It's not just foreign policy that makes Americans unpopular in the Muslim world
The United States doesn't get a lot of love from the Muslim world. Only eight percent of Pakistanis, for instance, view the U.S. as a partner, according to a Pew opinion poll conducted in June. Fully 74 percent consider the U.S. an enemy -- $30 billion in direct aid pledged since 1948 notwithstanding. Equally discouraging is the recent outpouring of anti-American sentiment in Yemen, where President Barack Obama promised more than $175 million in non-military development and humanitarian aid for this year alone.
It's unfortunate, but there's an easy explanation, right? American values, perceived as antithetical to Islam, coupled with U.S. foreign policy -- think drones and American support for Israel -- have made the U.S. so unpopular in the Muslim world that no amount of aid can rehabilitate its image.
Not so fast. Political scientists Lisa Blaydes and Drew Linzer have a provocative article in the latest issue of the American Political Science Review that challenges the notion that "individuals form their opinions about the United States primarily as a direct reaction to what the United States is or does."
Obviously, grievances of this type are not irrelevant, but Blaydes and Linzer argue that anti-American sentiment is primarily concocted by political elites who try to ideologically "outbid" each other in their quest for votes. They call it "instrumental" anti-Americanism, and their model predicts when it's most likely to occur .

If there was no need for products from the middle east [translation : oil ] we could safely ignore what is going on there and withdraw all support from that region . Then if a terrorist cell starts up we could just drop some bombs and not worry about the backlash ... As it is we need to have a local base to launch killer drones .
The other strategy is to encourage Arabs to fight with each other even more than they already are . This is remarkably easy to do . It has been part of their culture there for 1000s of years .
BTW , that is one really cheesy US flag in the picture ...
If you're damned if you do AND damned if you don't, I vote for "don't".
As far as intramural carnage, the distraction of the West is delaying the Sunni/Shi'ite bloodbath that we're all waiting for. Right on 2 points, Rich. If we'd just vacate the premises, we could watch from a far and bemoan man's inhumanity to man.
I say leave. Best if we didn't need any of their oil.
Yes, ancient problems bring out themega in megalomaniac.
"I'm going to solve this 3,000 year old problem in 4 years. Just watch this".
I read a book recently by a descendant of the Bhutto family, many of whom were in positions of importance and power in Pakistan, and as well, many of whom were assassinated, that suggested that the USA was quite perfidious in its promises to be a partner and protector. i have no idea if it's true, or was just a statement from a bitter person.
Yup, oils gotta go.
Maybe somebody should develope an electric car!
;^)
C'mon, they keep some cheesy spares around for everyday burning, and use the nicer ones for burning duringholidays, at the beach, a picnic...
In my experience all news and personal accounts coming out of Pakistan are filled with distortions , inaccuracies and even complete fabrications .
And everything's great now, except for those pesky Jews Israelis.
If they would just give Abbas what he wants, there'd be peace...
...oh well. It wasn't my fault.
It was Bush's fault.
Yeah, dat's da ticket!!
Thanks for that geographical insight KB . Here is a map for us in the uninformed category :
Oops , looks like we are in HTML only mode ... See the next comment .
OK here is the map :
Interesting...
The Barbary Coast was also a piracy issue and led to the formation of the US Navy...
That reminds me of this :
"Sundown ya better take care
if I find you've been creepin' round my back stairs"
Treatment of the indfidel has not significantly changed in Islam's history. Where the rest of civilization advances, Islam stays true to its roots. Sad thing is, there are people who excuse their behavior in this day and age, while expecting them to play by modern diplomatic rules. The rest of us are free to suffer, while the terrorists' gains continue, unchecked.
I have just started learning about the Barbary Coast as well, very rewarding. I have noted a similar theme running throughout (including even today) much of the narative...
...we still are paying Jizya to this day. It's nothing more than a protection racket/extortion to be handing money over to our enemies to keep the peace; but, it's what we do.
But we do this with the understanding of what motivates them, as well as what they respect...
...and it's FORCE that they respect. They do not respect words or treaties. They do not honor the documents they sign. They do understand that, if their actions will be met with great force, they will respect.
We don't do that anymore. We send hundreds of thousands of our children to serve as "peacemakers" and "nation builders". We equivocate about our best interests. We apologize for their atrocious behavior. We scold our allies who dare to defend themselves against this. We pretend that it's our fault.
Disgusting.
Agreed.
What I am finding so fascinating is the fact that the US has actually been batteling Islamic supremacy for sometime now! The deeper I dig, the more I see. And yeah disgusting and hard to believe.