How much Liberty, and how many Rights, will you surrender in order to feel "safe"?
A while ago, I went to the County Seat of the county in which I currently reside. I left my pocket knife (1.75" blade) in the car. I was forced to empty my pockets into a tray. Put my cellphone in the tray. Put the envelope of paperwork in the tray. And walk through a metal detector. With my normal good grace, I complained about the violation of my rights against unlawful search, to which I received the following reply. "Shut up and go through the detector again, you missed something." After 2 more passes, they made me remove the belt from my pants, they wanded my zipper and the American flag hatpin in my hat, and finally gave me permission to replace my personal belongings.
I told the Blackshirt (County Sheriff) that this was a ridiculous waste of time, and that there were many better ways to protect human life than harassing American citizens. He said "Oh yeah, wise guy? Well, why don't you enlighten me?" I said that if they stopped violating the 2nd Amendment and allowed American citizens to be armed and to protect themselves, none of this would be necessary. I went on to say that 9-11 would have turned out differently if the passengers on those 4 planes had been allowed to carry guns with the new frangible bullets (safe to use in pressurized environments). He sneered at me, and called me "Ignorant and un-informed" I called him a "Jackbooted Nazi Thug" and went on my way.
After completing my business there, while leaving the building, he flagged me down, and told me not to come back into the building unless I could keep "A civil tongue in my head" I must admit, I told him to shove it, and that I would enter any building I so desired that my taxes paid for, and if he didn't like it, he could lump it. I added that I also have a Constitutional right to speak my opinion, and he had no power to prevent it..
So, to my point. Are you happy surrendering your rights in the name of safety? Do you feel safer walking through metal detectors an public buildings, rather than being allowed to protect yourself? Or am I a lone whack-job, railing futilely at the "Will of the People", refusing to accept this brave new world? I do not accept that, but I am interested in YOUR opinions.
Tags
Who is online
60 visitors

I've never quite thought about metal detectors, etc. like that before, but what you said makes absolute sense.
Well, are they or are they not searching your private property, prior to allowing you to enter PROPERTY YOU YOURSELF PAID TO BUILD AND MAINTAIN? And do they have a warrant? Are we not guaranteed, in the 4th Amendment,
The right of the people to be secure in their persons, houses, papers, and effects, against unreasonable searches and seizures, shall not be violated, and no Warrants shall issue, but upon probable cause, supported by Oath or affirmation, and particularly describing the place to be searched, and the persons or things to be seized.
A possible criminal, confronted by police on the street, has more rights than we do entering a government building to do business we are often REQUIRED BY LAW to engage in. The perp has to be told he has the right to remain silent. The cop has to have probable cause to search pockets, purses, or bodies.
It is a very trite, yet totally true, saying that "When guns are outlawed only outlaws will have guns."
Law abiding citizens are the ONLY people who will turn in their guns to victim disarmers. When the law is finally passed to outlaw guns, I will be an outlaw. Also, very few people realize just how easy it is to create a decent gun from scrap metal and common household ingredients. Gang bangers built zip guns farther back than the 1950s. It's pathetically easy.
You mean has anybody ever had their freedom removed by being foolish enough to carry stupidly prohibited substances into the den of the people illegally prohibiting those substances? Probably. Stupidity is it's own reward, but since I don't support drug laws, whether the idiots poisoning themselves (as is their right) get caught doing so is not a plus of the searches.
"Those who would give up Essential Liberty to purchase a little Temporary Safety, deserve neither Liberty nor Safety." Benjamin Franklin.
Yup. I'm right out there with our founding fathers. I would be willing to bet they'd have taken weapons in hand and changed the government over the USA Patriot Act. They'd refuse to submit to a TSA sexual assault. They'd be lined up to buy the best "assault weapon" they could afford, and amazed we tolerate the restrictions placed, UNCONSTITUTIONALLY, upon the acquisition of the fully automatic versions.
John, as KK just said, there is no safety anywhere. Now, in an ideal world, there might be a way to prevent all murders. But "gun free zones" are just signs, telling criminals "Defenseless Victim Zone". I'm not willing to be defenseless so that a judge can feel safe.
I said I was willing to bet. NOT that I guarantee anything. See, a bet is a wager, meaning, I'm willing to risk a loss. I believe I am right. Obviously, neither of us can prove the point. But hey, we're talking civilly, and having fun. Thanks!!
I am far more upset about the Patriot act and Rendition, then going through a metal detector, not that I am fond of those either. Read .And I often quote that same one by Ben Franklin on about this. To me, the issue isn't just guns, it's the whole shabang. 9/11 changed everything, including many of our liberties, those being two. As for what would have happened on those planes, well, I'm not convinced that if everyone was armed, it would have turned out very differently. As my mom always says, it looks good on paper, but in reality....
When someone wants to do harm, they will find a way. Look at TimMcVeigh.
you may be right about things, but one thing IS sure. I won't fly un-armed. I used to ALWAYS fly, armed with certain things that go through metal detectors. On Those 4 planes, The passengers were murdered twice. Once by terrorists, and once by their government. It is pathetic that 4 guys with box cutters took over a plane with over 40 decent Americans, because their government denied the law abiding citizens the means of self defense. Flight 93
Now to Gitmo, rendition, USA Patriot Act, TSA, DHS, etc. from my article "Whythe ZAP is so important", published here on NT-
For some reason, it would not return to regular spacing. So I continue here. George W Bush is the man who began REALLY nailing the Constitution into a casket. And one of the few things I actually supported BHO on was closing Gitmo, ending enhanced interrogations, the USA Patriot Act, rendition, and all that happy horseshit. None of which he actually did. he renewed the Patrot Act. Gitmo is still in operation. His precious "I got Bin Laden" is because of information tortured out of prisoners by the US, and our allies via rendition. What the so-called "War on Terror" has actually done is enabled the terrorists to win. What they don't like about America is our way of life. And, to combat them, we have surrendered it. And pitiful fools crow about how much safer we are now.
Now now now, don't lie- criminals have more rights than we do!!
