╌>

Student Who Got 'Gay Cure' Sues California Over New Law Banning Conversion Therapy

  

Category:  News & Politics

Via:  len  •  14 years ago  •  36 comments

Student Who Got 'Gay Cure' Sues California Over New Law Banning Conversion Therapy

A college student who claims he once had same-sex attractions but became heterosexual after conversion therapy has filed a lawsuit against California, which has enacted a law that bans so-called "gay cures" for minors.

The lawsuit, also joined as plaintiffs by two therapists who have used the treatments with patients, alleges that the law banning the therapy intrudes on First Amendment protections of free speech, privacy and freedom of religion.

The student, Aaron Blitzer, who is studying to be a therapist in that field, said the law would prevent him from pursuing his career, according to court papers filed Monday in the U.S. District Court for the Eastern District of California.

More: http://gma.yahoo.com/student-got-gay-cure-sues-california-over-law-180012521--abc-news-health.html


Tags

jrDiscussion - desc
[]
 
Petey Coober
Freshman Silent
link   Petey Coober    14 years ago

The rancorous liberals on this subject declare that homosexuality [in males] is biological and genetic in nature . Therefore it cannot be affected by "therapy" . The problem is that only describes full homosexuality . It does not describe bisexuality . It also does not describe female gayness . This law was passed to protect the male homosexuals against ... discrimination ? But it does not protect the above mentioned other groups against the health dangers of homosexual behavior . It is an unwise law IMO .

 
 
 
Perrie Halpern R.A.
Professor Guide
link   Perrie Halpern R.A.    14 years ago

I am beginning to think this is a generational thing.

I am not a liberal. The science is there that proves that male homosexuality is biological. You are correct, that it doesn't take into consideration bisexuality or female gayness. I am very much on the fence on this subject. I feel that government intervention on personal issues should be limited. But I also have read that many of these "conversions" when done to minorshave had terrible outcomes, including suicide. If an adult chooses to do it, then I am fine with it.

The government has intervened on other religious practice that harm a minor, such as with Christian Scientists and with blood transfusions withJehovahWitnesses and femalecircumcisionall of which are religious beliefs.

As to the dangers of homosexual behavior, when dealing with adults, their bodies their rights.

 
 
 
Petey Coober
Freshman Silent
link   Petey Coober    14 years ago

[[As to the dangers of homosexual behavior, when dealing with adults, their bodies their rights. ]]

So you are against a little preventative action for bisexuals that might give them a fighting chance to avoid dangerous adult behaviors ?

 
 
 
Perrie Halpern R.A.
Professor Guide
link   Perrie Halpern R.A.    14 years ago

Rich,

They are adults and they can decide whether or not they want "treatment". I was referring to gay minors who have no choice in the matter. I don't care what an adult chooses to do, but I do when it comes to minors.

 
 
 
Feddy
Freshman Silent
link   Feddy    14 years ago

I agree with Perrie. I think the therapy can wait until they are not a minor anymore.

 
 
 
Petey Coober
Freshman Silent
link   Petey Coober    14 years ago

And I was referring to giving some assistance to sexually confused children . Waiting till they become adults will be too late to expect behavior changes . They need to be influenced while they are still impressionable . What is so hard to understand about that ?

 
 
 
Feddy
Freshman Silent
link   Feddy    14 years ago

I just would not personally want to screw my kid up worse than they may already be. My son is bisexual. As far as I'm concerned that is between him and God. I do however understand your point. I just feel that for instance in my son's case that I would rather him figure it all out on his own rather than him be mad at me later for interfering.

 
 
 
Feddy
Freshman Silent
link   Feddy    14 years ago

Thanks for the support Mickey! Grin.gif

 
 
 
Perrie Halpern R.A.
Professor Guide
link   Perrie Halpern R.A.    14 years ago

I agree with Mickey. You are doing the right thing Fed. Nothing you did, or most parents do, actually will change who a child is sexually. We are only just beginning to understand how complicated sexuality is.

