We Can’t Predict Who Will Commit a Mass Shooting
As a shaken President Obama put it in his address Thursday night , the reaction to yesterdays mass murder at Umpqua Community College has taken a sickeningly familiar course: Somehow this has become routine, he said. The reporting is routine. My response here at this podium ends up being routine. The conversation in the aftermath of it. We've become numb to this. He argued, as he has with increasing forcefulness over the course of his presidency, that gun control needs to be a big part of the solution. The United States of America is the one advanced nation on Earth in which we do not have sufficient common-sense gun-safety laws even in the face of repeated mass killings.
It would be nice to think we could sidestep the gun-control issues given the vehemence of the anti-gun-control lobby. That was the story I hoped to write today: Knowing what we know about the impossibility of passing any significant gun-control legislation, at least given the current incarnation of Congress and the current strength of the National Rifle Association, what else can we do about mass shootings? How can we better predict them, in a behavioral sense?
I reached out via email to Dr. Paul Appelbaum , a Columbia University psychiatrist who specializes in researching attacks like yesterdays. He responded bluntly: When I heard the news of the Oregon shootings, I thought, Im done talking to reporters about the causes of violence . Instead, he said hed prepared a one-size-fits-all statement for the media that concluded, If you tell me that theres nothing we can do about guns, Id say then were done. Weve conceded that we are willing to tolerate periodic slaughters of the innocent. Theres nothing more to say."
The problem, as he explained in a follow-up phone call, is that any attempt to predict who is most likely to commit a mass shooting and therefore prevent it runs up against the fact that these events are extremely rare, and as a result have only the broadest, least useful risk factors associated with them. (Mass shootings are generally defined as shootings in which four people or more die in a public place, and Appelbaum explained that stranger mass shootings like the one that occurred yesterday have somewhat different behavioral pathways as compared to multiple murders of, say, family members or co-workers, which are far more common events that dont seize national attention quite as strongly as seemingly random ones.)
The risk factors that are linked to these events basically, being an angry young man are so widespread in the population, he explained, and so weakly predictive of an individual actually committing a mass shooting as to be practically useless. The answer is yes, at least of the most highly publicized, most fear-inducing cases of stranger shootings, by and large they are angry young men, said Appelbaum. But that doesnt get you very far, because there are a lot of angry young men who are angry for all kinds of reasons, and unless one wants to lock them all up or put them all under 24-hour surveillance, its really impossible to build on a description that general to come up with effective preventative approaches.
Once you move past that incredibly broad category, he explained, youre really into murky territory where youre identifying categories that some people fall into and others dont, he said. Take mental illness: While more and better-funded treatment for mental illness is obviously a good thing, Appelbaum said it just doesnt have much of a direct connection to mass shootings. Sometimes mass shooters have a history of mental illness, but [l]ots of people who commit mass killings are not mentally ill in any classical way, Appelbaum said, noting that he wished Obama hadnt mentioned mental illness in his address last night.
Appelbaum also said he didnt take cultural explanations for mass shootings all that seriously. There have been commentators who have written for years about the peculiar violence-prone aspects of American culture, which they trace back to the frontier or even earlier. These ideas are interesting in a descriptive sense, but I dont think they tell us much about what we should be doing about the problem. Because changing the influence of 400 years of American culture is even harder than doing something about reducing the number of guns in circulation.
As Appelbaum sees it, despite the endless, whirling conversations about the causes of mass shootings, theres just no serious approach to the issues that doesnt involve gun control. He mentioned that, despite widespread beliefs otherwise, there actually arent major differences between the overall rates of violence in the U.S. as compared to the rest of the developed world. Where the U.S. differs is in the number of homicides , and to Appelbaum that is largely attributable to the free flow of powerful guns. Every country has its angry young men; every country has various cultural forces that likely exacerbate violent peoples grievances; not every country makes it easy for anyone to get a gun. Some countries, like Australia, reacted forcefully to mass shootings by restricting the availability of powerful weaponry, and Appelbaum thinks the data is clear that these approaches work (Margaret Hartmann dug into the debate behind the Australian and British reactions to mass shootings Thursday ).