You somehow got a double quotation going, and that is why it wouldn't revert back. It's all in the coding, which you can always check if you know how, byswitchingto HTML.
I agree with 100% of everything you said above. I am guessing that when you say you fly armed, it's not with a gun. I have often wondered why more folks didn't fight back. People tend to be sheep.
Max,
Don't lie. I saw you smile when you got groped the last time. But you did ask for the hot TSA agent... so that might have been one of the reasons.
You're so right. I just never thought about it before. I guess I'm just a dumb sheep, but I'm learning. lmao
I can reply no more on that guess of yours. As to sheep, at least on Flight 93, there were some sheepdogs. Unfortunately, the cops pulled their teeth!
Here's how I want to handle a TSA Sexual Assault Patdown.
I want to buy a SERIOUSLY oversized Dildo, and a couple of 10 inchers. Stuff the big one down my pants, where it can stand out. hang the other two in harnesses, under each arm. Like, say, a shoulder holster. Then, when the TSA scumbag starts hie grope, start doing Sally in the Deli . Then LOUDLY proclaim to all in earshot "You DEFINITELY want this guy- he gives GREAT patdown. (to him directly)Next time, I'll buy you a dinner first. You were marvelous!"
My wife won't let me.
You aren't a dumb sheep. You just never thought it out before.
C'mon, darlin', tell us how you REALLY feel! Stop holding back!
Robert,
To some point, I agree. But if I saw a person just armed with a box cutter, with an entire plane full of able bodied men, I would think someone would have stepped up.
Neale,
The only reason that flight 93 turned out differently, is that they were delayed and had heard about the hits on the WTC. They knew this was no ordinary hijacking and they knew that it could end ugly either way. There must have been something different about those people. They fought back even though they knew they could die.
I don't know, Perrie. I just know knives and me. A box cutter is NOT a particularly deadly weapon, short term. It is bloody as hell, but unless they are lucky enough to cut a throat (in a fight, very difficult), it is painful and bloody, but not too dangerous. I'm 6'3, 230. If four guys with boxcutters are at the end of the aisle, and 3-4 unarmed men are behind me, I will cheerfully charge 4 boxcutters, and do a flying tackle. Once in contct, bite, kick, and punch everything in front of me til it stops moving. It can't be worse than being stuck to a saddly for an hour by an arrow.
The individual is all there is. A group of individuals do NOT have more rights than a single person. RIGHTS ARE RIGHTS. Period. NO ONE has the right to strip rights from othersin the name of the public. So you are correct. It is all about each individual "Me". The smallest minority there is, being stomped on by a group. You are espousing "Might Makes Right". It's really that simple. And it's VERY rational. Just not to you.
At the gate, you present your weapon, and the ammo for same. Show that it is frangibles (airframe safe). Holster weapon, and proceed. As for bombs, x-raying luggage does the trick, if you think it's necessary. I don't.
Here's the simple point ALL of you seem to be missing. If a bomb goes off in a plane, sayonara passengers. All the guns in the world won't stop it. In 9-11, THERE WERE NO BOMBS! Don't you think every single one of those passengers would have willingly risked their getting hit with a stray to give them a chance to live? I sure as shit know I would risk it.
Okay, how about this. Two airplanes, side by side. One plane, everyone is strip searched, given surgical gowns, their luggage thoroughly disassembled and reassembled, and they file on the plane. The other plane, firearms are checked for frangibles and pased on. Which one do YOU feel safer on? (not that your "feelings" count towards infringing upon the rights of others). I'll be on the second plane.
Robert- I have two real solutions, involveing no weapons at all. Are YOU willing to try them?
Solution #1- The pilots are time-locked into the cockpit. NO entry or exit possible off the ground. Billy-Bob the White Supremacist (we'll use Achmed for the next one) stands up and yells "We are going to fly to Arya! WHITE POWER!!" Pilot John presses a button. The cabin floods with anesthetic gas. Passengers pass out. Plane lands. Cops either cut Bob's throat on the plane or take him to jail. Perhaps a passenger dies from a bad reaction to the gas. It would probably be me, because I have a bad reaction to anesthesia. Aspiration Pneumonia sucks, believe me! I'm willing to take that risk.
Solution #2. Get on the plane. Theflightcrewanesthesiologists set up the IV drip of Versed. You are conscious, but out of it. You don't remember the flight. 20 minutes prior to landing, they begin rousing you. Versed, via IV drip, does not pose the same threat of aspiration pneumonia, but it can happen there, too.
I'll accept either one. Will you?
Except for the principles (meaning everyone actually part of the trial), YES. Seriously.
As of now, we have reached the "Agree to disagree" stage. You ARE wrong, as far as I am concerned. I AM wrong as far as you are concerned. We ARE NOT going to agree. So, for now, I say "It's been fun and enlightening to me, hope it's been the same for you. Have a great Day!
No one has ever advocated drinking and shooting on this forum. Hell, I have one to two adult beverages a year. As to the rest of your comment, again, we are not going to agree.
As I said, we are NOT going to agree. You see the "rights" of a group as having precedence over the rights of an individual. I do not. Do not misunderstand me. A group I CHOOSE to subordinate myself to will get my wholehearted support, as long as it does not violate my core beliefs. Once it does, I leave the group. I will cheerfully CHOOSE to die to defend many groups- family, friends, community, and even country. AS LONG AS IT IS ME MAKING THE CHOICE FOR ME, I AM FINE WITH THAT. What I am NOT fine with is a group of people, deciding FOR me, that I do not have the right to defend myself in any situation. 10 individuals, acting as a group, do not have any more right to take one of my rights away from me thanI do to take the rights of the members of the group.
Democracy is based on the assumption that a million men are wiser than one man. How's that again? I missed something.
Autocracy is based on the assumption that one man is wiser than a million men. Let's play that over again, too. Who decides?
Robert A Heinlein
The same thing goes for rights.
Well, not liking planes OR drugs, I'd have to say we finally agreee on something!!
See again my last comment. The horse is dead. Stop beating it.