 
 
 
Petey Coober
Freshman Silent
link   Petey Coober    14 years ago

No . It's more like giving a little encouragement to the ambidextrous to use their right hand . But that comparison doesn't cover the dangers of fatal STDs . Surely you are not going to ignore those dangers ...

 
 
 
Petey Coober
Freshman Silent
link   Petey Coober    14 years ago

[[Nothing you did, or most parents do, actually will change who a child is sexually.]]

And yet the linked article is about one such person who did adapt to changes . He was so favorable about what happened that he wants to help others the same way . But feel free to ignore people like him as you go on your ridiculous quest to be so unbiased that you discriminate the other way .

 
 
 
Len
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Len    14 years ago

The "science" is not there.

Science Does Not Support the Claim That Homosexuality Is Genetic

By Robert Knight

The debate over homosexual "marriage" often becomes focused on whether homosexuality is a learned behavior or a genetic trait. Many homosexual activists insist that "science" has shown that homosexuality is inborn, cannot be changed, and that therefore they should have the "right to marry" each other.

Beginning in the early 1990s, activists began arguing that scientific research has proven that homosexuality has a genetic or hormonal cause. A handful of studies, none of them replicated and all exposed as methodologically unsound or misrepresented, have linked sexual orientation to everything from differences in portions of the brain, to genes, finger length, inner ear differences, eye-blinking, and "neuro-hormonal differentiation."

Meanwhile, Columbia University Professor of Psychiatry Dr. Robert Spitzer, who was instrumental in removing homosexuality in 1973 from the American Psychiatric Associations list of mental disorders, wrote a study published in the October 2003 Archives of Sexual Behavior. He contended that people can change their "sexual orientation" from homosexual to heterosexual. 8 Spitzer interviewed more than 200 people, most of whom claimed that through reparative therapy counseling, their desires for same-sex partners either diminished significantly or they changed over to heterosexual orientation. Although still a proponent of homosexual activism, Spitzer has been attacked unmercifully by former admirers for this breach of the ideology that people are "born gay and cant change." Immutability is a central tenet of demands for "gay rights" and "gay marriage."

Because no single study can be regarded as definitive, more research on people who have overcome homosexuality needs to be done. But a considerable body of previous literature about change from homosexuality to heterosexuality has been compiled, and the sheer number of exceptions to the "born gay" theory should be a warning to researchers and media to proceed with caution before declaring that science has "proved" that homosexuality is genetic.

More: [ PDF ] ORN OR RED Science Does Not Support the Claim That ...

 
 
 
Len
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Len    14 years ago

If it is not an illness, and not genetic, what is it?

It is an "inclination" and inclinations can be overcome, however difficult.

 
 
 
Len
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Len    14 years ago

I presume you are talking of Islam; a primitive form of religion.

 
 
 
Feddy
Freshman Silent
link   Feddy    14 years ago

Thanks Perrie! I really appreciate that.

 
 
 
Perrie Halpern R.A.
Professor Guide
link   Perrie Halpern R.A.    14 years ago

Len,

It is a part of their physiology. Their brains arestructurallydifferent. In male homosexuals, their brain are structured more like woman's brains are with both hemispheres being of equal size and more connections between the two hemispheres. There is also a larger and activity of theamygdala. It is not an inclination any more than being small is to dwarfism.

 
 
 
Perrie Halpern R.A.
Professor Guide
link   Perrie Halpern R.A.    14 years ago

First of Len, your link doesn't work, so I can't read it, or know it source.

Second, this reads like conversion therapy. You want the science, here it is:

The researchers used MRIs to determine the volume and shapes of the brains of 90 volunteers25 straight and 20 gay members of each sex. They found that the straight men and gay women had asymmetrical brains ; that is, the cerebrum (the largest part of the brain, which is responsible for thought, sensory processing, movement and planning) was larger on the right hemisphere of the brain than on the left. In contrast, they found that women and gay men had symmetrical cerebrums.

The team next used PET (positron emission tomography) scans to measure the blood flow to the amygdala , that part of the brain controlling emotion, fear and aggression. The images showed how the amygdala connects to other parts of the brain, giving them clues as to how this might influence behavior. They scanned subjects' brains when they at rest and did not show them photos or introduce other behavior that might have been learned.

