Obama Addresses Speculation in the Oil Markets
This morning, our President announced a few proposals to increase the oversight of the commodities markets. Before I address those proposals, I think it's important to take note of the fact that speculation exists in every market known to man. There are some negative attributes to speculation, but there are far more positive ones to take note of. I believe the speculators are being scapegoated because of the current level of energy prices, when there are far more obvious reasons.I also take note of the absence of CREDIT given to the speculators when the price of oil dropped to $40/barrel four years ago. We take the good with the bad, and try not to manipulate markets with regulation. On to his points:
1)Increased funding for the Commodity Futures Trading Commission
Good move. The commodity markets have grown far larger and more sophisticated in recent years. They've been underfunded for years. It's about time.
2)Increased penalties for market manipulators
You cannot make the penalties harsh enough. The death penalty should be leveled at these people. They're the scum of the earth, and should be treated as such.
3)Increased margin requirements
This is a dangerous move, and should not be considered. An increase in margin requirements will reduce liquidity, and make the markets more volatile. There's enough going on already thatcontibutes to volatility in commodities. Weather, natural disasters, war and disease are enough, thank you.
4)Reserve requirements for traders
Duh. They already have to have their own money on deposit.
The commodities market is a very efficient market. If you want the price of something to drop, all you have to do is make more of it. The price of many of our food commodities has dropped over the last 50 years, when adjusted for inflation. The price of oil is manipulated, for sure. But that's because there's a cartel out there, setting prices. When we break the cartel, the price will gravitate to its fair price. But that creates a completely new discussion, now doesn't it?

The sad part is that we've been relegated to tiptoeing around OPEC.
OPEC, the TRUE manipulators of the price of oil, gets a pass on all of this. We've got to produce more of our own energy to render them irrelevant. We've got enough natural gas in North America to fuel cars for 1,000 years. We've got to stop using the oil. That'll drop the price quick enough.
[[3)Increased margin requirements
This is a dangerous move, and should not be considered. An increase in margin requirements will reduce liquidity, and make the markets more volatile. There's enough going on already that contibutes to volatility in commodities. Weather, natural disasters, war and disease are enough, thank you.]]
Indeed . In the oil markets in particular volatility is now inevitable . It is extremely dangerous to mess with the already dangerous levels of volatility .
[[ 2)Increased penalties for market manipulators
You cannot make the penalties harsh enough. The death penalty should be leveled at these people. They're the scum of the earth, and should be treated as such. ]]
I don't think I'd go that far . But there should be severe penalties .
Yes, I remember your article. Very stimulating. What was not addressed in either of our pieces was the bipartisan nature of the graft collected by previous members of governmentin the form of "consultant" positions for OPEC nations and major oil producers. From the House, all the way to the Executive branch, there continues to be gladhanding. I don't think you can turn government over quickly enough to break this malignant chain.
Info on the graft would make a really great article . Are you up for it [if you have some time to devote to it] ?
Oy.
I just got back in the pool. That's a bear of a report. If I justfocused on the Executive branch, it would probably be easier, and enough of an eye-opener to get the point across. Do you knowwhodid the bulk of the funding for Jimmy Carter's library?
I know nothing about pres libraries ... Was it someone we both know ?
There is a real difference . Speculation is legal . Manipulation is not . I expect Jonathan would have a better explanation than I . But manipulation amounts to controlling the price by temporarily controlling supply . The only case I am familiar with involved controlling the supply at one particular pipeline terminal .
Manipulation is straightforward. It is very difficult to do, unless you've got an incredible amount of money or, in the case of OPEC, influence and control of the commodity in question.
Speculation is an integral part of all free markets. In the case of the current Admistration, it is being used as another vehicle in the populist philosophy.
When the housing bubble burst, a number of speculators made several hundred million dollars via CDS (credit default swaps). It was a bet that they made, and they won. This was met with disdain from many populist quarters as "succeeding on the back of failure". The fact is, these people did not take anything from anybody's pocket. They were rewarded for being on the right side of the trade.