Mike- it will NEVER be enough. For two reasons. People like you and I are branded extremists for desiring to protect ourselves. So we will be laughed at ant scorned until it's too late, because...
The bureaucrats who run the various "security Bureaus (DHS, TSA, FBI, BATFE, DEA, NSA, CIA, etc) ALWAYS work to expand their purview. NO government "bureau" ever gets shut down. The most we ever see is "The responsibilities of the XYZ Bureau have been folded into the ABCDept. No government workers were harmed in the folding of this bureau."
NO ONE but "extremists" are willing to call Islam what it is. Christianity, 500+ years ago. Think The Spanish Inquisition, Crusades, the Auto Da Fe, etc. They are in a violent, expansionist phase. With no Martin Luther in sight to lead a reformation. The Taliban and Al Qaeda are the theological successors to Torquemada. Killing, torturing, and raping in the name of Peace and love.
Neale,
I cannot relate to this at all. I have not flown since a trip i took to NJ. I did watch a lil ol lady get molested by by tsa in an airport. She could not get through the metal detector without a walker. Now we watch our wives, daughters and mothers get oggled by the perv behind the screen? I agree with you fully regarding armed passengers. I would settle for any or all of the following though.
armed pilots.
each airline culpable for any violence on their property
Israelistyle airline defense with soldiers in plain clothes and uniformed. Since the airports are claimed by the fedguv, then they can protect them. If you run your own private (or corporate) airline, you handle security. I am not opposed to throwing violent passengers out of the door. It would take just a few episodes and the rest would behave themselves.
I am sure that we have similar procedures for court houses and such out here. i have never been there though. I might go just to see.
We have a list of businesses that do not allow open carry in them. WE DO NOT GO THERE. Now that constitutional concealed carry is the law of the land, there are no more (or less) arms in pants than before. Just IWB now instead of OWB, sort of.
Whom do i trust when i swim? It is me who checks the gear before i get in the water.
As to trusting aphysician, i have a choice ofphysicians. It is free will that i would engage them. Did you trust the lab tech that did the blood work on the heart? or the donor? No you desperately accepted theirs goods and services.You had not obligation to trust them.
Did Neale have the option of refusing invasion of his person or confiscation of his property? Not in this instance.
There is no middle ground, no negotiation of a right. It is not an obsession to demand that which is yours.Either you have it or you do not. Either you protect it or you give it up. Or you live somewhere that is harmonious with your beliefs...
Wyoming is too dry for me, but I confess to wanting to live free. I would be gone in a heartbeat, but Annette wants to stay. DAMNIT! Oh well, I'll just do what's necessary, and live the best I can.
I did NOT have a choice on whether to enter the building. I was REQUIRED to file a paper IN PERSON in order to get a squatter off of my property. I don't go to the Courthouse voluntarily. EVER. Unfortunately, if Ihad the nerve to show up armed, remove the squatter, and re-take posession of my property, I would be the one jailed. So I went.
As to swimming- I trust ME. I trust my family (2 lifeguards)
Doctors- the last one I "trusted" fucked up. I had a stroke as a result. Now, medically, I trust my wife (the RN).
In intimate situations, MY gun is in MY nightstand. My wife's is wherever SHE chooses to keep it.
I NEVER drink and drive. In fact, I usually am the DD. On the rare times I DO choose to drink, it's USUALLY in Vegas, and I walk on Fremont Street.
If I need a heart transplant, I'll find the best guy I can find, and not really have a choice. But I don't THINK that will be a problem I'll face. No history of heart disease in my family.
On yes, to those we VOLUNTARILY submit
what a pretty picture
Sadly and tragically, we live in a shit-world; but more armed individuals, while it may save some, the reality is, it will hurt or kill more than it will save.
Your Second Amendment rights were not abrogated, at least not based on your report ... your FIRST AMENDMENT RIGHTS (again, based on your report), in my opinion, were!
Don't misunderstand, I'm not anti-gun ... I'm anti lying a la the NRA, hyping fear to drive waning gun sales. For example, there is no "secret plan" for Obama to take everyone's guns ... but there is a secret plan to repeat that lie as it drives gun sales every time it's pitched. In fact, the Obama administration went to bat for former President Bush by defending his last-minute rule allowing loaded guns in national parks. And, if you'll check the record, you'll find that Obama has been silent and absent regarding gun control.
I personally don't want my family anywhere in public where there are people with guns; idealistic I know. And yes, criminals will acquire and carry guns regardless of laws designed to "prevent" gun violence. But here's the thing; laws aren't made to make things perfect ... they're made to try and make things better. So, in my mind, I'd like a law that says ANY CRIME(S) COMMITTED BY AN INDIVIDUAL(S) IN POSSESSION OF A FIREARM (LOADED, UNLOADED, FAKE, etc.), UPON CONVICTION, SHALL SERVE A MANDATORY, MINIMUM PRISON TERM OF NO LESS THAN FIFTEEN YEARS, THAT TERM IMPOSED OVER AND ABOVE THE TERM PROSCRIBED FOR THE ATTENDANT CRIME(S).
I am ok without searching anyone, I wont live in fear and wont die but once.I find it so much safer than the police state we have adopted..
Well, here we disagree on so many levels, but because I like you, Mac,
, I'll deal gently with you! LOL.
First on Obama and no plans- Barack Obama voted "present in the Illinois senate over 100 times, meaning "This isn't something I am for or against. He voted "YES" on a bill to make it a felony to use a legally licensed handgun in self defense. Right there, he proves his antipathy to gun owners.
The NRA is the Anti-Gunner's best friend. They have NEVER defeated a gun control measure. When the anti-gun crowd proposes to ban something, the NRA promptly proposes to amend the bill and proudly proclaims to the pro-gun crowd "See! They wanted to ban 9 types of hollow poit ammo, and WE, your faithful NRA, got it down to only 3! Send us money so we can continue to help erode your rights."