Brain scans have provided the most compelling evidence yet that being gay or straight is a biologically fixed trait.

The scans reveal that in gay people, key structures of the brain governing emotion, mood, anxiety and aggressiveness resemble those in straight people of the opposite sex.

The differences are likely to have been forged in the womb or in early infancy, says Ivanka Savic, who conducted the study at the Karolinska Institute in Stockholm, Sweden.

"This is the most robust measure so far of cerebral differences between homosexual and heterosexual subjects," she says.

Previous studies have also shown differences in brain architecture and activity between gay and straight people, but most relied on people's responses to sexuality driven cues that could have been learned, such as rating the attractiveness of male or female faces.

Brain symmetry

To get round this, Savic and her colleague, Per Lindstrm, chose to measure brain parameters likely to have been fixed at birth.

"That was the whole point of the study, to show parameters that differ, but which couldn't be altered by learning or cognitive processes," says Savic.

First they used MRI scans to find out the overall volume and shapes of brains in a group of 90 volunteers consisting of 25 heterosexuals and 20 homosexuals of each gender.

The results showed that straight men had asymmetric brains, with the right hemisphere slightly larger - and the gay women also had this asymmetry. Gay men, meanwhile, had symmetrical brains like those of straight women.

The team next used PET scans to measure blood flow to the amygdala, part of the brain that governs fear and aggression. The images revealed how the amygdala connected to other parts of the brain, giving clues to how this might influence behaviour.

Depression link

They found that the patterns of connectivity in gay men matched those of straight women, and vice versa (see image, above right). In straight women and gay men, the connections were mainly into regions of the brain that manifest fear as intense anxiety.

"The regions involved in phobia, anxiety and depression overlap with the pattern we see from the amygdala," says Savic.

This is significant, she says, and fits with data showing that women are three times as likely as men to suffer from mood disorders or depression. Gay men have higher rates of depression too, she says, but it's difficult to know whether this is down to biology, homophobia or simply feelings of being "different".

In straight men and lesbians, the amygdala fed its signals mainly into the sensorimotor cortex and the striatum, regions of the brain that trigger the "fight or flight" response. "It's a more action-related response than in women," says Savic.

'Striking differences'

"This study demonstrates that homosexuals of both sexes show strong cross-sex shifts in brain symmetry," says Qazi Rahman , a leading researcher on sexual orientation at Queen Mary college, University of London, UK.

"The connectivity differences reported in the amygdala are striking."

"Paradoxically, it's more informative to look at things that have no direct connection with sexual orientation, and that's where this study scores," says Simon LeVay , a prominent US author who in 1991 reported finding differences (pdf) in a part of the brain called the hypothalamus between straight and gay men.

But as Savic herself acknowledges, the study can't say whether the brain differences are inherited, or result from abnormally high or low exposure in the womb to sex hormones such as testosterone.

Journal reference: Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences (DOI: 10.1073/pnas.0801566105)

Len, MRI's don't lie. They are not left up tointerpretationsof psychologist. They are literally there in black and white. People are born gay. They can not change. It is part of their brain structure.

I can get you more info from medical journals, but they would be much harder to understand for a layperson.

 
 
 
Perrie Halpern R.A.
Professor Guide
link   Perrie Halpern R.A.    14 years ago

Rich,

One person does not make science. There is no science to "conversion therapy", just case studies. I find this ironic, since they are claiming that all psychology has is case studies. I have shown you hard science, in the way of neurology, and you still have a hard time digesting this.

I think you are letting your emotional response get in the way of science

 
 
 
Len
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Len    14 years ago

No time to read fully but the link works, though not authorized by Yahoo. Click on the second link and the entire article appears in pdf.

 
 
 
Len
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Len    14 years ago

The important point is that the asserted role of genetics in homosexuality iis controversial and not established science. Here is an article by a world-famous GENETICIST that contradicts the politically correct "science."

"Homosexuality Is Not Hardwired," Concludes Dr. Francis S. Collins, Head Of The Human Genome Project

People are mixing up genetics and values/inclinations/morals.