Appelbaum made it clear he didnt see gun control as an instant panacea. I dont think anyone could say honestly that if we tighten up on the availability of guns and the ease of purchasing them, and reduce the number of weapons that are largely produced to kill large numbers of people, that the problem will go away completely, he said. I dont think it will go away completely there will be some people who will be able to get their hands on guns and be able to do horrible things with them. On the other hand, the harder we make it, logic and the Australian experience certainly suggest, the fewer such episodes there will be. So perfect safety is, Im afraid, unobtainable in this world, but that doesnt mean we cant start making the situation better by just making it harder and having fewer guns in circulation.
The depressing thing about Appelbaums argument is that the underlying idea well likely never be able to predict who will commit a mass shooting isnt new to experts. He sent me to a Psychiatric Services article by a colleague, Dr. Jeffrey W. Swanson of Duke University , in which Swanson made the same points. Profiles of mass killers suggest that they tend to be troubled young men, he wrote in 2011 . This does not tell us which one of the very large population of troubled young men in the world will become the next mass killer; the vast majority of them will not.
Appelbaum and Swanson and other researchers, then, are forced to repeatedly re-debunk an idea that, in their minds, already has been shown to not make much sense an idea that reporters and others grapple with only because a much simpler, more clear-cut solution has been deemed impossible for political reasons. Its no surprise theyre frustrated.
- - - - - - - - - -
We Cant Predict Who Will Commit a Mass Shooting. Gun Control Is the Only Way Out.
By Jesse Singal

Mass murders are committed by angry men. There is no narrower descriptor.
There are millions of angry men.
We cannot identify the shooters before they act.
Any time spent chasing this chimera is wasted.
So we have two options:
1) we control weapons that are always used in these crimes.
2) we accept all future transformations of innocents into shredded corpses
Talking about "behavior" is a coward's way of avoiding the real topic.
Sure you can - a Democrat -
We don't have to put a gun in evil's hand.
So now you'll try to shift the conversation to politics. You'll do anything, anything at all, to avoid the obvious topic:
The shooters are called "shooter" because all American mass killings are shootings.
With guns.
As usual, you are very careless.
-
The idea that recent mass shooters are mostly registered Democrats is a myth
Based on the assertions of Roger Hedgecock a right-wing radio show host, the meme that the five worst recent mass shootings were committed by registered Democrats is making its way through e-mail chains and social media. Hedgecock asserts, without providing any evidence or sources, that the Ft. Hood shooter, the Virginia Tech shooter, the Aurora Theater shooter and Adam Lanza of Sandy Hook infamy were all registered Democrats. He acknowledges that Klebold and Harris (the Columbine Colorado shooters) were too young to be registered voters but asserts, again without providing any evidence, that Harris and Klebolds parents were progressives or liberal Democrats. All of these charges are utterly baseless and perhaps do not even deserve a response. However, given the effectiveness of right-wing lies in saturating social media and duping the incurious (a far too numerous segment of the population), some more detailed debunking is in order.
To the best of my ability, I have attempted to research these claims with as much rigor as possible. If there is any evidence for or against my debunking, I welcome that evidence in the spirit of free inquiry. Let me also state that given that neither major political party condones mass shooter violence in any way, shape or form, and that all these acts are individual acts of violence that are not sanctioned by either elected Democrats or Republicans (at least not mainstream leaders in either party), the very notion that they are acting on behalf of a political party is itself problematic. This is not to say that mass shootings are apolitical acts, but rather it is to say that as political acts they may express an ideology (racism, misogyny, entitlement, psychosis, etc) but they do not in general express alignment with a political party or if they do it is not an association that the Democrats or Republicans would accept as legitimate (neither party wants to claim James Holmes or Adam Lanza as a member in good standing, no matter what Holmes or Lanza feels about them). In any case, we can categorically REJECT the notion that any of the shooters in question has been shown to be a registered Democrat on a case by case basis.
1. Nidal Hasan (the Ft. Hood shooter) lived in either Virginia (his state of residence prior to being sent to Ft. Hood) or Texas, neither of which has partisan registration. Therefore the claim that he was a "registered Democrat" is false. I do not know if he voted or how he voted, but I do know that unless he was registered in a state in which he did not reside, that the claim that he is a registered Democrat is FALSE.