I personally don't want my family anywhere in public where there are people with guns; idealistic I know
Here's the point, and I don't mean to sound nasty. What you want or don't want is irrelevant when it comes to the rights of others. using that logic is how the Christian right managed to force anti-pornography laws on the public, blue laws, and other similar laws. "We don't want our children able to see pornography, so we are going to ban it for all!" We don't want people drinking on OUR day of worship, so we will ban the sale of alchohol on OUR holy day!" "We don't want people selling cars on our Lord's day, so we make it illegal to do business onr seventh of the week." It's not the idealism I object to. I'm an idealist myself. It's the incrementalism. EVERY TIME a right is infringed upon, to any extent, it can and will be used as justification to FURTHER infringe that right or as a precedent to infringe the next one.
And finally, your addendum to criminal laws (already on the books to some extent in many places, and supported fully by your "opponent", the NRA, I might add). It is as useless as the so-called "Hate crime" legislation. NOTE- STRONG LANGUAGE TO FOLLOW- IT IS NOT INTENDED TO INSULT ANYONE, IT IS FOR ILLUSTRATIVE PURPOSE ONLY. I DO NOT USE OR SUPPORT THE USE OF SUCH LANGUAGE IN ELSEWHERE.
If I were to call a person a nigger while beating them half to death, why does it make the crime worse? It doesn't. You don't beat a person half to death if you like them. Yet, if I am white, and beat a black man to death while calling him that, it is worse than if I beat a white man the same way. A "Hate" crime. I wonder, since many blacks in the lower socio-economic levels call each other "nigger", if a black man were to use that term while beating another black man half to death, would HE be charged with a hate crime? The point of all this? Increasing the penalty based on the TYPE of weapon used is as asinine as increasing the penalty because you call you victim "Nigger" rather than "Asshole". Armed robbery is armed robbery. It has 3 degrees. You show a weapon, you present the impression of having a weapon (hand in pocket, finger making a "barrel against the fabric), and the victim simply thinking you might have one. Whether the weapon is a knife, a rock, a stick, or a Glock, armed robbery is armed robbery. Just as a beating is a beating, whether you call your victim "nigger" or not.
Well, I've rambled enough for now, I'll let you read, ponder, and reply if you want to.
Hi Neale,
I'm going to interject here on hate laws. While I agree that calling someone a racist name while committing what would have been a crime anyway, still makes it that crime, hate laws serve a different purpose. It's really for when people are beingharassedfor being who they are. Cross burnings on front laws, houses of worship defaced, business defaced, threatening messages left on phones or by mail. These are the crimes that those laws are supposed to protect. Hate is an element that we shouldn't accept as a society. Beating someone to death because of who they are, is a totally different thing, than your example above, because the intent of the crime was different and our law goes to the intent, as much as the crime.
NRA Targets Obama
It falsely claims in mailers and TV ads that Obama plans to ban handguns, hunting ammo and use of a gun for home defense.
It falsely claims in mailers and TV ads that Obama plans to ban handguns, hunting ammo and use of a gun for home defense.
A National Rifle Association advertising campaign distorts Obama's position on gun control beyond recognition.
The NRA is circulating printed material and running TV ads making unsubstantiated claims that Obama plans to ban use of firearms for home defense, ban possession and manufacture of handguns, close 90 percent of gun shops and ban hunting ammunition.
Much of what the NRA passes off as Obama's "10 Point Plan to 'Change' the Second Amendment" is actually contrary to what he has said throughout his campaign: that he "respects the constitutional rights of Americans to bear arms" and "will protect the rights of hunters and other law-abiding Americans to purchase, own, transport, and use guns."
The NRA, however, simply dismisses Obama's stated position as "rhetoric" and substitutes its own interpretation of his record as a secret "plan." Said an NRA spokesman: "We believe our facts."
Perhaps so, but believing something doesn't make it so. And we find the NRA has cherry-picked, twisted and misrepresented Obama's record to come up with a bogus "plan."
Update, Sept. 29: The Obama campaign asked broadcasters to take down ads from the NRA, citing this article and a separate Washington Post article that called the ads misleading. The NRA attacked us on its Web site, claiming that we are neither impartial nor independent. We respond in the Analysis section.
Analysis
The NRA announced it will spend $40 million during this year's elections, including $15 million to portray Sen. Barack Obama as a threat to gun rights. The NRA has been circulating fliers and mailers that claim to be "Barack Obama's 10-Point Plan to 'Change' the Second Amendment." And on Sept. 22 reports surfaced that the NRA had launched TV ads in several key states, also attacking Obama. They are false portrayals.
The flier looks almost as though it comes from the Obama campaign. It uses the same color and font scheme as well as the campaign's sunrise logo. And on some points it is right; Obama has called for national legislation against carrying concealed firearms, and he would revive and make permanent the expired ban on semi-automatic "assault weapons," for example. On other points it exaggerates. Obama has spoken in favor of government registration of handguns, for example, but has not called for registration of all "firearms" including hunting rifles and shotguns. But the TV spots and fliers also make claims that are directly contrary to what Obama actually says about guns
As for ...
I don't know about "worse," but if such an event were not addressed as to the bigotry-driven probable intent, it would give a form of sanction and credibility to other lunatic-fringe bigots to join the "fun." I'll wager that with words alone, I could provoke you to violence -- and I don't see you as a lunatic ... as I commented earlier, "laws aren't made to make things perfect ... they're made to try and make things better ."
The answer to your question ...
... is YES!
You cannot discount individuals who self-loathe (for various reasons) their race, religion, gender ...
NOTE: We disagree, Neale, but this is a good and fair debate ... it bodes well for NT.
As to your note- we agree wholeheartedly. If you recall, we first met (and became friends) while argunig vigorously and politiley back on NV, before we were in KK!