Psychobiology Prof. Peter Singer of Princeton maintains that bestiality -- sex with animals -- is perfectly OK. Is this also genetic?

Peter Singer and bestiality
In early 2001, Peter Singer reviewed Midas Dekker's book "Dearest Pet: On Beastiality". His review "Heavy Petting" caused a furore among Christian commentators and Animal Rights activists alike. Singer appeared to be condoning sex with animals under certain conditions.

He noted that: "our physical similarities with other animals are so strong that the taboo on bestiality, stems not from physical differences, but from our desire to differentiate ourselves from animals.."

Singer's view was that humans and non-humans may enjoy sexual contact as part of "mutually satisfying activities".

The Animal Rights argument was that Singer was damaging their cause as the founder figure of the movement. An animal cannot give any meaningful consent to sex.

Peter Singer was given the opportunity to explain his views during a visit to Australia. He was interviewed on television by Jana Wendt on SBS's Dateline (8th August, 2001).

Wendt: "Let me ask you about something that caused another storm, that comes out of your view on our relationship with animals. You said that bestiality should not be the taboo that it is. Can you explain?"

Singer: "I was asked to review a book that looked at the history of bestiality or human sexual relationships with animals. I wanted to raise the question as to why, when a lot of other taboos about sex have disappeared, but sexual relations with animals are still, I think, you know, very much taboo. Just as much taboo as they ever were."

"And yet some of them...you know, some of them obviously should be considered wrong because they involve cruelty to the animals. They involve coercing the animal, forcing the animal. But, you know, without going into details, it's not too hard to imagine sexual interactions - not necessarily sexual intercourse - between humans and animals, that don't involve coercion or cruelty to the animal, and yet they're still very much taboo, they're still in many jurisdictions, criminal."

 
 
 
Len
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Len    14 years ago

In the Bible God says to Cain: "If you do right there is uplift. But if you do not do right sin crouches at the door; its urge is towards you. YET YOU CAN BE ITS MASTER." (Gen. 4:7)

 
 
 
Perrie Halpern R.A.
Professor Guide
link   Perrie Halpern R.A.    14 years ago

Len,

I just read the paper, and you have got to be kidding. First of all, it is hardlyobjective, since it wassponsoredby a conservative group who believes in conversion therapy. Second, although they have not found the specific gene that makes people gay, (and that could bebecausethey they just found out that there is another 80% of the genome that they didn't understand), the differences in the MRI's are remarkable.

Long before we found a gene for dwarfism, we knew there weredwarfs. We know that there is a genetic factor to aging, but we can't find it either, but the proof is we age. If you can't accept MRI's and PET scans, then there is no purpose in this discussion.

 
 
 
Petey Coober
Freshman Silent
link   Petey Coober    14 years ago

Uh ... who is an ambidextrous person ? He is both . So is a bisexual . But are you saying you would encourage a bisexual male to explore his homosexual urges ?

 
 
 
Petey Coober
Freshman Silent
link   Petey Coober    14 years ago

[[I would urge him or her to be themselves.]]

These are not completely gay males we are discussing here . As a result they do actually have a choice . As a result you are abdicating responsibility by not informing them of the potential dangers IMO .

 
 
 
Petey Coober
Freshman Silent
link   Petey Coober    14 years ago

Perrie ,

You don't seem to be grasping what I am saying . I am not talking about full blown homosexuals . I accept the science that implies they can't be altered in their preferences . I am talking about bisexual males and maybe gay women too . But thanks for assuming the worst about my intentions .

 
 
 
Len
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Len    14 years ago

Savic/Lindstrom may well be right but that is not certain because their statistical analysis has been shown to be faulty.

Excerpts:

As someone who knows nothing about neurobiology but one or two things about statistics, I dug out the research paper by Savic & Lindstrom and looked at the analysis it presents. I very quickly began to suspect there might be a problem. For each volunteer, the authors obtain measurements of the left and right cerebral volumes (call these L and R respectively). Each pair of measurements is then combined to form an asymmetry index (AI) as (L-R)/(L+R). There is then a set of values for AI, one for each volunteer. The claim is that these are systematically different for the different gender and orientation groups, based on a battery of tests including Analysis of Variance (ANOVA) and t-tests based on sample means.