2. Since Virginia does not have partisan registration there is also no way to tell whether Seung-Hui Cho was a Democrat, but again because there is no partisan registration in the state we can say that the claim that he is a registered Democrat is FALSE . (Update: A more obvious point is that Cho was a resident alien, not a US citizen, so he was not eligible to vote in the US)
3. The false allegation that James Holmes was a registered Democrat was based on a Breitbart blogger named Joel Pollack, who found voter registration records for a DIFFERENT James Holmes who was approximately the same age as the shooter James Holmes. Alex Jones Infowars and other right-wing websites then incredulously repeated the false information without verifying it. It was later determined that the Colorado Theater Shooter James Holmes was NOT registered to vote, as evidenced by this retraction: {Newly-released information on the suspects birthdate (which, as indicated in our initial report, was a slight mismatch), combined with new details Breitbart News has obtained about the suspects likely addresses, together suggest that the suspect may, in fact, not have been registered to vote.}. However, most conservative bloggers continued to promote the lie without printing the Breitbart site's retraction. The claim that James Holmes was a registered Democrat is FALSE .
4. The claim that Adama Lanza is a registered Democrat has been suggested based not on any evidence that he was registered as one, but on the rather dubious claim that because Connecticut has almost 2 to 1 Democratic registration over Republicans, he was probably a Democrat. (Claim: "Adam Lanza, NewtownConn murderer. Registered Democrats outnumber Republicans by about a 2-1 ratio in Connecticut. The odds are therefore that the Lanza family are (sic) Democrats.") This of course is a bogus argument to begin with, but even if we were to make the claim that a mass shooters political affiliation must be the same as the majority of the people in his area, we can debunk this foolish idea by taking this shoddy analysis down to the local level. Yes, Connecticut voted for Barack Obama, BUT the city of Newtown voted for Mitt Romney . If we look at the results we find that Mitt Romney defeated Barack Obama in Newtown by 7451-6784 votes or 51.7 percent to 47 percent. Republican Senate candidate and Tea Party favorite Linda McMahon carried the city over Democrat Chris Murphy by an even larger margin. Add in the other information we have that Lanzas mother was a doomsday prepper and a home schooler in a Republican-leaning city and we can pretty well dispense with the erroneous assumption that Lanza must have been a Democrat (UPDATE: According to at least one media source , Nancy Lanza was a registered Republican. The source does not provide a link, but the author of this article is seeking further confirmation) . We can therefore claim that with no evidence to support the claim, the assertion that Lanza was a Democrat is not demonstrated and that in the absence of any evidence it is likely FALSE .
5. Klebold and Harris of course were not old enough to vote and they had no apparent political affiliation. Allegations that they came from families of Democrats or liberal progressives appear to have no sources to substantiate those claims. What little ideology the boys demonstrated owed mostly to an admiration for Timothy McVeigh not Ted Kennedy. Harris father was a retired Air Force pilot and Eric Harris wanted to join the Marine Corps. The boys lived in Littleton, Colorado a relatively conservative and affluent suburb of Denver. The claim that their parents were Democrats is UNSUBSTANTIATED. Any suggestion that the two boys were Democrats is demonstrably FALSE .
Interestingly, Hedgecock and those on the far right have conveniently overlooked a number of cases where ideology is clearly right-wing. The acts below are instances of right-wing violence that are unequivocally committed by people who are openly hostile to liberalism. While this does not mean these killers are Republicans, it is quite clear that they are RIGHT-WINGERS and that they have far more in common with Mr. Hedgecock, Alex Jones and the other gun-toting conspiracy nuts on the right than with any evils associated with the Democratic Party or liberalism. In addition, to the list below is the obvious case of Timothy McVeigh, who I have not included because his crime was not committed with firearms. It was however, committed by a right-winger and the carnage was on a massive scale.
For example, on July 18, 1984 James Oliver Huberty, who told his wife he hated children, Mexicans and the United States opened fire inside the McDonalds Restaurant in San Ysidro, CA using a Browning P-35 Hi-Power 9mm pistol, Winchester 1200 pump-action 12-gauge shotgun, and an Israeli Military Industries 9mm Carbine (Uzi) all legally acquired. He killed 21 and injured 19 before he was shot dead by police.