Fair answer on the same-race question (And I hope you are correct that the charge would actually be added. I'm not sure you are correct, and I hope you'll forgive me if if I hope we never have the chance to find out
)
On Obama and guns- I hate to say this, but factcheck.org is NOT non-partisan. And I have seen their "facts checked" that are demonstrably false in other places. I can't consider their attemots to say that because, during a campaign, Obama said he "respects the constitutional rights of Americans to bear arms" and "will protect the rights of hunters and other law-abiding Americans to purchase, own, transport, and use guns." he actually supports the 2nd Amendment is reaching for it. I mean, does anybody actually think that campaign promises or statements are TRUE?!?! We BOTH know that politicians only lie when their lips move! And I will point out that that statement carefully ignores the part "and Bear" from the 2nd Amendment. Transport is not bearing arms. Nor is the 2nd Amendment about hunting at all. It does not, in fact, say "A well fed population, being necessary to the security of a free staate, the right of the people to hunt and kill game shall not be infringed".
Nor is the NRA!
Then just cite the anti-gun legislation he's ACTUALLY ADVOCATED OR INTRODUCED AS PRESIDENT ... you can't.
There isn't any.
(devil's advocate position)
Cross burning on private property of target is already several crimes- trespassing, destroying private property, and contributing to Global Warming.
Defacing houses of worship- already several crimes- vandalism, destruction of property, etc.
Threatening phone calls or mailings are already crimes. Threatenning violence is a crime whether the racial epithets are included or not.
Please do not think I am excusing hate as "not a problem". I just do not tolerate the concept of "thought", even reprehensible thought, as being a crime.
I never claimed the NRA is non-partisan. In fact, I have repeatedly called them the National Collaboraters Association, who use gun rights to collect money, then co-operate with the very people they claim to oppose.
I confess that he has yet to do much anti-gun. Except deny the licenses to re-import over 1 million WWII semi-automatic rifles and pistols, and support the UN's Small Arms Proliferation Treaty. Which is, I confess, enough for me to consider him the enemy of the 2nd Amendment.
Thought is not the crime ... adverse actions thus precipitated -- acted out as a physical manifestation of a (hateful) thought ... is a crime indeed ... in DEED!
Not exploring gun control? How about sending Hilary to the UN convention on small arms regulation? I cannot imagine any other reason she would be there.
Hitler was a reasonable man. Just ask Neville Chamberlain. The problem with "reasonable" is it usually means I give something up, and YOU take it. Then I give something up, and you take it. I prefer to be an unreasonable cantankerous son of a bitch who KEEPS what I have, and supports your right to do the same. I'm NOT willing to make others happy by surrendering MY rights. Now, to Hillarious Rotten Clinton.
Obama has to do NOTHING about gun control if he can get that treaty signed. Because he thinks the treaty can negate the 2nd Amendment without going through our Constitutional process to do it. Fortunately, he got shot in the ass this time. And next time it comes up, Hopefully we'll have a different president to NOT send our SecState to whore out American sovereignty to the UN.
There IS no other reason.
Let me be blunt here. I couldn't care less if the rest of the world considers it unreasonable to insist upon my right to posess and carry the means of self defense on my person at all times. People who wish to disarm decent individuals are not my friends OR eemies, but they ARE to be opposed. Just as they would need to be opposed if they felt it was "reasonable" to be stopped and frisked by passing cops because they just look "suspicious". Just as they would need to be opposed if they thought it was reasonable to require licenses to operate a computer connected to the internet. Just as they need to be opposed for denying homosexuals "permission" to marry.
Here's the difference between us, John. I support the rights of sapient individuals. ALL the rights. Not just the ones I like. My rights end at your nose, and your end at mine. You have every right to NOT own or carry a weapon. You have NO right to decide To remove MY right to own and carry arms. It is the right of every responsible individual to own and carry weapons, for defense of self and others. NO ONE has the right to use those arms to force others to complywith demands orsurrender property. And if the rest of the world considers that unreasonable, so be it. The "rights of the many" do not exist. Rights are individual only. 100 people do not have the right to decide a right they oppose must be stripped from 1 person. And each and every individual has the right to defend themselves from ALL aggression, by any means necessary, up to and including deadly force.
I understand that freedom and self reliance are anathema to you. And you have every right to state your case. But NEVER expect an individual who holds these words to be true to ever agree with you.
I know not what course others may take; but as for me, give me liberty or give me death!"
Stop ... Come on!
The actions of individuals or their failures to act are what determine "reasonable" or otherwise. Are you seriously willing to argue that because one man, or all of the Third Reich may have considered Hitler "reasonable," that the notion should even be considered?
Based solely on his record as President, with regard to gun legislation, Obama is the least anti-gun President in recent history signing ONLY ONE PIECE OF GUN LEGISLATION, that allowing guns in our National Parks.
Bad law IMO.
Regarding ...
I wonder how many have gotten their wish as the result of being murdered because someone exercised his liberty to own and use a gun ... in a moment of rage, while under the influence, when expression misplaced righteous indignation ...
I'm not opposed to gun ownership, but when the NRA makes it possible for some crazy without a criminal record, but who may be under the treatment of a psychiatrist, or, a member of a hate group ... to LEGALLY OBTAIN A FIREARM, a crazy who kills members of an ethnic group, a legislator along with a dozen other innocents ... a 9 year old girl (Giffords shootings), then the price of liberty is not just eternal vigilance, but the life of someone's child.
Beware of platitudes and slogans ... they sometimes kill ... like when a "reasonable" tyrant declares that he's come upon a "final solution."
That one killed 22 million.
Live by the sword, die by the sword, my friend; and that sword cuts both ways ... it's biblical and metaphorical as depicted thus ...
Neale wrote,
Yes and no ... laws apply to the many, those that give rights and those restricting rights in order to protect the rights of others. One's rights, as you said, Neale, ends at the nose of the rights of another. Laws are written not with the naive belief that they'll make things perfect, rather that they'll make things better. The NRA's making it difficult to determine who owns guns is not in the best interest of Americans, it's in the best interest of gun sales. Fear that such "reasonable" law will lead to the ease of government confiscation of guns is just that ... intentionally driven fear to obfuscate and frighten on behalf of gun dealers.
So, they aren't entitled to their Constitutional rights A.Mac?
Should the cops be able to search his house, his car, without a warrant, because he's under treatment?
Just wondering. Note also, it ain't the NRA, it's the Bill of RIGHTS!