Of course, it would be better to do this using a consistent, Bayesian , approach because this would make explicit the dependence of the results on an underlying model of the data. Sadly, the statistical methodology available off-the-shelf is of inferior frequentist type and this is what researchers tend to do when they dont really know what theyre doing. They also dont bother to read the health warnings that state the assumptions behind the results.

The problem in this case is that the tests done by Savic & Lindstrom all depend on the quantity being analysed (AI) having a normal (Gaussian) distribution . This is very often a reasonable hypothesis for biometric data, but unfortunately in this case the construction of the asymmetry index is such that it is expected to have a very non-Gaussian shape as is commonly the case for distributions of variables formed as ratios . In fact, the ratio of two normal variates has a peculiar distribution with very long tails. Many statistical analyses appeal to the Central Limit Theorem to justify the assumption of normality, but distributions with very long tails (such as the Cauchy distribution ) violate the conditions of this Theorem, namely that the distribution must have finite variance. The asymmetry index is probably therefore an inappropriate choice of variable for the tests that Savic & Lindstrom perform. In particular the significance levels (or p-values ) quoted in their paper are very low (of order 0.0008, for example, in the ANOVA test) which is surprising for such small samples. These probabilities are obtained by assuming the observations have Gaussian statistics, and they would be much lower for a distribution with longer tails. ---

They also claim that a group size of n=30 is sufficient to be confident that the central limit theorem holds. A pity, then, that none of their groups is of that size. The overall sample is 90, but it is broken down into two groups of 20 and two of 25.

cerebral-asymmetry

(c) 2008 Academy of Sciences of New York

They also say that the measured AI distribution is actually normal anyway and give a plot (above). This shows all the AI values binned into one histogram. Since they dont give any quantitative measures of goodness of fit, its hard to tell whether this has a normal distribution or not. One can, however, easily identify a group of five or six individuals that seem to form a separate group with larger AI values (the small peak to the right of the large peak). Since they dont give histograms broken down by group it is impossible to be sure, but I would hazard a guess that these few individuals might be responsible for the entire result; remember that the entire sample has n only of 90.

More alarmingly, Savic & Lindstrom state in their reply that one outlier is omitted from this graph. Really? On what basis was the outlier rejected? The existence of outliers could be evidence of exactly the sort of problem I am worried about! Unless there was a known mistake in the measurement, this outlier should never have been omitted. They claim that the recalculation of the data excluding this outlier does not change the results. It find it difficult to believe that the removal of an outlier from such a small sample could not change the p-values!

In my note I made a few constructive suggestions as to how the difficulty might be circumvented, by Savic & Bergstrom have not followed any of them. Instead they report (without details of the p-values) having done some alternative, non-parametric , tests. These are all very well, but they dont add very much if their p-values also assume Gaussian statistics. A better way to do this sort of thing robustly would be using Monte Carlo simulations .

The bottom line is that after this exchange of comments we havent really got anywhere and I still dont know if the result is significant. I dont really think its useful to go backwards and forwards through the journal, so Ive emailed Dr Savic again asking for access to the numbers so I can check the statistics privately. In astronomy it is quite normal for people to make their data sets publically available, but that doesnt seem to be the case in neurobiology. Im not hopeful that they will reply, especially since they branded my comments harsh and inappropriate. Scientists should know how to take constructive criticism.

Their conclusion may eventually turn out to be right, but the analysis done so far is certainly not robust and it needs further checking. In the meantime I dont just have doubts about the claimed significance of this specific result, which merely serves to illustrate the extremely poor level of statistical understanding displayed by large numbers of professional researchers. This was one of the things I wrote about in my book From Cosmos to Chaos . Im very confident that a large fraction of claimed results in biosciences are based on bogus analyses.

 
 
 
Petey Coober
Freshman Silent
link   Petey Coober    14 years ago

Thanks ever so much for ignoring what I said and just focusing on your own family issues . Have fun . Meanwhile bisexuals are dying needlessly .

