, said the violent attack meant she will be even more vigilant in defending gay rights.
This means that we have to keep doing this, she said. It makes it even more important.
A small number of protesters from the extremist Lehava organization, including the groups leader Rabbi Bentzi Gopstein, were present at the march, and were cordoned off by the police at the intersection of Agron and Keren Hayesod streets.
This is the holy city of Jerusalem and there is no place for such [a parade], and no reason for people to be proud about it, Gopstein told The Jerusalem Post. If such people can have a pride march, then soon pedophiles and anyone else with such inclinations can hold a march.
Despite Gopsteins vitriol, he released a statement following the stabbings stating that the organization is opposed to the stabbing of Jews.
Reuters contributed to this report.
Posted by:
Elisa Altschuler

Hello, Elisa, and welcome to NewsTalkers.
Have to say I agree with you here. We have unfortunately discovered that there are several people who have been released from prison here in America, and on the same day, committed the same, or worse crime. The world has turned away from capital punishment, saying it is inhumane and not a deterrent to crime. I'm asking if it is more humane to turn people such as this loose on an innocent society, knowing that he will injure... chancing that he will kill.... or is it more humane for society to put to death murderers, pedophiles, people of that nature?
The prison officials had to know that this man had not changed his outlook or opinion of gays and would probably be a danger to them. If they did not know, they should have, and law enforcement should have received a notice to be on the alert for this man.
Elisa, are you located here in the US?
How terribly sad.
In my neighborhood we say if you are gonna get a bunch of fruits together, don't be surprised when you attract a couple of nuts.
I don't care if you are gay or straight, or whatever else they call themselves today, making a parade of it is meant to get more attention and it looks like it worked, just maybe not the attention they wanted.
I wouldn't have an Italian pride parade down in south side, unless I wanted to get shot.
People gotta know where they are and who is around them, or else you take your chances.
I agree with your practical philosophy . This attack was against pride more than against being gay .
Petey Coober :
"This attack was against pride more than against being gay."
What is this supposed to mean?
Gay Pride events were created in order empower LGBT folks to break out of the shame the dominant culture would have preferred that we adopt toward ourselves.
Read this:
I don't expect you to understand any of this, Petey. I think you probably think LGBT folks SHOULD be closeted or ... or ... anything but proudly out and visible.
Maybe you think of "pride" as one of the seven deadly sins, or some such. But that's not it, you see. Pride may not be the best word. But what it comes down to is a refusal to be ashamed and hidden.
When violent freaks with knives or other weapons attack us, they attack everyone -- all cultural diversity, all who are marginalized and oppressed. But I don't think you understand this, Petey.
It is for your understanding--in part--that these Gay Pride events were created.
It means don't flaunt your sexuality on the public streets . Just because Miley Cyrus does her thing in public doesn't mean you have to . Women also get attacked in public for wearing too revealing attire . If you refuse to dial it back you can expect to pay a price ... eventually .
I'll never understand this level of hate.
Elisabeth Altschuler-Heinze
She probably would too, and it wouldn't be the first time.
I meant no disrespect. I do feel bad about the gays that got stabbed. I just think that by marching, you make a target out of yourself, for crazy people to come find you.
I'm not trying to be macho, just saying what I think.
Fruits is just what we call them in my neighborhood, not as an insult, just what we say.
" I meant no disrespect. I do feel bad about the gays that got stabbed. I just think that by marching, you make a target out of yourself, for crazy people to come find you."
So, what you're saying is that these are amazingly courageous and totally fabulous fruits, right? Much morecourageously fruity than the limp-wristed and swishy fruits in your neighborhood? After all, to make a statement about how Queer Lives Matter, they took the risk of being stabbed by nutballs with giant serrated knives.
Oh my goodness, they sound like such nice people. Why would someone do something this awful?
Do Jewish people in Israel hate gays like in Iran and Russia?
I am a Catholic, so I am not much supportive of gays, but I found this and it disturbs me very much.
Brazil, where 44% of worlds anti-LGBT violence occurs, kills discrimination bill
BRASILIA Brazil s lawmakers on Wednesday killed a draft bill that would have prohibited discrimination or inciting violence on the basis of sexual orientation and gender identity .
The vote on the Senates floor rejected both the draft bill and excluded the concepts of sexual orientation and gender identity from a review of Brazils penal code.