Like so many who really don't believe in the Second Amendment, it's tough for you to understand that as a very clear (and singular, by the way) Amendment, it has, AT A MINIMUM, equal dignity with other amendments.
Most even argue it has a GREATER dignity/importance than those that come after, which I tend to agree with as well.
Note, as I've said so many times, and every damned lefty refuses to discuss the issues, is the way to stop crimes committed with guns is to strongly limit the 4th and the 8th amendments.
Fact is, A.Mac., most lefties don't give a shit about preventing gun crime, they just want to disarm the civilian population.
As I said, lefties just won't discuss actual reductions in gun crime.
Thanks for proving my point JR!
Note, what is your cut off for a "child?"
"So, they aren't entitled to their Constitutional rights A.Mac?"
"Should the cops be able to search his house, his car, without a warrant, because he's under treatment?"
"Just wondering. Note also, it ain't the NRA, it's the Bill of RIGHTS!"
Don't put words in my mouth, Terry ... houses and properties have to be registered ... owners known ... same with motor vehicles, dogs ... I haven't come close to "search and seizure," I only want the owners of firearms to be known as with other forms of real property.
I just don't want the tail wagging the dog particularly when the dog's bite can kill!
"Note, as I've said so many times, and every damned lefty refuses to discuss the issues, is the way to stop crimes committed with guns is to strongly limit the 4th and the 8th amendments."
Whoa! No generalization there ... you have the wrong lefty. I want common sense application of law ... not fear-driven bullshit that compromises the law and makes it a more dangerous country for me. I'm the "Law Abiding Citizen" and I don't like it when lobbies fuck with me.
"Fact is, A.Mac., most lefties don't give a shit about preventing gun crime, they just want to disarm the civilian population."
Fact is ... that's right-wing fear-mongering ... we've had this discussion before and either you're getting forgetful, or weren't paying attention. I'm not not gun, I'm anti NRA lies to drive gun sales.
_____________________
The damn text editor has been screwed up and I can't use the block quote feature so I put your comments in quotation marks. (It didn't make the any more sensible however).
A.Mac:
Houses and properties need to be registered? Tell me, what country you living in buddy?
In fact, that is just not true, not true at all.
I know you haven't come close to the 4th amendment, because, heaven forbid, that might actually be effective to deter violence committed with weapons!
And what about the 8th?
Fact is, and I ain't calling you a leftie A.Mac, lefties will not enter into this discussion because it is a losing one for them, period.
Their goal is NOT to rid us of gun violence, but to disarm the citizenry.
Why do you think that is?
Terry wrote,
So, no one pays property taxes because local governments have no way of knowing who owns what or lives where. What a schmuck I've been paying those taxes all these years ... and hey, my auto insurance company doesn't really know where I live, what I drive ... wow ... I'll save a load going forward.
Terry, maybe I'm not understanding your comment. What's a deed/title, etc. if not a form of ownership registration?
We had this very discussion in another thread.
4th Amendment ... I against "unreasonable searches," but think highly of "probable cause."
8th Amendment ... Let the punishment fit the crime ... I've never advocated anything else; now I might entertain "cruel and unusual punishment for cruel and unusual people," but if I did, I wouldn't be a leftie any more.
A.Mac:
Hate to tell you buddy, but registration of OWNERSHIP of property is not legally mandated. You are asserting that if you buy a gun you MUST register it. That is not true of real property, not true at all. Merely because the record owner is taxed does not mean that the "record" owner is, in fact, the true owner. One may deed one's house to another and the deed need not be legally recorded.
That's just the fact.
The 8th amendment issue, let's pass a simple rider to existing criminal laws, if you commit burgulary and have a firearm in the commission of the crime, then you go to jail FOR LIFE, no parole! Same with assault, etc.,etc. That would pretty much reduce gun violence. But that has been ruled unconstitutional (or laws like it, nowhere near as draconian by the way).
So, restrictions on amendments which are not even as important, Constitutionally, as the Second could solve/ameliorate gun violence but the left will not even consider them.
Why is it they ONLY go after the second amendment A.Mac, when it has been shown time and time again that restrictions do NOT lessen gun crime?
Answer? They wish to disarm the citizenry, not lessen gun crime.
I must respectfully disagree, A. Mac.
laws apply to the many, those that give rights and those restricting rights in order to protect the rights of others.
Lawsdo notgrant rights. The most they can do is codify rights. Rights are inherent in being a sapient individual. They most certainly do RESTRICT rights, should you be so inclined to follow them. But they grant nothing.
Whether the law says you can or not, you have an inherent right, as a sapient being, to defend your life from any and all attackers, using whatever means you deem necessary. The fact that Chicago has tried to make that a felony does not remove the right to defend yourself.
Whether the law says so or not, and even if the law denies you the ability, ALLsapient beingshave the right to express their thoughts and feelings via whatever form of communication they posess.
Whether the law says so or not, or even if it denies the ability, homosexual men, lesbian women, transgender people, polygamists, polyandrous, and any combination of these, have the right to love and marry whosoever they desire, as long as their mate/mates are consenting people, of the legal age.
I'll be honest. I'm a basically gentle guy. I don't want to fight anyone, and I actually don't even want to hang around a bunch of people. I have ZERO desire to ever have to defend my life against anyone. I have no desire to fight off government hooligans enforcing ridiculous incursions into my life. Msotly, I just ignore the rules I don't already live by BY MY OWN FREE WILL. Laws do not keep me from murdering. I keep me from violating the rights of others to live. Laws do not keep me from walking down the street beating people over the head. I keep me from doing that. Laws do not keep me from stealing. I keep me from stealing. And if you are honest with yourself, the same is true of MOST of us. At heart, every thing done, whether it is between reading Archie comics or Shakespeare's Othello, or whether it is between walking away from an annoying asshole or killing him, or even launching a nuclear missile, in teh long run it is the choice of one individual. Not laws.
So, in my life, I make choices. Follow this "law". Ignore that one. make my choice, take responsibility for my choice, and do it because it is what I choose to do. And understand that if the unwashed masses decide they hate my choices, they may well violate my rights in order to "enforce thier group rights" and "punish" me for my actions. I accept this, I try to make sure there are less and less things they may choose to force upon me, and I make the choices of what I will and will not do.