 
 
 
Petey Coober
Freshman Silent
link   Petey Coober    14 years ago

[[That is what sex education is for. ]]

So you are saying that parental responsibility has no place in this ?

 
 
 
Len
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Len    14 years ago

You obviously do not like religion in general and you are, of course, entitled to your opinion.

But while you speak of "all belief systems push[ing] against the boundaries of law" you should recognize that the First Amendment prohibits law from pushing against the boundaries of religion.

"Congress shall make no law respecting an establishment of religion, or prohibiting the free exercise thereof; or abridging the freedom of speech, or of the press; or the right of the people peaceably to assemble, and to petition the government for a redress of grievances."

Obviously there are limits so a Muslim would not be permitted to murder a child or spouse with impunitybecause Sharia permits it.

But you need to show how other religions like Christianity or Judaism "push against the boundaries of law." In fact, a cardinal principal of Judaism (my religion) is that "The law of the land is the [religious] Law." This is based partly on Jeremiah 29:7:

"Seek the welfare of the government to which I have exiled you and pray to the Lord on its behalf; for in its prosperity you shall prosper."

The Talmud is evenmore pragmatic:

Pray for the welfare of the government, since without fear of authority people would eat each other alive (Avot 3:2).

 
 
 
Len
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Len    14 years ago

I tried to find the source for your quote and could not. Please provide.

It sounds like Islam. But even if it is LDS, those clerics are renegades who are subject to prosecution just as were Catholicclerics who aided pediophilia.

There are rengades in all walks of life, religion included. But religion holds up an ideal to be followed. The objective is to be kind to one's fellow.

A sin against a person is a double sin because it is also against God.

 
 
 
Len
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Len    14 years ago

That case makes no mention of twoclergy beating a young girl.

Being married 53 years I naturally agree with SCOTUS. The Biblical patriarchs were polygamous and so was Judaism till about the tenth century when a rabbi ruled against it for Askenazi/European Jews. Sefardim/Middle eastern Jews continued to be polygamous though now they have also largely abandoned the practice.

The Bible showed that polygamy led to discord within the family.

Polygamy always meant a male with several wives, not the other way around. A wife with other lovers is an adultress. The reasoning is obvious. A male isgenerally more sexually active and his multiple wives take turns cohabiting. A single wife with multiple husbands would quickly be worn out. There are other reaasons but this is the most obvious.

 
 
 
Len
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Len    14 years ago

I gave an example of restriction (Sharia) before you did. Polygamy is another.

But religion is unrestricted otherwise.

That is why the Obama exec order (not even a law) forcing Catholic institutions to distribute contraceptives created so many protests. Religions conduct social programs for the benefit of all, not just for their own religion. Forcing them to violate their religiousconscience will just make them pull back on such universal endeavors.

 
 
 
Len
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Len    14 years ago

With the law against polygamy, polyamorous relationships have become more common because non-marital sexual relationships do not violate the law. It is a matter of "privacy."

Regarding child marriage in Islam, some Muslims deny it but the consensus is that it exists and I read about it, and the resultant abuses of thebride, even slavery and murder,frequently. Here is the "tradition:"

"Muhammad sexually consummated his marriage to the nine year old Aisha following her first menstruation. HOWEVER, after reading brother Sam Shamouns articles ( 1 , 2 ), I realized that the Quran, the Hadith, and Muslim scholars writings state that a Muslim husband can engage in sex with a child-bride before she has her first menses. Further, Muhammad actually did just this he had intercourse with Aisha prior to her first menses!e"

Look at this article and photo:

...

 
 
 
Len
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Len    14 years ago

When Muhammad is used as the paradigm it is more than cultural. Jews do not use Jacob or Solomonas a paradigm for polygamy.

Bin Laden had about 70 siblings and one of his wives found in Pakistan was a young woman.

The youngest and his supposed favorite, Amal Ahmed Abdul Fatah stayed with him. Pakistani says her passpoprt was found in the compound after the raid. She was 29 and had been given to bin Laden as a gift by a Yemeni family when she was only a teenager.

 
 

Who is online

Dismayed Patriot
Snuffy


97 visitors