Large crowds of speculators on one side of a trade can push the price in their direction, but only in limited circumstances. Oil commodity trading is one of those. Some estimate that it adds $4 to the price of oil. Some estimate far larger numbers. There is no calculus behind their estimates; they're pulling numbers out of their ass. That said, there can be short, SMALL swings over short periods of time where the price of the commodity is out of whack.
Bottom line:
The "speculator" debate is a distraction from the real problem, that being a cartel controlling the price of a commodity. It's illegal in this country, and amoral in humanity.
Tina ,
Here is a link to an actual charge levied for oil price manipulation .
http://money.cnn.com/2011/05/24/markets/oil_price_speculation/index.htm" target="_blank"> ...
They actually bought quantities of oil and attempted to temporarily corner the market at that pipeline termination point . Then they cashed in by buying shorts and dumping their massive holdings simultaneously . Notice how that differs from just trading commodities . It involved a conspiracy to manipulate prices in one particular location .
I also remember the Hunt brothers silver fiasco . Are you sure they were charged ? From what I recall they were not charged because their attempt to corner the market did NOT work . In fact they ended up losing the family fortune that way . If you want more details I can make an attempt but no promises of accuracy .
If you look at the link I posted below
you will see the following excerpt :
[[ The price of crude during the months of the alleged misdeeds changed very little, generally staying within a $10 range but the traders made their money off the daily fluctuations. Crude traded at $99 a barrel Jan. 2, 2008, and ended March 2008 at $101 a barrel. ]]
Notice that they made their profits by day trading . It is not possible for anyone but OPEC to have a major effect on the large , long term price changes .
It could not be a private entity, but it could be a GROUP of private entities. If the majors (Exxon, BP, Phillips, et al) colluded, they certainly produce enough on a daily basis to wreak havoc with pricing.
Yes, that would be collusion.
And I think we can agree that this did not affect the price at the pump.
OK ,
Thanks for the info . Those Hunt brothers got a double whammy against them .Their trading scheme didn't work and on top of that they were fined . Talk about your major bad day ...
Excellent article Jon. I think that this demystifies terms and what policy means in context in free markets and oil. The real problem is OPEC and no speculation. Also toss into that, that China and India are now using increasing amounts of crude. Demand is sure out doing the present state of production.
Mike ,
The key is to time the legislation for when prices are likely to drop of their own accord . That way it gives the appearance of working ...
RG,
Applying your "defense" of Saudi Arabia's market manipulation, we could take a look at wheat. The US, by far, is the largest producer of wheat.We don't even need a cartel to manipulate prices; indeed, we produce enough on our own to fix a price. But we don't. We allow the free market to determine the price, based upon supply and demand. The upside to oil manipulation is that, when the house of cards finally topples, the cartel members will once again be relegated to their tents, never to impact my life again.
[[Open the pipeline, Bams. Drill. Mine. Yes, get that Natural Gas. Steady, and quantity, are the things that do the most to reduce speculation influences, and speculation interests. Purposely impeding energy supplies keeps people close to panic mode, ripe for speculation panic. ]]
So that's your solution ... drill baby drill ? Nice McCain thinking there . Let's get Sarah Palin back on the ticket !
[[ First, as far as speculation and manipulation, it is a lot harder to do if you are not dependent on single sources and bottlenecks. Right now, all it takes is a despot having a bad hair day to cause price fluctuations much greater than speculators or manipulators here can do. ]]
Agreed . But right now the problem is that we are at peak oil .
[[If you are irritated at my CO2 attitude]]
Actually I don't care about CO2 levels . But I do care about peak oil .
Do you have any idea how disastrous it would be if our transportation infrastructure collapsed due to lack of fuel ? We need to get the hell off of oil ASAP .
Actually , to be more precise , we need to find substitutes for oil ASAP .
Rich,
We HAVE found a substitute, at least for commercial and passenger vehicles and power plants. It's NATURAL GAS, and between the US and Canada, we've got a supply that will last several hundred years. What's more, the equivalent price in gasoline terms is in the area of $2.50/gallon.