I understand that this attitude infuriates some, is incomprehensible to many, and is not the way many people look at life. But it is how life MUST be lived. Every single one of us does it, every day. It's just that most people don't even realize it. I do.
Was this understandable, or do you not even see my point? I actually DO want to know!
Owner of record is still the "registered" owner; real property and certain forms of personal property ... even dogs, are required to be licensed/registered/declared. How many "straw" purchased houses do you think there are?
On the letter of the law, I'll meet you part way ...
And ...
In Pennsylvania ...
So far, JR, you haven't embarrassed me! Perhaps, if you ever have a desire for a civil conversation (as A. Mac and I are doing right here) we can discuss things. But acting like an ass is not going to get anything out of me.
Indeed, laws do literally grant as well as restrict rights! I think we're disagreeing over terminology. Rights are granted ... not inherent as they are defined by law.
And here, you and I demonstrate the difference between OUR interaction and John Russel's interactions with me. Disagreeing respectfully.And in this one, we come to the core difference between us- the definition of a right. You see them as defined by laws, I see them as part of existance. I'm not sure you realize exactly what you have done here. And I hope, that after I point it out, you smack yourself in the forehead and say "Oh SHIT!! That pain in the ass is actually right to some extent!!" Are you ready for what that point is? Heeeerreeeesss The point!
Indeed, laws do literally grant as well as restrict rights! I think we're disagreeing over terminology. Rights are granted ... not inherent as they are defined by law .
That statement means that rights do not exist without laws. So, if there is no law prohibiting slavery, and I choose to make a person a slave, and they prove incapable of preventing me from doing so, they do not have the right to be free? If there is no law acknowledging that people have the right to live, then murder is not violating your right to live. Now, we BOTH know you didn't INTEND to say that. But that statement DOES mean exactly that- NO RIGHTS EXIST UNLESS A LAW STATES IT DOES. Since I believe you do not actually mean that, Would you care to either rephrase your statement or define what you REALLY meant?
Once a society introduces laws, then, by definition, rights will to one degree or another, delineate and define rights. Laws are subjective although they can be, and, ideally, should be IMO, utilitarian, humane, fair and enforced even-handedly.
I think you have the "slavery" example backwards. When the law allowed slavery, while it was LEGAL, it was, based on what is moral and ethical, WRONG and INHUMANE. Ditto for "THE LAW" under any government that is, by definition LEGAL, but, humanistically ... WRONG.
That which is legal isn't necessarily right by other standards. If we could reduce all law to the "Golden Rule," or even work towards such an objective, we might not be having this discussion.
Since no one yet has asked the question, even though at least one of you has harped incessantly on the point, I am forced to define a phrase for you all. I had HOPED someone would ask what I meant instead of assuming. Since no one did, I'll answer the unasked. For some reason, NO ONE has paid attention to the entire phrase that will be bold faced below.
Every Man, Woman, and responsible child has..............
What IS a responsible child? One of you almost touched on it. You asked (roughly) "What age do you stop being a child?" of another you were debating. So, what is a responsible child? There are two types. Neither acknowledged under today's laws.
First, and most probable type is a child (in relation to firearms, but it can be applied nearly everywhere by substitutiong a few words) who has been trained by his parents or a hired/volunteer substitute in firearms safety, handling, and conduct in living with firearms, and the parent says the child is now responsible.
The second type is actually sadder to see, but needs to be recognized by society. It is the child who has "divorced" their parents, and proven themselves capable of supporting themselves, standing to their debts, and who is the responsibility of no other person. Under todays half-assed laws regarding "majority age", you might declare people 18-21 "responsible children" because of the asininity of their status as halfway adult. In the days of old, children, at least male children, were adults when they went through a "manhood ceremony" be it a bar Mitzvah, or other ceremony. Girls were usually "women" when Daddy gave her to the husband he picked for her. And historically, until the early 1900s, a boy was a man when he shouldered a man's responsibilities, and a girl was a woman when she married, usually between 14 and 16 for both. Today, your children are not fully adfult and on their own till as late as 26, under law. (I'll explain that one as soon as someone either asks me what I mean, or posts the wrong answer, or at least one other than I meant.)
So, Mr. Russel, I am not actually advocating 7 year old kids roaming the street with a Beretta M93 machinepistol. But in your arrogance, you assumed you knew what I meant, and never even bothered to ask. Remember the definition of a stupid question? It's the one you DON'T EVEN BOTHER TO ASK!
So I guess no forehead smack? DAMN!!
So, here again weneed toclarify points/ideas. It still appears to me you are saying that laws define what rights are. "Once a society introduces laws, then, by definition, rights will to one degree or another, delineate and define rights." To me, the rights are not established or delineated. They simply ARE. what laws do is either protect rights (rarely) or limit orattempt to denythem (mostly). Note that I do not accept that laws actually have the ability to actually remove them, nor do I accept that by limiting/removing them as actually possible, moral, or acceptable. I am simply acknowledging what they try to do.
"Laws are subjective although they can be, and, ideally, should be IMO, utilitarian, humane, fair and enforced even-handedly." (will you PLEASE tell me how ro blockquote here? But I digress)
Ethical is a non-term. Ethics vary from society to society. As do morals. There is only one truly immutable "ethic". Preserve humanity. All else is defined by society. As we all know, today, we don't consider it ethical or moral to marry a 13 year old girl to a 40 yr old man here in the USA. Under Islamic law, it's fine. Hell, their founder married a 9 year old. And it was "ethical and moral" under their belief system. I have my system of morals and ethics. Some ingrained by my parents, many they do not approve of that I reached via reasoning. And I'm sure that you and I share some, and disagree on others. Yet I believe us BOTH to be moral and ethical people.
So, since laws CANNOT be moral and ethical for all, we need to define what they MUST BE/DO. You present a good start. But too many of the points raised are far too subjective.