On Aug. 10, 1999 White supremacist Buford O. Furrow, Jr., fired 70 rounds with an Uzi-type submachine-gun inside the lobby of the Jewish Community Center in Granada Hills, CA wounding three children, a teenage counselor and an office worker. He then carjacked a womans Toyota at gunpoint, dumped it behind a motel and murdered US Postal Worker Joseph Santos with a Glock 9mm handgun.
On July 27, 2008 Former U.S. Army private, Jim David Atkinsson, who hated Democrats, liberals, African Americans and homosexuals, using a Remington Model 48 12-gauge shotgun, murdered two people and injured seven others inside the Tennessee Valley Unitarian Universalist Church in Knoxville, TN.
The day after Obamas inauguration, white supremacist Keith Luke went on a killing spree in Brockton, Massachusetts. His goal was to kill as many Jews, blacks and Hispanics as possible. When questioned by investigators, the deranged gunman who had stockpiled hundreds of rounds of ammunition, proclaimed that he was fighting the extinction of the white race.
A little over a month later, Dannie Baker, a former Republican campaign volunteer shot five Chilean immigrants in Florida. Those who knew him said he was obsessed with the fear that illegal immigrants were taking over the country.
In April of 2009, Richard Popalowski, a white supremacist in Pittsburgh, shot and killed three police officers following a domestic disturbance call. He apparently thought that Obama was part of a government conspiracy to seize all guns, and he feared the government would take his guns away.
Later the same month, a Fort Walton Beach Florida man who thought the Obama administration was conspiring against him , shot and murdered two sheriffs deputies.
On May 31, 2009 Dr. George Tiller was murdered in his own church by a right-wing pro- life gun man who decided to express his belief in the sanctity of human life by executing a medical doctor.
Eleven days later a right-wing white supremacist and Holocaust denier walked into the National Holocaust Museum and killed an African-American security guard. Two weeks later, three Neo-Nazis were arrested for bombing a diversity office in Scottsdale, Arizona.
On April 20, 2010 a member of the Sovereign Citizen movement was arrested after a failed attempt to take over a Tennessee county courthouse.
Exactly one month later, in West Memphis Arkansas, Sovereign citizens Jerry and Joe Kane murdered two police officers before they themselves were shot and killed in the ensuing shoot out with police.
On July 18, 2010 Byron Williams, an angry unemployed man, was arrested by police after they discovered a car full of weapons and ammunition that he had planned to use to kill progressives . He was on his way to the non-profit Tides Foundation Center, a favorite target of vitriol from Glenn Becks radio show.
On Jan. 8, 2011 22-year old Jared Lee Loughner killed six people, including a judge and a nine-year old child, and wounded 13 others, including U.S. Rep. Gabrielle Giffords (D-AZ) , using a 9mm Glock 19 pistol during a public meeting in a supermarket parking lot near Tuscon, AZ.
On Aug. 5, 2012 Wade Michael Page, a 40-year old white supremacist and U.S. Army veteran murdered six people and wounded four others inside a Sikh Temple in Oak Creek, WI with a Springfield XD(M) semi-automatic pistol.
Excellent!
"Maybe it's the... " whatever... that is the cause...
But the tool is always the gun.
Excellent.
1st warrior's link
Claim - Jared Lee Loughner was a registered Democrat
fact -
Jared Lee Loughner was a registered independent
"Suspected Tucson gunman Jared Lee Loughner registered as an independent voter in Arizona .... Loughner's decision to affiliate as an independent rather than a Republican or Democrat would seem to affirm the sense that while he targeted Giffords in the attack, it was not a decision born of a set of deeply held political beliefs that fit neatly into either party." ...
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Claim - Maj Nidal Hassan was a registered Democrat
fact- "Hasans voting habits have remained undisclosed; theres absolutely no evidence that he is a registered Democrat." Neither Virginia or Texas register voters by party affiliation.
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
etc etc etc
If necessary , ALL the claims in the meme 1st warrior linked can be debunked
When the guns are not available it will be the suicide bomber or Ied's as we see in Iraq where they can kill fifty in one explosion.
Then we can call them terrorists and put their kills in the terrorist column.