Brazils LGBT activists had hoped that if the bill was defeated it could be incorporated into the countrys penal code reform.
But the countrys powerful evangelical lobby blocked the effort with an amendment deleting mentions of sexual orientation and gender identity, which they claimed are neither firm nor stable concepts in legislative context.
Evangelical leader and pastor Silas Malafia celebrated the bills defeat on Twitter : You can swear, were hahahaha plc122 [the bill outlawing LGBT discrimination] is dead, hahahha try something else and wait a few years hahahaaha, if God laughs at the wicked, imagine me, hahahaha.
According to the campaign group Grupo Gay da Bahia , 44 percent of the worlds anti-LGBT violence occurs in Brazil.
This year alone, 292 LGBT people have been murdered in Brazil, while 2012 saw a 21 percent increase in murders over 2011.
Our chances to add the concepts of sexual orientation and gender identity into the penal code are now near impossible, said Luiz Henrique Coletto, Vice President of the Secular Humanist League of Brazil (LiHS), in a statement to LGBTQ Nation.
This means that we have no nationwide federal protection against discrimination of, and violence against LGBT people, he added. The vote was a clear demonstration anti LGBT prejudice in Brazil.
Gustavo Bernardes, coordinator of LGBT rights of Brazils presidential secretary on human rights, toldLGBTQ Nationthat government did all it could to support the bill.
It was a legislative failure, he said. There are others motions already being taken as well as an appeal to Brazils Supreme Court of Justice to force a ruling in favor of protection from discrimination and violence against LGBT people.
Article continues below
Bernardes called for the European Union, United States and international bodies to apply pressure on lawmakers and provide financial support for LGBT rights campaigns in the country.
Paulo Roberto, an attorney and member of GADvS (Group of Lawyers for Sexual Diversity), toldLGBTQ Nationthat Brazil is in violation of international resolutions and statements where it signed a commitment to protect LGBT citizens, both at the level of the United Nations and Organization of American States .
Furthermore, he added, If this country is not safe for our own people considering anti-gay violence, how can it be safe for people coming for the world cup and the Olympics ?
Brazil is scheduled to host the 2014 soccer World Cup and the 2016 Olympic Games.
It seems that many here in Brazil not like the gays or the police kill them like many peoples.
Petey C.:
"It means don't flaunt your sexuality on the public streets."
So what you're saying is that if you want to have a political (or social change) march or demonstration, well, the best place to do that is in your closet ... or maybe far out in the wilderness, where nobody is around to see it?
By the way, you should know that it's not all about our sexuality. It really isn't. It's about our relation-ality. Y'know, those people whom we choose to enter into loving relationships with. You see, we LGBT folks are just like straight folks, in that the overwhelming majority of the time we spend together is doing stuff like ... cooking, eating, doing dishes, watching tv, movies..., recreational activities (non-sexual), hanging out, walking, hiking... talking.... We spend a very small proportion of our time having sex.
We're just people. Just like you. And when you finally understand that you'll understand why we will not be intimidated by schmucks who think we should not march, should not be visible.... And maybe you'll join us one day in our march as an ally.
But I'm not holding my breath.
Nah . Political marches are a different matter . Here's what you seem to favor :
Does this mean you will make a statement that straight lives matter ?
Welcome to NT, Elisabeth! Your post is just fine!
I agree with you that I can't understand why some people behave as they do. How can anyone who professes to love God have such hate in their heart for people who have no affect on their lives? Beyond me...
Take care!
Me, either, Chucky. It is unfathomable...
Well, at least one of them does. But you really can't generalize about an entire group based on one person:
You are being far too reasonable . Do you think anyone is convinced by reason ?
Because the road gravel scares up the toes of your boots, ruining the dam things and it'sawful uncomfortable for your lady friend!
Always take a blanket along if you're driving the back roads of Texas and "You're barley 17 & barley dressed".
I read the attacker was aHasidic Jew (ultra orthodox) aka Jewish extremists, similiar to the religious or far right in the U.S. sans the overt violence. ex: Israeli military says Jewish extremists kill Palestinian child, torch homes in West Bank
All lives matter.
"I am a Catholic, so I am not much supportive of gays, but I found this and it disturbs me very much."
I blame the pope. And the cardinals. But mostly the Pope.
The Pope should stand up and tell his flock of sheep that Jesus never had one bad word to say about gay people and members of the Church should treat all people with equal dignity and respect.
