What makes you think it is only the Chinese? Every woman should wonder whether,if today's norm of prenatalsex ID and abortion on demand existed 75 years ago,she would have ever been born.
Even if some women prefer girls and some prefer boys it appears to even out ... I would agree with the results that men favor male children over female children ...
So why has the yearning for a male ... the more likely they were to prefer boys over girls. With age, however, both men and women seem more flexible about having babies of ...
I know several families who have adopted children from China and Russia; all girls.
Boys are given up for adoption and/or aborted far less frequently.
Chinese and American cultures are not that far apart in this respect..
The main reason for the higher Chinese female abortion rate is that China restricts the number of children a family can have to one so each family wants to "make it count." When a family is poor they self-limit with similar results.
American families, being more affluent, have less of a problem but, when it exists, the "solution" is sometimes the same.
The reason that Chinese abort girls over boys is because of their culture. Girls are go to the boys family after marriage in traditional families to help with the care of the parents. Therefore, a family who raises a girl to adulthood, will loose her to marriage. On the other hand, if you have a boy, you will also gain a daughter in law. Hence why the one child rule played out so badly in China. They are trying to reverse that because they now have a generation of boys with no one to marry, causing trouble instead.
In Russia, where there is littleprenatal care if any, especially out of the cities, and a lot of drinking done duringpregnancy, there is a lot of both boys and girls given away for adoption.
As for Gallup poll, which is far from scientific in nature, and the two other blogs, which might have well come from a site like this, there has been conflicting information in long term studies. It seems that most American are indifferent to the sex of their child in the US
I did find other blogs that said the same thing, but I am very fussy about my sources. A teacher thing.
Cross-culturally, Williamson (1976) argues that sex preferences favor sons (versus daughters), a pattern consistent with the cross-cultural predominance of patriarchy. Institutionalized gender differentiation implies that the benefits/costs of sons and daughters differ (i.e., what one anticipates from a son may differ from what one anticipates from a daughter). When gender roles are highly distinct, sons and daughters are not substitutable. Economic, social, and psychological reasons to prefer sons exist given patriarchy and the nonsubstitutability of sons and daughters ( Williamson 1976 ).
The current study fits in this tradition. Focusing on data spanning the last 40 years, we ask whether the desire to have both a daughter and a son has disappeared, indicating the basic equivalence, or full substitutability, of sons and daughters. Such a finding would provide strong evidence of emerging gender indifference among parents and clear evidence of greater gender equality in U.S. society.
In the US there seems to be a gender indifference, despite the polls. There is also this:
Where are the boys? Right here in the U.S.A. where, for the 63rd year in a row, more boys than girls were born. Exactly 94,232 more boys than girls were born in the U.S. during 2004, according to a new Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC) report that examines total sex ratios at birth for over six decades. CDC calculates the total sex ratio as the number of male births divided by female births times 1,000.
Other findings of the report include:
The more children a woman has the more likely she is going to give birth to an equal number of boys and girls.
Since 1940, an average of 91,685 more male babies have been born each year than females, a total of 5,776,130 over that 63-year period.
The highest sex birth ratio occurred in 1946 (1,059 male births per 1,000 females) while the lowest occurred in 1991 and again in 2001 (1,046 male births per 1,000 females).
There were three major trends in sex birth ratios over this period: a significant decline between 1942 and 1959, a significant increase between 1959 and 1971 and another significant decline between 1971 and 2002.
So in actual fact, 60 years ago, when abortion was illegal, there were approx. the same birth rate of boys to girls. Furthermore, in 1991, after abortion was legal and after the advent of sonograms and amnio, there were less boys born. The fact is that you have not made your case for gender preference here in the US on any large ( or even small) scale.
Can't people just be happy with what they get? I wasn't thrilled about having a boy at first. But he grew on me.
Why should we change our laws because the Chinese don'tpreferboys due to their cultural values?
For the record, I hate abortion. It's a personal thing; just who I am. In the US individuals have a right to decide for themselves however.
If theChinesewant to procreate themselves into extinction; let 'em...survivalof the fittest and all.
What makes you think it is only the Chinese? Every woman should wonder whether,if today's norm of prenatalsex ID and abortion on demand existed 75 years ago,she would have ever been born.
Gallup: Americans prefer having boys to girls, just as they ...
Americans (Still) Prefer Boy Babies : Discovery News
I know several families who have adopted children from China and Russia; all girls.
Boys are given up for adoption and/or aborted far less frequently.
Chinese and American cultures are not that far apart in this respect..
The main reason for the higher Chinese female abortion rate is that China restricts the number of children a family can have to one so each family wants to "make it count." When a family is poor they self-limit with similar results.
American families, being more affluent, have less of a problem but, when it exists, the "solution" is sometimes the same.
Len.
The reason that Chinese abort girls over boys is because of their culture. Girls are go to the boys family after marriage in traditional families to help with the care of the parents. Therefore, a family who raises a girl to adulthood, will loose her to marriage. On the other hand, if you have a boy, you will also gain a daughter in law. Hence why the one child rule played out so badly in China. They are trying to reverse that because they now have a generation of boys with no one to marry, causing trouble instead.
In Russia, where there is littleprenatal care if any, especially out of the cities, and a lot of drinking done duringpregnancy, there is a lot of both boys and girls given away for adoption.
As for Gallup poll, which is far from scientific in nature, and the two other blogs, which might have well come from a site like this, there has been conflicting information in long term studies. It seems that most American are indifferent to the sex of their child in the US
I did find other blogs that said the same thing, but I am very fussy about my sources. A teacher thing.
Fed,
Hey I took twin girls. Kind of goes against what is being said here.
Is this what you meant (from your link)?
Cross-culturally, Williamson (1976) argues that sex preferences favor sons (versus daughters), a pattern consistent with the cross-cultural predominance of patriarchy. Institutionalized gender differentiation implies that the benefits/costs of sons and daughters differ (i.e., what one anticipates from a son may differ from what one anticipates from a daughter). When gender roles are highly distinct, sons and daughters are not substitutable. Economic, social, and psychological reasons to prefer sons exist given patriarchy and the nonsubstitutability of sons and daughters ( Williamson 1976 ).
Without intervention roughly five percent more boys than girls are normatively born. In China it is now 20 %.
In the US the number is the normative one meaning that most abortions are not gendercide; "merely fetucide."
And I bet you're really glad you took twin girls. Especially ones that go to college.
Well, sons love their mothers and daughters bicker with them. LOL But they are two smart cookies, so that has to count for the headache they give me
Actually, even more, but Iexplainedthat further up this thread.
As for the US, you have not proven your case for gendercide.
No I was talking about this:
The current study fits in this tradition. Focusing on data spanning the last 40 years, we ask whether the desire to have both a daughter and a son has disappeared, indicating the basic equivalence, or full substitutability, of sons and daughters. Such a finding would provide strong evidence of emerging gender indifference among parents and clear evidence of greater gender equality in U.S. society.
In the US there seems to be a gender indifference, despite the polls. There is also this:
Where are the boys? Right here in the U.S.A. where, for the 63rd year in a row, more boys than girls were born. Exactly 94,232 more boys than girls were born in the U.S. during 2004, according to a new Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC) report that examines total sex ratios at birth for over six decades. CDC calculates the total sex ratio as the number of male births divided by female births times 1,000.
Other findings of the report include:
So in actual fact, 60 years ago, when abortion was illegal, there were approx. the same birth rate of boys to girls. Furthermore, in 1991, after abortion was legal and after the advent of sonograms and amnio, there were less boys born. The fact is that you have not made your case for gender preference here in the US on any large ( or even small) scale.