Utilitarian. To whom? To what end? To ensure the government can function properly? To ensure that individual liberties be preserved? To ensure a large tax base? Too vague a term.
Humane. Again, by whose standards. Do (I hate to pick on them again, but they are very useful to illustrate an extreme) Muslims consider their Koran humane? Probably. But it defines the length and thickness of the rod you may use to beat your wife and where you may strike her. It defines which hand to cut off the first offender thief. It defines the punishment for adultery. Death by stoning for the woman, a stern "Behave, man!" for the man. Humane is another subjective term.
Fair. One man's "fair" is another man's "repressive". And I doubt even you and I will agree as to what is fair in 10 random instances, even totally ignoring firearms laws.
Enforced even-handedly. Here, we can totally agree. IF the law is acceptable, I want it to apply to all. no exceptions. No extenuating circumstances. Not sure it's POSSIBLE, but it's certainly something we can strive for. Well, my hand is getting sore. This is EXCELLENT therapy for my stroke weakened right hand, but I've had enough therapy for now. I look forward to your response. I am truly enjoying this debate, and I think we could make an excellent article with just the two of us, proposing anddefending, our positions, and picking apart the other's!
"Ethical is a non-term. Ethics vary from society to society. As do morals. There is only one truly immutable "ethic"."
Based on your statement, immutable and ethical are contradictory, since ethics and morals in fact vary from society to society.
Again, once a society codifies aspects of human behavior as "laws," rights are granted and, contrary to the Declaration of Independence, not thus inalienable. As laws are written, evolve and/or are amended, immutability by definition, is a concept, not a realizable entity.
And only had the Constitution not followed the Declaration, would there be totally or even partially inalienable rights.
"So, since laws CANNOT be moral and ethical for all, we need to define what they MUST BE/DO. You present a good start. But too many of the points raised are far too subjective."
I didn't say nor mean to imply that laws can't be moral or ethical depending on the culture involved, only that "legal" and "moral/ethical" are not necessarily synonymous.
"Utilitarian. To whom? To what end?"
Because utilitarian refers to what works best for the greatest number of people, the question defies answering. Of course it's subjective but so is the question, "how many angels can dance on the head of a pin."
And "fair" implies that which is applied evenly ... one set of rules for all ... that too could be turned subjective.
And again the difference between you and A. Mac. Not a tracedebate in you. It's your way or the highway. Well, I choose neither.
Yup. Let him have Chicago. A nasty place. Been there, hated it, don;t intend to return.
Anytime. I never advocated that CoC deletion the other day. I just ignore or respond as I see fit, and tell you to go away if I choose. But whether you actually go or not, I could care less.
i just caught up with the recent posts here and i gotta chuckle about some...
As to Neale and having 7 year olds walking down the street with machine guns...Yeah, we do that!
We start marksmanship training as soon as a youngster is old enough to carry a broom stick. If the child has presence of mind to know where the "muzzle" end of the broom is, he (or she) is old enough to game with us in paintball. Those that show good sportsmanship and safety get invited to the range and they are taught the basics. They are required to bring notebook and pencil for taking notes. After they learn the fundamentals, they train in an indoor laser range. Only when they have demonstrated unerring safety habits are they allowed to shoot on the live fire range. I know this sounds like a military academy, but it is how the youngsters graduate to harvesting their first deer or elk. A couple have gone on to military service (over my objections) and reported that they had the best training any soldier could get. We do not have machine guns for this, we DO go to the fire department every year and let the little ones shoot any MG they can control while shooting. So yes, we had a few 7-10 year olds shooting M1919s and G18s and Uzis.
As to registering property...my farm is titled, but not to me, my little ones are not registered with the state, hell i pick up their rabies and rattlesnake innoculation from the vets office on my way home from work and administer the shots myself.
Why is it we have the least regulation of firearms in the uSA and the lowest violent crime rate?
Some of you good folks have lived in the moral squalor of a malevolent parens patriae society, that you can no longer fend for yourself.
Mr Russell, C'mon up, we are waiting for you toembarrassus. Make that the first weekend in june and i will sponsor you and your children at the shoot. I will enen introduce you to Dave, the ATF officer.
Mr Macarthur, Who determines what a "radical" is? Terrorist and freedom fighter describe the same man from opposing viewpoints. i have never committed anunprovokedact of violence, but have been ready all my adult life to prevent or interrupt others from doing so. In a couple of times that has happened.
Neale,
I just got an update on the courthouse. No metal detectors. However, the city council has recently mandated that the council meetings be attended only by members of the disarmed victims league. GO figure...
As I said, "Except for the principles (meaning everyone actually part of the trial), YES. Seriously."
And as I ALSO said, "there is no safety anywhere. Now, in an ideal world, there might be a way to prevent all murders. But "gun free zones" are just signs, telling criminals "Defenseless Victim Zone". I'm not willing to be defenseless so that a judge can feel safe."
Think of it. With the exception of the Giffords shooting in Arizona (by a mentally diseased person, NOT a TEA Party member as the media tried to insist), not one mass shooting has taken place where firearms carry is permitted. NOT EVEN FT HOOD!! On an ARMY BASE the soldiers were prohibited from posessing the arms we spent months and millions training to shoot, and who all had weapons they COULD have carried, were in a gun free zone. 13 victims dead, dozens wounded. Except for the mentally deranged Jared Lee Loughner, EVERY SINGLE MASS SHOOTER, EVEN IN STATES WHERE CONCEALED CARRY IS PERMITTED, CHOSE A "GUN FREE" ZONE TO RAMPAGE IN!!!
Courthouses have seen their share of gun violence. Scanning hasn't kept out criminals OR legitimate gun owners when they are determined to carry. Here's the problem. With less than 20 minutes of work each I can easily get guns through the "security" of our courthouse if I were so inclined. Which I am not, because I value my freedom should something untowards occur. Except when compelled by law to go there, I simply do not go. And if you want my honest opinion, I think that is exactly the goal of these checkpoints. To keep those who believe in fredom away, and to allow the sheeple free (but well screened) access to their masters.