I know of no one who is proposing to "take guns away from law abiding citizens". Do you? Give me a link, please.
Whining about a delirious fantasm -- "they're coming to take away our guns" -- is just another cowardly excuse for not facing up to the fact that shooters shoot guns.
There is one very obvious common denominator in all mass shootings: the killer uses a gun. Duh!
So can we please talk -- seriously -- about gun control?
Responsible gun owners have nothing to worry about -- they already control their guns. So it seems to me that the folks who dont want any restrictions on guns cannot be "responsible gun owners".
So that is your reason for allowing children to be shot to bloody bits?
Seriously?
Your worries about IEDs justify the continuing slaughter of innocents? Wow.
You have serious moral-judgment problems, Dean.
Not being an American, Dean, I'm curious about something. Why is it that among the developed nations of the world, that the USA is the source of so many of such shooting rampages? I don't see reports of anything close to being a comparison in other countries.
I believe teachers and college students should be allowed to carry firearms to help prevent or minimize these tragic events.
I'm not a gun person. I don't know current practices.
It seems to me that the leaders in this action should be gun owners.
Ask a hard question to answer and don't expect a repy.
------------------------------------------------------
Obama has been president since 2009, not 2008
the republicans filbustered from 2009 until they took control of the senate in 2014
what else would you like to know ? i will teach you current events , and history, for free.
Maybe not shootings but the number of vicious attacks is just as large if not worse in Europe . And in China the number of knife attacks is pretty large .
When we outlaw knives, only criminals will be able to cut their steaks...
Are you saying that the Democratic Party is responsible for mass shootings? Really?
Wow.
The wingnut mind is amazing.
No, you can't predict mass shooting. But with the current shooter, you sure as hell can pay attention to what your kids are doing. The mother of the current shooter had a small arsenal in the house and had moved from So. California to Ore seemingly because of open carry laws.
Hard as it might be to admit to yourself that your kid is off his rocker, doing it just might save a lot of lives.
Kavika,
The whole point of this seed is to demonstrate that "early detection through behavior" is nonsense. The numbers are straightforward:
Two households in three have no guns. There are about as many guns in America as people -- about 320 million. There are 123 million households, so 40 million households share 320 million guns -- eight guns per household on average.
I assume there are lots of gun-owning households that have only one, so there must be quite a few that have many more. Thirteen guns in a household is not an anomaly in today's America. If there's a normal bell-curve distribution, there are probably at least five million households with thirteen guns.
I have no data on "angry men per household", but I think it's safe to say that there are a lot of angry men among those five million families.
And we have no means of screening.
Bob, the Supreme Court has ruled that private ownership of guns in the US is protected by the Constitution. It will take a (far) different Supreme Court or a constitutional amendment to change that right.
In the meantime we should address the cultish obsession with guns that exists in some elements of American culture, such as this household of the Oregon shooter desiring 13 guns in the household. "Gun love" is a cultish tradition in this country and it creates the atmosphere that makes people believe they can solve problems, or become notorious, by using a gun to work their will on others.
We also need to address the internet, which has holes where these deranged creatures such as the shooter wallow in self pity and bizarre motivation. This Mercer character did this because he couldnt get a girlfriend and he was taunted about it over and over again , and he masochistically went back for more taunting and self-belittlement.
I have never advocated anything like an abrogation of the Second Amendment.
The Second Amendment does not say that rules cannot be established about "how" people keep and bear arms.
What's you point? Your's probably could also - I just have better things to do that debunk other comments.
Bingo!
And imagine going to the cops: "Hi, Officer.. I'd like to report a neighbor who has lots of guns and an angry son..."
I can hear the... enthusiastic... reaction...
Go for it!
Watch out for vehicular homicide ... not that that ever happens /S
A key point!
Its worked well in Australia.
This is, in reality, a "Duh!" subject.
Unfortunately, American politics are not governed by reality.
Fortunately we have rights that protect us from the government confiscation that happened in Australia. We enjoy more freedom than they do.
Not everyone is happy in Australia , notably those who feel threatened by islamics ...
The US is the only country with a "right to keep and bear arms". It is a historical / contextual artifact from the 18th century.
Do you really measure "freedom" by the number of guns?