I'd like to remind you of one other benefit of drill, drill, drill. As previously mentioned, we've got peak oil and environmental issues, but how does the long-term degradation of the planet compare to the short-term degradation of the planet when all of these OPEC nations spend their riches on nuclear warheads? The sooner we render these nations irrelevent, the sooner we eliminate the short-term danger, and the sooner we can address the long-term danger.
Yes NATURAL GAS is a substitute but only if your vehicle has been designed or modified to run on it . Most cars won't . There is only one US car made to run on nGas . It is made by Honda and it would satisfy neither the performance requirements nor the range requirements of most US drivers . It is also dangerous because of the possibility of explosions during a collision or even when filling up the tank .
Drill all you want . But all of the easy to get oil has already been gotten . That's why they have to resort to things like deep sea drilling and fracking . The cheaply priced oil is running out and there is no reason to
expect that will change any time in the future . [There may be one exception to that but it is an unknown .]
To sum up , the immediate future of US transportation will almost certainly involve nGas . It will probably start in the trucking industry since there is plenty of room to put in compressed storage tanks . Cars don't have all of that room .
Rich,
There are already a number of commercial vehicle fleets that run on nGas. As far as the dangers you mention, there is always innovation and improvement. The battery on the electric car has done quite a bit of shrinking in the last few years. There's no reason to think that they won't improve the nGas systems.
As far as the dwindling supply of oil, there are circumstances beyond our control, and we've got to adjust. The developing nations are increasing their consumption of oil every year, at far greater ratesthan we are. We are ahead, but they are charging fast.
The reason why we drill in deep water is because of the restrictions in drilling in shallow water. This, as you know, was outlawed. It is far safer to drill in shallow water, for reasons that I don't need to explain to you (because you already know). Shallow water drilling is something that needs to be reconsidered.
[[As far as the dwindling supply of oil, there are circumstances beyond our control, and we've got to adjust.]]
Indeed . That is the reality of the global economy as you said .
[[ As far as the dangers you mention, there is always innovation and improvement. ]]
It's possible but I wouldn't hold my breath . Unless they can come up with something other than high pressure storage tanks there will be no way to avoid the potential for explosion .
As to the trucking industry , the short term reprieve from converting all the trucks to nGas is very helpful .
I recall a figure of 23 % for the US transport fuel usage for trucking . That much reduction in consumption of gasoline/diesel would be a real benefit . Bit it may be more complicated than that . Trucking currently uses diesel fuel . If the refineries stop producing diesel it should help to produce more gasoline but probably not 23 % more .
[[ The reason why we drill in deep water is because of the restrictions in drilling in shallow water. This, as you know, was outlawed. ]]
Actually , that is a deficit in my knowledge . Please expand on that .
After the Gulf spill, shallow water drilling was banned. I don't know why they would do that, as the BP spill was in veeeeeeeeery DEEP water. Nonetheless, that's what happened, and the decision has not at this time been reversed.
[[ I don't know why they would do that ]]
I do . Florida depends on its GoM beaches to attract tourism . That is a big industry there .
Rich,
You can find shallow water 50 miles off the coast. That's past the horizon. Out of the line of sight.
If you are expecting me to defend the regulation , I'd have to decline , if only because I don't know the details of the regulation .
You could be right about the extent of shallow waters but that still doesn't mean there isn't a risk to the GoM beaches at 50 miles out .
Mike ,
You are forgetting the women vote .
The woman vote has nothing to do with looks. It's issue driven, just like you guys.
1) Peak oil = impending doom.
Yes , but not inevitable doom . What may happen is Obam may end up backing away from the ban on shallow water drilling . But to expect him to do that before the election is to expect political suicide from him . Not gonna happen ...
[[ It is impending doom, or it is not, Rich. ]]
Although that was a rhetorical question I'll answer it anyway . It's like when James Bond is strapped to a table where the evil villian has the laser about to cut him in half . Is it impending doom ? It would be if Bond does not come up with a successful plan to escape .