Behind all of the violence and hatered is a legacy of religion. Religion needs to change. How can we believe that the Church is all about love and goodness?
Reply by Petey Coober :
"Nah . Political marches are a different matter . Here's what you seem to favor: ... "
Why would you say this? Are you basing this on something you saw at the Jerusalem Gay Pride Parade?
And why would you assume anything at all about what I "seem to favor"? How could you know what I, personally, favor about Gay Pride events?
Why make it about ME? You don't know me.
Have some people at some Gay Pride events been a little over the top? You bet! But that is no reason to believe that everyone in the parade sanctions their weird behavior. The tolerate it, yes. And as long is no one is harmed by it, why not tolerate it?
Of course! They are human, after all.
And the lives of heterosexists matter. There are far more of these than there are homophobes -- which implies fear (phobe). Heterosexists are not necessarily afraid of gays, lesbians, bisexuals.... Rather, they feel that they as heterosexuals are superior to LGB.... Anyway, these are people too. And their lives also matter.
Or your Boones Farm/Mad Dog 20 20.
On a warm summer night mothing can make road gravel fell downy soft like abottle of cheap,fruity wine.
Or so I've been told.
Or your Boones Farm/Mad Dog 20 20.
Nothing can make road gravel fell downy soft, on a warm summer night, like acheap,fruity wine.
Or so I've been told.
I'm thinking this guy is deep in the closet.
I blame the pope. And the cardinals. But mostly the Pope.
When you blame the cardinals, who exactly are you blaming? The GM? The owner? Because I know you're not blaming the players. They would play for another team, if not the Cardinals, no?
Not those Cardinals, silly!
Actually, I'm not entirely serious about my use of the word "blame". You really cannot blame people for being ignorant and for lacking in empathy, compassion and understanding. What you can do is acknowledge the causal roots of these things in our society and try to nurture those conditions which allow us to become less ignorant and unkind.
Still, I think it's time for the various churches to take the sort of steps the Boy Scouts of America recently took, and which the U.S. military somewhat recently took -- and which the US Supreme Court took. It's inevitable, I think. In time, LGBT people will just be people, not a despised class of people whom folks feel the need to oppress.
Actually, yes, it was a giant serrated knife -- a very scary knife.
The major institutional religions have somehow evolved, while those who "officially" represent those faiths have not. Inertia's the word. They see that, in order to become current, they must sacrifice some of their power. It's always about the power.
BTW, pleased to make your acquaintance. Glad you liked my corny joke.
Religions (especially the monotheisms) have very often encouraged treating homo-amorous people as "sinners," ..., as "evil" ..., as "abominations".... They have often encouraged fear and contempt toward the homoamorous (and biamorous). So it's not all that surprising that some will take it as far as hatred, or even violent hatred.
[I've elected to use the word "homoamorous" (and "biamorous") in place of "homosexual" (and "bi-sexual") in order to emphasize loving over sex. Gays, bis and lesbians have not struggled these last decades primarily for the right to openly have sex with persons of the same sex, but rather to have the right to love their partners openly. The LGBT struggle has not been primarily about sexuality, but about love.]
" ... making a parade of it is meant to get more attention and it looks like it worked, just maybe not the attention they wanted."
" It means don't flaunt your sexuality on the public streets . [....] If you refuse to dial it back you can expect to pay a price ... eventually."
This sort of commentary has me wondering if you'd have discouraged a certain important historical march at Edmund Pettus Bridge on Bloody Sunday (March 7, 1965), or whether you would have discouraged any of the now famous sit-ins at lunch counters in the South... etc.
Standing up in the face of oppression always involves courage and risk. It's not a picnic in the park. It's often not pretty. People get hurt.
James Martin
So, what you're saying is that these are amazingly courageous and totally fabulous fruits, right? Much morecourageously fruity than the limp-wristed and swishy fruits in your neighborhood?
Thems your words pal, not mine.
Glad to meet you, too, Jonathan.
You think knives are somehow phallic? But they are so tender and fragile and ... mostly harmless.
phalluses, that is. Not knives.
Knives and phalluses don't get along at all. I asked mine and he said he hates knives.
One of these days I'll explain the Catholic dogma the church's teaching regarding sex without the benefit of procreation (which I don't believe in), and it's not what you think, suffice to say the Pope and Cardinals have nothing to do with it and to change it would require an Ecumenical Counsel.